Welcome to Four Guys in Comic. Here are your hosts, Four Guys in Trust, and we're protecting New York Realm, Red, Rusty, Tap, and Noah. Welcome everyone to another edition of Four Guys in Comic, and we are excited to be here with you today, and glad you're able to join us. Speaking of joining us, I have with me, Nova.
Nova. Hey, how's it going? I'm here in Canada. It's so cold, and you know how it is, it's winter, you leap for work at night, and you come home after work, and it's night again.
It's a wonderful time of the year. Oh man, and of course we also have with us Rusty. Rusty, how's it out in there, Texas? It is hot.
It's kind of ridiculous. Usually it's really cold by now. Even sometimes we'll even have a snow by now or something. It hasn't, at night it gets down to about 55, and during the day it's still 77.
Wow. We had an 85 day last week. It was ridiculous. Wow, that is warm.
Oh my goodness. I think it's snow. I instantly don't know why I think Emma Frost. Gotta love Emma Frost.
You like it when she turns into diamonds, right? Oh yeah, who doesn't, right? Speaking of Emma, let's talk a little X-Men today, shall we? Yeah.
Sounds like an unbiased topic. It is, it really is. I mean, who doesn't like X-Men? I mean, come on, they are a huge contributor and influence in the comic book industry, really.
I don't even know where to begin, all the stuff that is brought into it. Some thoughts on your guys and some of the big things about X-Men that have contributed to the world of comics? I think that mainly the idea is that there's a character for everyone, and it represents every single group or race or anyone that you could possibly think of in some way or another. Yeah.
Yeah, for sure. And it's really really together too. That's the coolest part about it. Yeah, and it's always, I think, one of the big things that's always done well is sort of relate to social and political problems going on in the actual world.
Maybe not so much anymore. I don't know. I'm not really keeping up, but I know that was something Mr. Claremont liked to focus on, and I thought it made the comics more relatable to what's happening on a day-to-day basis.
Oh, it did. Definitely with that question there. Yeah, I mean, that's OK. After you.
Yeah, but I mean, that's the thing. I feel with new X titles, they deal with relationships more between the mutants rather than what is going on around them. They still talk about the discrimination and everything they get against them. But now we're having to worry about is Bobby Drake gay?
What happened to Cyclops? Who are these new young X men? Rather than what's going on politically in the world? Who's discriminating against two?
What's trying to do? Yeah. It's more personal. I feel like maybe the humans are also taking the spotlight in that sense.
Either way, I mean, X-Men, they've always been the hot book at Marvel too. Yeah, yeah. In the 90s or even now, it's like if you're working on X-Men, you've made it. Oh, yeah, definitely.
I'm even going back into the 60s. It was something after what was that? X-Men Giant Size Number 1 came out. Boom.
It's like, whoa, what is this? It was. Who changed the game? Claremont changed the game.
Yeah, changed the game. Well, I will say that Len Wien wrote that giant size. But Claremont was the one that escalated all those characters. Right after all.
Right after all. You're on Uncand then just went the town. To me, that seemed to be the focal point. That's when everything really started to change.
Right around that area. And it has evolved a lot since the 60s to current. Oh my god. Yeah.
I mean, that's like a huge understatement. I mean, just even now, I think now it's been the past five years, the amount of changes they've gone through is just staggering. I think it's hard to keep up with even. It can be.
It really truly can be. So who were you talking to somebody who's like, hey, did you realize that this happened to this character? Like what? Yeah.
There's a lot of like... Yeah. They've like fought every other hero in the Marvel Universe at this point. They're not really friends with anyone.
Yeah. You know, it's... They've gone through a lot. And in terms of characters too, a lot of characters have had fundamental things changed about them.
Thank you, Mr. Bendis. But yeah, I mean, they're definitely an exciting and interesting crowd to read on a monthly basis. Now, one thing about the storyline, how long has it been going on with the mutants versus the humans scenario in humans?
Thank you and humans, that's what I meant to say. How long has that been going on? Two years, underlined kind of two-ish years. Underlined, yeah.
Two-ish years. But I mean, not directly until like earlier this year or last year, I guess. Yeah. Whenever the whole...
I mean, I don't know, but the Tergion Miss thing was happening before Secret Wars, wasn't it? Yeah. So there was after, I think, was it original snow? Infinity, was it?
