Skip to content
Intense Chat With An Intensivist - Part 1 episode artwork

Jun 14, 2021 52 min

Intense Chat With An Intensivist - Part 1

from Simblified Hosted by IVM Podcasts

Boy, is this a special episode. We spoke to Dr. Nitin Arora, a Consultant Intensivist who practices in Birmingham, England. Dr. Nitin, interestingly enough, wrote to us on Twitter feeling that our earlier episode on oxygen was incomplete. So we did what anyone should do to their critics - invited him to a podcast episode recording! And what a time we had - it was insightful, emotional, funny (Chuck tried to make bad jokes on oxygen) and very, very fulfilling. This was such a great chat that we had so many questions, and ended up with a long chat that we're splitting up over two episodes. We hope you enjoy both of them. PS: Yes, Chuck wanted to call the episode "I see you, ICU" but was mercifully vetoed. Many thanks to Dr. Nitin for giving us so much of his time. He's on Twitter: https://twitter.com/aroradrn And here's a post he wrote which he references: https://thosewecarry.wordpress.com/2018/03/28/could-i-see-your-soul-by-nitin-arora/ Add one part news, one part bad jokes, one part Wikipedia research, one part cult references from spending too much time on the internet, one part Wodehouse quotes, and one part quality puns, and you get Simblified. A weekly podcast to help you appear smarter, to an audience that knows no less! Your four hosts - Chuck, Naren, Srikeit and Tony attempt to deconstruct topics with humour (conditions apply). Fans of the show have described it as "fun conversations with relatable folks", "irreverent humour", "the funniest thing to come out of Malad West" and "if I give you a good review will you please let me go". Started in 2016 as a creative outlet, Simblified now has over 200 episodes, including some live ones, and some with guests who are much smarter than the hosts. Welcome to the world of Simblified! You can contact the hosts on: Chuck: twitter.com/chuck_gopal / instagram.com/chuckofalltrades Naren: twitter.com/shenoyn / instagram.com/shenoynv Tony: twitter.com/notytony / instagram.com/notytony Srikeit: twitter.com/srikeit / instagram.com/srikeit

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Intense Chat With An Intensivist - Part 1

0:00 52:05
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I, V, M. Sivist as opposed to as Tony will. Yeah, we're famously insensitive is so we have a few letters of so. So welcome, yeah welcome, who has woken up at four AM half an hour before his schedule time just to impart some wisdom to simplify listeners.

Thank you so much, Dr. Gionius. Good morning. Hi, and hello to all of your listeners.

I've been a listener of the show for quite a while now. So actually, when the opportunity presented itself to come in, I volunteered to jump in and thank you for inviting me. And can we please just use first names? I'm comfortable with Dr.

Mithin. And yeah, so at work, we are famously first names on the unit. So from everyone from penis reporters to the hospital chief executive is addressed by their first name. And again, today, I thought I'd come in and have a little chat about oxygen.

What I didn't realize was I should have spent a little bit of time preparing some jokes. I think that part of the conversation will take care of here. We are not going to use the. You don't need to.

What you're saying to say is you don't need to habor too much on the process. Yeah. Maybe start the show and then we should have spent a little time researching facts. But jokes.

But it's starting tonight. I think I was 42. I thought like which unit there in the UK. So I trained in India.

I worked in India in medicine for five years after I finished. Then at that point of time, there was no training in intensive care in India, which is why in a lot of corporate hospitals in India, you'll find people that have trained in America, Australia, the UK. So I came over here and then the plan was to come back and then 17 years later, I still haven't. So I work in intensive care.

I've been an intensive care consultant for nearly 10 years now in Birmingham. I work at University of Mass in Mass. In addition, I have a bit of an interest in online education. So I was the digital media lead for the intensive care system, which is a national body for a period of time.

And then currently I'm chair for learning and we do a fair number of podcasts and webinars, which can be found on our YouTube channels and podcast channels as well as developing a new e-learning app for intensive care, which we hope to make available worldwide. So that's a little bit about me. Yeah, it's like us who call you with enough of that. No, sorry.

Yes. So many that's so many strands we can pick over there. I feel that oxygen is, I shouldn't be saying this, like, I feel like oxygen is just a stick in this conversation because there are so many different strands that could be done from, but I'm just going to ask one thing before we jump into the oxygen part of things has changed in India since you left, because it didn't have that education that you were looking for in intensive work. Yes, absolutely.

So I work very closely with the Indian Society for Critical Care. So they're kind enough to invite me to join various committees and invite me to the conferences and things have definitely changed. So it's very high quality intensive care training available in India now. And thankfully, after a bit of time, we're actually getting very good research studies coming out of India as well.

So things have definitely changed. If I was in India today, I wouldn't leave probably. The problem, of course, is that intensive care in India tends to be concentrated in the big cities and the smaller towns still have a problem accessing good quality intensive care. Any care really for that matter, as we've seen over the last time.

