Welcome aboard Via Rail. Please sit and enjoy. Please sit and stretch. Steep. Flip.
Or that and enjoy. Via Rail. Love the way. The new Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid is the most fuel efficient Crosstrek yet. That means less time filling your tank and more time filling your day. More court time. More ride time. More lake time. More camp time. More go time. The new 2027 Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid. Consumer Reports top rated subcompact SUV. Stop by your local Subaru dealership or visit Subaru.ca to learn more. Consumer Reports is not endorsed products or services.
This is Unorthodox, the universe's leading Jewish podcast. I am Stephanie Butnick and I'm joined by my co-hosts, tablet editor at large, Leah Leibovitz. Ramadan Kareem to all who observe. And the intergenerationally traumatized Joshua Molina. Hey, hey, ho, ho. I did see that on your Instagram, right? Yes. I've got a property of generational trauma t-shirt. Awesome.
Oh my God, that's amazing. Today on the show, we're welcoming back Phil Rosenthal, host of the Netflix travel show, Somebody Feed Phil. We talked to him about his new children's book, Just Try It, which he wrote with his daughter, Lily. It's about a very picky young eater. I tested it out on a very picky young eater. It is delightful. We're also joined by Eric Cohen and Abe Unger of Emmett Classical Academy in Manhattan, which calls itself America's first Jewish classical school and opens this fall. Plus, we speak with Rabbi Manny Evan Israel about his work at the Seinsalt Center, where he helps make Jewish texts accessible, continuing the mission of his father, the late Rabbi Adin Seinsaltz. It's going to be a great show. Before we get to that, I think we have a lot of Hollywood news. And I want to start us off because I did the...
most cinematic Hollywood thing one could do this weekend, which actually was not the Oscars. It was a little known screening of Crossing Delancey. Very cutting edge. You're right on. You got your finger on the pulse of what's happening in America. And it was followed by a Q&A that actress Jenny Slate did with the film's writer, Susan Sandler. It was like New York's hottest club. You would not believe the people in that room were amazing. You're going after the Oscar winners of 1986. It was 1988, please. And I have to say, I'd never seen Crossing Delancey, but I knew it as this like canonical Jewish film of like 80s New York life, 80s Lower East Side. And I was...
not disappointed at all. You know when you see the movie that all the other movies are based on? That's how I felt watching this movie. And people say that the Oscars are Hollywood's biggest night. Not even close. It was the Crossing Delancey screening. I met Jenny Slate. I got recognized by some Unorthodox fans. Oh, look at you bearing the lead. That's the big news. Fantastic. If not there, then where? And if not now, then when? And if not you, then who? If not on the Upper West Side, where? Literally. But they came up to me and they're like, oh, we just want to tell you we love Unorthodox. And I was like, you guys look really familiar. Have we met? And they're like, you know, we have seen you at like Barney Greengrass a few times. Like sometimes when we're walking by, we'll see you inside.
That is a celebrity 101 rookie mistake. When somebody recognizes you, don't respond with, I recognize you. Just take it and be like, yes, you should recognize me. I have no idea who you are. You're a stranger. I was just like, we must have run into each other before on the Upper West Side. They're like, yeah, I think we have. But something really interesting came up. So the film is like super Jew-y, Amy Irving, Peter Rieger. It's like the tension when your grandma's on the Lower East Side and you're uptown basically. And like, do you want to be with someone from the old country of the Lower East Side or your new like chic literary life? It felt very on the nose for this moment too of like, how Jewish do we want to be? But you know, one of the questions at the Q&A was, this film's so Jewish. Like, did you get any pushback along the way? Because this was 1988. And she said, no.
But I think it was because Amy Irving, the star of the film at the time, was married to Steven Spielberg, who was very close with the head of whatever studio produced the film. And she said the word protected. She's like, this is Susan Sandler. She wrote the play that the movie was based on and also the screenplay for the film. And she was like, I think we were protected. No one gave us any trouble. This is amazing. So you're saying that like Steven Spielberg was like the godfather who made it all happen. He was the Schindler of this production. He's like, I'll make you, I'll make you an oof-roof you can't refuse. It's beautiful. Everyone should watch Crossing Delancey. You have to buy it online, but I'm all about that right now. It exists exclusively in VHS. Should we move on to the second biggest night in Hollywood? Yeah, I mean, they're much less glamorous.
First of all, let us celebrate the ascendance of what I argue is the Jewish movie of all time. A movie that, as far as I'm concerned, said as before, I'll say it again. It has absolutely nothing to do with that silly little bomb that they drop or not. It has to do with an argument between two Jews about the nature of Jewish life and assimilation. And it's like an incredibly Jewish tale, and I'm kind of enamored with it. Mazel tov to Abedin.
Before we get to the serious depressing stuff, what other fun stuff did we enjoy about the ceremony? Remind me, who was this? Is Oppenheimer or Strauss? Who's like the assimilationist versus... Oppenheimer is the assimilationist extraordinaire who basically tries to find like some universalist framework to all of his, you know, ideas. Whereas Strauss is like, nah, buddy, I didn't grow up rich and privileged by pretending to not be Jewish. I actually grew up in Jewish institutions and work within my community to make it better. And let me tell you, you're out of your goddamn mind. And here's the thing. Strauss is kind of the hero, both historically and in a weird way also in the film. I mean, they both won Oscars. I kind of think so. He's not...
a villain. He's a very, this is Christopher Snowlin ultimate's credit. He could have been much more, especially when you have Robert Downey, like he could have been much more like, you know, toothsome baddie. And instead he's a very, very kind of intricately complex and kind of almost likable figure. You understand his machinations. Toothsome baddie. We should, we should use that going forward. The only thing I can think of is Purim. Like we call Heyman a toothsome baddie. Let's do it. Before we get to the serious depressing stuff, what other fun stuff did we enjoy about the ceremony? Actually, the ceremony gave me a new career goal, which is that after the in memoriam reel, honoring those who in the industry.
of note to have passed in the last year. They then flashed a QR code on screen so you could check out other notable deaths. And that is now my life's goal. It's not going to happen on the Oscars, but maybe I'll be in Emmys barcode other notable deaths. Oh, come on. I'm not shooting for an EGOT. I'm shooting for other notable deaths. I think Emmys, you could definitely correct that in memoriam, don't you think? If not there, Lina. It depends how soon I die or how much of a third act I have in my career.
Do you want to talk about the other stuff? Sure. We're beating around the bush as almost like we live next to the bush, but we're next to it and we're not paying attention to it. Let's take baby steps to the bush because was anyone else as troubled by Al Pacino's senior moment? Right. What did he end up doing? He ended up opening the envelope and saying, well, I see Oppenheimer. He said sort of tentatively. I have to go to the envelope for that. And I will. Here it comes. Anne-Marie, I see Oppenheimer.
I think he was sort of trying to hedge in case there was some sort of mistake. I think I see the word Oppenheimer, but what do I know? First of all, let's introduce him properly. This is former Academy Award winner, but even more importantly, former commentary magazine office boy, Al Pacino. Is that true? John Pothortz tweeted it last night. It is absolutely true. He was the mailroom sort of all-around office go-getter for commentary. And, you know, his career has really been downhill.
From there, he could have been someone. His entrance music was the Godfather theme. And I wondered whether he likes that or it's annoying to him. Like, I've done other stuff. He strikes me as someone who doesn't like anything. You know, that may be. I interviewed him once about the Merchant of Venice that he did. And I was like, I don't know, 24 at the time. And I asked him some dumb question. Like, how did you prepare for the movie? And he said, I read the fucking script. Hooah! Like, I deserve that. My version of that was when Nicole Krause came and spoke in my high school. And I was like, so starstruck. And I was like, how do you write? And she's like, what do you mean? And she's like, like, on a laptop. Like, it was literally like... I mean, with all the pain and suffering, how do you create fiction? But yeah, so my Pacino.
Who's your Pacino? Yeah. Melina, who's your Pacino? Who's the one kind of like person you admired and then met or worked with who's like a total dick? Wait, no, no. Nicole Krause wasn't mean to me. I want to say Nicole Krause was not mean to me. I was an idiot. In my version, she was very mean. I actually have an answer to that. I will say I was disappointed. I worked with John Malkovich on the movie In the Line of Fire. He's an actor whom I admire. And I found myself alone in the elevator with him. And I thought, I don't normally do this. I wouldn't say something to someone. But I'm in the movie.
I can introduce myself. And he said, hi, as we're going up in the elevator. Hi, my name is Josh Molina. I'm playing Agent Chavez in the movie. I just want to say I'm a huge fan of your work. It's exciting to be working with you. And I saw you last summer. I drove cross country with my sister. And in Chicago, we stopped and saw you in a play, Slip of the Tongue and Steppenwolf and blah, blah, blah, all this nice stuff. Long pause. And then he just turned to me and said,
Oh. It's kind of fucking brilliant. Yes, it made me on some level like him more. I'm like, okay, this dude's a legend. But also, I remember in the Flintstones, when Fred Flintstone was humiliated, he would go and become one inch tall. And I felt one inch tall. So that's my Malkovich story. Forget about being John Malkovich, being in an elevator with John Malkovich. That's the movie they should write. So from being John Malkovich to being Jonathan Glaser.
