Skip to content
Live Event: An Evening with Donald Hoffman episode artwork

Apr 17, 2026 1 hr 25 min

Live Event: An Evening with Donald Hoffman

from The Daily Vedantic Hosted by James Beshara

Reserve your spot and sign up now to be part of this engaging Friday conversation: ⁠https://forms.gle/QaRSWndLbyvKeF1j8 In this episode, host James is joined by Donald Hoffman, a renowned cognitive scientist and professor known for his groundbreaking work on consciousness and the nature of reality. With over four decades of research, Hoffman challenges one of the most fundamental assumptions in science that we perceive reality as it truly is. The conversation explores Hoffman’s controversial yet mathematically grounded claim that the probability of humans perceiving objective reality is zero, based on evolutionary game theory. He contrasts the dominant physicalist view where space, time, and matter are fundamental with his own framework, which proposes that consciousness is the true foundation of reality, and what we perceive is merely a simplified interface or virtual reality system. Hoffman shares insights into his team’s cutting-edge work developing a mathematical model of consciousness capable of reconstructing space-time itself. The discussion also touches on neuroscience, quantum physics, evolutionary biology, and ancient philosophical ideas, drawing parallels between modern science and long-standing perspectives about illusion and perception. This episode is a deep and thought-provoking exploration of perception, existence, and the possibility that everything we experience is a constructed interface, not reality itself. Takeaways The probability that humans perceive objective reality is mathematically zero Evolution optimizes for survival, not truth Physicalism assumes matter is fundamental, but that assumption may be incorrect Consciousness may be the true foundation of reality What we perceive functions like a simplified interface or virtual system Neuroscience shows correlations, not proof that the brain creates consciousness The brain may be a projection rather than the source of experience Physics suggests space-time is not fundamental and breaks down at small scales Mathematical structures outside space-time may better describe reality Consciousness may be unified and expressed through many perspectives Each individual can be viewed as an interface or avatar of consciousness Scientific progress may require reversing core assumptions about reality Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Live Event Context 02:30 Who Is Donald Hoffman 04:30 The Problem with Physicalism 06:50 Why Consciousness Might Be Fundamental 09:15 The VR Headset Model of Reality 11:30 Consciousness vs Brain Activity 14:00 Building Space Time from Consciousness 16:00 Infinite Perspectives of Consciousness 18:30 Rendering Reality in Real Time 23:15 The Evolutionary Argument Against Reality 27:30 Physics Breaking Down Space Time 32:30 Reverse Engineering Reality 36:30 The Brain as a Projection 40:50 Scientific Resistance and Paradigm Shifts 43:20 Proof That Reality Is Not Real 49:50 Limits of Scientific Theories 54:40 Space Time as a Headset 57:00 Ancient Philosophy Meets Modern Science 59:15 The Trace Institute and Future Research 01:01:30 Q and A Begins Consciousness and Birth 01:03:50 Unity of Consciousness

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Live Event: An Evening with Donald Hoffman

0:00 1:25:03
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey everyone, today's episode is a special one because it's a live conversation with Dr. Donald Hoffman who is lighting the internet on fire right now. It was recorded at one of our in-person events here in LA. We host these events every few weeks bringing together an awesome community who wants to explore big questions around philosophy, science, consciousness, reality, and how we experience the world.

This conversation is a deep dive into the work he's been doing for the last four years. He and his team are likely gonna win a Nobel Prize here in the next few years, by the way. And over the last four years, especially the last six to seven years on the scientific approach to what are we perceiving in this world, in this universe, and is it reality? Their math seems to suggest that the chances that we are perceiving reality is zero percent, zero percent chance that what we are seeing, perceiving, touching, tasting, smelling, feeling, the chances that it is reality, that is what's really happening.

Their math seems to suggest, as I said, there's a zero percent chance that it is what's really going on. As wild as that sounds, there are so many other aspects within their work in the last few years that's the reason that he is lighting, like I said, lighting the internet on fire right now with perhaps the coolest podcast guest across a lot of the top 10 podcasts that people consume because this work is up there with Copernicus. It basically is saying Socrates may have been right with the allegory of the cave. People convinced that the shadows on the wall are real, are reality, and, well, the allegory of the cave lays it out quite bluntly.

Maybe something else is happening, even though we're so certain what we are seeing is reality. So without further delay, let's jump into this awesome live conversation with Dr. Donald Hoffman on the Daily Vedantic, the fun live conversations we get to record every few weeks here in LA. If you want to join one, shoot us a DM on our Instagram, and we can add you to the email list.

