Skip to content
Larry Stone joins Softy and Dick episode artwork

Sep 17, 2025 20 min

Larry Stone joins Softy and Dick

from Softy & Dick Interviews

Larry Stone joins the show to talk about the special Cal Raleigh season, is he the AL MVP?

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Larry Stone joins Softy and Dick

0:00 20:46
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The Hard Rock, Back Casino app is here, Ontario. It's safe, secure, and crystal clear, with past fails and 24-7 local support. You can play over 3,000 games right here, including Hard Rock, Back Casino exclusives. The Hard Rock, Back Casino app is here, Ontario.

Roll with us. Must be 19 years of age or order to play. Ontario won't be pleased responsibly. Concerned about your gambling or that of someone close to you?

Visit thenexonterio.ca The entire draft room groans because you just took the guy they wanted. There's no better feeling than crushing your fantasy football league. I'm J.J. Zacharyson, host of the award-winning late round podcast.

Before your draft, our players to target and players to avoid episodes tell you exactly who to circle and who to cross off. Listen to the late round fantasy football podcast and the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. On Big Lives we take a single cultural icon... People like Jane Fonda, George Michael, Little Richard.

And we pull apart the story behind the image, discovering forgotten interviews that change exactly how we see these giants of our culture. We're here for the messy, the brilliant, the human version of our heroes. I'm Emmanuel Jocee, and this is Big Lives. Listen to Big Lives on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.

Did you think you were the only one like no matter what you did, it was never good enough for your mother? I'm Jennifer Arnees, and this is the Black Mother One Podcast, where we unpack and heal from the very first relationship that shaped us. We rush to accommodate other people when we have been hurt, and I've heard it has not been healed. Listen to the Black Mother One Podcasts from the Black Effect podcast network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, and wherever you get your podcasts.

I am talking to a felon right now with face tattoos, and I cannot decide if I like him or not. That was a caller from my podcast, Therapy Gecko, where I speak with anonymous callers about their problems, relationships, and anything else in the depths of their mind. It all happens on my show, Therapy Gecko. So if you're trying to get out of your own head and into someone else's, this is the podcast for you.

Listen to Therapy Gecko on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. It's time for our weekly conversation with legendary sports writer Larry Stone, brought to you by the Ram Restaurant & Brewery. Bigger, better, and fresher since 1971. With eight Pugetown locations from Marysville to Lacey and everywhere in between, there's a Ram there you.

Now it's softy and dick. Here's Larry Stone. Alright, it's amazing how this works, man. This guy, I think, just does this on purpose.

He waits to come on the air until there's big things to talk about. And he's done it yet again, because big thanks to the Ram, by the way, for providing the necessary funds to get this guy to join us every Tuesday at 6 p.m. Fresh off watching Cal Riley tie a Mariner team record with 56 bombs. It's our friend Larry Stone.

How are you, pal? Pretty good. How I planned that, isn't it? That's incredible talent, man.

I don't know how you do it, man. But if you could teach me that'd be great. So in 1997, Griffey hits 56 in the second to last game. In 98, he hits 56 in the third to last game, and now Cal Riley's got 56 with 11 games left to go.

How impressed are you by what this man just did? I mean, whatever the adjective is for the most impressed you could be, that's what it is. To me, this game is the quintessential Cal Riley. He gets a foul ball in the throat.

And then comes up and hits the home run. Hits one from both sides of the plate. Just incredible. Just showcasing everything he's done this season, ringing double to boot.

Now with 56, I think 60 becomes into play. Now you've been in a relative home run drought, but he doesn't in bunches and he's on one of those runs again. It appears. So I don't think you've got the question by any means.

And that's really going to make the MVP rate very, very interesting. Larry, I'm just trying to think about the most improbable sports seasons in Seattle history. And we've gotten some team one like Lenny Wilkins taking over a losing team and taking the finals that year. I mean, that was obviously maybe at the top of the list for a team.

