Skip to content
Is The Digital Platforms Inquiry A Big Stick? episode artwork

Jul 31, 2019 49 min

Is The Digital Platforms Inquiry A Big Stick?

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

In our second look at the ACCC Digital Platforms Inquiry, we dig deeper into what it may mean for the Australian media. To help us do this we chat with Derek Wilding, the Co-Director for the Centre for Media Transition at UTS and Sacha Molitorisz Directorial Research fellow also from the CMT.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Is The Digital Platforms Inquiry A Big Stick?

0:00 49:23
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Safer Ontario.

Pay for by the Government of Ontario. Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from TSCR in Sydney.

I'm Gaggle Lands of the Ora Nation right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey and I am the Co-Director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology. Sydney, am I producer today, is as ever the wonderful Anthony Dockrell. Normally on this show we talk to journalists about journalism, as I just said.

But for the second time in as many shows, I'm going to make an inception. Why? Because in this podcast special, we are going to further explore the recently released report into Facebook and Google by the Competition Watch.com, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. At 619 pages, the digital platforms inquiry is not for the faint-hearted, but as we speak, it's probably the world's most comprehensive look at the market power of Facebook and Google and what potentially to do with that.

It comes with 23 recommendations including no less than four proposed new industry codes and covers everything from privacy, data protection, digital copyright, fake news, media literacy, industry regulation, data portability, the imbalance during the platforms and media business and suggestions for financial support for journalism with grants and tax breaks. You can check out my earlier interview with Rod Sims, the ACCC chair, on to a CR and its partner broadcasters or via your favorite podcast app. Just search for Fourth Estate. That show is mainly about what the inquiry has to say about journalism and its relationship with Google and Facebook.

And one of the key ideas is a proposed new industry code which will compel financial payments from the platforms to journalism for the use of news content. And that goes to what the news media industry has been saying for some time to Google and Facebook, which is essentially, give us some money back for using our content for you a lot to make so much money. The ACCC is giving the platforms nine months to work with the news industry to create an acceptable code that, quote, treats news businesses fairly. But if they can't agree, it says another regulator, the Australian Communications and Media Authority, which will obviously the code can step in and force the platforms to be fair.

So there is a promise of a carrot and a bloody big stick. We will see how all that plays out and in the end of the day, it all rests with the federal government, whether they accept all the recommendations from the ACCC report, some or none. So far, the noises from the Treasurer, Josh Frydenberg have been very much in the favor of the ACCC and journalism as well. But as I mentioned, there is plenty more to talk about in the digital platforms inquiry, in particular the ACCC's ideas on data, privacy, and how to regulate this crazy, converged media landscape where the power has shifted from publisher to consumer to platform.

So in the manner of who wants to be a millionaire, I've called in some friends to help me sift through the inquiries of recommendations and what they may or may not mean for us as consumers and we as an industry. So welcome to the show, Derek Wilding, the co-director of the Center for Media Transition at UTS. Thank you for having me Peter. It's lovely to see you.

And session, well, it's a journal turned academic who also has the wonderfully exalted title of the post-doc research fellow at the aforementioned Center Hello, session. Hi, Peter. Welcome, doctors, I should say. So yes, I know this is all a bit in-house and I know it's a bit of a sausage fest, but frankly, I couldn't think of any two people better qualified to talk about the ACCC digital platforms inquiry than you two.

So not least because the CMT helped out that ACCC on this inquiry with some background research. And I should add that it's gained funding from both Google and Facebook. So I guess we are kind of equal opportunity offenders. So let's start with some overall impressions, Derek.

I mean, you've worked in and around media regulation and media reform for much of your wonderful career, which is only not even half over, let's face it. What do you make of the thrust of the digital platforms inquiry? What does it get right? What does it kind of miss?

I think the starting point is to say what an incredible resource it is that it brings together so much. I mean, and indeed some things that we didn't know before. So the ACCC is not just looked at what's on the public record. They've used their investigation powers to go out and acquire information that the rest of us didn't have access to.

