Hi, this is Carolyn Ryan, Managing Editor of The New York Times. At The Times, we strive to help everyone stay informed. And at this critical moment, we're making all of our election coverage free in our app. This election has an expansive battleground map. States that hadn't been in play before are suddenly competitive. We have more than 100 reporters out there talking to voters. I wonder if I can just call Will to get the actual numbers.
Hey, how are you? How many voter interviews do you think we've done? Our plan is to talk to 30,000 voters this year. Okay, you're awesome. Thank you very much. Thank you. Don't you love the New York Times? On election night, we are the place to go for race results. Our maps are updated minute by minute. Our data team can show you what votes have come in, what votes are yet to be counted, and how that might affect the overall results. Come experience all of our election coverage for free right now in the New York Times app.
Hey, it's Michael. For our last few episodes of 2024, we're bringing you something really special, a year of culture in review. We're going to begin with one of our all-time favorite guests talking about one of the year's most astonishing performances and the really improbable story of how it even happened. Today, critic at large Wesley Morris on the comeback of the singer and songwriter Joni Mitchell. It's Christmas Day, Wednesday, December 25th.
I'm Wesley Morris. I'm a critic at the New York Times. And back in 2022, this news broke that this amazing event had taken place at the Newport Folk Festival in Rhode Island. Joni Mitchell had come out and played a concert for the first time in a long time. And it was a big deal! Because Joni Mitchell, the singer, the songwriter, influencer of generations of musicians, that person had virtually disappeared from public life. She'd sworn off touring. And then, in 2015, a brain aneurysm almost killed her.
She survived, but her ability to sing, or even speak, was gone. So you can imagine the shock when she appeared on stage at Newport surrounded by a bunch of musicians led by Brandi Carlile, and including folks like Winona Judd and Marcus Mumford. Some of these same musicians had been convening at her house in LA, and somebody started calling those gatherings Joni Jams. And now, here they all were, taking her living room sessions public. The Joni Mitchell fans went crazy! She was back! And, I might add, back in that signature beret.
But honestly, I had my doubts. Like, what was really happening here? Did Joni Mitchell even want this? Or were these adoring young musician fans making her do something for their own reasons? Was it elder care? I wasn't there! I don't know! And then, earlier this year, I'm watching the Grammys at home in my living room. And in the middle of the show, the stage went dark and a familiar voice filled the room.
It was low, and it was deliberate. And slowly, part of the stage spun around to reveal Joni Mitchell. Seated in an armchair, one hand stirring a walking cane, the other moving to the cadences of her own lyricism. And she was indeed surrounded by other musicians. And I was like, okay, never mind. I take it all back. Because so much about this performance was so moving. First of all, just the way the people on stage, these musicians, these great musicians, were regarding Joni Mitchell. Like, they were having the same experience that I was at home, except they were there. And they were in awe of the beauty of this moment. Like, they were at the feet of a musical mother. And then there were the cutaways to musicians in the audience. One shot looked over Dua Lipa's shoulder at Beyonce, who was just swaying in thought. And then another shot caught Taylor Swift midstanding ovation.
And I just got the sense that a lot of people in that room were thinking about what 50 years from now looks like for them. How's antihero going to sound when Taylor Swift's 80 years old? What's that song going to be about then? But mostly, I was struck by how good Joni Mitchell sounded. She's lost an octave over the years, but there's still tremendous power in her lower register. She can still control. She can still wield it.
So when more of these Joni jams got scheduled at the Hollywood Bowl, I knew I had to get myself on a plane to hear her with my own ears and see her with my own eyes. I also knew my friend Sasha Weiss was going. Sasha's a writer and my editor at the Times Magazine, and we talk a lot. And I wanted to ask her what it felt like to be there at one of these shows. We went on different nights. She went on Saturday, I went on Sunday, and I wanted to talk about who Joni Mitchell is to her and how it feels to experience an 80-year-old in full command of her meaning.
Hi, Sasha. Hi, Wesley. How are you? I'm good. I want to talk about the concert, obviously, but before we do that, I just, I gotta ask you what your relationship to Joni Mitchell is. Like, what's your first Joni Mitchell moment? My parents introduced me to Joni Mitchell, and it was at a pretty young age. I mean, I can't really remember a time when her voice wasn't in my head. I woke to Joni, I slept to Joni, you know, I think from the ages of like seven on. I mean, very young. Wow. And they play it a lot on car rides. So I think Joni... That seems apt. It's so apt, of course. That seems apt for a person who's a traveler. She's a traveler. She's a restless wanderer. And I think that also implanted something in me that...