Okay, let's do it. What a night for the Jews. Let's set this up for anyone who has not yet been through Thursday. So if you have not heard about this, you're officially on no social media network. The film, The Zone of Interest, which is a German language film about the family of Rudolf Hess who lives right outside Auschwitz. And you're aware of what's going on, but to some degree, it's about sort of like the ability to live right next to something horrific and to be a participant in it to some degree, willfully or otherwise. So basically, the film wins Best International Feature and British-Jewish director Jonathan Glaser gets up. He wrote the screenplay, which was adapted from the Martin Amis book. And he does the usual, like, thank the Academy.
Thanks to the Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum and the people who helped with the film. Then he goes on to say, our film shows where dehumanization leads. Dehumanization leads at its worst. It shaped all of our past and present. Right now, we stand here as men who refute their Jewishness and the Holocaust being hijacked by an occupation which has led to conflict for so many innocent people. Whether the victims of October the 7th in Israel or the ongoing attack on Gaza, all the victims of this dehumanization. How do we resist?
We're parsing this. We're parsing this like a graduate-level seminar. Like a Talmudic text. Okay, so do you want to start with the refutation? Yes, because it seems to me that there are two readings here. And as a Talmudist, I want to be very, very attentive to text. The first, and in my mind, unlikely, I don't think this is what he meant, is we stand here as men who refute their Jewishness. Rather, here we are telling you, Hollywood, on this stage, with Dwayne The Rock Johnson standing behind me, that I refute my Jewishness. Had this indeed what Jonathan Glaze had done, I think he would have been a world-class moral monster, especially winning an Oscar for a Holocaust movie. I don't think that's what he meant.
I think what he meant is we stand here as men who feel very uncomfortable that their Jewish identity and the idea of the Holocaust is being hijacked somehow by Israel, which does not make Jonathan Glaser a moral monster, but makes him a bunch of other things. First of all, a piss poor fucking writer. Hold on, I put some nice British words. A wanker, a plank, a Charlie, a Burke, a prick and a Wally, which I hope all connotes. a first-class fucking idiot who can't write a sentence to save his life. How good is this fucking Academy Award-winning movie if you can't even in a speech that you're reading from text be clear about such a fucking important thing, you asswipe. Number one. However, let's let it roll off. Okay, fine, whatever. We all make mistakes in front of a live television audience of 38 billion people. Okay, but then, you know, he continues. And this is where shit really gets interesting. He continues by basically saying, you know, this has been hijacked by the occupation that has led to conflict because, of course, famously, the PLO.
was established in 1964, conveniently three years before said occupation began, but let's let history be. And then he says, you know, whether the victims of October 7th in Israel or the ongoing attack in Gaza, all the victims of this dehumanization, how do we hashtag resist? Now, look, we could spend a lot of time debating whether or not Israel should be doing more to make sure it's not encouraged many Palestinian civilian casualties in Gaza, or whether or not that is not something that Israel should concern itself right now. We could even debate whether or not Israel has any kind of moral responsibility to do something that not a lot of nations have done in time of war and allow, you know, humanitarian aid. The people are still actively trying to fight it. These are difficult discussions with a lot of very good points to be made on either side. What I don't think we can and should ever debate is the existence of some supposed cycle in which the victims of October 7th and the victims of the ongoing attack in Gaza all live in some perfect yin-yang of moral culpability. This war, as listeners of Unorthodox probably don't need reminding, could end tomorrow with the return of the 134 men, women, and children still held captive by Hamas. This kind of actually put me in a very, very interesting...
I mean, usually these, you know, kind of like little tempest and teacup type situations go away. But I read a really brilliant observation by my friend, Rabbi Joe Schwartz, formerly of Brooklyn, currently of Israel, who made this really great observation. You know, the Holocaust is obviously very, very, very, very difficult concept to parse theologically. It's like, if you look at it correctly, it is a uniquely Jewish story in as much that it's hatred and murderousness. was unleashed against a very specific people for a very specific set of historical reasons. However, if like so many people right now, your general takeaway is Holocaust is bad because it teaches us that we should be tolerant of all people, then you're stuck with the inconvenient fact that this happened to specific people for specific reasons, the Jews, which is why you're very tempted to practice a sort of, you know, replacement theology and say, well, but that's okay because the Jews have now gone on to be oppressors in kind, which is why Jonathan Glaser and so many other complete fucking moral idiots have such a hard time.
with understanding the fact that there is no moral equivalency between Hamas and Israel, which again, is not to say that you cannot seriously debate and denounce many of the Israeli government's decisions in the last five months, but to claim that somehow the victims of October 7th and the victims of the ongoing attack on Gaza are all the victims of this dehumanization. No, they are not. Ones are the victims of dehumanizations because they were raped and beheaded and literally dehumanized by invaders. And the others are... You know, people who are killed in a very unfortunate war that was forced upon us by murderous maniacs. There is no equivalency here. And just one more reason, I think, why so many people, myself included, find themselves really kind of bumped out with the kind of stuff that people like Jonathan Glazer put out in the world. Joshua Malina, I think you almost pulled out all of your beard hairs during that. I think that's just a habit. He wasn't making me go crazy. I agree with much of what Liel says. And first of all, let me set the scene.
Jonathan Glaser was clearly shitting a brick. His hands were quaking. And so I think he read what was an inelegantly worded statement in the first place. He also read it poorly. And the first thing I heard, and I turned to my dad after his speech, I said, did he just say they're refuting their Jewishness? And I immediately tweeted something like,
Why would someone have to refute his or her Jewishness in order to take a moral stand? As a result of which I, between that moment and this moment, am receiving a hundred tweets a second. People calling me a Nazi and a filthy Zionist. And I don't understand why people are so up in arms. Even if I now acknowledge and have in about 20 different tweets, acknowledge that I go with Leo's reading. He's saying he's refuting their Jewishness and the Holocaust being used to...
Blah, blah, blah. The blah, blah, blah part still to me is too opaque. And I think he really ought to clarify. I think Liel suggested that he's drawing an equivalency between the Holocaust and what's happening in Gaza. I don't think that's what he's doing. I'm not exactly sure what he is doing or what he's saying. I think it was a bungled attempt to show empathy for innocent civilians dying in Gaza, as well as the victims of October 7th. I think it would be nice if he had mentioned the hostages that remain in Gaza. I think if he was going to try to speak on this important issue on the platform that he was using, that he should have been...
clearer and he maybe should have had a little bit more to say because it does leave me wondering what exactly it means to say that the Holocaust has been hijacked by the occupation and that's led to conflict. I don't really understand what it means exactly. The feeling that I'm left with, that sort of icky feeling is like, dude, you won an Oscar for a movie about the Holocaust. And then to sort of subvert that into say like, oh, and actually because of this movie about people across the fence from Auschwitz who didn't care about what was going on, I'm uniquely qualified therefore to lecture you about Israel and to draw such a specific parallel between this idea of like what goes on in our backyard to the people over there, I find very repugnant. I think that he's participating in...
Something I am uncomfortable with, which is this like Schindler-esque dramatization of Holocaust stories in a way that as Dara Horn like drilled into my head with her book People Love Dead Jews, like perpetuates one type of Jew. Then to go straight from there, which is problematic on its own in some ways, arguably, to then go and be like, and now occupation bad. There's more in the middle of that. And it saddens me that he sort of took this moment to say that you knew he was going to say it. I feel like you just like you saw where he was going. You were like, oh, no, no, like it's not about the past. It's not the present. You're like, oh, no, no, no, don't do it. Don't just have this moment. And he did it. To me, it just it feels it feels gross. I don't like it. I also didn't love, you know, I feel similarly to the people who were like red pins for.
Palestinians and you're like, you don't fucking know shit. Sorry. You don't know what you're talking about. You do not know what you're talking about. When one of the most iconic images of the people you're trying to support is a literal pogromist showing his two bloodied red hands after like beating two innocent Israelis who took a wrong term to a pulp. Maybe don't choose a red hand. I get what you're trying to say. Choose, you know, you have watermelons. You got a bunch of things. Just go with that. But look, let us properly congratulate. And the Oscar for being such a bloody wanker as to unite the entire Jewish people in absolute seething hatred for your stupidity goes to.
