Skip to content
It's about ethics in journalism, with Ben Smith episode artwork

Aug 17, 2026 1 hr 11 min

It's about ethics in journalism, with Ben Smith

from Decoder with Nilay Patel Hosted by The Verge

Today I’m talking to Ben Smith, the editor-in-chief of Semafor. Ben ran BuzzFeed News at the height of the Facebook traffic boom, and even wrote a book about it, called Traffic, which he discussed with me on Decoder back in 2023. Semafor, which is only four years old, is now a fast-growing and profitable media company, which makes about half of its revenue from events. So I wanted to talk to Ben about how that all works, and what it feels like to navigate the ethical conflicts that seem to be everywhere in media right now. Read the full interview transcript on The Verge. Links: Jonah Peretti explains why he sold BuzzFeed | Decoder What’s after the social media era in news? | Decoder (2023) Semafor raises $30 Million after first profitable year | The Wrap Semafor’s new AI tool helped boil down its flagship conference | Nieman Lab Semafor launches Silicon Valley & The World | Semafor Semafor takes aim at Davos as events surpass half Its revenue | Adweek Semafor Is Betting Big on 'Anti-Scale' Video | Adweek Semafor wants to be ‘business outlet of record in the Gulf” | Press Gazette Subscribe to The Verge to access the ad-free version of Decoder! Credits: Decoder is a production of The Verge and is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Decoder’s producers are Kate Cox and Nick Statt. This episode was edited by Xander Adams. Our Supervising Producer is Greg Ott and our Editorial Director is Kevin McShane. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

It's about ethics in journalism, with Ben Smith

0:00 1:11:22
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Solved, cushy, plush, cozy, soft, smooth, buttery, marshmallowy, warm, soft, socks, underwear, tees and more, Bumble, everyday comfort, worth obsessing over. Visit bumbus.com.audio and use code AUDIO for 20% off your first purchase. That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash audio. One purchase equals one donated, always. I'm Ina Garten and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City.

On this week's episode, I'm joined by Julia Louis-Dreyfus. We talk all about attending a fashion show in Paris together, throwing dinner parties, and making her Broadway debut in other desert cities. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers.

How far would you go to have a healthy baby? Embryo editing is very much illegal in the United States, it is illegal in most countries. But there is growing interest as the technology has gone better. This week on Explain It To Me, the ethics of embryo-maxing. Listen to new episodes of Sundays wherever you get your podcasts.

Hello, and welcome to the Coder. I'm the only editor in chief of The Verge, and Coder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today I'm talking to Ben Smith, the editor in chief of Semaphore. Everywhere you go, people say they don't trust the media, and yet they've never consumed more of it. Audiences have moved on from legacy names in favor of sub-stacks and podcasts and TikTok news influencers that seem to be everywhere in our feeds.

Why would anyone want to start a new global news organization in the middle of all that, when even one story grants like CBS News can't seem to figure it out? Well, that's what Ben did four years ago. He's the guy who ran BuzzFeed News at the height of the Facebook traffic room. He even wrote a book about it called Traffic, which we discussed with him here on the coder back in 2023. And so I'm trying to time-keyed co-founded Semaphore, which launched with a stated goal of reaching 200 million college educated readers.

You're going to hear Ben say that since then, Semaphore has evolved into what he calls an anti-scale company. It still doesn't have a website paywall, but it makes about half its money in the convening business. That's what media types have taken the calling of events lately. And Semaphore throws some big events, actually have a new one called Silicon Valley in the world, which will feature some of the biggest names in tech and AI. That's part of the events business, having the people on that you cover.

So I want to know how that all works, and what it feels like to navigate the ethical conflicts that seem to be everywhere in media right now. How does Semaphore's newsroom is approaching AI, the ethics and the people you cover on your conference advisory boards, and whether independence is something an audience still even wants to pay for. Ben and I talk about these things a lot, usually over beers. And I think you'll be able to tell, we really enjoy getting into the weeds of all this together. I hope you enjoy this conversation.

Please subscribe to our YouTube channel to get new episodes every Monday and Thursday. Alright, Ben Smith, editor in chief of Semaphore. Here we go. Ben Smith, you're the co-founder and editor in chief of Semaphore. Welcome back to the coder.

It is really nice to be back. I'm excited to talk to you. You were on the show three years ago, just as Semaphore was launching. It was right as BuzzFeed news, which you found in Rant for a long time was shutting down. I keep talking to media CEOs about what is going to happen.

It feels like you have figured something out at Semaphore. How are things going over there? You know, things are going incredibly well. I knock down wood as I say that. I do think that I think we figured something out.

I think there are a lot of different things to figure out where this unbelievably strange and unstable moment in media. But I do think we figured out a model that is quality journalism built around great journalists paired with really large-scale convening that is building both great journalism and a really good business, a profitable business, which is something that is to me as a former BuzzFeed executive novel. Yeah, a profitable digital media business is in short supply these days. It's when I was looking over there a conversation from a few years ago, you had just published your book traffic, which was basically about what I would call the millennial digital media moment and everyone chasing massive scale. The platforms are going to deliver tons of traffic to us and then we'll click pennies and we'll get rich.

This was a pretty common thesis. It feels like you're saying you've turned away from that. You've learned the lesson about that. Our chief revenue officer, Rish Alaban, likes to joke that my next book will be called No Traffic. But yeah, I think we are really building an anti-scale business.

I think in a way, the luxury of starting in that moment in the rubble of the traffic apocalypse was that was obviously not the path to success and we had to think a lot about targeting a very specific audience. I also think the thing that I have come to realize as when all these conversations are happening, we have a show about media, we have about this on. What's the future of media? Is it live? We're just talking about it.

Who knows? But I think in journalism, I have a lot of conviction that great stories aren't going anywhere. The need for really high quality insight isn't going anywhere. Great reporters aren't going anywhere. What surface this all lives on?

Up for grabs. And you can't be too ideological about that. You say surface, I always say distribution. And a theme on decoder that we come back to over and over again is your distribution shapes what you make. It's just inevitable.

The medium is the message and to borrow that framing. If the surface is a distribution of up for grabs, what are you holding onto? So I think I actually don't buy that thesis. At least I'm resisting that thesis because I think the audience shapes should, the poll of distribution is incredibly powerful. The core thesis of BuzzFeed was we crafted a distribution and built for the distribution.

And maybe I'm overreacting a little to that. But we definitely think all the time about we want to reach political leaders, we want to reach business leaders, we want to not profit leaders, we want to reach people, making decisions, we want to reach them in person, we reach them a lot in email, we reach them in the web, we reach them in the video. But we're thinking about that same audience across media. And in fact, I think video is particularly interesting because the poll of video is a video is replaced with the web in terms of the place you can get massive scale. And then conversely, where there's a poll of massive scale to create, to basically the biggest poll is just to be hyper-polarizing and find ways to create polarizing confrontation.

That's how you go viral or one of the best ways. And I guess we're really trying hard to build the discipline to resist that poll of distribution. We're already deep in the weeds. I hope the listeners can tell. But I like talking to each other about these things.

We do visit semaphore.com. I'm excited to play some clips for you. So I'm glad that you said you were reacting to BuzzFeed. A few months ago, we had Jonah Friday on the show. Right after he'd sold BuzzFeed to Byron Allen and the Weather Channel, a lot going on there.

