Right, yeah, as you can see, Matt, this is Join just again. Hey guys, it's me, Matt. Yeah, and it's me, John. Yeah, wait, no, it's me.
It's me, okay, I don't know how Matt would say. Matt, now I'm happy to be here, and I'm actually a really good guy. That's my first nation. That's all I got.
Here's some whiskey, everybody. He is Irish, though. Nobody always brings us the whiskey, too. That's right.
It's always Irish whiskey, because it's Irish. It took us 10 seconds to get into race tonight's episode. She drew his name. Okay, well, that's what the podcast is now gonna be about.
Is Jake Kerber? Let's get it. Okay, so welcome to legend lore, brought to you by snwproductions.com. And as you already heard, to my right, we do have back with us.
Damn, Rockfest, I'm back. Don't be fooled by that previous podcast. There wasn't any posture. And he sounded nothing like me.
Yeah, I was just some guy. I don't know, I think his performance check was pretty good. He did pretty good on his performance check. I'll give him that.
Thank you. Yeah, that was Jason Karch from Texarkana. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Art Kansas.
I didn't think we were saying all last names on this podcast. Actually, no, we would. My last name is. Yeah, and he always goes his last name.
So I am DM Osborne, first name Keenan. I was redacted. What's your son's security number? This is Cody, Jess Cody, no DM on Earth.
I got a bad choice. This is DM, Pobotene, or Matt. It's got to be serious tonight, guys. Oh, serious.
Holy cow, that was like forceful. I was actually a little bit like, oh, that's great. It's funny because it's like you put more evil emphasis on the name Matt than you did Pobotene. What?
That is DM. Hi, guys. I'm not DM Pobotene or you may also call me. Okay, so what are we talking about today?
Oh, oh, I have a funny story though. Okay, hold on. Funny story first before I actually start business. DM Rockfish is my moniker and I use it on YouTube stuff.
I post up and use it when I walk into Zoom because I'm doing D&D stuff on Zoom. And so it has DM Rockfish with my Minotaur holding his axe. And that's my image on Zoom if I'm not doing my camera, right? Well, that's on my iPad.
Well, my company has a brand new CCO, which is one step down from the CEO. She's an awesome lady. And I traveled with her this last week. She lives in my area.
So we had to get on a conference call for the whole company. And without thinking, I said, well, you can just use my iPad. So she gets on the Zoom call with almost 200 employees. And it's her talking on the camera.
But it says DM Rockfish right underneath it. So yeah, I'm looking for a job. Dude, wait to get us some free plus. I know, right.
Yeah. If you want to ask, John, what's DM Rockfish? Let me tell you all about it. I'm just asking WP.
So yeah, so she lives in your area. What's your address again? Oh, it's a and then I get Keenan's address. Yes, for my social and his address.
That's right. I'm getting slowly at the time. Okay, so today we are going to be talking about Homebrew and covering a few different subjects on that, talking a little bit about Homebrew rules, some pros and cons of Homebrew and about Homebrewing existing campaign settings that are official D&D products and also about your own Homebrew. So I would like to kind of kick this off with just one really quick thing.
In 1974, Dungeons and Dragons was released. And when I saw that, I did sometimes just bog on my mind, or I didn't introduce it to the mid 80s, right? So I was in 1974. I was like 83 84 that I that I came across it.
So I was literally four years old in this game came out. They're old and already crossed over into my 50s. And I'm still playing this game. So I think it's kind of cool.
But one of the things that are is right in the introductions to the very first basic set is this. I'm going to quote this on my paraphrase. These rules are as complete as possible within the limitations imposed by the space. That is they cover the major aspects of a fantasy campaign, but still remain flexible.
They provide framework around framework around which you will build a game of simplicity or tremendous complexity. Your time and imagination are the only limiting factors. And that's right off the bat. And then 1978, Advanced Dungeons and Dragons came out and basically says, even the most important material here in can be altered and bent to suit the needs of the individual campaigns.
The game is unlike chess in that the rules are not cut and dried. In many places, they are guidelines and suggested methods only. And this goes on through all the editions, second edition and so on. So immediately they're telling you right in these rules that they're guidelines.
You do what you want with them, which means you home brew them the way you want to, which to me is very exciting thing is really I think I've talked about this in past that Dean D to me is the ultimate home brew anyways, because the way it was born from tabletop wargaming and the way they adapted into role playing and the way they adapted all these different systems and they made their own thing and continue to grow until they finally publish it. And then write their own rules. They address the fact that, yeah, we we made a lot of the stuff up and we home bring a lot of stuff and stuff too. Something that's kind of cool about this subject.
It's sort of related. There's a comic book that I really enjoyed reading about Gary Gagax and how him and the other guys name ever again. And Dave Anderson. Thank you.
