Skip to content
JAY COST: A Republic No More episode artwork

Feb 17, 2015 23 min

JAY COST: A Republic No More

from The Daily Standard Podcast - Your conservative source for analysis of the news shaping US politics and world events

This is an archived copy of The Daily Standard podcast. Please note that advertisements, links and other specific references within the content may be out of date.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

JAY COST: A Republic No More

0:00 23:03
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the weekly standard podcast. I'm your host Michael Graham every once in a while We are able to track down a hot sought-after author. It's very difficult to do We've got these big-time writers by manage to corner the incredibly exclusive J cost who we never hear from here at the weekly standard Hello, Jay. Hi, Michael, you know, I was waiting my introduction.

It should be Peter Gabriel big time now You know, I mean cuz that's where I am absolutely should be and I we appreciate you fitting us in between phone interviews with a tumbler Iowa And the ladies home journal, but flacking a book is not easy. Jay as you know No, it's not but it's good rewarding work You know, you write the book you put all this effort into it and you really you know, you just wanted to find its audience Whatever that audience may be and you know, if that's what that's good work It's a good problem to have was a fellow author. I hate the fact that you've written a good book that makes it much more I'm sorry to say or a republic no more as a title and I will tell you I am here to throw down all day with you Jay cost Alexander Hamilton had it right Madison had it wrong Start right there, baby. Well, bring it.

I'm ready. What are you got? No, I'm a big Hamiltonian for way back and it's fascinating to me how you have managed to drag James Madison away from the White House That he lost in the word of the British in 1812 and bring him to today's political moment Which is politics in America in and of itself is corrupt. I think that's a good thesis statement for your book I think I think that's a good thesis, you know, and look just to be clear I am amazed by Hamilton You know if I had a criticism of Hamilton it would be this that you know He's get daddled from the Constitutional Convention too early and did not make the case for building Institutions of government that could manage the powers that he had in mind, you know I mean because he was the only one in the country I think well I don't want to exaggerate but he was one of the few who had a real understanding of how public finance operated And then it's something for all of James Madison's many many many virtues He had he really had a very backward view of how credit actually worked I mean he thought banking was a kid to gambling so well That's what you get for hanging out with that inbred farmer John Thomas Jefferson, but we'll get to that another time The book is a a republic no more has corruption and first I got to explain to our listeners what you mean by corruption But that's the political corruption truly ended the Republican Republic in a way that Madison and Hamilton and Jefferson review it I think so, you know, I mean obviously you don't pull any title pull any punches in the title of the book You know when I was originally sketching this out I pitched it to Roger Kimblewood encounter as a study in corruption a historical study that then, you know focuses on the present day And I was thinking of calling it the violence of faction which is taking which is a phrase that Madison uses in federal of number 10 But you know Michael by the time I got about three quarters of the way through the book and just had seen Item after item and I had this running total in my head Okay, how much is political corruption costing us today?

How much is it cost us through the years and I just got to the point it was like who am I kidding this? I don't know Well, what do you want to call this system of government we have but it is not a republic in the way That the founding fathers envisioned it would be I end up using the phrase special interest democracy, which is Not an invention of my own, but it's something that George George Romney mitt dad in an interview in the 70s labeled it And I think it's a pretty apt description of what we have now Well, let's back up because we do need to talk about what you mean by corruption You don't mean the good old-fashioned kind of corruption that I saw in Boston with the big dig which was originally supposed to cost $3 billion It's currently at $23 billion and it's already failing and has killed somebody you don't mean that corruption No, I mean although that certainly is you know There is certainly corruption when we talk about you know bribery and kickbacks and extortion and just stuff that you could go to jail for That's certainly included in my definition, but I do take a broader view of it And again, I you know and I apologize to your tender sense of Hamiltonian sensibility But I take a Madisonian view of it Madison understood. He called it factionalism And in Madison Understanding a faction was a group of interest who had you know preferences that were adverse as he said to the rights or Interest of the whole community so interest group politics, but not just that but interest group politics in a way that works against the public interest And corruption happens when the government Works on behalf of interest groups at the expense of everybody else That's why Madison called it the violence of faction and indeed when Madison wrote that phrase in the 1780s I think it actually turned violent for instance in your former home state of Massachusetts. Yeah, Chase rebellion.