In full disclosure, the audience literally had a beer with you just before I sat down in and I did not ask the questions you told me to ask. But he said... It was about running. It was about running. You asked me to ask me to ask me to do it.

I was quickly in the weeds of Jonah as well. And I put to him what I think of as the original sin of digital media, which is that I think Jonah thought he could go so viral so consistently that he could crack distribution that Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook would pay him money. And I'm going to play you what he said to me in response to that. And I just want to get your reaction to it. Yeah.

So first, just as a factual matter, we did get paid millions of dollars by Mark Zuckerberg. So the prediction that they would pay for content was accurate. It just was short-lived. So we got paid for that exploding watermelon. Okay.

That was a good day in the office. It was a great day in the office. I'm guessing. But everyone knew that he wasn't going to pay forever. So I think that there was a...

I agree with Jonah on this. I think that looking back, we all say the social platforms were obviously going to always be dependent on UGC and never pay for anything. And these media companies building on social platforms never made any sense. And these investors who... And these investors, it's worth remembering.

They're experiencing a bit of a shape by cable, which was a different distribution platform in which companies like Viacom, ESPN, CNN, MTV, whatever, had built huge businesses on the back of this new distribution. So they were like, oh, here's another new distribution. We're going to build businesses on the back of it. I think we now look back and say it was inevitable that Facebook would never pay for content. But I guess it wasn't.

I think it was choices made by Facebook executives at various times experimented with different things. I don't think that if you look at... If you are the person in charge of the success of the Blue Facebook app, do you think, oh, it was a great decision to continually rely on low quality, user generated content? Like, no, that thing is dying, obviously. They should have found a different path.

It was a mistake. So Jeremy, this argument is well. And this is the... I mean, obviously I'm brainwashed by Jonah for a long time. No, I'm just curious.

Like, your paths have diverged and you are building a very different business. Yes. And I'm just curious. What's the difference you want to play for you? It's an argument that Facebook made a mistake.

Here's that clip. I actually believe that it was a mistake for Facebook and Mark Zuckerberg and to not continue with the news tab, to not continue to pay professional content creators. These platforms have tons of resources and could have spent a couple billion dollars a year on that. Sustained a vibrant media ecosystem really owned media in a way that would have been incredibly powerful for them and given them charisma and relevance and authority that they just don't have today. And this Jonah charisma is if Mark Zuckerberg had continued to fund BuzzFeed, he would have more charisma.

That the Facebook blue app would be more successful. They've done different things. Like, that's pretty obvious. And you can argue about which things. But I think, yeah, I basically think that's true.

And if you look at what you'd rather be Netflix or what you'd rather be the blue Facebook app, you'd rather be Netflix. What Netflix honestly doesn't invest in you either. Netflix pays a lot for content. They pay a lot for content, but they don't invest in news. Oh, news is news.

I agree. News is a complicated business where you separate questions. But they pay for a lot of professional content. I mean, I think YouTube is obviously the big and most interesting story here because I think YouTube really has found a way for individuals to build businesses on top of it in a really impressive way. Occasional news creators like Don Harris, almost the exception of the rule.

But a lot of, you know, we just had Karima on our show, like building real businesses, real careers on top of YouTube, paying producers, increasing the kind of moving up market. I guess the thing that I give Neil Mohan, the YouTube CEO, a hard time about is I do think YouTube, almost with the idea of the creator and the development of the word creator, build a system in which media companies, middlemen, can't really survive. There was a company called Maker Studios that Disney bought for half a billion dollars. It was supposed to be a kind of middleman between YouTube and creators kind of to give. And that's one way to give a group of media people leverage against the platform.

And YouTube has designed a system in which it's sort of like Uber. It deals with atomized individuals, not with collectives who have any kind of power. And that could be, they're all sorts of different collectives. A media company is one kind. And I think YouTube has probably to their own benefit to certainly to the detriment of the media industry, build a system where it's built for individuals, not for, and no one has any leverage except for YouTube.

This is the kind of big question I'm getting at. You're building a new kind of business, you're profitable, you're saying you're anti-scaling, no more chasing traffic. And I'm still personally obviously looking at the traffic. It's a personality flaw. If you were raised in a swamp, you will always be a creature in a swamp.

But I look at some of the other big success stories of our time, CBP is big success. These are not huge numbers. They're driving massive influence and they're charging high rates to advertisers that are integrated into their content. And by opening eye, who they cover on their show, you look at big YouTuber, Scream Rama's a great example. I saw him speak in around Cannes.

And he was very much like, yeah, I make advertising for partners. I make videos. The advertising is the thing that I make. It's the revenue. Somewhere in there is a big tension for the news, for media companies, where we can't go, we shouldn't probably make the advertising for the companies we cover.

But that is actually how you monetize all these platforms at scale. And I haven't found anyone who saw that I'm curious if you take a run set. Yeah, I think the entertainment business, which Kareem is in, that's always how it's been. James Bond is wearing whatever kind of watch he's wearing. I got the fact that I don't remember his real fail of marketing.

And there's not that inherent tension in the entertainment business that you're going to sell out by doing product placement or appearing in advertisement. Where news really is and you need to be careful. Again, I think the answer to that is actually audience. The traditional advertising business is that you're reaching an audience who the advertiser values, I think for the scaled advertising business, Google and Meta just built the best and tick tock increasingly built the best mass traps and it's impossible for publishers to compete on scale. I think if you're reaching people in a very focused way in various particular environments in person, in email, in video, that's a case you can really credibly make advertisers.

And so we build a really big advertising and a very, in a related convening business that way. And I think that's one answer. It's not the only answer, but it is one. When you say convening business, that's your events business. I want to come to the relationship.

Matt, I always gives me a hard time, but the word convening. I've run most of the word convening. It's good. You've gotten told by the revenue people. They love to say it.

I mean, we're going to come to it because there's a relationship between needing to get everyone in the room and then covering them, which I personally find fascinating. It's booking. Yeah. You had to not insult me for weeks to get me here. Or did I nag you every single day until you showed up.

Tell me about the revenue split between those things. Are you mostly making money on journalism or making money events? Which is how you're doing? It's just about 50-50. Yeah.

And is there a poll in other direction? Or are you trying to grab both the same way? I mean, where do you start up? We're opportunistic. I think the convening of business grew a lot faster.

Like my partner, Justin Smith, has been building businesses like that. He was the Atlantic and Bloomberg and so it's much more his experience than mine. He came in with this thesis, which I bought into that basically convening with the business that you could stand up fastest and make profitable fastest that was a journalism business. And so we launched really hard into that. It takes longer to build digital advertising business.

You've got to build that digital audience. So we launched with that. And then it's just taken off the way we didn't really imagine that it would be really competing with Davos this soon. Yeah. And when I come back to that too, when you launched, I remember part of the plan was to go to subscriptions.

You're going to build this elite audience. You're going to charge them lots of money. It was in there in the very beginning. It was that part of the plan. Early on, it was part of the plan.

Startups. You also were like, no, we barely need a website. It's all going to be newsletters. We did talk about that. You saw one of those website people.

I'm sorry. To this day. The last website on earth. That's the version. That'll change.

For reasons that things change with startups, but the media industry industry can change around it. Was there a moment where you said, oh, we can keep it free? Because you are one of the last free websites. Yeah. I think in my memory, we always thought at some point we'll do subscriptions.