How they created D&D and it goes all the way back to when they're playing their war, like the Civil War and World War Two games and how they had the idea from the chain mail game to make D&D and they're somewhere in the comic book. It mentions how he would get phone calls at like two in the morning from random people because for some reason he just has house phone easily accessible for these people and people comment in the morning asking for rules clarifications and he would go, okay, yes, we're going there with that. So what did you do? And then they would tell him what he was like, yeah, that sounds great.
Yeah, go and do that. And so it's I think it's kind of cool. Like just right from the get go, the original creator of the game or one of the creators is just saying, yeah, how about it? You what the way that you did it sounds great.
Right. That's your rule for your game. I'm so surprised to hear that from Cody, the rules heavy guy. Like, yeah, the rules are flexible.
Then you're like, no, it's not what the text was says. No, actually it's not. Well, no, it's like, yeah, I'm a rules lawyer, but as long as there's like fairness or balance with it, it's all about the balance. Well, you know what?
I think it's a little more than that too, because when I first found second edition D&D in high school, one of the things I really liked about it was going, okay, there's these monsters, they have these stat blocks, there's these mechanical rules to the combat and the spells all have their different rules. And I approached it when I first found it as like sacred text. I was like, when we would be playing as a DM, I took a lot of pride in that moment where I could be like, no, actually the spells were like this. And then the player got, no, it's not.
And then they look at it and they go, Oh, shit, you're right. And I liked it. I liked that there was some degree of structure to what we were doing. And it wasn't just really nilly.
But as we were thinking about tonight's episode and what is a home brew and you find different definitions, right? But like one of the more common definitions is just anything that's not in the rule book. So it could be a setting, it could be a monster, it could be a spell, it could be a twist on the mechanics, like, you know, anything that's outside the rule book could be a home brew. But I think that every DM and every player falls somewhere on the spectrum of like wanting to go deep into home brew material versus stay close to home in official publication type stuff.
And it's remembered why I'm such a rules heavy guy. I did play a 1D and D and D game where the guy had a staff of haste and yes, the DM is an action or bonus action to activate the haste on the staff. You know, we'll just make a bonus action. So you bonus action taste and then he has a regular action to cast like a super high level spell and then he uses his taste action to cast another super high level spell and end up killing the monster that we were all trying to fight.
And I was like, I just want to smell a struggle myself. I mean, it's pretty bad. So you can run a campaign. I was disappointed.
Yeah. What if it was you? I would never, never done that. Well, I think, you know, kind of going back to what you were just saying, John, is I think that's kind of interesting take on things because you've definitely you were, you may have kind of started out the way, but you're way more of a flexible DM now as far as making up rules on the spot, doing things on the spot.
I've always kind of been that way. I just am, you know, I probably started home from my own roping games early on when I was a young kid and I think there is definitely you have to have that rule structure. But I do think this always have that mind as long as you guys can agree at the table about the home route. Like, yeah, this is OK.
This works for us. Like you should never ram and I try never to ram things down your guys. It's that you don't like you have like a PDF or like a slide on TV for us to read. Yeah.
Yeah. And we'll talk about it before we play or even in game where we can take them on what to talk about. Yeah. Well, let's do this way.
And sometimes we sometimes will bend rules on the fly just for expediency of combat, too. I think that's something that's seen us all do quite a bit, except for Matt. He's hard as and he was still so I think you're confusing me with Keenan. Oh, yeah.
That's right. That's right. Yeah. But I could give you guys most ridiculous gear and abilities so that I can.
And you're probably the loosest with letting us do different things that are outside the norm for sure. I like it to be more cinematic. It's more about the narrative than the mechanics. Yes.
I find that to be more enjoyable. Right. And it lets you do more than your standard like last week when we played in Cody. I love that like flesh goal and basically.
And you couldn't care exactly what it is. You could you want to creatively attack it and I wasn't really doing super great damage to it. So I but it's a flesh goal. I'm covered in armor.
So I've figured it's like cybernet. I figured I could just like rip off all that armor thinking that it's not super well attached to the creature because I don't know. I just can't imagine how that kind of thing would like be really stuck on the creature. It's just trying to like yeah, it's really stable science.
So I was just trying to like rip off some armor. It had like a helmet kind of thing. So I was trying to rip off its helmet. Maybe expose its brain.
I could punch its brain, which ended up doing. And it was good. I loved how you did it too because instead of just giving me an inspiration point for doing combat outside the box or that you were lowering its modifier to hit us and it had a crazy high modified one. It was high modified plus 12.
So every time I was able to succeed on taking off its armor, you were lowering its ability to do damage to us. And I thought that was a really good creative way to change up how combat was being done. Thanks. And I wanted to make it compounding.
So it was rewarding you to continue it. If it was just an inspiration point, it would be easy to be like, oh, I did one off thing in combat, but the fact it was a modifier reduction or like it could have been an AC reduction to, but that that I feel like would nurture you to doing stuff like that. Because you're like, oh, it actually is compounding. If I keep doing it, I'm going to gain more benefit.