Are you being critical of care? Sorry. Not quite. Not quite.

If I can say another line, until about 18 months ago, most people that work in intensive care had never thought about oxygen. Oxygen was taken for granted. It arrives in the hospital in a big tanker. You open the knob, it comes out.

We never thought about it. And then suddenly in the last 18 months or so, we've had to think about it. Now, oddly enough, I have had an interest in ICU design and infrastructure for a period of time. So that just meant that when this pandemic arrived, the hospital, that someone tapped me on the shoulder and said, okay, you're going to make an oxygen plan and expansion plan.

So that is essentially what I've done for the last 15 months, COVID ICU and expansion plans infrastructure, planning publishing stuff like that. So, yeah, I think, listen, what is interesting for me is this, right? So my father was an ICU in February for 18 days. He passed away.

He was in for aspiration pneumonia. And he had a lot of other issues well. And so I got involved a little bit about ventilators and intents and everything. And they did an empirical job of keeping him conscious and in health, you know, while the basic infection was being taken care of.

But he was already 82 years old, and he was a lot of other issues, and he wasn't able to make it. What struck me? And so there was equipment in that place that even the chest physician didn't know how to operate. So it had to be the intensivist.

And so, you know, the level of knowledge. So the intensivist had to know a lot of medicine also, but a lot of technology as well. And what struck me was that technology is a really huge part of this entire operation. And so yours must be the fastest evolving discipline within that thing.

So that was my observation. Thank you. And I'm sorry for your loss, Nari. I should have said that earlier because I remember you mentioned this in the previous podcast as well.

And you're right, intensive care is one of the youngest specialties in medicine, but it's not as young as you might think. It dates back to the 1950s when there was a big poly epidemic in Europe and they developed the old fashioned heartland machines. But then for the next 20 years, I see language and it was only in the 80s that there was an explosion in intensive care. And to be fair, the explosion in intensive care largely came from heart surgery.

So in the late 70s and early 80s, we started in cardiac back houses and then it was realized that actually a huge big determinant in the outcome of these patients who have heart surgery or by surgery is the kind of attention to detail and intensive care that they get after. And then we started realizing that there are a lot of diseases that we can help with intensive care. And so over the last, when I've been doing intensive care for just over 20 years now, and I am stunned at how far we have come. And oddly enough, oddly enough, we are using fewer drugs and actually they're using less technology than we used to 20 years ago, 20 years ago, we thought the technology would revolutionize stuff and then ultimately we've come to the contradiction that actually the more we do to people, the more we mess them up.

So you're trying to as little as you can get away with. So don't try and get their oxygen to 100% to 90%. That's enough to keep your life and then you're not injuring the lungs while providing oxygen to not wish the pleasure too much because you will then stress out the heart and the circulatory system all of that stuff don't give antibiotics for three weeks. You will get antibiotic resistance, give antibiotics for short sharp doses five to seven days.

So stuff like that. So we actually in some ways, we're doing less than it was thought at one point that we should try and do and actually that works better. I think our education system could also do it a little bit of that don't try to do too much. Just focus on a few things and do them.

But it seems to me that an intensive is somebody who's I see will need to be a cross disciplinarian, a cross various medical fields. I want to say. Yes. Yes.

So I actually did my qualification in medicine. So I did my internal medicine. I did my MRCP exam. So I finished my rotation in medicine.

I did in all, I did nearly four years of medicine. Then I did another four years of anesthesia and then I did four years of intensive care training. So I was a slowpoke. So it took me nearly 12, 13 years of training to become concerned.

And the minimum amount you need in the UK. So the UK standard is you need to have done at least one year, but most people do two years of medicine and you need to have done at least one, but some people do two years of anesthesia. You also need to have done at least six months of pediatrics, ideally one year and you need to have a pediatric and you need to have a new device. So I like to call intensive is one of the only two classes of general doctors in the hospital.

So everyone looks after their passage. The surgeons cut the internal physicians to their own thing. The gynecologist to only women pediatricians to only under 18 on a typical day. I will see anyone from six months old to 90 years old pregnant women old people, anything between emergency departments and intensive care.

We are probably the only people in hospital that will see anyone. I have to say one thing about Dainikal. I saw there's to be this writer named Richard Gordon back in the States who is two times pregnant. He's two books.

Yeah, he used to be. And so he's the protagonist of many of his books. I was on a surgeon named Lancelot Sir Lancelot Spratt. So in one of the books, there is a situation where Sir Lancelot Spratt has to perform an emergency delivery.

Okay, someone is delivering and he's the only doctor around. So when I asked him, are you sure you can do it? It's like it's forever. It's 40 years since you've got this.