Well, it had the whole Tergion Miss thing happen, right? Because Black Bolt decided he was going to bring the inhumans down to Earth, I think. Something like that was a while ago. And he had that whole fight with Thanos.
And I think that's after that, there was like an inhumanity thing. I don't know if you remember reading that, Rusty. It was like a one shot, I think. But that started the whole Tergion Miss thing.
And then the Inhumans series started with all those goo-coons coming out and all the new inhumans. And then I don't... I think it was after... When the extraordinary X-Men started that, it was like, oh, but the Tergion Missed is like sort of cancerous for mutants, and it's not very good for them.
Yeah. And then it was like, oh, don't touch me. I don't want your mutant cuties and everyone who's scared of mutants again. Impots, right?
Yeah. Yeah. So I mean, pretty wild stuff. It's been a question I have.
It's been a question I have, right? Yeah. When are we going to finally see mutants and non-mutants finally embracing each other and getting along in the Marvel Universe? To me, the whole drama that has been going on for way too many years.
Yeah. It's like, let's wrap up that problem in Can It? Shall we? We'll never be friends.
Kind of. In X-Men 92, that series, even though it's a different timeline, they are friends with Kelly in it, and he's president. So they kind of made a man's sort of in that one. Kind of sort of.
Kind of like a one, though. No. But I mean, they're obviously doing something, right? I mean, what other Marvel team title do you know that has reached 600 issues?
Yeah. Fantastic Four. Is that an answer? Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Okay, that's pretty true. I'm only thinking Spider-Man at 700 or so.
There's not too many Marvel titles that have. I mean, come on. I just mean, Fantastic Four, Spider-Man. Those are the only ones, really.
What about Avengers? Avengers never reached up there? No, they... No.
They're going to have a whole action-comics thing and start renumbering again. Yeah. That's possible. I mean, they've done it before.
Mm-hmm. But yeah, I think X-Men in general, like if you look at every single adjective used and whatnot, it's had the most issues put out for sure. Yeah. Not including your Wolverines and your, you know, your Legion, your cable, your X-Force, all that.
Damn it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
The mutants are probably the biggest part of the Marvel universe. But I'm not to ask you guys, I know Rusty's answer, but favorite, I guess, creative team, either writer or artist on a... that's ever worked on X-Men. That's a lot to choose from.
Where to begin? Um... Gotta give me a second. You can't hit me cool with that one.
No problem. So you said you already know the answer to mine. What is the answer? I'm going to guess it's Mr.
Claremont and Jim Lee. Maybe not that time, but in general, like your favorite artist, Jim Lee and your favorite writer, Chris Claremont. Yeah. Maybe not, they run on it, but you know...
I mean, storyline wise, you know, burn and then Claremont. But team wise, yes, Claremont and Jim Lee. I mean, that was just amazing. I mean, no wonder they sold so many issue number ones, right?
Yeah. It was like, Jim Lee Magneto is just like, wow, wow. Yeah. I mean, yeah, X-Men one was sold like, was it 8 million?
Something like that. And then the second issue... Yeah, and then the second issue was like 5 million. But yeah, for me, I don't know what to say.
I love Grant Morrison's new X-Men, but astonishing X-Men by Joss Whedon was just... that's my jam. That's probably my favorite X-Men. That's what I'd go with.
And I think it was John Cassidy on hard work who used to be quite the artist. Now, I guess he's alright still. Alright, yeah. Now, think about it.
I kind of, you know, of course Claremont. And then I... How's the artist? I do like John Byrne.
Yeah. That's the old school answer right there. It is. That's the thing you know me, I'm kind of old school and I like the old school stuff.
And his work just notably sticks out my brain. I think it was dark Phoenix that it wasn't he worked on. And it just sticks out my head probably the most. Neil Adams was a good X-Men artist as well.
Yeah, he was. He pretty much saved the X-Men from being cancelled. He's done that for so many books. I mean, Neil Adams is just changing the game.
He was on it. Roy Thomas, right? I was just going to say that. Yes, Roy Thomas did some great...
Oh, I'm like any X-Men. I mean, going back into the teens as he memory starts correctly. Yeah, he was following up after Stan. Yeah, we would be getting Roy on the show one of these days.
I can't wait to get him on. He's done some great work as well. You could talk for hours on end, I'm sure. I've never seen it all.
