Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism coming to you from Sydney. Gaggle lands on the Ora Nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey and I am the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology Sydney and my producer today is Anthony Dockrell.
Today's edition is a bit special on a couple fronts. Firstly, we are recording it before a live audience in the business building of UTS rather than in the studios of Chirciar, our normal home. And secondly and most importantly, we're doing that because we have a very special guest who once we've had this chat is going to submit himself to a public Q&A. We're not recording that, I shall add.
That person is interested in being a vice president of New York Google, whose job among many other things entails guiding the company's strategy on how news is surfaced in search in Google News itself and on other devices and overseeing the company's efforts to sustain a healthy ecosystem for journalism. Welcome Richard. Thank you very much. I'd like to be here.
It's great to have you. So on one level, you have a dream job. You fly around the world working out how Google can help the news media industry. You sit on top of a US$300 million fund for the Google News initiative.
You are like the Santa Claus to journalists. But then again, you also fly around the world for meetings with news executives who sometimes think and sometimes articulate it on short to your face that Google is stealing all the advertising money or words like it and with regulators who increasingly want to clip the wings of Google. So that's a kind of bad Santa vibe. So how do you, how do you balance those views out?
Will you, your good Santa and bad Santa at the same time? Well, the way I look at it is simply this. I think as we know, the internet has changed our world in so many ways. It has changed all of our behaviors in terms of how we find and access information, how we understand things, how we understand the world around us and each other in dramatic ways.
It has changed business models, obviously, significantly, which I'm sure we'll talk further about. So yes, I have an extraordinarily fortunate position to be able to do what I'm doing today. Does it come with challenges? Absolutely.
But frankly, we are in this privileged position and we should simply step up and we are stepping up and addressing the challenges as best we can. So when there's executive side here, but Google, we had a business before and it's all your fault. We lost it. What do you say?
When I say let's look at the facts, right? The internet happened. The simplest way to look at this as far as I'm concerned is in 1985, the Metropolitan Daily Newspaper, whether that be in Dallas, Texas or here in Sydney, was the internet of their communities. It wasn't interactive, but it provided all the information that people in those cities needed to live their lives.
Yes, the local city council coverage, but also where were the movies playing? Let me read the few reviews and see the big ads from the studios. It was where my dad, when I turned 16, found a used car for me in the classified of the Providence Journal where he worked. It's where my mom found recipes for Sunday dinner in the discount coupons at the supermarket.
When I came out of college and moved to Washington D.C., I found my first job in the classifieds of the Washington Post, my first department, so on and so forth. But our behaviors have changed. None of us would do that today. And so yes, the business model has changed.
That was a vastly profitable business in its era. And it was a comparatively short era. The modern age of newspaper basically started after the introduction of television, which had a huge impact on the newspaper space. And it began to end in the 1990s, first with cable television and satellite television, which changed the economies of advertising and then of course the internet.
So let's understand these core dynamics that occurred. Yes, Google plays a significant role in this environment, but the revenue that newspapers gained when they were the internet of their communities did not move to Google. Classified advertising moved to online marketplaces. It's not even called advertising anymore.
So it's not Google's fault? No, it is not Google's fault. It would be incorrect in any kind of factual analysis to suggest that is the case. Okay.
Well, we turn to a similar thing. We've got plenty to talk about the future of journalism issue, but I do want to take you back a bit. So just over seven years ago when you were a director of news and social products at Google, same job, different title, more or less, you noted that the media was, in the process of being completely transformed, tossed upside down and you added a question of what will be the next starting innovation. We're at about the same time, any number of news executives, and I was one of them, were saying the most extraordinary thing about these times was watching the revenue shift.
And most of us were thinking that survival and cost-cutting rather than innovation. So I guess my question again to return this thing, you are primarily optimistic about the future of journalism. That's your job, I guess. But those times, these people were primarily pessimistic.
Seven years on with the benefit of a bit of hindsight. You got it right. In terms of optimism? Yeah.
You got the optimism index, right, as it were. Oh, I'm still optimistic about the future news and there's a lot of good reason to be optimistic. Again, we're going to see transitions in the environment of news. We're seeing legacy, traditional publishers clearly go through the pain of disruption.
Many of them will survive, some will not. But at the same time, we're also seeing very vibrant news sources of news and journalism at every level. And let me just cite a few examples, because this isn't just a theory, right? You look at someone like The New York Times.
