Skip to content
Lessons Learned from Rebel Wilson 'Outing' episode artwork

Jun 16, 2022 35 min

Lessons Learned from Rebel Wilson 'Outing'

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we discuss the criticism towards the Sydney Morning Herald for its reporting of Rebel Wilson’s new relationship. What lessons have been learned and are we witnessing a recalibration of public interest journalism? Monica Attard spoke with Hamish Macdonald, Journalist, Host of The Project and Sunday Project, and Eric Beecher, Chairman of Private Media and Solstice Media.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Lessons Learned from Rebel Wilson 'Outing'

0:00 35:43
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to For The State, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SCI in Sydney on the Gadigal Lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast, I'm Monica Atard. In recent days, the Sydney Morning Herald has been reeling from a huge backlash that it received when it tried to cover a story about Rebel Wilson's new girlfriend. The story was seen by many as an attempt to out the star.

This perception of the Sydney Morning Herald trying to outwil some was not helped by the journalist working on the story Andrew Hornery, saying his column was gazumped when Rebel Wilson took the matter into her own hands and published details of her own new relationship on her Instagram account. The backlash has been loud and fierce from sections of the media and the public alike, and if that wasn't bad enough for the Sydney Morning Herald, the story has now gone international with people like Mookey Goldberg, among others, joining the chorus of indignation. In this edition, we ask some serious questions about the editorial judgment behind this failed scoop and ask if we're seeing a recalibration of what is in the public interest in the Australian media. Joining us today to discuss all of this, we're lucky to have a heavyweight journalist and former SMH editor now turned media baron.

Eric Beecher is the proprietor which runs and operates Crikey and the Mandarin. He also runs Solstice Media, which runs the New Daily. He has also not just being the editor of the Sydney Morning Herald, but also the youngest person to be so. Eric Beecher, welcome to the program.

And Hamish McDonald is a man of many talents, host of the Project and a Sunday Project on Channel 10. He has extensive experience in both radio and television, including hosting ABC's Q&A and Radio National Breakfast. He's also worked for Al Jazeera and the ABC in America. Hamish, welcome to the program to you as well.

I want to pack a number of different aspects to this story, but Eric, I'll start with you as a former editor of the Sydney Morning Herald. Yesterday in Crikey, you and Peter Frey, another former editor, wrote strongly about this matter. You didn't hold back. You both say that this is not just the Sydney Morning Herald making a mistake here, but it's been caught moving into tabloid journalism.

What besides this story makes you say that? Look, you don't make a mistake like this, which is such an obvious, egregious mistake within the right kind of culture and under the right kind of ownership direction and within the right kind of editorial environment. It just can't happen, something like this. So that's what really concerns me and Peter.

And this has probably been coming for quite a while. The Herald and the Agent and the Financial Review, which is part of the Fairfax organization, and now owned by an entertainment company. They're probably 20% of that company's business. The rest of that company largely doesn't do journalism.

They do a little bit of it. And so the journalistic culture that prevailed before, and I don't want to just hark back for the good old days, it just can't happen like that in the right kind of culture. But can you understand if that is indeed happening, that a culture does change when businesses are trying to exist in such a tough business environment out there? Well, of course I understand.

I mean, I have many businesses of my own. I do understand that. But what we're talking about here are some of the last vestiges of serious quality journalism in a vigorously democratic country that's dominated by concentration of media ownership. And so it's pretty important, I think, for our democracy.

And I think this kind of discussion is really important because if the Herald and the Age are well down that path, and if the culture and the ownership and the board that supports that ownership support that kind of much more commercial culture, then I think it's really important that we at least talk about it and understand it. Is this the first indication then, the story in your mind of this shift that you're identifying? I don't think it is. I don't want to sound like a cynic or a critic about this.

Like I'm out of it, I've been out of it for a long time. I do my own media themes and people can kind of comment and criticise them. But it was interesting when I look at the stories that the Herald had written about this topic the other day, I went to the Herald's home page, which I don't normally look at. And I looked at that home page and I thought to myself that it didn't have the City Morning Herald mastered on it.

