Skip to content
Keeping Community Newspapers Alive episode artwork

Nov 11, 2021 38 min

Keeping Community Newspapers Alive

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

COVID-19 impacted on regional newspapers, forcing many to shut. But regional communities still have a hunger for news and from these news deserts, the green shoots of community publications emerged. So after a long year of lockdowns, how are these publications faring? This week, Monica Attard speaks with Susanna Freymark, the editor of the Richmond River Independent and indynr.com and Matt Nicholls, the editor of the Cape York Weekly.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Keeping Community Newspapers Alive

0:00 38:32
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails that keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.

Hello and welcome to For the State of Charlotte Art Journalism. We're coming to you from 2SCI in Sydney on the Gaggle lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the GloVide podcast, I'm Monica Atter. Well, when COVID struck in March 2020, regional news outlets were hit pretty hard. Last year, saw a litany of closures of newspapers across the region.

Some of them had been in operation for 100 years or more. After years of hearing about the crisis in the media business model impacting big media, now all eyes were turned to the local community-focused papers who were struggling before COVID, but for whom the pandemic was more or less a final blow. But though the papers themselves have been disappearing, there are two hopeful signs. Firstly, people still want and need at local newspapers.

And secondly, there are dozens of green shoots showing across the news deserts that COVID created. So how have these outlets been? Joining us today via Zoom is a framework, the former editor of the Richmond River Express Examiner. She then became the editor of the Richmond River Independent and is now the editor of Indie NR, a website which provides regional news covering the Cuyogal and Richmond Valley regions in northern New South Wales.

And also joining us is Matt Nichols. He's the editor and publisher of the Cake York Weekly, a weekly community publication covering Cake York and the Torres Strait Islands. Welcome to you both. So Matt, we're going to start with you from our, tell us a little bit about the Cake York Weekly.

It's free, I take it. Yes, it's a free paper. And as the name suggests, we are a weekly newspaper. We're right at the top of Australia in Queensland.

We cover an area about two thirds of the size of Victoria, but our population is only about 15,000 people. We've got two big centers, Cooktown and Weber, and one's a mining company, one's probably a tourism town, and we've probably got a dozen Aboriginal communities scattered throughout the Cape. So quite diverse and we do our best to serve as all those communities. So you cover the entire peninsula?

The entire peninsula. From all the way down to the most southern place we go to is would you all the way up to the tip of Cape York and we actually go into the Torres Strait as well? And what sort of stories do you cover in the main? Well, the ambulance roll over at the Cooktown Racist on the weekend.

We cover everything, so we cover things from COVID vaccination rollout to the pandemic to crime to community stories to events. We have a lot of big events in the Cape and this morning I was at Remembrance Day service in Cooktown, so we travel far and wide and we try and give people a sort of a broad representation of what's going on in our local communities. And what led you to start the paper? Why did you want to do it?

Well, I worked for the old Cape York paper back in the day and then it shut down March last year. And I was living in Cans at the time and I basically got the call to say that we've lost that paper, can you get one back? And I was contractually obligated to not work, not compete for 12 months, so I went to a September last year to start up and paper, even though the old paper was not running. So that was sort of motivation, just really to give the community members a voice because I've noticed in the 13 or 40 months we've been running that we've really been able to put a spotlight on issues in the community and also be a voice for both the councils and for the residents.

I mean, how did you fund the startup? Because that's... On the smell of my own, I was highly ragged. So no, look, I obviously my savings and my lovely partner was working, so she sort of helped for the bill for a little bit.

I sort of had some good, I guess, hand-shaking agreements with businesses that the first paper would come out, so the first paper came out on a Tuesday. We would invoice that day and we'd make sure a lot of the businesses paid within those seven days. And that was basically how we kick started. And we just didn't extend ourselves too much.

We didn't invest a lot in office space or things like that. So I was running off a laptop and I had a basic Canon camera and it just worked. And it worked actually really well. And of course, you're entirely online, correct?

No, we've printed the papers well. So on the month I happened in the paper go to Townsville electronically and they'll print it there and they'll go on the truck to Cans in the middle of the night. And then it gets flown to all the communities. So there's only two places to get the paper via truck, the rest will get the paper via plane.

And so it's advertising revenue kind of sufficient to keep that process happening? At the moment it is, yes, in the 13 or 14 months it's been terrific. We've had great support. One thing I learned from newspapers is quantity is really important.