But Softy mentioned a 4-8 team being taken over by Kaitlyn de Boer and going to the National Championship game two years later. But as far as an individual accomplishment, have we ever seen anything like this as far as just something that there is no way you could predict a guy that had a career high of 30 home runs, basically doubling it in one year. Yeah, I agree, Dick. I think, I mean, it's not like he came out of nowhere.

He was establishing himself as one of the best catchers in baseball. I think before the season started, we talked about how good he was in relative to all the catchers in MLB. But to have this kind of historic season where he is the biggest thing in baseball, I think, you know, at least outside of Judge and Otani who everybody knew about, Alex just burst onto the scene and become a superstar. And you said he's throwing a homerun derby.

Yeah, no one in the world could have predicted that he was going to be pushing 60 home runs. Yeah, well, Dick talks about the most improbable seasons. I don't know, man. I remember where we were the night the Mariners signed Hori Palanco.

I never would have saw 824 OPs coming back. That's pretty damn surprising too. But I mean, make the case for the MVP, right? I mean, we just talked about this off the year, excuse me, on the year last segment.

And I think we said, you said a couple of weeks ago, you thought he was going to win the MVP. Make the case if you still had the MVP vote. Make it for Cal Riley right now. Yeah, I mean, this is going to be one of the most interesting votes I can remember.

I was just looking at judges stats. He's going into today and this has changed with what Cal has done. But he had his judges slugging with exactly 100 points higher than Cal. It was 577 to 677.

His OPS is almost 200 points higher. His batting average is almost 100 points higher. So there's a compelling case to be made for Judge for no question about it. But I think you have to factor in the position he plays, particularly with Judge doing a lot of the aging after his injury, what just happened there was the foul ball off his throat and then hitting two homers after that.

It just shows the beating that he takes and not just a catcher. He's the platinum club winning catcher. He's one of the best defensive catchers in baseball. Even his metrics aren't quite as high this year still.

Very, very good. And then you throw in a historic home run season. If you can reach 60, I think it's going to be very hard not to vote for Cal. Yeah, I'm with you.

It's just I'm looking at these betting odds and it just keeps getting bigger and bigger for Aaron Judge as we go along. And maybe that's just simply the fact that he's got a 1225 OPS in the month of September. I mean, we're so Cal centric Larry. And we were so proud of the fact that he's got a 1225 OPS in the month of September.

I mean, we're so Cal centric Larry. And we are marveling at what Cal is doing. But Aaron judges like outperforming him. I mean, you really you just mentioned that he's outperforming Cal Raleigh, right?

Yeah, well, Cal had one ninety four in June and 173 in August. So, you know, I think the people in the anti-Cal camp will look at that and say, you know, for two whole months, he was under 200. You know, he's back close to 300 in September to judge. He's three forty one in September with an OPS like he said over 1200.

So judge judges. Judge is like out performing him. I mean, you really, you just mentioned that he's outperforming Cal Raleigh, right? Yeah.

Well, Cal counted 194 in June and 173 in August. So, you know, I think the people in the anti-Cal camp will look at that and say, you know, for two whole months, he was under 200. You know, he's back close to 300 in September to judge. He's three forty one in September with an OPS like you said over 1200.

So judge judges is coming on down the stretch as well, which is why I think it's going to be such an interesting case. I think you could really make strong arguments for both of them. And maybe the final two weeks will be the difference, you know, there's still two weeks of ball to play. And Cal goes crazy.

This is the start of him on one of those searches. I think he could, I think he can certainly make a closing case that he's the MPP. Yeah, I don't think anybody's going to throw a fit if Judge wins it, right? I mean, I'm just telling you what my gut is that I think the voters are ready to vote for somebody else.

And I think Cal Raleigh is going to win it unless he just falls apart and Judge goes bananas in these final couple of weeks and the M's miss the playoffs that could obviously factor into it. But does winning the division for Cal Raleigh does that greatly increase his odds? Do voters care about that stuff? Like we remember when Andre Dawson Larry won the MVP in the last place Cubs team back in 87, right?

