Skip to content
IWD - Fixing the Joint episode artwork

Mar 11, 2021 48 min

IWD - Fixing the Joint

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we chat with Samatha Maiden and Jacqueline Maley about the continuing fallout from the allegations of rape and misconduct from inside the Canberra bubble. Your host this week is Tina Quinn.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

IWD - Fixing the Joint

0:00 48:18
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails that keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.

You're listening to Fool This Night, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from Twisia in Sydney on Gagalands of the ER Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the GloVi podcast. My name's Tina Quinn, welcome to the program. Warning, this episode does deal with sexual assault and violence.

If you or someone you know is impacted call 1-800-Respect on 1-800-737-732. Or visit 1-800-Respect.org.au. Well, Australia has just witnessed one of its strangest international women's days. Yes, it was the usual day of celebration and positivity on the surface, but a quick look under the hood revealed it was also a day of distress, frustration and exhaustion.

The reason being because the crisis in Canberra, of course, seems no closer to being resolved. And we're also no closer as a country in moving forward on the fundamental issues of equality, consent and safety. This week, atop a Britney Higgins allegations of rape and the allegations against Attorney General Chris from Porter, the ABC 730 had more allegations, this time into the behaviour of Frank Zimbo. And also Foreign Affairs Minister and Deputy Leader of the Liberal Party, Julie Bishop dropped a bombshell outlining her own experiences within federal politics, including being undermined by a group of Liberal MPs who proudly called themselves the big swinging dicks.

In this edition, in the week of International Women's Day, we ask where to from here for our nation and how will this play out in the media? Joining me on the show to discuss, Samantha Madon, political editor at news.com.au, a longtime member of the Canberra Press Gallery, Samantha has lived in our nation's capital as a political correspondent for over 20 years and is the author of Party Animals, the secret history of a Labour fiasco, which told the story of how and why the ALP lost the seemingly unlosable 2019 election. And Jacqueline Mayley, a former press gallery sketch artist, she has now a senior writer and columnist for both the Sydney Morning Herald and the Age. She previously worked with Guardian in London and the Australian Financial Review.

A debut novel, The Truth About Her, is set to be published next month. Oh, and welcome to you both. Thank you, Tina. It's nice to be here.

Thank you for having me as well. Samantha, I'm going to start with you as I'm sure many people feel that you were really the catapult to the now relentless allegations we're seeing as few fourths. You broke the Britney Higgins story and you coincidentally enough also have a personal connection to the now deceased woman at the centre of the Christian Porter allegations. Canberra has been your home since 1998.

Are you surprised by the sheer volume of allegations we've seen come forward in the past month? No, I'm not surprised because I think that while the allegation of an alleged rape is obviously the most shocking and extreme end of these claims that women have talked about these issues for a long time, I should say though that I think what has really set this bushfire raging is Britney Higgins and she has just been so resolute and so brave that she wanted to tell her story and I didn't imagine and I know that she didn't imagine that it would set off so many days and weeks of coverage but a lot of other people have been coming forward and a lot of other things have happened organically and I know that there are some people who want to suggest that this is some sort of carefully orchestrated plan but it's really not and you know Britney Higgins didn't know that other women would come forward with their other stories. I didn't know that and there was a lot of things that were revealed and came out along the way that shocked me. Jacqueline, you previously worked in Canberra and the press gallery.

What was your experience? Are you surprised by the breadth of allegations coming out? No, I mean my period in the press gallery was fairly short by comparison. It was more or less the life of the Gillard Prime Minister's ship and then I used to bust in and out before and after that just for sitting weeks.

