Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from to Islay Arund Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Tina Quinn and it's a pleasure to be back in your company and in the Fourth Estate Chair. I'd like to pay tribute to the amazing Anthony Docrell, who, whether it's host or executive producer always, sesh and incredibly high bar and he's left an indelible mark on this program.
Over the next few months I hope you'll join me each week as we deep dive into the most pressing issues affecting media, politics and of course everything else in between. This week we're going to take a step back. There's no competition for which news story truly dominated the headlines last month and if we're honest it wasn't really the war in Gaza or the presidential primaries in the United States or Vladimir Putin extending his reign with another election within Russia. The story that seemed to be consuming us all was that of a missing princess.
Whether it was tweets on X, threads on Reddit or your friends and families group chat we were all consumed with one topic and one question, where in the world was Kate Middleton? Was she dead, alive, in a coma? Perhaps recovering from a Brazilian butt lift gone wrong or maybe just growing out some very unfortunate bangs. The royal family is no stranger to gossip or conspiracy but the speculation on the health and whereabouts of the Princess of Wales reached new conspiratorial heights and grew to an absolute fever pitch with the release of a family photo which was designed to quell the rumours but only ended up pouring a lot of gasoline on them.
Then on March 23rd Kensington Palace released this field announcement from the princess. In January I underwent major abdominal surgery in London and at the time it was thought that my condition was non-cancerous. The surgery was successful. However, tests on for the operation found cancer had been present.
My medical team therefore advised that I should undergo a course of preventative chemotherapy and I'm now in the early stages of that treatment. So to say we were all left feeling pretty, well, grubby. Did we bully this woman into confessing something extremely private? How did this all get so out of control in the first place?
And how does it reflect on our relationship with once very trusted institutions like the media and the monarchy? So as the dust settles on this story, let's do a post-mortem. To assist us in that, we're joined this week by Alan Russ Bridger in London. Alan was the editor and chief of the Guardian newspaper for 20 years.
Since 2022 he's been editor of Prospect magazine and shares the Royce Institute for the Study of Journalism at the University of Oxford. Alan, thanks for joining us on Fourth Estate. I'm very happy to be here. Across the Atlantic is Ellie Hall who joins us from Washington DC.
Ellie spent 10 years covering the Royal Family for Thus Feed News until the outlets' demise in 2023. She's now a freelance reporter who can often be found in New York Magazine or online at Harvard University's Neiman Journalism Lab. Welcome to Fourth Estate. Thanks for being with us.
Thank you for having me. And lastly but certainly not least is Grace O'Neill, the editor and chief of the newly relaunched magazine, Elle Australia. Grace was previously the global content editor for Harper's Bizarre Australia and as a freelance journalist she's written for British Vogue, The Guardian and The New York Times. She's also the co-host of the Pop Culture Podcast after work drinks which is built quite the following.
And welcome to you Grace. Thank you so much for having me. So Ellie, I'm going to go to you first as you've been quite specifically covering the Royal Beat for over a decade now. Can you give us a bit of a timeline to how all of this really unfolded?
Yeah, so out of nowhere, January 17th we get an announcement from the palace that Kate is in hospital and she's had planned abdominal surgery. She's going to be in the hospital for about two weeks and then we won't see her again until after Easter. And there's lots of questions about this but doesn't really give any tons of lagging until people start noticing that there is a similar medical crisis going on at Buckingham Palace and they're treating it very differently than Kensington Palace is treating Kate. So your listeners might not know this.
The palace doesn't have one centralized media operation. Each world team has their own press team. They don't always work together. So the same day we hear about Kate, we hear that the king is going to be in hospital for an enlarged prostate and they're just giving far more information.
So he goes in the hospital, we see the queen visit him four times while he's there. We're out the two weeks that Kate's in hospital. William only visits her once. People just noticing some differences in how much information is being released to the public.
Soon after the king leaves hospital, we find out he has cancer and we see two public statements from him. We see lots of pictures of him. They even put a video out of him reading get well soon cards members of the public have sent. And meanwhile, no one has seen Kate.
