Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We are coming to you from to us the R&C on Gadigal lands of the Oran nation, right across Australia, on the Community Radio Network, and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Tina Quinn. In this edition I speak with Todd Heisler, an American photo journalist whose work has won him both a Pulitzer Prize and an Emmy Award.
Todd was born in Arlington Heights, Illinois, and grew up in and around Chicago. After graduating from Illinois State University in 1994, he went on to work for a number of local newspapers before joining the Rocky Mountain News in Denver, Colorado in 2001. Todd was part of the Mountain News team that won a Pulitzer for their coverage of the Colorado Wild Fire season in 2003. His 2006 photographic work on the essay Final Salute won him the Pulitzer Prize for Feature Photography.
In December of that year, he joined the New York Times as a staff photographer, where, amongst many other things, he has covered every US election and primary season since 2007. He joins me now from New York. Todd Heisler, welcome to Fourth Estate. Thank you, pleasure to be here.
As I mentioned, you've covered just about every US election over the last 13 years. It must seem like a ridiculous question, but how has 2020 compared to the ones you've previously covered? No, it's not a ridiculous question. 2020 couldn't be more different than any of the other years for a number of reasons, and it keeps evolving.
It's been quite an extraordinary and unprecedented year, and it started out that way even before the pandemic hit. We were covering the Iowa caucus in January, which is what kicks off the primary season in the United States, and that had a totally different vibe this year as well because of the impeachment hearings that were happening. And for the candidates on the Democratic ticket for the primary were senators, so they were not in Iowa campaigning for most of that time, so that changed the dynamic considerably. So this year just started off in a very strange way.
Little did we know that it would get stranger. The pandemic, which brought a normal campaign season to a screeching halt for all intents and purposes, and from there it was a completely different summer, at least for part of it. Along the way, the political conventions, which is when really the campaigns kick into high gear in the summer, toward the end of the summer, were vastly different. The Democrats held a convention that was almost entirely virtual, and on the Republican side, part of it was virtual, and it was capped with an in-person event at the White House, which is also unprecedented.
Moving on from there, the events were unlike we've seen before in terms of taking precautions for COVID. Biden's events were mostly driving events where they were done outside, people drove their cars, and they were to remain in their car or near their car. And he or one of his surrogates, like Dr. Joe Biden, his wife or former President Obama, would speak to the crowds on a stage and instead of applause, you'd hear cars honking.
So I'd never seen anything like that before. And it was also very challenging to photograph, because your normal cues of applause and noise usually guide you to where the images are, but often you'd look out and just see a car. So it was a unique experience. On the Republican side, President Trump was still doing in-person events with very little distancing, but it was still a very different year.
Pre-pandemic, there was already a great sense that Donald Trump was very likely to sail to another victory. When you were able to hit the road again in October, were you already getting a sense from your experiences with people on the grounds at Campaign Stomps and rallies that something had indeed shifted since the pandemic? I would say that there was a sense all along that President Trump could be reelected. I think this year, and I think the difference between 2016 and now, I think you certainly saw more Trump signs out and about, and a new thing that you would see are Trump flags.
You certainly saw those in 2016, but you saw way more this year in a new dynamic of this campaign season where the truck rallies and the convoys, both supporters were both candidates were doing this, but you were more likely to see Trump supporters do this. You have flags and pickup trucks and driving around town or meeting up in a, say, like a target or a Walmart parking lot and having a parade or a convoy through a town. That's something you didn't see a lot of in 2016. I would say even the pandemic notwithstanding, I would say being out and about as late as October, at least visually saw quite a lot of what looked like support for President Trump.
So, and let's not forget, more than 70 million people voted for him as well. So, I think turnout played a big factor in this year as well. You still manage quiet and extraordinary turnout. One thing that I've noticed in your work is that you don't spend as much time covering the actual candidates themselves, but more so their supporters.
What attracts you to covering those on the fray? You obviously find them more compelling in a sense. Yeah, and I should clarify too, for the most part, I do whatever's needed at any given time. So, there have been since that I've done following the candidate and doing what we would call on candidate coverage.