I don't remember my mind. But I know that there's nothing much in gynecology. You just have to stand in the slips and take the catch. Lancelot is also good.

I remember two things about Sir Lancelot Spratt. One is that catching the slips. And the other thing I remember being impressed at is Sir Lancelot had a Rolls Royce. And I used to think, oh, okay, so consultants in the UK have Rolls Royce's.

Unfortunately, no. Yeah, but if he was Sir Glantzlot, you would need a leg slip. But I had a, you know, and his status doctor in my neighborhood. And I kind of remember what he always used to say.

I mean, I grew up Catholic. So his line was that God is the first and his status because when he created Eve, he actually put Adam to sleep before taking off the day. Yeah, but I can ask you a very basic question. What exactly is the need for an intensive care unit and how does it work?

Yeah, I was about to ask something very similar. So you can kind of take both together. I guess it's like what qualifies a person for needing the ICU versus, I don't know what it is actually. There are three important things about ICU.

And you will notice that I'm not going to say equipment. Okay, so there are three important things about intensive care. So intensive care, we look after the sickest patients in the hospital. So if you have a disease and an organ dysfunction, so if your oxygen saturations are falling or your blood pressure is dropping or your kidneys are stopping working, then you will need care that is more than can be delivered and not on an ordinary ward.

Back in the day, 30, 40 years ago, we were trying to a lot of things on the watch. We would try and put in central lines. We could do dialysis on the wounds. And then slowly it was realized that what you need is you need to cohort these patients together and have a bunch of doctors and nurses looking after them who only look after sick patients.

So you have a bunch of people that only look after cardiac patients, which is cardiology department. You don't the era of the old fashioned general surgeon and general medicine person is over. You still need someone to the broad overview, but you get much better results if you can have people that specialize in this stuff and intensivists what we specialize in is sick people. What we specialize in is people that have multi organ failure or at least respiratory failure.

And if you can cohort these people together, then what you get is you get experienced stuff who know exactly how to look after these patients. You get improved nursing ratio. So in the UK on a ward, you will have one nurse for eight patients. You will have one doctor for 30 patients on the ward, typically at night in an intensive care.

You will always have one to one nursing. In fact, on our 24 bed, I see we always have 25 nurses because there's a nurse in charge who's there to who's the senior most who's there to help us supervise and stuff. We have a minimum of 25 nurses on every shift. We have a minimum of three doctors on every shift.

So what you are then doing is on an ordinary ward in a 12 hours shift with 30 odd patients. One doctor is going to spend 20 minutes a patient at best. Once you take out phone calls lunch breaks during the paper and half of that time will be spent entering data on the computer. In intensive care, I have the unbelievable luxury that my doctors can spend an hour with the patient minus this can spend a 12 hours shift to the patient.

So then what you get to do is you get attention to detail and what we have found is for 20 years intensive cancer is for magic bullets. And I can tell you this is my own patient, I think that I can tell you that COVID has brought up the worst instinct of intensive care again. What we've been doing is the media are partly to blame for this. We've been searching for magic bullets.

But magic bullets do not exist. We haven't found a magic bullet, but every week there is something you hydroxychloroquine, I will make them whatever. And what we found was that the best predictor in the UK at least of ICU survival apart from how sick the patient was in the gay men was how much a unit had to stretch. So we had to go up three times.

So our ICU nurses were now spending one third of the time with the patients. We was spending one third of the time that we normally do with the patients. And what happens is it's not just one third of the time you get cognitive or whether you're not used to dealing with so many second citations. And suddenly, actually, you're not working at one third agency, you're probably working at less than one third agency.

And units that were not stretched had outcomes that were very similar to their baseline and units that were stretched. The more you stretch the units, the worse the outcome got, which is why during our second wave, we set up a national system of transfer. So we admitted 700 patients to ICU in the second wave. Of them, nearly 300 were transferred to other hospitals because we had live dashboard.

We had an operations manager meeting every morning across multiple hospitals and whichever hospital was least stretched, they would. And we had dedicated transfer teams and we ended up sending patients as far as new customers, which is 250 miles away. And we sent nearly 20 patients there. So we were able to do this because we have a fairly centralized health system, which is free at one delivery.

Now, I remember talking to a colleague in New York, who even though me, Governor Cuomo had said that, yes, we will have a robust system of transfers. It didn't eventually work because it's a fee for service model. No hospital chief executive wants to let go of the patients. So they just kept stretched and stretched and stretched.

And then the worst outcomes were in some hospitals that took Medicaid patients because they are lower paid than in short patients. And so some hospitals had an un-nursed patient ratio that was three times worse than other hospitals because they couldn't transfer out. We were lucky enough that we had the facility to transfer out. So one of the most important things is staff time, attention to detail and it's little things, little things, attention to detail like regular suctioning.