You know, I grew up in, I would say in some ways, in a kind of cozy, somewhat cloistered environment. I mean, I grew up in New York City, but, you know, in a kind of strong Jewish community. I mean, there was a sense of, like, shtetl-likeness in my upbringing, I would say. And I think Joni did implant a seed of wondering and wandering because so many of her songs are about, I mean, on Blue alone. She's in California and she's in Spain and she's in France. I have been on, like, all I want is, you know, the first line is... I'm on a lonely road and I'm traveling, yeah. Traveling, traveling, traveling.
I mean, I love to sing. I still love to sing. And I really studied her singing and learned to sing from Blue. And I think just the leaping in the range, you know, the way that Joni can adventurously, boldly, almost insolently, like she can go from really low to just leaping up. It's sort of doing a parallel bar routine where like it goes from a low bar to the high bar, flips around a little bit, goes back down, comes up and then sticks a landing every time.
I feel like there's a desire there, there's a hunger, there's a command. I wanted that vocally, and I think I wanted it, like, interpersonally or something. What does that look like? I don't know. I think the ability to explore, the ability to, like, take command, the ability to be daring. I mean, I don't know if I've achieved these things, but I think this was, like, my fantasy. Especially Blue. But Court and Spark, too, shaped my ideas about what love was. I always felt like love was a complex, laden thing, not a simple thing, because of Joanie. What it was to be a writer, I think. You know, her songs are so writerly. So many of them are...
short stories in miniature and you get a whole life in those songs. So I think that her words, I listen to them thousands of times. I mean, blue is just stamped on my consciousness. So I think I wanted to see what kind of woman I'd become by encountering Joanie. Oh my God, we just started talking and my eyes are already welling up. Okay, I first heard Joanie Mitchell in the 90s because I was listening to this radio station when I was a kid that was really singer-songwriter heavy. So Night Ride Home. Night Ride Home was my first Joanie Mitchell album.
I bought a cassette, and the voice on it was unlike any of the other people they were playing on this radio station. The voice was deeper than the leaping that you're talking about. All of that beauty... which I would describe in some ways as young womanish, by 1991 had really solidified into something that moved less, but weighed more. There's a song on that album called Passion Play, When All the Slaves Are Free, and it's essentially the sort of song that she'd begun to really luxuriate in, which is a kind of moral judgment on the condition of this, well, I'm going to say the United States. She's Canadian, lives in Los Angeles, according to her, is her workplace, and her home in Western Canada is her home.
But she has a real sense of, you know, the way the world is operating and the way the world is different in 1991 from how it was in 1974 or 69 even. In this particular case, it's just about the possession of land and this idea that men are not stewards of the land, they're proprietors. And like, what's it going to look like when the people that you have laboring for you have a revolution? There's just something about the way that she says, who are you going to get to do your dirty work when all the slaves are free? And she's doubling herself.
And that doubling, it just sounds different when your voice is that low. And I just was so drawn to whatever that sound was because there was wisdom in it, especially with this later music, which I would say... Which I don't know as well. Most people don't. Most people don't. All right, let's talk about the Hollywood Bowl show we went to this fall. I've been waiting. It's been hard. I mean, I watched the Newport performance. The one in 2022? Her big comeback. And I was so moved hearing her sing again. I think in those performances, her voice was still in the process of returning. There were moments when her voice broke, moments when the songs felt...
Like they were being explored again. So I felt both moved, amazed, sometimes anxious watching her. And I really wanted to see her a couple years later and to see what had happened to her voice and her performance now that she really decided to take it on the road. What was different? I felt it was really her show. Yeah, yeah. She was the band leader. And it's so interesting because she was seated the whole time, right? She sits. Oh my God, the chair. And we got to talk about the furniture, which is incredible. But her presence just has this gravitas and physicality, even though, you know, she's not standing, but she really draws the 17,000 seat, beautiful outdoor amphitheater.
into her. There's something energetically incredibly potent, and maybe that was Drew at Newport too, but I just felt that she kind of returned to some kind of energetic center. I could feel like the minute I saw her come on the stage. I felt the same thing. I mean, there's something about the chair, right? I mean, it really is a throne-like set piece, and it really gives everybody right around her a kind of, not subservient role, but they're all there to facilitate the needs.
