Thank you for listening to For The State, the show where journalists talk journalism, or where people who have got something interesting to say about journalism sometimes get a look in. We're coming to you from TUICR and Sydney on the Guadalcanal landscape, on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frayan, I'm the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology Sydney and my producer today is Anthony Dockrell. Today we're talking to someone who is a recovering journalist, a pollster, a columnist, a media commentator, a spin merchant and the author of an excellent new book called Webtopia, which subtitle is The Worldwide Web of Tech and How to Make the Net Work.
That's two words, net work. How indeed? Welcome to the show, Peter Lewis. Thanks for having me, Peter Lewis.
It's a great pleasure. So for those of you who don't follow, Peter Lewis, as many iterations in the public space, he is the head of essential media communications, which is kind of a PR outfit for the left. Was that a fair comment? Yeah, I'd like to say campaigning and strategic comms, but if you call it PR, I guess I'll sort of set off for that.
You'll set off for that? Okay. Before we get to the book, Peter, I just did want to ask you a bit about polls. So in essence, are they dead?
Look, I think they're wounded and I think we're in recovery at the moment. And there is a degree of sausage in going on within the fraternity of pollsters. There was clearly an intelligence failure that had profound consequences in the lead up to the federal election. It's easy to play defensive and say that we're in the margin of error because 5149 could be 5149 the other way, but the fact that the polls had consistently put Labor ahead for three years really did shake the narrative, but more importantly the way that the progressive movement approached the election campaign.
So we're taking stock and I think there's three levels that we're reviewing. One is the quality of the samples we collect. The second is the way we wait preferences. So one of the real mistakes I think was to overestimate the amount of one nation and parliament preferences that we go back to Labor basically none of them did.
But the third and the most profound thing that we're really thinking through is what we do with the disengaged. So particularly the Tea Party preferred is a creature of American politics where voting is voluntary and Australia of course voting is compulsory. So even if you don't have any view at all, you've still got a legal responsibility to turn up and vote. What we do is pollsters for people that can't say who you might even lean towards.
We just take them out of the sample because it's inconvenient. They're not it. It's noisy and it gets in the way. And then I engaged.
Yeah. But what that actually does is skew the results. So 5149 was never 5149 even the cheers day before the election. If we'd put the people that couldn't answer the question in, we would have been saying Labor's ahead 47, 45 with 8% undeclared.
Imagine how that's a different narrative and how you approach it differently. So we are kind of licking our wounds at the moment. Our partners, the Guardian, have decided that we won't start publishing the party polling until a bit later in this year, but I'm seriously looking at what it could look like that we move away from 2pp to keeping the undeclared in because if you think about it a step back from the stats, what we're doing is disenfranchising the disengage, which is exactly what the political process does. And then we wonder why we get results that surprise us.
And you're privileging the people who engage with politics. Yeah. And when in fact the elections have decided that people were not. Exactly.
And the campaign that worked was brilliantly focused at people that did not know what was going on. Great learning. One thing just before we move on, the Australia Institute, Richard Dennis recently made the point that one of the reasons why maybe people fall in a favor with the polls is that Australia is no longer a place where uniform swings happen. So national polling in one sense is obsolete.
What did you take on that? I take Richard's point. But I never took polling to be the political scoreboard that maybe some in the media did. So you see the way the news polls being reported.
And it even still is. Like this week's news poll, which apparently the softening of 2pp was because of a backlash against New South Wales abortion. It was like, spammy. The purpose of a political poll is to be part of a broader bunch of intelligence about where the election is.
And I think the intelligence value of the last election wasn't just about polling. It was about the breakdown of institutions that used to be ways of giving an indication of where people were, the breakdown of the media. A lot of the themes that I look at in the book, I think, in a way, the problem was polling was all that was left. And it was a very low quality abstraction because we'd lost all the other ways we used to have of understanding what's going on in our world.
And fragmentation of different communities is part of that. Yep. But you know. I mean, the other part of polling, which you just touched on in a way is how they have been traditionally been used by the news media.
Right. So you know, you can load lots of things in a poll, as you just mentioned. I mean, I've written and commissioned many, many polls in my life. And it's a two-way relationship of abuse because the third parties that are trying to buy their way into the media, rather than writing a policy paper or engaging a real community network, we can do a Robopole for $1,300.
