All right. Well, welcome to DC5. Happy to have everyone here. Happy Valentine's Day. I'm excited about this talk today. I've been looking forward to this talk on the calendar since we put it there many months ago. So I'm excited to introduce Dr. Mike Keller. Mike works at both NIH in the critical care medicine department, and I think also you do some time at Johns Hopkins, right, Mike? Yeah, I do lung transplant at Hopkins as well. Okay. And so Mike is here today to talk to us about heart-lung interactions in spontaneous and mechanical ventilation. Mike, again, I'm super excited. Thanks for being here. Great. Well, thank you. Thank you, Annie, for the introduction. So we're going to just jump right into this, guys.
We're going to be talking about heart blowing interactions and spontaneous and mechanical ventilation. I have no disclosures. And so just the first thing I just want to point out is that. both spontaneous and mechanical ventilation can really have dramatic effects on the hemodynamic status of the patient. And if we're not considering these effects based on really a sound knowledge of the principles of physiology, we're potentially missing out on really a wealth of valuable clinically relevant information. And I think truly doing our patients a disservice. So this is just kind of an outline of the talk. And throughout the course of the talk, we're going to first cover the physiologic determinants of cardiac output. And now this will involve about 10 minutes of a review of the physiology. And for many of you...
I'm going to warn you, this can get quite tedious and I may lose some of you, but try and stay put and understand as much as we can so that we can apply these clinically. We're going to cover both spontaneous ventilation and positive pressure ventilation. And for positive pressure ventilation, that includes mainly intermittent positive pressure ventilation, but also a blurb on the effects of PEEP, although they're very similar. And then throughout the talk, we'll talk about the effects of ventilation in various disease states and then how to avoid detrimental heart-long interactions. So first, a disclaimer. So the first thing is that there's going to be, as you'll notice, there'll be a lot, there'll be countless variables really to take into account when predicting the impact of ventilation on hemodynamics. And more often than not, we cannot measure all of these variables, actually most of these variables. And so what we end up doing at the bedside is oftentimes resort to really guiding overarching principles in order to make our best prediction, which is what we do a lot of times in the ICU. And that rings true here.
And then lastly, this is really to serve as an introductory lecture. So I may not go into some of the other subtle nuances that are involved with this, that are outside the scope of this lecture. So let's start off with the case. We have a 76-year-old female with COPD and heart failure with reduced ejection fraction. And you come to evaluate her in ED or for a consult in the ICU. She presents with shortness of breath and she's having some chest pain. She's in respiratory distress. She's got cool extremities and really significant amount of increased work of breathing that you notice on exam.
She has an EKG with ischemic changes. Her troponin is a little elevated, and here's her chest X-ray, as you'll see here. So bilateral pulmonary infiltrates concerning pulmonary edema. And so I want you to think about a few things. So number one, what impact does her breathing pattern have on both her hemodynamic status, given the comorbidities we mentioned, and then the degree of cardiogenic pulmonary edema?
And then to take this a step further, she's ultimately intubated. She's treated accordingly in the ICU. And then four days later, she's now undergoing spontaneous reading trials. And so when she's undergoing her SBT, I want you to just take a second and think about what are the potential impacts of extubation on her hemodynamic and respiratory status, especially given the comorbidities that I just mentioned. And what kind of consideration should we make prior to extubation?
So let's just start off with some just very basic guiding principles. And that's that the effects of ventilation on the counter-action system are primarily mediated by really two things. And those are changes in lung volume and changes in intrathoracic pressure. And spontaneous ventilation, as we know, is really characterized by an increase in lung volume and a decrease in intrathoracic pressure. And when I say intrathoracic pressure here, you have to be careful with that. I'm using this as sort of an umbrella term. And really, this is going to be synonymous with plural pressure for the sake of this talk.
And then mechanical ventilation is generally characterized by an increase in lung volume and an increase in intrathoracic pressure. So as you can see, since both of these forms of ventilation increase lung volume, the primary differences here are the differences on the effects of pleural pressure, intrathoracic pressure. So let's analyze where some of these effects may take place. So here we have a diagram. This is our right ventricle, our left ventricle, our pulmonary vessels. Here's our alveoli. Here's our pleural space. This is our pleural pressure, IVC, and our abdomen.
Okay, so the mechanical effects of ventilation really result from application of mechanical stress to various parts of the circulation system here. And these are the surface of the heart, the pulmonary blood vessels, the interventricular septum, and an area we don't often think about, which is the abdominal vessels. But really, if we want to have an understanding of the effects of ventilation on the cardiovascular system, we have to have an understanding of the factors that really determine cardiac output. So let's start off with a principle that we're all familiar with, the Frank-Starlene curve. And as we know, this informs us that cardiac output increases with increased natural pressure. And that the slope of this curve will change, which changes in the contractile state of the heart and changes in afterload. So if contractility were to decrease or afterload or increase, we'd have a shift in this curve to the right.
which is what this is telling us is that at any given rate atrial pressure, cardiac output here on the y-axis will be lower. And then with increases in contractility or decreases in afterload, we'll have a shift up. For the same filling pressure, we'll have higher cardiac outputs. But let's digress for just a moment. And you'll notice here in this diagram that there are flow states represented by a negative atrial pressure. And this is going to just be kind of a foundational component of the talk. I know many of you are aware of why this is the case, but I want you to think about how can you have a negative atrial pressure, right atrial pressure that you're measuring, but still have cardiac output.