Jonathan Glazer. I cannot sign off on this. I cannot sign off. I really disagree with you guys. You stand here refuting our refuting of Jonathan Glazer. I refute my co-hosted-ness. On some level, I admire what he did. I don't just think he's a wanker and a bellend and an asshole. I admire him for trying to say something nobody else addressed it. You want to say something about innocent lives being lost in Gaza, I would have been happy to hear it last night. You want to say something about the hostages and bring them home, I would have liked to hear that too. So for being the only person to try to say anything and to attempt however inelegantly and badly worded, I give him credit for trying to say...
something i don't i don't think it was grotesque listen i agree with that but melina like should people who win oscar for writing the best film like actually know how to write something yeah but also here's another thing i also think i heard it with my jewish ears and i immediately heard something that these people are refuting their jewishness in order to take a moral stand i subsequently was disabused of that interpretation and i think he worded it badly and i acknowledged it on twitter even though people don't seem to be able to acknowledge that i can think of three high-profile jews that read it the same way and have not backed down. And so I think there's a disingenuousness among some to turn what he said into something that it wasn't, even though what he said was unclear. They all came out and said, they're refuting their Jewishness. Fuck you and asshole and all this stuff. And that does not make them better than that guy that they have an issue with because they are, I think, being purposefully obtuse about what he was saying or at least trying to say. And I think you owe him at least the attempt to figure out what he's saying. I think he should say more because it's trending on Twitter. Like enough people misunderstood what he was saying or had trouble with what he's saying. I think once you understand it, I think I would still have issues with what he's trying to say, but I'd like to know what the actual message is.
I am sure that an equally obtuse, equally self-serving Guardian, you know, think piece is forthcoming. I don't think we have heard the last of Jonathan Glaser. I suspect not. I do want to round us out with one final bit of entertainment-themed news, which is that Adam Sandler was apparently Hollywood's highest earner in 2023. So all the anti-Semites listening. So the Oscar may go to Jonathan Glaser, but $73 million. So the shackles go to Adam Sandler. My man. Adam Sandler, whom I have called to the Bima as Gabi at Synagogue. That's a real L.A. Jubrat. Yeah, L.A. Adam, Ben, Happy Madison, Gilmore, Little Nicky.
He made a ton of money on these three movies, Murder Mystery 2. I don't know if anyone saw that or Murder Mystery 2. Oh, yeah, I forgot you're a Sandler. Every Sandman movie I've seen. The animated movie, Leo, which actually we have not gotten to yet, but it's on the docket. And You Are So Not Invited to My Bat Mitzvah, which is the film that, you know, we talked about a ton when it came out and started him and his daughters and his wife. It was amazing. Most importantly, he's also the auteur behind the greatest documentary ever made about contemporary Israeli life. You don't mess with the Zohan. I rewatched this weekend with my kids at their suggestion. It is a profoundly wonderful film.
You know what I want to say at the Oscars? Instead of Kate McKinnon doing a bit where she thinks Jurassic Park are a series of documentaries, I want somebody to go up there and refer to it. You don't mess with the Zohan as a documentary. 73 million is a good year. It is coincidentally almost exactly how much more than I earned last year. Those three films were all released on Netflix. And apparently, according to Netflix, people consumed more than 500 million hours of his movies. All of his movies. The full Sandler canon in just the first half of 2023. That is remarkable. Anyway, that is, yeah, mazel tov. Mazel tov to the Sandman. It's today, Sloppy Joes.
And my breath reeks of tuna, and there's lots of black hairs coming out of my nose. Oh, hoagies and grinders, hoagies and grinders. Navy beans, navy beans, navy beans, navy beans. Hoagies and grinders, hoagies and grinders. Navy beans, navy beans, we love sandwich. Sloppy dough, sloppy, sloppy dough, yeah. Sloppy dough, sloppy, sloppy dough, yeah. Sloppy dough, sloppy, sloppy dough, yeah. Sloppy dough, sloppy, sloppy dough, yeah.
We make Chevrolet vehicles, but what you do with them makes them so much more. You make them mobile offices, your kid's personal taxi, a concert shuttle, your hockey equipment locker, your recording studio. We make a Chevrolet, but you make it a Chevy. Discover yours at chevrolet.ca. Welcome aboard Via Rail. Please sit and enjoy. Please sit and stretch. Steep. Flip. Or that and enjoy. Via Rail. Love the way.
Our listeners know Phil Rosenthal from his Netflix travel show, Somebody Feed Phil, which just launched its seventh season. But Phil is back on Unorthodox today to talk about his new children's book, Just Try It, which he wrote with his daughter, Lily. It's about a food-loving dad and his very picky daughter. We talked to Phil about how he went from a picky eater himself to someone who literally travels the world eating, and about the importance of keeping an open mind at meals and in life. Phil Rosenthal, welcome back to Unorthodox. I love it. I love you guys. You're great. It's always fun having you, but it's especially fun having you this time because I told my two-year-old that I was meeting Phil Rosenthal and she could not believe it. She thought I was meeting a celebrity. She has not seen Everybody Loves Raymond. She has not watched Somebody Feed Phil. She is a big fan of Just Try It. Wow. Well, that's nice. I'll bet you would love Lily and Lily would love her. That's kind of the nicest thing about the couple of bookstops we've made already is meeting the kids. They're so damn cute.
So, you know, you sent us copies of this new book, Just Try It, which you and your daughter Lily wrote. And as journalists, I did what I, you know, what I'm supposed to do. And I took it home and I did read it to the toddler in my life. I recorded it and I wanted to share it with you. Do it.
Today, Dad is taking me to a food truck festival. I am nervous. I know what he's going to say. What does Bill say? Just try it. Yeah, just try it. See, I told you. It's an everything bagel with cream cheese, lox, tomatoes, onions, and capers. Just try it. I should be polite and say no thank you, but by accident, I say... Yeah, she says...
All right. That's the best ad for anything I ever heard. I think I hire Edith now to come to readings. It's such a sweet book. And I would love it if you just tell us a little bit about how it came to be, how you decided to write a children's book, how you decided to write it with your daughter. Just tell us everything. So Lily found the text the other day. I honestly forgot because I'm very, very old. Here's the text. Dad, I see how much kids love the show and you're good with the kids. Why don't you write a children's book? And I texted back without hesitation. Yes, if you'll do it with me. And that's how it came. That's really how it came. It's loosely based on our relationship. You know.
little girls, little boys can be very stubborn. Lily wasn't as bad as this little girl in the book, but she had her hesitations about certain foods like mustard, for example. And you know, we came to realize mustard is almost a sign that your kid is growing up. Because think about it. Ketchup is the sweet, right? And mustard is only savory. There's no sweetness unless you get honey mustard, of course. Which might be a good transition, I just thought. Forget bar and bat mitzvah. This should be the rite of passage. Just put them in a room with all their relatives and a hot dog. Bar mustard. Right. And they just have the mustard. You smear a little mustard on the Torah. And that's it. And you take your pointer and you dip it in the mustard. And today you're a woman. Yes. So that's really, that was the genesis of the thing. You know, we all know you as Phil who goes to far fun places and acquaints himself with the culture and the cuisine by just eating everything and meeting everyone and connecting to people through food.
I like the idea that you've actually been doing this your whole life and your children's life, sort of like pushing them to try things. So just try it means literally have a little open mind. I say in the show, if you can open a mouth, you can open a mind, right? If you taste something from another culture, now you're a little more open to that culture. If you sit and break bread with another human being, you're now a little more open to that human being.
because you've done something we all do that we all relate to. So now we're not enemies for a second. Every time I talk to you, I ask myself, how is this man not president? I mean, children's book is nice and TV is good, but like, come on, man, the nation needs you. Can you just tell us Just Tried Collective? It's a great campaign slogan. We'll eat whatever you tell us. I'm too dumb and maybe too smart to be president. I believe you're too smart. So tell us kind of like the story behind the story behind the story. So I imagine you're the kind of dad when Lily was young who actually said Just Tried quite a lot. What are the weird things that you sort of try to foist on her as she was a toddler? Oh my goodness. Monica was really the genius because she came up with...
or maybe her mother said this, a no thank you bite. Right? That was her just trial. I don't want broccoli. Okay, then you'll just have the no thank you bite and you don't have to eat it. Ah, that's brilliant. That's brilliant. That disarms them from like all the weaponry. What can they say after this? So a lot of it, and I'm sure you find this with Edith, it's not so much they don't want to taste the food. They're just asserting their personhood. They're just saying, I'm in charge of me. I get to say what goes in and comes out. I'm not taking orders. You can order me to go to bed. You can order me this and that. But when they push back, that's just them becoming people.
That's hard to remember in the moment where I'm like, you need to eat something on this plate. Listen, we all know this. Everyone. I was terrible. I was a very picky eater myself. Really? My mom couldn't believe it when I became the food guy. She would say, Howard, you never ate anything when you were a kid. And my father goes, maybe it was the chef. So was there a moment in your own parenthood that, you know, must have decided that you were sitting there watching Lily eat something and be like, ah, I've arrived. What was it? It might have been like, like caviar at a fancy party, which is a very rare thing to have.
We're not caviar people. It was a very rare thing to have. And she loved it. I said, oh, this she likes. Now I'm broke. Oh, broccoli you say no to, but beluga, that you'll have. Okay, thanks. But she was actually, here's what I think. And this obviously doesn't work for everybody. You model the behavior. Lily, if Lily was here, she would tell you it was hard to resist when her father was literally jumping up and down that the pizza was here.