They were struggling, but they decided eight years ago to go full bore on developing their subscription business. They now have four million digital subscribers, which is twice as many as they ever had in the days of print. Look at the Guardian, the Manchester Guardian, that had about 150,000 circulation before the internet. Now they're a global brand and have a million people who are regularly contributing to them.
So is it only about scale? No, it's not only about scale, because the third example, there are others, but I think these are really important ones. In Canada, there's a fascinating company by the name of Village Media. It's a for-profit company developed by Jeff LG, founded about eight or ten years ago.
He has digital pure plays in communities across Canada, 12 that he owns and operates, and I think in the process of launching another dozen or two dozen more. He is profitable, but he's come into the arena with a very clean slate approach and a very strong focus on the community. He first of all recognizes that what brings a community together is information about the community. What's going on at the high school?
What events are happening? Yes, you do accountability journalism on top of that. He's been very savvy about it. In some of his markets, he has 60% of the population getting his daily email newsletter, and he's profitable.
By the way, here's how his revenue mix is today. 85% of his revenue is custom local advertising, including classifieds, because interestingly in small communities, that degree of trust is important. I'm going to sell a used car, and rather not confront someone from 50 miles away who I may not know. All kinds of custom local advertising.
The other 15% is programmatic via services like Google and others. He hasn't yet gone to subscriptions. Google helped him. That's helped him instantly.
We have not directly helped him. He uses a lot of our technology, which I did not even realize at the time. I met him when I was testifying before the Heritage Commission in Canada. Now, we're working with him very closely because he has a platform that works.
For instance, with McClatchy newspapers in the United States, we have funded an experiment to basically take Jeff's platform and apply it in a community in Ohio in the United States, Youngstown, Ohio, to see does this platform approach in his playbook work in other communities? If so, then we want to take those learnings, whether through him or through companies like Automatic Automatic, where we're funding a CMS for local newsrooms, can we allow these models to more easily be scaled by others? What we're really talking about here is a combination of the civic function journalism and the business model. Yes.
The two can, in your view, coexist. They can. In fact, even in the modern heyday of newspapers, what made the newspaper work wasn't the accountability journalism. It was the community information that made it work, and obviously the accountability journalism, which was very important on top of that.
Do you think journalism needs to change in its fundamental nature? The kind of idea that journalism will tell you that the local journalism will tell you there's a cat up a tree or a car accident in your road, that sort of news is so ubiquitous, it seems hardly a value proposition for journalism anymore. What is the proposition for journalism in say, village media or even the MIT in a sense? Well, my preferred definition of journalism is to give citizens the information they need to be informed good citizens.
I actually see our role as Google with Google searches. How do we give our users the tools and information from third party sources to be informed good citizens? I think that principle, I would like to think as is true today as it was then. Now given all that, what I've said many times over the past decade or so is I think it's important for journalists to rethink every dimension of the model, not that it must change but intellectually important to do so.
Yes, the business model has changed. But what about the media form? We have people consuming information throughout the day on these devices. How do we get knowledge into their heads?
How does the story form evolve? I don't have the answers, but I do believe it's important for us to consider. How does that work? It's a little bit about constructive journalism, which we may be explaining a little bit about that for the audience.
The constructive idea being not reporting the car accident down the road rather than reporting why it happened or how it might not happen again. Yes, I mean the way I say it, and I love the phrase constructive journalism. Others use the phrase solution, journalism. Not that I disagree with their intent, but this isn't about happy news.
Yes, it's important to report the car accident. To me constructive journalism says you report the event as it happened, but you also want to go beyond that. You want to try to understand why it happened. You might want to surface what are the options available to the community to make sure it doesn't happen again.
I think you want to establish that perspective and that philosophy about news with your community. One of the deeply unfortunate things that's happening and this didn't start recently, but it's getting worse, is people don't even want to listen to the news because they say it's all horrible and I would rather just hide away from it. This is awful. This is deeply challenging to our societies.
That can't be how we move forward. It is a lot of people. Again, the news from Facebook. They're getting a lot of people getting the news from the Facebook feed, which is feeding them what they want to hear.
Yes, they're getting it from all kinds of sources and indeed social networks as well. That's something that I think we have to take into account also. That does present new challenges, but there too. That's why, again, it's important to rethink not just the form.