But I think in my experience is you just cannot be ideological about revenue. Like it's hard enough to build a business in news without getting all hung up on the sort of values of the different revenue streams. Adfree publishers will tell you that democracy can only survive in a world where there aren't paywalls. Subscription publishers will tell you that advertising is corrupting. At some point you just realize everyone's just talking in their book.

Sometimes they're already in a tough business and they're talking themselves out of incremental opportunities and really successful media companies. If you look at Disney or the New York Times, what business is there? Well, they're actually in a bunch of different businesses. They're managing them all really carefully. The other view is that if at some point it makes sense to do subscriptions, we'll totally do.

We don't really see it as an ideological choice. Just when you're starting a company, you just can't do that many things at the same time. I got mocked for this at some point, but we are insanely ambitious about our long-term growth. We are trying to build over decades a huge global company and subscriptions are a trade-off that caps your growth in some ways. That's something we think about too.

But that said, we're really trying to build a good business and if subscriptions are part of that, I think at some point it will certainly be part of that. You launched a lot of ambition. You're the first news organization you're kind to really say, we're going to cover Africa a lot. We're going to cover the Gulf a lot in various ways. That ambition was these are under-covered.

We're going to provide new information you're not necessarily getting from. The places we'll build up that audience and will monetize them in some specific way. Has that thesis proved out? Yes. I would say this was...

I think when we launched this was the thing that I think was most confusing to people that Justin and I had worked in Global News and had these real ambitions for it. But also we were very careful about sequencing. So when we launched, we were in the US, Brooklyn, Washington, on Wall Street, Silicon Valley, and Africa. I remember it would be like me, Justin, our great Africa, Eddory, and Gatorgo Gay doing an interview. It would be like, oh, yeah, we're America and he's Africa.

And people were like, what are you talking about? What way doesn't make any sense? But I think we saw there was an opportunity to be very, very competitive very quickly in sub-Saharan Africa, particularly Kenya and Nigeria, South Africa, with great journalists led by Yinka and our colleagues Alexis. And just to figure out that model, we're now in the Gulf. We're going to launch in Europe and Asia.

And those are really growing businesses. They're part of a network. They're not reporting back to New York for what people in New York care about. We're trying to build a network of audiences in each of these places. Is that pulling you in different directions in terms of resource-ing?

If your audience in Africa goes faster than the audience, I'd say it's going to put more resources there. Yeah. I mean, we're definitely very attentive to what's working. I would say it's just a truth that the US is the biggest media market in the world by far. And I think it depends how you can, but more than half of all revenue associated with media in the world is in the US.

Yeah. That was the poll. So the poll is mostly always here. I think we fight against it a bit because we think this is a really good long-term investment. This is ancient history, but when I worked at AWL, in all places, there was a lot of poll that we ran in gadget channels.

We wanted to be in all these other countries and how we would resource and run those operations against much cheaper advertising revenue. Yeah. Penny is the dollar in some cases. The audience was there. The audience was there.

We had this experience about why I was so excited to do some of what was just because it successfully built businesses in these other markets. We'd have gone in, built big audiences, seen in Brazil, in the UK, in Japan, these very intense engagement people wanting independent journalism of this new digital and independent journalism. And then I remember in the first meeting we were talking about this very smart, long-time digital investor was like, do not do this. You will never make any money. Shut it all down.

We were like, ah, forget it old-timer. And he was totally correct. We just never figured out how to reliably monetize them. And then even when you could, you'd be like, oh, the Brazilian edition was profitable this year, but bad news, they have currency controls. So you can't, the money stays in Brazil.

And it was like, oh, nobody told us that. So obviously for now, we're pretty careful about keeping the costs low and growing the verticals with local revenue. There's also a lot of value in these huge gatherings that we're building up. They are fundamentally global, there's Silicon Valley or Washington. So building these global networks of CEOs, of political leaders kind of feeds that network.

So that's been valuable. But we're, I don't know, we're careful as part of it. That's one thing I learned from about it. Yeah, I mean, yeah, the high-flying VC era has produced a generation of very conservative the operators. Yeah, that's right.

We have to take a short break here. We'll be back in just a minute. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project, one after accounting another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where O2 comes in. And all in one business management software that brings every part of your business together.

From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform, no messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs and best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at ODU.com.com. That's ODOO.com.com. What if we told you there was one thing you could eat to reduce your risk of death by about a quarter?

Interested? And what if we added that this magical substance can dramatically lower your cholesterol, improve your mood, and keep your weight stable? No, it's not protein. It's actually fiber, the least sexy, most overlooked nutrient of all. But what is fiber?

How could one nutrient do all those amazing things? And how can you get enough? Is a powder you stir into some water going to do it for you? All that plus the strange tale of the Gorilla poop obsessed, father of gornth likes in the latest episode of Gastropod. Find Gastropod and subscribe.

Wherever you get your podcasts. We're back with some of our editor in chief, Ben Smith talking about what he thinks makes some of four different. The other big innovation I want to talk to you about the beginning of semaphore and then I want to start talking about what we're doing now is the semaphore. You launched with this way of writing an article. You still use it to this thing.

I see it all the time. And the thesis was that it would just sort of make it simpler to understand what all the different pieces are. And I always thought it was funny because you were chasing the most elite audience possible. And presumably they could already understand what's going on. Well, that's the problem.

They could understand what's going on. And what is going on in a newspaper article is we have like a who, what, where, why sentence? And then you have another sentence that says the same thing. That is from an expert but just reflects whatever the reporter thinks and they pick the expert with their bias to repeat. And then you have like an unsupported paragraph of random theories called the nut graph and everything else is just a risk-rena-latch order.

And I think particularly the, well, an expert in disinformation says this or an expert in democracy says this. I think like any reader sees, oh, this is what the publication thinks. This is what the journalist thinks. Why don't they just say it rather than do this weird move of filtering your biases through an expert and particularly a sophisticated audience. Like they're in on the joke a bit and they're two sides to it because one is that the journalist is required to smuggle their opinion or their analysis in and other people's voices.

The other is that really good beat reporters are real experts. And I suppose you actually want to know what Maggie Haberman thinks to a really high degree. They don't want her to, because the other deal and the new papers you can seal your own analysis and opinion. And I think on both sides of that, the reader is sort of losing out. Like you're both treating them like an idiot because you're smuggling kind of bias and opinion in.

And then also your particularly is just truly a really senior experience of your reporter who already never got a or a just ever like the reader wants to know what they think. Like tell me what you actually think. And so the some forms in it tempt to separate like here are the facts of the story we can all agree on. Here's the journalist's analysis. By the way, for an analysis to be interesting, there's got to be some chance it can be wrong.

Otherwise, it's totally banal. And so then we go out of our way to try to find some of you disagrees with us to include that too. And I think people like that. It's a bit of humility also. Back in my day, we just call it this blogging.

I would just write down what I thought all the time. I would say this was influenced by blogging. We're all bloggers now. It's so embarrassing to explain to people that you used to blog. I mean, what do I run to this day?

It's still fundamentally the reporter say what they think. The reason I asked about this is the idea that it will be explained to people who had a podcast. Yeah, it's just to be my EFR, no legs. The reason I asked about the format in particular, right, is my thesis is that distribution and formats shape each other. Some form was a new format.