This was a packed house. Each one seems to be more and more packed with standing room only, so we might have to get a bigger venue, but if you get on the list, then you get the first chance to join in on these live events. So with all of that out of the way, let's jump into this conversation with Dr. Donald Hoffman.

Welcome, everyone. So fun to see this many faces on a Friday night for a topic that is near and dear to me, but it's my wife is here. She knows that I will bore people like crazy at dinner when I start just diving into this topic. So it's really fun to see a community of like-minded people that also want to dive into this topic, especially when we get to do it with Don.

Come on up, Don. Go for it. Grab a seat. And then we are delighted to get to have this conversation with you, Don, and I'll give a little bit of an intro and background on Don, and then we're going to chat for about 45 minutes, just us, and then open it up for Q&A with you all, and that's one of the most special aspects of a live event like this is it's not just something to listen to and listen to someone else interview Don.

And also, if you have any burning questions on this work, whether it's coming to this talk or on anything that we touch on in the next 45 minutes, feel free to raise your hand. We've got a microphone for you. Dr. Donald Hoffman is at the forefront of consciousness studies in a way that no scientist has really attacked before, and that is through mathematics, through rigorous scientific study around reality.

I can talk about consciousness, but really it's deeper than just consciousness. It's in his colleagues, which we have a few of them here as well, so if any physics questions come up, you guys might get the microphone and have to answer as well. But this topic, I will go so far as to say I have a feeling Don and his colleagues are going to win a Nobel Prize in the next few years, if sometimes it takes 20. But I think one of the things that we have a chance to do tonight is hear from someone that is not only lighting up the Internet with his podcast conversations around this topic, but also can explain it so beautifully simply for a little simple Texas brain like myself and make this topic not only go to the way deep end of the pool in the science, but also in the shallow end to explain why this work is so fascinating.

Not just important, but fascinating for us tonight, and at least I'll speak for myself. For me, we have chatted and known each other for a few years, and every six months or so, you seem to come up with some new piece of information that relights up the Internet, and especially in the last year or so, you've been a crowd favorite on some of my favorite podcasts and, well, some of the top podcasts around the world, so some of the most popular podcasts around this topic. And as a cognitive scientist, I'd love to kick it off by asking you how you describe, in your own words, the work that you do. So most of my colleagues who are studying consciousness academically start with space-time and particles in space-time as fundamental.

So they're physicalists, and their goal is to try to understand how physical systems that are not conscious to begin with could somehow get the right kind of complexity to have consciousness emerge. And I would say that 99% of my good friends and colleagues who are studying this work are studying the problem of consciousness are physicalists. And so that's the dominant paradigm. So the question is, is this some kind of integrated information, orchestrated collapse of quantum microtubules?

There are all sorts of different kinds of physical mechanisms that could possibly be the magic that turns unconscious matter into conscious experience. And that's what I would say 99% of my colleagues are trying to do. So that's where the game is being played right now. The question is, so what aspect of brain activity, for example, or what functional properties of the brain or physical systems more generally, or what functional properties of an artificial intelligence would be the magic that turns unconscious circuits and software into the consciousness that experiences the taste of mint, the smell of garlic, and so forth.

So that's where most of the work is being done. And the work that we're doing is the opposite direction. We're saying two things. First, they haven't succeeded.

If you ask these approaches to give you a specific conscious experience that they can explain, like orchestrated collapse of quantum states of microtubules of Penrose and Hemeroff, or integrated information theory, the right kinds of causal structures. If you ask the proponents of these theories, okay, great, you have a theory of consciousness that's mathematically precise, so what specific conscious experience does your theory explain? Like the taste of mint or the smell of garlic? Or what can you give us?

And the answer is zero. Today, and this is an astonishing thing, these are brilliant scientists, because there are many of them my friends, my colleagues, they're absolutely brilliant. So it's not that they're dumb, they're really working hard and they're really brilliant. There's not a single specific conscious experience that any physical theory can explain, none.

So that's quite stunning because usually science makes some kind of progress. Now we have made some progress, of course, in measuring neural correlates of consciousness in the brain, so lots of progress there. We can find areas of the brain whose activity is correlated with conscious experiences. And that's good work and I'm glad that we're doing it.

But going from the actual mathematical model of the neural network, for example, and saying this kind of mathematical activity in the neural network must be the taste of mint or it must be the taste of chocolate for principal reasons, there's literally nothing on the table, nothing on the table at all. So, and yet that obviously flies in the face of 10 out of 10 people walking down the street, they're like, well, obviously. And even the term physicalist, for those unfamiliar, which is, most of us take it so for granted that physical matter is real, space and time is fundamental, that it doesn't even come up in conversation. Therefore, you don't really need a term like physicalist because, well, everybody is a physicalist.