How can reporters have a better ability to use data to do the work that they do? How do you engage with audiences? If you're increasingly reliant on reader revenue, everyone I know who's successful at that at the local level is changing their methods of engagement with the audience. It's no longer about sitting up here as journalists and telling the community what to believe.
It's how do we engage with them? Are we doing town halls? Are we saying, tell us, what are the needs in interest of your community? What are the issues that you would like us to address?
How do you establish that relationship? To me, that's the important of constructive journalism and saying yes, what they're doing is important. It tells me understand yes bad things happen in the world, but here's how we can find solutions as they may happen less frequently going forward. I'd like to acknowledge that Google does a lot for the news industry.
I should also acknowledge that Google has actually funded a project for the CMT. I'd like to come back to a couple of specific things you're doing, namely the backlight project and common knowledge. I would like to touch on, given that you are sitting in Australia, something that Google doesn't seem reluctant to do for the news industry. That is this revenue sharing idea as proposed by the Australian Competition Consumer Commission reporting to digital platforms.
I'm sure you're across it. One of the recommendations which is before the treasure at Joce Ryanenburg is essentially to have a regular sanction of revenue sharing between platforms and news publishers. You guys don't like that, why is that? First of all, it's very important in these discussions to understand specifically what one might be proposing.
I think that's not a lot of detail in that, but I think it's just broadly that there should be money coming back from Google to the publishers. Now, let's take it apart in its different pieces. As I mentioned today, we do offer, for instance, advertising technologies used by hundreds of thousands of publishers around the world, where the revenue shares, by the way, are 70 to 90 percent to the publisher. That last year generated $14.5 billion to publishers around the globe, money in their pockets.
We're doing subscribe with Google, which we developed in collaboration with the community of publishers around the world to help drive reader revenue, where we've come up with some easy-to-use tools, where we say, you know, we have email addresses and credit card information for a lot of our users, and that can help simplify a purchase process. If I have to enter a credit card number, people will abandon. I mean, all anyone in e-commerce tells you these things. Under that program, by the way, 95 percent of the revenue goes to the publisher, and we also do not seek to own the customer.
So if the subscription happens through us, we give the user name and the email address to the user. Quite different from the way Apple News, for instance, works out their subscription program. But all those things involve using Google tools. And the option, by the way, of the publisher, in fact, we've broken it up into component parts, and they can use each individual component at their will.
For instance, at the back end of it, we've now in Google search, for instance, if you do a query on, say, Brexit, we won't change the organic search results. But if we know that you're a subscriber to a publication, then we will put typically in like position four, here are results about that query from the publications that you subscribe to, because we think it's important, if you're a subscriber, that you get the full value of that subscription. We will do that. If we know that you have a subscription, we don't care how you get that subscription.
If you tell us you have that subscription, or if the New York Times or the Washington Post or the Sydney Morning Herald says, by the way, if we can link these accounts with your permission, Google will help make sure that you're seeing information from us. You still don't like the ACC's proposal. I want to make sure that, again, here's what I think some people are trying to propose, and this is what has transpired in Europe over the last several months. We will get to that in a second.
But that is the answer to the question, is the notion of a snippet tax. I don't necessarily say they have a subscriber snippet tax, and we'll get to that, because people may not know what we're talking about. They're really just saying, hey, Google, Facebook, publishers, sitting in room, and come up with the way the more money can go to the New Times. So too, that's very well, they're saying at that fundamental level.
And that is exactly what we're doing through the programs I mentioned. That is exactly what we're doing with the $300 million where we're looking to drive innovation. But let's be clear about a couple of things, whether we talk about snippets or not. There's a presumption underneath all of this that somehow we're making a lot of money off of news content.
Now, we currently send 24 billion visits each month to news organizations around the world through Google Search in Google News, which is valuable traffic in and of itself. Traffic which publishers used to pay news stands to accommodate distribution of their content. So let's recognize that. But in spite of the fact that it's 24 billion, current events queries on Google is in the low single digits.
And by the way, if you look at the results against those queries, you don't see ads because those typically aren't terribly commercially viable. One out of a thousand queries is a commercially viable query. So if anything is based on a notion that somehow we're making a lot of money off of news publishers' content on Google, it's simply incurable. But aren't you making money out of the data of the people who access that content?
No, because interestingly, that data is specifically in that category. First of all, it isn't terribly helpful. The data that's helpful is, are you looking for a refrigerator? Right?