And that's going to be good enough to get a headline in, you know, mainstream years media. So the devaluing of what a poll was and what a poll meant was kind of going on it on both sides because it was cheap and cheerful for all of us. Yeah, I'm doing it on a box as many as well. I mean, it's cheap.
Well, it's a cheap for a headline. Yeah. Like, you know, get your value into the debate. Compare that with buying a, you know, quarter page ad.
Yep. That looks like news. It looks like news. Right.
And take it as read. Yeah. And, you know, and again, that's linked to just not having time to get across the issues properly. So someone says I've got a robo saying, actually go, well, that's, that's a story.
It's not a story. It's a robo poll. Yeah. Okay.
Well, it's a critique of journalism than as much as anything else. I think we all need to be self-searching at the moment because, you know, whether or not you are happy with the election outcome, I think that it wasn't the finest moment in Australian democracy. We can do a whole new show on what were the finest moments in Australia. But that's another whole show in the good court.
That's not called the Fourth of the State. Let's talk about your book. It's sort of a bit of a polemic. Are you looking at the time before the net, the time where we are now and with all its incumbent problems and pushes forward to what we think the net might be or what you think the net might be in the future.
There's a lot to cover and I am mindful that this is a show about journalism, but there's a much broader critique in your book which we must touch on. And that is perhaps summed up in a phrase phrase you use in the book, which is the web.is.2.good.2b.true. Why do you say that with so many dirty dots? I guess it's a new form of emphasis, but it really struck me that as a society we have all been totally entranced by this amazing technological change that people of our generation had the privilege to live through.
It was transformative. In its early inception it was radically collaborative. It was going to challenge the existing structures and allow communities to develop organically and build power. And 20 years later I don't see that being the end point of this process.
So I started the book looking at that journey. It was actually a bit of a polemic. It was also a book about my political project, which is generational politics. It was a straight white middle-class male.
I can see only the area where I'm in a minority group. So I like to see the world through a generational lens and being a genexer just in 50. I was looking at the way people's lives had changed and technology was the punctuation point in my life and most of the other people who I've gone through this sort of journey with. And the internet is that kind of the life before that change on the last generation that will grow up and come of age in an analogue world and to make sense of what that world was like, look at the promise of what was going to happen, look at the reality of where we are now.
And we start doing a bit of thinking about what do we need to do to regain our compass a little bit. Because a lot of this is, you talk a lot about the tech and you talk about the moral compass of the web. You know, say, where's the morality and say deep fake porn where you can stick revenge porn based on someone else's face on a porn star or even some of it more mundane. Like ticket sales or tickets can get scooped up and sold at inflated prices on the web.
These are all reprehensible practices. But don't they all boil down to us? It's humans, right? It's humans have got to change.
And this is the disconnect. We've embraced the technology thinking it would be a self-evident good. And I think a more rational view of looking at it is a moral. It is what we do with it and what we make of it.
The problem we had was that the web came online, came online as a self-evident good. In my mind, just at the end of the Cold War where there was the triumph of libertarianism, which morphed into, there was no role for government to get out of the way. When it came to policy around the internet for the first decade, it was seen as totally libertarian. The only role of government was to get everyone connected and then no rules.
So in that world of no rules, of course, good things and bad things will happen. But on top of that, the business model now is evolving, which is very much one of its capitalism and its purest form. It's taking what we give throughout interactions online, monitoring what we do because we've said it's okay in order to get free access to these platforms and then create insights that then influence us as human beings. And it sounds like a totally weird, fast impact that we're giving ourselves up so that we can use Facebook for free.
That's kind of where it's all ended up. So we're fooling ourselves in part that we're in control, in some way. Yeah, I think we get the impression that we're in control on a level at a very surface level, but we're giving up a lot of control. If the world was going great, I'd say, well, let's keep on going.
But I don't think it is. And I don't know. Maybe it's just, I wrote this before the end of the election. So it's not about that.
But I point to things the four days. So distraction, we are just addicted to our phones and we're finding it hard to lift our head up and think critically denial. We can't find a public space to mediate our truths anymore because it doesn't exist. Division, whereas the idea of the web was to bring the world closer to part, it's actually pulling us into our own communities and further apart and not listening to others.
And displacement, which is this whole industry that's being built off the back of the harvesting and acquisition of data, which ultimately is going to take away most of our jobs. So where is the upside? Well, there isn't that way. Yeah.