Oh, yeah. I'm sure he has. Man's a legend as well. No, Rusty, I wanted to ask you because you go back when it comes to the X-Men, how do you feel about how much it's changed?
In terms of the quality of the storytelling, how much it's changed since the big gold Claremont epics. That's the thing, man. I feel like the stories just don't have as much depth anymore. And the weird thing about it is even Jeff Lemire, he's a great writer.
You can't deny that. There's just not the same kind of depth on the stories as it was. I don't feel as connected to the characters as I once did. And they don't feel as relatable now as they used to, for some odd reason.
I can't put my finger on it. I'm assuming it's just the writing and stuff. But it seems like the characters just have been redone so many times that they're not the same person anymore. Yeah.
And I agree with that. I mean, it has changed. I think a lot of it also just stems from almost 600 issues, what stories haven't been told, and they kind of rehashing the same stuff, is almost to the point where it's like if you kill off three forces at X-Men, replace them and start creating whole new storylines and everything. It's just after...
Well, I kind of like to do that. I mean, the rest of him, they eliminated so many people. But I feel like... But that...
How long did it last? I was like, I'm a damn. A lot of people blame the house of him for the reason X-Men is today. I will say also, I think a big part of it is the fact that, you know, back when Claremont was doing it, it was pretty much only him.
He'd be like, you know what? I mean, we got this magic character. I'm going to do a little four issue with me on her. Wolverine.
Same thing, why not? I'm going to write all of it. Oh, I'm going to be a new mutants. And it was just him sort of taking over the whole...
Too many cooks now. You got Jeff Lemire, you got Charles Soul, you got Lord Knows Who Else Doing, Colin Banya, you got Tom Taylor doing All-New Wolverine. It's just all over the place. So that's probably...
But also Claremont was canon. He created these guys and created... Just like I said, we created those issues in Storylines Forum, and of course being the amazing writer he is. It gave you something new, something interesting, and it crossed over with everything really well.
Whereas it now, I can say too many hands have been in the pot. Yeah. No, I like that you bring that point up, Nova, just because like... In the past three years, how many writers have changed on just the main title alone?
Just been at least five or six in the past four years. And they've all got their own interpretation, and they've got their own mark. They need to leave on the X-Men universe. They've got to kill off this character, change this one's sexuality, this one's, you know, hairstyle, god damn it.
They just all got to do their own thing, and it just sort of... You get lost in the mix of it. And you do. You really do it.
Then now it's like today, you read the titles like, okay, is Logan, a male or female, is the older, is he young? What's going on with Wolverine? It's just like it's all over the place. I think one of the biggest greedy moments in recent X-Men history, even though a lot of people like it, that it happened, was bringing back the young X-Men from the past to the present, and then just changing them completely.
I feel like that... X-Men, X-Men 92 is what you're talking about, right? No, all new X-Men. Okay.
All new. All new. All new. All new.
All new. All new. They brought them back from the past, from the 60s, or wherever they were back then, to the present, and they're all little teenagers again. They're changing them completely.
Yeah. Basically, they're just rewriting them to where like, okay, what if they grew up in this situation? It was ridiculous. Like, everyone's forgotten.
The reason B's brought them back was to show Cyclops the air of his ways and how he used to be so innocent and young, and that was like forgotten about the third issue. It didn't even matter. They're like, no, you know what, we're cool. We'll chill here.
I guess I can't really show Cyclops how it used to be. It was just a gimmick. It's one of the most frustrating parts about it too. It's like, they came back and like you said, they were supposed to show Cyclops, but then it felt like them as characters got greedy.
They were like, no, I don't want to go back. And it's like, what is your problem? Why are y'all all of a sudden jerks? See, I didn't use jerks.
Oh, yeah. The professor will wipe our minds and we'll forget about this. I don't want to forget about this. Like, I want to be here.
Let's stay here. This guy, kind of silly. Especially when you go back and actually read like X-Men 1, where they're all like, oh, good. We should do whatever the professor says.
If he says to go jump off, if we trust him and we know, it's just all backwards. Now, okay, going back to that story line. So they brought all the younger versions back. And now are the younger versions interacting with their older versions?
Of course. Now, how does that, doesn't that screw up the timeline? No, because as B said it, I don't know, but it doesn't seem to be doing anything. So probably doesn't.