There have been no personalized statements from her. It's just been a press release that she's had surgery and then a press release that she's left hospital. And everything sort of their questions being asked, some overseas media outlets raising some conspiracy theories, the Spanish journalist reports that she's in a coma and the palace actually goes on the record to deny that, which is not something that they do very often. Right, because usually the policy is never complain, never explain.
Exactly. So I know a lot of people who weren't paying attention started paying attention when they denied the coma workers. And then at the end of February, Prince William at the very last moment, 45 minutes before the ceremony begins, I think, drops out of a memorial service for his godfather, the late King Constantine of Greece. And this sort of explodes everything into pop culture.
People who have been following the world family have been sort of wondering, well, we haven't really seen any stories about Kate. We haven't really heard seen anything of the tabloids about her. But William dropping out of this memorial service, all of a sudden people start saying, Hey, what's going on with your wife? The palace lets it be known that it has nothing to do with Kate, but people don't believe him.
Don't believe him, don't believe the palace. And then from there, within 24 hours, they released another statement saying, we told you we wouldn't see Kate until Easter, why are you guys asking questions? And that doesn't help. Discussion continues to get louder and louder for a week.
And then they release a photo from others day, ostensibly of Kate and her three children. And then within 12 hours of the photos released, all of the world's major newswire agencies start releasing notices to their clients saying, do not run this photo. They put out what's called a kill order on these photos saying that it has been manipulated beyond their levels of acceptability. So that sort of takes what was just a burgeoning conspiracy theory and launches it into internet wildfire.
And that's when we reach the point that no one can talk about anything else in the world until we do get the announcement from Kate that she's being treated for cancer. Grace, I was in London at the beginning of March. And while I obviously knew that the Princess of Wales had been in hospital and that she was recovering from major abdominal surgery, I hadn't really given it much more thought until I was listening to the latest episode of After Work Trinks. You and your co-host Isabel Truman brought up the rumors that had been swelling online about her whereabouts.
Now, you yourself sounded completely enthralled as I became, as many became or some already were, by this topic. Why? Why, why we like this? Why did this capture our imagination in, I guess, all the wrong ways?
I think there's multiple things going on at once. I think all of the serious lofty news events you mentioned in your introduction have had the world feeling quite sort of down and desperate in a workplace. And I think stories like this have this mixture of the glamour factor of a beautiful princess and then the sort of who done it, the mystery novel aspect. But I think there was more serious underlying issues at play in why this captured so many people's attention.
There has been a sort of history in the royal family, specifically of women whose lives, talking about specifically Princess Diana and Megan Markle, Dr. Sussex, who's lives look so perfect and wonderful and shiny. And then later we find out behind the scenes, it was a very different story. And I think Princess Kate is an embodiment of that shiny, perfect, pristine, ideal of royal femininity.
And this idea that there might be some crack behind that facade was very exciting to people. And I think we saw as well this sort of spilling out of TikTok and Reddit and Twitter conspiracy theories into the mainstream media in a way that was very exciting for sort of internet sleuths. Right. So we all kind of got to be Nancy Drew for a little bit.
Yeah, exactly. I think there's this very strange blaring of the lines between what is just sort of idle, non-fact based gossip online and what mainstream media reports as fact. And we saw in the story of really interesting and to me slightly concerning case of fanatical conspiracy theories to a certain degree being proven right. And I think that was very fascinating for people as well.
We did have two instances of photos and video being taken of Kate out in the wild, so to speak. And the first was a paparazzi photo that was published on TMZ in America, but the palace leaned on the British press and they didn't publish it at all. And then we have a few days later, a video is taken of her. And that one does make its way into the papers, seemingly with palace is full approval.
So there's always a lot of conversation about, you know, what's the relationship like between the media and the palace? Does the palace control the media? And there seems to be some evidence of that. So that really, again, didn't help the conspiracy theorists when you have these examples of, okay, it looks like the palace really leaned on the press here.
