Jonathan Sarna on American Jewry’s Past — and Its Uncertain Future

As Jewish American Heritage Month draws to a close — and as the United States approaches the 250th anniversary of American independence — I wanted to share a remarkable conversation that feels especially timely.On the latest episode of the Jerusalem Journal Podcast, I sat down with Professor Jonathan Sarna, perhaps the foremost historian of American Jewry today, for a sweeping discussion about the past, present, and future of Jewish life in America.Paid subscribers are receiving early access to this episode ahead of its wider release.Among the questions we explore:* How did Jewish smugglers in the Caribbean help supply the American Revolution?* Why did George Washington’s famous letter to the Jews of Newport fundamentally reshape Jewish history?* How did waves of antisemitism repeatedly transform — and ultimately strengthen — American Jewish life?* How did Zionism go from a fringe movement to a defining feature of American Jewish identity?* And what lessons does the history of American Jewry hold for this moment of rising antisemitism, polarization, and uncertainty?Along the way, Sarna makes a striking argument: that many of the debates tearing through Jewish life today are not unprecedented at all — and that earlier generations of Jews faced moments of similar anxiety, division, and upheaval.He also offers a provocative warning: that both of the great modern Jewish “solutions” — America and Israel — now feel far less secure than many Jews once imagined.And yet, despite everything, his conclusion is ultimately a hopeful one.This was one of the most fascinating and eye-opening conversations I’ve had in quite some time, and I suspect many listeners will come away seeing both American Jewish history and the current moment differently.And finally: due to strong response to our first anniversary offer, we’re extending our 25% discount on annual subscriptions through June.If you value thoughtful conversations like this one — and would like early access to future interviews, essays, and analysis — please consider becoming a paid subscriber today:As always, thank you for reading, listening, and supporting Jerusalem Journal.Shabbat Shalom from Washington, D.C.,— A.M. Get full access to Jerusalem Journal at www.jerusalemjournal.com/subscribe