Okay. Or they just created a new timeline, created a new universe, whatever. Like there's so many explanations that they explained to that and one of them that they were the same X-Men in like a similar, extremely similar universe. These are from Earth 616.
Yeah. So it was. Yeah. Yeah.
He's basically saying I didn't time travel. I didn't just time travel. I went back in time into a different dimension. Boom.
Which can't, but then again, didn't we just get rid of all of the dimensions and alternate universes recently? You think so. And spoiler alert, I guess it's been like two weeks already, but it looks like the ultimate universe isn't really gone either. So Secret Wars was all just sort of a waste.
Money grab, yeah. Which we kind of knew that was going to be the story anyways. Yeah. When you're trying to re-brin, that's the thing with all these like, I mean, let's bring back the old X-Men.
Let's do a Civil War II. Let's do a Secret Wars like three. Let's do, you know what I mean? That's why I was making jokes earlier where it's just like, watch the new X-Men now.
Be like, all right, Dark Phoenix II. Yeah. See, it wouldn't have been better if they just kind of like, okay, we're going to reboot it to issue one as if nothing's ever been written type of thing and the guys, you're going to be introduced to their main stories all over again or something. So, I think it's way too complicated.
I think that's what they're doing. Marvel's always been called the House of Ideas and they've got ideas, they've got a bunch of them, but they don't really know what to do with them. And it's sort of like Civil War II, is it over? Did it finish?
I don't know if it did, but they were books saying acting like it was done already when it wasn't the final issue, it wasn't actually released yet. Yeah. And they were like, oh, you know, as a result of the Civil War, this has happened to me. And it's like, well, thanks, I guess.
Why buy the rest of Civil War II then? It's like what you said they have a half an idea, whatever. They take an idea, they're not sticking up, pin it on the board. All right, somebody else finished this up.
Yeah, Ben, this you've got time tomorrow, right? Why don't you just whip this thing together for us? Thanks. Take this idea, break by issues and have it on my desk tomorrow afternoon.
I think the biggest realization for it was at the end of the new Secret Wars when they ran and be like, all right, we're adding an extra issue. And it was like, what? And he's like, did you not think about this beforehand? Or were you just playing this out by ear?
Yeah, issue by issue. And then what was funny is in the joke issue for it, Secret Wars II or whatever, they actually joke about him like acting like he didn't, was it Cassetta or was it a... Yeah, yeah, yeah. Now he didn't realize what he was going to do at the end of it.
And he just played it by ear. Maybe that is a joke in it. And it's like, was this really a joke or? Yeah.
Mm-hmm. Here's an idea. Throw it all out. Startle over again, issue number one, hand it off to Chris Claremont.
You have full cart bludged whatever you want. Give us a four-year run. Nice. We'll see what happens.
We know Chris is on retainer. You can do anything he wants if Marvel just gives him a call. So it's just like... Yeah.
Call him. Yeah, they just... I mean, I'm not sure if anyone who wants it enough to do, I guess what Claremont had done just sort of take... If you want to have three X-Men books, sure, but I need to be writing them all so it's not all over the place and crazy.
Exactly. It's hard to do, but I mean... Yeah. And give it to that person for longevity.
Not just, oh, here you can have the next five issues or six. Well, the problem with longevity is if they need to pump out these events because these events sell even though people hate them, logic. And so that person's going to be sort of like getting dragged into events and having to change the story line to fit the event and it's just become a real... Well, is it the events that sell or is it all the variants to the events that sell?
Well, I know it's the events that sell just because they hype them up. So I'm just like, there's going to be so much that changes. Yeah. Nothing changes.
Yep. And it's going to be a bunch of people sitting around that hoping that maybe Marvel will be the truth for this time. Yeah. Well, the one thing that doesn't change is you're done at the end of it.
That's always the constant. There is that. When we were talking about putting someone though on it for a long period of time, in a way, I kind of feel like they're doing that with Colin Bunn now. Mm-hmm.
Because he's been writing on some kind of X-Men title now for like almost two years and then Jeff Lemire just keeps getting handed X-Tidal after X-Tidal too. So I'm wondering if one of them might just end up being the long haul guy for it in the end. Yeah, which one of those two would you rather have though? Colin Bunn has a weird fascination with Magneto, which I'm cool with.
Right? Weird in some ways. Like you could tell that it's different. He's like the darker side of X-Men.