I think that's really unique because there isn't as rules were in a way to really compound it packs or stuff like that. So I think of it for a pretty good. It made the combat dynamic. It made it like a living thing.
Yeah. And that's why I was trying to bring through Home Rule and bidding the rules is that. Yeah. So let's talk about a little bit kind of what we were talking pre-podcast and we were just all sitting there and getting dinner and all that thing.
And we kind of talked about the difference between there's the Home Rule of the Rules and there's the Home Rule of your campaign setting you might be running or if you are running a official Wizards Adventure or campaign setting, the Home Rule you can do within that adventure that makes it your own as well. Because as John said at the very beginning of this, it's basically Home Rule is anything that is not official Wizards content truly. So every time you add like said, you had Bob in the Goblin and two campaigns, he's not there. That's a little bit of Home Rule right there.
You have a reason for putting me in there. We can talk about campaigns like I run pretty much since we've been playing and actually pretty much all the time. I only run Home Rule campaign settings. I very rarely venture into official D&D settings.
I did in the Champions of Sae Loon. They did all take place in Fae Room. I did take you guys to Fae Room playing the Champions of Boos, but I changed things around a lot when I ran when I ran my second edition setting in Fae Room and around Cormier and see if all it starts a lot. What I ended up doing was I didn't really want to get too deep into the lore with everybody with what was going on as far as the God were because I kind of had my own plan.
They were serving a church and I kind of want to create my own God or so I kind of kept everything as it was pre the God were in the Forgotten Realms area and then made my creative my own. You, John, did a very incredible job with the Curse of Straw campaign of taking what they had and then Home Rule again into something that was light years ahead of where they had what they had in that book. Thank you, sir. And I think that's the two things you can do.
I mean, that's your choices. You know, either you play exactly to the letter, which is nothing wrong with that because I'm good. Okay. You're looking at me as I'm saying, which is very good listening, which I think is very good.
I think that's awesome. I definitely do not take anything away from people that want to follow the letter of the campaign setting or the letter of the adventure they're running. It can definitely take a lot off your plate as a DM. One thing I've noticed when I was doing a little bit of my own Curse of Straw campaign as a DM when they get to block you and I put like three or four or five different extra quests in there because there's there's so much in Milwaukee, but it almost feels like each of the side quests or little mini storylines, they're kind of surface level for most of them.
And so I wanted to dive deeper into them. I found some home brew supplements online and I did a little bit of my own stuff in there, but it ended up bogging down the story so much. They ended up spending way too many sessions in Milwaukee, not really getting a whole lot done in terms of the main storyline because they had to finish all of these little side things going on with there. So there is benefits to staying strictly with the book.
Yeah. If that's the way that you're going because it there's a pacing involved. Yeah. Like that's the story you want to tell.
That's obviously reinforced that specifically. Exactly. I think John did a great job home brewing all of Curse of Straw because I never really felt like a story being bogged down. I felt like every single session, even with all the side quests, they were as progress being made forward to the overall plot.
Yeah. Well, they were the ones you included were so part of Barovia that they were a part of the main story. They were just sub plots of the main story. Like when you included that where Wolf Encounter and the Revenant stuff, like that always directly about straw and messing with our party, but it was stuff that you had made or capitalized on that they might have mentioned.
And that made it feel like a real again, like a real world. So Cody, in previous stuff, like when you've run a lot of Pathfinder adventures, not a lot of you ran. Did you homebrew those or did that was that pretty much straight out of the book? The only Pathfinder games from the books that I run was Rise of the Run Lords and Wrath of the Righteous.
I didn't get too far into either of them because the groups were broken up for whatever reason or another. Rise of the Runelords. I got like the anniversary books was like all of the books put into one giant thing and they had already added a bunch of extra things onto that book. So they already had your side quest plotted out in that book.
So there was really almost no need for me as a very new deal. It was like first thing I ever ran was Rise of the Runelords. There wasn't really not a whole lot of need for me to make my own homebrew stuff on there because it already had like love interests and tiny little subplots going on or like mini adventures going into the woods to hunt some wolves. So they added a lot of detail and really to this campaign.
And it actually made it overwhelming for me because it had if your characters respond this way with this person, then this is what happened. So there's one this was there's one this was this was this was this was this was what happens and it was overwhelming for me as a very new deal. Right. Super detailed, which is probably one of the reasons why I think are you know, like the ones that we've been designing have been kind of really keeping in mind that we're keeping things a little simplistic, you know, especially if you're beginning to beginning player.
So I guess on the question, I want to kind of stick on. I'm sorry, but I get one when asked Cody, this before I forget. So you homebrewed a little bit into Curse of Strahd. I mean, and they got bogged down.
Do you feel that they got bogged out because you're playing with kind of a newer set of players or is it just was not fitting within the story narrative in the way you thought it would or I am a very bad DM. And I like some of the side plots that we put in there, the players really, really enjoyed it was very cool. They, but I realized the side things that I had included in the game were usually things that complimented the things in the book that were already there. So I stole a thing on Reddit about putting a dog inside Death House.