of this monarch. But at the same time, she's so playful. I mean, there's a chair and there's the scepter-like cane, which looked to me to be gilded. There's a coyote, I think. It might be a coyote on the actual handle of the cane. I didn't observe that. I just saw something metallic and glinting. And, you know, it's like she's wielding it, but she's so playful. And as you were talking about earlier, you know, her rhythms, her rhythms are so unusual. And she's tapping them and tracing this kind of rhythmic...
idiosyncratic signature throughout the songs. And it's just incredible. So she's at once grand, and there's just something droll and fun and playful about her in her posture. It's both. It's both end. And also, I would say that the way the stage looks, it's a recreation, as I understand it, of the Joni Jams that took place in her living room over the course of many years, which, you know, led up to this moment of coming back to the stage, you know, where...
She'd gather with musician friends. I think Brandy really facilitated it and all these different people would come. Many different people came to play for her over several years. Herbie Hancock, Dali Parton, Chaka Khan, Harry Styles. But not all of those people were on stage at Night at the Hollywood Bowl. Definitely none of the people I just named. But it seemed like there was a core group. Yes, and those were the people who were on stage. Those were the people on stage who clearly had a long-running experience singing with her. Like an ability to improvise that seemed to me to be drawing from the experience of having done a lot of work together. But the stage, I mean, it felt very intimate. And from where I was sitting...
Like everyone sort of seemed in a pile. So it was like, you know, it was both really like an ensemble. And yes, Joni was this commanding presence. I can't imagine what it would be like to go to this concert if you're someone who has flown halfway, like completely across the country. to hear what you think is going to be a night of her doing blue. There are 10 songs on that album and people only heard three. California. Carrie, which the audience sung. It was explicitly stated, this song is for you. You and the audience can sing it. I think that was it. I might be missing something, but I don't think I am. She did a case of you in my night. Oh, she did do a case of you.
But most of the songs were from these later albums, from Hijira in 76 up to Shine, which is 2007. Part of the feeling that I got of her being in command was the set list, which I felt like she was preaching. She was not bringing nostalgia and comfort. I got the sense that this is a person who does not think that they've gotten their due. as an artist past a certain point, right? I think in the popular imagination, Blue has kind of eaten her entire body of work, which is interesting to me because, you know, the song she sang at the Grammys that night was both sides now, not on Blue, it was on Clouds. And the songs that...
have all of the kind of world weariness come after that, right? It's the experience of being extremely popular and extremely famous for those two albums that kind of put her off. I mean, what's the great line from Freeman in Paris? I'm out here stoking the star-making machinery behind the popular songs. Right? I can't be free. I cannot be a free man in Paris if I'm out here trying to sell records. The two things are incompatible. There's making my art, and then there's toiling for money. So she gave us mostly her art songs. Yes, 100%. 27 songs, most of which are songs she wrote after 1976. I did feel like I was being schooled. In a really good way. I mean, there's a quality of attention that you have to bring to...
her new register. Yes, I agree. And there's such a depth and a richness. I mean, I kept thinking of wood grain. Like, it just felt so rich and, you know, so much to hear and think about and movement. But, I mean, maybe it's also about the reverence. Like, you could hear the crickets. Maybe you always come in the hardwood bowl, but I felt it was about a sense, again, it's this kind of energetic gravitas. And I did feel she was demanding a kind of listening, partly in the choice of song. She wanted a hush. And choosing those later songs, like, it didn't create the excitation, right? Like, it created something else that was unusual. I just was so in tune with her voice.
And I was really hearing these songs in a new way. I just closed my eyes and just got transported to wherever it was she was trying to take us. I also think... there is a really special kind of listening going on on the stage. Say more about that. Well, I think this gets back to the way that these concerts came about. I mean, you know, this is what I understand from reading and listening around, you know, that she had these regular gatherings. The Joanie Jams in her living room. And at first, she wasn't singing much because she couldn't and she was still recovering. And I think over time, she started to chime in, you know, and sometimes it was just with a line or two. Sometimes, you know, I think as her voice strengthened, it was more and more. And eventually she started.
to pick up the guitar. And I felt very much the attunement of the other musicians, which I guess with any great band, you feel that. But it felt really potent because I felt like... they really understood when she was taking over the song. To me, it was like really utopian. It modeled something really beautiful. Like they were partners and they could recede. And I really liked watching them do that. So I think, you know, they're doing really intense listening and you can kind of feel that atmosphere and it kind of invites you to listen in a different way. I mean, there's some kind of intimate, communal, collaborative act of attunement that was going on in this concert. But whatever's happening and however they're following along, there is a shagginess and an imperfection, you know? And I mean, on the one hand, Joni is such a virtuosic, like she does have a kind of like consummate.