So it doesn't feel like traditional X-Men. But it's still good. Then you have Jeff Lemire, which feels kind of current. I don't know how to describe it.
He's doing a good job, I guess, of continuing off the storyline, but he's not really changing a whole lot. Yeah. Well, it's kind of just writing it along, I feel like. We'll see what happens with all these new titles that keep coming out.
It will be coming out anyway. Yeah. What's on the docket? What are some of the new stuffs that we know of that's been put out?
So they're doing this event in April. It's called Resurrection, right? Yeah, Resurrection. Yeah.
And what are the team titles, Nova? Well, there's like X-Men Gold, Blue, some other colors, I think, as well. No, they have X-Men and Blue and Gold, and they have a Generation X. Yes, I think there's going to be a cable.
There's a cable book as well. There's a cable book. There's a Jean Grey book. When the next book, which we don't know if it's Wolverine or if it's Laura, there's also going to be an Iceman book.
And we found out today that it's going to be adult Bobby, not kid. Yeah. Yeah. And then like you said, there's cable.
Now, looking at these books, and it looks like each one has a different writer on it. No, Jeff Lemire and Sight either. So, yeah. All of my questions, yeah.
Will they all relate to each other? It's my question. I think I'm sure because all of that Resurrection sticker on it. Yeah, but they also announced that group of inhuman books, and I think that they're going to carry the Resurrection they wanted too, which is useful.
But you know how some of these events are, you know? And one issue you're reading, you know, I'll throw out their Wolverine and Gambit are out doing something, and then some other series, Wolverine's doing something else, and Gambit's doing something else and he just died. But then the next issue comes back to take up, you know how it is. They just throw them all over the place, and they did that with Jesus.
What was it? With the Watcher. I can't think of the series. Or the Watcher died.
Original Sin. Original Sin. Original Sin. Thank you.
I remember it was that with some of the characters, the characters were all over the place. And he read an issue like, wait a minute, he's supposed to be in Canada. Why is he now out in outer space? What's going on?
Yeah, we'll see how it goes. Are you excited for any of these issues, Rene and Nova? Is there anything you're going to think of? I'll read whatever happens to pop up on Comma College-y most likely and give it the old, you know, try and see if it's decent or not.
I'm not holding my breath. I'm just not because it's marble. I'm kind of excited for Cable. Just because I haven't, I mean, he's been around, but I just, I'm glad he's going to have his own title now.
Aside from that, I can't, I'll do like exactly what I said. I'll give him a try. Can't say I'm going to, you know, have hope sorry or anything. Now they were throughout a fantastic four series.
Then I can see that in my full box. It's possible. I mean, the thing has been in that Iron Man book, I believe, the one with Doom. The things shown up in there.
So I mean, they're, you know, maybe slowly. It'll be written by Bendis. That'll be the, that'll be the punch line. What's going to happen at the end is Ben Grimm turns back into a human never to be a rock man again.
Yeah, of course. Yeah. The human, human torch and Iceman become a couple of fire and ice and there's, there's a new one going for you. And turns out, demons, a woman and her brother are not really related.
Yeah. And Reed stays the same. Reed, you can't do it. He just sits back and watches all this on full.
See, I mean, I would just be happy, honestly, kind of going back to the old school marble. We have all your separate little titles and they all cross over every now and then a couple of times of your like they do in New York City like the past. Like also Daredevil shows up or Spider-Man or whatever. Simple little stories.
That's not the cool thing for a while there though. Like through the Saturdays, they didn't have them really feature in each other books. They just had their own series called Marvel P-Masks. Mm-hmm.
Yeah, I mean, we'll do that. Yeah. But now having Deadpool show up in a book means the sales go up. Yeah.
He got that pool of duck. I can't. I mean, I like to see that work with an expenser to tie the truth. He's a good writer.
He's a good writer when he adds that comedy edge to it. I don't know how his captain America's been, but I haven't heard too many good things. I suppose to like Ant-Man, which is like, oh, it's funny. It's got this like edge to it.
Yeah, but hopefully a little bit more from him. But you know guys, it's probably time to get on a very special guest. What do you guys say? Well, I may have to go, but you two enjoy.
Oh, you're going to come in after all this X-Men talk. You don't want to talk to Chris Claremont. Sad day. I've been tapped.
I've been MIA for all of this. So he misses out on Claremont too. All right. All right.
