Skip to content
Interview with Tinisha Agramonte, Diversity and Inclusion Expert episode artwork

Aug 28, 2020 28 min

Interview with Tinisha Agramonte, Diversity and Inclusion Expert

from FLIP THIS RISK® Podcast Hosted by Dr. Karen Hardy

Tinisha Agramonte, fmr Director of Civil Rights and Diversity & Inclusion (D&I) at the Small Business Administration and U.S. Department of Commerce brings 25 years to the podcast conversation. We discuss the issues and opportunities in D&I, what companies can do to make progress, the challenges that remain and the tools for making D&I effective in an organization.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Interview with Tinisha Agramonte, Diversity and Inclusion Expert

0:00 28:30
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, everyone. Hi, this is Dr. Karen Hardy, and welcome to Flip This Risk Podcast, where we interview high achievers and learn their stories about their relationship with risk taking and how that influences their leadership abilities. And today I have with me Tanisha Agremonti.

She's a D&I expert and thought leader over 25 years of experience in this space. She's a D&I extraordinaire, in my opinion, a D&I extraordinaire, and she's done some great work within this field, formerly head of the D&I Civil Rights of the U.S. Department of Commerce. Welcome, Tanisha, to the podcast.

Thank you so much. I'm so excited to be here with you, Dr. Hardy. I'm excited to see you and to speak to you as well.

I had to get you here. I had to get you here because this podcast is all about relevance and talking about topics that mean something at this particular moment right now, because a lot of people are looking for answers to some very tough questions. And some of those answers, the only way to get it is to ask the people that do the work, who are thought leaders in this space. And that's why I wanted to have you here.

But before we jump into that, where did you grow up? Now, I met you in D.C., but are you a native of Los Angeles? Los Angeles. Yes.

Did you spend most of your years here? I did. I spent from the age of eight until 17 in Los Angeles, then about eight years in the Bay Area before I married my husband, who was active in the Air Force. And then we lived in Japan, England, Colorado, California, and ultimately landed in the DMV area.

So that explains your route. And let's add to that, I was born outside of Dallas, and I lived in New York from the age of five to eight. So I've lived all over the place. You had, and you've seen a lot.

I've seen a lot. That exposed you to a lot of different people, you know, Midwest and the West Coast and the East Coast and, you know, the Southwest. At what point in time did you realize that diversity and inclusion was important? Did you pull any of that from, you know, all your travels and where you've lived and moving in different places?

No, you know where it actually came from? It came from the fact that I was identified as an at-risk youth when I was eight years old. When I was eight years old was the first time I got suspended from school. I continued getting suspended from school every year until I was expelled from schools when I was 15 or 16 years old.

At that time, and I think you're the first person I'm probably sharing this with. At that point, I was sent to a facility. And at this facility, there was a counselor at this facility, and they did some straight talk with me. And they was like, why are you here?

What are you doing? We can tell that you don't belong here. You're just being hard-headed, essentially. And so it was because of them that they really instilled a sense of public service in me.

I thought, I want to be like those ladies. I want to be like people who help other people. And so really around 16, 17, we moved to the Bay Area, and I completely shifted my focus. And at that point, I decided I wanted to go to school, and I wanted to give back.

And that's when I started working in capacities of social justice, racial equity, really socioeconomic equity is where I started first. But just they instilled in me that public service mentality, and I really wanted to give it back and pay it forward for people who really helped me and put me back on the right track. That is an awesome story. I did not know that story.

By the way, so thanks for sharing that. So just having that experience, that core experience for yourself and getting an understanding of, you know, investing your energy in these, a lot of issues, right? What were you finding as you went through your career and working with different organizations? How did the DNI start to show up for you?

So I think at first I started off my career in PEO, so Equal Employment Opportunity. And a lot of that is about compliance work, right? And then when I was in grad school, I got exposed to this whole concept and notion of diversity management. And I was like, oh, this is really interesting.

I like diversity because it goes beyond compliance, right? I was talking about the business case for doing diversity. And so I thought that might make it more palatable to work that we do in PEO because a lot of people dislike the compliance piece of it, right? And it also was broader beyond race and gender and all those things.

So then I would say probably about the early 2000s, you started seeing this show up in organizations where they're branching out and looking at diversity. And then that evolved to diversity and inclusion. Now we have terms like equity and belonging, right? So it continues to evolve.

But I think at least at this point, a lot of companies have at least accepted that there is a business case. You know, they've accepted the research that shows when you have a diverse workforce and you have people from all different lived experiences, different educational backgrounds, geographic regions, generations, all of that, that that brings a richness of thought and diversity to the workplace that yields tangible business outcomes. I think most companies have accepted that now. So at least that's when it's driving.