Forty years ago. So it hasn't really bothered me where teams finish when it comes to the MVP. Was that a factor for you when you voted and will it be a factor now? It was a factor for me when I voted in.

And sometimes that could be a factor like with Andre Dawson. You could be a second place choice for everybody. And the first place choices balance each other out and you can sneak in without getting a lot of first place votes. That's happened as well.

So it's not like you're saying this last place guy is the guy I think is the MVP. But if enough people think he's second, then you can get in there. But I would weigh team success, but I would also weigh performances by a player in the stretch drive in the pennant race. And if the Mariners are on a nine game run, if they make it 10 in a row today, which I'm not counting that as a victory yet, I still remember that game last year where they blew an eight run lead to the Royal and won one of the most horrifying losses.

And I don't know if you remember that game. Of course. I thought you were going to say the Indians game in 2001. What was that like a 12 run lead or something like that?

Yeah, that one didn't hurt as bad when you already had about 106 wins in the bag. That's right. But the one last year really, really hurt. The point I was making is if they finish on this incredible surge where they play 700 ball down the stretch to take the division and Cal leads the way, I think that would really be something that would influence voters.

Larry, I was worried about this game, the first game, because they have this weird mental block on the road. They are eight and 17 going into this game on the road since the All-Star break. But do you think winning this first one does anything that kind of break that mojo that they had on the road or is it just one win and that's it? I'm kind of with you, Dick.

I was wondering how they would respond on the road, whether they would carry that momentum in and you know, three batters into the game, they're up to nothing. I think that probably would lead some of the pressure and allow them to relax. You look back at the last three road, Nate, now they're decisive margins. The two big wins over Atlanta and then this one can go in lead right now.

You know, it can't help but to change their mindset on the road, if you could take two out of three or sweep going into the Astro series, I mean, you could ask for more momentum going into the series of the year. Yeah. You're rooting for Texas, right? To just take care of Houston.

I mean, you're going after the division. You know, I guess, you know, there's a silver lining no matter what, you know, if the Astros win, then yeah, then the Rangers are falling further behind. But would that be kind of your ammo as a fan? That what you are now, by the way, is that you'd be just rooting for Texas and let's go get the West.

Yeah. You know, I thought about that and played it in my mind both ways. But I think I agree with you that you already have a pretty handy lead on Texas. I think it would help them much more to gain on Houston because winning the division would be huge for the team.

And the other thing is Detroit. At last I checked was losing in the seventh or eighth inning to Cleveland. Right. That could pull the Mariners within two of Detroit, which would be the second, the best record of a division winner is the Maris-Linda division and they can catch Detroit.

And that's not only a home field advantage, but a first round by, which just think how big that would be to set up your rotation, your best Cal, that's some of these guys. So that's not out of the realm of possibility at all. But just getting those, even if you don't get that, if you're a division winner, at least you get those games at home in the first year wildcard round and that would be just immensely beneficial. Guardians are up three, two in the eighth inning.

And by the way, don't forget the Mariners have a tiebreaker on the Tigers. All they have to do is tie Detroit and they beat them in the standings. So let's just say Toronto wins the East. If the Mariners and Tigers have the same record, the M's get the buy.

Well, now Larry, for the most important question I have for you baseball related today, after this game, the Mariners are going to need to go seven and four in the last 11 games for me to come from miraculously behind and win my bet with Softie and get to 90 wins. And break even where would you, where would you put your money right now, seven and four or better or six and five or worse with 11 games left? I'm going to go seven and four and better. Just probably being swayed too much by today's game and the way they're playing.

You have three against the Rockies, which are challenging last year's White Sox at the worst record in baseball history. You have a Dodger team that may not have anything to play for. I mean, it's set up for them to finish pretty strong and give you your victory. Yeah.