So I had the sort of point of view of not being a lifer I suppose and I thought about it a lot particularly recently the culture of that time and it was a drinking culture, it was a hard work culture, it was a work hard play, hard culture, there was a lot of sex and that happened you know a consensual sex between staff as young people and stuff but I do remember as a young journalist being quite shocked by how prevalent for example ex-emotional affairs amongst politicians were and they were talking about very openly and like I quickly came to the conclusion that they were all at it so to speak and I realised I've just defamed the entire class of people but it really was normalised that it was a place where you could probably get away with behaviour that wouldn't be normal or would not be easily accepted in other workplaces or even just in other places I suppose. Can I just pick up on a point that Jackie made which I think actually fits very neatly with piece that a former labour staffer has written for News.com.au today called Anna Jabor and she has basically spoken about exactly what Jackie's talking about that there's a whole range of behaviours that seem to be normalised. Now I'm not saying this is my experience but the world she described in that piece is almost kind of like a 70s sort of 1970s madman culture where a madman culture where you know there was a lot of extramarital affairs, there's a lot of staffers that are flying in and flying out there's this understanding that some blokes have you know a woman in every court so speak. Now I'm not saying for a second that that is everybody but it's a really interesting observation because you know for most of the time that I have been in Tambora you know I'm a mother of three so I'm virginal of course and you know like it's not really been a culture that I have participated or taken in but there have been times when I thought my god all these people are shagging you know like it just seems to be in some pockets a very sexual culture that there's a lot of sex going on and a lot of that is conceptual sex of course right but I think what we're talking about and this is something that you know Louise Milligan got into with the original Canberra bubble four corners and you know Anna was talking about in the piece today is that this idea that it is a sexualized environment where sometimes women particularly younger women feel like they're kind of there for the taking for these men and it all gets very blurred and confusing because a lot of these men are older than them and more experienced and they press on them how wonderful and intelligent and brilliant and sparkling they are and they kind of then end up in these situations that they're not 100% comfortable with now I suppose that happens everywhere in the world to some extent but you know I think that the kind of you know what stays on to it what happens on to us stays on to it kind of people flying in flying out being away from their home the hard hard working hard drinking culture that Jackie also referred to I think that they're all factors in what the hell is going on here do you think that one of the other key issues here is gender diversity because federal politics seems to have a huge imbalance in that area you know there's very few women compared to men but it's interesting to know that while the workplace culture there hasn't seemed to have moved on from decades ago our public conversation around these issues is completely changing and I think a lot of that is down to there being many more female voices like yourselves in the media which completely changes the dialogue what do you think Jacqueline yeah I agree entirely I think you know I think back to the time in Arts and Canberra and even you know as a journalist you obviously want to have dinner with contacts that was something that's done online in Canberra but just because of the lack of gender diversity particularly at that time you know if you're meeting a group of coalition on labor MPs just casually for a dinner you would it's not unusual that you would be the only young woman you know on a table drinking on so forth with a group of old or middle-aged sort of like so that that in itself is unusual like I don't know if that would happen in any other industries when you kind of networking and in terms of what you've just said about media yeah I think that we have increasingly maybe even just in the last decade senior women in the media who have contributed to a culture where what is considered news and what is considered something that is within the purview of political coverage has shifted and you can see the backlash to that and you can see that there are members of the establishment who don't like that very much at all well I think it's interesting to note that let's cast our minds back to 20, 2018 for instance so the then deputy prime minister barner be joy sent to resign when the daily telegraph broke that he'd had an affair with one of his staffers and that his staff was now pregnant now there were many in the media at the time who thought the story was not just wrong but also beneath them to report on do you think the the high-mindedness and the snobbery from political journalists about covering the political class in that way is actually more protectionist is it is it more to do with the old guard which for the most part is made up of men at Jacqueline to you first I think that with that particular story that particular story represented a shift between the old ways and the new ways it was a very definite inflection point I think probably the older more gentlemanly style of reporting yeah definitely wouldn't have reported on something like that I think in that case it was justified because of the close and unprofessional relationship that Barnaby Joyce who then was a senior member of the government clearly had the staff member and and then Mountain Table you know instituted the famous bonk ban and made as thereafter made a story well that's what he's accused of I actually think you know the bonk ban was an entirely appropriate workplace measure for any leader to put in place in an organization and actually capital was sort of decades behind other organizations in that respect Samantha what's your assessment well it's interesting to remember and this gets a bit sort of lost in the midst of time is that when it was actually revealed by Shari Marks and that Barnaby Joyce was having a baby with his former press secretary he actually didn't quit over that so he actually held a line on that the reason why he quit was that there was an investigation into allegations of sexual harassment involving other women which ultimately ran a drift the national said that they couldn't find enough evidence of this right and that was a very uh urchi affair because the woman who was the complainant didn't want to be identified she was identified you know that's a whole other can of worms right but I do think you know the notion which was very prevalent in the press gallery at the time that it was somehow not a story that the deputy prime minister of Australia had left his wife and had gotten this mistress pregnant and that there were all sorts of questions you know about her being sort of bouts from office to office now there was a lot of work done on looking into their travel and that found nothing you know I mean think Barnaby Joyce and Diki champion were pretty obvious pretty clear on the fact that when they actually went through all their travel that I think that the taxpayers owe them money there was something they could have planned for and they didn't but there were legitimate questions about all of that and obviously you know the bog band sort of weaponized all of that and that was very interesting but of course that is a story right but you know Shari Marks and I think had to endure a lot of tut-tutting and people putting pegs on their noses and acting as if you know it wasn't a matter of public interest that this had occurred when you know and also this idea that this is somehow new and explosive well on one level it is and I actually agree with you know Jackie's assessment of the whole thing but on the other hand I mean come on go back to the 1970s right you know go back to Junie Morosi right like these things have always been reported on when they got big enough that there was a perception that it was interfering with that person's ability to do their job and their interactions with their colleagues and clearly there was a perception among some that that that was the case with Barnaby Joyce so of course it was a story and you know I look I think there's lots of men that do great work in this space right you know Eric Bagshaw from the Sydney Morning Herald obviously broke the original story in 2019 of the two women who said that they had been sexually assaulted when they were liberal staffers right and maybe there's a bit of men sometimes sort of standing back a bit and letting women kind of do the heavy lifting with some of these stories for whatever reason maybe that's going on but I see something different as well which is that when we broke the Britney Higgins story there was a number of news outlets that didn't touch it or barely touched it for several days and you could tell that yeah and you could tell that they thought that this was something that was going to be a one-day wonder and maybe that's also why the Prime Minister's office didn't think to tell the Prime Minister Scott Morrison that I was making next inquiry so spent a whole weekend answering my questions with about five different staffers involved in his office and none of them thought fit to say the Prime Minister oh by the way did you know that there's a formal liberal staffer who's alleging that she was sexually assaulted in the Defence Minister's office and it was really only when two things happened that people started to pick the story up first of all obviously Linda Reynolds publicly apologized and conceded that she shouldn't have had an employment meeting with Miss Higgins in her office in the room where she alleged she was assaulted but more importantly on the Tuesday morning the Prime Minister came out and basically said well you know I've watched the interview that she did with Lisa Wilkins I've spoken to my wife Jen about it he got all sorts of flak for that but to give credit where credit is due he actually elevated the issue and he actually you know essentially you know made a legitimate story that people had to follow it up by taking it seriously and saying that he took it seriously and launching all of these inquiries and it was only then that several mass heads actually got interested in covering this I mean I don't think this journey financial review for example touched it for the first day whereas you would have thought you know workplace issues these are big issues for business that you know it would have been a story but a lot of people didn't want to touch it and then there was also a little bit of some blokes kind of going oh we can't really get in on the kind of inside running of the Brittany Higgins story so let's do the other side you know let's do taking her apart and you know that was interesting to observe as well.