I mean, it's a commercial query. And in fact, any queries in the current event space, particularly if there are anything close to politics, right, we specifically by intent, we don't track ideology either in terms of the content that we're assessing in ranking or of the ideological leanings of our users. So no, there's no particular data that's valuable to Google. So I was saying this is a, it's based on incorrect assumptions.
But bottom line, the important thing I think is also this. Journalism is best when it is independently sustainable, right? You do not want journalism to be based on artificial peers of support, particularly based on a notion of, you know, it's easy today to look at Google and say, wonderfully successful company. Will that be the case five, ten years from now?
Right? Part of my career, by the way, is I read it. So it's not going to be broken up in ten years time. I'm not saying that.
I'll tell you this. Okay? In 1996, 97, I was head of the number two search engine in the United States and probably far beyond called Excite Yahoo was number one. And we were trying, how could we conceivably knock Yahoo off their perch?
And Excite was an excellent search engine. But guess what happened? Larry and Sergey came out of a garage in Palo Alto and created Google and knocked both of us off our perches. They gave you a job.
And good job for me. Luckily for me, they ultimately gave me a job. But you look beyond that and you look, look how device behaviors have changed, shift to mobile, shift to audio speakers. What does that do to the underlying models that drive our success today?
We don't know. So my main point is, be wary. We all in the world of journalism should be wary about relying on third party sources of support that may not be there the next day. Okay.
So just on the ACCC, though, you're not really going to go to where they want you to go. Is that what I'm hearing? Well, again, they posed the question. They didn't pose a specific solution.
Right. Well, they said that Google had market power and privilege positions and therefore it should pay over more money. That was their essence of their argument. Well, again, but it gets back to these very core facts.
I mean, one can say, oh, the world of news has changed and maybe big companies should help. Well, you could look at that across the board and say, oh, interesting. I mean, and some people have proposed this. Maybe all digital advertising should be taxed.
I don't know. Whatever one might want to do. But be careful about about the determination of artificial means of support and be careful about models on the presumption. Like here's an interesting thing when people even talk about taxes.
I say, be careful about presuming that a disproportionate amount of that revenue, wherever it comes from, is going to go to support quality journalism. Well, because I've never seen a model that would allow that to work because of the simple reason that it's impossible to define. I travel the world dealing with public policy issues. I've not seen a law that defines what news is, much less quality journalism or suggest how that should be supported.
So when I look at the world of media today in the world of journalism, say, what is quality journalism? How do we make sure that if that's going to happen, you're not supporting, for instance, poor quality journalism? Well, you've actually made Google's just recently made some changes to the guidelines that privilege original reporting. Correct.
So you've had a crack at this question. Exactly. In the simple context of original reporting. What is that?
What's the definition of original reporting? I think original reporting as people in the business would define it is where you have reporters who are doing the hard-nosed work of gathering basic facts and introducing those facts to the media landscape. Right. And I think the concerns and understandable concerns that news organizations who do a lot of original reporting are appropriately concerned about is I do the original reporting, but somebody else is taking and rewriting my story in benefit from that.
And they're getting provisions in precisely. Precisely. And they're not getting privileged, but they often occur. And so we have over the years, we've done a lot to try to do a better job of understanding what is the canonical article in this story?
What is the original? Which is complex. And I could spend an hour just defining how we approach that. And I would actually, instead of spending that hour, no, I did a very detailed interview with the Global Editors Network that they republished on medium.
And I would encourage you to all take a look at it. So yes, we are making further advancements. One is machine learning has been very helpful to us in understanding stories and how they evolve. And we've also introduced policies that guide those who evaluate our search results to help us do a better job, to help them as they go through and assess results and say they read each article and say, go behind the article.
Where is this coming from? What do you know about the domain? What do you know about the expertise of the author? Is this an original piece?
What are the attributes that might say this is an original piece? Does it feature, for instance, a lot of quotes from people who aren't necessarily known? These are hard things to understand. But our objective there is to say one thing I would be particularly satisfied with is in addition to identifying the original report and doing it as much justice as possible, are we doing a good job of understanding who are the sources in the ecosystem that are doing original reporting to some degree versus those who are doing none?
And so can we raise the tide on all those boats who are doing that work? This wouldn't stop, though, a rewrite of it from taking a canonical piece, rewriting it or sticking a few extra quotes and then getting surface quite high in Google search. Well, it won't stop anyone from doing the rewrites. Obviously our objective is to make sure that those rewrites aren't surfacing highly.