And so when they go into the basement, they got to sacrifice someone or get out of the basement. Right. There was the option of sacrificing a player or sacrificing the dog. And they ended up sacrificing a player because nobody ever wants to kill the dog.
And the players cried, like three of them cried. And I loved it. I was able to introduce the dark powers in there because I was able to resurrect one of them because she cut her hand in order to lead out and sacrifice herself. So she had like a scar on her hand and it was like a, I pulled her aside.
Like, okay, so your hand is like an undead hand now and she had a glove already on it. So like if you were to remove that glove, it'll look like a zombie hand kind of thing. And I was trying to get her to do like some, like Adam's family, the things that I've got to do with her hand. And she did it sometimes.
But so the things that really worked well were the things that complimented the overall story instead of just here's a random side adventure. So, so, you know, you are much like me. You know, you like to do a lot of a lot of open end up narratives, you can let the party drive things a little bit and obviously it was completely your creation as far as campaign setting and so singularity really. Yeah.
And so with Matt, you're right now, we're the only one who's I think that are truly running an actual homebrew campaign, but not a homebrew that you created, but a homebrew that other people created. What's cool about Mass is he has the biggest universe to work with. And so he's not well, he's homebrewing a lot of the universe stuff too, but he's he's creating a storyline inside the giant Star Wars universe. So how do you feel about like running that running that homebrew Star Wars?
Well, I mean, it stems from obviously my love of the Star Wars universe completely. And especially Star, I would say it for me, running the campaign for you guys was my my way to not reflect. I'm trying to think of my way to see the Star Wars universe keep going on because I finished the last book of the extended universe and then it stopped and then that was the end for me. Well, and you loved the movies so much too, didn't you?
No, I just heard a beating on people. But yeah, so I mean, that was for me, it was the way of just being, and it was, we were just started it. I was going to do the edge of the Empire was what we're going to do. And that was completely like, that wasn't a wizard to the coast.
It was fancy flight games. And we thought about doing that. The system was weird. Didn't really like it.
You could crit, but you could like critically succeed, but you could also critically fail. But at the same time, you're still succeeding and failing at the same time in those situations. So we found this, Mike actually found this basically 5D conversion where someone completely converted community. Literally blew my mind.
And literally Star Wars 5th edition. Yeah. And there's so much content. And it's all free.
Yeah, and it's still going. It's insane. But I mean, when we actually got into that, it was so it's my, my desire to make that campaign and set it in the way that I did was I have this giant span from, and I'm going to mess it up and everyone who's a super star wars nerd compared to me is going to be like, it's not right. Well, there's somebody more super star wars nerd than you.
Probably. Yes. Okay. But it was, I think 50 ABY up to like 126 ABY.
There's a giant gap where no one knows what happens. And so in basically at the end, like there's, you know, there's other stuff, like basically these, you know, these factions or stuff from that, at that height I've been created, but there's a giant gap. And it's like, for me, it was like, I can do whatever I want. I get this, because all the main characters, like they've passed on at this, you know, late stage in the game.
And so I just thought like, hey, I really love all these characters. I want to give them their grand finale, but I also want to give them their grand finale with all of my friends that really enjoy Star Wars as well. We've done a great job at it, man. And one of the things that I was just thinking about when you're talking, you know, it's like you almost like when you homebrew anything, whether it be a campaign setting or you homebrewing a rule or whatever, I think the key is just you got to know why you're doing it, right?
And, you know, Cody had mentioned how Homebrew and some additional quest and Curse of Strad ended up taking them down sort of a distracting path, maybe, but you also homebrewed stuff that actually was really great for the main campaign. And then you're homebrewing all this stuff in Star Wars, but it's really coming from that love that you have of Star Wars and that depth of knowledge you have. And like Keenan and Mike, you guys have homebrewed full campaigns because that came out of your twisted imaginations and my love for Strad and Strad lore and Barovian lore, that helps supplement what I was doing from a homebrew perspective. And, you know, I think so to me, the key is like, you got to know why you're doing it.
And one of the things that we sort of all adopted in our games was this homebrew rule. Actually, I don't think we're necessarily doing it in every one of our campaigns. I refuse to do it. OK, it's fine.
But I just want to talk about it. Oh, I know we're talking about it. It's a check going over there. It's fine.
It doesn't matter. Hopefully it's not like going to drop a bomb on us. But anyway, so we have this homebrew rule when it comes to at least this over campaigns and it's about getting feedback. No, you're going to keep it.
OK, so we have this homebrew rule where if you're going, oh, God, no, if you make an ability check, but you don't have that skill, right? So you don't have an efficiency. Efficiency. So let's say I want to do a investigation check.
If I don't have that skill, then I roll at disadvantage, right? And not everybody even likes that or agrees with that. But the reason that I came up with it and some others have adopted it is because it does address that issue that you have with how the rules as they are written. Anyone can do anything, right?