Since the allegations against Christian Porter and made public we've had calls for an independent inquiry do you think do you both think an independent inquiry is the answer smather? Well my personal view on an independent inquiry into workplace culture at Parliament House is of course I should have one and you know I think that that clearly is occurring right that you know the several inquiries already in train and that's something that's going to be looked at. I have a personal view on the Christian Porter matter which is that I can see the arguments around the problems of setting up a sort of quasi-judicial process that operates separate from the legal system. I fully accept that many people disagree with me and have very good arguments about that but I suppose on some level I'm also a pragmatist threat so do I think that the Prime Minister is going to establish some sort of independent inquiry?

No I don't. So I suspect that the best way to actually potentially get some answers is through this coronal inquest option. Now that obviously is very heavily dependent on how wide-ranging the coroner wants to make it but the advantages of that process are as follows. One it would obviously look at the decision to release this woman from a health facility in the days leading up to her suicide the decision to make her quarantine at home without any support and because she was released so you know close together with her suicide and because she contacted the police and she emailed them 24 hours before she saw her suicide.

That's already got the you know the triggers there for a coronal inquest into something to look at. Now through a coronal inquest we may learn more about what she actually said to police about why she wanted to withdraw the complaint it would potentially provide an avenue for her friends and family to provide supporting evidence of all the people that she told for years and some people say she told you know well well before you know recent years there was a very controversial crikey piece that tried to suggest this was some sort of repressed memory situation. She in her own affidavit says it wasn't she says it was something that she always remembered but the coronal inquest would also be able to look at that right they'd be able to talk to her psychologist they'd be able to hear evidence from other friends. It's true that that process would not provide some sort of fit and proper test for the attorney general nor would it make any allegation or could it essentially test criminal allegations but I don't think that that can happen now right like I mean the police have made that clear that you know they don't have a live witness essentially they don't have a sworn statement I don't think any of those things can occur but if you know as Christian Porter says that he is completely innocent of the things that his good name has been beset but besmirched let him give an opportunity to give evidence under oath because you know that would obviously depend on the coroner but you know he has complained of trial by media and I think it's understandable that he feels that way but essentially the media has also been you know that 20 minute press conference whatever it is has been the only time he's been able to you know be asked any questions about this and I think much better to ask him those questions in a courtroom like setting where he is under oath to give those answers and I think that that would be a good thing.