It's a lot more controlled and access gets tighter and tighter, it seems, with each campaign season. But I do always prefer to be on the periphery and on the fringes of any story. I think if you look at a lot of my work, I like to take larger news stories and take a granular look at them through the lives of people being affected by it. And I like to do the same thing with politics.
I find you can get a more genuine look at it and you get away from what I would call the show, campaign events are a show and they're choreographed to some degree and all designed a certain way. And if you do cover a particular campaign for weeks or months on end, they do start to look the same after a while. So, you do anything you can to find some variety to give readers a different sense of what things are looking like and feeling like out there. I recently watched a keynote speech.
You gave a number of years ago and you spoke of how ever since you had been in college, people had predicted the depth of photojournalism, but that what you would learn time and time again, even though the general public is often inundated with imagery, one photograph still has the power to make people stop. Now, one photograph that certainly comes to my mind is one that was part of a sequence of photos that you took on election night in 2016. He was the man in the overflow section at the Javits Center where Hillary Clinton had been expected to give her acceptance speech. And it was towards the end of the night or in the early hours of the morning and he was on the ground crying.
Can you tell us a bit more about that photo and perhaps about that night? All the polls were pointing to Hillary Clinton being the first female president of the United States. And that was the mindset going into that evening. And when we plan an event like that, you have a number of fixed positions in the event space.
And so you would have what would be a center stand that would go, you know, shoot straight towards the podium, you would have a cutaway, which would be to the side. You would have somebody that's actually traveling with the candidate that year we had Doug Mills traveling with Hillary Clinton. And maybe a few other people just roaming. And you have an editor, a photo editor, in this case it was Jessica Dimson who did an amazing job of moving the pieces around the board to put the right people in the right place.
And we had a conversation leading up to that night where she gave me the option, but also a suggestion of where she'd like me to be. And that's what a great picture editor can do. They know your work and your personality. And they can kind of nudge you where they'd like you to be.
And she gave me the option. She said, I can put you on a center stand. You'll get the potentially the page one picture that's pretty straightforward. But what I'd really like you to do is be outside and try to find something that's a little different.
You know, we always strive for something. I hate to use the word iconic, but that's what you're always striving for. But just to try to find something different and maybe somebody who couldn't get inside. But you know, you always work the edges of these things to take a chance and try to get something that nobody else has.
And I'm always up to that task because that's the type of work I like to do. I don't like to be stuck in one spot and being set on a center center stand can be a little boring. So I jumped at the chance to try to do something different. As you know, as the night starts, Hillary Clinton is starting to win states and you see people celebrating.
But maybe after about 9, 9, 30, she's losing states that she was expected to win. And you can see the faces in the crowd just telling that story and just reflecting the reality of the news that was breaking right there. Really puts light on the myth that she didn't inspire passion like Donald Trump did or on the other side candidates like Bernie Sanders or President Barack Obama. Oh, absolutely.
And I covered her a little bit that year. And obviously, as we discussed, I covered her in 2008 as well. And the energy and the passion for her was evident at all of her rallies. There's no question that there was incredible support for her.
So then how did you come across this man in the upper floor section of the Javits Center who was on the ground so clearly agonized by the way the night had gone? I ended up just staying in that hallway all night. Even when most people left, I think this photograph was taken about 1.32 o'clock in the morning when most people had realized that the candidate was not going to come out and speak to the crowd the night was over. Donald Trump won the presidency and that was it.
And just before I was about to leave, I took one more pass through the hallway as people were leaving and it was getting darker and I saw this situation and it was pretty reflective of how everybody in that room was feeling that night. Did you realize at the time that the American flag was actually reflecting off the floor next to this man? It seemed like you framed the shop perfectly. His head was in his hands.
He was on the ground crying and next to him was this reflection of the American flag. And it seems there was a great poetry to it which seemed to represent the great turmoil that was within America. I guess still is. Thank you.
Yeah, I did. If I recall, I did because you could see, I think I photographed it wide so you could actually see the flag in the set up in the empty room and then was able to zoom in a little bit and get a couple of tighter shots that abstracted the flag a little bit more so it was a little less literal. And I think ultimately that was the frame that resonated better than the more literal wide shot. Look, I'm going to go back a little bit now.
