Skip to content
Kim Williams in Conversation episode artwork

Mar 14, 2024 30 min

Kim Williams in Conversation

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week Monica Attard talks with Kim Williams about objectivity in journalism and his new role at the ABC. Produced by Anthony Dockrill

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Kim Williams in Conversation

0:00 30:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on the Gadigal Lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Mike Antone. This week we're jumping into a deep and at times murky pond of discontent and concern, objectivity and journalism.

Is it still important for the practice of journalism? If so, how can it be reconciled with a push for our newsrooms to become more effective of who we are as Australians? Or is that not a question that should be asked because it's not a problem? And when it comes to difficult stories like the Hummus Israel War should impartiality give way to humanitarian concerns?

The man will soon be taking the reins of power at the ABC where many of these questions have been aired in the wake of the internal and external complaints about the broadcaster's coverage of the war and following the removal of their of a feeling radio host for using her social media to express a view about the war is Kim Williams. Kim Williams is a familiar name to those in the media business. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese says Williams is a perfect fit to chair the ABC board. Williams has previously had leadership positions at the Sydney Opera House Trust, the Australian Film Commission, Music Viva Australia as well as a stint as an executive at the ABC and at News Corp.

So what's he waiting into at the ABC? This interview was one that I did for another podcast called Double Take produced by the Centre I Work at, the Centre for Media Transition. So Kim Williams, welcome to Double Take and thank you very much for joining us. First up, it's not long now until you rejoin the ABC.

Looking back at your previous stint there and looking at the organisation you're about to enter, what strikes you as having changed? Well, these are views from the outside of course, Monica. They're not yet properly informed from internal briefings and internal close observation. But clearly the organisation is smaller in the number of working professionals inside the institution.

It has expanded in terms of its variety of services. It has moved very substantially into a digital delivery modality, although I think it has much work to do there. And it is an organisation which is experiencing the dilemma that all broadcasting organisations are experiencing around the world, which is declining audiences. So it's an interesting kettle of personal.

It's a fascinating bucket of problems actually. Is that something that is daunting at this point or is it something that, do you think that the solutions to all of those individual issues that you've just raised come together to form a kind of solution that is applicable and in the best interests of the audience? Look, I don't think anyone has a magic crystal ball in relation to the trends in modern media. It's an era of staggering behaviour all change, technology change and societal change.

So to say that one has a handle on the solutions confidently, I think it's probably letting optimism get ahead of reality. It's a tough time. I do think it's the continuing challenge and will always be the continuing challenge of the ABC is to ensure that it is an institution that is genuinely relevant in a contemporary sense and that it is firmly rooted in the present and the future and not harking back to previous grand times with the ABC because so much changes occurred that one simply must respond to that and must respond in ways that are relevant to the way in which audiences are moving. So what does relevance look like then, Kim?

Well, the first thing that I think relevance looks like is in dealing with this complex issue of impartiality in journalism. And I think one needs to reflect on why we have institutions, what governs institutions and what makes those institutions worthy of public respect and affection. And in looking at the ABC, the bedrock of the ABC, at least journalistically, must always be an unerring commitment to independence, to editorial integrity, and to the extent possible in human affairs in partiality. If the ABC does not stand for such values, which are after all prescribed in the ABC Act, but if it does not stand for such values, I think it's in danger of people saying, well, why bother?

We must have an institution in which we can repose our trust. Now, that's a very significant burden in the modern era. And I know there are many views about contemporary relevance in journalism, but in working for an institution which is a creation and creature of and respondent to the national parliament, which has a defined charter and has defined rules of engagement and obligations under that charter. I think the ABC has to repose confidence and real commitment to those values.

I'm on many tentacles of this objectivity issue seems to be the issue of what is truth. I mean, how do we balance what I think of a particular issue with what you think of a particular issue? We thought social media would balance this all out by giving people a platform, but it's kind of served to give objectivity really a bad name and reinforce the notion that what I think is the truth. Is that a problem?

Do you think that has crept into newsrooms to the extent where many journalists, particularly young ones, don't really understand what impartiality is? Well, then I think we need to improve the process of mentoring and of active sense and developing an active sense of community between journalists in a body like the ABC. It is simply not available to individuals to say what I think and what my view is triumphant over all others. That's not available for debate.

