EPISODE · Aug 22, 2026 · 10 MIN
Justice or Excuse?
from Ones Ready · host Aaron Love, Trent Seegmiller, and Jared "Peaches" Pietras
Send us Fan Mail Three children were murdered. So why is so much of the conversation focused on protecting the person who killed them? In this solo edition of Outside The Wire, Trent examines a mother’s admitted killing of her three children and the defense’s claim that postpartum psychosis diminished her responsibility. Trent argues that mental illness may help explain an action, but it does not erase the victims or eliminate the need for justice. Drawing on Immanuel Kant’s philosophy of punishment, Trent makes the case for capital punishment—not as revenge, deterrence, or spectacle, but as the consequence deserved for deliberately taking innocent lives. The question is brutally simple: when guilt is not disputed, should psychological illness change what justice requires? Links: OnesReady.com Chapters: 00:00 - Justice for Three Children 01:18 - The System Makes Mistakes 02:28 - What Immanuel Kant Said About Punishment 03:07 - Justice Is Not Revenge 04:52 - Does Psychosis Excuse Murder? 05:39 - Stop Forgetting the Victims 07:21 - Trent’s Case for the Death Penalty 08:20 - A World Without Responsibility 09:45 - Justice or Excuse? Support the show Join this channel to get access to perks: HERE Buzzsprout Subscription page: HERE Register for our Operator Training Summit: OperatorTrainingSummit.com Find an Air Force Recruiter: AirForce.com Collabs: Ones Ready - OnesReady.com 18A Fitness - Promo Code: ONESREADY ATACLete - Follow the URL (no promo code): ATACLete Danger Close Apparel - Promo Code: ONESREADY DFND Apparel...
Embed this episode
What this episode covers
Send us Fan Mail Three children were murdered. So why is so much of the conversation focused on protecting the person who killed them? In this solo edition of Outside The Wire, Trent examines a mother’s admitted killing of her three children and the defense’s claim that postpartum psychosis diminished her responsibility. Trent argues that mental illness may help explain an action, but it does not erase the victims or eliminate the need for justice. Drawing on Immanuel Kant’s philosophy of pun...
Ready to play
Justice or Excuse?
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.