So I'm sure you've been asked this before. Was there a specific moment or point in your life where you decided that you wanted to be a photojournalist? Or was it something that you wanted as early as you could remember? I think I'm trying to think of photographs.
I was interested in photography as a teenager in high school. And I think one thing that was really moving to me early on when I was a teenager, we visited the Vietnam War Memorial in Washington, D.C. And it just so happened that we made this trip on Memorial Day weekend. And it was packed with people visiting.
And I remember it was just a really moving experience to witness. And I was learning how to photograph in a situation like that. And I remember making a photograph of these two men embracing. And I think from that point, maybe I didn't even know what photojournalism really was.
I didn't really know what you could do with it. But I just remember that moment of being able to articulate what an experience felt like through a photograph I think is what clicked for me and pushed me in that direction. But I think it from there it took many years after that to really find my place in it and really find what I could do with it. Once you realized that you wanted to become a photojournalist, were there any great heroes that you looked to that inspired you in a way or informed the sort of work that you thought you wanted to do?
Yeah, at that time, each generation of photojournalists learn from and are inspired by the generation just right before them. So for me, coming out of college in the early 90s, you had the Bosnian war happening at that time. And the great photographers were James Noctwey, Christopher Morris, Ron Heveve, some of the others that I'm forgetting. Different conflicts, but similar generation, Maggie Steber, people who shot a lot for National Geographic at that time and did a lot of amazing work in Haiti.
These were the people that you looked up to and that you might even be able to meet them somewhere. And that was that was something that was really inspiring at that time that pushed me along. Not necessarily, I didn't necessarily want to do that type of work, but that was the work that really stood out at that time. And these were people who were going to the edge of the abyss to really tell that story.
And for me, that was really inspiring. You said that you didn't necessarily want to do some of the work that some of your heroes had done in terms of going and covering conflict zones and so forth. What sort of work did you want to do? What sort of things did you want to cover as a photojournalist?
I did want to do that at first, but I think the work I really wanted to do was, at a younger age coming out of college, I was interested in politics, for sure. I loved the work of Stephen Crawley from the New York Times and P.S. Bentley, who did a lot of great behind the scenes presidential work. And Christopher Morris later was doing that as well.
And Kelly Shell. So I was interested in that, but I guess I never really had, it really didn't matter where it was. It was that I wanted to be able to say something with my work that maybe gives the viewer the reader a deeper understanding of somebody they didn't, that they had met and to encourage empathy among other things. And I think that's what I was always really drawn to, stories like that.
Johnny had a little bit then to 2006, you won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction Photography for your series, Final Salute. And it covered U.S. Marines, whose job it is to break the bad news of a soldier's death to their families. Can you tell me a little bit about that assignment and how long you spent working on it and how well you got to know these Marines?
Yeah, and that's a really good example of what I was referring to. And that story, for me, exemplifies a lot of what I've learned as a person and a photojournalist and what I want to build on moving forward. One of which was I started, when the Iraq war started, I covered it in a couple of different trips. And that was the story of that time.
And a number of my peers had covered that war extensively much more than I, but I really wanted to cover that war and just for the sake of history, if nothing else. And what I didn't realize is that there was a way to tell that story without ever having to go there. And that's what this story was. And I think a lot of great stories find you as much as you find them.
And this is a perfect example of that. I started working on that story with Jim Sheehler, who was an amazing writer, was at the Rocky Mountain News at the time. And he was doing obituary, excuse me, Jim Sheehler was writing profiles of service members who were killed in the Iraq war. And he had spent so much time in this veteran cemetery, he met Major Beck, who was doing a lot of this casualty assistance work.
And he approached him about following him and really getting a closer look behind the Marines that were doing this really solemn duty. And eventually he, Major Beck, capitulated and allowed us to follow him. But it was a long journey. It was something that we thought would be a two week assignment.
And ultimately we spent about a year on it. I guess there's a lot of preconceived notions about those that work in defense in the armed forces. Did it break down any stereotypes or prejudices that you yourself had about those that worked in defense? I mean, you're, it's a very cerebral profession that you're in.