So my pricing range was really well measured to get as many advertising as possible. And then it becomes a bit of a flow on effects. So people say the paper's doing well, people reading out this advertising, other businesses then pick up. And we've expanded.

So I also think it's worth noting that we sort of started out on the West inside of Cape York and then we slowly run the paper to cover the whole peninsula. It's not that we didn't cover things in Cooktown and other parts of the Cape, but the very start is just that we didn't focus our energy on day one. But now I mean Cooktown as we speak right now, we feel like we've got a good footprint across the whole region. And so just to be clear, Matt, you're running entirely at this point in time on advertising revenue?

Yeah, I've had no grants, no federal government support, no stakeout, but there's been nothing except for advertising revenue. Have you sought any grants? I haven't even applied for a grant to be honest. I'm a person at that time, but also a member of the Queensland Country Press Association.

They did a collective bargaining agreement with Google and I think Facebook as well. We missed out on Google this time around, our individual paper did, but we're making some changes internally to make sure we qualify for next year. Well, we'll come to that actually because that is a discussion I want to have with both of you. It says, and I might come to you at this point because you've had a bit more of a difficult time of it, I suppose.

You were the editor of the Richmond River Express Examiner. That had been in publication for some 150 years before it was closed down last June by Newscorp, its owner. First of all, you had that paper being travelling OK before the closure? It's hard for me to answer that because I didn't have, you know, when I went for Newscorp, I was the editor and didn't know the ins and outs of the business model.

I think papers was struggling across the region for Newscorp. And for me, part of that was because there was just this constant pull away from what I consider, you know, super local news. And that also includes advertising. I think when people read a local newspaper, they also want to see local ads.

I know it was a very loved paper than the community were to so upset when they heard within two weeks that it was going to be closed without even an online presence. And what was it, circulation at that point? Do you know? 15,000.

Right, so that's not terribly unhealthy, correct, in terms of local newspapers? I don't think so. I mean, we cover a really wide geographic area. The population's about 33,000.

It's Kyogal and Shire and Richmond Valley Shire. So it's quite a diverse community. And it's not as wealthy as neighbouring communities of Ballano, Byron and Lismore. They're where the money is.

So one of the reasons I've continued to want to do News in those Shires is because then I don't think they're well-represented at all until we have a fire or a flood. And when you say, well-represented, you mean urban media outlets? Well, just in any outlets. You know, we have a great ABC in Lismore.

They will cover some stories. It's just limited because there's not enough reporters on the ground out here. Right. And is the area, do you think, in your view, at least reasonably represented in mainstream media?

No, not at all. I don't think so at all. The only time we had a lot of attention here was when we had the 2019 fires when Rapville lost 18 houses. I know the Guardian is now doing a rural focus.

I think it's very hard for those bigger agencies to cover these smaller areas. And I just think, like, today, I've been at the Remembrance Day, which, you know, there'll be photos on the TV everywhere about Remembrance Day, but in Casino, where will those photos be? And then I had to go after that to do a story about a woman who's worked at the brush for 50 years, which doesn't sound like much, but it's a really big deal for that community because mothers have taken their daughters to get brass fitted. And she didn't want to do a story.

And I said, people will want to see it. And I know I haven't put it online yet, but I know when I put it online, people will love it because it's about them. And of course, that's a hyper-local story. Are there stories that you see in your region broadly speaking, that you think do deserve wider coverage, do deserve to be taken notice off by state and national media about?

Obviously, this is a big beef industry area, so there's a lot of stories around the beef industry. I think one story I'm working on that, I think, needs national attention is take forest and the agreements they've done with farmers. I know many farmers who have planted hectares and hectares of spotted gum and other trees and have been left high and drive by state forests. So those stories that I would have thought would be of interest nationally, not just to this area.

Yeah. OK, so let's just go back to what happens. So after the Richmond River Express Examiner is closed, you don't lay down and say, oh, well, that's over. You just heard the Richmond River independent.

So tell us a little bit about that process. What were you thinking? What did you want to achieve there? I think at the time it was the emotion and the loss.

I remember crying at my hairdressers because I just couldn't believe the paper was gone and people's response in the community. They were quite angry. And a group of people from Caiogal called me for a meeting and said, we want to start a paper. At that time, we really wanted it to be owned by the community, so it could never be sold again.