That was a big party But almost as big as the party after the New England Patriots You got to get one another Super Bowl, but almost I want to give you an I want to give you an example from a local story here in Atlanta I currently live because I think it it kind of highlights one of the problems you're talking about if we were just talking about the fact that Big businesses try to spend money and influence government where you go while there's other big businesses and there are other interests who don't like it But when you get to the point where you abandon the notion that taught you know that people using their power to exploit others You don't have the power is just taking for granted I think that's it in Georgia like many states are having a debate over how to pay for roads They want to spend another billion dollars a year. They're run by Republicans good small government types, right? Jay so of course so we're told so the common sense thing would be you want to pay for roads you raise gas taxes gas taxes pay for roads Because people use the roads. They buy the gas you're done the proposal that is actually being debated is a half million-dollar tax on smokers Before you cigarettes in tobacco and the question is what does this have to do with roads?

You buy a package that has that connected to roads and the answer no joke from the lobbyists was hey Only 18% of us smoke 90% of us drive. Let's go get them Now that's not technically corruption, but it is in the broadest sense the we've got power We've got the ability to use the power you don't have any recourse from our power ha ha guess who's gonna spend five hundred million Dollars a year in new taxes. Yeah, that's that's right And you know what I mean Madison himself says that a faction can amount to a majority of the whole of the population I mean you can have a faction of one person you can have a faction of a thousand people you can have a faction of a hundred and fifty million people The real the real distincting distinguishing characteristic of a faction is it when it's interest sort of operate against the public interest in some way And the story you've described is sort of like you know situations where the majority says like let's go screw over this Minority because they can't do anything about it in a democracy That is the violence of faction, you know and even if the minority is not particularly sympathetic in this case You know smokers like in 2015. It's like why are you still smoking?

You know, but you know nevertheless that's another aspect of it, you know, I mean if they may be sympathetic they may not be sympathetic But they still you know in a republican form of government You should not have the majority using the powers granted to it to just take money from a minority They can't do anything But you know, but there was a time when if an interest wanted to do something they felt some need to you know Show how was you know the greater good, you know that here's our here's the principal decision behind it And what I loved about this story was listening to the the lobbyists say straight up Here's the math on who to get you look at you look at farm You look at farm spending what you write a lot about in a republic no more the people pushing for the farm subsidies They have no argument whether it's ethanol, which is a terrible deal for the taxpayers or whether it's agribusiness terrible deal They simply say there are a lot of farm states out there and they got a lot of votes What about your principal position screw position? I've got lobbyists. I've got the states. I've got people to pull You're gonna keep those subsidies coming.

Yeah, you know the most extraordinary thing about farm subsidies Do is that there aren't really that many votes attached to it anymore? I mean that the percentage of Americans I believe that are attached to the farm economy that actually are farmers It's like 1% of the country. So it's not even really out. It's not even farmers You know, we're not really talking about like, you know, the family farms and subsidies I mean and that that is what's so dangerous about corruption and the way it works in the United States, right?

Is that it you know so often it is a it is a drain of public resources from the taxpayer to some small interest group That is plugged in on the right subcommittee And and has contributed to the right members of Congress that you've never even heard of I've never even heard of you And I studied this stuff for a living, you know, and you know money carefully targeted law being carefully targeted promises are made The bill is produced. It's a it's a terrible piece of garbage that misallocates tens of billions of dollars But nobody notices and I mean that was what I found writing this book again and again and again and again And by the way, this is and this is one of the reasons why I wanted to do it from a historical perspective Is that a lot of this stuff is very very old, you know, farm subsidies that they're relatively new thing But you know Congress has been monkeying around with taxes in pretty offensive ways really since like the 1820 And so here's my question for you. Why is it a republic no more? Was it a republic say in 1980 during the Reagan Revolution was a republic FDR, you know, when when did we turn the corner to a special interest?

Democracy well, I think we turned the corner a while ago. I think that the Reagan Reagan I think in my story is really notable for getting a genuine decent piece of reform legislation passed which was the tax reform act of 1986 But it's it's been a long time coming and you know look I want to be pie in the sky naive about things You know a lot of people when I tell them about the book They're like, oh, well, you know corruption. It's inevitable and you know my response is of course it's inevitable I mean Madison himself says factionalism is sewn into the very nature of man That's what he says and the real question is whether or not we're controlling its negative facts You know because we can't get rid of factionalism if it's part of human nature There's no getting rid of it. The question is whether or not we're dealing with the effects too reasonable extent And I just think that having looked at you know in the second half of the book I look at five contemporary policies I look at farm subsidies which we talked about the pork barrel I look at Medicare taxes corporate taxes and and reg financial regulation and in all five of them I see massive corruption really massive, and I'm very careful in how I document it I mean the book's got like 80 pages worth of footnotes.