They've done some original analysis. So this very long report actually I think helps establish the state of play in a number of different areas. And it's more far reaching in that way than similar work that's going on. Obviously, so that's an incredible effort.

Overall, it's difficult to get a handle on it in a way because it covers so much ground. So it covers competition law, which is so different from consumer privacy issues. And that's so different from copyright or from media content issues. And it's covering all of those.

And it's taking a different approach in those different areas. It's hard to say, OK, this is the score overall because you really need to assess what its recommendation is. We will drill in. We will drill down on that.

Just to say with you for a second, Derek, the ACCC started out 80 months ago. And it's sort of we thought looking at the news media business and how it could rebalance the relationship with the platforms. As you say, it's not much deeper than that. In that specific area, do you think they've got that right?

They're getting there. I mean, people have different views on it. I think the most interesting aspect in a sense is how they characterize what digital platforms are now. So they have got closer to the publisher model in terms of how they characterize them.

So they talk about the media-like functions of digital platforms. And they talk about how the impact the platforms are having on the news and journalism environment. So I think... So why is it important that they got closer to the publisher just for the listeners to explain that?

OK. Well, I think if you start out thinking, if you ask the question, do we need some kind of regulation here? You need some kind of category or some kind of class. By which you, how you characterize these particular service providers in order to say, OK, well, we're going to regulate them in this way.

So that raises the question then, well, are they the equivalent of media companies? And so a certain set of obligations arises as a result. Or are they something different from that? And I guess before all of this started, the assumption was that they're just kind of intermediaries.

And some people were saying, some people in the news media business say, no, they're not. They're publishers and they should have the obligations of publishers. The ACCC landed in between those two. But I do think it's getting closer to the publisher category than the peer intermediary.

It's useful that they use this term content creator. And I think maybe personally, I think that's kind of critical to it, that platforms are not, at least in the news and journalism area, they're not content creators. So my view, they shouldn't have the same obligations that publishers have, news and journalism publishers have. But that doesn't mean that they should have no obligations.

And so what the ACCC is really achieving here is helping us to steer a course through this and say, OK, well, given all these different things they do, in each of these areas, let's work out what are their obligations. And the ACCC has by no means actually got us to that point of saying these are the obligations, and this is how it should be done. And a number of areas, they're saying, actually, this is the path to get us to the analysis of these codes. I mean, of course, it does depend on whether the federal government accepts their definition.

And then shines it in some form, a legislative reform, assuming it has to come out of a lot of this. Yeah, absolutely. And it was really interesting, I think, that when this report was launched on Friday, Josh Friedenburg, the Treasurer, was saying, was actually describing the value of news and journalism within society, and describing it as an essential public good, which does, I think, really help with that, getting us to that point of saying, OK, there is something special here. We're prepared to recognize that it has a function over and beyond, say, manufacturing of cars or some other kind of consumer good.

There's something here that has got this inherent kind of social value to it, and there's a problem with the business model for creating it. So it's in this environment where there's now these very dominant players that are affecting how you produce that good. So we're prepared to actually recognize its value and step in. Yeah, that's a really good point.

I'm bringing you in, Sash. I mean, both you and I used to work in the C-Mong Herald. As we all know, we're through a massive digital transformation, still in it in many ways. But if we go back, say, or eight, nine, ten years ago, it wasn't that it was quite common for the leaders of that company to talk about essentially equating journalism with a kind of widget.

We were there making content. Well, and it's really indicative of how that debate has moved in this last decade to what Derek just said, that even the treasurer, the liberal treasurer, thinks we were a bit more than just widget makers. Does that give you some sort of warming a glow? It does, I guess.

I mean, there's been that realization all along that news and journalism has some sort of significance. It has a real public good element, but it did get lost a little bit along the way and it's coming to the fore again. I think that seems to be the feeling. So it is great.

I agree with Derek, that it's great to see that recognized so explicitly and strongly in this report. You're going to talk about proscing a minute, but I just what's your overall take on this report? We've been waiting for this for a long time. Yeah.