So I didn't necessarily want to own a paper. I just wanted to be the editor. So we had two weeks to get a paper going because we didn't want to miss the routine of the Wednesday for people, getting their paper every Wednesday morning. So we started up the independent and it was a rollercoaster and it was fantastic.

I'm sure it was very exciting. So tell us a little bit about how it was funded. Well, we had a fundraiser crowd funder. We got about 11,000 from that.

Our paper was weekly and free as well, like maths. And all of our money came from advertising. And we had a lot of support like we had Days Machinery and Casino RSM. They agreed to take out the front page and back page for a whole year.

And Casino RSM would, you know, if we were running short of money, they would pay us three or four months in advance. So we had a lot of support and a lot of that came off the fact that people had lost their paper. So the community really rallied for over a year. We went for 14 months for over a year, volunteers delivered the paper every Wednesday, which was a lot of work because we're a wide geographical area.

We had a journalist, but we couldn't afford to have another journalist. Bit like Matt, we ran on the smell of an Orley Rag, had a donated office. And I did the editing and the journalism. And I had a sub editor, designer and two ads sales people.

So we were a very, very small team. Were you being petty? Was this with these papers? Yes, we were all paid industry rates.

I couldn't afford to do it for free. I needed to pay my rent. So we were all paid, you know, as well as I've been paid any other job. But since then, of course, that has been forced to shutter as well, correct?

Yes, during the lockdown's up here, we had quite a few. And our revenue fell by about 50% because people just weren't advertising. There was a lot of uncertainty. So I have taken that news online to indianr.com because I just didn't want there to be a vacuum of local news.

How are people reacting to it going online? Is it? Some people love it. And of course, when you go online, like we're up to 20,000 users, you grow very quickly online because it's easy to share.

So a lot of people love it. And a lot of people really miss the paper, like when I go into town, you know, they come up to me and say, I cried when I heard the paper was shining and I was like, me too, it's a different audience. I would love to have both. I would love next year to see how things are travelling here.

And I would love to get a paper going again. I think they go hand in hand. But what's good about this time I've got in these few months, when I was doing the paper, I didn't have a lot of time or energy to make the website compelling. So now I have a lot of time to do a really fantastic online news presence.

So I would like to see both. And when you say that the audience is different, is it younger? How is it different? Well, of course, the people, you know, a lot of people come up and said, you know, my mum's in a nursing home, she loved getting the paper.

So it generally is an older audience that want the newspaper, because when we had the paper, I'd meet younger people and they'd say, oh, no, I only read the news online. And I read the news online on my phone every morning over coffee. But there was something about, there's a certain magic, I suppose, of that Wednesday. And Matt would know this when the paper comes out and everyone's reading it together.

You know, they've got it tucked under their arm or you're walking down the main street and you're looking at a cafe and people are reading it and sharing it. There's something about that you can't get online that they're doing that together. And you still, in my picture, still get people, you know, like, if you're out somewhere and you take a picture, the kid will turn to the parent and go, I'm going to be famous. I'm going to be in the paper.

There's still that credibility out in the country. So now that we're out of lockdown, a question to both of you, really, are you expecting to see more new business open up that could contribute to your revenue base, Matt? Well, I should just add that K-Gore has in that one case of COVID, it hasn't been locked down at all, really. So we've been very lucky and I really mean that we've been very, very lucky.

We know the virus is coming and we have to look down vaccination rates in some communities. I don't think we're going to see a whole new opening of new businesses, but we'll see, we'll see business growth, particularly in the tourism sector with orders opening up. People wanted to get out and about international travel still limited and people wanted to explore their own back out. So, you know, in the next five months, we'll see we're growth in the business sector in K-Bore, but we won't necessarily see a lot of new businesses.

When I refer to us being out of lockdown, I mean, what we have been told repeatedly is that there's a great demographic shift underway at the moment that people are leaving major towns and big cities and heading for quieter locals. Is that something that you're noticing, Matt, up there in the peninsula, or is that not there to you? Well, I mean, K-Town at the moment and K-Town real estate's definitely, you know, had a big change in the last five or eight months. It's certainly been a lot of southern buyers coming to the market.

Very hard to get a rental in K-Bore, but we've got fully occupied downtown, has very low vacancy rate for rental. So, yeah, I just think that there's been a lot of southern buyers and there's a lot of empty homes. So, the southern buyers bought them, but they're not necessarily renting them out because they want the holiday houses and they want to eventually move you when Bore is open. So, yeah, there's going to be an interesting change in the next six or so months when things open up.

