A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.
That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.
Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism come into you from TUICR and Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Oronation right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frei and I am the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Tainandian Sydney and my producer today is Rod Chambers. Last time on the show with the Dean of the Columbia Journalism School, Steve Cole, I promised more panels and more women.
Well today, you're getting half of that promise. The important half. More women. And not just any person of the female gender.
Today my guest is the editor of the City Morning Herald. She is in fact only the third woman to have held that position in the papers 180 year, almost 180 year history. Welcome to the show Lisa Davies. Thanks, Peter.
Did you know that with your appointment there's no more women editors of the City Morning Herald than editors who were also Methodist ministers? That wasn't actually something I knew. No, that's three women. Three women, two clerics.
Oh, terrific. How does that make you feel? Well, look, I'm pretty proud of the fact that I am in fact the third female editor and I think long may continue. I hope that some time over the next few editors there's more than that.
Well, I'm sure there will and the Methodist clerics will be... I'm not confident that they're going to run these days. No, I don't think they're in the running. No, they're not.
No, they're not. Okay, we're on Safegre. We don't even have a religion reporter. No, no.
Well, maybe. Well, maybe. Well, maybe. So before we get to talk to you about journalism and whether talking about the Prime Minister's religion is fair game for politicians, talk about religion, we better deal with the news to hand, which is that I guess as you know, many of you don't know our word about nine entertainment.
The City Morning Herald is still relatively new parent hosting a $10,000 a plate fund raises for the Liberal Party. That dinner made about 700k for the Libs and the guests included the Prime Minister, the Communications Minister Paul Fletcher, the Trading Minister of Sun and Birmingham and a host of other ministers and a few top end of the term types like Harry Trigoboff. So more to the point, of course, it was raised concern about the SMA's independence. Are you worried?
No, I'm not for a number of reasons. But I should say from the outset that I ever since the City Morning Herald and the age and the financial review were the old Fairfax Business purchased by the nine group. We've been really happy with our new owners. I think the fit is good.
We feel part of a very big and powerful media organisation and that hasn't always been the case, as I'm sure you remember often feeling buffeted by the winds of change, as they say, as part of the wider nine group and media of all kinds of course facing a lot of challenge at the moment. We feel quite stable and we haven't seen any cost cutting in recent times since the 2017, which is the last lot. We feel really safe and quite powerful and I think when we're being spoken about these days, we're being spoken about because of the journalism we do and that's for me very gratifying and of course everyone. I think basically what's disappointing about this decision is that it detracts from that.
We actually broke the story. It was actually me who got the tip that was happening and I passed it on to Kyla, our CBD columnist, who quickly published it around the same time that Joe Aston at the IFRD. So the story was actually broken by nine newspapers, which is a good story. I guess initially I hadn't, more perhaps than I've ever said, really appreciated that while it said that Hugh Marks and some of the nine team were hosting it, I assumed it was in a very, you know, like you rent out a dining room or a function said it correct.
I thought she didn't turn out to be that case and we just put up a story this afternoon that says that Hugh Marks has admitted it was a mistake and he will likely not be making that mistake again. Because it was on the centre of the day show? It was and it was. No confirmation that Jordy Gardner was there or the team, but yeah, look, it did seem a pretty odd decision and I mean Hugh for his side says that of course nine has a lot of reason to be talking to the government, regulatory issues, you know, the freedom of...
Absolutely. There are a lot of reasons. It's a company and we need to have a good dialogue with them. Actually helping the Liberal Party to raise money is not and I think anyone would cover the fact that it's not the job of a media company to help one party raise money.
So it is disappointing but I think we've all learnt something from it and hopefully the readers also realise that nothing has changed. That event did not change the way we do journalism or has any intention of doing that. Okay, well we'll get on to some of the great journalism that has happened since the merger. Before we...
But I guess it's understandable the media union in the... No, I fully endorse what they said. Yeah. I mean, I think myself and our executive editor James Tussle has put out a...
We spoke to the news for earlier and he doesn't propose to speak for Hugh, but on behalf of all the sea raise concerns as early as yesterday morning and hopefully that's where the matter stays now. Okay, well before we get to all the great stuff, Alan Jones. So if all goes to play on Alan and Ray Hadley and the crew will be a home sent home by Alan at some point in the future. Now needless to say GB is very much a different culture to the Herald.