It may be available in other domains that don't have the kinds of principles and long-standing obligations that the ABC has, but it cannot be the way at a place like the ABC. It's simply not available for even for consideration. Yeah, it is why I understand there are varieties of you about what constitutes truth, but in the big picture sense of what constitutes truth, facts matter and facts are the bedrock of notions of journalistic truth. In my view, and I think my view is supported by history.

Yet, while the sensitivities that we've seen arise, particularly in the last few months, that we've been witnessing a horrific war between Hamas and Israel, has been the question of how journalists of diverse background feel and how they report on issues, particularly concerning their own communities. Now, of course, I'm sure you would agree it would be ridiculous to assert that they can't be objective, but Jonathan Holmes, who the ex-media watch host, has raised this issue of the tension between diversity and objectivity. Can I begin by asking you, is there an issue there in your mind? Is there a problem there?

Look, I think there's an inherent tension when people are particularly close to a matter of major moment that has heightened polarities in social settings that's objectivity is seriously challenged and perspective is seriously challenged. In my view, in any journalistic organization, that's where editors come into their own and play the most vital part in trying to navigate through that difficult territory in ensuring that there is a core notion of what can be relied on as to the extent possible in human affairs, always with that qualification. Here is the truth, as we understand it to be today. But then, of course, they're hounded by social media.

I think there's a good kind of social media moniker in any of these environments is to invite dancing with the devil. I think that it is absolutely clear that social media has been a force for liberating many dark forces in relation to confusing fact and opinion and in endeavoring to manipulate public emotion and public responsiveness to issues of serious consequence to society. And I have to say to you that I have a deep and abiding and growing skepticism about the value of social media. I'm sure you're not aligned there.

I think many people have that, but it's there and it's let's assume that it's not going to disappear. Is your advice to senior editorial staff at the ABC going to be ignored? In many instances, I think I imagine I like many others and I've been involved in the media for from the origins of social media. I've never tweeted.

I have never had a public Facebook account. I have a private Facebook account, mainly for reasons of family. I read Twitter, or sorry, X, or I read X regularly up until the ridiculously branding and the absolute lack of any kind of editorial responsibility in the service. But I never responded.

I was aware of what was happening as part of a necessary information feed. And similarly, with other social media platforms, what some people now accumulate, he referred to as the socials. But I think it is one of many things to observe. I think it is not something in which to repose any kind of trust other than as a core reflection of extremities in society.

Sure. But I suppose for journalists who become victims of social media parlance, which happens regularly, it would be very difficult to adopt that position, particularly if in circumstances, for example, where they're reporting on a contentious issue, and they are using traditional methodologies of performing public interest journalism, and it's not delivering to the public what a particular public wants to have delivered to it. That's where the tension seems to arise. Well, I have grave difficulty with journalists being a respondent to what the public wants to hear.

I don't think the public gets to dictate what the recital of factual information in relation to human affairs composes and comprises. I don't think that is a balanced or fair view of journalism at all. I mean, going right back in journalism to the writings of people like Walter Libman, and that famous piece that he wrote on news and liberty in the Atlantic in 1919, and then subsequently wrote a small volume about these very issues in 1920. The recognition is there that objectivity is always an aspirational objective, because no one ever knows enough.

No one ever is sufficiently centered in a wide enough body of information to give you a perfect rendition of what is happening. But to actually pollute that with the view that in many instances, people are profound prejudice who are contributing to public conversation on these things should in some way impact the way in which a journalist is going about their professional duty is a very long bar in my view. So are you saying there that when journalists, ABC journalists, do come under attack, for example, as they do very regularly in the pages of news court papers, ignore it, move away, don't read it, don't look at it. No, no, no, no, no, no, practically that is my view.

I think few people have the capacity to read something and send it to the Deservant-Dustbin. They tend to be deeply affected by it. Now, that may be to varying degrees, but very few people are able to actually process that information and be unmoved by it. Probably some of the few people in society who have a well-developed capacity in that regard are politicians, because they receive so much of it, and that they are able to stand back and keep going.