That's because when we measure our radial pressures or our CVP, the number that we're actually seeing is referenced at atmospheric pressure. But this number really doesn't reveal the entire picture because we're actually missing half of the story here. And so this number may mean little unless we know that the pressure is surrounding the right atrium, and that's the transmural pressure. And that's simply the pressure inside the right atrium minus the outside, which is our pleural pressure. And this is a concept that we probably most generally feel comfortable with in regards to the alveoli, but the same principles apply to the cardiovascular system. So the transmural pressure here is the true distending pressure, the true filling pressure.
of the right atrium, okay? And so let me give you an example. Let's take this a little closer. We have a right atrium here. Let's say we have a right atrial pressure of 10 millimeters of mercury. Well, our right atrium is surrounded by a chest wall, and we have an associated pleural pressure standing outside of this right atrium, okay? And so what we're measuring here is a right atrial pressure of 10. This is what we're seeing on our central venous catheter. But of course, the true transmural filling pressure here is five, so 10 minus five, okay? Now contrast this to another patient.
The right atrial pressure that we're measuring here is 3, but this patient has a flow pressure of negative 5. Now, the right atrial pressure that we're recording is lower, but the transmural pressure in this patient is higher. There's 3 minus negative 5 to give us 8. And let's say this patient were to take a deep breath. or just a regular breath and lower their pleural pressure to negative 10. And assuming we have no increasing flow, the right atrial pressure may lower again to negative two. And again, this is what you're recording on your central venous catheter. But again, the transmural pressure here is really what matters. So looking at this alone in isolation, you could be missing a lot of information. So as you can see, the absolute right atrial pressure we're measuring, the measuring of the CBC or central venous catheter really changes with pleural pressure. And in fact, on this graph, the point where there's zero flow and transmural pressure is zero means that right atrial pressure essentially equals pleural pressure. And that's simple.
If inside minus outside equals zero, those two are equal each other. So as pleural pressure changes, you can imagine that cardiac output will shift along this axis. And with decreases in pleural pressure, as we see during inspiration, and increases in pleural pressure, as we see during expiration, we can see that this curve is going to shift along this graph. But again, if we want to know the effects of this on hemodynamics, this graph also only tells half of the story. And that's because it's important to keep in mind that the heart can really pump what it's given, what it is fed. So in other words, cardiac output also depends on venous return. So this is our venous return curve here.
As right atrial pressure lowers, venous return will increase. And so let's go into the factors that determine venous return. Well, in order to have flow, we must have a pressure gradient. We must have a driving pressure. You're all familiar with that concept. And so the upstream driving pressure for flow is really generated by the systemic venous reservoir. And that's called the mean systemic filling pressure. And essentially what this is, is the static elastic recoil pressure of the systemic vascular beds. And so what determines the recoil pressure here, our mean systemic filling pressure? Well, the primary determinants are vascular compliance.
Okay, how stiff those vessels are. And the stress vascular volume is the systemic venous fed. So as you can see here, looking at their equation, if you were to increase volume, let's say by giving a fluid bolus, you'll increase the driving pressure for venous return. And likewise, if the vascular compliance would decrease, there's stiffer vessels with higher elastic recoil, let's say vasomotor tone increases because you give vasopressors or you have an adrenergic response, your driving pressure will also increase. Okay.
Now, I emphasize the term stress volume here because not all blood volume that resides in the vasculature is going to descend the elastic walls of the circulation. So a certain amount of blood, known as the unstressed volume, pulls in the vessels without generating much pressure until enough accumulates and starts stretching the vascular walls and generating recoil pressure. Now, you can think of this analogous to like if you were to take a balloon, a deflated balloon, and put it on the table, there would still be some air in that balloon, even if you didn't blow in it. But it's not really exerting a recoil pressure. But once you started blowing air into that balloon, what you're really adding is stress volume, and that's what's going to result in the recoil pressure. So increases in abdominal pressure or any vasovac active agents, those may recruit unstressed volume to stress volume and increase in systemic filling pressure and your driving pressure. And finally, our downstream pressure for flow is right atrial pressure, which is located in the thorax. And again, this is subject to pleural pressure changes. And then we also have to account for venous resistance to venous return as well. So as we can see, putting this all together.