Well, I hope it gets it because I got the over 85 and a half. So I need that too. And I'm already breaking even with the Ram Trae with Cal's 56 home run. So I feel good no matter where.

Larry, we're watching the game in the studio. And it's 10 to one in the sixth inning and Cal is still in the game and he's still catching. Is this the kind of game where you would say, hey, maybe it's time to get you over to D Asia or give you the rest of the night off? I'm sorry about that.

But that's an interesting question because he has those numbers of targets that he's going after which could play in the MVP as we talked about. But he's team wise. It's probably more important to rest. But I would have a memory of that game against Kansas City last year.

It's still not safe. I would keep them in there. Got it. Got it.

They've blown the team's low leads and I just want to feel comfortable picking them up. Well, and here's one thing to add, guys, if we're keeping track of how many games Cal Raleigh has caught and he's caught 113 games, which still leads the American League. But he's nowhere near last year's numbers. He caught 135 games last season, which led all of the major leagues and 128 in 2023.

So unless he catches every game the rest of the way, he's not going to come anywhere near how many games he caught a year ago. So do we now sit here, Larry, and say, hey, maybe they've done a pretty good job of managing how many games he got behind the plate? Yeah, I think you have to think that it didn't seem like that. It seemed like he was catching off every day.

But you know, Garver caught virtually every game that a left-handed starter started. And that was quite a few lately. And they've done a pretty good job of mixing them in there and getting Cal at least off his feet. So, you know, I don't think Cal or the team would benefit by having him catch many fewer than that with the way he handles the pitching staff and the job he does defensively.

So I think it's kind of a nice niche that they found there with less than a little bit, but catching him the bulk of the games. Who's your starting second baseman to playoff started today, Larry? I kind of like what they did today with getting Robles and CanZone into the lineup and putting Polanco at second base. Although Polanco, there was one error he made and one play I thought he should have made that wasn't an error.

So defensively, I think you're better off there with Rivas and or Young. I think the decision is Rivas at second base and Polanco, DHE or Polanco, second base and CanZone, CanZone, DHE. No, not you're wrong. No, no, no.

What do you want? When the playoffs start, Polanco should not be given a glove at all. They should just hide it from him. Just don't give him one.

He's not allowed to touch a glove. I mean, that is terrible. I mean, Larry, pay me a picture where Hori Polanco is not your best DH option every game in the postseason. I think you could definitely make that case.

The only time that's not against the left hand starter, if you want to get an extra right-handed bad in there. But I guess he could revives a switch hitter so that he could even take that argument away. I get it. You can pin to me.

There you go. That doesn't take much, apparently. Larry Stone, Larry, before you go, why don't we just shift gears and get a thought from you on what's happening with the Seahawks, man? They go to Pittsburgh.

They got a big win against the Steelers. And then Dick and I were talking about the Saints game on Sunday. You realize that they are one in seven in their last eight games at home. And I don't know if they've ever had a stretch ever in our, you know, radio careers where they've been that terrible over eight games at Looman Field.

So you tell me how surprising that is and how much you think that is in the back of Mike McDonald's brain before the same game on Sunday. Well, it's very surprising when you consider how dominant they've been at home in their recent past, but they've watched that mojo that aura. And I think that's got to be foremost in the forefront of his mind to turn that around and get whatever he's got going on the road and translate it to home. You know, we talked last week about all the 49er fans who were at Looman Field and, you know, that's been an ongoing problem.

And the only way you turn that around is by winning at home and making the playoffs and all that. So I think I think he knows that. And that's what he's what he's aiming at. All right, Larry.

Well, last thing from a favorite Apple Cup memory and Huskies minus 20 and a half. Where are you going with your money? I think I'll go with the my money on the Huskies. Smart man.

Yeah. Such a pathetic performance by the Cougs last week. Trash talking stage. There is.

They kind of deserved it. When Larry's talking, oh, really? Okay. Wow.