It is. It always has been. It always will be. I think so.
Yes. But so let's not concentrate on Alan but if you had a columnist advising the Prime Minister to stick a sock down the throat of the Prime Minister of New Zealand, would you sack them? I think it's very difficult. I think...
It's difficult to sack them all. I think, well, it's difficult because of his popularity and I think the way he sought to clarify his point, you know, one could not be good, but someone might say that he misspoke and didn't actually intend. So he's made his defence of that. Look, I disagree and I think he has shown he has...
He often speaks badly to women. If you listen to the tape of him speaking to Louise Heron, the CEO of the Opera House last year, I personally felt quite confronted by that. If I had been on the receiving end of that kind of tirade, I would have been extremely upset. You apologise about that as well?
There is a pattern. Look, until such time as the nine board Holly Owens, I don't think they can do much, but I think Alan would be aware, as I think Ray Hadley or others who may do similar things, should be aware that I think the... I think he marks a show and he's not necessarily afraid of big talent, evidenced by Karl Stefanoi K'tra from today. And a few other big changes that he's made there in recent times.
Yeah, he's not afraid of that. And look, it's arguable... I mean, of course Alan Jones has a highest rating radio programme in the country, and he's got a long track record of doing that role and performing it to the standard that his listeners enjoy. I think it is over-inflated.
He's important and it still makes me a bit... It surprises me how much certain government or opposition ministers count out of him. There's a fantastic photograph of the former Premier Mike B going down Alan's place to tell me about the great... Exactly.
I mean, remarkable. But that is the way that he does business and it's up to other people to change that as much as it is up to him to maintain modern standards. Whatever they may be in one's case. Well, I do think there's been a huge backlash to that and I think he's on notice that one more time and he's probably gone.
And just on that first question though, if you had a con with who did that, would you get really? Quite possibly. I think if the radio response was anything like it has been to Alan more broadly and if it went against the principles that we hold as the editor of the city, I think I probably would. Okay, let's talk about you.
The easier things that you... Now you've been, as you said, you've been ended for about... Was it two and a half years? Yep.
And during that time, there was that initially that was that ran across heading. And then we went from hell. Yeah. We had about 30 million bucks out of the business and then there was a little reorganization editor structure and then there was the merger with nine.
So it's not been wired. It certainly hasn't been quite what I imagined. So is it in that period, keeping your eye, because you're very editorial focused on this job, but keeping around the editorial board with all that going on? Is that hard?
It's really hard. There are only a certain number of hours in the day and I think to myself how nice it would have been to be an editor when there was just one newspaper once a day and the deadline was about 10pm, I'm curious, whereas the I take responsibility for a reasonably fast-moving website and two or three editions of the newspaper as well as a tablet app. Obviously it is extremely hard to keep across everything. Some days a bit like today, I feel as though I'm not entirely clear what has actually been happening today.
I couldn't tell you what has been happening like, but happily that's because it's been a period quite day. But I think, yeah, I'm very grateful that I've got an incredibly competent and passionate team who take responsibility for different parts of the machinery. And we seem to get there at the end of every day somehow. Oh, I'm sure you will.
What keeps you awake at night though? About the job? I mean, what keeps you awake at night? Maybe you sleep like a baby.
Well, I'm actually a pretty good sleeper, I must say. But I do worry about the ability to remain calm in a pretty frenetic world, not me personally, because I can be both calm and frenetic. But I worry that it's easy to get caught up in the craziness of certain incidents or news events. It is.
And you want to kind of get dragged along by stories. So as you mentioned in your opening, the Herald's been around for more than 180 years, and our readers and the wider community rely on us to maintain a pretty centrist and sensible course. So to get too caught up in some of those issues is problematic. The falling readership of print newspapers, it's still where a huge amount of everyone comes from.
So that, of course, is worrying. And just actually, basically, staying across things. I mean, sometimes I have people call me and go, I can't believe you published exercise in like this thing. Did I?