Jacqueline what's your assessment do you think an independent inquiry likes math are suggested really wouldn't really lead anywhere or wouldn't I think it's not going to happen so I think these conversations are so hypothetical I would have issues with whether or not it's would be fair because you know people have made comparisons of the Dyson Hayden investigation that was done by the High Court that was done essentially in secret or in private and nobody knew about it until the report of you know until we sort of broke it and you know the High Court announced the result of it and also look what's the point of it are you declaring that you know is it to determine whether or not Christian Porto is a fit in proper person. I guess that's what some of the what people are really the back saying is he a fit in proper person to serve as our attorney general I think that's yeah so I mean I guess you if you're going to have trouble establishing anything to possibly establishing anything even to the sort of threshold of balance of probability probability is kind of threshold within that forum when you have essentially a dead complainant or an as for a corona link west well that's a sort of different question that's you know as an artist is said that you know that's really wide-reaching and that could be very important for the system for system reform and also for the friends and family of the dead woman that it wouldn't have pertained to Christian Porto himself look I mean I'm hedging on this question because I really don't know I don't know whether it will be fair or effective to have an inquiry into whether or not Christian Porto is a bit proper person to be the attorney general I just don't know. Prime Minister Scott Morrison within the last 24 hours has said and I quote he is a fine attorney general and he is an innocent man under our law. Do you think Scott Morrison can continue to tough this one out?

Samantha? What the Prime Minister said is of course factually correct right? Christian Porto has not been charged he hasn't even really been investigated right I mean the police never even got to you know basically having a formal statement taken from the woman so he is innocent under the law obviously there's a huge group of people that hear those words he's a fine attorney general and he's an innocent man and they find that very triggering because they say well there has been no investigation right but what the Prime Minister says is accurate. Clearly they're going to try and tough it out but you know they've got two problems here I suppose you've got Christian Porto who needs to make a decision of whether you know given what has been extracted from him he says in this process whether he wants to keep going he seemed pretty clear in that press conference and you know that he did want to return because he said if he didn't you know anyone could raise allegations against anyone essentially to story their life and that would be it so I think he's pretty clear he wants to return and then the Prime Minister also has the problem with the defence minister Linda Reynolds has of course referred to Britain Higgins as a line cow she says not in relation to the rape allegations but other matters and so you know there's a bit of a legal tussle going on there.

Yeah I mean will they try and tough it out? Yeah clearly and at this stage at least you know there's every sign that the Prime Minister would have no problem with Mr Porto returning to work you know as soon as he feels able. Morrison's position here seems to be that no police charges equals nothing happened basically. Do you think that's going to continue to pass the pub tester amongst the general community?