And it was fun and new for me to hear you use that term and probably by the fifth time you'd use that term, I realized, oh, that's someone that believes that matter is real and I'm only 30, 40 minutes into this conversation and with, I think it was maybe Andre or Tom, there's some of the great podcasters that Don has been on their podcast for here tonight and it probably took me about four or five times of you saying physicalist and being like, oh, that's everybody. Everybody basically believes that matter is real, obviously, because we're touching it. And you and your colleagues are saying, well, we need a name for that viewpoint because just because 99.9999% of humans have it, it might not be correct. And it's the way you're just talking right now when you've spoken about this before, the thing that comes to mind is like seeing light come from the moon, you and all of your friends see light coming from the moon, everybody and your neighbor is, well, yeah, of course, we got the sun, yeah, but the moon too.

And then science comes along and says, actually, shit, there isn't any light in the moon. Even though it's quote unquote lighting the night sky up, there is no light inherent in the moon, it's coming from somewhere else. And physicalists would be in this metaphor saying, well, it's not even worth studying, obviously light is coming from the moon. And you and your colleagues are saying, actually, is this real?

And space-time, which we think is fundamental and matter comes from it, if I'm recasting it correctly, you're saying, actually, there's something below that and space-time is a function of that. So by that, I mean conscious experiences, like the taste of garlic, the smell of mint, the sense of pressure on your hands, and so forth. These are all conscious experiences and that is the fundamental nature of reality, at least more fundamental than space and time. And so, now, I just complained about the physicalists not giving us conscious experiences, right?

They can't start with physical stuff and give us conscious experiences. So turnabout is fair play. If I'm going to start with conscious experiences, then what do I give you? So what we have to give you is physics.

We have to show how we start with consciousness and we can build space and time and physical objects as a headset. So the idea would be that consciousness is fundamental but it can look at itself through different kinds of VR headsets and space time is just a particular kind of VR headset that we're using to look at other consciousnesses. So it's all consciousness and the illusion that there's physical stuff is just an illusion because our headset is not showing us all the reality. It's dumbing it down.

That's what headsets do. They dumb things down. They make it easier. Interfaces dumb things down and make it easier for you.

So we have the illusion that we're dealing with unconscious, like this floor doesn't look conscious. It looks inanimate to me. But that doesn't mean I'm interacting with something that's inanimate or unconscious. It just means that my headset gave up.

My headset is trying to dumb things down and make it simple so that I can interact and deal with things. And so of course at some point it's not going to reveal the conscious nature of what I'm interacting with. So what we're proposing then is that space time itself and all the objects that you see inside space time are nothing but a VR headset that consciousness is using to interact with other consciousnesses or to interact with itself. In a non-dualist kind of framework you would say interacting with itself.

And so now that kind of idea, the non-dual spiritual kind of idea has been around for thousands of years. So now the question for them is to say, look, all the science that we have, all the technology that we have has come from the physicalist framework. All the mathematical sciences, the microphones, everything we have, the lights, this has come from physical science. And so surely the burden of proof is on someone who says that physics is not fundamental, that consciousness is fundamental.

We have to show that we can do something here. And spiritual traditions have been around for thousands of years and they don't give us technology. So you can see where the physicalists are coming from. They're saying, show us the beef.

What can you do with your stuff? We can build all this technology. Is that an Arby's callback? I should have guessed that we were going to be using an Arby's tagline.

And so what we have to do is we haven't come forward in terms of the spiritual traditions with some mathematical model of the spiritual ideas that could compete with the rigor and mathematical technology that we get from physics. So the question is, why haven't we been able to do that and can we switch this thing around? And so what I'm doing with my colleague, Cheyton Prakash, who's a mathematician here and Charpon Chattopatier, who's a particle physicist at CERN and Fermilab and UC Berkeley, we're turning the thing around. We're saying, we'll start with a mathematical model of consciousness.

And we do have a mathematical model of consciousness. So it's absolutely precise. And in Q&A, if you want to go into the details, we can go into some of the details of the math. But the key thing we're really working on now is how do we build space-time?

And what do we have on that? And we had a breakthrough in the last year and a half, two years on the mathematics. We've discovered a logic of these consciousnesses that we call the trace logic. And this trace logic is the thing that we're seeing as the bridge that can lead us to actually build space-time, like Minkowski's space of Einstein, from a theory of consciousness.

And what we see as we're starting to do this is that our space-time perception is just one headset of an infinite variety of headsets that we could, in principle, construct. And it's actually one of the simpler ones. So we have this mathematical model of consciousness and we ask, what are the kinds of physicalist headsets that we could build to sort of simplify what we're seeing? Then ours is one of the simplest ones.