Our venous return is really a function of three variables. Our mean systemic filling pressure, our upstream pressure for flow, our right atrial pressure, our downstream pressure, and then venous resistance to flow. Okay, so returning to our venous return curve, now we can kind of better appreciate the relationship between right atrial pressure and venous return. And so as right atrial pressure decreases, the pressure gradient for venous return will increase and you have increased flow. But you also notice a point where flow becomes maximal. And this generally occurs at a right atrial pressure around zero at atmospheric pressure. And that's because at this point, you have abdominal pressure that rises above the intraluminal pressure in the great veins, the IVC, and it causes IVC collapse right at that thoracic inlet. Okay, and so notice here that flow doesn't cease, but it becomes maximal.
as vessels flutter open and close up thoracic inlet, and this is starting to have a vascular waterfall effect, okay? And now because resistance is simply a pressure gradient overflow, the slope of our line here is determined by resistance to being a slope, and changes in resistance will alter the slope of this curve. So as you can see here, it's really the negative inverse of resistance, but changes in resistance will affect the slope of this curve. And then lastly, we can identify mean systemic filling pressure on this graph. If you take a look at our equation here, you'll notice that flow will become zero when mean systemic filling pressure and radiative pressure are equal, okay? So therefore,
When we look at our radio atrial pressure at zero flow, this effectively represents our mean systemic filling pressure. As we can see, if we were to give a fluid bolus or get basal pressure, which would decrease compliance of the vessels and recruit stress volume, our mean systemic filling pressure would increase, and we'd have a right shift in the curve. So for any given radio pressure there, we'd have an increase in flow. And notice that our maximal flow has increased as well. Okay, so now if you're still following me here, what we can do now is combine these two curves, as Arthur Guyton described back in the 1950s, the cardiac output curve and the venous return curve onto the same graph, with the y-axis being blood flow, venous return or cardiac output, and the x-axis representing right atrial pressure. And importantly, the intersection of these curves represents the true cardiac output for any given right atrial pressure. And as you can see, it depends not only on just the cardiac function.
but all the variables that dictate the position of the venous return curve as well. And so this intersection is known as our operating point, or this is essentially the working central venous pressure that you're recording with a central venous catheter. But again, this value may mean very little in several circumstances because what really matters often is the transmural pressure, which is indicated here, which is right atrial pressure minus pleural pressure. And so this is really what represents our transmural pressure here. So let's see how this all relates to ventilation and how ventilation affects these variables.
Well, again, we'll start with spontaneous ventilation. So let's take a bird's eye view here. And the main concept here is that we already talked about. Spontaneous ventilation increases lung volume and also decreases intratheic pressure or clonal pressure. And in general, this will tend to increase preload, increase right ventricular afterload, and increase left ventricular afterload. So another way of putting this is if you look at these three things, spontaneous ventilation, it tends to really increase the amount of volume in the chest. Let's see why that's the case. So again, here are our guiding curves. And here's our right ventricular cardiac function curve. And here's our venous return curve.
And now with spontaneous ventilation, the muscles of inspiration are activated and lower pleural pressure. And as a result, the base of our cardiac function curve shifts to the left, because again, this is this point here, this base represents pleural pressure. And as you can see, we're now intersecting at a higher point on our venous return curve, okay? As radio pressure has decreased, we have actually increased venous return, thus cardiac output. However, we mentioned two changes here, not just a reduction of pleural pressure, but also an increase in lung volume. So as lung volume increases, we're going to have an increase in right ventricular afterload, and that shifts this curve down into the right of it.
Now, in normal health, we still tend to have a higher cardiac output, but this is kind of a summary of the changes we have from a cardiac output perspective. Now, so why does right-wing trigger afterload change with changes in lung volume? And I know some of you are probably familiar with this, but for a brief review, if we look at a relationship between lung volume and pulmonary vascular resistance, kind of have this U-shaped or inverted J-shaped curve here, where pulmonary vascular resistance is going to be lowest at FRC, and any decreases or increases above functional residual capacity will tend to increase pulmonary vascular resistance. And that's because of the differential effects that these changes in lung volume have on alveolar blood vessels versus extra alveolar blood vessels. So when we look at changes that occur below FRC, what we can see is that our extra alveolar blood vessels tend to be collapsed. We also have the combined effects of hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction. And so at lower lung volumes, the increase in pulmonary vascular resistance is largely due to the effects of collapsing these extra alveolar vessels. But as lung volume increases above FRC...
our alveolar vessels tend to be compressed by the alveoli, these increased lung volumes as exposed to the transpulmonary pressure, and that tends to increase pulmonary vessel resistance as well. So with increases in lung volume, we would expect an increase in our reactor load. So getting back to our curves, as you'll again notice, even though our CBP has decreased, our cardiac output has actually gone up. And that's because, again, the transmural pressure of the right atrium has actually increased, as we'll see here. Again, the transmural pressure of the atrium here is our right atrial pressure, which is right at this point here, the red dot.
minus our pleural pressure, which is, again, represented by the base of this diagram, where radiusure pressure minus pleural pressure equals zero. And so this is actually what we see in the literature. So this is a study by Pinsky back in the 1980s. And similarly, here on the left here, you have right atrial pressure. This is right atrial transmural pressure. We have pleural pressure, and then we have CBP, which you'll notice is during spontaneous ventilation, as a patient decreases their pleural pressure, CBP goes down, but right atrial transmural pressure will actually increase, as you can see here. And then the opposite occurs with positive pressure ventilation.