And I have known in an active life many met hundreds of politicians, and some of them really magnificently disciplined creatures who can look beyond that kind of chaotic expression of public views. I just want to take you back to the issue of impartiality. And I want to get to your take on that petition that was signed by some 300 media workers, some of them from the ABC, of course, last year, around the coverage of the Fama's Israel War, calling for a new journalism, calling for journalism to be conducted in a different way, discarding the old mechanisms of journalism and ushering in a new way of doing journalism, which essentially privileges different voices. What did you make of that petition?

Well, I think in any petition like that, at best, you note that it's a reflection of certain individuals and their views of the challenge of the complexity of affairs, particularly in a number of diverse settings internationally. But I am not in any way ashamed to champion a view that is actually in favor of aspiration to objectivity, because I think objectivity truly is at the core of responsible journalism, at least the aspiration to it, that maintaining a standard towards that aspiration. I can't assure that the public will repose their trust in you, but it'll go a heck of a long further than any other approach. But would you grant that there's always been attention in journalism between producing objectivity journalism on the one hand, and this notion that journalism is there to change the world, make the world a better place?

Look, journalism has a long history of campaigning. But that campaigning journalism in the hands of private media is seen through the entire history of journalism. In fact, the early history of journalism was avowedly about aiming to convert the public to a different point of view or a point of view that was aligned with that at the proprietor of the publication. That is not the case with the ABC.

And if the ABC is to sustain and hold a place of embedded trust with the Australian community, if it is going to be seen as a vital aspect of Australian democracy that provides, for want of a better term, a safe space for accessing information, for understanding the polarities in different situations, for understanding the drivers of individual events in news and current affairs, it must have an aspiration to objectivity. Does that mean it'll get it right all the time? Of course not. It's all done by human beings.

Just again, but given the issues that we've seen emerge, particularly from and around diverse members of staff who say they want it done differently, they want different voices privileged, they want different angles to be adopted as the norm as the solution if you like to certain problems. Do you think that the old traditional ways of doing public interest journalism offer protections against the ABC term wasn't falling into a trap of being accused of a lack of objectivity? I think the rigor of public interest journalism in its foundations and in the course of the way in which it has evolved over recent decades must always repose in an aspiration to impartiality. You know, if you don't want to reflect a view that inspires to impartiality, don't work at the ABC.

I mean, I really think it's a very serious issue, which is a publicly funded organization. It is a publicly accountable organization. It is a respondent to legislation of the national parliament, and it must always aspire to be as fair-minded in its work as it possibly can be. Does that mean it has always been fair-minded?

Certainly not. There are times in the past when it gave pretty clearly a primarily male and low Celtic view of the world and with all of the educational background and social settings and economic settings that implies. It needs to ensure that there is a very conscious movement to better reflect the panoply of Australian society, and that's journalistic workforce. I absolutely agree with that.

But that doesn't give people a leave pass to abandon the aspiration to impartiality. That's just not available for discussion. But for a start, it's not available for discussion because the access is not available for discussion. Yes, the protection is due journalism, the way traditional journalism, public interest journalism has always been performed.

Correct. I think we see that in many modern journalistic environments that are in many ways much more volatile than our own. If you were to read Marty Barron's new book on his eight years as the editor of the Washington Post leading up to and right through the Trump administration and the acquisition of the Washington Post by Jeff Bezos, he deals with these issues at great, great, caring length. It's a big book, and he finished it a couple of weeks ago.

It's a good 400-page read. But it offers, I think, a very good example of an exceptional editor doing the hard yards in trying to have a balanced view of sustaining an organ that represents journalism that you can truly trust. You will, regardless, have staff of divers background say that approach makes them feel unsafe. And I'm just wondering.

I would like someone to actually explain to me properly what that means. Having different points of view, which may involve actually rejecting much of established process and practice in the professional craft of journalism, doesn't in and of itself validate what is being said. A lot of these matters, I think, are best resolved by colleagues working together, working together, learning together, reading together, and continuing to aim to reflect the best quality of practice in journalism that we can arrive at. It's not a he said that she said kind of environment.