You don't suction the patient through the inter-triguity for three, four hours. You double the chance of getting a new money. And then you turn the patient regularly. It's before COVID, we had not had a bed sore on the unit for nearly six years because we police that very, very carefully.

It's little things like that, not giving them too much oxygen, not giving them too little oxygen, keeping their blood pressure in a very narrow band, just enough. Because if you're giving, say, not adrenaline or adrenaline to a patient, as you can imagine, it's going to cause tachynoid, it's going to cause palpitations. It's going to, in an old patient, in someone that has preexisting heart disease, you can actually precipitate a heart attack. However, if your blood pressure is too low, you're not getting blood flowing to the brain and the kidneys and the heart.

So you're, again, going to cause trouble. So you have to get it just right. And the only way to get it just right is constant tinkering. Unfortunately, we end up tinkering a lot.

I have two unnecessary observations and one question. The first unnecessary observation is just like how they say any discussion on the internet will eventually move towards talking about people. I think any discussion with about medicine will eventually move towards, they become a point where you criticize the US medical systems. I think that moment in this, I think that moment for this is part of every time my wife and I watched John Oliver episode, he said, thank goodness, we're not in the US for some reason or the other.

The second unnecessary observation was, I think since we're talking about the IC, we should stop talking about anything that's bullet silver bullet or something bullet or something. It seems to be inappropriate. But the question that I had for you, Dr. The action question that I had was how difficult is it to scale up or once his way was scaled down, intensive care operations?

Sorry, I don't know if your question was kind of related to that, but please go ahead. Should we get from the ring school? Yeah, absolutely the same thing. So I have a personal angle to this.

What one within said all of that happened to my father? So when he was, when he was taken to the hospital, we went in town, me and my wife, my son was and he acted very quickly. He picked him up to rush to the hospital. We have our own hospital.

That didn't have an ICU. We went to an hospital which did and they activated everything. And they saved him. And but it was a raging infection in the lungs.

So they had to treat him with antibiotics and antibiotics take a little time to work. And you have to keep the patient alive and healthy at that time. And that's when I, by that time, we had gone out of town, we came back. That's when I realized my father's a doctor was a doctor himself.

And so a lot of people treating him, they were his junior. So I knew all of them. And so they would, you know, they would tell me things that they probably won't tell other people and they would say things like this, you know, his blood pressure is dropping. So now it's getting involved.

So we need to increase the blood pressure. That's why it puts central and things like that. So what all of that, it was intensive is towards the final decision maker and they kept having the little conferences and they have discussion and then it would happen. And the point what Nathan was saying was the level of, you know, attention to detail is what kept him alive.

I mean, he passed, he didn't make it because he was really old and confirmed, but he did keep him alive for 18 days. And he was conscious for nearly every one of those days. So he was like that, okay. So if you really have to increase this, India is woefully short of all kinds of medical facilities for a multitude of reasons.

First of all, we have very large population, which used to like very calmly accept death and die. Most of rural India, if you fell ill, you just went crawled into your bed and died. And now, you know, India is the more prosperous. And even the poorest of poor people know that there is, you know, there are facilities which will keep you alive.

And that's why there is pressure on medical facilities because people want to die and go out. So all of a sudden, because of the prosperity, I think, one of the reasons we need more facilities. So how easy is, I'm sure there are fine minds who are thinking about this right now. So you really want to have one of the standard reference of this entire COVID epidemic because we didn't have ICU facilities.

So how quickly can we expect that was very similar to the box? I like how we're getting the doctor to try it live and simplify by throwing my different things at it. This is a really difficult one. Can I split this into two?

So I'm going to try and split this into two as one scale up on the individual hospital basis. So suddenly you have 22 extra ICU patients. How do you scale up? Are you expecting to double your number in the next week?

How do you scale up? That is going to come from my personal experience. The second thing is how do you scale up on a national level? That one, again, I can claim a little bit of expertise because I was on the National Workforce Planning Committee for Intensive Care for a few years, and I have actually just submitted a paper on a UK workforce very recently, which hasn't been published yet.

But I must say that some of this may not necessarily apply to India, but the broader principles will be very similar. So on an individual unit basis, scaling up is really difficult. This is how we did it. And then I'll talk about the problems we had as well.

So one was equipment. That was the easiest. The main problem was monitoring equipment. All we did was we have 30 odd operating theatres.

We closed everything except five of them. Only emergencies and trauma and pediatric trauma and obstetric and cancer work would be done. And then what we did was we had smaller hospitals on the side in the private sector, which did not have ICUs. So the government blocked the private hospital because they were not going to be able to do any surgery anyway because we had commandeered all their needs tests.