It's a way to go reach an audience and say, okay, we know you're not stupid. We're going to show you the structure of the story way out loud. Has it been successful? Has it actually succeeded in tracking audience or is it just the trademark of how you do things now? Yeah, I mean, we hear a lot about it from our audience.

I think we really like it. We also do a lot of shorter form stuff. And so that's not always broken out that way. But that kind of value of we're going to be really humble. We're going to be really assertive about what we think, but also very, very open to disagreement.

Very clear about the difference between the fact and analysis. That's really core to our DNA and everything we do, including the events. Let me ask you a couple of questions. I want to just talk about what's going on in this industry now. Because I think you've learned a lot and it's like four years, seven, fours have been going.

Yeah. And those are all the big, early bats. And I just want to check on them. How big is seven for now? I've got about 60 journalists, more than 100 employees.

And then so 60 journalists, 100 employees, how is all that structure? I'd say more than 100. It's about half journalists, half commercial team that ranges from a revenue team. It includes a great events production team. We do all that stuff in-house.

But I think part of the luxury of a startup and part of the challenging news, you're inside at the moment one or two companies that have cracked this. But there's not a lot of talent on the business side of news. For obvious reasons, it's a terrible business. You go to Harvard Business School. 30% of those people go into enterprise sales and we point 0.01% go into media.

Just for the obvious reason that they like to make money, they look around for where the money is. It's not in media. And I think we've been incredibly aggressive about trying to recruit really, really great commercial operators and people on our revenue side. It's fun to be in a place where the wattage on the business side is really, really high. And that's been a real luxury for us.

But we have a more, and then events is a real, we have bookers, we have producers, we have people thinking about the vibes and the music. I think we take all that stuff really seriously. Do you think in-house DJ? I would call Brigida and his DJ. I think that would be a reasonable thing to say.

I think I'll do it. When we did the code conferences. Just a lot of other stuff. I spent a lot of time thinking about the Spotify list. Yeah, you know what I think about that stuff.

Actually, that brings me to the other end of the question. I asked everybody, you have a lot of decisions to make. You've grown up a lot over the past four years and some of them for how do you make decisions with the camera? I think I make decisions personally, personally. Like not as a semaphore role that personally is the question.

I do. I do. I mean, I personally make decisions very, very, very fast at very high volume, but I'm very attentive to the people around me when they think it's a mistake and quick to reverse them. I care a lot about hiring great journalists and having people who I really trust and rarely jam a decision to anybody's throat. I think I want to be surrounded by people who are really defects in what they're doing, whether it's managing or building AI tools or reporting.

But I think I'm very happy to lose fights. So this is a new business you're describing. You want to make a lot of decisions fast. You're growing a lot of different areas. Every time I see you in person, I bring you a new journalism ethics problem.

This is a real recurring theme in our relationships. I'm always struggling to be pure of heart. Well, you come from the most corrupt corner of journalism, which is gadget reviews. I think you've appropriately figured out that in that dark cave, ethics is this incredible thing for the very incredible way for the verge to distinguish itself. Literally, we say to our audience, we are selling you this policy that you can be bought.

Maybe that's the right thing. I look at some of the creators and I look at some of the my brigades and I think maybe that's the wrong thing, but that's what it goes. I'm curious. I started by playing that clip of John and Friday saying, if they'd only paid for news, they'd retain relevance and charisma, maybe the blue up would be better. I'm looking at a media ecosystem where it feels like actually there's a lead capture of traditional media.

He's gonna be, he's depending on your point of view, either trying to get out of his or another deal or he's dead set on it and changing it. However he wants to change it, through his family, there's ownership of TikTok. Brendan Carr is follinating at the FCC about what happens on the broadcast stations. He wrote an entire chapter of Project 2025 about regulating content moderation on platforms. I see more influence on the media from that side of the house than ever before.

You're in it. That's the audience that you aggressively try to go out and attract and monetize informaries. How do you view all of that right now? I think these are really different things. I think we're in this moment of politicized wealthy individuals buying media companies and using them to curry favor with the White House.

That's a very specific thing I've never heard. Incredible. I think in some sense, if you're media has always been like, if you actually are delivering something your audience wants, that gives you independence. They want you to be asking tough questions. They want you to be delivering them true facts and insight.

I do think there's always a temptation, particularly for places that don't have strong business models to start making ethical compromises. You see it all over the place. I do think that because you're in the gadget review space, you see it so clearly. I think it's true in every space. The core thing of journalism and what makes it interesting is the adversarial quality, the independence of the people you're asking questions of, the people you're covering.

Businesses like advertising, obviously complicate that. If you don't hold on to that independence, you're giving away the whole story. We think obsessively about that. I do think that for businesses that like innovating, it's just so important that you actually do not want to innovate in the field of ethics. That's the one space where nobody should be innovating or you should be very, very careful.

If you think about why our marketing conference is so boring, it's because they aren't doing tough independent interviews with the people. I think our events are interesting because we're doing tough independent interviews and giving that away is enormous. It would be enormous. Can I ask you a really direct question on that? You're doing Silicon Valley in the world, which is the big new conference.

This is you saying you're going to compete with Dallas. You're going to put on a bunch of conferences like this that compete on the big stage. You're convening people as I've been told. It looks at your announcement. You're going to invite me to it.

On the board is Jensen and Satchandela. They're advisors, but we're going to do challenging journalism. How does that work? It's a reasonable question. It's a feature of the convening business.

There's someone new business to me too. First of all, we're thrilled that Jensen and Andy Jassy are going to be there and we're going to be doing news on stage interviews with them. It is a feature of that business. If you look at the way The New York Times and the Wall Street Journal and are the competitors Bloomberg do it, part of building a community around these events and getting excitement around them is pulling the people who the news makers are interviewing into the event in some way. The New York Times calls them task forces.

The Wall Street Journal calls them a council. The Bloomberg actually calls them advisory board, but the journalism is totally independent of them. But how does that work? I did the co-conference. I remember thinking I really need to get so-and-so CEO to show up on stage.

If the day before they get on the jet to show up in California, where so-and-so-see I was deeply corrupt. Here's our eight month investigation. They're probably going to cancel. I was like, well, that's going to be fine. That'd be great, actually.

I'll get on stage and be like, they canceled because they can't take it. But at the same time, I knew that the people buying the tickets probably were buying the tickets to see so-and-so appear on stage. And this never actually came to a head. This never actually probably was just always in my mind. Maybe you weren't doing enough exercise.

Should I be causing this problem more? How do you think about that? I mean, you can cover these companies at a really high level. Yeah, I mean, I think we do, obviously, write stories that they don't like all the time. I think we try really, really hard to be fair.

We don't think we're trying to stand back people. But I also think, I mean, there are two different things. One is, right, did you write a story that upset them and they canceled on you? I mean, that's just that. You just got to be willing.

That's just the cost of doing business journalism. That'll happen. And you just can't think about it. I do think that we are trying to be grown up and fair. And one of the things that I've noticed is there's a sense, particularly if you go to these conferences that are not run by journalists, that you don't want to ask the hard question.

You're a little nervous of like other core questions in the CEO's business or in the politicians' leadership that is sort of awkward to ask. But of course, that's the question that the CEO since all his time are heard time thinking about. And not only are they ready for it, they thought about it more than anybody else. They're eager to engage on it. And so I think it's like a weird illusion that senior leaders don't want to be asked hard questions.