Look, I've been very impressed all the way along with how the ACCC has handled this inquiry over 18 months. You know, the extent to which it consulted with various groups, the number of submissions it received, the depth and detail of those submissions. The preliminary report back in December was a very impressive substantial piece of work. And now this piece of work is even bigger, at 619 pages.

So there's a lot to digest and there's still a lot to compare between the first preliminary report and this one to see what is different between the two. So this will still need some time really to get a head around. I think there's a few things to have gone missing in between the prelim and this one. I mean, one thing to concentrate on my mind is the preliminary report suggested that there should be tax breaks for a subscriber, which has got lost.

Why is that? Look, I can't say maybe there was a strategy there that the ACCC went hard. It's preliminary reports, I can pull back a little bit. I think that's a different somewhere I think that there's a difference between media that has a subscription model and media that doesn't rely on a subscription model.

So it just relies on an advertising model and if you're giving the break to consumers who are paying the subscription, then you're helping that part of the industry and not the other part of the industry. So, you know, they've clearly noticed a few of those additional aspects in this period between the preliminary report and the final report. But just, I don't know just how convincing it is that in fact you shouldn't try some of those things because there may be some distortion is, I mean, I kind of question that. The other aspect of the tax offsets for the production of journalism.

I know, yeah, sure, there are some problems around actually identifying who it is that gets that. And so you don't give it to say an entire publication or entire broadcasting operation because they do a whole range of things that are not public interest journalism. But it does strike me that there must be a way of actually characterizing something like public interest investigations, which has been a big one this weekend around Crown. And we know that there are lots of examples of those.

If we can, in the academic world, we can say, okay, well, this kind of research project is deserving of this kind of support. And we say that in film with Screen Australia, we say that in theatre and literature with the Australia Council. And we can find criteria to actually identify a particular work that we want to support. It's a bit puzzling as to why you can't actually isolate something if not everything that might help.

Well, it's not just on that point in sticking there because one of the things that did survive was this idea of making it easier. And so I think it's a very important thing to find really, but making it easier for news media to get charitable status. And when I asked Rod, it seems a similar question to what you've just been exploring there. Does that mean every news media organisation gets it?

He said, yeah, well, it's still work to be done because as we all know, news media is a very broad church and parts of say the Daily Mail, it concentrates on cats, up trees and Kardashians, but it also does what you might call them more serious journalism. But nonetheless, does the Daily Mail get treated the same way as the financial review or the Australian or the same one Harold or whatever? What do you think about that? Is it impossible to, that should we give everyone the text break?

If the Daily Mail can, at some point in the future, point towards some kind of activity that is deserving of that kind of classification, then I don't see why it shouldn't be eligible. But I mean, there's two aspects, aren't there? There's one. One is you've got to get the criteria which is able to identify what the work is.

But then you've also got to have on this particular proposal, then you've got to have someone that's prepared to make and fill a philanthropic donation for that particular entity. And that's different from, if it was through the tax system, whereby you do it, you meet the criteria and then you can claim the tax break. You've actually got to find the donor as well. Yes, when I asked for RODSims about that, I asked him any idea from Treasury or Finance, the numbers.

He said they were quite small, so I think you're probably right. Let's move back to you, Sash, privacy. We're all waiting for your very excellent book. Thank you.

In the meantime, Recommendation 16 goes to the heart of the matter. It's not strong privacy act provisions. Right, well, to start, what I'd say here is the ACCC wasn't really asked to look into privacy. It wasn't what asked to look into the impact of digital platforms on news and advertising.

On media and advertising, I think that was the phrase. And so should they have looked into privacy? Well, I think once we think about today's media ecosystem more comprehensively, it's a great thing that they did. And they needed to.

Privacy is just such a big issue. And it gets to the very heart of the issue here about market power of these digital platforms. The data that these platforms have that gives them all their power. That's the deal.

Right. We get the services for free with hooks across the word free, and they get our data. Exactly, exactly. So I commend the ACCC on taking privacy so seriously, making it such a big part of their investigation.