So where I land is, we're kind of where, and I wasn't around at the time, neither were you, but where we were after about 40 years of the Industrial Revolution when the kids were down the corner mines and the factories and people said, oh, this isn't working. Maybe we should put some laws in place. Yeah, we're going to get to the low lights in a minute. Yeah, yeah.
But it's true. Like the technology doesn't exist in a vacuum. And the other thing we're seeing is that it's not a worldwide web anymore. It's being fashioned to different societies.
So China has a great firewall of China. Russia has an extension of the secret repressive state. America is a hyper capitalist model. There's interesting stuff going on in Europe where there's an attempt to sort of say, civilise the web.
So what does the Australian web going to look like? Are we just a cheap offshoot of the American web? I think you know the answer to that. Well, and back to the theme of this podcast, we don't even get to have those debates and come up with those, make those decisions unless there is a public square in existence where we can mediate.
Yeah. Sorry, I know we've got time and time. I was convinced. So I'm really good at giving the whole book in three minutes.
That's a challenge. And I'll be listening to you in a second. Great audience. Good night.
So let's talk about you for a second because people in context of people, you were a star industrial reporter at the Daily Telegraph in the mid 1990s. Not yet. I'm in the last industrial correspondent when such people existed in far greater numbers than they do now. Do you know he's having industrial writers dinner and there was like 35 looking at the voice?
Yeah, and people would turn up to that dinner now. I think it'd just be you and head out outside. It must be more than one. I'm not even going to see.
And then you left journalism in the mid-90s and after Keating lost that election. Did you miss journalism? Because you do get, you know, you are a very frustrated journalist. I've always seen myself as a journalist.
I just don't have anywhere to work anymore. So I've found a way through most of my life to keep writing stories. But you know, and a lot of my embrace of the web in the early years, I went from journalism to a political staffer in the first time of the car government when it was actually a good government and then moved from there into working with the unions in the early sort of vestiges of them having communication strategies. And out of that came my adaptation of the web.
And I just started playing with the technology thinking through well, you know, these papers that guys like Peter Frey had aren't going to give us a free reign. So why don't we just go and find our own audiences and build our own. And we're going to talk about... Can I see you tell stories?
So we set up one of the first Australian political websites and really embraced what the technology could do and try to all sorts of things. And some of them worked and some of them failed at one point. We set up a TV studio in the basement of Trac Hall thinking that every organisation would need a design to night show on that one. So you were an optimist about the way you saw this as a great...
I was a webtopian. I used to get up at M.E.W.A. events and say, look, the media's dying. But that doesn't matter.
We're going to all be able to tell our own stories and reach our own audiences and sucked in, you poor genless come and join me on the dark side and it'll all be tickety boo. And it kind of was for a while, but the media was still there and we were kind of like punching up against it. And what was really interesting was with Workers Online, I think also with Stephen Mains-Kraiki, we started telling stories in a slightly different way and the media came to us and said, oh, yeah, they're legitimate stories so we'd get back into the mainstream. I think where things have fallen down is that now there is only the periphery and there isn't much of a cent or anymore.
So most of the news sites are either behind paywalls or with far less resources than they used to have. So I was totally wrong. I was totally wrong to get up and say, it's great that the public square is collapsing and we're setting up all these villages on the side. Well, you were an optimist by nature, right?
Yeah, but I miss, like, in a way, this book is a lot of, it's really a chronicle of all the things I got wrong, but one of them that was really profound was that there wasn't a role for, and not necessarily newspapers, but points of truth. And we see it now. Like, we see that if truth is just what you want it to be, then how can you deal with profound problems? No, that's it.
Yeah, okay, so there's two ways to look in that, I suppose. You know, as we all know, journalists go into the world and find truth. But there's an infinite number of truths, quite a lot of the number of truths about everything. So journalists have always exercised choice in terms of the truths that are portrayed, right?
Really what the web has done is hyperventilate that. And it's also rewarded, particularly for outlets that have gone to clicks, rewarded truths. You know, this idea of engage and, you know, a lot of the theories around how social media works is being fueled by anger and fueled by outrage. And you look at, you know, and I'm not carrying a torch for the Australian media as it existed in the late millennium, because it was starting to fall apart anyway, news limited was starting to become what I'd argue is an overly invested machine politically rather.