What are they hiding? I can distinctly remember taking notice of British newsstands as I walked down the street when I was in London around this time. This is before the photo, before the Mother's Day photo. And the only mention I was saying of Kate were really glowing puff pieces about her on the cover of women's magazines.
And they were sort of going on as if, you know, she was still sort of around. And when I say around, like she was out and about kind of thing. Otherwise, the only other royal coverage that I was saying were in tabloid newspapers like the sun who seemed to just be ramping up their Harry and Meghan hit pieces at that time. So all the speculation about Kate's whereabouts, it all seemed to be happening outside of the UK.
Alan, you've worked in the British media for a fairly long time. Your ear would have been quite close to the ground when did you first hear that something might have been a bit awry over at Kensington Palace? I don't follow it that closely. I mean, I think that the problem is that we can't really decide to what extent these are private figures and to what extent they're public figures and what are their really small expectations of privacy.
And on a human level, of course, I think especially with the women who are marrying into the royal family who, and it was not a good track record of people marrying into the royal family living happily ever after, you want to cut them some slack and give them privacy. And yet at the same time, I don't think it can ever be perfectly private because the whole monarchy depends on people and the bloodline and the order of succession. And I think the royal family is in a sort of, it's held, can't really decide. So you've got some of the royals being quite open about their medical conditions and some not and some being semi-open.
And I think underlying all this is a certain sense of fragility about the royal family. I'm rather nerd in a nerdy way, and I read that the court's secular each day, which says he was doing what engagements. And there are not many of them now. Now, Harry and Meghan and Prince Andrew are out of the picture.
I think there are only seven names who crop up regularly. And in 10 years time, they're all going to be in their 70s and 80s or 90s, leaving just Kate and William. Well, when you think all the duties they have to perform and the number of palaces they have and the number of countries in the Commonwealth, it looks as though there's a normalization that's teetering on the brink of actually being able to function. So you can understand the sort of constitutional importance of family members getting ill, coupled with this uncertainty about what is private, what should be private, and what actually can't be private.
And I think all that was paying out of the background. It was often discussed in the 1990s when press intrusion into the marriage between Shaz and Diana was at its height about the public's right to know. Do we have a right to know this much in real time? I would say of medical conditions, not.
I think the moment Kate made the announcement about her cancer diagnosis, I think a lot of people think it's like the she-ish about that. But the fact of illness, I think yes, that is we do have a right to know. You know, when you've had Charles the king being public about his prostate, but private about his cancer, about the nature of the cancer and how severe it is. And this is all a bit of a mess.
I was very briefly a royal report in the 1980s. I came to Australia with Charles and Diana, and I thought it was the most terrible job imaginable because you're being spoon-fed by the palace. And since the last couple of weeks I've been reading these pieces, with no sources at all that have been spoon-fed and treasured royal correspondence. And I think it's all a bit demeaning for journalism really, frankly.
Much of the coverage of the monarchy in the UK is communicated by way of royal reporters. Alan, you once wrote that it's unusually difficult to judge the reliability of royal reporting. Why is that? Yeah, I mean, a good, trustworthy piece has things that you can check out.
You know, that's the point of having sources and naming them. If your entire career is built on having unnamed sources, because the palace sources are always unnamed, then by definition it's very difficult to check out any of these pieces. And that's a generalistic problematic way to accept it. Maybe the only way to do the job.
But it kind of suits the palace to be able to drip feed stuff out to people they want to keep on shortly. So they feel they can trust. But for the reader, it's very difficult to work out what's true and what's not true. And I mean, genetically, in any other walk of life, that would be a problem.
Deferring to our current royal correspondent on the panel here, Ellie, do you think that's a fair characterization of how the media ecosystem around the royal family works? I do actually. And I've quoted one of Alan's stories in my work where he says that for a while now, because it really is the best quick way to get people up to speed on how strange the world of royal reporting is. Because it goes a step beyond that.