Okay. But again, this only tells, again, half the story because we have to recognize the effects of spontaneous ventilation on venous return. And so how does spontaneous ventilation alter the venous return curve? Well, if we take a look here back to our diagram and we have our equations above, well, during spontaneous ventilation, we have a decrease in pleural pressure and we have an increase in lung volume. Okay. So right at your pressure will go down, but with our increase in lung volume, we actually have diaphragmatic descent. And when we have diaphragmatic descent, this puts stress on the abdomen and increases intra-abdominal pressure.
And as that intra-abdominal pressure rises, we have an increase in stress volume. So we have a conversion of unstressed volume to stress volume, and that tends to increase our mean systemic filling pressure. So not only do we have a decrease in right atrial pressure, but we also have an increase in mean systemic filling pressure as well. And so what does that look like? Going back to our guidance analysis, we have an increase in mean systemic filling pressure, and we'll be operating at a point here on our graph. So a little bit higher cardiac output.
Having said this, the changes in venous return are actually dictated really by the volume status of the patient. So this was physiology described again by Fessler in the early 1990s. But in the same scenario that we just presented, we have a decrease in pleural pressure and an increase in lung volume and diaphragmatic descent. And a patient who is uvolemic or volume down, we may have vessels, large vessels that actually collapse as we have an increase in resistance to venous return. Okay. And so that may actually tend to decrease our venous return. And so what does that look like here? Well, that's going to, again, when we have changes in resistance to venous return, that's going to affect the slope of our venous return curve. And so a patient who's hypovolemic or euvolemic, they may look something like this. And cardiac output may not increase as much as we, or venous return may not increase as much as we expect. Okay. So this is the difference between a hypovolemic and a hypovolemic patient. Okay. Now, so.
So we know now why spontaneous ventilation may increase preload and RV afterload, but what about its effects on the LV? Well, in general, with spontaneous ventilation, there tends to be a decrease in left ventricular stroke volume, and that's really needed by two main mechanisms. One is we have an increase in RV volume, which causes displacement of the interventricular septum into the left ventricle, and it directly impairs left ventricular filling. This is a process known as ventricular interdependence. And then two, negative floral pressure actually impedes left ventricular ejection. And another way of saying this is that it increases LV afterload.
So a number of studies have demonstrated that an increase in artery volume... causes a decrease in left ventricular compliance and interviews with left ventricular filling. And as you can see here, the predominant mechanism is that the descended RV causes a leftward shift into the interventricular septum, into the RV. And then there's also experimental evidence that suggests that ventricular interdependence is really amplified in conditions of pericardial constraint, namely pericardial constriction and tamponade. And although this is a phenomena that also occurs in the absence of the pericardium, such as after a pericardectomy, it's markedly reduced in those circumstances. Okay. And so for an excellent review on this, Bob Weiss has a review, extra 1980s and long, which covers...
the effects on afterload and ventricular independence during spontaneous ventilation are very nicely. But again, ventricular independence can't be the entire explanation. for the inspiratory fall in left ventricular stroke volume. And that's because in animal models in which the RV is actually bypassed with an extracorporeal circuit, we've also demonstrated the same fall in left ventricular stroke volume of inspiration. And so let's look at how plural pressure affects afterload of the left ventricle. And so if we define afterload as systolic ventricular wall tension, then afterload is really a tough function of two variables. And that's...
transmural pressure and radius. As we know, wall tension is equal to our transmural pressure times our radiance, okay? And so this was a mechanism that was described in 1979 by Buda and Pinsky. And so to just look at why this is the case, let's take our left ventricle here. And this is our aorta. And this is our peripheral vasculature. Here's our pleural space. And let's say our peak systolic pressure generated by the left ventricle is 100 millimeters of mercury. Well, if our pleural pressure, again, is negative five, okay, the transmural pressure that the left ventricle has to generate during the peak of systole here is 105 millimeters of mercury, okay? But let's say now that the patient takes a breath, a deep breath.
and pleural pressure decreases to negative 25, okay? And the left ventricle still generates a pressure of 100 millimeters of mercury to overcome resistance of the peripheral vasculature. Well, in this case, the transmural pressure now is 125. So as we can see, that negative pleural pressure is really an impediment to left ventricular ejection. It's kind of, you can think of conceptualizing it as it's kind of pulling the ventricular walls open and not letting them close as easily. So if we, on the other hand, were to increase pleural pressure to 25 millimeters of mercury and...