And possibly roll a critical success. So I've been studying traps. So I'm really trying to get traps figured out in 5E and traps as they're written, in my opinion, are bad, right? Like they're bad.
And I think a lot of people agree with that. And I think it's why Wizards is now multiple times trying to fix traps, right? But one of the things they say in the actual players handbook about how to find traps is like, if it's a magic trap, then they literally says this in the book, any player can roll Arcana to try to find a magic trap, right? And I was just thinking to myself about Chud, the barbarian, how am I making the same thing?
And we're going through a dungeon and Chud goes, Chud looks for magic traps. And he rolls a 20 and he finds a room and he's like, here it is. And then you got, you know, we got a con the wizard next to me. And the next hallway, he goes, I look for a magic trap and he has an Arcana.
And he's got expertise in it. And he rolls a one. And he can't find it, right? Yeah.
So I think it's going to go. So what I was thinking about was a little bit kind of going back and we talked a lot about a lot about campaign home brewing. One of the things that I want to talk about maybe a little bit by home brewing specific rules, specific spells, things like that, maybe go through teach us and talk about the things we've done that in home brew has worked and stuff that has not worked, even though we thought it would work. But I want to start first with a question from Matt, because you are playing in that setup system with some of these, like, for instance, like with some of the Jedi and stuff that we thought or the set that we thought, have you just taken strictly just their powers out of the book?
Are you created some stuff for yourself too? I mean, really, whenever I mean, yeah, I'd say from my perspective, I'm looking at a monster, I'll look at the stats of a monster and I do it from the in the Star Wars campaign. I'll take a look at what, you know, there's other, there's users who have created like, saplots. I'll take a look at the stock block and I'll say, this is cool, but it's not going to fit what I want.
So I'll basically take that character. So, you know, for instance, you guys met Dengar and in the campaign, Dengar, there's like a legendary cybernetic bounty hunter is what the stat block was. And I was like, I was going to lame. I want to make him like a, like he's, this is like a bounty hunter that's been around for a long time.
We're talking Boba Fett level bounty hunter that can, you know, probably we don't know if Boba Fett or Dengar who would win? We don't know. You know, he probably has his own, you know, like I took that and said, okay, well, I'm going to give him these additional abilities. Now you guys never fought Dengar.
If you would have liked Dengar, you probably would have paid him a ridiculous amount of money to help us instead, which was the smart thing to do secretly. I was hoping they would fight him because I took all these abilities of, and I took stuff from the actual module that the person that created. And then I also took my own spin on things and I've done that with quite a few different characters. And I just, I like to make encounters like interesting.
I like to make them so like you have your different, and we all do this very well. You have your boss encounter there, you know, if you just have your boss encounter where you're just going in there, one person's at the front hit numb, someone shooting a bell at him, someone's casting magic spells and you're just hitting a hit pool. But if you have interesting mechanics where, you know, you have four different support, different bosses, and then as each boss dies, what, you know, the boss is getting additional attacks and additional attacks and additional attacks. And then you do the six.
Yeah. And now that one guy has six attacks and you because you've basically just changing counter. I don't know. I was a lot of rambling, but no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, there's really a homebrew enemies.
Yeah. Something I like to do with home brews is create, you said interesting comments reminded me of this is I like to make environmental stuff on my battlefields. So sometimes it's something simple, like boulders or crates that people can jump on top of and then, you know, use the high ground against the bad guys. Um, I had one where there was a chandelier.
They were in like a mansion. You're building and there's a chandelier and the chandelier was suspended using those little ropes that are tied to the walls. So one of the players wanted to get to the top floor and they did that movie, the thing where you cut the rope and then you swing up to the top floor. I got so fucking cool.
That's actually one of the things that I like to do for sure. Like I encourage you guys to do those kind of cinematic combat moments. I don't find bending some home rooms up stuff for that and bending some rules at that point because you're doing something so cool and so much fun to make combat so much more dynamic. Uh, can you like, can you think of any specific like kind of home brew things you've tried over the years that have, that has really worked and maybe something that haven't worked for you?
Um, yeah, I mean, the two home brew campaigns that I ran had firearms, which the official rules are awful for firearms. Um, so I made things like a lot of things were area of effect weapons, like machine gun, um, so I experimented with DC checks and a cone and stuff. Uh, and then that worked well. Um, because it shows the power.
It's a good area to nile device of people are trying to, if like they're trying to siege a building when they have two machine gun and placements, like that area is really well defended. And that forces the players to be creative on how to overcome it. So stuff like that, uh, all the monsters are always, I might pick something that someone had created or it's official and then I always modify it. Um, there's nothing really I don't ever stick my fingers in when it's part of it's because it's an entire home brew world slash campaign that I have to adapt things to, but it's particular rules.