You know, literally waving his hands like a crazy person because pasta arrived. So I think that a lot of the goings on in the Roosevelt household, just like in the Leibowitz household, is revolved around food. Where are we going for lunch? What's for dinner? Of course, we're Jews. We love food. But guess who else loves food? Every other person. Every other place I go. Oh, you haven't eaten until you go to a Chinese person's house. Oh, you know how you tell you're at a Greek person's house for dinner. There's no space between all the dishes on the table, right? Ray Romano has this bit. If you don't want any more food at my mother's house, you're going to have to shoot her.
By the way, you always come on and disabuse us of these notions of Jewish exceptionalism when you're just like, everyone loves food, this is not just our thing. Of course. By the way, let's go back to Raymond for a second. So it's ostensibly an Italian family, right? Loosely based on Ray's actual life. So many things came from my house. It couldn't be more Jewish. I was about to say, it took me a long time to understand that this is an Italian family. I think like three seasons, like, oh, they're supposed to be Italian. Right, Romano. But that's the television way, right? They used to say, right, Yiddish?
Cast British. Cast Queens. So, you know, one other thing that I really love about this book and about the show and just kind of about your gestalt in general. I think the last couple of years or the last couple of decades, really, food has become this, you know, almost contact sport, right? Like chefs are big celebrities. It's a big business. Like it's revered in this way. There's like a new man gastronomic science and stuff. And you're coming here and you're returning us. And I love that the book does this because the book takes it right back to, you know, the origins, the cradle, quite literally. And says, guys, this is about pleasure. Like when Lily in the book eats the food, like the pleasure is astounding. You could see how much fun she's having.
Yes, I'm not very serious about it. In fact, I would say I'm more serious about the underlying things in the show. And I'm only using food and my stupid sense of humor to get you the real message, which is number one, to travel. And number two, be a little open-minded to other people. I think the world would be better if we all could experience a little more of other people's experiences. Amen, Selah. That's beautiful. And I'm wondering how that feels for you right now. You're like a publicly Jewish person. You talk about food. I mean, I feel like things are just so charged right now. Can we even sit and break bread together? I guess here in America, like, are we past that? It feels like it sometimes.
That was a real oi. Did you see the Dubai episode yet of the new season? So I sit down with a Palestinian woman at her restaurant. This was almost a year ago, before the trouble. It couldn't be a more beautiful scene. I got emotional. This woman was so lovely and so great.
and told me, I don't think a unique story, but it was very passionate. And she fed me from her hands and the food was so delicious that it became this other thing. It became some kind of bridge to another time or place. I am not Mr. Wu Wu spiritual, even religious. I just, you get a feeling you can't help it. And you see me well up and hug this lady. That's how it can be. And by the way, that's how it is most of the time. It doesn't make the news. Oh my God, there's this town where Arabs live next to Jews. And you know what happened today? They had lunch like they do every day.
Right? I'm not showing you the world in the show the way it could be or some fantasy. I'm just showing what's there. I'm showing you what is. Most things are great and nice. Most of the world is beautiful. It's fantastic. You know, this puts me in mind, I think one of the greatest things that the United States has recently done is, I don't know if you were watching closely, the aid packets kind of like airdropped over Gaza, but they put Skittles, Skittles in the aid packets. I'm imagining some Hamas, like hardened Hamas guy getting his hands on a bag of Skittles, tasting a few, be like, you know, I could taste that rainbow. Maybe I don't want to kill people today. Maybe I just want to eat my Skittles here in the shade. It's good. That's hilarious and simplistic.
But it gives me hope these days. I'm honestly not far from that. I'm honestly not far from that. Wasn't there the story, correct me if I'm wrong, that on their terrible raid, Hamas, a lady made them lunch and then they went, they had the lunch and then went away. Cookies. Isn't that true? Yeah, it is. Absolutely. She's absolutely here. She's like, we're going to kill you. And literally she says, no, you're not. And they're like, why not? She said, because you're hungry. And then she said, sit down. And she just went to the kitchen. She baked them cookies. And they're like, wow, these are fantastic. And saved her life and her husband's life. Listen, I'm thinking this is a very specific set of terrorists, a very specific lady. We're not going to solve all the problems like this, right? But isn't it nice to know?
that it worked once even. Right. Even once is a miracle. Diana. Yes. Food taps into some sense of humanity, right? Like on this atrocious day, like she did get to some core elements. That's right. So take your mind away from Kamas for a second. Give us as the now worldwide expert on making kids try delicious food. Give us a sort of gradual. So we learned about the no thank you bite, which is, I think, a great beauty. Give us a sort of, you know. The way in the book, the way in the book is you notice, you leave it to them. They're going to eventually find it on their own. You know, you just said that.
It's a struggle. You forget that they're going to find it on their own because in the moment you want them to eat. But if you left the room, they were going to eat something or not. And then they would be hungry and they would eat. It is true. I feel like sometimes if we're just sitting there and we're all having dinner together and if I stop saying, just eat it, I'll look. I'm like, wait, did you eat? You ate the chicken? Like it just, it happens when I relax. It's not about the food. It's about them and their relationship with you. It's like the marshmallow experiments. Like you just put the herring on the table and you leave and you let the child eat their own herring. You got it. Or make them part of the process. There's a million ways to get them to eat. Paying them is good.
I love that you did this book with your daughter and you know, Lily has no voice. She could not be here with us today, but you seem so proud of her. And I just want you to tell us, tell us a little better. I'm proud of both the kids. I just, you know, of course you worry about the kid. Of course there's going to be tough times where you go, Oh my God, are they going to turn out? Okay. But I'm here to say by just experience that what seems to have worked because Lily's 26 or boys 29, they're both beautiful people. And we think it's because we modeled the behavior that they would eventually gravitate towards.
Now, could it have gone south? Could they have fallen in with, quote unquote, the bad crowd? Right. Could they have rebelled against us so much that there was no returning? Of course, we worried about that. But I think all we can do as parents is set a good example. I love that. And it's to me, it's more than just food. It's like you want to be excited about food. You want to be excited about us like being Jewish. Right. And to show that that is something that is fun and joyful and that there's, of course, Jewish food that we can incorporate into that. But I mean, I want to take your lesson and I want to expand it more broadly. Right.
They're looking at us and it's easy to forget that, right? And so how we react to things, whether it's a meal or a conversation or a holiday, right? Like they see that and they do start mirroring that in some way. And as human beings, we love ritual, right? And we love the things of chocolate. So if you have a Passover Seder every year, your kids are going to grow up and they're going to want that Passover Seder. Whether they go to temple or not, whether they're religious or not, they're going to like, like me, nice traditions that we revisit every year. Like your birthday. That's what it feels like. It marks the year. It marks the passage of time. It marks, you know. And it involves food. So what's not to love? Don't forget.
So let's do like some rapid fire Jewish questions, if you don't mind. I don't mind. Favorite Jewish holiday? I think it's Passover for that reason, for the gathering around the day. Least favorite Jewish food? You know the phlegm that's in the bottle of gefilte fish? Yes. I don't need that. But you'll eat like a gefilte. Yes. And I've had, have you ever had like a chef make gefilte fish like really good? Yes. Isn't it amazing? Alon Shaya. I had it at his house in New Orleans. Wow. That was good. It has a bad rap. I think because of those jars. Yes. And it has the word filter in it.
I personally love the fish flint. You do? It's like really one of my, oh, absolutely. But I eat like a Ukrainian peasant. Like the stuff that I love is like awful, like just really bad. That's your least favorite. I'm just curious. You know, it's a very hot take. It's latka, which I think is like the ninth, like it's not even the ninth most interesting thing to do to a potato. And it gets this like halo around it. It's not that it's bad. It's like, it's so overrated. It's like, oh my God, look at this. It's like, guys, you could have made french fries or mashed potatoes or baked potatoes or home fries. So many better things than this like intensely laborious, tear-inducing, finger-destroying.
process that ends up with like a decent, you know, thing. Oh, you're talking about the making of it. I'm talking about the whole process. I guess. He's a monster. Phil, he's a monster. I don't like food that makes you work too much. Me neither. And I don't cook at all. I don't cook at all. I'm just a fan. You just eat. But I will say, I've had world-class latkes. Yeah. I think you haven't had the right latke. Maybe. So it's funny that you say that because my take is that I don't really love Kugel. Yeah. I don't get it. Everyone's always like, no, you haven't had my, insert, you know, Bubby's name here. My Bubby's. But there's two kinds of anything, good and bad, right? You can have a great, I'm telling you, there's a great Kugel out there. And you know what I should do? I should just try it
That's it. If we've learned anything from you, Phil, it's just to try it. That's it. I've eaten some horrible things. But the journey is its own reward, right? It's like everything else. It's literally about having an open mind. And I'm thinking, you know, they would like another book from us. And we could do just try it. The first thought was just try it in Japan, right? Try these foods, right? We could have the same reactions. And that's one way to go. But what if just try it were other things that kids learn? Like just try it, sharing. Just try it, make a new friend. Because just try it only means have an open mind. So we can have an open mind about many, many, many things.