And then on coming up with these really strong recommendations, realizing as they do in their recommendations, that privacy is totally inadequately protected at the moment. And those protections need to be beefed up. And also in Recommendation 17, it kind of has this sort of Cambridge analytical moment, and then that flows into this overhaul, the ACT proposal. We were talking about getting rid of some of the exemptions for things like political parties and the identification of information.

So no more pseudos. Right. What's going on there? Well, there's a whole lot of detail in these recommendations that is all really geared towards having a more comprehensive set of legal privacy protections.

Currently they're wafel inadequate. So yes, the Privacy Act will be according to these recommendations, the Privacy Act should be improved and strengthened. But apart from that, there needs to be a much broader reform of privacy law. And I think Australia, like other countries, is just screaming out for it.

Yeah, I mean, look, one of the kind of overarching themes of this whole report is that in a sense, we've all been a little bit asleep. You know, we look at the numbers of the penetration of people on Facebook. Everywhere you look, you know, this massive penetration, 17, between 17, 90 million users a month, depending on which platform you're looking at, and then all the subsidiary platforms offered. So are we all going to sleep at the way on this sort of stuff?

Well, to some extent. But what I think works so well here is that privacy is brought into this whole larger question, all these digital platforms, how they operate, what their effect is on consumers. And as a result, from this report, we can see that we can't think about the news media, for instance, or we can't think about other issues to do with digital platforms without taking into account privacy, because we need to realize that that's the fundamental way that these digital platforms operate. It's almost a cliché to say now that data is in New oil.

I thought it was a new Bitcoin, but anyway, so let's go on to another matter. So you, Sash, myself to some extent, although I'm not my strong suit, I have to say in Derek, we all sweated on the media regulations framework part of this, and we've thought about this, talked about it a bit about it. I know that sounds about as exciting as eating tensaios all at once, but it does go to the heart of the digital world we live in and how it operates. Derek, what do you think?

I mean, is the HOPC going right here, or did it not go far enough on the suggestions around a new framework? Well, I don't see why it's boring as each of us. I'm a co-author. Thank you, Mr.

Sash, and myself. You're a brand person. Thank you so much. What was the question?

Media regulations. We live in a converged world. Does this adequately recognize the converged world? We have a set of frameworks, regulations now, which get us in all sorts of tangles.

It doesn't really adequately realize the world that we live in is a converged world where a broadcaster is a website provider, a newspaper is a radio station, etc. The HOPC has gone into this tricky territory, which is recognizing that, yes, we might get the same content via many different platforms, and why do we have these different regulations that apply depending on how you get it as opposed to what the content is. The HOPC is by no means the first to raise that. In some ways, it's been under discussion for a couple of decades, but certainly it was on the agenda with the convergence review a few years ago, and the ACMA has pointed to some of these issues the Department of Communications has done so, and now the actual sees there.

So it's challenge, I think, is in this concept of developing something that is platform neutral, and what do you do? How do you get to a position where you've got some rules that might make sense across different platforms without necessarily making everything, eradicating the differences that need to be there? So they do say that they're not seeking to get a uniform environment, but they're seeking to get an environment where, like providers or like content is treated the same as much as possible. And I suppose where they don't, that's as far as they get.

So they don't go, what's beyond that? What does that actually mean? Yes, they tell us what we can already knew in a way. Yeah, that's right.

So, yeah. It's kind of no man's like that. That's right. So does that return?

This is the eternal question about what do you do about Netflix? If it's getting a lot of attention, audiences are moving from, to some extent, from television to streaming services, Netflix doesn't have those obligations like, as content, Australian content, and children's content, the broadcasters do. They still got to do that, and it's expensive, and it doesn't necessarily generate the audiences certainly in terms of children's content. What do you do about that?

Do you impose new regulations on the providers like Netflix? Or do you remove the obligations that apply to free web broadcasters? So if you're king of the world, what would you do? Well, I'm very reluctant to remove all obligations, but I can see what's called this regulatory imbalance, this disparity that's there.