It's not just feeding royal reporters, many times the members of the press team don't want to be quoted as such. And that's especially quite strange to me. Just normally, it's a mark of trust when you can tell your readers, okay, you know, the people they pay to do press for them, their media team has told us that we can give you this statement that's officially from them. You don't see that with the palace.
It's very, very hard to get them to go on the record. So if you're reading a story, you might see something that quotes a senior court here or a source close to the prince or something like that. That could be someone on their media team who just doesn't want to be named as such. And it's like, I don't think it's quite difficult to know what you can trust and who you can trust.
And once you start becoming familiar with the sort of stories that certain royal reporters can write, you can start being able to go through and play and guess the source, like guess who they're connected with, based on the stories that they're getting. And you really need to understand a lot about the reporters and the ecosystem to try to make sense of royal reporting. And that's a very high level of entry that your average reader won't always just comprehend. They're going to just trust what they read.
And it's much more complicated than that. Of the relationship between the palace and the press, Prince Harry wrote at length in his memoir, Spare about the different press teams within the royal family that represent the different households and how they often had quite competing interests and agendas. So you'd have one press team, which would be briefing the media against another household. So the picture that was painted was one of just complete dysfunction, not just within the family, but complete dysfunction as an institution.
Would you agree with the picture that he's painted there? Everybody has their own story that they want to get out. And that's something that is at heart problematic about the way the palace's press team works, because it's not one team. You have people playing for different teams.
And you can't, even when the queen was alive, no one could really agree what that centralized narrative was going to be. And now that it's even more divided, it seems to only be more and more of a problem in terms of Buckingham Palace and Kensington Palace and the stories that they're trying to get out there. And this was a really great example of what can happen when everyone loses control of narrative and turns it over to social media, because that's been the driving force behind all of this. Some people, yes, people in the media felt sheepish for encouraging some of this, but this was driven by Twitter, by Reddit, by the people online.
And it sort of felt like both the palace and the media were playing catch up for a lot of this, trying to keep up with what was being said online. Grace, you're living between London and Sydney at the moment. Were you in London before the Mother's Day photo? I was in London.
I think I'd just arrived back when the photo came out. And I think that, for me, represented such a turning point in the story. It gave license to people to discuss this in a far more open way for the media to jump on the story, because there is such genuine newsworthiness to this idea of an image distributed by the royal family getting a kill notice, because it's been so heavily doctored. I think that gave credence to what a lot of what seemed like dark corners of the internet chatter.
It suddenly elided. And I think it's representative of the fact that the machinations of the royal family's press teams, whatever happened with that image, whether it was edited by Princess Kate or by someone on the team, just how primitive those edits were, the fact that they weren't picked up on, and the fact that in a moment of such serious speculation, such a lapse could happen, showcased how ill-equipped that press team are for the current climate of social media, TikTok, Twitter. They either didn't understand the depth of the chatter and how fever pitched that conspiracy discussion was, or they did understand it and they just couldn't adapt to it. And either way, it's concerning that the palace going forward, because this is a new reality we're in, and the level of sophistication you have to have as the press team for an institution like that is just far beyond what they seem to currently have.
Also, just on that note about the Mother's Day photo, how likely do we think it was that Prince William actually took that photo, and that Catherine was just mucking around with it on Photoshop during her convalescence? We know from the metadata that the photo was supposed to be taken on Friday. We don't know where it was taken. We don't know when.
It was edited on Friday and edited on Saturday. We don't know when it was taken. We know that it was edited on those two dates based on what it was saved. I don't think if you're ever covering through surgery and you're a mom of three, you're going to be firing up at Opie Photoshop at 9pm, 10pm on a Friday night and just going to town, that doesn't seem like something I would do, particularly if I have a media team and presumably a graphic designer on staff.
Presumably. Well, yes. Alan, in terms of what this does to the public's trust for institutions like Monarchy, what is this done? Well, I think there is a crisis of trust in all kinds of institutions at the moment.