I usually, it's quite like a different part of the bit, like in entertainment or lifestyle that isn't always front of mind for me. Well, it's interesting, isn't it coming at you from all angles? All angles. And it can be so varied.
And as I'm sure you remember, you can be attacked from the left, from the right, from all sides, in all sorts of spaces one day. Well, that's why you're doing your job. Well, you stay in the middle. We'll get back to that question in the middle in a second.
But I did want to touch on one of my favourite, City Morning Age stories and recent months, was that investigation into current consumer, which is ongoing, linking some very interesting Chinese high-reholders and influencers and money laundering and various other things. So tell us about that. That was the first to be copro with 60 minutes. As opposed to working with ABC, you know, normal buddies.
That's right. It's a normal bit fellas. So how was that? Was it different?
There's more money, especially around the world? Well, I think, yes, you can see from the high production values of 60 minutes that they don't leave too many costs on the table. That project had obviously been in the works for some time. Nick McKenzie has wanted for some time to do something with 60.
And I think the fact that it worked out with this story was terrific. He worked very closely with the producer there. And in fact, the way it ended up rolling out, Nick McKenzie obviously had the first byline. But then Grace Tobin, who is the producer at 60 Got Second byline, because between them, they worked incredibly closely to get all the ducks in the row and worked quite secretly for months.
You know, there are only very small number of people involved in the very initial brainstorming about how we would do it. And you know, Kirsty Thompson, who's the EP of 60 minutes, was pretty much working very closely with Nick's direct boss, basically age. So it came together really, really well. I loved, in fact, watching.
So I'd watched it before it went to air, but I loved watching on Twitter people's responses to it. You know, there had been a rather overly dramatic promo on TV. It was not that no Australians should miss it. It was going to change the nation or something.
It was a little overdone. It was slightly overdone. And I had people going, oh my God, are you going to bring down a prime minister? No.
But, I mean, it's a huge story. And you know, watching Twitter and watching people's reaction to it was very gratifying because I saw people say things like, oh, I feel like it's Monday night, not Sunday night, and I'm watching for corners. And I think another comment that was quite nice and quite prevalent was, or maybe the city morning Harold can have a really strong effect on Channel 9 and not the other way around. I know that they're really open to it.
And actually, if you look at the ratings from, it was the second highest 60 minutes of the entire year in terms of its ratings, but also interestingly, someone was telling me the other day that not only live was it, those ratings figures, but on catch up on the 9 Now streaming part of 9, it's had a huge, another huge go. So that's great at the world we live in, right? Totally. And people aren't booking appointments to watch TV anymore live commercial television, but I think it was a really great first toe in the water.
What's the next one? Well, I'm trying to get my client on TV. You've got to get the final TV. She's loves it.
She's got to read a book and people want to. That's right, exactly. She could read a menu or... I'm sure.
I'm sure. And people would pay to say it probably. Yeah, okay. Well, yeah.
So we're talking about things like on demand, what have you. So this show, we spend a lot of time talking about future journalists. And you mentioned a few things earlier. Yeah.
Let's talk about some of the hard ones, like the kind of social media platforms, the impact of Facebook and Google. You would have had a look at the Atropises report. It said, you know, Facebook and Google, you have a period of time, it's about 9 months, or less now, to get together with the news industry and work out of some sort of fair payment for the use of the editorial content. Hopefully you're in there.
Look, I think I'm generally an optimist, so I'm trying to be optimistic about it. I think it's in everyone's interest to work together. We need, in some respects, rely on Facebook and Google to get our content out there. We have an incredibly strong committed paying audience, but in terms of our ability to reach more people, search through Google and social media through Facebook is extremely important.
It's not the be on end all. We are a subscriptions business and we believe what we do is worth paying for. I think, you know, if you look at it from outside, that's important to maintain strong relationships with them. But also for them too, I mean, Google has developed a number of the Google News initiative.
They're working in New Dreams. They're working with the Walkley Foundation to really try and give some, something back to our newsroom. Facebook has a bit of a PR problem after quite a large period. Quite a large period.
Quite a large period. So it's in there interested to really work with us closely. And on a very sort of grassroots level, our social media and digital teams work quite closely with both of those organisations today. So things are okay.