and look at our transmural pressure, now it'd be 75. Okay, so positive pressure in this case essentially facilitates the inward displacement of the left ventricular walls during systole and again decreases left ventricular afterload. So negative pleural pressure increases in afterload, positive pleural pressure tend to decrease afterload. And this is a concept that is sometimes difficult to understand that afterload itself is actually really an intrinsic property of the ventricle, not necessarily everything that has to do with what's going on upstream, right? And then the last thing I want to say is that about this topic is that This phenomenon does not tend to occur with the right ventricle because both the right ventricle and the pulmonary vasculature are exposed to that pleural pressure, whereas the peripheral vascular that the heart is checking against is not relying on the thorax.
So what does this mean? What are the clinical implications of this? Well, it's really that large negative swings in pleural pressure can induce pulmonary edema. And this is what we've seen in the literature really countless times. And these effects are often really more marketing patients with reduced left ventricular function. So patients with profound increases in respiratory resistance, such as in status of maticus or upper airway obstruction, these are patients that have to generate much more negative pleural pressures to generate the same amount of flow.
By that same token, even patients who have decreases in respiratory compliance who have to generate large negative floral pressures to generate the same type of volumes. This includes patients with pulmonary edema, pneumonia, heart failure, ARDS, other interstitial lung diseases. These are patients who are going to develop wide fluctuations and large swings of negative floral pressure. So let's put all this together on our guiding curves. And so let's take a case where we have a high airway resistance. Okay. And again, we can have quite dramatic swings of pleural pressure in these cases, whether we have patients with COPD, asthma, post-excavation laryngeal edema, actually during an acute asthmatic attack in a child, peak negative intratheic pressure is going to be around negative 47 meters of water. And so in this case, we lower our pleural pressure here and we slide our curve to the left. And we may say, well, if we're generating such low pleural pressures, won't we just keep maintaining an increase in venous return?
as much and maintain cardiac output. But remember, if we lower pleural pressure enough to bring right intraluminal pressure below atmospheric pressure, we'll reach our point of maximal variance return. And again, this is the point at which abdominal pressure rises above the intraluminal pressure, the IVC, and it'll cause IVC collapse here. And so accordingly, large slings of negative pleural pressure, like we just said, will selectively decrease left ventricular ejection. Okay, so this was our right ventricular curve. Now here's our, so we have a limitation here in blood flow and our left ventricular curve here, as we can see, increases in afterload and dramatic reductions in cardiac output. Okay, now if you take the same patient, someone who's euvalemic or hypodalemic,
Okay, you also have more dramatic reductions in cardiac output as our point of maximum flow is actually decreased. So if we go back to our case with our 76-year-old female, one with COPD and heart failure with reduced ejection fraction, who's presenting a respiratory distress, we can again go back and think a little bit about what impact her breathing pattern has on while she's spontaneous breathing or hemodynamic status. So as we've shown, we're greatly increasing afterload, potentially placed on the left ventricle, which may induce hypotension. And then by increasing afterload, by increasing work on the heart, cardiac ischemia, which is why she's having chest pain and ischemic changes on EKG.
And then this can also further trigger arrhythmias. And when we think about the effects on the degree of our cardiogenic pulmonary edema, well, again, we're decreasing, we're increasing afterload and increasing potentially wedge pressure, precipitating worsening pulmonary edema in this case. And this essentially results in a vicious cycle here, where while we worsen and precipitate worsening pulmonary edema, and then the patient, again, may generate more negative intra-thoracic pressures to generate particular maintain tidal lines, which, again, further increases afterload on the heart, stress on the heart, worsening hypotension, potential cardiac ischemia, and all the hemodynamic issues that we just mentioned. Okay, so really, the clinical implication of this is that preventing or eliminating large swings in pleural pressure can decrease afterload. And as we'll get to in a second, really the application of positive pressure ventilation, including run evasive ventilation, to decrease these large swings of negative pleural pressure and decrease worker breathing may also improve hemodynamics. So let's move on to positive pressure ventilation. And this will be much easier and much more concise now that we've had the brief background. And so as we've gone over positive pressure ventilation, increases lung volume, increases intraplastic pressure. And in general, this is a guiding principle, tends to decrease preload, increase RV afterload.