They're all found in Barcelona and trying to work out how they deal with that. To my mind, the answer is always more transparency. I've tried to think of organisations that operate with this level of unaccountability. Probably only the British intelligence services are up there in terms of not being quoted in the way that Ellie was talking about and not being on the record.
The American, for instance, the American intelligence services, when we were doing the Snowden story, much more willing to have frank conversations and be on the record in a way that the British intelligence services weren't. I think at some point the Royal Family is going to have to learn from organisations like that and be much more accountable and transparent and to have spokespeople who speak on the record and put things on the record. This technique of whispering things unachributably is not going to work. If you think there's going to be a crisis of believability in and I think the Royal Family certainly has that at the moment, then you have to change the way that you work.
I will just say to that, I think what's so difficult now, I was at dinner with some friends, very intelligent friends who that video came out of Kate Middleton walking around Windsor. They would just say, that's not her. Look at her fingers. Look at her hair.
Look at her. And I think now in this time of AI and deep fakes, the concern, even of the video that Kate put out, I saw a lot of discussion on Twitter and Reddit about disappearing rings and roofs that it was actually a deep fake. There's a kind of concern going forward, I think, about how you rebuild that trust because we're in an era where unless people see something with their own physical eyes and even then they don't know what to trust what they're looking at. And I think this will be the biggest challenge for the Royal Family and many other institutions going forward is how do you actually build that trust?
That's a really important point because I met people on the BBC who said that within hours of the, as it were, the official statement coming out from Kate, the BBC was having to paraphrase this. It all been shot in one take and as it went and fired their own metadata to prove that this was genuine because people wouldn't even trust that. So you've got a crisis of trust and if I were the panist, I would be calling people who have dealt with this in different kind of institutions and corporations. They're not alone, but I think they are alone in not realizing the depth of the crisis.
Well, on that note of the official announcement video, it's probably a good time to mention that Getty Images has actually put an editor's note in the caption info of that video. It says that this handout clip, as it was provided by the third party organization, may not adhere to Getty Images editorial policy. Now that's not a disclaimer that they use on all third party clips that are provided to them. They've at this point declined to elaborate on why they've chosen to put that editor's note or that disclaimer on this exact clip, given what has just transpired in the last month with that Mother's Day picture.
I mean, this is only going to raise much more questions and get more conspiracy sort of swelling online. Ellie, what do you think? Oh, yeah. No, this is already, people are covering the fact that Getty added that note.
We don't really know when they added it, but people noticed it within the last 24 hours. And like I said, they are not clarifying at all why they put that note on there. They are giving absolutely no details, but it's already raising more questions because there is this theory going around the internet that the video is a deep fake and it wasn't Kate, it was AI generated. And they used an image of her from 10 years ago, where she was filming a video for the heads together campaign.
And you can see that she's got two rows of teeth in the video and her rings disappear. And it's, it doesn't take much to get people going. And once again, you have now this morning from Getty on the image that is only firing it up again. And it's not going to go away.
Every time you think it's going to go away, it comes back up. Right. And then how much harder does this then go and make our jobs as journalists? So much.
I mean, when you have to convince people, people can't even agree on what the truth is. That's a problem. That's probably the starting point with all journalism. People are green on a set of facts.
So what do we do about the social media element in all of this? Obviously, social media can be a very useful tool. It can break some really important stories, but it can also be a complete dumbster fire of conspiracy and misinformation. So how those traditional media really navigate that?
This is more anecdotal than from my position in my role. But I would just say that I think that the core issue with social media is that, for example, there was a very nefarious conspiracy theory that was on Reddit. And if you go on the Reddit page, that's posted by one random person, there's maybe 30 or 40 comments and 100 or 200 up for it. The amount of people who screenshot it and shared that with me from all corners of the globe, all different professions, this opinions that are being formulated by a very, very, very tiny minority of people are suddenly now with the dissemination of social media being treated as if they have credibility or just reaching the furthest corners of the world, hitting millions and millions of people.