And I would think that you'd be meeting completely different types of people to yourself. I think it certainly helps that I had been to Iraq a couple of times before that with the families and with the Marines that we were with. I think they knew or at least felt that I had a better understanding of what they go through. I hope that it broke down some stereotypes.
My guiding principle is that at the end of the day, we're all human beings and we all want the same basic things out of life. And I think you can usually find common ground with just about everybody. That doesn't mean anyone, photographer or journalist is the right fit for any other situation. But that's what you strive for in this profession.
And you do want to, you need the access and the trust of all the people involved to allow you the space and the time to document this in a way that's respectful, but also in a way that makes people want to spend time with the image to hopefully learn more about the people in it. And that's always a very delicate balance because you know, great photography is about aesthetics. And that's what draws people in. But I think if you lean too heavily on that, then it's more about the photographer than the people in the photograph.
And so I'm always trying to be aware of that balance and not make that so much about me and what I'm trying to say. It's about telling their story and showing them. The BBC's Nick Bryant was recently on Fourth Estate and in talking about elections and presidential candidates. He mentioned that journalists often choose their presidential story and the most entertaining always wins out.
He used as an example during the 2007-2008 primary season. Much of the media decided that electing Barack Obama, the first African American man to win both the Democratic nomination and then hopefully the presidency, that seemed a more compelling story than electing Hillary Clinton, the first female. Now that was your, that was probably the first election that you covered for the times. Am I correct?
The first primary season you covered? That's correct. Absolutely. Yeah, in 2008.
Well, 2007 actually because Hillary Clinton announced her candidacy in early 2007. So 2008 primary season was a very long, protracted, fascinating primary. And at the time I had never really covered a primary that thoroughly before because where I worked before, we didn't really cover those much. And we had, because there were so many candidates and it was an open year in that you had Republicans and Democrats both having primaries because George W.
Bush was finishing his second term. And I worked a lot with David Skoll at the time who was the picture editor heading up our campaign coverage. And the times decided they were going to put a photographer on each one of these candidates for as long as that candidate remained in the race. And so in January starting in Iowa, they put, I couldn't even tell you off the top of my head how many candidates there were, but they were in the double digits.
And so initially they put me on Mike Huckabee, Republican candidate who was the governor of Arkansas. And I think Doug Mills was on Hillary Clinton. And I forget who was on Barack Obama at the time. And so the plan was to just write it out with that candidate until they can see it.
And then we would move people around accordingly. And for me, I liked covering a candidate like Huckabee because there was less. He didn't have a secret service detail yet. He wasn't quite the front runner.
And those are fun to cover because you can move around more, you get better access, you can walk backstage, you can follow the bus around. It's more spontaneity. It's more genuine. And sometimes it's just a matter of getting different angles can make it more interesting.
When you can't go behind or move to the left a certain way, the light doesn't look right. And all these little things that just can make your coverage flat or more compelling. And so you make these decisions about which candidate you want to cover for a lot of various reasons. Some of which are Barack Obama had this really great narrative that ultimately in hindsight made, obviously, for great stories but for great images as well.
I didn't actually cover him very much. So I went from Mike Huckabee to Hillary Clinton and followed her from before Super Tuesday. So sometime in February, all the way through June up to the last primary when she ultimately lost. But they were neck and neck for the entire time.
So it was a very long primary season. And very close, obviously. Yes, correct. I think the campaigns were different at that time too because, yeah, in 2008, those were not only was it a long protracted primary, but it was grueling.
We would very often cover two or three states in a day, get to your hotel very late at night or even early in the morning and then have to go back at it and be swept with Secret Service at seven o'clock in the morning the next day. So it was a really grueling campaign season to cover. Do you feel that you've either consciously or unconsciously chosen a narrative as a photojournalist or do you think it works a little bit differently for you? I think it works a little bit differently for us.
I mean, there's no question that you don't cheer for a candidate. You know, there's the old saying there's no cheering in the press box. So you can't look at it that way. But you do have to look at it in some ways of whether you're going to click with a certain campaign.
And it's hard to really describe what that would be. It's not about your political opinions or their policy. Sometimes it's a matter of the people that work for them. And have you known them from other campaigns?