Well, I guess we'll have to bring somebody in. Why don't we give a Liberty call? Sit he's available. All right.
Let's go ahead and give a clear call. Now is the winter of our discontent made glorious summer by the son of York, and all the clouds that lowered upon our house are in the deep bosom of the ocean buried. Welcome everyone to another interview segment of Four Guys on a Comic. Today we have one of our most special guests, an accomplished writer and a man behind many of your favorite X titles and characters.
He's the best there is at what he does. Welcome to the show, Mr. Christopher Claremont. How are you doing?
How do you do? I'm fine. How are you? Though I should point out, as every acting casting director I've ever auditioned for has ever said, comedy is not my strength.
That's funny. Fine. You don't have to be a comedian here. I don't know.
Given the title, I felt it was obligatory. Sorry. Deep humor, I know. That's good.
There's someone out there in podcast land right now just geeking out hardcore about all of this. One can only hope. So, Mr. Claremont, why don't you just give a brief introduction of yourself for those at home who might be new readers who have never heard of you or what you've done before in the comic industry?
Somebody that hasn't heard of Chris Claremont? No, don't say that, right? Oh gosh. Well, an extraordinarily tall, extraordinarily handsome, extraordinarily youthful looking with the full head of hair and the most piercing blue eyes ever.
I've been writing comics, I've been writing for longer than I care to think about writing comics for almost that long, most notably for Marvel Comics, most notably in the X-Men Pentium. And so far, so good. Yeah, I would say. Definitely without question there.
Now, you started off with the late 60s, early 70s with Marvel, if I understand correctly. Yes. You were pretty much like the Gopher Boy from my understand. Yep.
Well, they're now called interns, but then there's not a Gopher Boy, you were just a Gopher. Gopher, Gopher Coffee, go for this, go for that. Basically, one was the unpaid lady in the office doing whatever was necessary to be done and helping out and learning at the same time. I have to ask, we recently had Bob McCloud on the podcast.
Did you go for side by side with him? No, I was predated frighteningly just about everybody. Oh, no. Jim Schubert came in as an intern or something, a few months or a year after I left.
One of the last things I did was reject a submission by Tony Asabella for a writing pitch. And I wrote back and said it's a nice piece of work, but not up to Marvel standards. And five years later, when I came in as a paid employee, he was my boss. So he gave me a little placard to put on my desk that said exactly the words I cited to him as to why I was rejecting his submission.
Oh, no. Do you still have that placard today? Somewhere. Somewhere.
Either in my basement or in Columbia's archives. There you go. Speaking of Columbia archives, you don't need a lot of your work to Columbia University. All my papers, manuscript, hard.
Because in the beginning, yes, I go back so far that the first chunk of years of my professional career and the X-Men were written on typewriters. I don't know if you're familiar with the term. A typewriter is a mechanical device which you typed, pressed a tab and another tab slapped a letter down on the page and you created a page at a time. Oh, yes.
And you had to photocopy them. Yes, there were no Xeroxes in those days. Oh, great. Carbon paper.
That came out a little bit later, though. Now, carbon paper was there. I have an intimate familiarity with carbon paper. But the interesting thing is that allows Columbia, in some cases, to have the original copies of a lot of my earliest stuff as opposed to just Xeroxes of the files that I turned in.
Nowadays, artists don't even draw on paper anymore. They just go straight on to screens and go from one computer to another without any printed original coming into existence, except perhaps either the publisher for editing purposes or at the printer. You don't even have that guy anymore for the letter. I've got the exact exact thing.
Trust me, there's a certain primal editorial reality that, in terms of your perception, that if you were actually going to have to cut up the original page of material to replace letter text, which is lettered on the boards as part of the art, or to make an adjustment to a figure or what have you, you actually had to think about it because you are in the process of altering and destroying a physical object. So it was never done casually. There's a classic moment that I've—it's a story I've told a number of times, but it's true. It was in the office and back in the day, and Frank Miller was turning in his latest issue of digital and editor Daniel Neil was reading it.
And he gave the last page back to Frank and said, Frank, if you don't mind, because Frank was writing and drawing the work, I need this last panel rewritten with this next to the last panel rewritten. It doesn't quite—it isn't clear. And Frank sits there and looks at it and looks at it. This is normal.
I mean, this happens to writers all the time. And then without—he suddenly goes, ah, picks up an eraser and just erases the whole panel. And Danny, just his eyes just popped. You're like, ah, what have you done?