From this point of view, we're not sort of the top of nature. We're sort of, we have one of the dumber headsets that's available. And the mathematics that we're developing shows how we could, in principle, conceive of far more complicated headsets. And so the idea here, then, is simply this.

Our goal is to reverse-engineer space-time. Space-time is just a VR headset. It's not the reality. So you can see how big a difference this is.

There's the physicalist which says, look, this is space and time and physical logics. That's the fundamental reality. Consciousness is a late-conner. That's what 99% of my colleagues think.

What I'm saying is the opposite. You've got that completely wrong. Consciousness itself is fundamental. And space-time is a trivial headset that consciousness is using to interact with itself.

And there are much more interesting headsets. And the reason why the physicalists haven't been able to give us a single conscious experience is because experiences do not arise from physical stuff. From our brains. It's not, they don't have little connections and then boom, you have a conscious experience.

Even though that is obviously the models that are talked about, the language that we use today. Absolutely. So now I'm a cognitive neuroscientist and I've done fMRI studies and EEG studies on the brain and so forth. And I'm all for that.

I love to look at the brain and correlations of brain activity with conscious experiences. We should do that. But the interpretation that the brain activity is causing the conscious experiences, again, that's the standard interpretation that my colleagues give. And for me as a hardened scientist, my attitude is, again, until you can actually give me a specific conscious experience that you can explain, there's nothing on the table.

If I came to you and said, you know, I've got a new theory of particle physics. And you say, oh, really? Okay, you've got a new theory of particle physics. Oh, so what can you explain?

Like gluon-gluan interactions or photon-electron interactions? I go, oh, no, I can't explain any specific conscious experience. I just can, oh, sorry, that's not very interesting. You'll come back when you can actually explain a specific particle interaction.

And that's where we are with consciousness. The physicalist frameworks have a lot of math, they have a lot of neuroscience, and not a single specific experience that they can explain. A lot of consensus. Well, actually, a lot of finger-pointing now.

Some of them are calling each other pseudoscientists and so forth recently. Calling each other. Yes, yeah. Not you.

No, okay. Well, that one goes without saying. Yes, yeah, exactly. I was going to say it.

You have taken heat for decades and you've been working in this field. And I want to talk about your background, your arc in three parts. One, going back 30, 40 years ago when you decided to study in this area code and how you even had the antenna to know there was or to feel like there was something in this area and then go through decades of not to oversimplify, to be kind of laughed at it like there's, what is that I'm working on? And then about seven, eight years ago to start to make significant headway in the mathematics of what isn't there, which was its own powerful foundation or contribution from your work that I want to talk about here in a sec.