So there's this question about how you redefine your policy priorities, or how do you do it? And so there's a lot of discussion about do you, for example, remove the broadcast quotas and come up with a financial obligation that, and the broadcasters would continue to have a financial obligation, but then you'd also impose that kind of obligation on providers like Netflix. So there's a lot of merit in that. But maybe the answer is somewhere in the middle, something or one, or something of the other.

But the question is, does that apply in the same way to Google or to... That's a great question. Which is a different again from Netflix. Of course.

And we'll just, in the same vein as that question, one place to aid didn't go, although it may yet go in these codes that have to be negotiated between the platforms and news media. But one place it didn't explicitly go was this kind of idea of content tax on the platforms. Why do you think it stopped at that? Because that was really, that was what the, if you were going to play to the crowd as in, play to the journalists, that was item number one.

Along with break up Google and Facebook, which would have been item 1.2. Well, listening to Rod Simms talk on your show the other day, he said very clearly that's still very much open. His recommendation is still very nicely open. The idea for that sort of content, Levy.

But it wasn't explicit. No, it could arise from the code of color. But in any event, I suppose they didn't set out to solve the Netflix problem. I've probably, I've taken this there because we're talking about the principle of it.

But they are looking at news, principally at news and journalism, not say drama and entertainment. But the same solution gets applied to the Netflix, you know, tax, Netflix in some way. So that content can be used to make Australian progress. Yes.

The same principle. Yeah. Essentially, I mean, just on that question, I know, I mean, in a sense it would have been impossible to do this. But it would have been very popular with certain groups to have broken up Facebook and Google.

HPC could they've done that? And does it matter that they haven't? Well, you know, I'm a very cautious person. I mean, to some extent, I think I can't see the argument for that in the environment in which we exist.

And to certain extent, regulators have had the opportunity to watch these things as they've developed. They've seen these acquisitions and there hasn't been action taken to this point. So absolutely, I can see the justification in the competition based recommendations for any future acquisitions. That in fact, you might scrutinize them more carefully.

You might take into account as they're suggesting potential consolidation or potential ramifications down the track that don't apply right now. And you might in future stop something like the acquisition of WhatsApp by Facebook in the future. But as to the point of actually calling for divestment, then in our environment, I think I find that quite hard to support in principle, given where we are. But of course, there's the practicality of it.

I mean, how could you investigate? How in Australia could you demand that that happen? Yeah, I agree. But this is with noting the more radical suggestion by some academics that these companies should be put into public ownership.

They shouldn't be in private hands. Are you one of those sorts of academic sessions? I can't say no. I find it a very interesting argument.

I think, you know, A, it's extremely unlikely. And B, I'm not sure that's the right way to approach it. I was taken by the view when Fairfax, for instance, complained about Facebook. I think, you know, I wonder what they would say if someone in Fairfax has thought, oh, let's start this thing that does basically the same functions as Facebook.

I mean, that would have solved the whole problem for the news media industry because they thought about Facebook before Facebook did. On the competition aspect, I guess, such a point before to the point about market power and data area. And so what is really important about this is that it's looked through all of this evidence. And it's actually come to a conclusion that both Facebook and Google, those two in particular, have market power in two or three different markets within Australia.

So there's a sense of full record that is now established and clearly the case. What the actual city doesn't do, and probably, you know, this is good that it's still this kind of middle course, is that it's not said that, okay, those two firms have misused their market power in these specific ways. And as a result, action needs to be taken. But it's established that, in fact, this is the case that there is no denying the fact that in relation to search and in relation to news feed, social media and so on, there's these two have this position.

That means that it's perfectly reasonable in a public policy sense that they are scrutinized very closely. Yeah, and to that point, I think they were they made a very clear point of putting the big numbers in the report just for the record here. Over 19.2 or a million Australians who's Google search a month, 17.3 million news Facebook, 17.6 watch YouTube, which is owned by Google course and then 0.2 million access Instagram. And then there's one.