And, Cesar, are you noticing a similar change where you are and do you expect that that might give advertising, revenue or boost if that demographic shift translates into the opening of new businesses? I think it will. I mean, it's still very quiet in the towns. In terms of housing, I do regular stories.

I just put one up two days ago about a family living in a hotel for three months. Rentals have more than doubled, particularly Cuyogol when a house is listed within a day or two at sold. The pressure on here is incredible. I was living in Byronshire and had to leave there because my house was sold and rent was tripled over there.

That's really gone high. But even the effect for the West in Casino and Cuyogol, there's so many people struggling. Like, and I'm quite interested in what that's going to mean because you've got people like me who were displaced from the coast who have come out to live out in the West. You've got people coming from the city.

We're hearing a lot of real estate agents saying people are buying sight unseen. And my worry is that people, like these people interview this week, the landlord wanted to sell the house. They've had to go into a hotel while they look for somewhere else, which they can't find a reasonable rent. What will happen to all those people?

There's going to be a price we pay in society for all those people who have nowhere to live. They're either going to have to go for the West or where are they going to go. So on one side, you will have more business opportunities. And I think we'll see a lot of profitability, although we haven't had the same bounce back as we had in the 2020 lockdown after that one.

But there's going to be a social outfall. And I'm watching it slowly unfold. And it feels like at some point it's going to reach a tipping point. And it's going to become dangerous.

I know women who are living in their cars, which in the country, we're all saying people shouldn't be living in their cars. Well, there's a caravan park at Casino Indochiog, it's full of people who can't find a rental. And something's got to give in that situation. It's an interesting social dimension, isn't it?

When you experience those kind of demographic changes, but I would imagine as well that with those changes, people are going to be wanting they need to work, right? They need to start businesses presumably. If they start businesses, they need to advertise. They're going to advertise over the newspaper, online or otherwise.

So surely that is an exciting prospect as a revenue stream for you? Yes, it is. I just haven't seen it yet. It's been slow.

Like when I go to the main center, it's like it's slowly waking up. There isn't that burst of activity that we had after the last big lockdown. So it's slow. I can imagine that will happen.

And people are starting to speak differently about things and there's Christmas coming. And of course, for me, online advertising is much cheaper than pre-advertising. So I'm hoping that will be the case. I'm sort of trying to get a feel of that at the moment.

There's only hints of it. I haven't seen huge evidence of it yet. OK, so I'll just want to chat a little bit more about the coverage of your various communities. I won't reverse the question for a minute with you.

What do the people in your community think of the media coverage of the peninsula? Do they rate it? Do they see it? Or is it non-existent?

No, they don't rate it all. I think KPL when the national or statewide media cover stories up here, they usually do a really bad job of it. And they usually make mistakes and mistakes that wouldn't be made if they had local knowledge. And the Cants Post is a good example.

The Cants Post, they will only cover using KPL for the first day. Usually if it's negative or really sensationalist, a crock attack or a sum of death or a car accident or something. But they're not covering the day of the day's issues. But the problem is when they do cover those big events, they do make mistakes.

And they can upset quite a lot of people. And unfortunately, that puts pressure on me locally to not only get right, but then to deal with the reputation of journalists not caring or not being sensitive to those matters. So I feel like people in the Cape Trust me and they know me and they really respect the job that I do. But unfortunately, our colleagues in bigger organisations tend to care less about the impact they haven't covered in those stories and what it means on the ground.

And so is what you're getting back from people in the community that there's a bit of an us and them thing happening between... Oh, definitely. Give me a good example of when the Weberfishing Classic was on earlier this year or only a few months ago. And they rang the owner of the local tackle shop to get some insight onto the event because quite a bit of it.

The tackle shop guy told me later that night, he's like, I had the camp's post-ring meeting. He said, I told them, I only talked to Matt from the local paper. I don't talk to you guys because you know, which is really nice to hear. But you know, I'm not against the other camp's post covering our events or anything that's positive for the regions overall better because they're not competing with us because they're not taking advertising.

They're not taking our readers. So I've got no issue with them trying to have a footprint in my area. I just hate it when they stuff it up because it's embarrassing really. And it also puts more pressure on me because I have to tell the story a different way sometimes because often I'm correcting their mistakes because they're a daily and you're on the weekly.