Or, you know, the kid is now 21 and the Just Try It is like just different kinds of cocktails. Just try it. Dirty martini. Yeah, we get to it. You are a credit to humanity. Thank you so much for being our guest. Aren't you sweet? This was so nice. I love seeing you guys. Thank you.
Want to get away but can't live without Wi-Fi? With select Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, and Cadillac vehicles connected by OnStar, you can enjoy an in-vehicle Wi-Fi hotspot with up to 15-meter range so you can stay connected even in unexpected places. Whether you're setting up camp or feeling up at a rest stop, you can enjoy the entertainment of home on the go. Explore OnStar tech today at onstar.ca and elevate your travels. OnStar. Better never stops. Welcome aboard via rail. Please sit and enjoy. Please sit and stretch. Steep. Flip.
All right, to the mailbox. We have a lot of responses to our letter last week from Hannah and Kay, who were looking for some new Jewish options in the Northern Virginia area. And it turns out, Hannah and Kay, we have you covered. This came in from Daniel Goldberg. He says, tell them to come to Olam Tikva in Fairfax. We joined when we moved to Northern Virginia, specifically because of the large young adult presence.
He also promises to hook you up there. Someone else writes in to tell them they should check out Gather DC and someone else says Temple Micah in DC. So Han and Kay, keep us posted on your shul hopping adventures. If it works out, we get 15% of the shul membership dues. Exactly. Then we got a second and very fascinating letter from Sam Ashkenaz, which is a very good name. I found a second American edition of Mein Kampf.
What is the appropriate thing to do with it? What a great question. I mean, you know, we have Geniza for holy texts containing Hashem's name. We don't just throw them away. We take them to a special place in the synagogue, which buries them in a special manner. What do we do with the opposite of holy? What do we do with texts and books that are so vile that we feel we can just, you know, toss them aside? We need to do something ritualistic with them. I know the answer is not burn them. The answer is probably not burn them. But can we think of something more creative than just dispelling them? Is there a use that we could think of? What about like toilet paper? Mein Kampf toilet paper? Too literal. Maybe this is too mild, but you could put it under the short leg on your table. It's not a big gotcha.
But, you know, the table won't wobble. We'll forever comfort Jews as they try to eat. Excellent. Listeners, write and let us know what ought we to do. So send us your emails. Tell us what you need, what we can do for you in your life at unorthodox at tabletmag.com or leave us a message on our listener line at 914-570-4869. Write a review of the show that says that you like me because there's one up there recently of somebody who really doesn't like me. Wait, actually? I need a few more positive reviews so the first thing you see isn't.
I hate Josh Molina as the new co-host. I'm happy to do that. By the way, you totally read reviews. You read all reviews. Oh, I read it all, yes. I once got in trouble for bringing bad reviews to the set of a TV show I was on because I thought they were funny. My publicist called me and said, I just got a call from the ABC publicist. You didn't print out bad reviews and read them to the other people on the show. I said, oh yeah, I did do that. He said, yeah, not everybody likes that. Don't do that anymore. It's very funny.
Our next guests are the duo behind the Emmet Classical Academy, which opens this fall. It'll be the country's, nay, the world's first Jewish Classical Academy with, you know, modest goals like preserving the best of Western civilization and saving the world from barbarism. We are joined by founding chairman Eric Cohen and head of school Abe Unger, who came by the studio to share their very ambitious plans and to tell us why they think everything about the way we educate our children can and absolutely must improve. Here's Eric Cohen and Abe Unger. Okay, I'm Eric Cohen. I'm the CEO of TICFA and the founding chairman of Emmet Classical Academy. I am Abe Unger, head of school, Emmet Classical Academy. We won't call you doctor. We will not embarrass you. Even worse would be rabbi doctor. There you go. That's a double threat. That's a double insult. Tell us about this year's initiative. What is Emmet Academy? We think the world needs a school firmly devoted to the majesty, the riches of Jewish culture and civilization, but that also believes that the West is this great inheritance, that America is this great inheritance, and that what we need to do is teach young people to be the carriers forward of their own civilizations. And that has to begin very low to the ground. It has to begin with this classical tradition of teaching young people.
grammar rhetoric and logic teaching them some of the greatest poetry that's ever written so you kind of furnish the wardrobe of their minds teaching them what great art looks like so they can recognize beauty you got to teach them the foundations teaching them latin teaching them language and what That allows for them to do as young people is it opens them up to the heights of civilized culture. And we want them to do that as Jews who know who they are and what they stand for, as Zionists who know who they are and what they stand for, as Americans who believe in this country. But fundamentally, people that believe Western civilization is a great thing and it's worth defending and it's worth defending as Jews. Now, if I'm interested in this line of argument, I can imagine a parent saying, OK, well, you know, we have day schools, we have yeshivas, we have no shortage of great Jewish institutions, educational institutions to send our children to. How's this one different?
We're not out to create just another modern Orthodox day school. We're creating a classical academy. Think gymnasium before World War II in Europe. Think of the great intellectual history of the West being imbibed by young Jews as part of their heritage and the Jewish studies that they do, which I'll outline in just a minute, in conversation with the intellectual history of the West. So the Jewish courses that we will offer will be Tanakh, taught with great respect and veneration for tradition, with rabbinic hermeneutics as well, but also archaeology and speaking as a great text of historical impact in conversation with the great books of antiquity. Think of modern Hebrew, but also Bialik Chernikovsky. Once that might have been taught, but we're really going back to the classics of Hebrew literature as well as modern conversational Hebrew. Think Jewish history.
with a strong focus on the continuity of the Jewish presence in the land of Israel? How many folks really think about the Yeshuv HaYashon and that Jews have been doing self-governance without a break? My kids think about it all the time. Okay, there you go. In Latin. They sit around the dinner table in Latin discussing these things. That's right. Let me ask you this. The classical education model is a model that has been thriving in recent years, but almost exclusively in the Catholic community. There seems to be almost something that I'm not sure if it's completely counterintuitive or so intuitive that I can't believe it hasn't been tried until now of putting this model of, hey, we have to get back to the basics of the logic of the rhetoric of the classics in conversation with...
The Jewish values. Is it intuitive? Is it counterintuitive? Have we always belonged to classical education? Are we reinventing classical education?
The Jewish people, we have sort of framed classical education, I believe, for the West. I'll make that presumptive statement. By the way, just as a side note, I actually did my graduate work, my PhD at Fordham, so I was trained by Jesuits. And I'll just give you an anecdote about that kind of training. So I remember having to take, even though I did policy, I had to do some theory work. So I had to do a course in Aristotle's metaphysics. And until I encountered that text, I never thought, wow, anything could be as great as the Talmud. With all due respect to the oral law, you know, the metaphysics use much of the same hermeneutic and dealt with, you know, the great questions of what is form, what does matter, what does it mean to be alive? You wouldn't have to find hermeneutic for some of our listeners. Interpretive rules, rules of argument. And I thought, wow, there's a real complementarity between the practical philosophy
first philosophy of the ancient Greeks. And there is a conversation methodologically, intellectually, even substantively there. And so I began to look at different models of what we should be doing as Jews methodologically. And I'll give you just a little bit of an example of how this is framed classically. Many young Jewish students learning the oral tradition don't really realize its connection to the written law.
They don't actually get how verses in the Bible are transformed rabbinically and that historical continuity. So that's something that we do as Jews. That's a classical thing. That's an interpretive skill. And Jewish tradition, the great works of Judaism are great classical Western pieces of literature that were in conversation with the West. Aquinas quotes Maimonides. And so I think we have to recapture that sense of the Jewish tradition being part of the classical tradition as just part of Western civilization, not something discreet from it. I think we also have to pay attention to the cultural crisis we're living through right now and why I think Jewish classical learning is an answer to that.
I mean, I think you have young people, and Jews are especially attuned to this, growing up in schools without moorings, without moral foundations, without intellectual foundations. And I think the flourishing of the classical movement is a saying, if we care about the West, we got to go back to the beginning. not just to look backward, but to actually build a future. And some of that has to do with the Greco-Roman world and Latin and the sort of gateway to the high culture of the West. But the deepest foundation is actually the Jews. The deepest foundation is actually the Bible. There's a reason that it's scenes from the Bible that are on the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel. There's a reason why we look to the Psalms as the deepest accounts of the human soul. There's a reason why proclaim liberty throughout the land is a biblical verse on the Liberty Bell. Like the Bible is the West's great inheritance. And in a moment of confusion where Jews are actually under assault, we see what's going on on the campuses. We think...
starting a Jewish class education movement is a way to renew not only Jewish life and culture and commitment, but it's a way to renew the West. And there's also an element of pride here, right? In sort of taking back this idea of, oh, we are the classics, right? We have offered so much. And instead of sort of shying away from that, it sounds like what you're trying to do is push people to embrace that in a way. Yeah. I mean, look, this is a school that believes strongly in Jewish exceptionalism and that the Jews have a unique heritage to pass on to their own people and to the world, that we have something to teach the West and that we need to first claim it for ourselves as Jews. And I think what we're seeing is many families that are...
flocking to Emmett in this early year of recruiting the founding students, many of them are in either secular private schools or public schools, and they've been mugged by the reality of a culture gone crazy, whether that's in anti-Semitism, in intersectionality, and all these insane ideological movements that have seen about the Jews, or whether it's in just the degradation of academic standards. At some point, like a sixth grader should know how to spell the word is, and you have creative spelling is still... And so a lot of these families, in a moment where... we're living in this kind of age of confusion are saying, you know, maybe being a more serious Jew is a part of the answer to that. And maybe it's time that I pass down this Jewish inheritance to my own kids. I love the audacity of this mission. And I love the fact that it's focused not just around academic excellence, but also around moral excellence, moral seriousness. How do you do it? How do you forge moral human beings?