Like there was great days of the Australian that sort of passed in the late 90s, I reckon. You know, the Herald was clearly struggling to resource what it could be. The ABC was coming under increasing political attack during the halogies. It wasn't that the media was necessarily working at all journalists where these fine upstanding custodians, but they were there.
And being there and this idea that there was this space where, and it wasn't just that it could produce it, but that people would come there. And that's the other thing, isn't it? It's not even a place people visit anymore the public square because no one knows where to find it. But when they sit in their own corner and it comes to them, they don't go to it.
And if it's just coming to you in your Facebook news feed, it's being pushed out from all different angles and for all different purposes. So, yeah, I mean, I was, you know, you would have read it too, but the recent Australian competition consumer report on the digital platforms, essential reading for anyone or essential listening if you want to go back a few episodes of the fourth estate. I mean, the one thing that really shines through, or not many things shines through in that report, but one snap that really stands out for me is the absolute popularity of Google and Facebook. I mean, the numbers are extraordinary.
You have 25 million Australians in that population, 19.2 million Australians use Google search every month, 17.3 million use Facebook, 17.6 million watch YouTube, and by Google, 11.2 million access Instagram and by Facebook, the list goes on. So there's a considerable power influence there, but Australians love these tools. They love these platforms. That's not a certain bad thing, right?
Indeed. And the power of these platforms is because we use them. And if we didn't use them, they wouldn't be powerful. But you're not suggesting we should stop using them.
Or are you? I don't know what I'm at the moment. I'm simply suggesting that we be mindful of the way our world's changing, what the implications of those changes are, and then start building backwards from there. There is going to be a live debate in the States about a structural separation of Facebook, if Elizabeth Warren makes it through the first few rounds of the 100.
Do you think Elizabeth Warren will make it through the first round of programming? I think she'll get there. I don't think she's going to come 22nd or 23rd. I think she'll be there with the last six.
So that'll be a live debate. I, you know, there are utopian ideas that you just set up a publicly, like, why isn't ABC a platform that people use for social protection? Well, they tried that and it didn't really work. Yeah, no, so you've got to find something that works.
But at the moment, I think the problem is that the people that are using these platforms aren't quite aware of the cost of entry. And if there is a proper public debate about what is being given up, then it starts hoping itself up to us. Well, you have some thoughts about that in the book. I mean, you have some thoughts about the role of governments.
You kind of advocate a more interventionist answer. You want us, for instance, to have the right to be unknown. So this is based on the European model where, look, at the moment, I think the problem is we don't even have a language about what is OK and what's not OK because we've got no awareness of what's going on. And while I have just finished it, most Australians won't read the rise of surveillance capitalism by Shana Zuboff, but they should, which is a fan show.
Should they read that before? Well, no, because they'll never finish that. It's probably the one afterwards when you want to read a really smart person talking about the themes that I've kicked around. But it's basically a Marxist analysis of the information economy and how our personal data is the natural resource that's driving the whole wealth of these big tech players.
So why is that the way it works? Why can't we just buy a service without having to give up all the excess data that we... Because I should say that's a business model. Yeah, but why does it have to be?
So it's just like the Gilded Age and the rubber barons. They were running a monopoly racket to enrich themselves at the cost of other people. And at some point, people caught an onto it and said, well, why is this going on? Let's do something different.
So an active revolution might be turning off Facebook and finding different ways to connect. But you know what? We're a long way away from there. We haven't even started the conversation.
No, but do you saw your Facebook? I turned it off after I read Roger McNemey's Zilch, which is another great book about the way that that organisation off right. So I reckon there's three levels. There is a role for government regulation.
There is a real debate around the way organisations handle customer and member. Information and I think what we need to see is a fourth plank of corporate social responsibility around the way that personal information is handled. And if we do that and if we put some rings around it, then that data that we still aren't ourselves might be valuable. And if there's going to be a world driven by data scientists, at least in data engineers, at least we get a little bit of that back.
But then finally, it's also about us just being aware of how we're being used and how hyperconnectivity has a whole bunch of downsides. And we know that it's not great to eat hamburgers and milkshakes every day that we should do a bit of exercise. We haven't got a sense of what's a healthy digital life yet. And I think, you know, it should be the next book.
Really. How I gave up hamburgers. How I gave up the net and learnt a little bit. What's your sense of the government?