And do you think that you could be able to get some access or move around or work with them? And so it becomes a fit in that way. But yeah, I think you also have to look at it in that you might pick a candidate and say, well, I think this person has a chance to go very far. And you want to be in early so you have to access to tell that whole story of whoever that candidate is.
But I think we might look at it more in those terms. And I guess you could say that's choosing a narrative so to speak. But I think you have to be cautious with that concept, I guess. Absolutely.
And what is that like when you switch from covering a campaign like Governor Mike Ocadis to then covering the one for then Senator Clinton? When you jump from one campaign to another, there's always a period that you need to get up to speed and get comfortable and get to know everybody and just kind of get a feel for the rhythm. I would say because Hillary Clinton was much more well-known at the time and had been campaigning for longer. I think there was a more intense rhythm there.
And obviously there's a greater infrastructure involved because she's a former First Lady and Senator at the time. There's much more security. She has a secret for the detail. Yeah.
And so you can't just walk up to an event and five minutes before it starts and find a spot and start working. You have to get there early, you have to be swept. Sometimes you might be putting a pen for a period of time and then you have to work with a campaign and move around. So right off the bat it's very different.
And then obviously the events are much bigger and there's more of them. And then as that particular year 2008 was just such an aggressive primary, the number of events in the number of states that she was doing was just astounding. Just the energy level was hard to keep up with. I think you see that with any campaign at that point but any great campaigner, you'll see there's a pace there that is pretty remarkable.
Yeah. The stamina required is quite phenomenal in terms of the schedule they keep. I often think jumping back ahead of election night in 2016, Hillary Clinton must have had an hour or two sleep before having to get up and then prepare and then present her concession speech all by 7am. I think it was the following morning.
Absolutely. And I would say too, we had spoken a little bit about picking a campaign and deciding where to be or where you click with. It's always, I think what most photographers like to do is try to link up with a campaign very early and get to know them. One because you say you connect with a campaign in Iowa.
If they're not a former First Lady or somebody with a Secret Service detail, you can work these small events, you can move around, and then you can really get to know the campaigns and be with it as it grows and follow it through its course. And I think back to some great, as long as we're on the subject of the Clintons, some great campaign photography that came out and Bill Clinton's first run in 92. Oh, that was remarkable. Yeah.
Remarkable images from New Hampshire when he was the underdog and the behind the scenes photography and his energy and his stamina just comes through in all these images. So those are the types of things you can get early on. If you pick the right candidate and you click with them, et cetera. That's a challenge of campaign photography at any time.
Even if you do have some behind the scenes access, you still have to show what the stagecraft looks like and what the events look like. And so it's your job to try to look behind the curtain a little bit or just to try to show how it's put together or just kind of give something that's a little different than that perfect straight-on angle that just gets flat after a while. In terms of, you've mentioned clicking with a campaign and how that can really affect access as you've just mentioned, you've covered Secretary Clinton now during her away primary run and her 2016 election bid. And I know her team already are quite protective of their candidate, but in particular the Clinton's relationship with the New York Times has always been somewhat strained and really goes back to the White Water Days in the 1990s.
In terms of access, how did you find dealing with them in OA compared to 2016 because she had a lot of the same staffers and aides working for her? Yeah, I would say it was maybe about the same, maybe a little better in 2016, but I didn't notice a huge difference. And I should also say my experience and my level of access is much different from a writer in what they need to get to do their job. So my access can depend on being able to move around events, being able to get into events, how willing the campaign is to get you in different places that go beyond just the center stand.
So that's the real mark of a campaign that's willing to work with still photographers specifically. And how does it work in terms of do you often accompany a reporter yet? You just sometimes are able to go that bit further or do you act as a lone ranger? Most often we will work separately because they might be reporting an event off-site or they might be in the travel pool that they would be reporting from a different area and I'm moving around a lot.
So we work pretty separate in those times unless there's a particular narrative they're looking for or perhaps a particular demographic or theme at the campaign events. We'll communicate about those things, but more often than not, I'm working more closely with other photographers than I'm competing with than I would be with the writers. Okay, getting away from campaigns and politics a little bit because I know obviously there's so much more that you do and cover, but what are the moments that have stayed with you the most do you think in terms of the events that you've covered from the Colorado wildfires of 2003 to the Iraq War to the Weinstein, I think it was when he was first indicted in 2018, or is it something even something that people would find less remarkable that somehow had an effect on you? For me it's the small things that really stay with me.