And now moving in the last, like you touched on the last year or two, but perhaps maybe the last three or four years. on what is there which um taking something away uh what we're perceiving and we'll touch on that and then also now proposing what what is that which is just a fascinating unfolding of this this arc um before we do that just to recast what you're saying uh there in the same way that um and we chat about this in terms of the dream example which is an ancient vedantic uh example that's that's given for vr headsets where thing where you get 10 out of 10 people on the street you tell them um consciousness seems to have come first at least with your work proposing seems to come first and the material comes from that and um if they're following they would say no no the universe like we kind of know this 14 billion years old and the last two billion years life has come about and single celled and multi-celled are complex organisms and then at some point time just switches on and consciousness exists that's kind of the consciousness comes from physical matter and again like we were saying it's 99.99 percent of of the viewpoint and what you and your team are proposing it's it's more perhaps like the dream where the vr heads that we're in the dream where you'd say if someone said that none of this is real the the walls of the ground these chairs and there's something much more fundamental that you're participating in um beneath this creating all this matter um you'd say that's that's kind of ridiculous um because it feels so real and then the dream example is a perfect one every single night everyone in this room world creators manifesting an entire world with rooms and walls and people and shoes and gravity but you and you wake up and you don't need someone to convince you it's almost so obvious that no one would even take the time ticket to convince you that consciousness of your dream was fundamental in all of that matter every shimmer on every wave every leaf and every tree and your dream was you was your consciousness creating it am i recasting yes yes so yeah your dreams are a good example how you can create entire worlds out of nothing just in your sleep so it shows you in principle that you could do this and what we're saying is that in fact everything that you perceive you're actually creating it on the fly so so to be very very clear um for example i'm a neuroscientist and and i very much like neuroscience but i will say and we should study neuroscience but i would say that neurons exist when you perceive them and they don't exist when they're not perceived you render them if you think about it again vr metaphor when you're using a vr headset i'm looking over here and now i'm rendering a ferrari that i'm racing again so i render it but as soon as i move over here i don't i'm not seeing a ferrari and it's not being rendered that ferrari doesn't exist and there's nothing where i'm interacting this metaphor with a supercomputer but there's nothing there's no red ferrari in the supercomputer so i'm creating that red ferrari and so what i'm saying is that everything that you see you're rendering it on the fly that's how good you are and then you're then you're deleting it so you're rendering deleting rendering deleting freely all the time now we're getting into the crazy shit yeah that's right right which i'm glad we're able to get into that uh within the first so um and again this is so friggin wild right for anybody took a flyer and was like i'm gonna come in on right i didn't hear all this for the first time um some of these points i might reiterate because uh you heard it correctly but you might have been like i don't know if i heard that correctly that what you just said was uh if you close your eyes right now everything in this room no longer exists for you or doesn't exist at all consciousness always exists but your rendering of consciousness into this room doesn't exist until you until you render it so consciousness is always there but you're turning consciousness into this little step with the seat or this the floor is something that happens by by your action of watching so when you look you render consciousness that way as a headset so but as soon as you look away then consciousness is always what it is whatever it is but you're not rendering that particular thing so we you know the question of the island is the moon there when you don't look and the answer why we give is no the moon is there when you render it and it's not there when you when you don't look and the question then you know there's one thing to say this you know it's been said for thousands of years in spiritual traditions it's another thing to now say we want to do science that shows this exactly so we actually show that we can start with a mathematical model of consciousness and show exactly how no hand wave we can get minkowski space iceland's curved space times excuse me we get time so how we can get curved space time get um quantum theory our goal sorry the big bang in other words one reason why scientists have not taken spiritual traditions seriously is because there's no points on the board where's your theory of the big bang we have all this data how do you explain the big bang can't do it come back when you have something to say all this theory of quantum mechanics can't explain it come back when you have a mathematical theory in other words yeah interestingly enough the quantum many of the quantum theorists is just like um yeah schrodinger schrodinger's dog is named ottman so many of them many of them love the non-dual philosophies yet uh similar to you it's like ah something in a text isn't quite enough isn't satisfying for them just pursuing it with uh with mathematics that's right that's a hard-nosed attitude of scientists right we want a mathematically precise theory that you can go test and show whether it works or not and so far there's just nothing on the board so spiritual traditions i think have the right ideas but they haven't turned them into mathematics that would be deeper give us a deeper understanding than space-time physics and quantum mechanics and that's the goal i think that space-time is not fundamental it's a fairly trivial headset that we construct and quantum mechanics as well and by the way i should say that one thing that makes me a little bit bolder on this is that high energy theoretical physicists are now saying the same thing they're saying that space-time is doomed that it cannot be fundamental so i'm talking about neemar khani hamed david gross what is their view how do they articulate a similar view well their argument from a physicalist point of view is to say that when you look at when you bring quantum mechanics and general relativity together it turns out that when you try to look at things that are smaller and smaller and smaller in space-time you need to use smaller and smaller wavelengths of light or radiation and that's fine you can always resolve smaller and smaller but then quantum mechanics tells us that by doing that you're using more and more energy so you're putting more and more energy into a smaller and smaller region of space and then einstein tells us that well when you do that mass and energy are the same thing so you're actually putting more mass and you're