I mean, it's been an extraordinary time, particularly going back to journalism a little bit, but we've had a Senate inquiry, but these various inquiries know about the police raids. We've now had the ACCC, digital platforms inquiry. There's a lot pointing to this debate. I mean, it's not like this debate is underground anymore.
It's very much in the public space. Your book's part of that. How do you assess the mood of the federal government to do something about something you talk about? I was really heartened to see the way Paul Fletcher responded to it in a really thoughtful and measured way.
You mean the ACCC? Yeah. Yeah. And I think there is a recognition that there is a problem.
I think the ACCC report going down, it's effectively a saying, I think, that the rules of the old media should apply to new platforms or at least be adapted to some extent. They will come under incredible pressure from the big platforms to do the bare minimum, and then they'll probably do something a bit less than nothing, and it'll be a little step forward. I think what's interesting in this space is I don't think it's a traditional partisan issue. I don't see this as being left right.
I think there's elements about this which is around protecting our personal freedoms. There are also elements about this about managing change in a conservative way, and then there's a bit of our government regulation as well. So I also thought when Morrison spoke about the use of Facebook after the Christchurch massacre, I thought, I'm going to back him in on that. If he's prepared to have a go there, it's just how far government goes and how far they're allowed to go, and they won't go very far at all unless we as voters demand some action.
I think there's a really fertile ground in public policy about protecting kids from this technology in the rights of kids, for instance, not to be subject to games and platforms that are using, gambling algorithms to keep them on longer and mess up their mind and beta test them to be lifelong consumers of this poison. So I think there's great retail politics. You've talked to any parent who's got kids who are going through this. We don't know what to do, and we're being played and sorry our kids.
Because the answer might not be as simple as turn it off. I mean, these answers aren't these things are so embedded in our lives. Yeah. And I so loved, as I said earlier, by so many Australians, it isn't just simple.
It's just a love or is there a difference between love and mutual dependency? Well, it's a bit, yeah. Can you imagine not having a mobile phone? You wouldn't be able to live with a mobile phone.
And it's even that can you imagine going for a walk by the water and leaving your phone behind rather than listening to a podcast, even if it's as podcast as good as fourth estate? Like, the space for silence and just reflection is gone whenever boards are how can we be creative? So yeah, turn it off as part of it and having a language about this thing. But for our kids, it's been totally integrated into their education as well, so that most schools to save money have bring your own device, they lay it back onto the parents, and then the kids are walking around with the world's most amazing library in the most toxic drug store all in the one unit and we're expecting them to self-moderate and only take the good stuff.
Now, yes, you can say you should parent better, but gee, it's hard. It's hard and ongoing because it keeps changing as well, right? It's not as if it's one source. It is work a month.
It's work a month. Has the book going? Do you're going to early figures on it? I'm told that it's been reordered into the fairly confined universe of short stores that stock searching for the future of the internet, but I think it's doing really well in the inner western parts of Carlton.
Well, there's only one with that. But what's been really heartening is I've gone around and done events in most capital cities and people seem to meet up to the conversation. So my challenge is to not write a book but use the book as a springboard to do so many full things off the back of it, which is what I'm hoping to do. Want to give us a hint about those?
I think there's a real hole for a consumer voice in the whole debate and so something that sounds a bit like a Center for Responsible Technology or something. That might be in the wings for later this year or next year, but you know, all these things, you know, they're great on pay for them. You've got to make them come to life. If I was having, I was having Peter, I drink with a very, very senior figure who had a very disappointing night on May 19th, the other night, who was saying, you know what?
They should have a website to check political facts so that they can, you know, someone tried that. It's not one of those. Yeah, that's right. Yeah.
Okay. Well, thanks Peter for your time. I wish you all the best with Webtopia. Thanks.
Maybe there's going to be Webtopia 2.0 would be the logical. But look, I think you, this is a start of a conversation. It's a conversation that I'd love to keep going with with you and others. And the idea of an institute for responsible tech use or whatever you want to call it, sounds like a rip-up.
Yeah. Thanks, Nate. Right. Thank you.
And thank you all for listening to The Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SCR in her across the country on the community radio network. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media, politics, the joys of the web, the dangers of the web, and a few things only between. We'll be back very soon with more.
But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter where our handle is Fourth Estate AU. And many thanks to my producer Anthony Dopril. My name is Peter Frey and thanks very much for listening.