I mean, they're incredibly one thing I put to Rod Sims was, so are they just doing something that people love and should we just let them alone get doing things that people love? Yes, they're letting people do what they love, but no, they should not be left alone because they can be also sort of unethical practices and dodgy practices. So to bring it back to privacy, I guess, on this point, one of the other recommendations we haven't mentioned yet to do with essentially versions of consumer law, bringing in versions of consumer law to apply to privacy practices. And that's something I'm a big believer in having a my research into privacy as well.

So it specifies the agency specifies a prohibition against unfair contract terms and that was recommendation 20 and then in recommendation 21, a prohibition against certain unfair trading practices. Now, these things sound really elementary. They sound so obvious that why we've been talking about them. But the fact is when it comes to privacy, those standards haven't been applied.

They need to apply and that point needs to be made very explicit. So we're in a whole new world here on that. Yeah, I mean, it should be elementary, but it hasn't been, so yes, we are. So come back to recommendations.

Recommendation 14 explores the idea of the platforms should do more on what they call credibility signaling, which isn't the virtue signaling that the Australian News It's forms of, if you like, digital branding or algorithmic use to identify content reliability, trustworthiness and other kind of factors. What do you think about that? There's sort of trust, kind of enhancing trust in journalism kind of. Yeah, I think that that has potential, but we don't really know how much potential it has, but it has.

It feels good. It does feel good. And it's, I think to the extent that it promotes verification techniques and fact checking and trust factors and so on, then that's great. So that should be fair.

Google and Facebook and others are actually taking a fair bit of action in that area themselves. They have invested in that. This is, I suppose, taking one step further, but not two steps. So two steps would be to actually require them to do that in a regulatory sense and imposing penalties if they don't do that.

This is a recommendation that the regulator actually monitor what they're doing and report on it, which seems like, particularly for the subject matter, what we're talking about here, this, this, this, this, this, compatibility signaling actually seems like a reasonable approach to say, okay, all right, so let's have some oversight some reporting, but don't intervene too strongly here because actually there are some things that are being done that are quite valuable, whether that's the trust indicators or first draft news or other kinds of fact checking that they're good, they're good initiatives. So let's just kind of have some transparency of that and some reporting on it. So yeah, that's a worthwhile aspect. Yeah, absolutely.

And so actually don't quite want to trust. Look, I have an end. I've been really heartened that trust was really big theme with the ACCC's report here. It comes up again under data and privacy.

This notion of users needing to be able to trust the way their data is being handled. And it really is crucial. We know all sorts of philosophers and various other academics have just written about the value of trust, the importance of trust, and showing the link between high trusting societies and thriving societies. So we know that societies where trust reigns are societies that really work well.

And we have a problem with trust at the moment. Do you think fixing trust on the platforms will also fix trust the trust problem with news media? Because let's not shy away from this. We have a trust issue in news media as I work in other workers show.

Yes, I think they're connected. I think they're deeply connected. And I think we have this very complicated media ecosystem now. And there is a problem with trust in different ways with Facebook compared to with news media say.

So digital platforms and news media, they're not identical, but there is a trust issue with both. And if we address trust with one, we will hopefully also help build trust in the other. But there are trust issues with both. We need to work on them.

Okay. We'll room for a few more questions. But Derek, you've traveled the world talking about media regulation, media reform, these sorts of things. How do you, with that sort of hat on with that view on, how do you think this report, how influential do you think this report will be in the, you know, on the planet as well?

People looking at Australia for leadership here or by default, by leadership. Yeah. Well, it certainly has got a lot of attention already. So as you said, it's been going on I think for about 18 months now.

So the first round with the draft report got attention. Rod seems personally has been recognized for the work of the commission. When I was at a conference towards the end of last year, even then people were paying attention to it. Which was at the regulatory conference.

Very nice. Thank you. The one in Berlin. I'm going no fair.

And then I went to one in Washington this year, which was a gathering of, you know, a lot of people are involved both in regulation and policy. And so, yeah, people are aware of what the actual C is doing because it fits within this international environment. So the UK government has issued its online harms white paper, which looks at a number of these issues, but a number of other aspects. I think you mentioned at the start the Ken Cross review of journalism in the UK, which is doing something similar to the ACCC.