Whereas, back in the day, that's probably a slightly odd person that would have said it to their friend at a pub. I think that presents a huge, huge problem because, as we know, across most social media platforms, a very small minority of people produce a huge majority of the content. And so, where we're consuming it from, due to the algorithm and the preference of the kind of stories and posts that are promoted, is niche, very extreme opinions that allow us to feel excited and spike our interest levels become a mainstream thing when they're simply not mainstream anyway. This was driven by social media.
The photo really gave media organizations a chance to write about it in a way that wasn't social media. You can see people trying to find ways into it because it was what the internet was talking again. I saw a few people comment that Twitter X hadn't been fun in a long time until everyone started discussing all these different conspiracy theories, which again, then when the news came out, everyone felt not too great about having had so much fun talking about what ended up being a seriously ill woman. People would see something on Reddit, something on Twitter, and it would immediately go around.
The same thing happened to me in terms of screenshots. I can't tell you how many times I saw the same screenshot, and I was getting tired of debunking it again. It was something that I had seen two days ago. It was only beginning to make its way around the world, and it was wrong.
But there was nobody to step in and say, no, this is wrong because it's too much fun to share. It's too nice to joke about a Brazilian butt lift or bangs, or you get into some of the darker stuff that really began to come up and then get some media coverage. I don't think it's great for the royal family that when left alone, when the information void was allowed to grow to a certain extent, it's no longer fun. It's dark.
It's serious speculation about members of the royal family, about their marital states, about whether or not they might be murderers. You don't want to let it get to that level, and it got to that level, and it could again in a similar situation. I think the questions about whether the royal family's press teams are capable of meeting this moment are really valid. Alan, in the same way that social media has given everybody that's sorted, they're 15 minutes of fame.
Do you think it's also made people feel as if they're these amateur sleuths or investigative journalists who are cracking this case? The internet is everything. It's good, bad, ugly. Some of it is wonderful.
Some of it's dreadful. It is there. It can't be unevented. There are billions of people on it, and some of them will do.
I was just losing. The relationship between that and the circle of mainstream media is an interesting one. I actually think overcage the mainstream media behaved with comparative restraint in what was swimming around on the internet. But they haven't got teen hands themselves.
It's interesting to me that I've reread spare Prince Harry's book, which I think is a pretty honest account of how he experienced being in the royal family, and he has been less berated for it. I think there are two things going on there. One is about us as consumers of the royal family. I think we like our royal families to be sort of dreamy and fantastical and magical and fairytale.
We can't stand somebody who comes along and says, actually, it's not like that. This is how it works. This is how toxic it can be. This is how the press briefings go on.
We sort of instantly reject that because it upsets our national royal family. The second is Prince Harry is suing most of the British press and is in their interest to try and destroy him and his credibility before these cases get caught. I've never seen a declaration of interest or comparative interest from any outlet writing about Prince Harry. And again, that seems to me just a complete failure of journalism.
There is a conflict of interest if Harry is trying to show that you behaved in a criminal way or to get money off you in trying to discredit him, which most of the British press does most of the time. And I don't think that really aids our wanting to trust the British press. I think it's the part of most people that there are ulterior motives and games in play. Do you think the going on there in the last six weeks will make the public much more savvy to the inner workings of what really transpires all the machinations that are playing behind the scenes.
Has it ripped down the curtain to really reveal that? Well, I think some people, I think people have divided about Prince Harry, but I think quite a lot of people who have read his book may think he has something of a point. There are some people who disapprove of him writing about it at all, some people don't like him. But I think there's a kind of honesty there, which is lacking from some of the press reporting of the royal family, which feels to me as though it needs different kinds of narratives imposed on it.
And these changing narratives happen. As I said, there is a clear interest in the British press discrediting this person who is suing them. Ellie, do you find that there's quite a great level of sicker fancy when it comes to the way much of the royal rotor covers the royal family and the institution? I think that the thing is that the people have said behind the scenes about how many of these things went down have been very illuminating.
