Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Monica Atard. Today I'm speaking to Tracy Kirkland, the continuous news editor for the ABC News Channel and Gavin Fang, Deputy Director at ABC News.
Together they've edited a collection of essays that cover the logistical, ethical and existential challenges faced by the news industry during the pandemic and beyond. The book is called Panda Media and it asks, how did the pandemic change journalism? This interview was one that I did for another podcast called Double Take produced by the Centre I Work at the Centre for Media Transition. For certain issues already underway deepened during the pandemic, issues like the weaponisation of disinformation and growing mistrust of the media, but other problems, including lockdowns, meant the journalists had to find enterprising ways to tell a story.
And at the same time, politicians were deciding what we could and couldn't do, where we couldn't, couldn't go, and journalists were facing criticism for demanding that those politicians tell us the reasoning behind their decision-making. This was a moment of deep polarization in Australian society. Between those who thought our governments were making the right decisions, and those who thought that they weren't. Journalists were caught in the crossfire.
Audiences swarmed to news media for information during the pandemic as well, but a year into the pandemic, they tuned out as fast as they tuned in, exhausted by the relentless tolls and doomsday alarm ringing. Journalists who lived and worked through COVID were exhausted too. Okay, so Gavin and Tracy, thank you both for being on this podcast with us at the Centre at the Centre for Media Transition. We appreciate your time.
Tracy, I'd like to start with you. It was a COVID-19 was an extraordinary experience for the world, but it was extraordinary also for the industry of journalism, because at the moment, at the most in-opportuned time, you'd have to say, audiences were already fragmented. Mis-trust of media was rampant already. Misinformation was already rife.
Importantly, there was criticism that news was altogether too negative, which is a criticism I've always found rather baffling in the news world. But try to find a way to report a very significant public interest story prone to all of those challenges would have been extremely hard. What were the considerations for you? Wow.
Big question to start with. If you go back to that time, you also, there was a lot of things happening in the world as well. Donald Trump was still in power, and we had just come off a summer of bushfires in Australia. So journalists had worked pretty hard.
The audience was with us for those fires, but yes, we did know that trust was in decline. The traditional audience, mainstream media audience was in decline. People were looking for their news in all sorts of places. Yes, misinformation campaigns were right, and we were dealing with all of that, which probably set us up in some ways for what was to come, because we were alert to these things.
But what we didn't expect was a worldwide pandemic, which also altered the way we gather the news. So people couldn't come into TV studios. We couldn't have audiences. We couldn't even get up close with our microphones.
We couldn't be in community meetings. We couldn't network with each other. People, journalists went and worked from their living rooms and bedrooms, and it transformed the way we work at the same time we had to learn as everybody did zoom overnight. Our meetings were went online.
And for people who were in the office, it was a time where there was a lot of fear, a wheel of frontline workers, we would drive the empty streets to get to work and to tell this story. So what was the consideration for us as the public broadcaster, the main consideration was how we tell this story in a way that is accurate and timely, and we explain it in a way that's helpful for our audience. I think that was our main consideration way back at the start. But we're concerned at all that you wouldn't be able to overcome all the challenges in order to do what the ABC was meant to be doing.
No, I don't think that ever crossed our minds, because in some ways we didn't have that luxury. We had to tell this story, and we had to, for me, I'm at the work for a continuous youth channel, we had to be on air 24 hours a day. We didn't have a choice, but we knew this was a really important story to tell, and we knew that we had a very significant role in telling it correctly. We knew that misinformation was a real problem.
We knew that people were turning to, for example, social media to find answers, and so we knew that our role was vital in getting really accurate and timely information out to the Australian public. I mean, there were things we did across the times during COVID that helped us, audience engagement and things like that, and we can talk about that. But way back in the beginning, we didn't even know what this thing was. We didn't know how it's spread.
I mean, we got back to the very basics of journalism, which was, what is this story? What is important here? And how can we tell it in a way that is relevant to our audience? I suppose you're in a situation as well where all of a sudden you're telling all the journalists that you're supervising that they've kind of got to become science journalists or mid- innocent journalists in a hurry overnight.