It could almost be any kind of tabloid newspaper home page in this country. Right. Well, that would have been worrying. Hamish, what do you think the City Morning that the Herald's reputation has been tarnished, cracked even?

I think that's very difficult to to, I think it's difficult to characterise it that way based on one story or one set of circumstances. I mean, I'm certainly not going to sit in judgment of other people's journalism or other news publications. I think broadly, the media has changed. I also think broadly, society and culture has changed.

And what is acceptable to talk about today is not the same as it was, you know, 10 years ago, 20 years ago, 30 years ago. And certainly, the way we talk about things today, the standards of acceptability have changed radically. I think even in a couple of years, I think the way that we talk about some of these things has changed. I think social media has done that.

I think also changing shifting societal norms around the way we not just think about, but talk about gender, identity, politics has shifted radically. And I do think all media organisations are constantly trying to adapt to that. And I suppose I see this more as an example of something, a type of journalism or a way of discussing an issue that probably has actually existed in different shapes and forms for a long time that maybe hasn't caught up with where society is today. I think for me, that's more what's happened here than anything specifically to do with the trajectory that a particular publication has gone on.

And when you talk about, you know, and you're catching up with society is today, I mean, this issue of outing has been out there for a very long time. It's been frowned upon for a very long time. Are you talking more about the way the public has a capacity now to weigh in on these issues via social media? Well, there is that, and it certainly does shape things.

But I also think Australia and the world has evolved. I think the way we talk about race and gender and sexuality has shifted radically. And like all industries, the media industry needs to clock that and reflect that back to society. I hope you don't mind me doing this, Monica, but I took the time to go back to your interview with Ian Thorpe, I think it was some decades ago now.

And I think you fairly pointedly asked him about rumors regarding his sexuality. Would you do that today? I don't think so. I wouldn't do that today to a young person that was so heavily in the public eye.

It certainly created headlines at the time. And I read some of your commentary at the time. You were incredibly sympathetic to this young man. And I'm sure knowing you as I do, you probably thought very deeply about it and tried to approach it relatively sensitively.

But I think today that would not be acceptable. And I think it's right that we've changed in that approach. So I don't think that's anything to do with you or the ABC at that time being tabloid or anything like that. So I guess I observed this slightly differently to Eric.

I don't necessarily see it in terms of the decline of a particular master or a desire to go after clicks. Those things may be true, but I don't know in this particular circumstance. But what I do know is that as a society, as a nation, we now apply very different standards and expectations to journalists and to the media in general in terms of how they should be probing, I suppose, into an individual's personal life, particularly when it comes to matters of sexuality and identity. Well, perhaps this is a question that relates only to celebrity journalism.

But how should journalists go about covering stories that they know about, that they hear about, that are actually out there in the public domain being talked about, but not specifically reported about within the kind of strictures of journalism in a way that doesn't breach a person's privacy and cause with the more days of the day. Eric, what do you think? But you're talking about celebrity journalism. I mean, I agree with pretty well everything that Hamies just said.

But I see these as two separate things. Where, to me, they kind of coexist is that if you have an editorial culture or a newsroom or journalistic culture that allows that kind of story to even surface for discussion, let alone be disused, let alone be published. And the editor and presumably other senior editors are involved in that. I think that that actually raises serious questions about the judgment that gets applied to all of these things.

So you asked the question about celebrity journalism. I mean, the typical reader of the Sydney Morning Herald over decades and presumably still now because it presents itself as a quality newspaper and journalism outlet. I would have thought those readers, most of those readers would have been completely horrified and jolted to see a story like that appear and to think about it, to the extent that they would have to think about it, that the process that goes into actually publishing a story like that or even contemplating publishing a story like that. So when you talk about gossip journalism, well, I think you have to kind of think about the context and you have to think about the audience.

And the audience isn't just one audience across the whole country or the whole world. Do you think that that story could have gone to print without the upper echelons of editorial management knowing? If it did, if that's possible, then I think it tells us a lot about how they think about their role as journalist and editors. It just seems incomprehensible to me, as Peter and I wrote in our piece, in a newsroom culture of what's called quality journalism, whatever you want to call it, or just a high degree of professionalism.