That's crazy. All they do, like the reason they're in those gigs is because they find it really interesting. They're much either relaxing jobs. And so if you're asking, if you're looking forward and you're not asking him, how are you not about this crisis of China just swallowing their business? What are you doing?

But I think there is an impulse, which I think is totally wrong, to tip to around the hard questions. I actually think for CEOs, for political leaders, it's boring for them to go on stage and ask a bunch of tell the same canned anecdotes of other personal biographies that go a thousand times. They're there to answer questions. Yeah, this is my, I'm always asking various comments. Why do they see how it's going to show?

They are YouTube comments. Why would they show up? The answer I've most commonly gotten is this is the only way their own employees will listen to them. They want to see the challenge and the stakes and the conflict of you as you've described are present in this format, whereas no one's listening to the audience. Yeah, I think it's important that you'd be respectful.

I do think there's a slice of tech journalism that really concluded that the people they cover are monsters. And I think it's probably hard to get those folks to talk to you then. And then, and then, and then, and then, conversely, there's a slice of the tech industry that has concluded all journalists are in a sort of deep conspiracy to destroy them. And like, I mean, there's, I think that both of those slices of media culture have kind of run their course and are both kind of toxic and boring at this point. Everybody should stop, but and just cover these people like important decision makers and the real great stories.

But yeah, but I think that's just the news business. And yeah, and so, yeah, so this week we care a lot about our independence and about our journalism independence and build it deeply into the events. I think it's one of the slices on either side, right? Like our own audience is like the all of these people are monsters and they're reading a tech website. I look at most of the politicians in America have, they've come around to like, maybe we should stop the data centers.

Or we should at least talk about it because we talk about it after a decade of talking about regulating social media and not being on big tech and doing nothing. We've never passed a privacy law in this country. You see there's a lot of heat around these guys are monsters. We can just throw sticks and stones at them. And then on the other side, they own the distribution channels, right?

They're just on X doing whatever they want to do. And there's a sense that they don't need the accountability. Mars software just published what a 6500 word manifesto that in my estimation is like freshman year political science thinking. And you're just going to get away with it because there's literally no one around him to be like, try being smarter than this. Do you see that connection at your events where the thing you need to challenge these executives on is people think you have bad values, not your business decision?

I think when you are interviewing somebody where there's like a core critique of the thing they're doing that is the values. Like you should definitely ask them. That's the question they've been thinking about too. I actually kind of disagree with you on the AICO. So I think we're moving out of an era where you had kind of business leaders.

They're like marketing to a sort of patient zero of this. Like very, very smart guy, very influential influence a lot of people think this way who had this sort of deep paranoia about the media and also then the sense that it wasn't relevant. I think if you look at the really great business figures of this era of the new ones, I would say, Dario Amadai, Sam Altman, Jensen Wong. These are classic showmen who love the media. Or they love the media to hate the media.

But they like Steve Jobs understand and like Donald Trump. They're selling something. Yeah, they're salesmen who see the media as a very important sales channel, which is basically how business leaders have always been. And I think they're running circles around the guys and the women who are sort of sitting paranoid. You know, I don't know if we can talk to this reporter.

Like they just pick up the phone, right? And they're on the cover and they wear the leather jacket and they do whatever the sort of slightly corny but incredibly effective time magazine cover style thing is obviously the legacy media is diminished in their new outlets. But fundamentally, they're showmen who aren't operating out of some kind of deep theoretical relationship with media that they plan to change. And Elon obviously the big exception to this role as of many. I think the rest of this new generation of business leaders have a much more normal relationship with the media.

One of the things I think is really interesting in that context is the rise of the news creator, the news influencer, where they aren't of the machine, the way that you're of the machine. They don't have a Justin Smith thing. Like I've built a global news operation. You just do the recording on a new business. By the way, all the big print newspapers have task courses.

We will have a global conference in the top of the penance, right? The influencers and creators I talk to, this is all a first impression for them. And the idea that they can be applied with gifts or access or made to seem more important, they feel it. They struggle with it in a deep level. A lot of our industrialists now, a lot of our politicians understand that that is a faster route to a bigger audience and there's more influence to be had there over the content, over the editorial.

How do you compete with that? I think you have to have sort of courage in your conviction that people want journalism. Like that people actually would like true facts rather than lies and independent voices rather than ones that are corrupt. And I think that's broadly and that's very optimistic view. I think that's broadly true.

And I think you're seeing that the most interesting and most successful creators are also finding that. Like I think the great, like the crowd caster at Rakhash Patel. Like his questions have gotten tougher and tougher because I think his audience is very sophisticated. And I think he realizes his audience if you're interviewing Jensen about kind of how he thinks about chips in China. You just ask him the hard questions, not the easy ones.

And that's more interesting. And it's so obvious. And I think journalists who sort of admire or worry about creators, there's some lacking the courage of your own convictions. No, no, it's more interesting to ask hard questions than easy ones. Do you need a person to shout to me and ask the questions?

I think this is the dynamic that I see several places. With the podcasters and the creators, I think what they're learning is that their audiences are durable. So you don't need the famous person. You don't need the Apple access to get into the audience. So you have a big audience.

You can do whatever you want. And my formulation of that is the less access you need the more you get. That's a hard lesson to learn at the beginning. Yeah, and there's an old saying that access is a curse. And I think you see in Washington, I think you see this in Washington.

You see this in Washington, if you remember, but in the beginning of the Trump administration, there were all these influencers in the White House press conferences asking Kyle and Levitt how she does her hair. And the thing is, I think they found in their audience is found that that was extremely boring. And they kind of wandered off to talk instead about paranoid fights with Candace O and whatever. And similarly, the Pentagon in particular brought in all these, what they saw as allied pliable right-wing influencers to replace the hated mainstream media. And then when they were started, like Gateway Pundit is grilling PXF about the war and he doesn't have answers because I think there are a lot of toxic things about audience capture and you can be pulled all sorts of crazy places by your audience, but also you can be pulled to journalism by your audience.

And I think actually what you saw in that Pentagon press room was that their audiences were nervous about the war and did not like it. And so suddenly PXF is being grilled by these pet outlets that he put in there to avoid dealing with real questions. And there was some sense of like, oh, journalism isn't a trade that you learned in journalism school. It is actually serviced your audience that anybody can figure out if you were paying attention. We're going to pause here for another quick break. We'll be right back.

We're back with some of our editor-in-chief Ben Smith discussing the responsibility journalists have to ask people and power uncomfortable questions. One of the really interesting things to me about that dynamic in particular with the Pentagon is so many of the journalists that put in there were video first. They were making clips. I could see them in those references, try to get a clip. And they knew the video would play and then the platforms were in conflict.

And the comments were like, what do you think Sam Donaldson was doing in the White House for 1980? This is not the, these are stages for performance. Oh sure. Who was a, was Nukingrich figure out C-Span was a, those stage for him? Yeah, I understand. But the clip economy in particular, right?

They're going to manufacture a clip and maybe it's the audience pulling you towards journalism. Or maybe it's just the algorithm pulling you towards conflict. Yeah. They're good polls in there about polls. It's hard to tell the difference.

You're doing more video now. And that's right next to you. The semiform is there to expose the structure of the journalism because our audience is really smart and their CEOs. And then you're going to go make video on video platforms and you're going to experience that other poll. How do you think about managing that? Are you not chasing?