and decrease left ventricular accolade. So let's think about it. And so we see that pleural pressure here increases. Let's see. Yeah, great. So it increases in pleural pressure. We're going to have a shift of our cardiac output curve to the right. And as we can see, we reach a new operating point here at a higher right atrial pressure. But again, the right atrial pressure that we're recording, whether it's something discussed, may be higher. But our transmural pressures we'll see is actually diminished. We have reduction in cardiac output here. But we see that pleural pressure increases. And again, it increases really indirectly as static airway pressure increases. But one question is, how much does this increase? So in other words, if you have someone on a peep of, let's say, 10 centimeters of water,
does your, does your pleural pressure increase by, by 10 as well? Um, or if they're an inspiratory alveolar pressure, let's say it's 25 centimeters of water. Um, does their pleural pressure increase by that amount? Um, and I think that's important information because in order to estimate how, how far the script shifts, it's obviously important to know, uh, to, to know this as well. Just a slight digression here, but really predicting how airway pressures are transmitted to that pleural space is difficult. Shoppin and Aquin and Marini have provided some ways to estimate this. And so one way to estimate how much of the airway pressure that you're applying at the proximal portion of the trachea is transmitted to the pleural space. Looking at this equation here, another way to say this is looking at the bottom. For our increase in alveolar pressure or a change in airway pressure that we're applying, how much does the pleural pressure change? Well, it's related. It's really a ratio, and it's a ratio of the compliance of your lungs.
over the compliance of your lungs plus chest wall. And so let's clarify this a little bit more. Well, what's a normal lung compliance? Well, a normal lung compliance is about 200 cc per centimeter of water. A normal chest wall compliance we'll call about 200 cc per centimeter of water. Of course, the combined compliance of the respiratory system is 100 cc per centimeter of water, but each and of themselves are about approximately these values. So if you're going to plug that into this equation here, the compliance of the lung over the compliance of the lung plus the chest wall is about one half. And so what this means is that normally about 50% of our alveolar pressure is transmitted to the pleural space.
If we were to put somebody on a PIPA 5, about 2.5 centimeters of water of that will be transmitted to the pleural space. And so this can be incredibly important for interpreting a lot of the data that we obtain in the ICU. And as I just mentioned, it's often not enough to simply know the absolute value you're seeing, but things like CBP, plateau pressure, SWAN numbers, these are all affected by changes in pleural pressure. And what you're truly interested in is actually the transmural pressure. So let's look at this again a little more closely. We have alveolar pressure, RA weight pressure, pleural pressure here.
Let's say we have a spontaneously breathing patient. And so at the end of expiration, there's no flow in a no-flow state. Atmospheric pressure is zero. So our alveolar pressure is zero. And our pleural pressure, with normal pleural pressure, generally at this resting state is around negative three, negative five. But let's say we put them on a ventilator and apply a PEEP of 10. And so now alveolar pressure is 10, let's say, at the end of expiration here.
So how much does our pleural pressure increase in this case? Well, again, when we look at our equation here, if we have normal compliance with the lungs and normal compliance with the chest wall, it should increase by about 50% of what we applied. So by about five. So pleural pressure should go from negative five to about zero. And as we can see, our transmural pressure in this setting is 10. But let's say chest wall compliance were to decrease. So we have somebody who's morbidly obese, they have ascites, something of this nature. Let's say it decreases by a quarter. So it goes down to 50 cc per centimeter of water. Well, now if we plug this into our equation, we can see that this is about 80%.
And now 80% of that alveolar pressure is transmitted to the pleural space. Instead of going from negative five to zero, we can imagine this may go from negative five to three. And so we're recording the same exact pressure here in the airway, but our transmural pressure is lower. So if we take a look at this during a positive pressure breath, we have a shift in our peripheral right. And this is somebody with a normal.
just law and law compliance. But if we took somebody who was obese or had ascites, we may see something like this, where we have a greater increase in pleural pressure for a given airway pressure that's applied and its consequent effects on preload. In addition, we have an increase in lung volume with positive pressure ventilation, just like spontaneous ventilation, which will tend to increase afterload. The one caveat here is that if the increase in lung volume here may actually reduce afterload if we're starting below FRC and we're actually bringing somebody up closer to what their natural resting FRC would be, and we may actually improve afterload in this case on RBN. So what does this signify? So again...
in an ARDS patient who's, who's not obese, um, less airway pressure, uh, may be transmitted to the pleural space. And so we may see less hemodynamic effects due to, um, due to increases in pleural pressure, both effects on venous return and our effects on, on left ventricular afterloads. Okay. Um, now we may see increases in, in transmitting pressure, which may increase RV afterload, but again, that'll be affected by, by the total lung volume. Okay. And so in fact, several studies have shown that in patients, um,
in which the application of PEEP determined effective alveolar recruitment. So if we actually applied PEEP and there was adequate alveolar recruitment, there are subsequent decreases in mean pulmonary artery pressure and while cardiac output is not severely affected. So the predictability of alveolar recruitment really can be very important to predicting the hemodynamic responses to PEEP and the chief mechanism by which increases in PEEP will induce hypotension will be really through increases in afterload by way of overdistension rather than changes in pleural pressure per se. But this is the opposite of patients with obesity or reductions in chest wall compliance. as we'll see in a second. But again, here, also this is just pointing out that increases in our partial pressure of carbon dioxide as well, and when patients are oftentimes permissively hypercapital, we'll increase our PVR.