Yes, people like Casey Briggs, our data journalists that really came to the floor, our health journalists were vital in this. We all learned what an epidemiologist was. In some ways, we didn't want our journalists to become experts, but what we wanted them to do is use their journalistic skill and now to be able to determine who were the right people to speak to, make sure there was no agenda with the people that we were talking to. So it's just using those real journalistic skills rather than themselves becoming experts in the subject, actually just telling the story through people that were reliable, using facts that were up to date, using sources that were reliable.
The problem was that in those early days, we were all learning on the go. So the scientists, the politicians, the media journalists, everybody was learning as we went. So we had to just be really careful about the facts that we were broadcasting or rushing on our website and make sure that it was the most accurate and up to date information that we could be giving. You mentioned audience engagement and I'll come to you in a moment, Gavin, but Tracy, can I just ask you to explain what were you doing and how could you engage with audiences in those circumstances?
Well, I think one of the things the ABC realized was that it was really important as the story went on and to make it relevant to people that we actually asked the audience, what do you want to know? What questions do you have and how can we help you? So what we did, we set up a whole engagement team and through the ABC website, we were asking people to tell us, what are your questions? What do you need to know?
And it was fascinating. We got thousands and thousands and thousands of questions and we were answering them as best we could and for us on the news channel, we were sometimes very blatant. We put the question, the most common questions up on the screen and we would get experts on to actually answer those directly. So we were listening to the audience, I would say like never before about what they needed to know.
You know, when all the rules changed and they were changing constantly, we were having to explain them. So we wanted to ask the audience, what is it you don't understand? How can we help you further? And often it was the most basic of information.
How do I stay within my five kilometer rule? Is it a mask, the right thing to do? If I need a mask and I make one myself, is that still safe? Those kind of basic questions just kept coming up over and over again.
And we felt it was part of our remit to be actually answering those. And I think going forward, it's something that I hope we don't lose, that engagement with the audience asking, what do you need to know about these big stories of the day and how can we help better inform you? It's the gamut and the clarification of the rules and answering some of those basic questions that Tracy just outlined there. And did it matter what people wanted to know rather than what they needed to know or should know?
I think I think it did. I mean, I think there are two things or to kind of pick apart those two things. On the one hand, because the story was so fast moving, there were days where the information changed within a day. And some of the things that our writers have spoke about in Panda Media, including Tori McWhire from Nine Publishing, is how difficult the media found it was to keep up to date with the latest information.
And that was in large part because the information was always changing. So I think it was important for us to be providing the audience with as much correct information clearly as possible as we could, but also really to be responsive to what was the most important thing to them, the most important bit of information for the Australian community. And I think because during this pandemic, when this was the one key story that really touched everybody's lives, there was a real thirst for information that was incredibly relevant to people. And we all felt that the community journalists, everybody felt that we needed to really get as much information as we possibly could, because we needed that to navigate our daily lives.
So I think it was important to both be responsive to the audience, but also to be digging away at, you know, what is actually the causes of COVID? What are the governments rules? What are the things that we should be looking into? One of our ABC colleagues, Wanna Gold Walkley and Connolly for looking at aged care during this period.
And she really had to dig away and investigate what was going on there. So we were trying to do that type of journalism while also balancing the idea of how do we be relevant increasingly to an audience, which is really thirsty for knowledge about the basics of this story. I mean, I know that people we all wanted information in that time, particularly during lockdown, but I wonder to what extent was the quantum of information issue for the ABC? How much information you gave people, what type of information and how often in order that you don't overwhelm people with both information?
And of course, the fear that came with the kind of information that you were imparting. It's a really interesting question and a really interesting discussion, I think that we have to have all the time about how much information the public is being asked to understand. I was listening to Laura Tingle speaking last week about this very issue and she was talking about it being like a fire hose of information and that that's what's really happening to people that really the community is struggling with information overload. I think with this story, what surprised us was that the community was so intent on understanding every single angle about the story.