The editor-in-chief of the Sun talked quite openly about conversations that she was having with the palace leading up to the release of the video of William and Kate at the farmers' market in Windsor. Very obviously a conversation there, which very big contrast when the week before you're having royal reporters say that the palace leaned on the entire media industry, not to publish an image of Kate. And now a few days later something has changed. There's also been a very transparent attempt, but not just the British media, but led by the British media of a sort of shame on you tour that really is focusing on how dare people have asked these questions, how did we force this woman with cancer to come forward?
And I think that the medical, there are questions we ask about the medical issue, but to act is if there weren't huge PR errors and very poor decisions and to just immediately jump to shame on you, but if you ask any questions you're attacking a woman with cancer, you're attacking a mother of three with cancer, how dare you? There is a real attempt right now to sort of paint over all of the mistakes that were made to have it just be about how bad social media was, how bad numbers of the public were. And you really are seeing royal reporters sort of leave that rather than look at the very obvious PR errors that were made and missteps and times the royal family could have made a different decision and they did not. So I think I can answer the questions so much about the presidency, but in terms of working with the palace to possibly change a narrative, that's definitely something we're seeing right now.
Should we, as a society, feel a collective shame here for how we, I guess, how we conducted ourselves during those weeks of speculation, Grace? I think so. I think when I saw the news come through in my first reaction was guilt, just for the way that I feel that we, and I don't know how far that we extend if it's me and my circle of friends, if it's the whole internet, if it's everyone in the world, lost sight of the fact that at the course, this was a real human being. And I think this is an issue with celebrity culture in general, the royals, obviously being the pinnacle of that, especially in the UK.
I do think there's a very good reason why there are very strong rules around what you do and don't report in the media and why you don't engage with mindless speculation with nothing behind it, because it damages, it's damaging to people and damaging to institutions. Having said all that, I completely agree with Ellie that I think the idea of it just being the collective fault of the unwashed masses for speculating when the palace made really serious, not just the gaffes, but deliberate attempts to obscure the truth of what was happening in order to protect their image. I personally believe that a big part of this was the notion that it was bad for the royal family's public image to have two key royal family members sick with cancer at the same time, and that there was an intentional effort made to obscure the news of the diagnosis. I don't know where I stand on exactly where the line should be drawn with how much should be revealed about the royal family's health and when, but I do think there are serious questions here about the credibility of the royal family and that all the blame shouldn't be placed on the people who speculated.
I think it's a shared blame. Alan, just now getting back to Ellie's point there about how there's a certain section of the media now trying to assist the royal family in changing the narrative here. Does it remind you at all of September 1997 when Princess Diana was very tragically killed in a car accident in Paris, the media, a certain section of the media was again trying to change the narrative but actually deflect blame from themselves. I mean, and the fact that they had put a price on this poor woman's head, which really ended quite tragically.
In that case though, they were actually trying to deflect blame away from themselves onto the royal family and their treatment of Diana and really whipped the public up into a frenzy. Does it remind you at all of that, this sort of dark arts of deflection that they're quite well versed in? Yeah, I think it's, if you live long enough, these things have a kind of sort of, they come round in circles and somebody at some point, maybe this has already happened who wrote a book about the press treatment of Diana and the cycles that that went through of sort of shaming and persecution and forgiveness and rehabilitation followed by shaming. It was sort of you know, a never ending cycle.
And when she died, there was a kind of sense of shock and I think shame, self shame, self loathing by the press, realizing how callously they had treated her. And you know, maybe that will happen with Meghan at some point. You know, fundamentally, this kind of royal reporting is part of the business model. And I think it feels it doesn't really have much to do with journalism as a craft.
It's an unhealthy relationship. But I think we've talked about the need for the royal family to restore trust. And we know that the press has got a similar need. And I think maybe these kind of wake up moments, as we've seen with Kate recently, will lead to positive reflections by both sides.
Because the conduct and behaviour has been particularly edifying to the full, the status or the profession of journalism. Not great. So what now? Do you I mean, we've got a lot of issues here around transparency, around trust.