No, we think about it a lot and not chasing scale on video, but trying to have really high level conversations. You know, I think that, you know, did a big, but not the biggest audience for really sophisticated conversations with leaders in media or in, or in, or in our business shows, CEOs on our CEO signal show, other stuff we're going to be launching. But I do think that video, it's, it just reminds me so much of the social web. It's said this, this, the kind of allure of infinite scale. If you just follow it toward this sort of fixed point that everyone else is also going toward.

And it's incredibly like homogenizing force. Like everybody is doing, you know, everybody on the left is doing like Barry Ways outrage this week. And everybody, and it's very, very hyper-partisan. So no, I mean, I think we just like have really had a lot of internal conversations about resisting that. How do you make money if you're in a chase going video?

You have to reach a really high quality audience. And you're just going to bake the ads in. Are you going to do the ad reads? This is like the other big problem of creator world, right? Is platforms don't pay you any money? They've certainly learned to pay people less money.

Yeah. I mean, yes, we do integrated campaigns with direct sold advertisers. I don't know. You, I think you do host reads. I noticed, I think I noticed that, that I had lots of my favorite, one of my second favorite show is doing host reads.

This is like the biggest talk in all of me. Yeah. But I think, I think that like the principle of journalism and independence is incredibly important. The forms change. And when you're in these moments, when I remember this, Google, the ads used to be in yellow.

They had a yellow overlay and a buzzfeed. We were like, okay, that's the convention. We'll have a yellow overlay on our ads. That's how you know it's an ad. And then Google removed it. And it was like, oh, I guess that's not the convention.

I guess that's going to be the same color as everything else. I think these things are, you know, signals to the audience and the forms change through time. And again, you just, you don't want to be, again, you don't be like innovating the field of ethics, but you have to realize that the forms are changing. So my hardest to take about all these platforms is Google made the ads not yellow, and then it made them look like the content. And then it changed the economics of the web, such as the only profitable thing to publish on the web is marketing content and listicles about what shoes to buy when you go hiking.

And now that's all that shows up in the I-O-R. And then, meta started charging you to distribute those. Right. And so everything became advertising. And the economics of YouTube actually YouTube just made it harder to make money.

They changed the rules of their partner program. The only way you can make real money as a creator and have your big staff is if you get an advertiser, or an ad agency. And that is the pull of all these platforms is we're not going to pay you anything. We're going to take the content for free. Maybe we'll even train our AI on it. And you will integrate advertising it somewhere.

I get what you're saying about not innovating an ethics. But as someone who has resisted the many, many, many demands of the hostries and the checks that come along with it, that's the innovation. We're making the reporters read the ads now. Yeah. I mean, in the old days, the hosts read the ads and the old days of TV and radio, then they stopped.

Now they do it again. I guess I don't really see that as like, I don't maybe there's some studies saying they were more corrupt than they were left. But I don't really see any evidence of that. I just think these are kind of forms. You know, they used to be front page advertising newspapers was considered like horrifically corrupt.

And now they do it all the time. I mean, so I think some of this stuff you'll get caught up on the forms in a medium that's just changing really, really fast. No, I mean, I think we wanted great, amazing advertising that our advertisers are really happy with and works for them. I mean, that's just core to the business. And so it is another nice thing about starting from scratch is that you can, and I do think you can, there's a difference between when you're building immediate companies, you have done thinking about, oh, like, this is a product that our audiences are going to love and advertisers are going to love.

And in that kind of like, you know, neonatal state church and state can talk to each other a lot. Yeah. Once you launch the thing, they've got to be really independent. Yeah. This is, I think that just a core challenge for a time, especially if you want to make something that gets wide distribution.

You want to start a newsletter on Sub-Sacker, Ghost or Beehive and charge a lot of money to a small audience. I think you can do pretty well. Your ability to have massive impacts gets immediately limited, as you've said, right? There's a cap on your audience size. It seems like you want to have the big impact to retain the elite audience.

Yeah, and that is a way to build a big business without reaching huge scale is to reach an audience, a very, very valuable audience. I mean, it's not the only way to build a media company. You wouldn't want to be in a world where that was the only kind of media company, but we are totally, totally focused on that. And it is working and it is allowing us to hire great journalists to bring stories. One of the things that I consider with our audience all the time, because we were free until about a year ago, I mean, huge audience, and they were just very aware of any of our potential biases.

And maybe this is just a tech audience. We have lots of commenters. You love Apple. Everything is going to be pro Apple. It's like, that is just a firmament and what your tech publication stands, I think. But I don't know, Comcast was an investor in Vox Media and Vox Media.

And we would have to disclose that Comcast didn't like me, but we would disclose it all the time. There's just some part of what we think the audience is smart. They're going to lead audience to understand the structure. They might understand the biases that come with having Jensen on the Board of Advisors. I think you mentioned Saudi royalty on your Board of Advisors. How do you feel about that?

Oh, I don't think they understand what we're doing quite clearly and in fact, like... Do they think the back gets them influence? Because that's what not a consumer audience definitely believes. I don't know what they think, but our promise to them is that it doesn't and that we're covering these people independently. In fact, a lot of the people in these advisory boards have diametrically opposed interest to one another.

There's no journalistic kind of follow-through. That any more than being on the dealable task force influences what you see in the New York Times. I do think though, in the biggest sense, as you said, just to go back to me earlier, the everything is marketing. And also, I think that in corners of media, including our corner, I think we've managed to hold the line on this. But I think if you look at a lot of social video and particular platforms like TikTok, I mean, just totally undiscloated advertising is everywhere.

And it really distorts how people see the world. And in terms of just people's judgment about what's working, what's real, what's not real. And I think there's actually a lot in the AI space because there is so much... There's so many sort of anecdotes out there or videos of people doing incredibly cool things with this tool or that tool. And you just never really know what's marketing and what's not, what's just literally paid for and what's not.

We're doing a project that I'm very excited about called Semaphore Innovation Atlas. It's like just literally trying to report out, here are some cool, really public sector AI projects that are real. Because there's so much out there that's just unreal. But that tells a good story, which is in a way the job of marketing. I had a partner in a very, very large consulting firm telling me they had done hundreds of AI deployments, and less than two dozen had yielded positive ROI.

And I thought, well, can you just tell me that on the record? I mean, it's like, absolutely not. We want hundreds more. And we're in that moment, where everything goes marketing, everything goes corrupt. And the thing I'm just pushing at is the audience, their base assumption, regardless of how elite the audience is, is that everything is corrupt. And I find the higher up we go, the assumption that things can be bought and paid for increases.

I just think you have to, I think we live in a very populist moment. And the sort of widespread belief that things corrupt is just to diffuse a society. And it's partly justified. And by the way, it's partly not. Like my favorite example, this is a congressional stock trading thing, where there's a lot of research.

I'm sure our corrupt numbers people aren't running stocks. It's never been a big problem. And there's no studies showing that it's widespread. And to try to disabuse people of this, they passed a law several years ago saying that members of Congress have to disclose their stock trades. And now there are all these accounts, finding members of the 400, whatever numbers of Congress, some of them are winning, some of them are losing.