I guess it's just a matter of, you know, coming to the, getting all sides to come to the table. So they need to give you a very large check. That would be nice. No.
But also, I mean, we don't necessarily want their money, but we want to be properly, well, I mean, that would be nice. But I also think we need to maintain our independence and that they need to value the content that we're helping them to serve. Because they're really just publishers. They don't know what we do.
Well, they would argue they're not publishers. Well, sorry. Yes. They're just hosts or whatever.
Yes. What are the words? Well, they use all different sorts of words. I mean, I think they're kind of quasi, kind of they're not publishers.
They're more than just simply passive players. So it is a. Yeah. I think that's true.
Yeah. Well, the next six to nine months will really set the time for the next few years. Yeah. And everyone's watching.
World is watching. And, you know, I think we've sort of led the way to some extent, but where it goes to from here, well, yeah, we'll be interesting. Talking about, one of the other things HBC talked about was making it easier for news organizations to get charitable status. Now, that isn't, I'm sure you're going to happen to nine or they're all at any time soon.
I don't think so. By the way, I did mean to ask how many pay subscribers do you have now? What's the official number? I think it's a commercial component.
Is it? No, it's not. Surely. I think it might be.
Really? Yeah, I don't think we talk about it. So, it's me, you and Rod. I mean, what else is here?
No, that's right. Is there a goal? Yeah, so we've publicly said that we want to have half a million paying digital subscribers. A timeframe on that is not particularly set, but it's ambitious.
But we've... I can't ask you how far you've gone down to that. We've made significant inroads. I would say.
We've spent an extra 20 minutes trying to work out what we get a number. Is it between? Yeah, that's right. So, would it be 50 and 50?
Yeah. Because of the negs or the sort of. Okay, well, move on. But I was interested to talk about charity.
I don't mind mentioning the charity thing was, Judas, the Judas, Nelson fans. So, Judas, Nelson gave the Herald and the Age some money recently to employ an Indigenous photographer and report her. Yeah, really great. And it's one of the most gratifying things I've done so far.
It was my proposal. And it came on the back and forth with the Judas, Nelson Institute. So, we've hired the journalist. She is terrific and we're starting in October.
And we're just in the final stages of employing a photographer. Can we have the journalist now? Yes, I probably can give you that exclusive if you like. Her name is Ella Archibald Vinge and she's been working at NITV in Queensland.
She was at NITV in New South Wales, but she's mentioned that she's been working at NITV in Sydney, and she's been back to be based in the Herald Newsroom, which is really exciting. Stan Grant is going to be a mentor. A mentor? I was going to call him an editor at large or some kind of, you know, a big portion of the funding that they've provided is for travel because everyone can appreciate getting out to remote communities, telling the stories of Indigenous Australians in 2019.
It involves quite a lot of travel and this place, this country is big. So, the nasty question that first one that of course is, if it was so important, why didn't the Channel 9, 9 and the Stame Group fund itself? It has always, so when I got to the end of last year and decided that I wanted to make the year that the Herald put Indigenous affairs back on its radar, I actually didn't have in mind to do this project. I had actually brainstormed with Peter Hartra, International and Political Editor at Whole Different Project, but...
There was a few Hartra recipes. Yeah, it was a... No, no, this was a whole separate... It was about Indonesia and the Pacific and climate change and various things, but as it turned out, that was a little bit trampling on what other people had pitched for, so they encouraged me to think differently and to think domestically, and so I came up with this idea because of course, I wanted to do it anyway, but it just turns out that this is a great way to start it.
To that, I would say that I'm also, hopefully, in the next couple of weeks going to a point in Indigenous affairs correspondent from the Herald's Newsroom, who will work more into the politics. It's gonna be a big... Yes, it's gonna be a couple of years. Working towards the referendum on Voice of Parliament, etc.
There's a lot going on in that space, and I just don't think we can have enough people talking about it. So, yes, you're right. I should have probably done it two years ago, but I was always gonna make a big issue of it and just really helpful that this project has come. Okay, I don't pretend you're having the note, frankly, but...
No, and I think I love what she's doing. I think it's amazing. That's how it's about. How'd you million dollars?