But if we take an obese patient with ascites, again, in these patients, more airway pressure will be transmitted to the pleural space. And so we'll see more human effects due to that pleural pressure change. And this has both effects on being returned and effects on the afterload. And a decrease in transmissibility pressure may preserve already afterload in this case. But again, this will be dictated by the overall total lung volume that's achieved. So this is all really to say that when evaluating a patient on a ventilator, it's important to consider and really estimate what the relative compliances of the lungs versus the chest wall are in order to predict how changes in airway pressure will impact hemodynamics.
And again, we've just reviewed how changes in flow pressure and lung volume affect cardiac function. But again, we also have to be mindful of the effects on venous return. In a volume replete patient on positive pressure ventilation, again, we typically have a rightward shift in our venous return curve. And again, that's because we have diaphragmatic descent. We have increases in intravenomal pressure. And therefore, if we have increases in intravenomal pressure, we have increases in immune systemic billing pressure. And so when we initiate mechanical ventilation on a volume replete patient, we oftentimes don't have the profound reductions in blood pressure that we see in a hypovolemic patient. Because in a hypovolemic patient, we may have collapse of the great veins and increase in resistance to venous return because of volume replete.
Here's our going deeply patient. And now our curve may actually look something like this in our hypovolemic patient. Now think about what happens when we give induction agents and set it as peri-intubation. So think about the effects on basal motor tone of the venous vasculature. Well, we can have a decrease in basal motor tone with a decrease in compliance.
and stress volume, which results in a decrease in mean systemic filling pressure. And so actually our curve may look something like this. So we can have pretty dramatic reductions in cardiac output in these settings. So these are really the patients at greatest risk of hemodynamic collapse per intubation. Our hypovolemic patients who are being administered agents that reduce vasomotor tonin. And obviously the administration of a fluid bolus or even vasopressures may mitigate these physiologic changes and there's an inappropriate shift here in our venous return curve.
And so even if the patient is wanting her cleat, their maximal venous return will be decreased. So when we think about the application of PEEP, we've been talking more about intermittent positive pressure ventilation. But when we apply PEEP, we do have kind of a static change here in airway pressure and plus interabdominal pressure. In the setting of PEEP, I won't spend too much time on this, but the one thing to keep to account is that our maximum value for our maximum venous return will actually decrease because instead of occurring at atmospheric pressure around zero, we tend to get collapsed at higher pressures where that abdominal pressure, since the abdominal pressure is increased due to PEEP, we tend to have that starling resistor effect at higher pressures. And then lastly, as you can see, shifts of this cardiac output curve to the left or to the right along this venous return curve will really have varying effects on cardiac output, really depending on if the patient is operating on the plateau portion.
or the ascending portion of the curve. So patients operating on the ascending curve should be predicted to have slight falls in their cardiac output as the curve shifts to the right, but those on the plateau portion would expect to have little changes. And so this is some of the physiology that comes into play during the consideration of pulse pressure variation, short volume changes, and IVC collapse during cyclic ventilation. So let's look at positive pressure ventilation in the left ventricle and in contrast to spontaneous ventilation. positive pressure ventilation tends to reduce left ventricular afterload, again, by decreasing the peak systolic transmural pressure required to eject blood out of the thorax. And while this effect is minimal normal health, it's still there. This can contribute significantly in patients with heart failure. And this, again, has been borne out countless times in the literature with several studies that indicate that cardiac output goes up in heart failure patients when you apply PEEP. And in fact, this is why, as we all know, the initial therapy for cardiogenic pulmonary atema is often CPAP, and not just from a respiratory perspective, but really to relieve the hemodynamic consequences. But here, the concept here is...
that it's really only, or most effective if it's abolishing swings in your intrathoracic pressure. Okay, so if the P-pass can be high enough to be able to abolish those intrathoracic pressure, and then you usually can tolerate these levels of P. So if you have a decompensated heart failure patient and you're intubating them, starting at a PEEP of 10 or even a little bit higher is a reasonable strategy, assuming that your airway pressures are otherwise not concerning. And you can always come back down if they're oxygenating well, but it likely won't hurt them and it could potentially help at the start. Okay. So I'm going to finish with weaning and extubation failure. And I know we're familiar with a lot of these concepts, but again, when we think about the transition from positive pressure ventilation to spontaneous breathing, again, this is characterized by really an increase in intrathoracic blood volume, an increase in left ventricular afterload. These patients are also going to increase work of breathing and oxygen consumption. So these are patients who are at high risk of, again, developing pulmonary edema, post-intubation, hypotension, and myocardial ischemia. Okay.