If you only look at the ones who are doing well, you can tell a story about widespread corruption. And now everyone believes it's incredibly corrupt. As a result of a transparency measure that actually showed it wasn't. And so I just think there's just obviously a moment where there's this deeply baked in sense that every institution is corrupt. And we try by being really transparent and really direct, and by not compromising on this stuff, to send a message to counter that.

But I think that's, obviously as you say, you're kind of swimming against a big cultural tide right now. Yeah, I mean, just at the version. No, I think the way, I also think that for us, like a big part of the marketing of our events and the way we make them good is that there's going to be a festival of news where we ask real questions. It's going to be exciting. Just at some point, I think called some of our world economy, Davos, with follow-up questions.

That's pretty good. But in any case, I think that to me, as for you guys, saying we don't take freebies in reviewing gadgets, I think that's a huge selling point. And I think you got to really lean into that, not away from it. The thing that gets me now is the reason I think we can market it. If I was 10 years ago saying the verge has an ethics policy, all of my competitors would say, plus a week.

Right? Like, I think why are there so many people reporting, a lot of the way they market their great reporting is they just say out loud. Look at all this reporting. We do it. Buy our subscription. I think it's totally effective. I think they've cracked some code there by just saying out loud.

Turns out people like journals. They do their reporting. People pay for it. I think that's very smart. What has occurred to me in all that is, particularly our youngest audience, does not know. They did not come up the same way.

The water they've been swimming in their entire lives is social media, is integrated brand campaigns by creators, is a feed that is increasingly fake and bought and paid for. And I'm not sure that us showing up and saying, you know, there's an old way of doing this. I kind of disagree. I think people basically don't want to be lied to and don't want to be fed slop. I think you're headed for some kind of reckoning, like the big pay-all list scandals in the radio industry.

This is what I want. Everybody inside the radio industry kind of knew that the only thing we got on the radio was totally open secret that we get your song to the radio as you pay off the DJ. But turned out the audience was not in on the joke. And when Congress held hearings into it, it totally blew up the industry and I've ended everything. And I think, with particularly with influencer marketing, with political influencer marketing, people hate that.

And I just got to think Congress is going to come in and crack down. I'm actually optimistic about that. I think it's Adam Schiff just a reporter recently who introduced a bill on it. That probably won't be the one. Everybody hates this. The idea that your favorite influencer is being bribed by some politician, the idea of people do not like that.

And I think they're going to, I think that disclosure, which is mostly in effect or somewhat, in effect, with big brand marketing, like Papsico buys an ad, they're going to disclose that. There's a lot of shady stuff happening around the margins. And then politics, because there's this like chasm between the F.E.C. federal elections commission which sort of collapsed and the F.T.C. which regulates other advertising.

There's all this undisclosed and undiscosable political advertising. I just do not think that it's people like that. I think that's going to wind up having to be regulated. I'm sure so. There's a recent story. I think it was Politico. And it was basically saying all of the young staffers on the right have no idea how to do anything because they're all like comms people like they're all influencers. And there's like a talent shortage.

I think Madison Cawthorn was like the, he was the bellwether. He came to office and he's like, I've got more comms people than policy people. And then very quickly, I can't clear that wasn't going to be great. But now that's the norm that we're all just tweeting policy into existence. Right? We're going to stop your annual tweets is a real thing that happens once a week in this country.

There's something there that's broken. Right? Like political influence operations. Maybe we hate when they're paid for, but they are politics now and they're part of the feed in a very real way. Yeah. I think sometimes in really damaging ways this administration and this was incredibly responsive to social media. And so some, so a story goes viral on Twitter and somebody gets their immigration status pulled because there's a piece of it from a woman who's in ice holding because there was a sort of misleading campaign saying her husband had worked for the, for her husband's mother had been a translator for the Iranians in the 70s. And so she's now in an ice holding cell.

And the administration acted because this went viral on social media. There's always obviously been a very intense relationship between the media and the politicians. I mean, the New York Times published a story and then Chuck Schumer, the next day, introduced a piece of legislation is like the oldest trick in the book. And so, but there is, I don't, I actually, there's not been my experience of Republican staffers in Washington that they're incompetent. I think they're like, I live in New York and often go to Washington and I've been watching a lot in people in the sort of my liberal, Brooklyn neighborhood will sort of say like, God, it must be so horrible to deal with those Trump people.

And the reality is actually they're incredibly polite and responsive. And it was an opportunity often to deal with the Biden people because Democrats as a journalist think that you work for them. And that writing something independent is an active betrayal and as those Republicans have either appropriate or lower expectations. And that's always been true. I guess that communication has always been a pretty important part of politics. But there's a way in which the, the disorganization of this administration in particular just means that they're totally reactive to random pieces of media that somebody plays Donald Trump on an iPad that is really different.

Yeah. I just see that we're going to tweet policy into reality is a feature of this administration. There's not a lot of rigor under that policy often. Often, yeah. Right. And you're often somebody else just tweets something that goes viral. I mean, this was the story of Doge's mosque was just seeing tweets and making policy based on it.

Yeah. Does that do you think that has come to an end? We're saying people hate these political influence operations that probably they will get regulated in some because both sides hate the idea that all the influencers will be paid for by politicians. No, right now we're like in the worst part of it. Yeah. This is definitely the although you're seeing the federal government that had a lot of momentum and ability to execute things that sort of lost all of that.

So the way that I mean, there's much less able to do anything right now. So there's less happening. Yeah. This is what I wanted to wrap up is it's going to break somehow, right? There's some kind of reckoning coming where people want the truth. People don't trust the tech companies. The antipathy towards AI in particular is high.

But the tech companies and a bunch of billionaires own all our distribution in very significant and serious ways. And something is going to happen, right? The audiences are going to change in some way. There will be some reactions somehow. Do you have a view of that? Yeah. I mean, I think this stuff keeps changing.

I mean, I do think there is a temptation to validate the populist impulses of the moment that actually journalism probably resists sometimes. And I heard your interview with Gabby about data center politics in which she pointed out that, you know, like, I loved her anecdote about how the, like, a bunch of there was a rumor that going around that the data centers were killing cattle and she tracked it down to one Texas farmer who had lost one cow. And I actually think the role of journalism is not always to amplify the populist reaction, even though it's so easy and social media validates that. So I think it's a little more complicated. I actually would hesitate to predict whether things are getting better or worse. Yeah.

So the value in the world is coming up. If I had to make one prediction of the midterms, it would be that surveillance and data centers will cause some sort of left, right, realignment. They scramble the lines in very populist ways. Yes. But they also cause alignment, right? They bring together very disparate groups of people. How do you expect that class of billionaires at all wants things to react to what I feel like will be a surprising story in the midterms?

I mean, I think that I think there are different, different strains of this. Like, I think the data center story, which right now is so hot and maybe I'm in the minority here. I think most people think this will be a huge political issue for a long time. I think like companies trying to build facilities in people's neighborhoods and then they go in and they sponsor the little league team and they pay a bunch of carpenters and they sponsor the parade. Like, that is actually something corporate America is pretty good at and it's unbelievable how badly they screwed this up.

It's really bad. It's really bad. But I actually think that is because they aren't actually causing stillborn cattle. Like, I think fundamentally with the exception, they're going to have to navigate the energy. They're going to have to find a way to not elevate energy prices.