curving space and at some point you curve space so much that you create black hole and so space-time makes no sense has no operational meaning at 10 to the minus 33 centimeters and 10 to the minus 43 seconds the so-called plank scale so space-time is a wonderful user interface like we're playing and the user interface pixelates away into nothing at the plank scale and so the european research council just in the last two years has a multi-million i think 10 million or a hundred i forgot lots of millions of euros on what they call positive geometries and there are a hundred plus physicists and mathematicians now that are saying okay we're no longer going to assume space-time and quantum mechanics are fundamental we're looking for these new structures they call positive geometries amplituhedron associahedron cosmological polytopes outside of space-time now they're still physicalists but they're so they're not you know they're not saying consciousness is fundamental but they're saying that quantum mechanics um and special relativity general relativity cannot be fundamental there's got to be some deeper structure that doesn't care about quantum theory and and space-time and they're finding these structures so they're actually finding them and so our goal is to say that last part again the amplituhedron would be an example of a structure that exists outside of space-time yes right so the amplituhedron the associahedra the cosmological polytopes that they're finding are are these geometric structures think of them like diamonds but really high-dimensional complicated and their their volumes and their facet structure actually encode in remarkable ways scattering probabilities if you like the large hydron clatter you send a bunch of protons smashing into each other at high rates and all these particles go spraying out and you want to predict what you're going to see these geometries positive geometries outside of space-time actually that you compute that remarkably and much much more quickly than if you do it inside space-time so by letting go of space-time you're you're getting something deeper that you're missing by sticking with space-time you're finding some deeper symmetries of nature outside of space-time and i know when i talk about this some people say i have no idea what you could possibly mean outside of space-time space-time is everything what do you mean about something outside of space-time and so what i'm saying is this is just a headset what most of us think is all reality is simply a headset and when you die you take it off and you realize that there's all sorts of other headsets that you could use and this is actually not one of the highest it's one of the more trivial headsets so what we're up to is saying if this is a headset we should be able to write down mathematics and that shows how the headset is built from consciousness so we have to have a mathematical model of consciousness show exactly how we get einstein's theory of general and special relativity how we get quantum theory exactly and in so doing what we're doing is getting the first layer of software outside the headset that's what we're really up to we want to find the first layer of software outside of the space-time headset now my motive is just simply as a scientist i want to understand this you know i want to just just words don't say but the technology that can come out of this is quite obvious if you if you're a wizard in some vr game and you can know grand theft auto or something like that you can drive the car faster than anybody and do all the tricks that's that's great but if you know the software and if you wrote the software for grand theft auto then you can do magic in the game that the wizard could not understand and that's what we're really like a spaceship that can travel to andromeda instantaneously because you work from a completely different framework that's right then all right bigger rocket need a lot of fuel and a hundred billion light years and then you'll get there if you can get outside the system and see as you said in other conversations in papers getting the source code of this experience then everything is at your fingertips and one additional point correct me where i might be wrong on this um you were talking about the dimensionality of the amplitude so in the experience of our universe and uh and um this plane we're on right now we got four dimensions um timing that fourth dimension and something that you and i chatted about is the amplitude um we don't know exactly how many dimensions it has but uh would anyone like to take a guess uh how many dimensions this structure outside of space-time that has mathematically been found it hasn't been like touched or perceived but the math points to it take a guess if this is four dimensions um feel free to offer a number ah not a colleague yeah go for it could be infinite yeah that's that's great um and 12 great and i think it's uh we don't know the exact number but it's trillions am i right well well infinity is is right i mean as far as we know the mathematics that we're evolving of course we can't build that in our own little computers that we're working on we have finite memory but the mathematics says there's no limit so the number of conscious experiences is unlimited so and just and underscore again so four dimensions here and a structure that it's only been the last 15 years or so that they've discovered the amplitude is that right yeah in 2013 so um something outside of space-time that has infinite number of dimensions um i would have guessed 12 15 that would have blown my mind and then i remember saying this years ago i was like we don't know how many but it seems to suggest uh north of 13 trillion or something so basically now maybe it's just infinite infinity and so what this then allows us to do as you were saying is we can do magic effectively if we know how the headset is built i'm sorry it's space time keeps ringing just to let you know hey don't forget about me nice try nice try timer so so if you actually know the source code for the headset um you could take the wizard's car and give it a flat tire you could take the wizard's car and move it from one part of the game immediately to somewhere else and it would just be magical or you can move it at mach 40 or you can make time slowdown or you can make answer anything you want because you know the code and so that's the idea so there is a little danger here if we're right if consciousness is fundamental and space time is just a headset and we go about reverse engineering it then then that does lead to technologies that are completely mind-blowing but it's going to be hard work um so i'm not too worried about it happening anytime soon um but the idea would be that if we what chetan and shapon and i and our colleagues are doing right now is we have these precise mathematical proposals about how to build space time and quantum theory from from consciousness and once we once we have those theorems proven that's what that's our first goal is to prove these theorems and publish them that then says this is a scientifically feasible project that doesn't yet mean that we have the software it means that we've proven that um it's very likely that this is a profitable approach and we should go after the software