The culture of the school itself, day in, day out. And here's a lesson from Jewish Values, right? The devil's in the details. So the granular details of the day are in terms of, you know, shaking hands with the head of school in the morning, saying good morning, table manners in the dining hall at lunch, some kind of culture of seriousness. It doesn't mean it's not fun. The place can be fun. There's nothing more fun for a child than learning and feeling empowered as a learner. But the idea of being in a place where there's some sense of presentation, even etiquette there, I say, matters, actually. So I'm a kid. I just entered through the door. It's, what, 8, 8.30 in the morning. Walk me through a typical day. Okay, so you say the Pledge of Allegiance. You sing Khatikvah.
Obviously, then there's some good morning, either just before or after. There's a handshake, good morning to teacher and head of school. You sit down, you do either English or math. They'll be the first two classes offered on a rotating basis each morning to each grade. Then you go through your seven, 15-minute periods throughout the day. There's a little break between. We actually do want kids to have a little bit of respite and running around a little bit, not run from class to class. But it's only in Greek that they have to speak to English. Only in Greek, yes. All recesses and strange, archaic languages. So anyway, so they go through these periods, and they'll have visit every day too, Monday through Thursday, with some martial arts, actually. And then they will have their lunch.
And there really will be some kind of etiquette at lunch. It'll be a kind of formal thing. By the way, once or twice a week, there'll also be music history and art history. And so they will actually be able to identify a piece from the Baroque or a piece from the Romantic period. By the end of the day, 320 the day ends after your seven academic periods per day, right? Then from 330 to 530, you have the Emmett Conservatory. 330 to 530, which I consider just as important as the school education during the day.
where there'll be a series of different after-school offerings done very seriously. If there's a student who loves cello, we'll bring in a fine cello teacher to work with them. A student who loves even more math, wants philosophy of math, wants to spend, you know, a semester working on what the idea is of infinity, which is actually pretty advanced applied math, they will do that. There will be school production, school plays, but all in a kind of conservatory atmosphere, plus athletics, by the way, and some team sports. I just want to emphasize that the day will reflect the educational vision of the school, which has a number of key pillars. You know, the first, which we've been talking about, that Western civilization is majestic.
And so we built a curriculum where the study of history, the study of literature, the study of art is done in an organic way. It's one subject, the study of man as he's unfolded in the West. But what we're going to do that's different is we're going to actually make sense of the West in a uniquely Jewish way. So our entire humanities program will be reading this classical text, but it will be reading them through a Jewish lens. We'll be reading Hamlet, asking Jewish questions and drawing upon Jewish texts. And so the second pillar is that the Hebrew Bible is at the foundation of everything. And whether you're a person of religious faith or not, you can't be an educated person. You can't be an educated American. You can't be a part of Western culture without understanding the Bible.
as the foundation of our civilization. We're going to teach that in a very imaginative and interesting way. Our students will learn Hebrew and Latin, the two of the three, I'd say, crucial, Greek being the other foundational languages of the West, and we'll do it at a very high level. Our aim is that students in Hebrew are able to read serious literature by the time they graduate. And of course, we'll teach math and science at a high level, but not just as the tools of technological mastery, but also as the gateway to understanding with wonder the mysteries of the created world. And we've lost some of that. And we want to awaken in our young people a sense of wonder about the given.
world and its beauties and its mysteries and its tragedies and its possibilities. That's the deeper purpose of this education. You asked earlier, how do you form character? You form character by exposing young people to the greatest men and women who have lived and helping them see what we can learn from them. That's what we're going to try to do. So this all sounds great.
How many kids are signed up for this? How many parents are into this idea? We're starting in the fall. And by the way, this is a school that aims to be small by design. So it will be a 6th to 12th grade school. At scale, our aim is to be about 40 kids per grade. Obviously, that could grow or change, but we have a kind of Juilliard mentality. We want this to be excellent, and we want it to be a model school that serves kids that are right for this kind of education. Our core first grade is going to be sixth, and then we're going to just build it out grade by grade after that. We may open a small fifth. We may open a small ninth because there's just been a lot of interest. But the core idea is to build it up grade by grade.
Probably start with a pilot group of, you know, 15 to 26 graders, double that the following year, and then build it out systematically over the next number of years. And the other thing is that we want the school to be at the center of an intellectual community. I mean, we also have a lot of programming oriented toward parents, oriented to the community. We want Emmett to be a kind of citadel of serious Jewish, Western, and American learning. And getting parents involved is very important.
Let me just add to Liel's question regarding the day. Excuse me. Number one, no Chromebooks. If you want something in terms of detail, no Chromebooks or iPads during the day. I hear the angels saying. Manual note-taking with penmanship, including cursive. Oh, cursive. We will teach students how to curate what they hear and actually take notes. We're not against technology.
The Jewish value is something is what you make of it, right? You can sanctify it or you can degrade it. So we have no problem with giving out homework on Schoology or RenWeb or some kind of platform at night. As soon as turning it in on their computer, there will be computer science as an elective, including coding. So we're not an anti-technology place, but they should learn to write down what they hear as they hear it and study from those actual notes. I was sitting with a friend of mine who's a professor at Princeton, been there for 20 plus years. And she's saying, look, the kids are very smart, but I'm telling you in the last five or six years, my students at Princeton can't read a book.
They can't actually go from the beginning to the middle to the end of a book. And that's because the culture is a culture of permanent distraction. And part of what we want to actually do at this school is slow these young people down and actually teach them how to read again. I don't mean literally how to sound out the words, but how to read again, slowly, carefully, in search of wisdom and meaning. These are not like profound, innovative insights. These are correctives to the fact that you stick a screen in front of everybody. We think it's so cool, but it's not. All you're doing during the school day is doubling down on the distraction of the rest of the day. How is that healthy?
And I think a lot of schools are waking up to the fact that this is a problem. We're going to be very countercultural in that sense. I love that cursive is countercultural. For the 2024, 2025 school year. We're going to make cursive great again. That's it. That's going to be our new school model. We're going to have hats and everything. Let me play devil's advocate in a big way here because I love everything about this. But at the same time, I'm asking, you know, here you are and you're standing a thwart history yelling, stop. You're saying to these kids, OK, well, we're going to teach you a set of skills, which we all in this room understand are so important. And yet then they go out into a culture that overwhelmingly.
rejects this, attacks this. Is there going to be an Emmett or for Emmett grads, a sense of fight, a sense of like, okay, we're not just here protecting you in the little hothouse. We expect you to go out there into the world and charge. By the way, that's so important. Meaning, I think...
The deepest aspiration of this school, and I say it with a lot of humility, is to educate leaders, meaning people that can be leaders in culture, leaders in politics, leaders in religion, leaders in the great arenas of human life that need energy and talent and spiritedness. And so we have to educate spirited young Jews who want to defend these cherished values. It's not enough for them to just be nerds who've read books. They also have to be warriors of the mind that want to fight. And we want to educate people that have that energy and that spirit. And look, if you look at the great leaders of history, they generally spent their childhood
reading about giants, meaning giant figures, Greek mythology and Plutarch's lives, their imagination was shaped by the possibility of human excellence. And then they became excellent. Well, we've got to put in the hearts and minds of our young people again, the images of human excellence that they can emulate in their lives. And the truth, of course, is if you can understand Aristotle's metaphysics, you can learn how to code. If you can learn Latin and Hebrew at a high level, you can learn the practical skills you'll need. Our young people will be able to go into any field of human endeavor at a high level. They'll just maybe understand a little bit better what science is for and what technology is for and what the purpose of their life and their culture is for.
That's the deepest aim of this. It's not to create automatons. It's to create carriers of civilization. And that means people that are willing to stand up for these values. They will have not only the good sense to know what to create, but the even better sense to know what not to create. Yeah, that's called wisdom. That's a shockingly old idea. The purpose is to recover our inheritance so that we can actually build a future that will flourish. Do you anticipate having any non-Jewish students? Look, there's no greater advocate for the friendship between Jews and non-Jews, especially Christians, you know, who I think are comrades in arms and trying to renew the culture. I think this is a school that's devoted to Jewish formation.