And the result of course is a mistrust between the community and the national media. Yeah, 100%. And look, to be fair, ABC far north in Cairns do a reasonable job. Again, they're not doing day to day stories on the ground.

They're just doing bits and pieces, usually the highlights. And in fact, they read my paper. They follow a lot of stories up from the go in my paper. They'll often ring me or text me and say, I'm Matt, have you got a number for this person?

I'd love to do a follow up on that. And I'm usually very cooperative, often go on radio sometimes and do segments and bits and pieces to help them out. A lot of people I shouldn't be ABC because they know where they stand and they know that they come second to the local paper. But I feel like they're trying to do a good job and telling out local stories.

Now, both of your outlets are, you know, the independent. They're not owned by big regional syndications or syndicators like Mews Corp and, for example, Australian community media. Does that separation make much of a difference to the way you operate and also to the way the community sees you, Susanna? I think it's a massive difference.

And I hadn't realized how messy that was until it happened. And when the paper was community owned, I really did feel inside like I was working for the community. And you know, people think my job is writing stories. My job is all about relationships.

Bit like Matt was saying, you have these relationships with people. They call you up. When you walk down the street, they go how's our editor today? So they all know who you are.

If you do get something wrong, they will tell you the next time they see you. So you're not anonymous. You're very much a part of the community. It's been really interesting.

I feel like my question that I always ask is, is this of interest to the readers? Do the readers need to know this? Why? So they are always at the forefront of any story I do.

I don't have to consider any corporate ideals or not. It's all about them. I find that quite free because, you know, it might sound good, but it isn't a huge privilege to tell people stories. You know, you don't see a farmer.

They might be a bit shy about getting their photo taken or they don't think they're interesting and they are. They're in the paper. Everyone says, I saw you in the paper. I saw you online.

You become a big part of their life for that moment. And I think it's a real privilege to tell that story. So I think when I was with Newscorp, your culture had to subscribe to get the news, which I am not a believer in subscriptions. And people, you're taking this story, you're rewriting it, repackaging it and presenting it back to their community.

So that's a huge responsibility. And one, I don't take lightly. I just want to say really importantly, I used to read the front page of the paper, so down there and there, and he said, well, what I like myself being free and independent newspaper is we can put whatever we think is the best story on the front page. We could be positive.

A lot of the news call, but even the region community media front pages, they focus on crime and courts and getting people pick up and buy it. The advantage of being free and community focus is it doesn't matter what you put on the front page, because we don't need to sell the paper. We don't need people to buy a subscription. I'm not anti-subscription.

I believe there is a place for page journalism, like that's my issue. My issue is that the Newscorp model of driving subscriptions based on bad news, tragedy, clickbait. I really don't feel like that's got long-term value. I've got friends that work at the Newscorp and I always have this argument with them.

It's easy to get a subscriber. It's harder to keep one. Give away these trials. They're $4 for the first month or whatever it is.

It's nothing. So some of the things that I'll click on, they'll pay the $4 or whatever. But do you keep that person? I used to have that person in the use time or they just buy it and then see no value for it.

The Newscorp model is all about getting new subscriptions, whereas I'm all about keeping my readers. Then obviously growing. If readers are happy, they'll just keep coming back to the paper for a week and a week out. If they're not happy, why don't you lose them?

You might not ever get them back. The car asks you both. It means they're not downsized. You're not being aligned with a bigger organization.

That is that if you were aligned to a newscorp or an ACM, that you would have an easier time of getting your community recognised in the bigger state and nationally focused debates. I don't feel that because it's all about the story and there's a lot of women in a big company. There's a lot of noise. So your story's got to still cut through that, whatever the loser is.

Obviously, things like, and I still do this online as well, like recipes, the humor column, the quiz, they're all done locally, whereas when you're with a big organization, you have that syndicated copy. So you don't have to find that. But I really like those smaller parts of what I do, the fact that they are written by locals. I just again, there's a certain excitement about that for them.

I don't know. I haven't thought of any downsides. Maybe when there's legal issues, you've got a big legal team backing you. Like when if there was an issue when I worked for Newscorp and I did a developer story and they threatened to sue, you'd just pick up a phone to the legal team.

So that sort of thing, that's a safety net. There's most probably less safety nets when you're doing it on your own. Right. And what about for you, any downsides?

