Larry Hall Pt. 4: Tricia Reitler episode artwork

EPISODE · Sep 1, 2025 · 9 MIN

Larry Hall Pt. 4: Tricia Reitler

from Extinguished · host McClam/Humphrey

In this episode of Extinguished, hosts LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam delve into the disappearance of Tricia Reitler, a 19-year-old student who vanished in 1993, and explore the potential connection to Larry Hall, a convicted kidnapper suspected of multiple murders. They dissect Hall’s confessions, contradictions, and the lingering impact on the victims’ families. This episode urges listeners to come forward with any information that could help solve these cold cases.TIMELINE00:00 - Trigger warning and content advisory.00:09 - Introduction to the theme of overlooked victims.00:45 - Welcome to Extinguished and introduction to Tricia Reitler’s case.01:25 - Details of Tricia Reitler’s disappearance and the discovery of evidence.01:55 - The emergence of Larry Hall as a potential suspect.02:21 - Investigation details and challenges faced by law enforcement.03:03 - The impact of Trisha’s disappearance on her family.03:48 - Larry Hall’s background, crimes, and confessions.04:36 - Chris Martin’s investigation and correspondence with Larry Hall.05:21 - Larry Hall’s confessions to other disappearances, including Lori Depies and Paulette Webster.06:24 - Possible connection to the Springfield 3.06:56 - Challenges in verifying Hall’s confessions and the impact on victims’ families.07:59 - Call to action for listeners to provide information.08:40 - Closing remarks and encouragement to support the search for the missing.Key Takeaways:Understand the complexities of cold cases and the challenges in bringing closure to families.Examine the psychological profile of Larry Hall and his manipulative confession patterns.Recognize the importance of continued investigation and public awareness in unsolved disappearances.Consider the potential connections between different missing persons cases and patterns of criminal behavior.Learn about the resources available for reporting information and supporting families of missing persons.

In this episode of Extinguished, hosts LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam delve into the disappearance of Tricia Reitler, a 19-year-old student who vanished in 1993, and explore the potential connection to Larry Hall, a convicted kidnapper suspected of multiple murders. They dissect Hall’s confessions, contradictions, and the lingering impact on the victims’ families. This episode urges listeners to come forward with any information that could help solve these cold cases.TIMELINE00:00 - Trigger warning and content advisory.00:09 - Introduction to the theme of overlooked victims.00:45 - Welcome to Extinguished and introduction to Tricia Reitler’s case.01:25 - Details of Tricia Reitler’s disappearance and the discovery of evidence.01:55 - The emergence of Larry Hall as a potential suspect.02:21 - Investigation details and challenges faced by law enforcement.03:03 - The impact of Trisha’s disappearance on her family.03:48 - Larry Hall’s background, crimes, and confessions.04:36 - Chris Martin’s investigation and correspondence with Larry Hall.05:21 - Larry Hall’s confessions to other disappearances, including Lori Depies and Paulette Webster.06:24 - Possible connection to the Springfield 3.06:56 - Challenges in verifying Hall’s confessions and the impact on victims’ families.07:59 - Call to action for listeners to provide information.08:40 - Closing remarks and encouragement to support the search for the missing.Key Takeaways:Understand the complexities of cold cases and the challenges in bringing closure to families.Examine the psychological profile of Larry Hall and his manipulative confession patterns.Recognize the importance of continued investigation and public awareness in unsolved disappearances.Consider the potential connections between different missing persons cases and patterns of criminal behavior.Learn about the resources available for reporting information and supporting families of missing persons.

NOW PLAYING

Larry Hall Pt. 4: Tricia Reitler

0:00 9:52

No transcript for this episode yet

We transcribe on demand. Request one and we'll notify you when it's ready — usually under 10 minutes.

Chapters 15-16

Jun 16, 2026 ·33m

Chapters 17-18

Jun 16, 2026 ·29m

Chapters 19-20

Jun 16, 2026 ·28m

Chapters 21-22

Jun 16, 2026 ·26m

Chapters 23-24

Jun 16, 2026 ·26m

Chapters 25-26

Jun 16, 2026 ·27m

Finding Home Healing Sadie I believe you were born with a light that guides you to your higher self and most passionate life. But for many of us, it's been extinguished or lost.My mission with this podcast is to help you find your way back home to that light so that you can love deeper, live in your power, and truly thrive. For those lost or lonely souls, welcome home.  Being Mindful with the Spiritual Litigator Cheyne Scott - Spiritual Litigator This podcast is for high achieving attorneys whose passion for the practice of law may have been extinguished by years of stress, self doubt and anxiety. Cheyne Scott gives advice from the inside of the profession and can relate to other attorneys who experience the pressures of the billable hour, the hierarchy of a mid-sized law firm and the day to day pressures of circumstances out of our control, such as the actions and attitudes of adversaries, clients, supervisors and judges. Mindfulness is not just about being zen and sitting meditating on a mountain or on the beach. It is about accepting, observing and noticing what is going on in the moment without judgment. Mindfulness is also about noticing the ways that make you the most effective lawyer; noticing what is and what is not in your control; and knowing when it is time to let go. The goal of this podcast is to discuss how mindfulness can lead to increased satisfaction, fulfilment and success not only in the practice of law LaDonna Humphrey LaDonna Humphrey LaDonna Humphrey is an investigative journalist, award-winning author, public speaker, and podcaster dedicated to uncovering the truth and advocating for crime victims. She has written The Girl I Never Knew, Strangled, and Connected by Fate, and directed the award-winning documentary Uneven Ground: The Melissa Witt Story. LaDonna co-hosts Deep Dark Secrets and Extinguished podcasts and speaks nationally on cold cases, missing persons, and justice reform. Her work brings powerful voices and attention to the unheard and unresolved. Extinguished Gentlemen Clint Licinngd Talking about video games, anime, movies and opnion on such peices

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of Extinguished?

This episode is 9 minutes long.

When was this Extinguished episode published?

This episode was published on September 1, 2025.

What is this episode about?

In this episode of Extinguished, hosts LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam delve into the disappearance of Tricia Reitler, a 19-year-old student who vanished in 1993, and explore the potential connection to Larry Hall, a convicted kidnapper suspected...

Can I download this Extinguished episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.
URL copied to clipboard!