I'll just come back to that in a moment. But in a way, the strength of the ACCC and what, from my observation, what people have said about it in the context of those other, knowing what as they do, what's happening in their own jurisdictions, is that the ACCC has taken this approach that covers competition law as well as copyright and privacy. So there are a number of different people watching it. That is a drawback in a way, as well, I suppose, in that it's not directly transferable elsewhere because this activity around different domains and they're all related to our peculiar frameworks within Australia.

I wouldn't expect it to be picked up and applied somewhere else, but at the same time, the thinking that's, and the evidence gathering, is an important part on this international work that's being done. On that Ken Cross point, I think it's gone the other way now. So the Ken Cross review reported a few months ago, and the business code, the code that the ACCC is now proposing about how the platforms were required to have codes that they registered with the ACMA that they're kind of governed their dealings with news media. That's something that is quite similar to what Ken Cross has proposed.

So clearly, this thinking that's happening in different countries around the world is actually quite productive in the elements of the best of everywhere are available for others to consider. I'm kind of slightly unfair question for you, but let's put our boots, our collective feet into the shoes of Google and Facebook. What do you think they would be thinking about this? Well, I think there's not, well, you raised the question about should there be a recommendation for divestment?

And so clearly, the kind of, the nuclear option hasn't been proposed. So they'd be happy about that. They'd be happy about that. They'd be happy, I think, that the idea that was being floated about an algorithm's regulator, which might require them, if it were possible anyway, to reveal confidential information to a regulatory authority is not being proposed.

So they'd be happy about that. However, there are so many different areas of recommendation here that, in fact, suddenly, I think, the regulatory framework within which they work is being beefed up across the board. Or there's the potential for it, depending on how the government reacts to it. So it's a lot more work for them.

There's obligations that could potentially come in across a range of different areas. But that's probably one of those costs of business, and it won't send them out of business. Maybe the areas that I'm not so involved in are the ones that are actually the most significant for them, which is data management and privacy and what they can do on that front, because it's unclear to me just how significant those are and how they affect their business practices. The other aspects that we've been talking about here, they're manageable.

There are a number of players in the Australian environment that have to comply with a whole range of obligations like this. It's not unreasonable that we would expect these players to be satisfied. And perhaps it's illustrative that they haven't gone crazy in their response to the FIFRA, in fact, and partly said much, and said they're going to cooperate with these various consultations and they're going to continue. And to that point, the algorithmic cancel.

I'm glad to raise that, because that was a big E in the preliminary report, and it seems to have... It's still there, but it's not there in that kind of explicit way it was in the preliminary report. Is that really thing about that, Sasha? Well, I was quite impressed with the initial preliminary recommendation for the algorithmic oversight.

I'd hate to see that. I think they've done, in terms of the news media business, I think there's a provision that the news media providers will have to be told of changes before, which was also something that the cancels going to do. I think they've come some way, they just haven't established this. That was a really good observation, I think, about the impact upon news and journalism of those algorithm changes can be so profound, more so than just for a business in another area of the economy, because of the fact of the public good and that it's...

And I'm looking at a bus feed, but basically, as business model was, I think it was 1.70% of its people coming to bus feed, same people coming to bus feed, were going to the context with Facebook. It was the single biggest, most important thing, and then they changed the algorithm and they could get there. So we know what's happened. So anyway, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm interrupted with all that.

No, I was just... I guess if I think about the issues here, there are some recommendations that are peculiarly Australian and quite specifically Australian, and there are others that really are international in their scope, and privacy is really ultimately largely international. We need to think about privacy in global terms. These are multinational companies operating all around the world, Google and Facebook, of course.

And so what we get now, it doesn't really make sense for laws of countries to be vastly out of line. There needs to be some sort of global consistency. It doesn't mean every country needs to have exactly the same privacy laws, I don't think, but there needs to be some sort of level of global acknowledgement of this issue and what needs to be done. And I think the tech companies have started saying this as well.