So we blocked those hospitals. We did aggressive COVID testing on the staff and patients in those hospitals. So cancer work urgent surgeries continued in those hospitals, they were on patients who didn't need ICUs. If unfortunately you were someone that needed relatively urgent surgery and you needed an ICU bed, it was difficult if you needed emergency surgery and be carried on because we always had a small number of ICUs.

In fact, we got to one stage where of the five hospitals in Birmingham, one was designated as the non-COVID ICUs, all non-COVID patients went there. If they needed to have emergency surgery in COVID, hospital they had the surgery and then were transferred out. So as soon as we heard about the epidemic in Italy, we set up a very aggressive, very short, two week staff training program. One of the things I'll say very immodestly is we rather illegally.

So I wrote a book, a textbook of intensive care for the beginners. It's called a Bigginess Guide to Intensive Care. It's like a done-it's guide. It's meant for someone in the first three months of intensive care.

So what we very illegally did was we made, so I obviously had the PDF and we just printed out 200 copies of the book and we just handed it to everyone that wanted to come to the community. And then we got to the college level. Exactly. It's amazing that these tactics, right from like first year engineering all the way to ICU.

Technically I hold the copyright. There you go. No, but you were the author. Yeah.

And actually I contacted the publishers and they made the book free on their app for a period of six months. So actually, but that took a few weeks. So they had to go through some legal procedure. So that took about three weeks.

So we couldn't really wait. So I told them that I was going to just print off stuff and they said, yeah, look, this is an emergency to whatever you want to. So we fought about two weeks. We had six, eight, ten hour training sessions every day, which is not to say that in two weeks, these guys became ICU nurses or ICU doctors.

But what they did was they got to a stage where they had orientation and induction so they were not dangerous in ICU. And they could do things like they could have to turn the patient. Oh, if nothing else, just make tea for the staff on the coffee break. And they go on a break.

They're still waiting already instead of wasting time and it's making and running around getting stuff. So we managed the staff and the equipment. So it was the ventilators. And for some reason, all governments in the world got hung up on ventilators because in the mind, I think of the average politician, ICU is a ventilator, which is ventilator is one of it's a vital machine, but it's not the crux of intensive care.

And on a typical day in my ICU, less than half of the patients are going to ventilator. So we managed to cob it together some ventilators. We had ventilators that we had in decommission that we had for training and we need ventilators. So we were able to double that ventilator.

It wasn't that big or not. There was a program for emergency ventilator manufacture, none of which worked because it's not something you can cobble together in a garage. They're sophisticated machines. And what we got was the cobbled together stuff we got was very basic machines.

They would have been looking in the 1980s, but it is ventilators a bit different. And then we came to the two things that no one had ever thought about. So previously when we talked about, so what we do is we have a major incident planning meeting. We have major incident drills.

There is a bombing of 50 new patients suddenly coming. What are you going to do? The problem with this is this was like a major incident, but a major incident only last for two days, three days, and then it starts scaling down. So what you can do is you can get everyone in and then slowly you can let them go.

But as we knew this was going to last for a long time, so we were very careful with not trying to burn out our stuff and we knew some of our stuff would get sick as well. So we had to phase it in slowly and we had to make sure that it was sustainable. Then we got to the problem of oxygen. This is where it got interesting.

So in the UK, as standard, all hospitals were the nice. You need to have a centralized liquid oxygen tank. The liquid oxygen in a tank is stolen at about it's basically the liquid oxygen tank is a metal world giant thermos flask. We call it a vacuum insulated evaporator.

So you have a steel outer steel inner and then in the middle, that's pretty much vacuum is evacuated to roughly one kilopascal, which is 100th of pressure, which is apparently deemed to be a sustainable vacuum. They've tried doing more getting it down to 0.1 Pascal and it doesn't seem to work. You get more leaks. Most of the oxygen is liquid, but obviously it's kept at 160 partial and obviously with the satch, there's a bit of vapor on top and there is a pressure release value.

It's normally kept at about 70, so 700 kilopascals. The release value is typically set at 10 and then there is a system of release tubes. So you take the vapor out and the typical tank is a 3000 to 5000 litre tank. We now have a 12,000 litre tank and each litre of liquid oxygen gives you at SDP roughly 900 to 1000 liters of KCS oxygen.

So actually it's quite a lot of oxygen and you have a pressure differential. So at the top and the bottom, so odd and it rests on a scale. So you always know how much is left and actually we got live updates on an app because it was all automated because over here, what happens is we have a contract with the British oxygen company and they will monitor how much oxygen is left in your tank. So they know the historic usage and they will come and we feel it two days before it finishes.

So they come and come every five, six days at one point last year they were coming every day. Once it comes out, it then has to go through a heating grid, pressure regulator valve and go through. As you can imagine, if you're using a lot of oxygen, the temperature of the rest of the liquid oxygen will drop because it's evaporating quickly. And suddenly you find that you are out from your oxygen is dropping.