Oh my God. And Frank just sits there and starts reading the panel. And Danny actually finally gets the words up. What have you done?
And Frank was, oh, the words are right. The panel is wrong. Thanks. Well, Frank could do this because it was his art to begin with.
You know, whereas editors being, for the most part, writers instinctively assume it's the words that are wrong so you can fix it. We just have the writer or a flunky around the office fix the words. It was an interesting time. But because, again, you're involving physically altering the material, there is a level of internal caution.
Is this absolutely necessary? Does this really make it better? Are we really going—is it really worth the possible friction between writer and editor or writer and publisher? Or do you want to pick up a phone and call the writer and have the writer do it?
Whereas when you're just typing a new line into a computer file, it gets done instantly without a second thought, which is infinitely more efficient, perhaps, from a publishing standpoint. But it creates a certain level of perhaps not so useful friction between the two elements of the creative community. But that's just, again, the evolution of technology in the creative publishing craft process. Now, through that evolution, are you still nostalgic for the older days when I used to do it that way or if you embraced and enjoy the new way that they're doing things digitally?
Or is there a happy medium somewhere in between? No, what I'm actually nostalgic for are the days when the X-Men was new. I had the ridiculous good fortune of getting the book with literally the second story with I mean, Len, Len Wien and Dave Cochram had created a giant size X-Men number one. I took over with X-Men 94, which was the first half of giant size number two.
And Len had plotted giant size number two, but then left the book. And I had to re-plot the second half because it was now not a giant size but an ongoing bi-monthly title. So from that point on, it was my responsibility. And here I was with five brand new Dave Cochram visual designs, five totally new and in their own way revolutionary characters to play with.
And publishing environment where Stan's attitude was, I hire you to be a writer? Be a writer here. Don't bother me. I'll get involved if it turns out to be crap.
If it's crap, you're fired. So don't make it crap. Be good. Hit your deadlines and don't be a pain in my ass.
And I'll leave you alone. And that was a remarkable, wonderful time because you could literally go, Dave and I could do anything. We could do giant double spread space operas in one issue and fight leprechauns in a castle in Ireland the next. We could create Phoenix with one breath and resurrect Magneto with the other.
It was just ridiculously cool. And that's not a luxury, sadly, that any contemporary writer on that title will have because it's all, there's now so much history and so much weight attached to the title of the characters that you can't play around anymore. Yeah. You're the one that created all that history in that way.
So big shoes to fill. Well, trust me, there are enough big egos who want to fill it. That's never been a problem for Marvel, I think. And the same rule applied 40 years ago that applied now.
I mean, you know, wow, who are you taking over the book from? Roy Thomas. Roy Thomas. I mean, the first story I had to read as a proof reader when I was working as a gopher was Roy and the Aladdin's third issue on X-Men, on Candy back in the days.
And that was a coolest stuff ever. So every generation has it superstars or whatever. I think the human failing all of this is the presumption that regardless of when you come into the game, if you hit a top level, you'll stay there forever. And sadly, publishing like sports, games evolve, new players come in, new attitudes become paramount.
The audience wants to see new faces and sometimes ends up taking people that they've known for 10 or 20 or 40 years, a little bit more for granted. So it evolves. On the other hand, that allows the people who've been around for a while to reestablish themselves, rebrand themselves, redefine themselves, and ideally take the audience by surprise and create stuff that dances a whole new direction. So it works out better for everybody.
Have you ever found yourself in a position where you had to like say, excuse me, what are you doing? Someone who comes in as a new writer on an existing platform and the X-Men say, why? Has it ever come up or are you just happy with the way it's going? No, the one time I did it, the one time I did it, which was way back in the day.
I was a Avengers annual 10, where I felt the writer on Avengers had done a fundamental disservice to a character, Carol Danvers, and I wanted to set things right. So I did. And I had the good fortune to be doing it in concert with Michael Golden, who turned in, as usual, a brilliant art job. And it's one of those weird stories that's still being reprinted today and is holding its ground.
I think if I were on the receding end of that story, I would be pissed off and I will not but I saw something that I felt was wrong. I felt the need to set it right. I did it and it turned out to be a good story. So that's the only time I ever actually yielded to the temptation to say, what?