So so she's not listening though. My favorite memory was the one of the first ones I covered when I was at the Yakama Herald Republic with the one where the Huskies needed to win the game to go to the Rose Bowl and the Proogers beat him with Chuck Nelson, the field goal. Yeah, you know, I was young and impressionable and it was a, to me, it was an incredibly exciting game and a fun one for a young guy to write. And so that's the one that speaks in my mind.

I'm sorry. We just lost Larry. Larry, Larry, just lost Larry. Hey, Larry, before you go, I got one more for you.

I'm going to give you a homework assignment, right? Because I know you're retired now. You're bored. You're standing around with your cup of coffee, just staring off into space, not knowing what the day is going to bring.

And this is a really, really easy thing for you to do because you've got the connections and you've got tech. So the way I understand this with the MVP, there's 30 writers in the American League that vote for the AL MVP. Is that correct? Yes.

Okay. Two from each city. Gotcha. Do you have cell phone numbers for every single one of them?

No, because I don't think anybody knows who the voters are. Come on. Really? It's a sign by the chapter chairman.

In this case, Ryan Divish, he knows who the two Seattle voters are. I don't know who they are. And each chapter chairman around the baseball writers, that's the chapter I'm talking about, baseball writers, association of America, signs the voters. And so, I mean, it would take an incredible amount of work that frankly, Dave, I don't get enough money to do.

All right. How about we give you a couple extra burgers from the Rams? Because I was going to say, you can just text them all and just say, hey, who would you vote for the MVP right now? But maybe you'll call those chapter presidents if you know who they all are and just get their thoughts on who they would vote.

I'd just be very curious to have some kind of a straw poll, maybe an anonymous poll of baseball writers in the American League and just kind of thought from them on who they'd vote for the MVP. But if you don't feel like putting the effort, then that's what I'm going to say. Well, the other thing is, and then we are told in strong terms that we're not allowed to give out our vote. So it has to be anonymous.

Yeah. So, but you know what? Somebody's going to do that. I beg you, son, one of the esteemed baseball writers, because this is going to be an incredible talking point and point of interest around baseball with this MVP race.

No, I guarantee you that there will be people doing that at polling that you're talking about. No doubt. Larry, you're the man. Great stuff.

And who knows what the next week will bring. They haven't lost since you were last on the air with us. So maybe they'll be riding a 17-game winning streak by the time we talk in a week. Who knows?

Great stuff. And we'll talk next week. All right. Thanks, Joe.

The entire draft room groans because you just took the guy they wanted. There's no better feeling than crushing your fantasy football lead. I'm Jay Zachery Sinh, host of the award-winning late-round podcast. Before your draft, our players to target and players to avoid episodes tell you exactly who to circle and who to cross off.

Listen to the late-round fantasy football podcast on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcast. On Big Lives, we take a single cultural icon. People like Jane Fonda, George Michael, Little Richard. And we pull apart the story behind the image, discovering forgotten interviews that change exactly how we see these giants of our culture.

We're here for the messy, the brilliant, the human version of our heroes. I'm your man on Joe Chi, and this is Big Lives. Listen to Big Lives on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts. Did you think you were the only one, like no matter what you did, was never good enough for your mother?

I'm Jennifer Arnees, and this is the Black Mother One podcast, where we unpack and heal from the very first relationship that shaped us. We rush to accommodate other people when we have been hurt, and our hurt has not been healed. Listen to the Black Mother One podcast from the Black Effect podcast network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcast, and wherever you get your podcasts. I am talking to a felon right now with face tattoos, and I cannot decide if I like him or not.

That was a caller from my podcast, TherapyGecko, where I speak with anonymous callers about their problems, relationships, and anything else in the depths of their mind. It all happens on my show, TherapyGecko. So if you're trying to get out of your own head and into someone else's, this is the podcast for you. I'm TherapyGecko on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Softy & Dick Interviews?

This episode is 20 minutes long.

When was this Softy & Dick Interviews episode published?

This episode was published on September 17, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Softy & Dick Interviews episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.