Apollonian artistry to her. Like everything she does is excellent. But I did feel that there was a... you know, sometimes like the starts of songs were a little, a little off. And I loved that. And I love that she let us hear that and see that. I kept track of when I felt she was most present. Like when she did Night Ride Home, I mean, she was back in the song. She's back, whatever the song is about, whatever memory she's having of this dance, wherever the song came from, she was back there. And like a romance, right? Like no interruptions, no distractions. No phones till Friday.
I was struck by just how present she was in this music. And like when she sounded to me, like this arrangement has found a great place for her singing. And it happened, you know, out of 27 songs, it happened more than half the time. Yeah. Okay, let's take a break. And when we come back, I had one complaint about the show. I only had one. Oh, wait, did you have any, by the way? Zero. Zero. I think I can give you one and I'll tell you after the break.
Law transforms agreement into reality. A word becomes an agreement. An agreement becomes a contract. A contract becomes law. Today, Harvey, the AI platform for legal work, is writing the next chapter. More than 200,000 lawyers are building with Harvey, accelerating review, sharpening negotiations, and more. This is how the future of agreements is being crafted now. Harvey. Learn more at Harvey.ai.
The New York Times, celebrating 175 years of helping you understand the world. Subscribe now for a special offer at nytimes.com slash subscribe. Wait, I do have one complaint about this show. And I don't know how you felt about this. Brandi Carlile kept calling the music deep cuts. Deep cuts, like she's singing with Cher. This is the person who has one top 10 song. One top 10 song in 60 years. Which is you turn me on on radio? Well, that's a top 40 song, yes. Help me. Help me. Help me hit number seven. By the way, come on.
Perfect song. I'm really taking all I have to not burst into song. You can do it! You can do it! I will not harmonize with you because it will not sound good at all.
I will never sing on this show again. That was beautiful. That was beautiful. As a person who cannot sing. I love when you sing. I do enjoy trying. I love it. But that's her only top 10 song. Like, she really was following her heart and not her pocketbook. She wasn't down with that. She thought it was funny when they were like, give us a hit. Oh, wait, can we listen to that part of Miles of Isles where she's about to do the circle game? Miles of Isles, of course, being her first live album, which came out 50 years ago this year. And there's this moment on stage.
that I just think is so indicative of who Joni Mitchell is as a person. And she's standing there, I guess, tinkering with her guitar, and she's just finished Blue, and there's like 30 seconds of people just shouting at her. They're just shouting out song titles. Play this! Play that!
This is what she says in response to that. This is her in 1974. She's just like, I don't want people screaming song titles at me. And the concert felt like a culmination of that or like some bracket to that, right? Like she was like, I'm playing what I want to play. And you're going to listen really carefully. You know, it's also worth saying like her persona on stage, I think it's very different than it was. I mean, in the, you know, like YouTubes I've seen of her youthful performance. She was a little more, I mean, she always was like a cool cat, but, you know, a little more soft. I mean, she's got a droll, unbothered persona, which is really interesting next to these adoring musicians. I mean, it's not like she undercuts them because I think she's really receiving, which is also something we should talk about, the receiving of the love and the adulation. But there is just a kind of...
knowingness, unbotheredness, and drollery that I found extremely charming and funny. And, you know, she's not ingratiating. She just isn't. No, not at all. I mean, she's not a person out here trying to do what they call fan service. I mean, this is also a person who said she'd never perform again. Yeah. I mean, I swear to God, in 2015, we found out that she'd had this aneurysm. We thought she wasn't going to make it.