to get the software then we have to do we have to reverse engineer our headset so how do we know how our headset is being built right that's the question how do you understand and reverse engineer this headset now this is where neuroscience will be very really critical most of my colleagues are studying the brain because they think somehow brain activity creates conscious experiences so we need to understand the neural correlates of conscious experiences that's all good stuff but the brain does not create conscious experiences it's just the opposite here's the different way of thinking of neuroscience and i'm going to say it slow because it's a mind bender the brain is the headset representation of how the headset is engineered that's going to take a while to wrap your head the brain is your headset representation of how the headset itself is engineered what that means is that neuroscience is far more complicated than we thought there are 86 billion neurons trillions of synapses it's very complicated we thought we have to understand all that and then somehow we would figure out how consciousness emerges and what i'm saying is as complicated as that looks the brain is a trivial projection into our space-time headset of the engineering that goes into making our headset so that's what complex is the brain seems to us which is the most complex object in the universe that we know that's right and you're saying it's trivial compared to the complexity of what's actually generating that's right that's right it's a it's a projection so there's really some complicated construction process going on and that complicated process all we can see of that process is what we can see for our headset and that's the brain and so the brain as complicated as it looks is trivial compared to what's going on beyond it that's projecting into the brain so what neuroscience has to do now is we have to we haven't actually started the real problem of neuroscience the real problem of neuroscience is to reverse engineer neurons to reverse engineer the circuitry so right now my colleagues are trying to think about how does the circuitry or properties of neural activity create consciousness and right now they have zero successes in terms of specific conscious experiences zero and i but they know when i get on stage with them in front of scientific audiences i'll say so you know steward hammer off so how many specific conscious experiences can your orchestrated collapse of quantum microstates the quantum tubules microstates and he'll have to say zero and with christophe ko i'll get out there with great information burn burn yeah that's right so and i do it on purpose and then we'll go have a beer afterwards and be friendly it's all very friendly but hey science is science until you have something on the table you don't have anything on the table so i always take it to them but they have the same response back so don you got this theory of consciousness so how much space time can you explain well nothing will come back when you have something to explain so that's absolutely the hard nose attitude that we should have so so our goal that's some pretty cool papers coming out in 2026 that moves that puck forward so it's for for time we'll open up for q and a here in a second but so i didn't get to each topic that i wanted to cover with you but highly encourage anybody to drive home after this uh this weekend to listen to the episodes that you've done with some great podcasters like i said some over here um andre and uh and know thyself podcast and impact theory with uh tom as well um so the um and by the way shout out to tom he said in an episode one time in his podcast he said uh uh that you own a t-shirt that's uh the matrix was a documentary is that right that's so beautiful for what we're talking about um if you're hearing all the science and and words that might sound unfamiliar to you what is being said is maybe this experience is directionally closer directionally closer to the matrix then right all right there's eight billion of us walking around and i'm the culmination of a bunch of uh a bunch of biology that has presented this is reality and i'm a tiny little speck within it maybe something much much more complex and much more fascinating is happening the um but one of the last things i want to ask about it by the way you mentioned you know you touched on einstein and even einstein establishing a space and time one continuum that was a hundred years ago and yet we still walk around like no space in time 10 out of 10 people on the street of venice would say well space is different there's space and then there's time so these kinds of scientific discoveries they get made you might win a nobel prize and still a hundred years later doesn't make it into the cultural consciousness yet um maybe i won't use that word it doesn't make it into the cultural lexicon or how we view the world um but it doesn't make it any less accurate just because it's so freaking different that it's like uh the sun being at the center of our solar system you could discover that you could get burned at the stake by saying it and tell 100 people in a village 500 years ago and all 100 everybody like no there's no way i see the sun moving and it doesn't change their practical lives until uh it does until the science does catch up until we actually do start building out maps that follow stars in a very different way and navigate the world in a very different way than we did 500 500 600 years ago with the previous model so the uh the question that i wanted to touch on with you is um some of your your important foundational work that got you um a lot of notoriety you and your colleagues a lot of notoriety six seven years ago was on this probability that we are perceiving reality and this is kind of like the the beginning of you taking away what we think reality is and then over the subsequent six seven years since then now presenting every six months something new on what reality is but as you're taking reality away and really put you on that um ted talk and and like i said lighting that in the fire the last few years you might touching on that similar work on what we're perceiving and the chances that uh the percentage chance that what we're perceiving is real right so this is a slightly different topic but they're related and most of my colleagues of course believe in evolution by natural selection and i think within our space-time headset that is the best theory we have about biological evolution so within our headset the theory works very very well but most of my colleagues would say that evolution has shaped us to see reality as it is i see the moon that's because the moon really looks like that i see an apple that's because there really is an apple there and i realized in early 2000 that that evolution probably wouldn't do that that it would probably and steven pinker by the way at mit now harvard um was saying similar things he was saying that evolution is really shaping organisms to um to stay alive have the perception you need to stay alive and that's very different from saying that you're being shaped to see the truth and so i decided to look into that you know steve and our friends and he got me interested in this aspect of evolution but i realized that it might