I don't think you really don't have to do rulings. Yeah. Like I do a lot of like, okay, well, this is going to happen. Um, or like, oh, you want to do that?
Well, I'll mediate things like that. But nothing that I've nothing like John's, uh, proficiency rule of them, hard to fast that I've really implemented, not that I'm aware of. Yeah. So John, I'm kind of like, when you, what do you think as far as like any really homebrew kind of rules or spells or anything that you've kind of come up with over the years that you really love and maybe some things you're like, oh, man, I screwed that up.
I should never work. Well, I like my role about the skill checks. No, but that's one that's broken. I like it.
Um, but play with it. It's a good one. Matt Colville does Matt Colville will straight up say you can't roll that skill. Oh, that's well.
And, and you know, we have played it because Mike does it in dark. I'm in order to make it more difficult. Um, you always complain about it. But no, I don't.
What kind of vile DM would come up with such a role, but you should see the looks on your, you look on your face when you roll it, it doesn't manage your role. Like I do. Oh, I do. Oh, I do.
Sixes. Yeah, exactly. Um, but you know, a little confession. I don't think I've ever made a homebrew spell before.
I think every single spell I've ever had anyone cast any NPC cast in my campaigns has been from the book directly. Um, maybe something like Deep Magic, which is a homebrew supplement, right? The Coble press without, um, but, uh, wait, cobre press it. They're only.
Yeah. Yeah. And boss mechanics and I like those. Some of those have not, I guess where I've maybe failed is I have created homebrew monsters and bosses that I'm like, this is going to wipe the party.
And then like three rounds in, you guys just decimated the, you know, I'm like, well, I don't know how to make monsters. Talk about the ill situation. Yeah. I'll play.
Yeah. Yeah. So I feel kind of the same way, man. I do a lot of homebrew monsters, or even if I'm not doing homebrew monster, I'll take monsters, I'll add things to them.
And I think they should have to make it more challenging because if I just take it straight out of the book, you guys are going to walk over the top of this grab like in two rounds. So, and then of course, we both are both, um, hit point or hit, hit dipole bumpers. Like, we'll bump up the dice on these con, most of the standard monsters. Anyways, just because of the massive amount of action economy and all the action, all the damage that a party, you know, five or more can do.
Um, I have in the past, home brew, some spell stuff. It's been okay. I don't think it's been, I don't think I've ever made anything really spectacular. I think my favorite thing that I ever did home brewing was actually for segmentation.
And I created spell points and basically the spell points work pretty much identical to what they ended up with, with spell slots. But this was like for segmentation when there was nothing like that. I thought, you know, I just didn't like the way the wizards and the clairs were so limited to what they can do. Yeah.
And I, and so I created spell points, which is almost identical to spell slots. And now a day, so I'm like, Pat myself on the packer, head of that. But I've done some stuff in the past that definitely has not worked. Um, I think we've discovered that as we're playing dark kingdom because there's definitely a few things I kind of threw in there that would be cool.
And then ended up not really working very well. I think, um, I think I think definitely home brewing in some of the classes. Definitely made them super powerful, which is fine for the, for the dark kingdom, you know, I actually am very proud of the drew class because it works so well in the dark kingdom because there's no clairings. Yeah, I think you did a great job.
I mean, yeah, I would say they're a little overpowered, but I mean, you know, that's you when you're making a class, I mean, it's hard not to make it overpowered. I mean, when you're not actually play testing that class, you can't actually see everything on the table where, you know, I'm casting, you know, I remember what it was, a flame strike or, um, firestorm, casting firestorm, like a level, uh, five or whatever. So, yeah, but I mean, we won the war because of that. It's true.
I don't like it. I don't like it. Do you know, mass heal or was it heal? No, it was mass.
Yeah. Like level spell. Like, but that again, that was it. I was done.
I was out. Like, just kind of like, yeah, no, I didn't have candidates at all. Um, I had kind of what I had was these spell points or mana points that would allow me to cast certain spells that were kind of really high level spells. And then I had my remedies, which were things I had to make.
So like potions kind of thing, but let me cast spells and yet. Ritual magic, which you never got a chance to do too much ritual magic, which is not completely different than ritual magic in in five. This was very, uh, drew it specific stuff that you would do either. You'd have certain ritual spells you could do that were completely home brew by me, uh, to either be something you could do singularly.
Like I think you had the one where you could buff up someone's given to brain hit points and you do that by yourself. But most of the time you had to have another druid of your, of your circle. Yeah, I do at least two, three, four, there's some, some rituals which we never got around to because you never, she kind of got off on her own tangent story when I ended up being a queen of a country. So you never really ran into too many other of your own drew circles.
So, uh, you know, so go in talking about things that, um, homebrew systems, basically, which Star Wars five use a homebrew system really for that. So I'm going to give a shout out to Garrett Myers, who after listening to our last podcast and we were talking about feats and skills and we talked briefly about skills a little bit about how we really thought they weren't as good as they should be. And that feats were probably not what they thought they were going to be. And he sent me a PDF of a thing that kind of re that replaces feats and it lets you expand upon what your skills can do.