And I'm not going to suggest by any means that the approaches that we've undertaken will be perfect. These are moving targets. Yes, there are continue going to be outlets that do that. Now, as you know, as we often say, that's part of free expression as well.
That might be hard, obviously, if you're in I've been there at Salon, we did a lot of investigative journalism and the Associated Press would go do the same story two days later. It wouldn't give us any credit for it. It's a tough word. We should talk about the European Union and the snippets tax because we sort of floated it up there.
Well, it's not a snippets tax. Well, okay, they've given the French in particular, given new sites the right to charge Google for the privilege of providing new snippets. No, actually, he's not going to watch the U.S. You better explain because I'm clearly not right.
The European Union passed a copyright directive earlier this year, which is a directive to the member states. The French government was the first to transform it into law. With the copyright directive states is that appropriately it enhances copyright for the digital age and it says the copyright can determine what third parties can use. That's what it states.
It doesn't require payment. It says the publisher determines what they're willing to make available. Right? Even in the right.
Precisely. And so we have complied with that law and I was in France just three weeks ago communicating what our compliance would be. Now, let's understand a few things here. Some of this might be obvious.
Some of this might not. When you look at search results, yes, what you typically see is a URL, a headline or title for that URL, and often a preview underneath it, what some people call a snippet. Interestingly, on Google for the last several years, for news results on the top of search and in Google news, we typically don't use snippets. And the reason is that news headlines tend to be very descriptive and written carefully to communicate information and compel interest.
The snippets aren't terribly useful. And by taking them away, we could actually have more results in less space, which actually drives more traffic. And interestingly, publishers have also told us over the years in news that they felt the snippets give away too much information. And they would actually prefer we not use them.
So there's an interesting paradox now where French publishers are saying, we insist you pay for snippets that we would prefer you not use. All right. And so beyond that, what we've said, yes, is we have unveiled new tools available to all publishers in the world to tell us what we can and cannot use. Do you want to allow us to use a preview?
And if so, at what length? Can we use a thumbnail? And if so, what size? Can we use in surfacing a video result?
Can we show the first six seconds or nine seconds or zero seconds? It is up to you to tell us to do that. So we're not in a situation where we're with Spain, the Spanish a few years ago, where Google's going to pull out because it's inside this. It's like the most subtle fuzzy.
The difference in the world of Spain, but I want to get to finish the EU first. And then we can glad to go to Spain. All these countries, glad to visit them. I'm sure they got to have it.
And so what we've said is we will honor those selections, but no, we will not pay for the snippets. And there are many reasons why. One is users who use Google Trust Google, the consumer research tells us thing very clearly, very high percentages of trust. Interestingly, when we look at people who don't trust us, the primary issue is they think we're being paid to surface the results that we surface.
And so by policy, we will not accept payment for search results. We have ads. They're labeled as ads. Nor will we pay for results to appear in Google.
That's a red line. We will not cross that line. Now to the value equation, are we giving appropriate value back to publishers? Well, let's take a look at that.
Historically, and to this day, as you know, print publishers paid news stands to actually make their products available and build audiences. Interestingly, France, the only country on earth that actually regulates news stands, they did this after World War II, and the purpose of the law was to say news stands should carry a wide breadth of diversity of sources. Guess what? That's what we do, right?
But we don't charge publishers to be in search, as you know. And we do provide immense amount of traffic back. As I said, 24 billion visits per month. And in Europe, Deloitte assessed that news publishers, large news publishers, in Europe, each of those clicks is worth between four and six euro cents.
Now, use whatever math you'd like. Use a penny. Use five. It's an immense amount of money.
So the notion that the value exchange is not there is a fallation. Just because we're running out of time. So where do you think this is going to be in this particular situation in France? Well, what we've said is, look, we will not pay for snippets.
We think there's a very sound principle for why we should not and we will adhere to that. But don't mishear us. We have been and will continue to contribute resources, technologies and dollars towards the future of news. In fact, I would suggest that no private company on the face of the earth is contributed more towards the future of news, not as investments, not equity holdings, but as contributions to the industry.
We will continue to do that and we will continue to do more. So let's just be clear that what we want in the end here, I think what all of us want is a principle of a fulfilled, fair and equitable ecosystem. Not one that's driven by what decisions Google or any entity might make as to who the preferred sources are. So let's create a fair and equitable ecosystem.