I could see it actually partnering with non-Jewish classical schools in all kinds of creative ways. But I think the full-time enrolled students of Emmett are going to be coming from families. By the way, families across the Jewish spectrum. I want to emphasize that. Coming from families that buy into this vision of Jewish and American and Western civilization and want their young people to be formed as Jewish carriers of the West. That's what we're looking for. If someone's listening at home saying like, oh, I wonder if my child's right for this. What is the profile of a good candidate for Emmett? Intellectual curiosity. A student who is bright, who is curious, who comes from a family culture supporting the furtherance of those talents.
and also with a passion. It doesn't matter if the student might love athletics or theater or text or mathematics, but a student with some sort of passion that we can then grow and evolve with that student. I think the most important thing, if I had to try to put it in two words, is this is about Jewish excellence. And I think what we have, even in many of our most elite, quote-unquote, schools, that work our young people to the ground, many of them have long days, but what we have in many of these schools is exhaustion without excellence. We don't actually slow kids down enough to recognize what it's like to appreciate a great work of art.
and then learn how to perhaps produce a great work of art, understand why it matters. So we want young people that can learn to respect excellence, and they're going to be coming from families that, in a positive sense, are inspired by that, and in a negative sense, have been awakened to the fact that perhaps some of the schools they're in have a very different ethos. And however fancy the buildings, you know, it's great to have a beautiful wine bottle, but if the wine isn't so good, then the wine bottle doesn't matter. Well, the building's the bottle. We're going to have beautiful wine. We'll be in a very nice building. But what matters is the substance, and we want families that are drawn to that. Where should people who want to learn more go?
Besides to Emmett Classical Academy. No tablets in the classroom, but people are allowed to go online. They're allowed to fill out the application. You know, Emmett Classical Academy lays out very clearly the processes for seeking admission. And we're in high gear right now and evaluating students for fall of 2024. And we're really, you know, looking to likely open in fifth, sixth and possibly ninth grade next year. And so that's the key grades. But I'd say kids in any grade from fifth to ninth who are intrigued should apply because you begin a relationship that maybe will end up matriculating into fall of 2025.
One will really scale it even more. So that's how you can learn. And the website lays out very clearly the founding pillars of the school. Do you want to give the URL? The oral torah on it? No, the URL. Oh, the URL. The URL torah. I can give the URL. This is very, very fancy. It's just emetclassicalacademy.org. E-M-E-T. E-M-E-T. And the name of the school is worth maybe a second on as we close. Emmet means truth. And I think, you know, it's the Hebrew word for truth. And I think if there's anything that we've learned in the last many years is that cultures that pretend the truth isn't real.
cultures that try to live in adherence to certain kinds of falsehoods, they lose their way. And we need to make truth serious again in terms of the quest as a kind of pillar in our lives. And so we thought this was a Hebraic value of transcendent importance. And that's why the school is called Emmet. It's also easy to spell, E-M-E-T. It sounds like you spell it. You can write it in cursive. It'd look good on a sweatshirt. That's it. It'd look good on a sweatshirt. Thank you very much. Thank you.
Our next guest is Rabbi Meni Eben Israel. He leads the Steinsalt Center, whose motto is Let My People Know. The center was founded by his father, the late Rabbi Adin Steinsalt, and is dedicated to translating and explaining Jewish texts. We spoke with him about what it was like to grow up with one of the greatest Talmudic scholars ever as his dad, and about how he too now tries to make the entire world of Jewish knowledge more accessible, one page at a time. Rabbi, welcome to Unorthodox. Thank you so much for having me here. It is an absolute pleasure to have you. I'm a very big fan and a dedicated follower of your work. But to those of us who are new fans, tell us a little bit about the grand project. Mainly the Steinsall Center, which I ran for at least, I don't know, 15 years. Our main work is to make text available to everybody, reading it in as close to the original language. Sometimes Aramaic, sometimes Hebrew, sometimes whatever language we need. And they just make it accessible completely. A motto, which I think represents everything we do, is let my people know.
The purpose is everybody has the right to know. This is not a text belonged to some Orthodox rabbi with a long beard or short beard or any kind of beard, but really present this is the knowledge of the people. We believe that knowledge is the key. I always look at it as a coin, two sides of the coin. One side is let my people know, which is the positive part. The negative part of it is there was a language that was used by my grandfather describing that it's better to be unheretic than ignoramus.
When my father was about 14, maybe 16, his grandfather was not religious at all, was secular completely, communist secular Israeli of the 40s in Israel. And he told me, you have to go learn Talmud. And my father was, but why? And he said, because in our family, we have a lot of heretics. In Ramesses, never. Know what you reject. Yeah, if you reject, you reject it well. You can't just pretend that it didn't happen. And I think it's extremely important. We try to do it now on everything. My father, with a last publication in Hebrew, with the mission of publication in Hebrew, became the only commentator since the beginning of time.
who did commentary on the five elements of Jewish text, which are the Bible, the Tanakh, the Mishnah, the first book of oral law, then Talmud, then was the Rambam, the one of these book of law. And the last thing he did was the Tanya, which is the essential book on spirituality. So these five things are done in Hebrew, and I have promised him before his passing that I will do the same thing in English. Since this is very much a family story, first of all, I heard a great story about your great late father I had the privilege of meeting on several occasions, that when someone told his father. that he was you know truly and he louis sort of once in a once in a generation mind his father said something like why did it have to happen in my family absolutely growing up with a genius at home and i was only a child was not the father it's a nightmare You know, they have a different perspective of life. First of all, they remember everything, which is not all geniuses. For a kid, it's horrible. It's horrible because you can't lie. Remember you promised me a pony last week? Yeah, exactly. No. No, it was never a promise made, never. It's funny because I did, one of the years I stole Duffy Common, you know, I took Duffy Common, better language. Liberated. Liberated Duffy Common from the clutches of my father. And the goal was to get a set of Lego. It was a very big popular Lego of Knights. It was a new series logo started. I remember that very well. And in my mind, the promise was constitute every single Lego.
part of this series. You know, they're like eight or nine different. The final perspective was a bit different than that. So we had an argument about this for a couple of years. Then I gave up. By the way, what a nightmare because it's such a Talmudic argument. Right. And now you're arguing about Talmudic thought with Ravadin Steinsatz. Right. It's like, no, no, no, no. When I said Seth, Seth only refers to that. Exactly. And anything else. Yeah. And then also he, and this has seen also many other great people.
the commitment is for the world or the Jewish world. But in this case, it was really the world as a whole. And as a family, we came second. And it took me years to get over it. As I love to say to my psychologist, build a third house in Monaco. The big sign there dedicated by many, you know, clearly. Yeah, but I don't think it was a hard father or harsh. It was just not there. And at what point did you understand that it now falls onto you to continue this monumental work that you did not choose? I mean, eventually you chose, but it was sort of foisted on you. Yeah, there was not an option. My father came to our house in Christmas night, 2003.
It was very entertaining because like, you know, Santa Claus, you know, old beard. So come in and he's like, he never said any line like this before. I was a Hilo rabbi at the time in Maryland, University of Maryland. And he's like, I want you to come work with the family. I was like, okay, when? Tomorrow. I said, no, I can't do it tomorrow. It took me about a year. You're like, tomorrow's Christmas day. We have a plan for a Chinese in a movie. Come on. Right, exactly. It was Boxing Day. It took me about a year and a half to get back to Israel. He was really insistent that he'll have to come. But in the beginning when I was there, it took me time to realize what he wants and realize how much potential he's there and how much need he's there. You may think that
By now, in even 2003, we've said everything that needs to be said. There are translations. There's the internet. There are all these resources. So what need did he identify and you then came to see still very much exist? So I think there's two major needs. One is to make it accessible. Yes, there are commentaries, but if you don't write them in the right language and use different languages, more spiritual, unattainable, you need to write it for the people in their language. So, for example, if you read his text, the English always is superb. The Hebrew is very good. It's written for people who can actually read. It's not meant some kind of abstract, unattainable. It's not a PhD material.
It's really human-based material. That's one. The other need is, was to bring it to the people. It's very nice that I publish a book. You know, the rule when you publish a book is very, very simple. You can get somebody to support the book. When you explain to them that now you have to do marketing, you actually have to sell the book, that's the issue. So people can have the access. You can have, I mean, if you learn Daphioni, they have, what, 300, 500, 5,000, who knows how many classes given by anybody. And people still don't want to touch it. They're still too scary. Association with text is automatically religion. You know.
Given my look, and of course my father's look did not help the fact that we are, I have a beard, I was getting whiter, as the minute's moving on. But really we are open-minded people. That's where my father educated me. My mother is not less of an open-minded person. I spend my childhood watching Les Miserables in French. In every version of it, I saw it. I saw it, I know it. That's what education we got. So for me, I want to share the other part of my life, which is Jewish text, which is Jewish information, with everybody. And some of the stuff there is very, very cool. Since the last few months, I was questioning the idea of what makes a book holy? What makes a book an important book?