And it's called talent trees. Um, and I can you read that? Cause I can't read it on my copy here. It's a, it's by Reddit users, uh, you, I'm from NASA and then you set crayos 125 C R A I O S one to five.
Yeah. So I think these two red users, the ones who kind of got everything going and then at the end of the, at the end of the PDF, they do also mentioned some other people that contributed ideas. So this was a really true homebrew from the community, which is awesome. Cause I love this.
This is such a cool system. Right. Yeah, we're really excited to actually try it. So yeah, we're kind of learning about it a little bit.
Go ahead and talk a little bit on what we read so far and we're definitely, we're bringing this in. We're going to use it. So thanks again, Garrett. That was really awesome that you sent that to us.
So basically what they do is when you get a level up where you have an ability score improvement, you can, uh, sacrifice one of those or both of the ability score improvements. So you can bump your strength up by one. And then that other point, you can put it into a talent and the talents are divided into, uh, uh, skill talents and specialty talents. And the skill talents are basically like, you can take your acrobatics and then you put, uh, uh, the point into their, you already have acrobatics as a skill.
So then you get the handspring expert and handspring gives you a special thing where you get to, um, uh, standing at only cost you 10 feet of movement instead of a half movement, but then, and later levels or maybe in the same level, you can put a point in a handspring and then another, uh, talent point into, um, let's hear a freestride and freestride has another type of ability on there, which is your quick stride lets you carefully pick a path through rough terrain, your speed increases by 10 feet. When you take the dash action, difficult terrain costs you no extra movement. This turn is really cool. And it's like the entire thing just makes your skills much more dynamic and useful for things outside of just, I want to jump across this roof or I want to pick up this boulder or, uh, when I like investigate these footprints and it's like, we do more cool stuff.
And so, and it's called a talent tree. So when it is, you start off, you, you can actually even forego, you're not putting any, uh, points into ability score and just take two talent points and then, so you have more points to spend on your thing. So first you have to, first thing you have to do is you have to start the talent tree and that's the handspring expert. That's the top and each one of these has, for each skill has one of these at the top, which is the very first thing you take and you have path ap, ap, c path, or avs, or avs, that's like the second time I forgot, I'm alpha, but a b and c and then you, under each of one of those, you have two other things and then you get to the base of the tree, then it holds the whole tree up and that's the really super awesome thing.
So, and I just love that. I just think it's, you're right. It just makes things so dynamic and I actually have only briefly got a chance to kind of look at the, uh, the, um, what was the other one called special, especially trees and these are a little different. They don't necessarily have each specialty is a little different.
They don't necessarily have the same amount of things you can take. Uh, one thing I really like is they brought back weapon specialization, which is kind of a not to second edition. And I actually had a thing in a second edition that I did at home, I did weapons specialization too, but I opened it up to other classes. You could be a fighter, you could be a thief, you could be cleric, and you could take those weapons specializations and you get certain features for having taken specialization, spending a proficiency slot at whatever level you're spending on.
And then they did the same kind of thing here, but they have these, I think they have like, um, minor traits and then medium constraints in the middle and they got like higher traits and stuff too. Okay. There was one that I really enjoyed. It was, um, so 1.4 endurance and endurance just gives you extra dice at short rest when you want to recovery.
Yeah. It's cool. Yeah. It's nothing crazy strong.
It's like a breaking at all. Um, but I like the idea of this, you get a level up, you want to increase your strength. You have a 19 strength. You want to go to 20.
So you put one point into your strength score and you put the other point into this endurance ability. So now you can just recover better, right? And then a couple of levels later, you have another ability score improvement and you can put one point and you can get tough and tough is straight up just the feet out of the player's handbook. Right.
And when it getting that tough equals the exact same as a feat, you know, two points of ability score improvement, well, you just put two points into a talent. It equals the same. You get the tough feet. You also have the 19 strength or the 20 strength.
You also have this two extra hit dice of healing. It's not breaking the game at all. It just gives your player just a little bit extra uniqueness to it, more customization, which fifth edition horribly lacks. Right.
And I think that's one of the things is that they did keep some of the feats like, you know, alerts in there, obviously, because that's one of the coolest beach you can possibly get as far as I'm concerned. But what I do like is you're talking about being more dynamic, but it also helps you build your character, even if it's even it's outside your class a little bit, you might be able to do some kind of cool things that might seem to cross over because some of these skills are kind of very specific. But if you're like, one thing I could definitely tell like I haven't played a lot of rogues, but looking at kind of the options for acrobatics, deception, performance, and stealth and all that kind of stuff that they had, I'm like looking at stuff like going, my God, you can actually make a thief very, very fond to play by having a skills and it's mostly role playing kind of stuff, right? Stuff that's going to probably get you in trouble and speed.