Except for the fact that I guess when I came back to the book in 2000, the whole, for me the whole point of doing kitty was to keep her as the young element, the beginner, in a sense of the team. So I had a very gradual evolution of her life structured out. So when I left Excalibur, she was 15 and almost 16. So part of the joke was having Brian Braddock's ex-girlfriend, Courtney Ross, here, have some champagne young lady.
It's your birthday. Have a little cake. It's your birthday. Why don't you drive your new Jaguar?
But I don't have a license. I won't tell if you won't just don't hit anybody. So you know, of course, Courtney is really Saturday night, so she's leading kitty down the path. And then a new writer took over Excalibur and decided he wanted to have kitty jump into bed with Peter Wisdom.
But you really can't do that with a 15-year-old. It's even in England that's frowned upon. So she instantly jumped up 10 years and jumped into bed with Pete Wisdom. When I came back as editorial director and surprisingly writing the accent, I wanted to fix that because to be a 25-year-old kitty is boring.
Because once you become an adult, all the questions in your life are pretty much answered. There are very, very few to my mind surprises to spring on the audience, whereas when you are going through adolescence every moment, every incident, every encounter, every decision, every crisis is a big deal. So I tried to retcon the earlier retcon. And how should I put it?
Severely chest-to-high by the reading community. Fans liked kitty the way she was. They did not like some olfark coming in and rebooting her. So you win some, you lose some, and time.
That's why it's always nicer. But ever see that happen, for example, with Harry Potter. Or with what to say in the new one, because it's J.K. Rowling, top to bottom, right to left, the same with Game of Thrones.
George owns all of Game of Thrones. Therefore no one's going to screw around with any characters without his approval. That is a circumstance that is denied any writer who works on mainstream corporate-owned material, either from Marvel, for DC, for Dark Horse, or anybody. The company owns Batman.
The company owns the Fantastic Four. The producers of the work, i.e. the creative producers, are merely transitory folk. The characters, the titles are what's important.
The characters and the titles are the property of the corporation. We are just the facilitators. Which nobody was lied to when they came in the door. We all knew the game.
The differences in a situation like X-Men, it's a very, very, very rare occasion where you have one group of characters defined for such a significant amount of time by a single creator. That's the other side of the equation. So the emotional side of oneself says, I wish I wish I should have, why didn't I, the real world side is saying, eh, not my game. Time to move on.
Now, just talking to you in the short period of time that we have, you seem like you were very personally involved within your work and your comics. Now throughout your whole legacy and history, is there a story or maybe a title or something that you feel you are the most emotionally connected with? Are we talking just in general or specifically the Marvel, specifically the comics, specifically just in general to you personally, what do you feel like you have written that you feel is probably your most emotionally connected? Clearly, the book I haven't finished yet.
Oh, okay. No, you never, you, trust me, you never apply that kind of rationale to material that's imprint. I mean, that's done. I've done it.
I'm moving on. My focus is always on what I'm doing now and what comes next. If I were looking in an absolute sense, I think any writer will say the work you feel most bonded to is the work that is wholly and unimpecibly yours. So in my case, it would be Maratha, it would be so often.
So, you know, you're talking about the new novel that you're working on now. I understand that you have like nine novels already under your belt. Can you talk a little about what you're writing now for us? Very little.
Okay. I never, I never talk about work in progress. It's if I talk about it, why should you read it? It's the second, it's the second in the series.
I'm sitting in my desk trying to structure out what's happening, what happens next and who the characters are and where they're going and what they want and how they get there and what's cool. It's about 50 pages of handwritten notes and we'll see. Very cool. It's always a spider to create stories into right.
Oh, God, no. I wanted to be a political theorist. Wow. Yeah.
No, and then I originally set out to be a political theorist then discovered the only way to take an acting class was to, at university was to major in it. So I majored in it and ended up coming to New York to be an actor and was one for three years doing off off Broadway, bus and truck, some TV work. The irony being that I haven't done a significant amount of acting in the last 40 years yet my SAG card is 42 years old, which I find very amusing. I was on leave for 38 years until days of future past where, when I actually ended up with lines, when I ended up with lines in a movie, because it was the second or third time I'd done an appearance in a Marvel film, I couldn't go waver.
So SAG pointed out, you can't have another waver. You've got a re-op boy. So I had to pay, I got my check from Fox for acting in the movie and had to give two-thirds of it back to the Screen Actors Guild. Oh, no.