And I think the answer I came up with, a book that I can retranslate or reapply to my generation, make it holy. Therefore, in a sense, Shakespeare is a holy. Because English lit, for the last 200 years, you're learning Shakespeare. Now, can anybody debate that the story of Romeo and Juliet is not important for today? I mean, really good, amazing, romantic story is amazing. And I think that's the need. The need is people need to go and I want to give them this treasure in their hands. Is there a part to you that says, look, I'm really sorry. My father was an incredible man, but also had incredibly good luck to come on the scene at the stage where the stars were aligned just so. Mine is a different historic moment. People are losing their attention spans. They're losing their minds. They're losing their access.
I'm going to go in the opposite direction. I am going to make it accessible to the few and the proud who really want to dive deep. And I'm sorry, but there's a certain kind of barrier to entry. Dark thoughts like these, do they ever enter your mind? Always. But the main reason is because I believe in general, again, you can decide what you'll do with this. I believe that Judaism, the essence of it, was always for the few. Moses comes down from the mountain, right? He has 70 people that he's going with. Son, his brother, Joshua, and then the rest of the 70 people. Then the prophets, the individuals who kept the tradition, really.
The priests, second temple, even worse. Second temple, what do you got there? You got 20 rabbis, 20 leaders of the community who really knew what to do. Everybody else was following through and coming together for the sacrifice in the temple. Judaism in the temple wasn't the most bizarre thing, right? You came in, you saw about a great guy or small guy, whatever the size of the high priest or the regular priest, sacrificing a cow or whatever it is, ointment, whatever. But that was your religion. There was no prayer. You say shmai in the morning, shmai in the morning, that was it. Second temple destroyed, right? We're doing this amazing revolt against the Romans, which we lose tremendously.
We were not known for scholarship. We were known for our ability to be mercenaries in agriculture. That we were very famous to, which is funny because that's what we're known for today. Same idea. We've come a long way. We've come the same thing. So think in general, think Judaism. The essence of Judaism, the people who really keep it and know it and feel it and really 100% with it was always meant for the top, top, top tier of Jewish life.
That's it. There are texts where you cannot learn, even after my father's commentary. It doesn't help. You have to sit there and break your head. The same thing that you sit there and like, what the heck is this? But that's the only way. It's literally the only, only way to move forward is to understand, yes, some things you want to understand.
But most people don't understand what they're supposed to understand. By the way, as you are now a verse Talmud Chacham, and you know after you learned Talmud for so many years, some of the text in Talmud is normally attainable when you sit there with a hammer and chisel things out, and you work on it and you try to figure out what they want. Some? No, some. Some of the stuff, look, some of the stuff, I'm a big fan of prioritizing. Okay? Some stuff is easy, some stuff is more complex. Hence, you sit down there and you learn. Also, I believe people don't have patience. You're supposed to enjoy this. My father's main complaint constantly was,
How come people don't read science fiction or novels or binging as much as they do Talmud or Mishnah or any other Jewish text? Why this thing is not happy? Why is that thing not giving you joy? What's the answer? What's your answer? My answer is we screwed up, obviously. I mean, not we. We, the Jewish people who know, screwed up. I know this. I'm sure there's a better word for this. We did not give it the right proper behavior. We didn't treat it well. We kept it internally. And that is devastating. It's devastating because I'll give you a perfect story, right? There's a big debate worldwide.
about what was the shape of the menorah, the candelabra in the temple, right? You have the Chabad stench movement by Lubavitcher Rebbe. I have to mention it. Absolutely. There was a straight line, right? And then you have everybody else. It's like, dude, all the pictures, all the historical, everything we have, it's semicircle, right? That's a debate. And the real proof of this is the way you analyze one word, kane. Kane is a straw or a staff or a pipe, whatever it is. It seems that the word, little translation, is a straight line. That's a little translation, okay? So, rabbis or historical...
archaeological, can argue this for years. I had to find an answer. I went to my neighbor in Jerusalem. A guy was, very odd guy, was very not religious, really living next door to us. After his wife passed away, he started to learn Bible.
So I came to him and asked him, because he's definitely going to have a different perspective. He never went to Jewish education. And asked him, what does the word kanemi mean? What is the word, literally, you said straight lines, a staff. You hold it. You need to be straight. You can hold. But that is opinion of somebody who doesn't know. But he's reading it from fresh eyes. There's nothing greater than teaching somebody who never learned Talmud. You take one of your favorite texts, whatever it is, in the Talmud, and you teach them for five minutes this cool idea. And you're like, you know, you see the jaw opening, opening, opening. Like, yeah. Then you try to explain the answers. And that's the coolest thing. But if you don't...
If you're not going to open your eyes to it, you're going to be back, again, be the book of the religious people. Mind you, the fact that it's also 44 volumes doesn't help. 2,711 pages? It's not the best. No, not the best. You know, one of my dreams, and probably we're going to do it the next couple of years, we're going to do the anthology of the Talmud, of the top 100 pages. You can choose anything you like. These are the 100 pages we chose, okay? People can read one book now instead of 44, and maybe they will enjoy it, and then we'll have a great time of it, understanding it and comprehending it. But that's the goal. The goal is to get people to understand this is their text. Okay, so...
Before I let you go, you have a bunch of people here listening right now who are very, shall we say, Talmud adjacent. People who are curious, want to learn. Give us all homework. Give us one thing that you want us to do right now to make our lives a little bit more Talmudic. The first thing is take the Talmud as a whole and pick the section and become yours. One section. It doesn't have to be all 2711 pages. Pick one page that you leave with that text. My favorite track is Talmud. A, because it's the shortest. It's eight pages. And two, because it's the most eclectic stories. You know the story about the princess and the...
Pi and a P. It's in the Talmud. And it's like, hilarious, it's there, but that's not my favorite. Favorite is the story of Alexander the Great. And in fact, the Talmud talks about it, that he's going to go, he's going to Africa to meet the Amazons. It's a mind-boggling story. I love this track just because of it. I don't know if everything's as exciting. Pick something and become yours. You live with the Talmud. And you can make art from it. You can make a movie from it. You can make a TikTok from it. There's a variety of them already. Live with it. And don't be embarrassed to ask questions. And more so, understand that the Talmud is not a sealed book. And I'll end with this.
The Bible is a sealed book. Took time till we sealed it. Took time till the rabbi decide what time we're going to seal it, what's in, what's out. And then they took, of course, other thing in. But they sealed the Bible around, let's say, second century. It was clear what's in, what's out, right? The Mishnah is the same thing. The Rambam is the same thing. The Tanya is the same thing. Many other books are the same thing. Talmud never ended. And your commentary is as good as mine, as good as anybody else. The way you read it, the way you explain it, even to yourself, it's yours. And you can write your own commentary. I mean, please don't publish it. We have enough of those.
Buy timeouts and put the notes on the side. But I'm saying you can write whatever you want, which is not sacrilegious. You're not getting to a religious issue. It's yours. Play with it. That's the beauty of it. And that is my recommendation to everybody. Pick a part. Make it yours. Baruch Hashem. Rabbeinu. Thank you so much for being our guest.
All right, time for some mazel tovs. Liel, will you kick us off? Yes, I have a warm, warm mazel tov to super listener, Zippy Pearl Turner. She writes, I have a mazel tov. My daughter, Sarah Kalanith Turner, just got engaged to David Greenfield. Hooray to David, to Sarah Kalanith, and to Zippy. Mazel tov to you, our dear, dear friend in Arizona. And producer Josh Cross jumps right in to tell us that it is also Zippy's birthday. So Zippy.
Mazel Tov from all of us here at An Orthodox. We love you. Happy, happy. We got to give a Mazel Tov to Gal Gadot, who recently gave birth to a baby girl. So Mazel Tov, Gal, we love you. Wonder baby. Wonder girl number four, I believe. And many of you may remember the segment we did with Rabbi Alana Garber, who told us about her journey with her son's fragile X diagnosis. We are so excited to wish him a Mazel Tov on becoming a bar mitzvah this past weekend. We're so proud of you and Mazel Tov to the whole family.
This is awkward. I was going to, I don't know if you heard, but Zone of Indifference won the Oscar for Best International Feature. I was going to shout out Jonathan Glazer, but it just doesn't feel right at this point. It's actually Zone of Interest, but I love how to call it Zone of Indifference. Zone of Indifference. That's a movie I would actually watch. Maybe that's a reflection of my, yeah, I didn't bother to watch it. That is the opposite of the online chatter, yes. The banality, yeah, whatever. The banality of maybe. Zone of Indifference.
Until next week, shalom, friends. Well done. Hi, Edith. This is Phil. Your mommy just played me a little tape of you reading along with the book Just Tried. I'm so proud of you. You sound like you are very open-minded and you'll try lots of things. I hope you try lots of things in your life, Edith, and that you like most of them. You don't have to like all of them, but I'm so happy that you just tried, Edith. Good for you. Feel like you know enough to start your own podcast? We get it. Feel like you don't know enough to start investing yet? We got you. Cooperators. Get investments, insurance, and advice from someone who gets you.
Terms and conditions apply.