But you know, it's cool too, because I think that, and we mentioned this in the previous cast, I forgot which one, but you know, when you first come to fifth edition, you know, one of the reasons they designed it as simply as they did is so that it would be accessible to new players. But if you're like us and you've been playing for several years now and you're very comfortable with the baseline mechanics, you know, again, this is where a supplement like this becomes really appealing because it adds some customizations, some extra layers of complexity to the game that aren't game breaking. And so I think that's why, you know, guys like us would be like, oh, this is really cool, or as a new person might go, well, that's just more stuff for me to have to learn and right now that. And I think when you read some of the introduction material in both the player's handbook, Dungeon Master Guide, some of the other books, Jeremy Crawford, whoever wrote it, you know, they say straight up like, hey, use this.
And if you want to do something different, do something different. I like they did the original, which that's cool. You read that I didn't know the original version of D&D literally starts out with them being like, Hey, we gave you the basics. Now you do whatever else you want with it.
And I think that for people who are new to the game that might be listening to this, like be comfortable branching into the areas you want to branch into and different things if you want to do different things and adapt it to your players. If you're playing with a group of new players, maybe keep it close to the book, right? But if you're dealing with some veteran people, you might say, Hey, I heard about this supplement or, you know, strange new worlds made this supplement. And you know, I want to use it in my campaign.
What do you guys think? And you know, you might find that more veteran players actually embrace these more complex or interesting kind of home brew type things. And I would also say on that on that on that behalf of actually, if you are even a beginning DM or more seasoned DM, if you're playing with new players, that's kind of the perfect time to maybe do some home proof too, because they're going to, they may be a little more receptive. Because sometimes I've been with the players that do get a little like, Oh, it's not this way.
It's not that way. It's not this way. And I'm like, dude, it's a home brew. And but they won't argue about it a little bit.
And I'm like, look, it's kind of cool. If you're not comfortable with that, cool, we'll take it off the table or, you know, if everybody else is comfortable with it, but one person isn't, then dude, you're going to have to adapt kind of thing. But maybe, you know, same thing, maybe that's a good time for the DM to really try some new stuff with new players just to get something to be more open to experimenting. So we are kind of getting towards the end of things.
So let's do a little wrap up here, kind of get everybody's final thoughts on home brew, whether it's campaign, whether it's rules, spells, classes, whatever. I mean, I thought, I mean, I really we've said everything I would have said. I mean, I think that homebrew is a general thing is just creating content that's not in the official materials. And that that is intentionally open.
It's intentionally, it's a wild west kind of situation, right? Different groups are going to do different things. I would challenge everybody to get out of your head, the idea of right and wrong when it comes to home brewing. There's no right.
There's no wrong. There's only what you and your players have kind of all agreed to be on board with except for if it's me, then I'm always right. Well, if you're the DM, you're right. Oh, yeah, of course.
It's good. I think as long as everyone's having fun, then, yeah, it doesn't really matter what you do. One thing that's cool about D&D is that there's kind of a limited meta to the game, you know, even things that are in the official rulebook, you can just remove those and completely changes the meta players who study the monster manual up and down, they know everything about everything. Monster in there.
Well, they don't know monsters from your world and maybe they have resistances or maybe they have extra limbs or some crazy stuff like that. And that's what's cool about D&D is that the meta is pretty limited compared to like the legends and stuff like that. Right. Yeah, I agree.
I would just say if you're a DM, try and do some homebrew. If you're a player, try and homebrew as well when you're in the campaign. Oh, yeah. I mean, just do homebrew.
I mean, when you think about it, D&D was a homebrew when it was created. Like it was a homebrew off of, you know, the two people made together and essentially was its own home. I mean, it's actual game, it's actually licensed, but it was a homebrew at the beginning. So don't feel ashamed if you try and homebrew the game.
Yeah. And then go back to what you were saying there, Matt. Yeah, as a player, definitely bring ideas to your DM. If you got an idea about something like, you know, about the way a feature or an ability, whatever, don't be shy.
Bring that, bring those to your DM. Actually, we did this in Dark Kingdom because it was kind of game testing, right? I created the Syndrome Cup, and we got together when we started playing again. And we got it out there and we learned that it was power in balances.
And especially like when we were talking about the Ranger. Yeah, Mike fucked up the Rangers just like everybody else did. But John and I think really we started talking about it and he started feeding me some ideas. I'm like, oh, that's a great idea.
We're talking about it. We actually kind of got kind of a cool Ranger out of the whole thing. Yeah. So and the final thing I would say is I think that the words of Gary Gaihkex were going to stick in my head with this when it comes to D&D, homebrew, role playing games in general, the only limits is your imagination.
Strange new world's production is going to take a moment and say, thank you to our driving tier patrons. Thank you so much to Doug, F Sutton, Nicole, Kirsten, Beth and Charles. We appreciate you and all of our patrons. Please visit us at snwproductions.com and see how you can support our work.