What's not to love? Yeah, it's right. It's given a lot of love. Yeah, yeah.
So, just tell me about this. You were a reporter for many years before reaching these dizzying heights, you know. First question is, do you miss it? And the second is, if you were able to talk to your younger self, what would you tell her to go into journalism?
Yeah, I would. I never wanted to do anything else. I always tell this story. When I was about 12, I started telling my mother that I was gonna write stories for a living, and she thought, oh, fabulous, she'd be best-selling novelist or something.
Turns out, there's something of different kinds of stories. I've been really lucky. I've done jobs that I've loved. I think the advice I would probably give my younger self would be to be a little more varied.
I always say I'm a bit of an atypical harealtor. I've never worked in Canberra. Full-time, I've never worked at State Parliament full-time and did crime and courts for most of my careers. Whilst I've always taken a strong interest in all those areas, I've never done a huge amount of reporting in that space.
But I guess my new judgment is okay. Since we're going so far. I'm sure the readers will tell me if it's not. But I think it's...
I wouldn't do anything differently. Great. The way news media makes money these days is essentially through engagement, through audience engagement. So subscribers and other forms of engagement.
So that means... What I'm more interested in talking about is whether that means that we're privileging news content or opinions that get more engagement. So I'm wondering if there's a shift towards more opinion pieces as a way of getting people to write up and in their engagement. I don't see engagement necessarily as bad.
So we look at a number of factors when we're looking at our content and what the perfect story would be or the perfect engagement is actually not always opinion. There's a lot of opinion. There's a lot of opinion. And I think you...
because when you're reading on the website and you're seeing a lot more stuff promoted. If you read a newspaper of a morning, you might read a couple of the opinion pieces of the month. No one reads the newspaper of a morning. No, there are some.
I love them so much. Thank you, everyone. But we try and look at a measure of completion. So that's people actually getting to the bottom of stories.
Time on article. And then also sort of retention. So people staying with the content on the site. So we think a factor of a sort of a combination of those factors make for high engagement.
Some weeks, you know, Peter Karchar, for example, might write an absolutely blistering column. And it has over a thousand comments on it. And I love how readers because they don't just sling mud at each other. They're actually debating what he's talking about and giving their own opinions, even on the website.
But that's not always the case. And it can't be the case for every article I was talking earlier today. Readers might recall where you did a front page of cover story of Good Weekend on Brenton Tarrant a few weeks ago, lead by line with Nico Malley. And that piece with 8,000 words now.
We don't usually run pieces that long. I think the usual length of article in Good Weekend is 5,000, 4,000. Now, that had an engagement. It took me half an hour to read it.
It was so great. But I wanted to think I can be for us. I can also really like to spend time with it. And it sounds absolutely ridiculous to say that the average engagement time was 5 minutes 40.
But that's actually incredibly good for a digital piece of journalism. And it showed that people were really sticking with it. It also might mean that people stuck with it for 5 minutes and then came back and read it more of it later. And that wouldn't be picked up.
But I think that sort of time spent is we're just trying to push out the amount of time people are spending both on individual stories, but also on the site more generally. So I think engagement is not just about inflaming opinions, but attracting people's attention and getting them to stick with us. Because other news media, I don't say that Harold is innocent in this either, but other news media, well, news media generally is not picking on anyone in particular. But there is a bit of a cultural war going on these days.
And I wonder about the readers, I guess, if you are on the left or the right, that reinforces your views and therefore you're going back to it. So it is tempting, isn't it? It is. Get those people and keep on the basis of work.
Yeah, absolutely. And that is true. I'm really interested in, I mean, this is a classic example. In March this year, as we always do and have done for many years, we endorsed one side for the state election on the eve of the poll and we endorsed the Coalition, the Clasier What was even more interesting was that that's fine.
And we've always done that. I'm still amazed that people are surprised because it's been happening forever. Yeah, and I wrote about it in a note to subscribers. But interestingly, what we've since found out is that we're tracking a lot of what people read that lead them to subscribe, not necessarily the last thing they read before they subscribe, but the things that they read in the three or four sessions prior to subscribing.