And in fact, you know, many patients actually, we oftentimes don't think about this, but probably fail weaning for cardiovascular reasons rather than primary pulmonary reasons, even in the absence of hemodynamic instability. But, you know, even somebody who's on vasopressors, and this is why we always stress caution when weaning somebody who's on vasopressor sports. And then, you know, you'll hear Michael Pinsky say this, I tend to agree, but you never wean somebody who's hemodynamically unstable from mechanical inhalation because you'll kill them. But again, failure to wean often reflects cardiovascular insufficiency here. And it's also important to keep in mind the effects on the RV as well. As I mentioned earlier, the differences in pleural pressure between positive pressure ventilation and spontaneous breathing, the changes in intral thoracic pressure won't have much of an effect on RV afterload. But again, think about the volumes that the patient's taking. So again, increases in lung volumes and tidal volumes of somebody after they're excavated on a spontaneous breathing trial will increase RV afterload. So we have to think about the effects on that as well. And so obviously the key here is really to be mindful and think about.
preventing volume overload during weaning and then when we exudate. So let's look at a couple examples of this from the literature. This is an example of some of the physiology I just described. And this is data from Lemaire back in the late 1990s. And this is data for patients with COPD who are undergoing spontaneous breathing trials. And they demonstrated increases in pulmonary capillary wedge pressure during failed spontaneous breathing trial events. And so as we can see here, this demonstrates a transition from positive pressure ventilation to spontaneous breathing. And again, these patients are at risk of wild swings in pleural pressure, negative pleural pressure, because they have high resistance.
And as you can see here, here's esophageal pressure. And then there's two y-axis here, but esophageal pressure here, which is slightly positive as the patient's on positive pressure ventilation. And then we have pulmonary capillary wedge pressure here. And as we transition from positive pressure ventilation to spontaneous ventilation here, we can see that our esophageal pressure, now we have our pretty noticeable swings in our esophageal pressure. Again, esophageal pressure is a surrogate here for pleural pressure.
So we have these wild swings here. And as we can see, because of the effects of this on the left ventricle, pulmonary capillary wedge pressure is rising. And it's not only rising, but it's going through the roof here. So not subtle. The majority of these patients were going to be diurese and successfully mean days later. But here's kind of an insight into some of the physiology that may be occurring behind the scenes. And then similarly, this is a study by Gibran.
back in the late 90s as well. And what they're looking at, they had pulmonary artery catheters, as long as catheters in patients and monitored mixed venous oxygen saturations in these patients. And so with declines in venous oxygen saturations as a marker again for declining cardiac output, we can see two groups of patients. And can you guess who was weaned successfully and who failed their spontaneous breeding trials? Well, as you can guess, these are the patients who were weaned successfully. And the patients who had weaning failure had substantial declines in some mixed venous oxygen saturations.
as a result of reductions in cardiac output from the effects of spontaneous inhalation on their hemodynamic status. So just to kind of review some key points here. So the lung volume effects of positive pressure ventilation and spontaneous ventilation, these are similar, and they both tend to increase over the afterload. But PEEP can have varying effects depending on its impact on lung volume in relation to functional residual capacity, depending on whether you're actually recruiting lung volume or it's tending to over-descent. But the key differences in effects of pleural pressure and positive pressure ventilation can have decreased in left ventricular afterload and preload. And with spontaneous ventilation, we can have increases in left ventricular afterload and preload.
Large swings and negative pleural pressure can precipitate pulmonary edema, hypotension, and increased work of breathing, and increased oxygen consumption, which can, again, induce myocardial ischemia. And so keep these points in mind when evaluating the patient in respiratory distress, something like COPD, asthma, again, ILD, anything that's going to result in these large swings and negative pleural pressures. And positive pressure ventilation can help mitigate these effects. And knowing the underlying cardiac function of these patients may be very helpful in predicting these as well. Differences in relative compliance of the chest wall versus the lung will affect changes in pleural pressure, and that can have an impact on management of patients with ARDS versus obesity. Potential impacts on the interpretation of plateau pressures, as we just saw. You can have the same exact reading between two different patients, but their transmural pressures may be different because more or less of that pressure will be transmitted to the pleural space. And then keep in mind the potential impacts of this on chemodynamics. And then lastly, the transition from positive pressure inhalation to spontaneous inhalation upon excavation, again, represents really a cataclysmic shift in a patient's physiological state.
So it's important to consider whenever we're weaning patients, consider the volume status of the patient, their underlying cardiac function, their current hemodynamic status, their potential to develop hyperinflation, which is something I didn't talk about. But again, think about the impacts of dynamic hyperinflation as well on right ventricular afterload, the potential for laryngeal edema in these patients and the impact that that increase in resistance will have on cardiac function. And then this may guide methods of spontaneous screening trials, whether or not you want to use a T-piece. pressure support, or CPAP, as we just saw, the application of positive pressure may really mitigate those effects, those hemodynamic effects that we're seeing, which may even be revealed with the use of a TPC. And with that, I will end there. Thank you. I'm happy to answer any questions.