Let's do everything we can to make sure that we enable, whether it be Google or anyone else, a future for news that is sustainable and independent, which is what it needs to be. Okay. A couple of quick things. What do you think of that?
It's an interesting, because I found interesting about myself and I know they're not. You can't be a dispassionate observer, maybe. But is the idea that they seem to have done a deal with the New York Times and News Corporation. And that seems to be a change of focus on news corporation in terms of Facebook and you know, the news keeps asking, suggesting that Google should be broken up.
What's happened? Are they back in love with them and they don't love you guys? What's going on there? Look, outside of my facial expressions.
Yes, we should be on TV. It's not for me to comment on Facebook strategies or what they do. What I will point out, what I think is so important in all of these conversations. And it's something I make sure to raise in every engagement I have with publishers or with tech journalists or this group here.
Today the term platforms is tossed around as if it were generic. And I say, when you consider it the ecosystem in the role of these companies that you label as platforms, make sure you understand precisely what you're talking about in each case. And I don't say this to criticize any particular company, just understand what drives them, what's their business model, social networks, Facebook. It is a private platform.
It is all about engagement in their environment. In everything they've done, whether it was instant articles or this, is about activity within their environment. I look at Apple. I work at Apple.
iOS is a great operating system. They manage it tightly. That's their business, the clean, well-elected place of the iOS ecosystem. Google, specifically Google search, Google News, Google advertising services, right?
YouTube, you can put more in the social network category because we host the content. We can set policies for the hosting of that content. But when you look at Google search and our ad technologies, the truth is our platform is the open web, right? Like, people have asked me, and maybe this isn't appropriate close for this portion.
They say, Richard, all this stuff that you're doing, why are you doing it? Are you doing it because publishers criticize you and you want more friends? Say, well, I like having friends. That's not a bad thing.
That's not what drives us. They say, is this because you have high level principles about the importance of journalism in society? I hope so. And yes, we do.
But that's not really what drives us. If you want, again, look at the underlying motivations of a business and understand why. Google search, by far our most popular product and valued product by consumers around the world, its value in relevance is based on their being and open and rich ecosystem of expression on the web. You look at our ad technologies, again, used by hundreds of thousand publishers generating a lot of revenue.
None of that would happen if those publishers weren't successful on the open web. So all of these efforts that we're driving, whether it's to do a better job in search results to make sure they're trusted and relevant, or whether we're doing to enable a healthy ecosystem for news and expression in general is very much tied to the core nature of our business. The reason why I went to Google, right? I mean, yes, I've had an interesting career and an extraordinarily privileged career.
But I went to work for Google initially 12 years ago because I felt in this ecosystem and it was very clear to me back then. Because again, I have been on this cutting edge of media and technology for actually close to 50 years. It's kind of scary. What I realize though is that there was any entity in this ecosystem that could have good and positive impact on the evolution of media and journalism is okay.
Right. And again, I'm not saying we're perfect, but I think that's what we're trying to do. I think we're doing it in a principal fashion. And as I tell every journalist, your job is to hold institutions to account, including Google.
Oh, that's what we have to do. And do that. And the only thing I ask is go deep, understand the true nature of what's going on. Don't base your reporting on means, because means are dangerous.
But go deep, understand the nature of the environment, of the economics, of the particular challenges of free expression in our world today. I deal a lot with challenges of misinformation. This information is a huge problem. We know that.
To me, the biggest and most dangerous impact of misinformation is that it is stimulated regulation around the world. Some of it well intended, most of it well intended. Some of it less so. But in many cases with very troubling secondary consequences on free expression itself.
Okay. We're going to leave it there because I want to leave room for questions. And we're going to keep asking questions because we've taken up a little bit too much time. Richard, thank you so much for your time and thank you for being on Fourth Estate.
Oh, thank you. Go play. And thank you for listening to the Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the School of Business at the UTS.
And thanks for everyone involved in making it happen. Fourth Estate can be heard across the country on the community radio network. And may possible by the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Make sure you subscribe to your favorite podcast app.
So you can listen to Fourth Estate at your leisure. And we'll be back next week. But in the meantime, you can have on Twitter as Fourth Estate. You may thanks to my producer and my name is Peter Fray.
And thank you very much for listening. Thank you. Safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars.
And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer. That's how we protect Ontario for all of us. Learn how at Ontario.org.org.org.org Learn how at Ontario.ca.
Safer Ontario. Paid for by the Government of Ontario.