Jacqueline? I'm getting say very unsatisfactory poorly again that I just don't know I find it really difficult to judge how this is going to play out in the long term. I tend to think that it is a bit of a sort of misogyny speech moment in the sense that we are seeing a huge diversion of views and a sort of schism if you like in political reporting and in the ability of the system to hold you know both what they say is sort of the rule of law and the presumption of innocence and all those incredibly important liberal and democratic values to hold those hold on to those and also incorporate what women are calling for which is to have their stories listened to to be believed to have the victims of sexual assault be treated with respect and I suppose some a courtesy that they historically have not been treated with I think institutions probably all over the world are dealing with the conflict between those two ideas and those two principles and not many people are doing the perfect job of it but I do think that our government that might in the last few weeks has done a rather bad job of it on a number of levels whether or not they're going to be punished in the next poll I tend to doubt actually but long term whether or not it'll be looked back on with with a historical lens in a different way is sort of quite a difficult or shameful bad moment that's a different question and I tend to think maybe that that might happen within the general community and let's be frank that the media do you think they're already moving on most people's social feeds are now about Harry and Megan and Biden's dog being sent home is this moment for change slipping by Samantha? No I don't think it is and to be honest I mean I think it is a testament to the women involved that this is a story that has now been running for nearly four weeks right Britain against told her story on February the 15th and next Monday when Parliament resumes will be March the 15th and it is very unusual for a story to run this long and this hard and no you don't measure it by a news poll you know I know there were some people that were sort of pointing out that when news poll was taken there was I think one week into the allegations of one week where it hadn't had an episode all the needle hasn't moved there for no one cares well lots of women are talking about this and lots of younger women have been talking about issues of consent which I think is fantastic you know there's that petition that Chantal woman in Sydney has been putting up when lots of people have been having these discussions it's not partisan people have been trying to say it's partisan but actually this is an issue that concerns women the Liberal Party the Labor Party and the Greens and I think there's lots of positive things that have come out of these weeks that people have had a chance to talk about these issues and think about these issues and give pause for thought you know about their coverage and the way that these things have been handled in the past and the fact that community standards are changing so I see a lot of positive things about that but also just picking up something Jackie was saying about the rule of law you know I mean I'm not a trained lawyer but people that are you know Annabelle Crabbe has made some really good points on this that the rule of law is not just about the presumption of innocence you know the rule of law if you want to go back to the magna Carta which seems to be about how we need to go back and raise the weights is also about the rise of normal people to have justice and you know there's a huge debate about whether or not given the very how difficult it is to get convictions in rape because it is as the Peter Dutton said he said she said a fair that I think that it's going to trigger a larger and ongoing debate about whether the rule of law do women who are sexually assaulted and raped and men who are sexually assaulted and raped do they have access to the rule of law you know I think it's a really big important debate and if you go back to you know Julia Gillard's misogyny speech a speech that dropped in a moment of high drama with the speaker and Peter Slipper and all the rest of it and it was a bit lost in that moment and people saw it as a political prison but even then you know people did see at the time that that was a historic speech that it had meaning and that it had power that people were going to debate and you know I do remember that at the time on the Sunday Telegraph where I worked at the time we did have the luxury right of having a few more days to play on our coverage and think about it but our paper on that weekend was full of women talking about that speech foreign against what it meant it was a big debate and we really did talk about those issues in the Sunday Telegraph and it did have a huge reaction you know and sometimes you can't tell what that reaction is until later but you know I mean I caught up in Brittany Higgins today and it has been a you know a life-changing experience for her but you think about what she has achieved by telling her story in terms of all of these inquiries into workplace culture and a debate about changing the employment arrangements for staff and all these things that plug right back into the debate about what is or isn't happening in Craig Kelly's office you know no prime minister or politician is perfect their responses will never give everybody what they want but I think that the prime minister has actually moved to tackle some of these issues and things are changing and will changing and the sex discrimination commission is already saying that she wants to make recommendations about an independent mechanism where people can feel free to go to men and women to complain about their workplace arrangements and I think that we've come an incredibly long way in a month I really do and it might not be perfect and it might not be what everybody wants but I think that you know change has has arrived and things are changing and it may take a generation or another generation of people for things to change further but that's the nature of life and protest movements and change that's the way history works you know but I'm quite positive overall that the issues that are being in are powerful and they're making people think you're listening to Father State on the Community Radio Network and across the Glovire podcast I guess this week is about the maiden and Jacqueline Mayley let's turn to the media's performance in recent weeks I'd like to unpack a number of different threads in recent weeks we've seen some top notch investigative journalism Samantha Well done and you can collect your flower from Dave Sharma after the show but there's there's also been a I think it's not a gerber because I hate gerber because I hate gerber because I hate gerber because I'm very passionate about it very classy about flowers what would you prefer I like a peony but then out of season what a shame but there's also there's also been at times I think divided in the media in regards to the Britney Higgins allegations we've seen parts of the media treat this as a political problem the government is working through or even as a sex scandal when it's clearly about an alleged crime and a toxic work culture through the prism of politics I'd like to get your assessment on where parts of the media have dropped the ball when it came to Britney Higgins