Krishnamurti: The Machine Isn’t the Danger
from Mr Murugan and Ms Fong Hosted by Mr Murugan and Ms Fong
When a machine can think, what is left of us? An Indian philosopher asked that question decades beforeanyone had a chatbot, and his answer was not about the machines. It was aboutus. "The machine is not destroying us. We are destroying ourselves." IN THIS EPISODE • Jiddu Krishnamurti, and the day in 1929 he dissolvedthe organisation built around him • Why he thought human thinking is also mechanical —programmed by culture, religion and upbringing, running the same reactions onrepeat • "Unless that machine of the mind stops — not thecomputer — we are going to destroy ourselves" • A Chinese story two thousand years older that lands inthe same place • One practice: catch a thought you have had a hundredtimes, and don't answer it THE MAN In 1929, at Ommen in Holland, Krishnamurti stood up in frontof thousands of followers and dissolved the Order of the Star — theorganisation founded on the belief that he was a coming World Teacher. He saidtruth is a pathless land, and that no organisation should lead people along apath toward it. He spent the following fifty years refusing to be anyone'sauthority, which is a strange career for someone most people encounter as aguru. WHAT HE ACTUALLY SAID ABOUT COMPUTERS The quotes in this episode come from dialogues recorded inthe 1980s, one of them with Asit Chandmal, who worked in computing. Krishnamurti's position was not that technology is the enemy.It was that we had already become mechanical, and that the computer merely madethe resemblance obvious. His argument runs: knowledge created the machine, and we liveon knowledge. The computer is programmed by humans. Human thought is programmedtoo — by culture, by religion, by upbringing. He did not see much difference between the two. So thewarning was never about the chip. It was about the habit. THE OTHER STORY The Chinese tale is from the Zhuangzi, roughly the fourth tothird century BCE. A student finds an old gardener hauling water jar by jarfrom a well and offers him a well-sweep — a simple lever that would saveenormous labour. The old man refuses, saying that clever tools lead to cleverdealings, and clever dealings to a cunning heart. The phrase associated with it is 机心 — the machine heart. He was not afraid of the lever. He wasafraid of what using it would do to him. Two thinkers, two thousand yearsapart, one worry. Not that the machine will think. That we will start to thinklike one. ABOUT THIS CHANNEL Mr Murugan & Ms Fong. Two voices. One conversation.Wisdom, reflection and connection — in a few minutes a week. Also available asa podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music and most other podcastplatforms. New episode every week. Subscribe so you never miss one. Andshare this with someone who has asked a chatbot what to think this week. Contact: [email protected] This episode is for educational and reflective purposes only.It is a philosophical reflection and does not constitute professional advice. #Krishnamurti #Philosophy #AI #MrMuruganAndMissFong#WisdomReflectionConnection #Nvidia #JensenHuang #ThinkingMachines #Mindfulness#IndianPhilosophy #Zhuangzi #Consciousness #Attention #SelfInquiry #Technology
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.