The idea of a story like that in their surface, let alone publishing. Can I just jump in on that? I think it's probably a little more, I've agreed to participate in this conversation on the basis of having a constructive conversation about what the lessons are. And I think the framing for that very much is that the Sydney Morning Herald itself and the journalist involved has said that there are lessons and that they will be learned.

And I do think some of these things have been in flux for some time. I'll give you an example. I've been very interested over the past couple of years to observe the journey that Grace's team has been on with the nation in a conversation about her experiences. And I have learned and taken a lot from her commentary around the desire for journalists to probe individuals for stories or for experiences that may actually be very traumatic and detrimental to them.

And I think the conclusion that I've reached is that there's a very basic and fundamental thing that you can do when you're going down that path and it certainly shaped my approach, not necessarily to stories about sexuality or identity as such, but where I know that the interview or the story may go into territory that is personal, that may be uncomfortable, may involve trauma, may involve things that one as a journalist shouldn't assume that the individual, the subject, is comfortable talking about, is simply to ask them beforehand. We all prepare for an interview. We all have a conversation with the person before we put them on air or before we, if you're just a print journalist, turn the tape recorder on or just go ahead and write the story. I think it's very easy in a circumstance like that too.

And I make sure and I don't, I've actually moved beyond just relying on, for example, the producer to tell me, look, we've spoken to this person, they're happy to go into this personal stuff, it's a very strong story and I want to talk about it. I now actually take that further step, if it is an interview like that, to say to the person to take a moment before we start and say, look, I understand that you've indicated you do want to talk about these matters. I just want to understand where you're out with this and I want you to know that if we do strain the territory that you're not comfortable with, that you're free to let me know at any point. And if you want to discuss it now is the time to do it so that we can both go into this, you know, with a clear mutual understanding of what's going to be discussed.

I think people's stories of trauma, people's stories about their, you know, their journey around their own identity are very sensitive things. And I think actually, as journalists, it's not too difficult to up our own game. We can all improve all the time. And so I guess the conversation I'm interested in having, if there is a conversation to be had now, it's how do we establish those new norms and practices and make sure that if stories are told like this, that it's done in a way that isn't shaming, that isn't creating a novelty out of sexuality, that is moving beyond some of those traditional, I suppose, stereotypical views of of sexuality, as was the case.

And I want to come to that point, Hamish, but can I ask you though, given what you've just said, isn't that in a sense what happened in this case, or be it in a testy and inappropriate email, which sounded threatening, which sounded as though it was lying down a threat that Rebel Wilson would be out in. But isn't it the case that the journalist in point here did reach out and say, we want to discuss this with you? I mean, I will be very clear. I'm not going to go on the attack around individuals' journalistic practices.

But I think he has published the details of what he puts in his email to her. And I think people can make their own judgments about the inclusion of a deadline and what that would have meant to the individual involved. I think if you were Rebel Wilson or her team, there would have only been one reading of that. So can I just add there?

I mean, I think what Hamish just said when he was talking about people talking in a very candid way about their trauma and identity and that kind of thing, and asking them and reaffirming that they've given permission, I agree with that 100%. I think there's a really big difference here. The Rebel Wilson story is just about salaciousness. It's just about sensationalism.

It wasn't about her talking about her trauma or her identity. It was just a celebrity story. I also wanted to talk to you both a little bit about whether some of the public reaction to this is in part because it has been so ferocious. There's some aspect of it that is about the public adversely reacting to seeing how journalism has actually done, how the sausage is made, if you like.

That when there was the initial reaction, bad reaction to the original story, the original column. But then there's also been very, very significant negative reaction to the pieces that are followed it to from the editor one from the reporter. And I wonder whether people are saying, well, if that is how journalism is done, we're not comfortable with that. Eric?

I agree. But I think if you buy sausages and you don't get sick, then you don't ask how they make. But when you buy sausages and you get really sick and defend you, then you start to ask how they make it. I think that's 100% legitimate.

I think what do you think? I would observe that there's been a fair amount of candor from the publication around what they did and why. And that's to be encouraged. But certainly, I think, the way that stories come about and the time that is taken from journalists at times, I think there's probably a reason that we all collectively as a profession have the reputation that we have in the end, it's up to each individual to try and act with as much integrity as they can.