And so what we had to do was we had to and this was winter over here. So what we had to do was we bring down a warm water 35 degree water sprinkler system. Wow. So when we started dropping the sprinkler system stuck but in the same thing, they had the opposite problem in India.

It was 45 degrees in Roto and I have a friend in Roto and they had the opposite problem. They had over pressure. And so after talking to me when I said look, you read about this system, they read about the cold water sprinkler system. I'm just saying it's a brilliant solution.

It's just absolutely a brilliant solution. I want to say that Jay about over here but since we're talking about ICU, I'm just quoting. I think it's just I know. Last year we worked on Jugat.

Honestly, in this country, everything is totally regulated. Everything has to go through 23 committees. Last year we worked on Jugat. So coming again to Jugat.

I mean, you're printing, you're creating licensing words and examples of Jugat in some sense. Then what we did was with oxygen, we tested all our ventilators, we found some of our ventilators used more oxygen, some use less oxygen. So we had to find out where to put them. Then we found that suddenly because we never even thought about this.

Most people had it. That our oxygen, our ICU only had an oxygen ring which was capable of delivering 600 meters a minute. And we then thought about, okay, is there any way to extend this? But our ICU is about 400 meters from the oxygen tank.

And as you know, there are fixed pipes and the flow because the pressure is fixed. It's coming at four bar. So the only thing that really determines flow if you go back to your fluid dynamics and the laminate flow, the poiser's equation, which says flow is dependent on the fourth bar of the radius. And that you can't basically crack open the whole hospital and change all the oxygen pipes in the middle of the pandemic.

So what we had to do was we had to reverse the rule of the last reverse things that we had learned in the last 50 years. I said we put hot-assic patients together and stuff like that. But what we had to do was since we had to, so ICU was full, we had to expand into the wards. Each ward would only have 400 liters of oxygen.

That was barely enough for five high flow patients. So at one point, I had 28 high flow patients spread across six different wards. So basically we put four sick patients in one ward, four sick patients in the next ward, four sick patients in the upstairs ward. And so on a typical day, so we had one consultant who was inside the ICU.

So we had a group of people who were inside the ICU and we had one consultant and one registered to what, registered to what outside the ICU. And on the day that we were outside the ICU, we were typically averaging, so in a 12-hour shift, somewhere between 20 and 25,000 steps. Because we were just walking up and down the doors. So you were supposed to see?

So you were supposed to see? I see you two the wards, basically. Yes, we moved the ICU to the ward and we spread it out. We decentralized ICU.

Because of the diameter of the pipe. Because of the diameter of the pipes. Exactly. And then we discovered new stuff.

So if you've ever been in hospital, you know, there's an oxygen thing on the wall and you open the valve and it goes up. Okay. What we discovered is, and this again, we'll be doing a project on this. And I'll tell you about this one.

You may find this interesting. So you open it, it goes up to 15 and we found they are very accurate. So we had oxygen calibration kits. We found up to 15 is very accurate.

The problem is people don't stop at 15. If you say 10, people will go to 10 and stop. If you say 15, 15 is all the way to the top. They keep turning it until it goes and sits at the top.

The rotating wall goes and sits at the top, which is about half an inch above the 15 level. We found that depending on where you were and what brand you used, that if you have it stuck right at the top, it gives you between 40 and 60 liters. So we started. So what we did was we made a Google phone spreadsheet every morning.

The scene and us on every single ward would go around and see how much oxygen was being used and entered it on their smartphone, onto the Google phones app. It would come to me by the evening, by in an hour or so. And then we would decide, okay, which ward has oxygen subs, and how do we move patients around? So it was crazy.

Not something we are trained for, not something we'd ever thought about, but as you said, it's a drug. This is so brilliant. I mean, you have to figure these things out on the fly. There are people whose life is hang by threat.

So it's not like you can take a decision tomorrow. You have to be. And oftentimes you are the only one who has to take the decisions. And just another example of how a spreadsheet can solve any problem.

Absolutely. Absolutely. Not a spreadsheet. That's the key.

So what we found was we had a spreadsheet, a shared spreadsheet, and everyone is scared of spreadsheets. So what we had to do was we had to make a Google phones document. So they would just pick the Google phones. So you would get the responses.

The responses came in the spreadsheet. I saw the spreadsheet, but the end user did not see the spreadsheet. They saw the Google. This is why they say the healthcare workers are always a class apart.

The form might be temporary, but the class is fine. Can I go back to Nareen's fly? You said something about fly, Nareen. What was it again?

No, on the fly. So you have the fly. Can I use that as a segue? Have you heard of something called the fly sticker splash solution?

Fly in the eye. No, no. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. No. No. No.

No. rare dots at the 15 mark. And secondly, we started prescribing 14 and a half meters, the different billion and half and 15. So this is because of this using behavior behavioral psychology to save oxygen.