The only downside I could say is just the resources in terms of technology, but the way it used goes, going, you're better off being independently home because if you're in a safe way to the camp, it's supposed to be on a computer board, where they're probably buying another old one or something like that. If my computer board tonight don't buy a new one and you might say, well, that might cost you money, but can you really afford not to have a good computer when you're running newspaper type things? I don't see a lot of downsides. The positives could be if you're in a bigger company, like the legal aspect obviously, but I've been a journalist for seven years and never been sued once.

I've been threatened to have been sued a thousand times. Also, that's a thing people say when they're like, oh, I'll sue you. I'm like, go for it, mate. If you want, I said, I've got no money anyway.

So what do you think that? I just think that people try can say, I'll make you're the next real murder, or whatever. And I just say, the news maybe industry, in my opinion, it's very viable as an owner operator model. But as soon as you need to pay shareholders or answer to a board or whatever, you're a tricky murky business.

I think it's sustainable in a very small scale locally, but they're not cash cows anymore. And I would imagine like once, you know, 12 months in, I'm starting to pay myself properly. I could probably pay myself from paper per hour on the record, maybe $85,000 to $85,000 a year. That's what I'm selling.

I'm going to pay myself. And I feel like that's probably under this for the amount of hours. I do, but probably a fair way to a newspaper editor in a big area like we're covering. I feel like there'd be no profit because any profit the payer makes goes back into the business.

So that might be hiring photographers, paying freelancers, getting computers or cameras, graphic designers. I could make more money. I could probably pay myself $110,000 to $120,000 a year and try make more money that way. But I certainly wouldn't be doing the community a favor by skipping on, you know, well, I feel like I'm important things like paying for photos.

I mean, when we cover an area like the way we do, there's only one of me. So I need people to take photos and do paid for their work. So by the sounds of it, then, of course, you would no doubt appreciate it. If you were able then to negotiate with one of the platforms with a Google or a Facebook in the shadows of the news media bargaining code, you mentioned earlier, Matt, that you just missed out on Google.

But that was, look, there's a few factors that apply. So I'm quite in-country press association. I had to go into confidentiality agreement in the negotiations. So they couldn't really go back to individual publishers and say, well, Matt, if you made these requirements, you'll get it or whatnot.

So what they did is they did the best deal they possibly good for as many publishers as they could, asked being really print focused. I'm not saying print focused, but print focused, I mean, we put the print paper along, but we don't necessarily have a great website presence in uploading stories daily. And that's where the Google saw the value in those uploads per day and things like that. But that was okay.

So we missed out. So that would be a nice 30 to $35,000 a year if we're on the bottom tier. But that's okay. So the first thing I did was instead of sulky, I just went and went to a website developer, one that developed our site for success when he spoke, went to them and said, Hey, I want a website that looks exactly like this, but customizer for our brand.

I'm going to pay them probably $10,000 in total months. It's all running down. I've got my hands on that website. I'm going to start police stories on a daily basis because I don't see the $35,000 a year from Google as being $35,000 for me.

I'm saying that I can spend $35,000 on a reporter to increase the news offerings we have. So that's what I want to do. So that money, if we do get it next year, that would go directly back into journalism. So it would incentivize you in other words to be a kind of journalism.

Yeah, 100%. I believe that Google and Facebook do have an obligation to support local news in Australia. And that's not just, I must say, like, I mean, it could be the Sydney Morning Herald as well. I think they've definitely been a competitor to our business.

And not necessarily a bad thing. I mean, I use Facebook every day. I mean, I find more stories out of Facebook than I probably do from people ringing me up anymore. Because back in the day, when I was like, that people see a character in the street and ring the paper.

Oh, Matt, you better come down here. There's a bit of character in it now. They'll just get on Facebook and say, oh, there's been an accident on Charlotte Street. You also use social media, though, in terms of getting your stories out to your readership.

Is that a big thing for you? I would say it's probably 20% of our traffic comes from social media in terms of news, like readers online. We have a huge subscription list. I just email the paper out every Monday night and I've got over 1,000 people on that list.

So and then they forward it on. And yeah, where to now? So Facebook's an important tool for Jones. I think we've got to work side by side.

But I think that Facebook and Google can certainly pay their fair share along the way. And so, does that know how much of your traffic comes via social media? Oh, I do Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, but this area, Facebook is the most popular. I would say, now with what we're doing online, 80 to 85% is coming from Facebook.