Right. But how do you measure that? So I know that the D&I, as you said, has evolved, right? It's been diversity, different words, equity, belonging, all of that.

So, you know, the terminology has changed, but what about the practices? Why haven't the practices changed within some of the organizations? Some of them are still struggling to make the connection between D&I and impact. Well, because I think our organizations are still built off of systems that were maybe not designed to be inclusive, right?

So all of our workplaces are really just a microcosm of the societies that we live in. And so, for example, I'm going to take it outside of a race and gender perspective real quick and focus on first-generation professionals because, you know, that's something that's near and dear to my heart. I don't think workplaces, in terms of your standard organizational culture, we have learned, are built on middle-class values. That means the systems in those workplaces are not really designed for people who come from lower socioeconomic backgrounds to necessarily thrive in them, right?

So when you do that, then I'll use one quick example. That is, we have found like people who are raised in blue-collar working class backgrounds, not all, right? But many were raised to value plain speak. Say what you mean?

You mean what you say? Spit it out. Don't use all these fancy adjectives when you're talking. Why?

Because people may feel like you're talking down to them. They may also feel like you're disingenuous, like you're not telling the truth and you're just not straight. But we know in a middle-class organizational culture, straight talk may not be valued. How that comes across is you're too brash, too direct, unpolished, right?

You're not tactful, not diplomatic. And so we see that clash, not because one is inferior or superior, but it's just based on some norms that may not be someone else's norms, right? So I think when companies still struggle with policies, practices, or procedures that are not meant for everyone to be included and thrive, that's where we see the issues. You know, I'm finding that, I'm glad to see that more people in companies are talking about D&I, right?

The conversations they engage. I'm seeing that on the perimeter, right? Outside. But inside the organization, there's an operational institutionalization of D&I that needs to take place.

The tactical things that's actually going to make it stick. What are some of those tactical things that organizations can do to really make D&I prevalent in a measure of success within their organizations? I think some of the very tangible, you know, tangible things, practical things that people can do is really focus first on the data. What does the data tell us, right?

So a lot of times we'll hear people say, oh, we need more diversity. Well, what do we mean by we need more diversity? Do we need more thought diversity, draft diversity, occupational diversity, parental diversity, what diversity? If we're really talking about those primary dimensions of diversity, race, gender, color, ethnicity, disability, or ability, if that's what we're talking about, then we need to be able to name that so we can change that, right?

So we have to understand, we have to go where the data takes us. So first, who's in our workforce, right? Who's represented? And then where are they represented at?

Then the second part of, do we have an advancement, a promotion issue? Do we have a career development issue? What are the perceptions of the employees who work with us? Once we understand the data, the qualitative and quantitative, then we can devise some very practical, tactical level, transactional level strategies that we can implement.

But I'm going to tell you, bottom line is something we don't talk about enough is accountability, right? Around behaviors. I think the most basic thing an organization can do is make sure that the behaviors of all of its employees align with its core balance. That's excellent.

That's not excellent. I like that explanation that you gave in terms of how they can actually do some practical things. And you start with data, you have to understand the makeup of your organization, who your organization is, who are your organization? Who are your organization?

What can you bring to the table? The mix of skills in representation. So I like the idea that you say you have a name, diversity. It's just not a broad term, because it is very broad, right?

And that's great. We need to know what we're targeting. What are we targeting? Okay, that's impressive.

Now you have the diversity and it evolved to inclusion. So what's the difference between inclusion that you're not getting in diversity? So the difference with inclusion is how are you leveraging the diverse individuals who work in your organization, right? Do they feel like they're connected to the organization?

Do they feel like they're valued team members? Are they engaged? Most important, do they show up and want to see your organization succeed, right? Do they have that level of commitment and dedication, not just to seeing themselves succeed, but to seeing the organization succeed?

That's the difference between having a satisfied employee and having an engaged employee, right? And then when we talk about engagement and we talk about inclusion, clearly we're talking about it along diversity dimension lines, because otherwise it wouldn't have the same significant relevance and be discussed in a B&I context. So I always like to think of it this way, Dr. Hart, whose hand is being acknowledged and whose hand is being ignored?

That is where the data will take us, right? Who are we recruiting? Who are we promoting? Who are we retaining?

Who are we developing? Who are we listening to? That's all the things we need to pay attention to, because that will drive the strategies we need to implement wherever we perceive any weaknesses, any barriers, so that we can correct those barriers. That's great, because I think a lot of companies feel like at this particular time, they need to hire someone to look at that diversity when all they really have to do is look within themselves, the organization, all those things you talk about, the behaviors, whose hand is being, who's been acknowledged, who is not, who's being heard, who is not, who's been included, who is not, you know, the microaggressions, all those other things that wrap up into that.