And I think it comes back to that relevance piece. But one of my reflections after the intense period of COVID, because of course COVID still exists, but after that intense period of covering the pandemic, was that we really need to slow down often. We need to do more by sometimes doing a bit less by slowing down on the story and by trying to provide more context for what is happening. And maybe across this period, some of the things that we did around trying to constantly update the audience on what was the latest bit of information, perhaps we could have contextualized that a bit better, perhaps we could have slowed down a bit better and tried to wrap some more context around that information.
Having said that, I think it is important that we listen to our audience and that we respond and try to provide the audience with the information that they are chasing. Of course, there is a time and place to slow down, isn't there? I mean, for example, the daily press conferences, which were all glued to them, and then suddenly they became quite traumatic and then they moved into becoming basically very boring, but important. The ABC made a decision to abandon the daily broadcasts and there was criticism of that and there was support for that.
It was, you know, people were all over the shop on that one. What went into the thinking about that, about abandoning those daily broadcasts, which had become such an integral part of our daily lives as we were in lockdown and trying to find things to use ourselves. Well, it's just because we played them on the channel, on News Channel, we played all of them for the first year and a half, I think, essentially the language we use about us abandoning the broadcast when, so we will listen to our audience. And if you look at our audience numbers, and this goes right across the spectrum, newspaper, radio, digital, television, those in the first two years of the pandemic, the audience numbers were enormous.
And if you look at everybody games, the Australian public turned to the mainstream media to answer their questions and to understand what was happening to them and to their friends and around the world. But then if you look at the numbers of the people watching the daily presses, they were extraordinary. You put on these presses, which would go for an hour and a half, the audience numbers peaked at that time and stayed with us for the whole press conference. Then the next one would start and the next one would start.
I think in the first year, certainly the information was changing so quickly, people were tuning in and in a sense, gave them a sense of community because all of their friends were like, what am I doing at 11 o'clock? Well, of course, we're all going to turn on the TV and watch the daily presser. It was a kind of weird sense of community that we had all watching that together. But it was vital because they were waiting to hear what the, you know, the premiers were saying that was the latest kind of rules that they were going to have to live with.
But after a while, what we realized was that constant amount of information and those daily press conferences led to, I think, two things. One of them, it became a bit of white noise. So people started to get used to living with COVID and they didn't want the demand for that information wasn't as great. And also, for other people, of course, as you said, extreme anxiety.
And so they couldn't watch because it was just brought fear and anxiety to their lives. And so you had people turning off. So they're the kind of discussions we were having about. It was about the news value, as it always is, in broadcasting this.
So initially, the news value was the audience demand was there and it was offering in real time information direct from the source from the health offices and the premiers. But as time went on, it was actually causing distress and it was causing a turn off a mass turn off because people were avoiding the news because they had all become so negative. So we have to take all of that into account when we think about what we're going to broadcast as a public broadcaster because we have a responsibility to the Australian public. So they're the kind of things that came in.
I wouldn't say it as abandoning. I would see it as an evolution of a massive story that went on for years and the way we had to always be examining the way we covered it. And that was one of the decisions we made. And another one was around, broadcasting the death numbers and the hospitalization numbers.
There was a point where we thought again, this is causing unnecessary anxiety. And we have to decide whether it's, there is value in actually putting this up on the screen every single day when it's readily available on the health websites and the politicians' websites. So yes, we made a lot of ethical decisions during that time, but we always had the audience at the forefront of our minds when we're making those. And interestingly, that's how this book came about because Gavin and I were talking and work about these ethical decisions we had to make.
And we wanted to hear the perspectives of journalists across the country. And that's how the book came to be. What's interesting that you posed that as an ethical issue, that the decision based on numbers and who's watching and why people are turning off rather than the public's right to know and the ABC's obligation to inform. Is that how did you, how did you get to that conclusion?