The same number, if not more people read that editorial and did subscribe. So even if everyone who complained had given up their subscription, even more had. So again, it's the shows that there's real tension between left and right and people are entitled to their views, but I don't have to believe what we write. They don't have to agree with us, but it makes for an interesting discussion about staying in the middle, appealing to different sides.
And also I like to hope that Harold readers want to be challenged. They want their intelligence and worldly enough to want to understand what someone else is thinking. So I really try. It's one of my talking about things keep me awake at night.
It's hard to really keep that balance. Well, it's because the held is easier in a way to be more overtly on the right and more overtly on the left. Totally. Being in the center can be actually the loneliest place.
Yeah. But I think it's right for us. I think socially progressive, we embrace the needing to act on climate change. Same sex marriage, all the issues that we talk about a lot over the last couple of years economically and in many ways a little bit politically conservative.
So I don't think that's any surprise. I think it's always been the way. And people's horror that we might endorse the coalition. It's happened more than it's happened the other way.
Oh, absolutely. I think in history, talking federally, I think only two or three times. Yeah, great. Yeah.
We've got it wrong this year. Indeed. Oh, we've got these Methodist ministers, right? I don't think they were going by Marxist.
I have a couple more questions. And I did touch on one of them earlier in the piece, which was, and this is a political question. It's not a journalistic question so much. I was very interested in what you make of the labors, Christina Canile, and I think it's Gervin's citing Scott Morrison's religion as a reason for him to grant a sign into the Tamil family from Bill of Wila.
Yeah. What do you make of that? I mean, is it time to brush up on our Bibles? Well, I hope not because I was really bad at all.
I'm not really a believer. Look, I think the Prime Minister makes his religion a part of who he is. And he talked in his acceptance speech after the election about appealing to people of faith and having a view of the election. And having a view of the world from a religious perspective.
I think Christina Canile is entitled to make those points because she herself is an African athlete. No, it's a made-up point. And I listened to her interview on, I think it was Radio National Trade. Yes, therefore, when she talked about that, she was challenged about that.
And I think it's fair enough. Like, he's got Morrison holds it, and it's who he is. He makes no bones about it. No, he's not flipping it.
No, and he should be entitled to both use it to inform his decision-making, but as long as, you know, because he's been voted in his prime minister, there's no question about that. But I think he also needs to be mindful of the times when he should leave those beliefs at the door. It's happening in State Parliament also. It's happening in the abortion debate.
It's really interesting at the moment, these elected members of Parliament who, to some people, it's quite apparent that they have these very religious views. If you're not that way inclined, they don't like that part of the decision-making. But it's who they are. People who voted for him should know that.
So I guess, should he change his view, should he reverse the decision of a number of, I mean, there's been, I think, seven appeals on that case. I don't think it's really, as much as a huge public outcry of wanting them to stay. The law is the law, and I don't believe they are, you know, they've been found not to be asylum seekers. Well, Alan Jones wants to stay.
I know he does, which is surprising. I mean, I love that the community loves them and wants them to stay, but maybe they need to find another way to stay. It's not under the current system itself, I think is a little bit broken. Perhaps there should have been an intervention a long time ago.
Well, maybe that is another whole issue. That's another whole issue. Yeah, that's another whole issue. We're going to look forward a year and we're going to come back, you're going to come back, you're going to be sitting here doing this in a few years' time.
What has that year been for the Herald and what has that year been like for you? Well, in the next 12 months, I definitely want to see our Indigenous coverage really reaching new people and changing people's minds about where we're going and how we reconcile our past and move forward. I think I would like to have not had another conversation about a Liberal Party or Labor Party for that matter fundraiser by our CEO. I think it's distracting and not helpful.
But broadly, I just want the Herald to keep kicking goals. I want us to be talked about because the great stories are breaking, not for any other reason, personally, I hope to still be here. Lisa, thank you so much for your time today. It's been absolutely worth it and I wish you all the best for this ongoing and in the Herald and all that.
And thank everyone for listening to the Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the Studio's 2CR and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. And make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk about the media, the politics and a few things in between action. And we'll be back very soon with more.
But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter where our handle is Fourth Estate AU. Many thanks to our producer, Rod Chambers. My name is Peter Frei and thank you so much for listening.