So, you know, what's the biggest risk to the D&I right now? Because right now it seems that there's a lot of positivity around it, which I love, and there's a lot of engagement around the conversations, but what can go wrong here in terms of not being this right? We know this wave here, right? So what can we, what do we have to watch out for to ensure that we do it right?

So I would say what I think we need to watch out for is sort of something that you just hit on. There's this wave of organizations that are hiring chief diversity officers. I'm one, I'm getting ready to take a new role as a chief diversity officer for a 4 to 500 company. I actually think that's where companies are getting it right.

And the reason I say that's where they're getting it right is because a lot of companies in the past have relied on someone who was in a marginalized group to do this in a collateral capacity, right? I mean, well-intentioned, it just didn't have the impact that they thought, right? So perhaps they pick someone from a minority group. So either they pick a woman, they pick someone from the LGBTQ plus community, they pick a racial minority to head up their diversity efforts.

But just because a person belongs to one of these groups, a member of one of these groups does not mean they possess the competencies and skills, the subject matter expertise needed to help set the vision, to help get strategic direction on the infrastructure that's needed to have sustained long-term outcomes for the organization, right? So I think that's one of the things companies are doing is that they are relying on the subject matter experts and they're bringing these individuals so that this can become part of the culture, part of the fabric and help do some transformation work in organizations. Yeah, I come from the risk management profession, of course, and, you know, managing risk with an organization is very important. How do you elevate the D&I?

Because the organization, organizations are dealing with a lot of risk, okay? Just not the D&I risk, there's a lot of competition when it comes to managing risk. What are some tactical things I know that I've seen and actually have instituted what you think are very useful in terms of making sure the D&I issues stay on the radar of leadership? Well, first and foremost, I think all businesses have to recognize that D&I is a business imperative.

That's the reality. And I like to look at the business imperative through three pillars, people, culture, and business, right? That if you look at those three key areas through a diversity lens, you'll be able to determine the risk just like you do with all your other business outcomes, goals, right? So I think when people fail to recognize the value of having a diverse workforce and leveraging the innovation that can come from having a diverse workforce, they are missing out on that opportunity gap.

So let me give you a plain example. When I worked for the Small Business Administration, we had an openly gay African-American male senior executive service member, and he came up with an idea to launch an LGBTQ plus small business owner tour. Why did he do that? Although SBA was already meeting its goals, they were already meeting its goals with regards to SBA small business backed loans, right?

But he saw an opportunity gap with a constituency group that perhaps we had not reached out directly, that we had not been deliberate and intentional about reaching. So when he embarked on this tour, guess what happened, Karen? They ended up exponentially increasing the number of SBA backed loans to these small business owners, this demographic population, right? So why does that matter in a D&I context?

Again, through those three lenses or those three key areas, had he not been in the workforce? So it's the diversity that he represented on the people side, right? Then from the culture standpoint, had he not been in a position of influence, or had the organization not valued his perspective, because they could have knocked that down. They could have said, we're already meeting our goals.

But he's saying, look, I think there's an opportunity gap to optimally meet our goals, not just meeting it, right? As a result of him being there, then from listening to them, there was a significant business out there. That's a great case study that a lot of organizations will look at in terms of instituting the D&I impact model, is what I would think of it is, you know, within organizations to make that change. In terms of reputation, moving forward in the D&I space, what do you think is going to happen within the next three, five years within, within the space?

So I think we're going to talk about reputational risk, perhaps? Well, yeah, only because the reputation, because, because a lot of corporations are on the spotlight right now, right? In response to what's happening in our environment. So, you know, reputation risk in terms of those who do something to move forward versus those who, you know, stay in a steady state and continue to be the status quo.

Right. So definitely, I think in terms of private sector, right? Because, you know, I've been on both sides, I'm looking at the perspectives, right? In the private sector, which is driven by revenue, right?