It's one where there needs to be a mutual commitment to doing the hard yards to actually earn and sustain public trust. One of the other issues causing extreme discontent at the moment, Kim, within the organization is, of course, the issue of lobby groups, particularly in relation to the story of Hamas Israel, having access to the board and more over to the chair. Do you think that the board should be open to taking calls from unhappy lobby groups? I don't think the board members individually should not be open to receiving such representations.

I think the ABC has well established lines of communication for such representations, certainly included in those lines of representation, the managing director and the chair. But the ombudsman inside the ABC has been created for this very reason. And I think that it is always important that in receipt of any representation from one or opposing points of view, that one has an extremely sober, serious impartiality in receiving the information, and that one should not respond ever in haste to such representation, because that's exactly what any proponent of a single minded point of view that is dissatisfied with what is happening once. So assuming then, if I'm understanding you correctly, it'll always be the case that unhappy lobby groups at first instance, direct their unhappiness towards out of the chair or a member of the board.

But are you saying then that you look at that complaint and if there is something there, then what gets referred to the ombudsman? Well, the ABC does now have an instituted practice for processing such representation. And I'm saying all of this without being in the chair, without having had the benefit of discussion with board colleagues, without having discussed this specific issue with the managing director and not having met the ombudsman. But as I understand it and perceive it externally and from reading a very large number of ABC publicly available documents, there are established processes, which process this information.

One would hope always in an objective frame of mind. I'm not in any way someone who is discouraging of criticism or representation, but representation and responsiveness to the content of that representation are clearly very different things. You have to in the first instance satisfy yourself as to whether the complaint is valid, if the complaint has substance and represents something rather than just of an ephemeral momentary nature, it really is something of a serious source of concern and the quality of journalism. And that requires considerable effort.

So once you establish that it's not a vexatious issue that's being brought to you, do then advise your MD to take a look at it and if necessary, but for you? I mean, I think that always there has to be a balanced approach with the managing director. The managing director is described as the editor in chief. So ultimately the managing director in that matter will form over you and one would hope that the chair and managing director have a sufficiently good working relationship that they can discuss it as mature informed professionals.

Okay, so Kim, what are you looking forward to? What I'm looking forward to is renewing a focus of the ABC on external issues from the ABC, rather than the kind of addictive focus that so often happens in the ABC, of the ABC talking about itself to itself within itself. I think that is not healthy. And I think it enables small cohorts to become very to have an exaggerated influence over the process of decision making.

I think it's tremendously important that the ABC, again, having regard to the charter, understands that it is responsible to the diversity of Australia as a nation and the diversity of the communities in Australia. And that it produced that in reflecting contemporary relevance, that it is really very enamored of that obligation because it is fundamental to it being an institution that matters to Australians. Now, it's foolhardy to say that the ABC matters to Australians today in the same way that it did 30 or 40 years ago or the way that it did 50, 60 years ago, there have been steady changes in that regard because so many members of our community rarely engage with services delivered by the ABC. So the challenge is to actually invigorate that relationship and to ensure that there are much stronger ramparts to the relationship between the ABC and the diverse audiences of the Australian community.

Are you excited about the deep pivot to digital that the ABC appears to be making at the moment? I'm excited about the ABC always being prominent in any major technology or general content direction that is part of the inevitable process of change that is taking place with Australian consumers. The ABC has not pivoted to digital as effectively as many other organizations. I certainly think it's pivoted in a much more direct and better version than most of its commercial counterparts in Australian domestic television, not necessarily as well in audio services.

But there's a lot of work to be done by giving a sense of ease of access to material and by clear and legible presentation of that material so as to facilitate a really delightful experience for Australians in finding programming that meets their needs. It's a pretty clunky process currently. Well, the best of luck to you, Kim. It's a very exciting period ahead and we wish you all that we wish you the best of luck.

And thanks for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of QSCR and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support.

Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so that you can hear us talk about media politics and of course everything in between. We're back next week with more. In the meantime, you can stay in touch with this on Twitter and handle their ease for the state that you and we're also on threads. I'm Monica Aton.

Thank you for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 30 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on March 14, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.