I don't know why the way that's part of the book It's the most readable and punchy. I like that. Oh, well, thank you very much. I try to strike a balance with that I appreciate that But you know look I think you know added all up and honestly, you know that my balcony on the low calculation by the end of it Was over a hundred billion dollars every year every year and you know I trace that the subtitle of the book is big government and the rise of American political corruption and my hypothesis is that as the You know that when the framers handed created this government and handed it off to us their idea was okay We have these institutions we've given them certain powers and they're gonna balance and check one another's today even though the country is factional and men are selfish They will enter the system and they'll knock against one another and the end result will be self-interested It's a or a public interest it's almost is it the Constitution was a finely calibrated Swiss watch right and what we have done over generations Is we have added power after power after power to this government under the assumption that it could handle the load that checks and balances would work just as well for a government has designed in 1787 as for the government after the new deal and My hypothesis is that that's not correct that Madison has the right view of things with that You have to calibrate these things very carefully and very precisely They calibrated it well But we have been clumsy and we have been ad hoc and we haven't thought things through when we've added power to the government And that this is eroded the government's capacity to check and balance factions And so what we get is interest you could call it interest group liberalism Which doesn't exclude conservative republicans in government.

It's just sort of you know liberalism from a general perspective interest group liberalism You could call it crony ism. You could call it honest braft or so many different words for it But I just see again and again this government was originally designed to favor the common good over special interests And now too often it does the opposite. So how do we get our republic back? What can we do J cost to you know?

What should the platform of the republicans be or what should the platform of Americans be to get it back? Well, you know look it that's a tough question the book doesn't deal with that directly My piece in the magazine starts to look at that, you know I think there's a couple different ways to approach this I think conservatives need to start pushing the republican party full bore into an anti crony of the agenda And I think that they just have to be stand up against corporate welfare and stand up against the ways that big government favors and patronizes big business because honestly Nine times out of ten when I found corruption that was the sort of corruption that I found right we get ourselves We get ourselves all tangled up in knots over over over all sorts of issues But I think that's a real winner for conservatives beyond that we got to work and we got to think about fixing Congress and making Congress behaves better and thinking about how can we actually get some stuff passed? I think too much of our on the right already we're starting to spend an enormous amount of energy thinking about the 2016 presidential election And the nominating convention and who's gonna be the best candidate and we spend so much time on personalities and meanwhile the house is a mess The Senate is a mess the house is more of a mess than the Senate and Republicans have controlled the house for 14 of the last 18 years So it's the Republicans fault that the house is a mess and I think that conservatives need to start spending a little more Time and effort and put more thought into thinking about how can we fix the House of Representatives? How can we make Congress responsible for the public interest?

How can we end this interest group liberalism? You know by the way, this relates to you know, I know that there is a broad dissatisfaction with conservatives with the Republican Party these days God knows I feel it too And I really think part of our problem is that in the last 20 years the Republican Party has become the party of Congress But Congress has also got its clause into the Republican Party like the Republicans Congress has been dysfunctional for generations, right? Now that the Republicans are in charge It's like that dysfunctionality is like seeped into the Republican Party itself into two-way street And I think conservatives rather than like thinking about which Republican nominee can fix things and thinking about the personality We need to start thinking about well, how do we deal with this mess that is the United States Congress because it is a mess? Well, it is but you have the party of you know Opposition to government trying to run the government I think that's inherent flaw and then the other part is the way to make To move towards the Madisonian vision that you talk about in your book your public no more is to take power away from government I've yet to see a serious movement from serious Republicans to actually do that They just want to change how the power is used.