But I think some of that probably does fade as companies figure out how to do this without infuriating neighborhoods and doing it in place. People want it. I think that maybe becomes less of an issue. I think the big questions around regulating AI are just fascinating. And right after, as you said, not regulating social media and then sort of beginning the Trump administration with this incredibly accelerationalist point of view, they are now just doing it.

They're just regulating this technology day to day. They're going to have to figure out a framework for it. Every political candidate will have to have some point of view on it. It's pretty unpredictable though, what this is going to be. But I do think we're in a new era.

And then particularly the biggest part of the new era is just that the federal government is now this huge participate in the economy and in the economy of tech. And his own is a big chunk of intel is trying to shape technological policies, picking winners and losers. Executives are in Washington constantly trying to make their case. I think that whoever the next president is, that probably doesn't change. And that's a really massive structural shift that we're all going to be covering.

Do you think that you can run as a populist if you want to take a big stake in the REA companies? Is that a redistributive move? I mean, I don't think populism is necessarily that. I think that there are lots of... I wouldn't get too far into the details.

It just depends how you talk about it. To seem like the theme of the day in Washington. But what do they say about some simple solutions to complex problems? Yeah. Trump has compared those stakes in companies to sovereign wealth funds.

Yeah, that's reasonable. A lot of Gulf states have. I actually wanted to ask about this. You cover the Gulf deeply, you've got events in the Gulf. The United States, I would say, is in some kind of free speech crisis that is modeled a lot after the control that Gulf states have over their media and what people are not allowed to say.

But Kushner family is all wrapped up into that. How do you think about all of the things you talk about in Independence when you have that money in your organization, when you have those folks on your various boards of events when you have journalists on the ground in those places? Yeah. So we cover Saudi and the Emirates, particularly a lot, pretty aggressively hired the great reporters from Bloomberg and the Journal and places like that in the region. We don't have any investment money from the Gulf and from any sovereigns, just to be clear about that.

They're on your board. Yeah, there are some executives from the world on the advisory boards. But yeah, we cover them independently. They're the same as the FT and the Journal and others do in that region, which in the times, and it is like if you talk to reporters who are in the region, it's very, very hard and complicated. And you do, and you just have to, and there are local laws that you have to be careful about.

I think we're the only ones to write about a very interesting story, the way in which the Emirates, I believe, were preventing photojournalists from distributing images of the, and that's just a lot. Like if your photographer goes and takes a picture of a drone that hit a building, they will arrest them. And so I think every news organization that operates in that region that operates in China, you just have to be really, really careful and thoughtful about it. But you can't let it compromise the reporting. Yeah. Do you feel like it compromised the reporting here in the United States?

No. I think that global news organizations actually, and I think you think about the New York Times, which has reported in Tehran. I mean, there are a lot of global news organizations that thought really hard about, I think there are stories that you write, that you have your correspondent in Washington, right, that you wouldn't have somebody on the ground in Tehran, right? And obviously, we think a lot about the safety of our reporters, but it's a complicated question. I ask that question because I see what the Trump administration does to journalists here, right?

Yeah, I would actually, it's funny because I think that we obviously are in this, as you said, kind of a free speech crisis here in all sorts of ways. I don't think it's like a monarchy that doesn't have the first amendment. I think we're a long way from that. And to me, the closer parallel to the Gulf is the kind of personalist rule, the people talk a lot about corruption, but I think when you think about these relationships often, it's a totally different style of doing business where you're helping your friends and family. But that's just, it's like a totally different modality that obviously in the American tradition is incredibly corrupt, but you've got other parts of the world, and that's just the nature of business.

And I think that's parts of the Trump administration is evaporate that way. Yeah. I think the Trump family in particular sees that as a model. That was a comparison I was making. You can see them enriching themselves, particularly that part of it.

I do think that like elements of the style of doing business is more like other parts of the world. I think that obviously is a lot of the speech stuff here is terrible, but it's really not like somebody who, it's not like being in a country that first amendment. Yeah, fair enough. Lastly, I just want to talk about AI in your newsroom for one second. We talked a lot about AI in the industry.

You make a lot of stuff. The poll, especially when you go up and make a bunch of video, is to fire ever more content into these algorithms. We haven't really talked about it. Maybe the only journalistic ethics crisis I've never brought to you is how should we use AI? Because I know that you're such a purist.

So I go back and forth on how I impact it. We'll be right now. I'm like all the way forth on this. We just a colleague of this great internal tool that is too boring to explain, but it's going to totally change all of our lives. And I'm now a huge believer in the saspocalypse.

It's all going away. You cancel the travel contract and you're done. I think some of these internal tooling is amazing. We also produced this report out of some four world economy where we had a five day event with three simultaneous stages, 300 interviews. And I then on Saturday morning texted the team and was like, hey, I know you're all tired.

Everybody write a little, what I learned at some four world economy and everyone's like, and then read out, we got it. Our great tech editor was like, give me a couple hours and dropped all the transcripts into, actually not sure if it was codecs or co-work. And then produced something that was kind of, it was here are the most commonly made statements, here are disagreements, here are disagreements. Then we spent a week hammering through that and actually went up creating a lot more work for humans because the notion of what's the takeaway from these 300 conversations. That's a job for AI, basically.

It's a very hard thing because no one was in all of them. They were simultaneous. And that was a great product that we then released and will continue to build on. So I'm actually very bullish about AI. But fundamentally, the best parts of reporting are gathering new information that is on the Internet and then communicating it with people.

Everything in between is production and is very vulnerable to AI. Those things, I think, are pretty indefensible. That's a good argument. I'm going to come around to it. I promise.

This very much was a conversation, exactly like a conversation we have over beer. Okay, I have an AI question for you. There's a tool that allows you on a podcast if you screwed something up. If you mispronounce somebody's name, just to drop it in with your own voice. So you don't have to go back into the studio and rerecord that sentence.

Is that okay or not? This is not okay or not? We're having it internally. It depends on exactly how misleading you think you're going to be. No, just like you mispronounced my name in the intro.

And your producer is like, hey, can you come back into the studio, it's Saturday morning. So if I mispronounce your name to you. On air. On air. No, I think you're in your intro.

So no, because that's just that I would just pick it up. No, I know, but you have to go into the studio and rerecord that. But you're on a boat doing whatever it is you do. And your producer can just take your voice and re-do it. I honestly think that's fun too.

The deception comes is if I mispronounce your name to you here and then you leave and then I make it better. If I've done something misleading, I'm just picking up audio that you would have never heard by myself and we're just going to do it in an edit. We're editing it in an anyway. Okay, good. I feel the same way.

To me, the line always comes down to who is being deceived. And if you're literally going to deceive the guest and you're going to create a moment that never happened, probably your way over the line. Yeah, honestly, that's a standard practice in television to read the questions. Yeah. I've heard this.

Now they're all getting in trouble. That's probably the answer. Transitions to them. Then this is great. Like I said, this is very much like many of the conversations we've had.

I hope the audience is great. This is great. Thank you so much. I really enjoyed it. I love the show.

Thank you for having me on. I'd like to thank Ben Smith for taking the time to speak with me and thank you for listening. I hope you enjoyed it. If you like this note, you thought about this episode or anything else at all. Drop us a line.

We'll see you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Decoder with Nilay Patel?

This episode is 1 hour and 11 minutes long.

When was this Decoder with Nilay Patel episode published?

This episode was published on August 17, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Decoder with Nilay Patel episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.