I was about to say that because it sounds like something like a Danny Kahneman would prescribe this. This is inspired from him. Yes, this is exactly inspired from that. It was Richard Taylor that advised you for their vote on this problem.

So this is directly stolen from the ideas. Actually, I'd like to refer back to a point that Chuck made and you were talking about. I mean, from your perspective, the reason I think Chuck was also a little apprehensive to use the Jugard word per se and you were also quite enthusiastic because in your context, working in the UK, Jugard is actually a very positive thing because it helps you break out of all of these regulations and work in that positive way. The problem by Jugard is become a little bit of a bad word in India is because in the absence of any kind of system, there is a become a substitute for building any kind of positive systems of working.

Different systems, different whether it's medicine, whether it's everyone seems to think that, okay, when the time comes, we'll figure out some Jugard and do something about it. Jugard was beautifully, if you have an existing system and you use innovative ways to break out of it as you have done, where you had existing systems and go out of it versus just saying that we figure out what it does. Jugard is not fit for laziness, right? And laziness or bad planning or bad infrastructure.

And I think in large part, I agree with you. Just because when I first saw you, because I'd obviously not seen you before this call, I saw you and the first thought was he looks like a young freak-up. Okay, so then what I'm going to say is this is like the difference between the Indian team of the 80s and the Indian team of the of the last 10 years. So in the 80s, we used to win matches by essentially individual brilliance.

In today's Indian team, individual brilliance, okay, you still have a few really brilliant people, but this is not a team of superstars, this is a team of theirs and they play on a system. So it is, it is what you will get is in a team that relies on superstars or Jugard, one person will do it, but there isn't a system to decide who's going to do what. It will occasionally produce really good results and the individual people who are going to be really good. Some Indian doctors I know are amongst the smartest people I know.

The problem is that we also have some who are not. So I would say the average level of your doctor, the average doctor is safer in this system, but you will not find as many brilliant doctors as you do in India, which was the same as you know, Australia, or England would never have produced with Richard's career. Absolutely, that's the difference between, I mean, it's a system will help you win a league versus individual brilliance will help you win like a final or a playoff. That's why I said like over a period of time, the system wins out because the average performer is always consistently performing and the system wins out there.

So, the big reason I would say in Indian ICUs is that with a very small proportion that I will not have brilliant, the biggest problem I find with most Indian ICUs and with the Indian healthcare system is that we do not respect our nursing staff. We do not respect our nursing staff, we do not pay our nursing staff enough. And so, while especially now that the economic situation is so different from what it was 20 years ago, we find a lot of Indian doctors become over here. I currently have four clinical fellows from India, four senior fellows who have all done their intensive care in India.

They've come here for two or three years of experience and then they go back. And the universal thing I hear from them every day is your nurses, your doctors aren't that much better than your doctors. It's very similar. And actually these guys that come over there are all really, really good.

They are at part with any of my fine-year trainees, fine-year, as in, you know, people that have 10 years of ICU, they're at part with that, no doubt about that. But the nursing staff, because they are not respected over here. If a nurse tells a senior consultant, I don't think you should do this. You will not do it.

Or he was spent 10 minutes explaining why you're going to do it. So, there's a lot more collaborative culture. Whereas in India, it becomes very difficult. We are intrinsically very hierarchical.

And one of the things that I find helps is we are a first-name unit. If you are going to start objecting to something by saying, sir, I don't think we should do this. That won't happen because sir will probably not listen. And we don't pay them enough.

So, I don't think today coming over here, we're double-doctor of the salary, but their expenses will do well. So, it doesn't matter. And as in India, over here, nurses, our senior nurses get paid about 50 to 60 percent of what I get paid in India. They would get paid 10 percent of what I would get paid.

So, nurses, all the goodness, and this is what I hear all the time, the goodness is, tend to leave a lot of the good motivated nurses, unless they have a real reason to stay in India, they tend to leave. Our ICU is full of Indian nurses, and they are all really, really good. And they are all happy here because they say that they get more respect. Absolutely.

But do you bank plates for them? Sorry. Sorry, yes. Last year, for 10 weeks, every Thursday evening at 8 o'clock, people would come out and they would clap for the NHS.

So, they did that for 10 weeks last year. No, please. So, Dr. from what you're saying, essentially, the key part of the intensive care unit is the availability of human resources itself and how...

Absolutely. ...trained human resources is number one. Then is the infrastructure. Can I come back to infrastructure?

Yes. So, I actually had an observation there, which was that I don't know if it's true or not, because in Indian hospitals, at least the ICU was always air conditioned, whereas the rest of the wards or rooms need not necessarily be. Is that just because you can charge more, or is there a real reason for that? And on that, just as an infrastructure point on the ICU, I think recently, there was this fire in an ICU in Iran.