Yeah, I agree with that I think that's a that's a real problem, which is why I'm sort of as a starting point I think the best place to start is an anti-Chronism agenda, you know, this would be you know The agenda would be let's shrink the power of government in ways that you know in the ways that it helps big business and showers You know the tax code There's like forty billion dollars in the tax code worth of corporate welfare and the export import bank and farm subsidies I mean, there are so many different things there are so many different ways that governmental activism favors the wealthy and the well-connected That just seems to me like an obvious political winner for Republicans Especially since big government liberal Democrats always accuse them of being elitist and for the wealthy I mean, doesn't it make sense to like say like no, we're forgetting rid of corporate welfare. What are you for? You know, I mean it would be a perfect contrast with Hillary Clinton who is like the archetype She's like a platonic ideal at this point of the revolving door You know it would be a perfect contrast with her to have a Republican come up there and say we are gonna cut the crap out of the corporate tax code And we're gonna reduce taxes for small business. We're gonna get rid of all these corporate welfare programs We're gonna get rid of we're gonna get rid of farm subsidies.

We're gonna clean up the graft in the waste in Medicare You know, we're gonna stop Congress from wasting all this money in the pork barrel every year What are you gonna do Hillary? And what's her answer to that? I mean did she have one that the Clintons have mastered this sort of phony populism over the years But it's completely dependent upon Republicans playing along and I think it's time to stop Well, you pointed out that the fighters in Congress the Republicans focus too much on 2016 They need to focus on Congress. So that in mind jacos who should be the nominee in 2016 to help get the message across?

You know, I don't know yet. I'm keeping an open mind You know, I like we're Scott Walker searching in the polls, you know, I want to see what he's got You know, I tend to have a very pragmatic view of the presidency I sort of almost have a view like similar what Henry Clay had where I my preference would be for an active Congress that sort of runs the show and a president who who doesn't take a strong elite But just sort of keeps it in line. So I sort of think primarily about electability and from that perspective I think Marco Rubio's at the top of the list he's up there But what about having ran the only guy who's running a full-throated anti-government campaign is Rand Paul and you obviously there are problems there For a lot of people including myself with foreign policy aspect of it But when you talk about just making a full-on case for it, no, don't do that government There's nobody else even inhibiting that trying to take that ground from him And I was I was the other some of the other nominees to try to fight up on that hill, too Yeah, I would I mean I for me from a personal preference standpoint Rand Paul is a nonstarter But I agree with you that I would like to see somebody else in the field who has more mainstream views on foreign policy Really start occupying a lot of the space he's trying to occupy and I would say especially on issues of criminal justice and race relations as well I think there's room for Republicans to make a move there in terms of, you know, like let's reform the criminal justice code particularly as it relates to drug Prosecution let's rationalize it. Let's make sense of it You know in a lot of respects a criminal justice system You know it's the sharp end of the stick in our in our system of government and if you are on the receiving end of that And you haven't done anything wrong That's a pretty awful place to be so you know when we're talking about reforming our system I think that that should be at the top of the list and yet Rand Paul's the only guy talking about it I'd like to see somebody else like Scott Walker or Marco Rubio or Mike Pence or Rick Perry Those are probably my four top guys I may be taught to Bobby Jindal, although he's got such bad reviews coming out a little lately I'm not sure my point is what what's interesting to me is why aren't some of the other candidates running straight at that space?

And I know I don't know because of the way you fund your campaign Yeah, you've got to have interest to throw the money at your campaign Yeah, look that's one reason why I'm not hugely I'm not really enjoying this pre pre-primary game of sort of who's where and what when you know In 2013 Jeff Anderson and I wrote a big lengthy piece for National Affairs sort of diagnosing the Republican nominating process and suggesting ways to reformate because we all think it works and Nobody nobody in power paying any attention to it. And so I just have my gal I just don't think it's a very good process and I you know, so I just been trying to you know keep my expectations We all know the answer which is have each of them guest host Saturday Night Live Whoever does a best job is a nominee let's call it a break there And we've got to call it into this is a ton of fun I can't rate I have to confess I haven't finished your book a republic no more But it's absolutely terrific got to get at J. Cost thanks I'm up at your time so glad we could pull you away from the weekly standard to get you here on the podcast for the weekly Yeah Well, thank you Michael. Thanks for having me.

You've been listening to the weekly standard podcast Please be sure to check weekly standard calm regularly for podcast updates. I'm your host Michael Graham

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Standard Podcast - Your conservative source for analysis of the news shaping US politics and world events?

This episode is 23 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Standard Podcast - Your conservative source for analysis of the news shaping US politics and world events episode published?

This episode was published on February 17, 2015.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Standard Podcast - Your conservative source for analysis of the news shaping US politics and world events episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.