I think, well, I think just to pick up on what Tracy was saying, I suppose what I was going to say before was that we are always making what I'd call journalistic decisions every day about what is the best way to communicate this information to the public, to the audience. And at some point, you do need to make a determination about is a rolling press conference that goes for a number of hours, the best value and the best way to communicate what is the public interest aspect of that press conference to the audience. And it's not necessarily done in a live broadcast. It doesn't mean that we were not then taking that information and using that in our stories or putting that in our website or in fact playing elements of that across our news channels.
But we were making, as we always do, decisions about how do we tell our stories in the best way to get that public interest information to the public. I guess in a sense, it's almost about striking a balance between being truthful about what's happening, which is pretty scary and producing news which is not sensationalist. Is that what you're trying to say? I don't think we ever steer away from from providing truthful information, but we always have to balance up what's the most important information that we're putting in our stories.
What's the, I would come back to that. What's the context for this information? How important is this bit of information as compared to something else that is out there about a particular story? And as you know, Monica, we're always making those choices when we when we construct our stories.
So there was also the issue of Norman Swan's podcast and his general view that Australia wasn't handling the pandemic as well as a quote-hab that the situation was actually worse than we were being told. Was there, Gavin, do you think an element there of media competition between the health experts and was it appropriate for that competition to take place on the public broadcast? I guess his job was particularly difficult because as a doctor, he had a very deep understanding of what the statistics meant and what was coming at us. But how do you strike a balance there?
And when you say competition, what do you actually mean by that, Monica? Well, there was a competition. Was there not between him and some of the epidemiologists and indeed with some health reporters and other media outlets that who disagree with him and who criticized his negative takes on what was being done by the public health authorities in Australia? I wouldn't characterize that.
I suppose as a competition. I think what Norman Swan was doing was doing journalism and doing journalism around information that he was able to source and he was bringing his expertise as a doctor, but also, you know, his sources and contacts and his analysis, which we were expecting him to do to provide to that. The information was absolutely at times contested both by government and by other people in the media. And also there was a contested space between epidemiologists about how this pandemic would play its way out.
I think what he was trying to do and what the ABC was attempting to do through his analysis was to provide the public with the best information and to try to provide the public with the best analysis about where this might be going amongst information from a whole series of sources. I mean, I think one of the things that was pretty apparent across this entire pandemic was that the information regularly changed and that even the government and the health officers at times didn't have a clear understanding or a total picture of where we would get to. I mean, for a long period of time, if you remember, before the prospect of the vaccine was even around, we actually had no idea about how these pandemic might play out or end. So I think what Norman and other analysts with a medical background were attempting to do was to try to provide the most accurate information but to contextualize that within the what's the most likely thing that could happen based on the best medical advice that's happened.
Okay, so you kind of raise very many issues there. One of them, of course, is the question of trust. And you know, Miss Trust in News Media was an established phenomenon in World before COVID. Miss Trust in what the authorities were saying about COVID also, as you say, became a pretty big issue.
Tracy, how important was it for the ABC to be seen to be reflected in what the authorities were advising and how did you overcome the expectation, which undoubtedly was there that you'd be questioning that advice, prosecuting it in other words, to make sure that it was viable and correct. How do you deal with that? Well, I think when it comes right down to it, our role as journalists is to hold to account those in power who are making these decisions. And we need to be able to question them in a way that is fair, because at the end of the day, we need to provide our audience with the best information possible.
And it's our role, whether we're public broadcaster or commercial broadcasters, part of our role as journalists. And so I think we took that really seriously. I think at the start of COVID, when what the media was reporting, what the politicians were saying, what the health officers were saying was very similar, it's because we were all learning. We didn't know what we didn't know.
And so there was only so far we could go in under, you know, we were pushing all the time to really understand the latest advice. And you know, there were certain turning points throughout COVID. And I think Gavin makes the point in his essay in the book that AstraZeneca was one of those times when all of a sudden, the things that the politicians were saying seemed to bring into question the other advice that they'd given, which raises the red flag of all journalists. It's like, ah, now here's something we need to look into.