There needs to be some sort of global solution when it comes to privacy laws. So the model that's most often cited now is the European one, the General Data Protection Regulation, and just some observations on that. Which in some ways the ACCC is taking some steps towards in some of its recommendations. But it has now been enforced in Europe for a year or so, and it's still very unclear.

And having spoken to a good lawyer who's a good friend, there are still a lot of problems. Even companies don't really understand how the details of how it operates, the difference between a data processor and a data controller, and those sort of really significant details. So look, we need to think in a global context. That's going to be hard, but it's not impossible, and it will take some time.

And I think what this report does really well is take that global context into account. As Rod seems to keep saying, he's in touch with all the equipment bodies overseas. I think that's really important. Yeah, no, he travels more than Derek.

My final question is everyone. My final question. Let's look into the crystal ball and let's look forward to say 80 months. So all these codes have been consultation process.

The federal government is largely back to the ACCC report. The codes are now in place. Acme has got these new teeth. ACCC has got this new digital branch.

All these things are in place, and the platforms are playing nicely, or nicer. So what do we see, Derek and Sasha? What do we see? What does our picture?

How Rosie, I mean is journalism saved in 80 months since that's going to happen? What sort of world are we going to be living in if the ACCC report flows through as it flows through? Well, maybe I'll deal with that if. No, no, no.

The big, the higher question to Sasha. So at least on the media side, on the media framework, there was to be a review, and that's changed in this final report to what the ACCC calls a process as deemed appropriate by government for moving to this kind of harmonised media or converged media regulatory environment. And it's hard to know what that means. It's been something that's been on the cards for some time.

But there's a fairly big task, but important task there, which is looking not just at these aspects, but because the ACCC, for example, hasn't looked at into aspects like responding to violent content like the response to Christchurch. So there are other components, even though they've been wide-ranging, there are some things that they haven't looked into. Of course, their brief doesn't extend to telecommunications and so on. And there's a bigger task there which is reforming that communications regulatory environment.

So there's a question first of all about whether these content issues are tried, we try to solve them on their own, whether they fit within that kind of bigger reform process. So if it's that bigger reform process, 18 months from now to the rebirth of journalism is maybe a bit hopeful. No, no, no, I think you point, there's a lot to be done. And even though there's 6,000, 19 pages, there's a whole other 6,000, 19 pages waiting out there to be written.

Sasha? Well, I'm an atron optimist, I guess. These are just very significant recommendations and they point us in the right direction, where if they're adopted, news media and journalism has a better chance of doing the job it needs to do in supporting democracy. And also, people's data isn't exploited, where people are engaging with these services on a more fair level, where their data is being used in a way that's more transparent and more fair.

So that's all I would hope that these recommendations are implemented and that leads to an environment where there's more fairness in the way people's data is being used and the way these transactions go on. Journalism and news media gets a nice boost. Yeah, that same principle probably applies in the journalism area, that kind of harm principle because some of what underpins these recommendations is the do-no harm to journalism, which is, I guess, that business code, that code of practice about the relationship between the platforms and the news media, that is possibly the most important of the recommendations in that field. Because if that is drafted in such a way that it really does require some serious thinking about that and that that code of practice is only registered by the ACMA if it's got strong protections in it, then those kinds of practices like sudden changes that really dramatically to algorithms that dramatically affect news should start to disappear from this environment.

And not to mention also the potential for more money to flow into. Exactly. And not the only one I said before about the timeframe. Some initiatives like that are obviously possible within our existing regulatory framework.

Those kinds of codes can be developed. We have the regulator there, the ACMA that's been working with these kinds of processes as well as service providers for many years. So even if we don't have the full review of the communications framework, some of these suggestions are able to be advanced, you would think within that time for your team too. Well, on those two very positive notes, what's about all we have time for?

Thank you very much for your time. Thanks very much. And thank you all for listening to Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of TUICI and heard across the country on the community radio network.

And make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media politics and everything in between at your leisure. We'll be back very soon with much more on the Fourth Estate, but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter where our handle is Fourth Estate AU. And many thanks to my producer Anthony Dockall, my name is Peter Bray and thank you very much for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 49 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on July 31, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.