Samantha were you surprised or exasperated or were you not shocked by parts of the media that they did not see this for what it was oh of course I wasn't surprised I mean no I wasn't surprised look I mean I think it panned out pretty much entirely as I expected other than the fact that it went a lot longer and stronger than I expected but yeah like I think there has been a bit of a cry of the angry white male about god you know do we have to talk about rape and sexual harassment because it makes me feel very uncomfortable and there's sort of a suggestion that I or whoever's writing about it is a bit grotty and sort of shabby and sex obsessed or something when as you pointed out it's not about sex at all right it's actually about you know allegations of a very serious nature happening in the workplace uh no it hasn't surprised me I mean uh I think it's been entirely predictable okay Jacqueline what's your take I think we have seen two things I suppose I mean I spoke before about the establishment I think that there are certain you know media guardians I suppose of that and they don't like the fact that the rules have changed so this sort of stuff is reportable it's considered news the implications of me too are sort of threatening if you look at it in terms of you know the political coverage it's sort of been the norm and then there's also I think probably just a journalistic ego thing which Sam I think alluded to before which is that like it's not your story like if it's not your story and you sort of don't have the reins on it then you've got to find another way into it or you've got to ignore it or you've got to like try to trash it I suppose if you're a big journalistic ego and there's probably a bit of that around um I think um Sam might have a deal on that I think maybe even just also come you know maybe not on the conscious level that might be part of the dynamic um but I don't think it's unconnected that these stories are starting to be reported a little bit more and they're being reported by you know mostly women um for whatever you know for probably a variety of reasons yeah and I think on that front one of the things that's been really influential rightly or wrongly and they'd be arguments that this is wrongly as well is that because a lot of people knew Britney Higgins they knew who she was and they really liked her right she was a very respected person she's very polite um she's very dignified she's very lovely and people I think she had a name and she had a face right so she had all sorts of advantages that for example uh the complainant against Christian Porter doesn't she can't speak for herself anymore which is why obviously her friends have felt the need to do that for her but you know I think that people really respected Britney Higgins and they were horrified that she had you know this terrible story of what had happened to her right um you know I also think that um there's lots of journalists that have followed this up very diligently and they followed it up very seriously you know um look I'd note that there has been a lot of things written about Louise Milligan from Four Corners as well she obviously broke the story of the letter to the Prime Minister and she had the original you know inside the Canberra bubble story that had those claims about from a former press secretary to Alan Tarj about her experiences and you know the sort of things that have been written about Louise are really interesting um a lot of the coverage is centered on this idea that she needs to be reigned in right she's out of control she needs to be reigned in and why won't an editor just put a stop to this right like you know as if as if you know like Chris Masters or some person on Four Corners when they were covering you know Queensland police corruption can you imagine someone saying someone just needs to rain Chris Masters in right you know he's obsessed he's writing all these stories he needs to be stopped someone needs to you know take a firmer hand at his man right I just think it's really interesting and look I've got no doubt that people have said all sorts of nasty things about me to their credit thankfully at least they haven't really sent them to my face so I'm sure there's someone out there that thinks that I need to be reigned in uh you know well really after the season I'd like to them yeah good luck for my friends I'm sure that when um Kathy Mayley and Kate McLiamont broke the Dyson Hayden story maybe there are people that thought that they need to be reigned in when is Kate McLiam not going to be reigned in someone who's she's she's she's unrainable it brings them under certain known that media commutator who talked about winning the story and enjoying all these women's story and enjoy it yeah remember that guy I know I know and these women they do need to be reigned in they just I don't know when are they gonna learn some manners well I would argue that both of you are unrainable I let's just turning back to Christian Porter this is again been treated by sections of the media as political problem but we've also seen to varying degrees advocacy for Christian Porter for many people in the media most prominently Chris Yulman and Peter Van Anselen who picked up Morrison's line about the rule of law is this just a sign of diversity of views in the media or do you think it went a step too far Samantha oh well I'd never would suggest these men need to be reigned in no no no nothing to be fair to Peter Van Anselen he actually thinks they should be independent and choir so his position is a little bit nuanced but um he has gotten dragged over the collars for you know essentially you know he's declares that um Christian Porter is a friend of his and to his credit he's quite upfront about all of that um I certainly think there's been a unity of opinion and you know I support the rule of law and the presumption of innocence as well right but um there was a point at which I did pick up a couple of papers over the weekend and thought god this is quite operatic right it's quite sort of you know it's all getting a little it's like watching an opera and yeah they all seem to be of one view uh maybe I don't know maybe they have a point I'm sure they do have a point I mean the points that I've made that I agree with um but I know I haven't really seen a bloke that many blokes other than the idea of Hart Smith but I haven't really seen that many blokes sort of weigh in from the other side and you do start to wonder you know the thing that comes to the fore here is a lived experience right and you hear people talking about this as well not just in gender terms but obviously in terms of racism like I mean if you have a lived experience of uh having men undermine your work or even being sexually harassed or god forbid sexually assaulted which a lot more women than you realize have had those experiences uh they're obviously going to bring those experiences to the table and if you are a man that looks at this and thinks holy shit any woman could make this allegation against me and what would I do if it wasn't true that would be devastating you know that's a legitimate view but I think you know a friend of mine said to me not that long ago that you know what is coming through some of these opinion pieces is this culpable fear that you know they can see a sort of glimpse of another world where the rules are different and it frightens them.