So a final question to you, Bo, and that is, what are the takeaways and what are the lessons that you learned from that period of time? And Tracy, I might start with you, because one of the things that you talk about was making news relevant, which struck me as worthy of talking about, because shouldn't news media already be relevant? And if it's not, why not, and what needs to change? I think relevance, besides accuracy, relevance is up there as one of the key things for me, because well, a lot has changed, Australia has changed, we're a very multicultural nation.
There are people who didn't grow up with the ABC, and you know, we need to, and also people are looking for the news in all sorts of places, in other platforms. And we need to move with the times, if you know, if you understand what I mean, we've got to remain relevant. And which means we need to hear what audiences expected the news, we need to, I think, one of the days where the old-style news that Gavin and I are used to, and I know you would be the same on where, you know, we all gather together the news editor makes the decisions, you have your priorities, and you're telling the world or the country, this is what we think the news is. Now, we need, it's a much more relational engagement with our audience.
We need to listen to the kind of things that they want to hear about. We need to reflect them in our stories, which means we need to be considerate about what we're actually broadcasting, much more so than before. Still, the news values and news judgment is still there, it's still core to what we do. We still want to curate or bring together things that we think are relevant and most important for people to hear, but we've got to do it in a whole new variety of ways.
We've got to engage a whole lot of new communities. We need to engage younger people, we need to engage women, and we need to do it in ways that are not the traditional form of we know everything and we're telling you what the news is. And I think that is something under COVID where we've actually made real progress because we haven't been able to have people in the studio, we've been able to zoom in right across the country, we've been able to get to the most remote places to tell stories. I mean, what makes the story, I think, fundamentally is the same, but we've been able to get closer and closer to the source of those stories because it's not reliant on getting a camera there or being available to a studio.
So I think we have made some progress in our diversity, and so we reflect the Australian community in a way that makes the news more relevant. And look, these are issues that come up all the time. So we're constantly thinking about how can we be most relevant to the Australian community because we are the public broadcaster and that is our charter. So like I said, to me, accuracy is key, but next comes relevance to our audience because you know what, unless we do that and we engage with the audiences, think about who we are.
We are just on a downhill slide, all of us as the mainstream media, not just the ABC. I mean, we're lucky because we're very, very trusted in the Australian community, but we have to maintain that trust by engaging with our community and thinking about our audience, what their needs are, and taking seriously our charter as the public broadcaster to be accurate, to have really high integrity and trust will follow that. I think trust in the media, yes, is on the decline, but I think a lot of that has to do with the rise of mistrust in social media and other media platforms, but it doesn't mean it's not relevant to us and we've got to take note and we've got to think about what it means for our journalism. And Gavin, for you, the takeaway, the takeaway is from all of this?
Some of them are similar, I would say listening to the audience. And I don't know sometimes that some journalists feel that what is being said there is that we are simply going down a path of clickbait, but we're not. It's about really actively listening and connecting with the community on the issues that are important, and pursuing those issues with doggedness and with the public interest at heart. And I think that's really important.
It's around the importance of accurate and relevant information to the audience and the power that that brings around empowering people to make sense of what's happening, so that they can use that information in their own lives. It's the strength of our fundamental editorial principles that in the face of issues of misinformation and the like, but actually the value of those really strong journalistic editorial principles drive trust and that's so important. And look, really the need to engage with our own people on not just on the way that they're doing their journalism, but how that is impacting their lives and how they're navigating the challenges of that so that we can continue to have resilient journalists who are doing their best jobs. There's so much more to talk about, so I hope that I can get you both to come back again in the future.
But I thank you both, Gavin Fang and Tracy Kurzman for a great discussion, and we'll talk to you again soon. Thanks Monica. Thank you Monica. I really enjoyed it.
And thanks for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of TUICR and heard across the country on the community radio network. For the State is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support.
Make sure you subscribe to For the State on your favorite podcast app so that you can hear us talk about media politics and, of course, everything in between. We're back next week with more. In the meantime, you can stay in touch with this on Twitter and handle there is For the State AU and we're also on threets. I'm Monica Atard.
Thank you for listening.