Insurance Due Diligence in Small Business Acquisitions

Sam Rosati and Kaustubh Deo are joined by Andy Harbut and Josh Richman to break down the often-overlooked role of insurance in small business acquisitions. Drawing from decades of experience in private equity and insurance brokerage, Andy and Josh share how they built NewCo Risk through a hybrid of acquisition and startup, and why they chose to focus on the underserved search and ETA community. The conversation dives into real-world examples of how insurance diligence can make or break a deal, along with lessons from their first year as entrepreneurs scaling a niche, service-heavy business. They discuss: - How insurance diligence can uncover hidden risks that materially impact deal viability - Why many small businesses are underinsured or mispriced and how that affects buyers - The strategy behind building an insurance brokerage through a carveout and acquisition model - Key operational and technology decisions that shaped NewCo Risk’s early growth - Why sales capability is critical for operators and searchers running small businesses Support our Sponsor: NewCo Risk gives SMB businesses access to the same bespoke approach, sophisticated strategies and big thinking as the leading global insurance consulting firms. Learn more @ https://www.newcorisk.com/ Have SMB questions for Kaustubh and Sam? Email them to [email protected] and they will answer them on the Pod!  Links: Kaustubh on Substack - https://bigdealsmallbusiness.substack.com/p/read-me-first Sam on X - https://x.com/Sam_Rosati Topics: (00:00:00) - Intro(00:02:34) - Introducing Josh and Andy(00:07:22) - Learnings from the self-funded community(00:12:15) - How Josh and Andy think about the NewCo Risk business model(00:15:22) - The decision to start NewCo Risk(00:24:45) - The state of NewCo in 2026(00:29:14) - How to run your business for less money(00:32:16) - Josh and Andy’s roles within the business(00:39:28) - War stories(00:51:23) - Getting in touch