Jacqueline what's your take? I think everybody's entitled to their views and I don't I don't have any problem with you know people expressing those views I do think that you know Samantha's point about lived experiences right I mean I'm just thinking about the last few weeks and I've written you know secondary stuff on on both the Britney Higgins matter and the Christian court of matter and I've met you box is full of two different types of emails um emails of women disclosing their sexual assaults to me and saying you know go you go all the women who are writing about this stuff and what I can politely refer to as mansplaining emails from grumpy men who hate that this is in the news who feel deeply threatened by the fact that it's being reported or that it's being reported in the way that it is and they really fall into those two categories there is actually third category of man who writes in a supported email I had a woman who I know in my local area woke up to me the other day and this was a rape because we were chatting about this stuff it's every single woman I know has had a conversation with a friend of that nature in recent weeks because it's Britney Higgins it's the Christian court of stuff it's also yeah the conversation that the school girls are having about consent it's just everywhere at the moment and it is very upsetting for a lot of women and I think that if you're not a woman and you don't understand that and also if you're a good man you don't really know how prevalent it is unless women tell you and you listen to them and believe them so if there's anything I suppose that can come out of this maybe it's a plea a plea for that now it's pretty clear our police have a lot of work to do to join the 21st century but our media also does need to improve maybe not as maybe not as much to be fair obviously I'd like to get your views on how the media could up its game when reporting on the types of allegations that we've seen surface over the recent weeks Samantha look I think that I'm still err on the side of optimism rather than pessimism I mean I think that through a variety of reasons and partly because you know the prime minister got up on that Tuesday and said that he's listened to Britney Higgans and that he was taking the issue seriously that you know there's been a lot written about this there's been a lot discussed about this on radio and television and newspapers and no it's not perfect and no yes there are things that you could say that you would criticize but you know like Jackie says I would never criticize people for having a view I mean that's the point of an opinion piece you know I think let a thousand flowers bloom as long as they're not jubbers you know I don't I don't look at the recent weeks and say this has been a disgrace and an outrage you know I think that we've tackling these issues and that's good let's end on a positive note if that's possible both of you have spent a number of years covering federal politics what changes would you like to see in place by next International Women's Day? Jack I'd like to turn to you first in terms of positive actual practical changes I do think that Parliament House is clearly crying out for some sort of proper process by which staff members can complain of inappropriate conduct within their office I think that's a bit of an O'Brainer I do think that in order to really correct the culture of Canberra and to make it friendly to women you just probably need more women in Parliament I don't think that's going to happen by next International Women's Day but in a longer term that would be a good thing and I suppose I would just like to see a culture where women do not feel ashamed to talk about this stuff and they do not feel worried about the consequences of talking about this stuff in a truthful and open way again I don't think that's going to happen by next International Women's Day but maybe it will be on that. Samantha?

Yeah I would like to plus one all of the above I think that at a micro level it's important that they put in place structural changes at Parliament House in terms of the appointment arrangements of both men and women but I think you know this is a conversation right and the conversation has been going for many many years it didn't start you know when Brittany Higgins told her story but obviously she has really turbocharged that debate and I think that we need to think about the structures that are in place for people when they come forward saying that they've been sexually harassed, sexually assaulted, the support that they're offered and you know I hope that that's a conversation that will continue. On that note I'd like to thank you both for being on Fourth Estate Samantha Maiden, political editor at news.com.au and Jacqueline Mayley, senior writer and columnist for the Sydney Morning Herald and the H. Thank you for having me. Thanks as well.

If you or someone you know is impacted by sexual assault or violence call 1800-respect on 1800-737-732 or visit 1800-respect.org.au and thank you for listening to Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded out the studios at Tua Sia and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a lull in between.

We'll of course be back with more next week but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter and as for Fourth Estate are you. A big thanks as always to my executive producer Anthony Dockrell. My name is Tina Queen thanks for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 48 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on March 11, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.