Where do we go from here? I think if I was working for, I guess not the royal family, but for the specific whales is right now, I would be using this brief period of hopefully space from the media and intrusion to be having some really frank conversations about the future of how communications are handled and how the institution can better adapt to a new climate. I think they're in a very, very tricky position that I don't envy, which is that so much of the power of the royals is built on the sneak and distance and a certain degree of unknowability and how you make that work in an era of social media, maintaining trust and authority whilst also not giving away the thing that makes you so unique is not an easy thing to do. But that unfortunately is what they're going to have to do.
Because as everyone hopes Kate makes a very speedy and healthy recovery, there will be a moment where she'll be back in the public eye again and all eyes will be on them. And there will be very little appetite for further mistakes. So I think there's skating on thin eyes, so to say, and I think they need to be prepared for that fact going forward. I like the percent.
I think that there is a respite now and people are going to feel not great about this. They've got some time before they come back. But the sympathy doesn't excuse some of the violations of trust. And I think we're going to see that the media seems to have sort of forgotten about that for in light of the horrible news that was shared.
But the fact that these wire agencies put out a kill order is not great. The AFP, I think was the editorial director of the AFP said an interview with the BBC. It was covered picked up by a lot of different news outlets. This is the sort of thing you see with North Korea.
You don't see this with the royal family. And I think they're really going to have to build up that relationship again. But also the thing Queen Elizabeth said, you have to be seen to be believed. The Wales family is going to need to be seen.
Prince William is going to need to get out there to the level that Kate's comfortable with. She's going to need to do that too, just because we are at this point in terms of deep face and AI and all of the things that can be speculated about everything, every piece of information that comes before our eyes. The only way this story is going to go away, the only way this public trust is going to be rebuilt. It's a person by person.
It's each person who shakes hands with Kate at a walkabout. It's every single person who you know can go online and say, I met her. Here's my cell phone video of her. And this was really great.
And she looks like she's really recovering because right now nobody has any reason to trust what they're putting out. And obviously with the Getty warning on the video announcing her cancer diagnosis. Now, that's just really proving that they have a lot of trust with the public and with the media that they need to build up again. And right now, no one's going to really call them on it.
But especially, hopefully when she recovers and everything sort of goes back to normal, that's going to be an issue. And they're going to have to deal with that. And I don't know if right now they're ready to deal with that. The social media, the mystique that's part of the royal family, I think they mistook the mystique and never complain, never explain with the information void and the information void got out of control.
And that's why you started to see these really insane stories and these really damaging stories come up. And by the time they went away and they couldn't get control of it. So there needs to be some sort of strategy to not let this situation happen again where it gets so out of control. But in the meantime, it's created this justification for us to feel like we need proof, we need more proof, we feel completely justified in that want and that desire and demand.
Well, I think with Kate's diagnosis and this sort of residual sense of guilt and shame that we all felt because you are not alone in feeling in your knee-jerk reaction big. Oh my God, we're all horrible human beings. I think that everyone feels so ashamed now. And I think Kimmy and the Palace is going to come down like a ton of bricks.
If anyone does anything to violate her privacy, photos of her taking going to treatment, I think we're all sufficiently shamed where there's not going to be a market for that sort of invasive coverage and invasive paparazzi techniques. I think that any media outlet that tried anything like that, the public outcry would be such an extent that really, how much would the Palace have to do themselves because we would all be so angry about her privacy being violated. But eventually when that's died down and when she puts herself back out there, again, there will need to be these conversations. So I think that the voracious press, the voracious audience has been quelled adequately, has been shaved adequately, but it's not going to last forever.
Well, it seems like a good note to finish on. I'd like to thank my guests, Alan Russ Richard. It has been a pleasure. Ellie Hall.
Thank you for having me. And Grace O'Neill. Thank you for having me. It was a pleasure.
And thank you for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of Twizzer and heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, a big thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a lot in between.
We'll be back with more next week of course, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle is Fourth Estate, are you? I'm Tina Quinn. Please do stay well, stay safe and we'll catch you next week on Fourth Estate.