So really, reputational harm is huge from the standpoint of there's a potential revenue loss associated with having a bad reputation, especially when we think about like Gen Z. They very much attach their consumer habits to brands and whether or not that brand has a social justice stance, whether or not they're thinking about the environment, you know, all the rest of things. So they look to brands to see which brand they support. carbon footprint based on you know again social justice um stances so you risk losing consumers when your reputation is harmed um in the area of any organization that's not known for hiring diverse people or an organization where discrimination and harassment is pervasive in your organization or where you mistreat your customers your consumers that gets out now especially with social media your reputation it only takes a viral tweet you know it's a viral video or something and i mean so that's significant revenue loss for an organization so that reputational harm also it prevents you from hiring more diverse candidates because if you do not have a reputation for treating the diversity you currently have with dignity respect fairness and equity then you risk bringing on other ones and you risk them living so it's a risk of turnover it's a cost of turnover right now i hope i answered that but i think yeah no that was excellent you did you did answer that um and uh before we close a little bit i did want to talk a little bit about more about the future of dni and places where it's showing up where i would never think about dni we had you know previously we were talking about product development you had some thoughts about that i was fascinated by that when that conversation was going right again i love to think of dni holistically you focus on people you focus on the culture and then there's that business side or either there's how they all integrate you know together and you have synergy on the product development side we've seen this right in the news uh the reputational harm around brands that perhaps uh develop some clothing that some groups felt were insensitive you know to them or where there are some brands where people felt they co-opted african-american culture or appropriated african-american culture without getting um appropriate recognition to that community then there are also things like there's a company that produced a hand soap dispenser for commercial use in bathrooms what they found out after they had already developed after they had already made them and they've already sold and distributed them is guess what for some reason the soap wasn't coming out when black people would wave their hands darker people would wave their hands and that's because of whatever technology they use could not penetrate the skin on darker huge skin right and yeah so then they found out oops it doesn't work on all people so that probably was an opportunity for that company to do two things again on these three areas one have more diversity within their workforce who would have been on that product development team in the early phases and potentially get that perspective also when they were testing the product to make sure that they included diverse people to ensure there would be no issue so not only diversity along race diversity along ability um because what if someone with a disability for whatever reason was unable to reach the hand dispenser or something like that are there some age differences in terms of younger or older people so it helps to have that diversity in your test population right before you spend all that money you can find a lot it's your problem yeah you definitely want to i've seen that i've talked to marketers i've had interviews with other people on other podcasts and we talked about marketing and having you know things vetted before they go out the door and having diversity according to the table to make sure you know you're asking the right questions right right i want to make sure people understand that dni is just not for corporations it's just not for private industry it's for in a microcosm of the whole um you know a conversation with dni small businesses have to practice dni podcast owners like myself you know have to have a diverse sort of guests to come in to talk about different things diversity is everyone's responsibility it's just not a company responsibility and i believe that how we practice it individually we carry that behavior into our organizations or we carry that thought into the organizations so we have to check ourselves at the individual level as we go in and integrate it to these organizations that we either lead or influence or supervise or mentor you know within you know at different levels within the organization do you have any final thoughts for the audience before we sign off i think i'm gonna piggyback on what you just said when i was at the department of commerce i led my team in coming up with and launching the inclusion is on us campaign and it is about everything you just said the recognition at the core is that inclusion is on each and every one of us that every employee in a business in an organization has the power and influence to effectuate change right and many times we're just looking to the senior leaders to set the tone and that's very important don't get me wrong but it's not just their responsibility it's not just the responsibility of the vp of hr it's not just the responsibility of the chief diversity officer because at the end of the day i have the power and influence to make my colleagues feel welcomed in the workplace to make them feel included their voice when it comes to bystander intervention when i'm in a staff meeting and if i see someone's voice is not being heard or i see someone has been offended or they're treated unfairly i have the power to say something and interrupt that behavior right and so it's not just any one person's responsibility it's on all of us and i will end with and in every sector right um in my last example again first gen had a first gen phd uh employee at one of the research agencies and they were doing research on sleep deprivation and the impact on truck drives so as part of the team she said did you ask for both sets of books and they were like both sets of books she said yeah i grew up around truck drivers i know that if they get pulled over they have one set of books they show to the cops and they have another set that they keep for them now this is before gps they couldn't drive the point being this is someone who comes from humble blue collar working class background right who's now in a position in the workforce to help influence outcomes on research that will impact all of our nation's truck drivers and all the people who are on the roads with them to ensure safety if she did not feel comfortable that she could reveal that part of her identity her lived experience she would not have been able to add value that made sure that the outcomes of that research were balanced accurate and comprehensive awesome that is awesome awesome story and also insights i want to thank you for your time today tanisha i really do appreciate helping our audience understand more about the dni how important it is especially at this particular time but just not for now i hope this is a long-term commitment across the board from big companies to small companies to individuals and i really appreciate your contributions to the industry thank you so much i appreciate you having me on the show and i'll miss you thank you so much and thank you everyone for tuning in to slip this risk you can check us out at slip this risk dot tv at any time i'm dr karen hardy and i'll see you next time

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of FLIP THIS RISK® Podcast?

This episode is 28 minutes long.

When was this FLIP THIS RISK® Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on August 28, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this FLIP THIS RISK® Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.