Skip to content
Lindsay Clancy: What Does the 911 Call Actually Prove? episode artwork

Sep 10, 2026 19 min

Lindsay Clancy: What Does the 911 Call Actually Prove?

from MAMA RAE PODCAST Hosted by Hosted by Mama Rae

Jurors who heard Patrick Clancy’s 911 call have described his reaction after discovering his children as horrifying, visceral and unforgettable. But an emotional reaction—even an extraordinarily powerful one—is not the same thing as forensic evidence. So I went back to the testimony with a very specific question: What does the 911 recording actually corroborate? Patrick testified that after finding Lindsay outside their home, she told him, “I tried to kill myself.” He also testified that when he asked where their children were, Lindsay told him, “They’re in the basement.” Those statements have become an important part of the public narrative surrounding this case. But were they actually captured on the 911 recording? In this episode, we separate Patrick’s sworn recollection from what witnesses and experts said could actually be heard on the recording. We examine reporting from journalists who heard the restricted 911 call in court, Patrick’s testimony about difficulties connecting with 911, and an especially important exchange involving prosecution expert Dr. Gregory Saathoff—who listened to the recording and testified about what he could and could not hear Lindsay saying. We also examine something I’ve seen repeatedly since jurors began speaking publicly: Patrick sounded genuinely horrified—so does that prove he couldn’t possibly have known what happened beforehand? Psychologically, no. Human emotional responses cannot reliably establish prior knowledge. But that works both ways: Patrick’s reaction also isn’t evidence that he did know. Possibility is not proof. And an inconsistency—or an inability to independently corroborate someone’s recollection—doesn’t automatically establish deception. That’s why this episode is not an accusation against Patrick Clancy. I have found no evidence establishing that Patrick participated in the deaths of his children, and he has not been charged with doing so. Instead, we’re asking a narrower evidentiary question: What was testified to? What was recorded? What can be independently corroborated? And where does the evidence simply require us to say, “We don’t know”? We also revisit why describing Lindsay as having “confessed to Patrick” may oversimplify what the evidence actually establishes. Investigative journalism isn’t about finding the most suspicious explanation. It isn’t about finding the most comforting explanation either. It’s about following the evidence—and having the discipline to stop where the evidence stops. Cora. Dawson. Callan. They remain at the center of this case. Disclaimer: This episode discusses publicly reported testimony and evidence from the Lindsay Clancy criminal proceedings and contains commentary and analysis. Disputed or uncorroborated claims are identified as such. Nothing in this episode should be interpreted as an accusation of criminal conduct against a person who has not been charged. #LindsayClancy #MamaRaePodcast #CourtCase #InvestigativeJournalism #TrueCrime

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Lindsay Clancy: What Does the 911 Call Actually Prove?

0:00 19:46

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of MAMA RAE PODCAST?

This episode is 19 minutes long.

When was this MAMA RAE PODCAST episode published?

This episode was published on September 10, 2026.

Can I download this MAMA RAE PODCAST episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.