I'm always left with, and a big fan of the work of the writer Stutt Sturkel, who was a Chicago writer who did a lot of oral history, and he had this quote where he says he likes to look at history from the ground up and he says how everybody talks about the pyramids and how the pharaohs built the pyramids, and he said the pharaohs didn't lift a finger. It was slaves who built the pyramids, and he's more interested in the people who really did it on the ground level. So I'm always fascinated at looking at moments like that, and I think those are the ones that really resonate with me the most. I mean, they're happy stories, of course.
I mean, there's one particular piece I worked on a couple years ago in New Hampshire about the opioid epidemic, and I worked with the writer Kitziele, partly following a family that was dealing with addiction to the children, where the opioids heroin, and being there with the family when they were confronting the sun for how many, I don't know how many ODs he had had, and he had had an OD the night before, and then trying to get him to go into recovery again. And it was a very intense scene, but you're also there being somehow welcomed by this family to show what they're going through. And this is, looking at a larger issue that is affecting the United States and communities all over, and you're sitting in this living room watching it play out, thinking how many different ways is this playing out right now across this country? I was just looking through images from this year, and obviously there's so many I could probably go back to from previous years, but in working on the story about the New York City of our imagination, just capturing the sounds of the city in during the pandemic, and as we're sort of coming out of the dark days of April, I went to this street party in Clinton Hill, Brooklyn, and there's a DJ on that block, and all throughout the stay at home orders, at seven o'clock every night, he would come out and play house music, and people would go in the street and have this social distance dance party, and it could go anywhere from 10 minutes to 45 minutes.
And one of my colleagues had told me about it, and I went to this party, and it was, for me, it was like watching everybody come together and seeing everybody dance. It was that first moment coming out of the dark days of March and April, and realizing like, oh, you know, wow, we're gonna get through this, and that New York and Brooklyn still has it. I remember thinking while Brooklyn, you still got it, and that was a really special moment for me. That's beautiful.
Do you hear them, Brooklyn, or you? I do. Yeah. So this was in June, and some time had passed, but you know, I mean, that's what I get to do with this job.
I get to go experience things that many people don't get to, and it's part of my job is to be curious and to just go check things out. Finally, this has been so fascinating, Todd. Finally, how do you think the work that you've done over the last number of years has changed the way you see the world? How has it informed your view, especially in the last 12 months?
I mean, it seems that you have run the gamut as a photographer from elections to covering a pandemic, your coverage of New York during this time has been incredibly moving. How has it sort of changed you, the work that you've done and informed your views? Well, I think, I think over the years, and if anything, just for having years of experience, learning the technical parts of photography and photojournalism, that falls into the background and becomes muscle memory, and it frees you up to be more aware as a person and be more engaged with the person in front of you, and the people that are letting you into their lives. And I feel like that experience has freed me up to a degree to really connect with people more.
I think that was always the goal of mine when I look back, is that I wanted to connect with people and share their story so that people can understand somebody that's very different from them. I think about some of the stories over the past few years of covering the migration of Central Americans coming up from Honduras, Guatemala, El Salvador, and the family separations, and all the other things that have been happening in the US, and I think it's just learning to spend more time with people and learning to listen more. I think a good lesson, it sounds counterintuitive, but I think a good lesson to learn as a photographer is to learn when to put the camera down and listen and talk to people, and you'd be amazed at how many photographs come from doing that, because each photograph is a gift from the person you are documenting. Well, that seems like a good place to leave it as much as I hate to.
This has been absolutely fascinating, so Todd Heisler, thank you so much for joining us on Fourth Estate. Thank you. That was Todd Heisler, American photojournalist and staff photographer for the New York Times. And thanks for listening to Fourth Estate.
This edition was recorded at the studios of Tua-Si-R, and heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app, so you can hear us talk media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back with more next week, but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter.
I handle this Fourth Estate AU. Thanks to my producer Anthony Docrell. My name is Tina Quinn. Thanks for listening.