I'm sure there's probably been times in my career where politicians or business leaders have felt that they were pushed and shoved a bit and tried to get an interview or to try and get an answer. I guess there's probably times where I reflect on things and think, I probably pushed a bit hard myself. I think, all I can say is it's important to try and maintain some humility and try and self-reflect as much as possible and see, I always work hard to try and look for instances where I could have done things differently or better. And I probably do spend a fair amount of time considering what I've gotten right and what I've gotten wrong, what I can improve on.

I think that's healthy to do as a journalist. And maybe that's one of the other lessons out of this that you don't always have to be right. If you did get something wrong, it's worth thinking about. I think sometimes the criticism from the public, particularly around social media, thank God I'm not on it anymore.

I think that criticism from social media can be pretty overwhelming. And it is a skill, I think it's a discipline in fact, to be able to identify within the scope of the criticism that exists what the salient points are, what's useful, what's constructive, what is worth taking away to help you improve and be a better journalist and what should be disregarded. And working on the ABC, there is no shortage of criticism, whether it be in the newspapers, whether it be on text lines or through social media or emails to you directly. You are constantly receiving critical feedback of your work.

And I suppose, maybe I'll land somewhere different. I think there are people that ignore it all and it's just water off a duck's back. That's not me. That's not how I can function.

And so for me, certainly in recent years, particularly when I was doing Q&A, it became about how do I make a process out of this? How do I take all of this feedback and get some constructive out of it that hopefully makes me better? It can be really vicious out there. How do you find the same level of public critique of your work on tent?

Or is it an AUS? Look, I can't really give a clear answer to that because I have left social media altogether. So I don't have any connection with that world. And I think as a journalist, I wasn't really wasn't sure about closing down those profiles because it had mostly, or for most of my career, particularly as a foreign correspondent, felt like a very positive tool of my trade.

And I built a large audience there, which I could report to directly if I was in Ukraine or Iraq or wherever. And I had always found it to be more good than bad. That changed for me when I was at Q&A and at the ABC full time. So certainly, there's less of that, but I'm not on the platforms.

But you're not immune from it at 10. It's just a very particular, I suppose, scrutiny that comes with being at the ABC. And I certainly find it easier to manage now. And to be fair, I think I work in an environment where I think there is, I think maybe the commercial world is a little more adept.

I think actually, in terms of the management of commercial media, I think maybe it's a little more advanced in it's thinking about how to manage this stuff. Then perhaps what public broadcasters, I'm not critical of the ABC at all, but just, I think, because of the public ownership, there's almost a sense sometimes that, well, you're the public broadcaster, you just need to lie back and couple of years. Okay, well, let's circle back to this story at hand though, and the issue of public interest. Eric, I'm curious to hear from you whether you think there's some contemporary formulation of the public interest informed by the principles of accountability, the public's right to know, that can be applied to celebrity journalism?

Or is it as Hamish has just articulated that the new benchmark is basically having open, transparent conversations with the people about who you intend to report or write? Well, I agree with that, but that's the theory, and then it depends on the individual journalist to whether that's not fair to see it. It's interesting when you use the words public interest. So we have this phrase public interest journalism, which is actually now enacted in legislation, the Google Facebook legislation, and has been in previous legislation, and has a definition in that, quite a long definition in that legislation.

And I think most people, when they think about it, understand what public interest journalism broadly is. But then you have another phrase, which uses the same words in different order, which is journalism that the public is interested in. And they get to kind of swept along together in ways that it suits certain organizations and so on. So I remember about two or three years ago, the ACCC, the Rod Sims held a kind of forum where they were looking at the Google Facebook issue and some of these issues.

And the theme of it was public interest journalism and the impact that the Google Facebook's advertising revenues is having on public interest journalism funding it. And there was a lot of discussion and there were media people and academics and whatever there. And we were all on the same page broadly, but towards the end, the senior representative, very senior manager from News Corp got up in front of the 30 or 40 people and basically said, we don't agree with this phrase public interest journalism. We produce journalism with public interest in it.