And I think for people who do come out the other side of that situation, you know, if you're even close to being a death store, the idea that you're going to live for nine more years and that for at least three of those years, you're going to be thriving in public. You're going to go to the Grammys. And I don't know. I can't imagine what that's like. It may be worth saying that this is the second time in her life where she came back from a severe illness when she was a young girl. She had polio and she was stricken for months and couldn't walk. And apparently really.
sort of dreamed herself back into walking. She was lying in a bed and she was determined to walk. And there's some real force of will there, obviously, you know, some capacity for self-creation that she had even as a young girl. And I don't know, to me, there's something really amazing and, I mean, very upsetting about the fact that she had another experience of being bedridden again. But there's some... Something was just like, nope, not like this. Not like this. Y'all got to find another way to end this. It's not going to end here. Yes. I want to go back to that Grammys moment, actually. The thing that really struck me and completely embarrassed my skepticism about...
Was this her choice? She got bills to pay. What is going on here with this return? But the Grammy's performance, I mean, for my own two eyes, it just said, Wesley, shut up. You know what? Why are you suspicious? She's not going to do what she doesn't want to do. That's what we've been talking about the whole time. I understand that. But, you know, the entertainment business is full of stories where people have been weekend-to-burnied. Like, lots of people have been propped up, made to keep working when they shouldn't have been, and we don't find out until it's too late. So I just wanted to know. But this performance, to me, was just so life-affirming.
And it was beautiful because I just can't imagine writing something when you're, what, 25, 26 years old? She was even younger when she wrote it. And to re-inhabit that song as an 80-year-old. Like, and have it mean even more! It was an incredible thing to witness. I mean, there's a beautiful line in that song.
something's lost and something's gained. And the way she phrased it in the performance I saw, she really elongated the word gain. I felt like she was taking in the riches of experience right there on the stage in front of all of us. And it was incredibly transcendently moving. I really don't know life. I really don't know life at all. I mean, it's just so...
Rich. I was going to ask you if there was a moment that really messed you up. Was this a moment? Yes. Why are you so sheepish about it? No, I just, I'm just like re-inhabiting it. Yeah. I mean, it just felt like the profundity of life right there in the Hollywood Bowl, you know? Throwing a tissue at you. I can't believe we're lucky enough to experience living on Earth with Joni Mitchell, who is still able to interpret her own music.
60 years later. Yeah. In a time of doubt and turbulence in the world. That got absorbed into that night, too. The personal and the kind of national and political meaning and all of that in that song. Like, I just feel like she's a distiller and processor of our collective experience in a way that kind of like none other. And it's all there in the timbre of the voice. It's all there. I just couldn't believe my good fortune. We'll be right back.
I'm MJ Franklin, and this week on the Book Review Podcast, Switzy by Emma Klein. Hands down, the novel with the most impressive control I've read this year. Someone is losing their mind, and they're approaching their death. Completely moving, elegantly written. And I've got lost in the prose of it, which sometimes feels like poetry to me. What does a life add up to? What does it all mean? Listen to the Book Review wherever you get your podcasts. Let me talk about the laughter. She laughed through that whole show.
She laughed after every applause. She has a great laugh, and she laughs sometimes on her recorded songs. She has this kind of musical, slightly antic laugh. To me, it evokes, this is very Jewish, it evokes the biblical laughter of Sarah, who, when she was told in her 90s that she was going to be a mother to Isaac, laughs. And Isaac is the name for laughter in Hebrew. And it's this deep story of renaissance, of creation, of surprise, of fertility in old age. And I felt like the laughter was an ancient laughter of generativeness that came from someplace really deep.
I heard that in the laughter. I think that's it. She sang a song about Job, so she'd appreciate that. Sasha, I mean, you've been in my life for such a long time. It's wild to have a conversation with you about, on a microphone anyway, about a thing we'd be talking about at our desks. I know, so fun. So thank you for doing that. I really appreciate it. Me too. Thank you, Wesley.
Thanks for listening, everybody. Before you go, I just want to tell you that what you just heard is going to happen every week starting next year. It's going to be me talking to other people who I love talking to about everything. Art and movies and books and sports and all kinds of things that are happening in the culture. So to be the first to know when we launch, sign up for our audio. There's an audio newsletter.
I didn't know. So I'm going to sign up with you to find out what's happening with my show in the audio newsletter. You can find it at NYTimes.com slash audio newsletter, which is what I'm going to do right now. All right. This episode was produced by Elissa Dudley, edited by Wendy Doerr and Paula Schumann, and engineered by Pat McCusker, with production assistance from Kate Lopresti. Special thanks, by the way, to Matty Maciello and Nick Pittman, and thanks to you for listening. Talk to you soon. That's it for The Daily. I'm Michael Barbaro. Happy holidays, and see you tomorrow.