EPISODE · Jul 20, 2024 · 2H 31M
Kant's philosophy - Criticism as an answer to dogmatism and scepticism
from Kant's Philosophy · host The Voice of Reason
Kant’s critical philosophy is an answer to the philosophy that came before and can be properly understood only in this context. All pure philosophy, i. e. metaphysics, was done in a dogmatic or sceptical way before Kant: there was either a blind faith in or a blind distrust of pure reason and its ability to answer the big questions of metaphysics concerning God, freedom and immortality. With criticism Kant found a solution, by first examining reason itself, its abilities and its limits, before examining any metaphysical objects through reason. Quote: 0:08 The critiques gave Kant importance and fame beyond his own day: 1:44 Digression: Unaufkläred people are imprisoned in the moment: 6:02 Kant’s copernican turn in philosophy and what came before it: 17:24 Dogmatism: 21:41 - The dogmatics: 26:12 - Reason of dogmatism: 34:43 - The conflict of different dogmatisms births scepticism: 43:20 Scepticism: 59:36 - The sceptics: 1:07:01 - The role of the sceptics: 1:15:02 - Misology as the result of the conflict between dogmatism and scepticism: 1:18:02 Criticism: 1:30:03 - Metaphysics and history are the sciences which need a critical propaedeutics: 1:57:56 - The elements of the critique: 2:03:38 - The betrayal of Kant’s critical project: 2:07:15 The history of thought is now taken to be only a patchwork: 2:22:18 Thanks: 2:31:20 Overview of the sciences needing critique according to Kant: https://jonathanivoloewer.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/sciences-needing-critique-according-to-Kant.jpg Kant says some words about his view of pre-critica philosophy in various parts of his work wherever he’s speaking about the critical philosophy. As the most exhaustive description I recommend his What real progress has metaphysics made in Germany since the time of Leibniz and Wolff? http://korpora.org/kant/aa20/253.html (I could not find a free English translation online.) If someone is interested in Kant dealing in a polemical way with the dogmatism of his days, he should read his text On a discovery whereby any new critique of pure reason is to be made superfluous by an older one: https://archive.org/details/kanteberhardcont0000kant It is fit to get acquainted both with the disputed questions of that time as well as the state of academic philosophy back then. However it also deals with some metaphysical subtleties, which won’t interest someone seeking an introduction to Kant’s thinking; reading it is therefore only recommended as a supplement and a deeper dive after first reading other works. Whoever wants to support my aufkläring work can do so via: https://ko-fi.com/jonathanivoloewer https://www.patreon.com/jonathanivoloewer https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=VDDT7T7XHR77U Thumbnail: www.hotpot.ai
Embed this episode
Ready to play
Kant's philosophy - Criticism as an answer to dogmatism and scepticism
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.