And there is just a stark difference. So okay, so the rebel Wilson story that falls outside of the current acceptor definitions of public interest journalism. Yeah, it's like I assume like a shooter because I thought public would be interested. And what about the second, can I ask you both what about the story of Barnaby Joyce's relationship with the CAMPION?

Was that was that in the public interest publishing that story? Hamish? I've had a lot of conversations with Barnaby about this. I mean, clearly the argument that he's made right is that the CAMPION was a staffer and on top of that Barnaby Joyce had been one of the most vociferous campaigners against same-sex marriage in Australia based on family values.

So there was a broader context. It came about the paparazzi photographers following a pregnant young pregnant woman around the streets of Canberra when she wasn't at work. I think that's where it starts to get into far more nuanced territory. I personally find having a paparazzi photographer following you or appear out of nowhere quite a frightening experience.

And so I would find it difficult to defend that practice generally. But in terms of the substance of the story, very clearly as the public configure that he was, there was a level of public interest in it. But I think where you went to the Grey Zone is the how and the where and the where. And how does she because you've had your own brush with this kind of journalism, haven't you?

Do you mean photographers or photographers and prying journalists? Yeah, I have and I mentioned it briefly on the project the other day. I don't want to sort of you know do a big sob story or turn this into something about me. But I have been on the end of some of that.

I'm a gay man. I've never particularly tried to make a huge secret of it, but I've never really I never really was of the view that it was something that I needed to make a big statement about publicly or make a big song and dance it out. But I've had some experiences with journalists. So I got quite some time ago, I might add, you know indicating to me that this was something that they knew about.

And to me at the time it felt fairly threatening the way that they spoke to me about it. And it was a pretty scary experience in the sense that it felt beyond your ability to have any control or agency around the way your own very deeply personal story might be told. And so in that sense I feel the degree of understanding about this. And I suppose that probably does frame the way I come at this.

Because ultimately these things are deeply personal, but for every individual day a difference. And some people may feel that they want to talk about it publicly from the get-go that's great for them. Others may not. It may be a very long journey for some people.

And I think no matter who you are, it really should be up to you the circumstances in which you do talk about that in the public domain. Okay. Final question to you both. Do you agree that we're this week with the kind of recalibration of public interest journalism?

And are we as Peter Fray said on Radio National Breakfast also witnessing the death of celebrity journalism? Eric? I don't think we're witnessing the death of celebrity journalism. I hope we're seeing some kind of recalibration particularly at the Herald and outlets like that, where the standards are different.

I really hope that that's what we're seeing. Can you talk to what you think? I'm optimistic actually, because I have seen how much the world has changed, how much our society has changed on these matters. I just would offer a very simple personal reflection.

There was a lot of hurt and upset that I understand for many people around the same sex marriage plebiscite in Australia. But I come from a very small, regional community in New South Wales, which I always thought to be a deeply conservative bush community. And when that plebiscite happened and the vote was yes, they released all of the information about how individual communities voted and overwhelmingly my home community voted yes to same sex marriage. And I understood myself differently because of that.

And I feel proud to come from that community, to being myself in that community, to go back to that community with my partner. We went home to that community and got engaged last year there, because it's so special to me. And I was so proud to share that day and that moment with our neighbors and have a bonfire down the back of the house. I think we can change.

I think we do change. I think the world changes. And I think journalism can do that just like everyone else. And I hope that this is an opportunity for us as a profession, as an industry, to just make some subtle changes.

We don't need to get our niggas in and not too much about individuals or publications. I think we can always adapt and we will. Well, we might leave it on that very, very hopeful note. Well, I'd like to thank you both for a fascinating and forthright discussion.

Eric Beecher and Hamish McDonald. Thank you for being on Fourth Estate. Thanks for having me. Thank you.

Thank you. And thanks for listening to the programme. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation.

Thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast, so that you can hear us talk media, politics and of course everything in between. We're back with more next week, but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle there is Fourth Estate AU.

Thanks to my producer, Marlene Even and my executive producer, Anthony.org. I'm Monica Atard. Thank you for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 35 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on June 16, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.