I'm coming to that. Yeah, exactly. And one of the reasons was that oxygen was passing through the roof, the ceiling of the drop ceiling of the ICU. And that's something I wanted to ask you about about the design of the ICU overall and how important that is.

Yeah. Yeah. So, okay. So, what we have is we have an every country has this.

India has the standards as well, but there's likely very, very enforcement. Just like we have five standards, there is something in the UK called hospital building, non-regulations, 5.2, construction, standards for any intensive care unit. And we have just revised that, taking lessons from the pandemic. And one of the things is going to air conditioning point in a typical office 20 years ago, there was a computer room that was the only room that was air conditioning equipment and you can charge more.

But basically, I think that is the thing of the past now, whole hospital is our air condition. But the thing is that in intensive care, you have patients, the real reason is you have patients that have very unstable chemodynamics, their hands will be warm and flushed, they will start sweating, you will start losing fluid and the blood flow will be directed to the perifreeze rather than the central essential organs. So, actually, it's better to keep it slightly cooler, but keep them at a reasonable temperature. So, you want to have very controlled conditions for temperature, rather than swings.

Having said that, most union ICUs are cooled way more than the cooler ICU. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We could weigh further down than you really need to. But yes, so you need to have a controlled temperature condition, but it doesn't need to be at 15 degrees.

We keep our ICUs at 21 standard. So, there was a pressure made to dropping. You put them in an uncontrolled temperature, you will get a vasoconstriction sweating, sorry vasodilatation. So, that's one.

The second thing is, electrics. No one thinks about it, no one talks about it. In a typical ICU event, we are expected by standards to have 28 electric sockets, of which four have to be capable of sustaining up to 20 amperes and in the in-vehicle that could be 40 amperes. So, low voltage, low voltage.

And half of them, and they have to be clearly marked, have to be connected to a UPS supply. And so, there are standards around this. When we expanded our ICUs to the wards, a typical wardbed has two sockets. So, we thought about how do we get around this.

And rather than buying, and we talked to our medical engineers, and they advised us very strongly that rather than buying the five pound extension lead with six-month, six bucks, we go for the expensive medical rated equipment, which was 500 pounds each. So, we converted each of them into 10 things, but it was guaranteed spark-free surge protection, all that stuff. Even with that, two hospitals in the UK, the, so what you did was you protected the plug, you protected to the local area. The local area is important because once you give about six people oxygen in a bay in a ward, you get ICU standards for ventilation.

So, there has to be air flow, air exchange, so that you do not get a buildup of oxygen in the environment. Because once you get about 24%, that becomes essentially a flammable mix. Yeah. One spark will ignite it.

That's different. So, 21 to 24 becomes a hazard. Yeah. 24 is the limit imposed by the UK Fire Service.

Even though I read some papers, I'd say you have to get up to about 26, but it doesn't matter. It is not that big, a change. On the ward, we do not have the same ventilation standards because we do not get that much oxygen on the ward. So, if you expand your ICU out, it's a problem.

So, even in winter, we had to keep the windows open by four inches or six inches, which made it cold, and set off a whole new set of problems. But you did all of this. And then, what we didn't think about was, okay, in a ward, we put so much equipment, the wire overloaded. So, we had someone spent burning plastic.

We did not thankfully have a fire. And it was 20 meters away from the ward, because the whole ward circuit had overload. And for some reason, it did not drip. And what I find is, when I see a lot of ICU's in hospitals in India, when I see new footage, unfortunately, I find that they're using a lot of multiplex, which was spark.

And that is always made to be a fire risk. Again, when I was in India, our ICU had a home-related air conditioning unit rather than an industrial-related air conditioning unit. And home-related air conditioning units aren't supposed to run for weeks on end without stopping for even one minute. Yeah.

So, it's infrastructure problem, but a lot of it is the standards exist. It is adherence to standards, because the problem is the stuff that matches up to your industrial healthcare standards, it's costing four or five times more. Some of it is testing, some of it is, the volume is low, so they cannot be a volume there. And the other big problem is they know they have a captive market.

There are only going to be two or three suppliers of medical equipment, whereas not all electrical equipment, you can go anywhere and buy whatever you want. And we're going to take a break right about here for the first episode. Yes, there are two episodes, because when we started talking to Doklin in the world, so many questions that came up that we decided on the fly to do two episodes. So, this is a very awkward ending to the first episode.

So, guys, say something so that this is less awkward. Oh, I'd say let's do it. Tell us to stay safe. Yeah, stay safe for the first episode.

Yeah. Stay tuned. Stay tuned. Yeah.

Stay safe. Stay tuned and stay simplified. Stay tuned. Okay, never okay.

All right.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Simblified?

This episode is 52 minutes long.

When was this Simblified episode published?

This episode was published on June 14, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Simblified episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.