Oh, that's a lot. Well, because we're a new site as well. So I post a story on Facebook, I post it on everybody. And because you know, I get the Google Analytics, I, oh, it's huge.

What comes from Facebook, you put a story up and it's a bit like the analytics is like my little new poker machine watching. How many clicks I get on a story? How many people are using the site? So it also gives you an indication of what stories people are liking as well.

Well, you up and running when Facebook momentarily closed down news feet? Yes, yes. That was you. What do you think they have on you?

Well, I quickly just turned my personal Facebook. I went on there and said, we're over here. And I just hosted the news on my personal Facebook page until they reversed that decision. But it was an interesting sort of call to all of us because at any point that could happen with Facebook.

And have you sought to send it to to bargain with Facebook? I was obviously a bit of a loss how to do that. But I've connected with a lawyer who said he's representing about 5% of the independent media in New South Wales. So I have connected with him.

So he's going to make a case for all of us because we're all too small to do it on our own. So I'm yet to hear what's going to come of that. But I hope something will because I would put about five or six stories online every day on the website. Yeah, I have to see what happens without one.

Okay, we're almost out of time. But can I just ask you both to finally and briefly tell me if you can what you've learned since starting your various ventures and what would you pass on to others who want to get into the same terrain? Cisanna? Well, for me, I've had to learn to be good at lots of things.

In years gone by, you just did the story. You never wrote the headline, didn't take the picture. Now I write the headline, take the picture. I've learned to code with the website with the newspaper, I had to learn about how to build a newspaper.

So my skill set would have grown massively in the last two years because I've got to be good at a whole lot of things. I had to be good at managing staff. And my fallback position when I get really tired, what always lifts me is when I go out and do a story that's like, oh, this is what I'm doing it for. But the amount of other work I've had to do has been absolutely huge.

So I think I'm a lot more skilled than I was two years ago. Okay, and Matt, what about you? What have you learned? The thing I've learned most is that small business owners, they run this country.

They such hard work. I mean, just being a newspaper editor on its own is really difficult. Being an operator, just probably doubles a workload. And I wouldn't have been able to find interest stress along the way.

I mean, yes, it's been times where you've been keeping it on the books and you've got to pay back and things like that. And I just think that the amount of work that goes into running a business is highly commendable and a real appreciation for it now. The money outside of people, if anyone's listening here, that the community doesn't have a newspaper or doesn't have a media outlet is think about how you're going to go about it. But if you want to do it, if it don't expect to get rich out of doing it, you might be able to make a living out of it.

Hopefully you can. But I ask for help. I mean, there's people out there that will be able to offer advice. I mean, I'm a phone in other communities.

I've been approached by Douglas Shrycansling, I'm a board Douglas, to get to Andy's paper back up and running. I've been approached by Robbie Carter, the state MP about newspapers out in his area. There's a real appetite for news in those regional areas. But how you make it work and how you save money is really key.

And one thing I worked out about saving money is real estate is the biggest cost in a lot of businesses. Lues the office, work from home. If you need to do an O'John meet them in the cafe or a parbo, or in the park or your house, save on the money in terms of real estate because the rent really does draw the prices and you're paying for double internet expenses and electricity expenses and air conditioning. So save as much money as you can.

You can do a newspaper off a laptop. I mean, I've got a public computer obviously and a laptop. But I remember two years ago, I was in Sri Lanka of all places before COVID and I put out a newspaper from Sri Lanka. So it can be done.

You just need to have a really good work ethic and be prepared to hit a few hurdles. But once you get over those hurdles, it's really, really satisfying. Well, Matt, you make it sound almost tempting. I think we'll leave it there.

I thank you both very, very much for your time today. And I wish you both a best of luck. It's a hard ride that you're travelling, but it sounds immensely satisfying. So, Suzanne at Framark and Matt Nichols, thank you very much for being on Fourth Estate.

And on that note, thank you to Suzanne at Framark and Matt Nichols for being on Fourth Estate. And thank you for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation.

Thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe before the stage on your favourite podcast app so that you can hear us talk about media, politics and of course, everything in between. We'll be back with more next week. But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter.

Our handle there is Fourth Estate.au. Thanks to my producer, Toby Hemings and executive producer, Anthony Dockall. I'm Monica Atard. Thank you for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 38 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on November 11, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.