go even a step deeper that you know there may be a very very low probability that we see anything truly if evolution if we take evolution seriously so it turns out there's something called evolutionary game theory the mathematics of evolution and i started to learn with some of my grad students and we came up with some some simulations that seemed to show that yeah the probability seemed to be very very low that we would be shaped to see reality as it is by evolution and then i worked with chayton chayton's a mathematician and he took it to the next level and proved it so we had done enough work to to say this is really interesting maybe there's a theorem here and chayton proved and the idea is this that evolution shapes organisms to do whatever they need to do to perceive whatever they need to perceive to stay alive that's that's what darwin tells us so you know fitness is about having kids so perceptions that enhance your fitness what that means is they enhance the chance that you have kids and it turns out that um you don't need to know the truth so there's a funny example of the jewel beetle so this is a classic example there's this beetle that's dimpled glossy and brown the males fly the females are flightless the males fly around looking for females and if a male finds an eligible female he'll alight and mate but in australia where some of these beetles live there are these um beer bottles and some guys in australia would throw these beer bottles out into the outback and they're also dimpled glossy and just the right shade of brown to excite the males and so these males would fly around and they would swarm these beer bottles and try to mate and even with full body contact with the bottles they couldn't figure out that this was not a real female so this is all sorts of interesting fun stuff there but so there's all these males forsaking the females for the bottle um and swarming all over trying to mate and they actually had to be careful because the species could have gone extinct so so here we have the the jewel beetles had been around for hundreds of thousands of years the males had successfully made it just one little change in the niche throw out some beer bottles and all of a sudden the whole thing falls apart and species could go extinct so that's how much insight males have into the females and but but more more generally it's how much insight our perceptual systems have about the nature of reality and so what i realized was that in i realized it conceptually and and then chayton proved it mathematically the probability is precisely zero that evolution would shape any of our sensory systems to see any aspect of objective reality precisely zero so that's saying that's again right right that's a lot what is the probability that according to now again i'm just being a scientist now i'm saying evolutionary theory of our perceptions according to that theory what's the probability that what you perceive is the truth and the answer is the probability is precisely zero exactly zero not seven percent not no that's right three percent but zero percent zero percent according to math and it's not you guys uh in a cabin philosophizing right this is just from the structure of evolutionary game theory itself you're saying yeah do you want to add right right so so so in the limit as your perceptual systems have more and more resolution right the probability goes closer and closer to zero is a little bit more technical way to say put it this way don't bet your life on it i bet my life that you don't see reality as it is basically on evolutionary theory now now again i'm not doing that to dis to dis evolutionary theory within the biological organism framework space-time framework there's nothing that competes with evolutionary theory it it works and i've used it in consulting and so forth it really really works so the theory i think is a great theory but it's tied inside of space-time so it is assumed space-time are fundamental and but it also predicts the demise of space-time as being fundamental because if you think about it we're using evolutionary theory to show that the probability zero that objects inside space-time which is what we see is the nature of reality now philosophers several philosophers have published in philosophical journals rebuttals of my work on this because they'll say look you've just refuted yourself you've shot yourself in the foot you started up with evolutionary theory which assumes organisms competing for resources in space and time and then you show that darwin's theory says that we don't see reality as it is therefore we have no reason to believe in space and time organisms competing for resources so you've shot yourself in the foot right and a lot of them actually there have been philosophers in major journals who've published this and they're missing a very very fundamental thing about science science has theories and every scientific theory starts with assumptions and the theory says if you grant me these assumptions then i will explain all this wonderful stuff but you have to grant the assumptions no theory explains its assumptions it assumes them so there is no scientific theory of everything now you can often then get a deeper theory so i have a theory that makes certain assumptions i might get a deeper theory that explains those assumptions but my new theory will have its own assumptions so so no theory is a theory of everything so science can never give you a theory of everything in fact if you think about the logic i just gave you we will always be infinitely away infinitely away from a theory of everything in science so there's good reason to be modest about our scientific theories but what we can do and what we can do with these scientific theories is say if you grant me these assumptions then i will give you tools i can explain certain things there is a scope to this theory there is a non-trivial scope all the technology we have here you know from maxwell's equations and you know physics theories they do have a very important scope and they give us this technology but a really excellent theory will not only give you the tools to describe its scope and explore its scope it will also tell you its limits and so for example einstein's theory of gravity together with quantum mechanics they both assume space time is fundamental and they they give us the tools to explore space time but then they also tell us space time cannot be fundamental it stops at the plank scale 10 to the minus 33 centimeters 10 to the minus 43 seconds the very notion of space time is no longer even coherent so here are best theories which assume space time and our theories about space time tell us themselves without shooting themselves in the foot no one thinks that einstein and quantum theory are shooting themselves in the foot logically they're telling us something very valuable the very notion of space time itself falls apart at the plank scale and so all i'm doing is the same thing with with darwin's theory of evolution with evolutionary game theory darwin's theory says i'm assuming that there are organisms in space and time that are competing for resources and trying to maintain and reproduce and that has a great scope it's there is no better theory in science to explain all sorts of biological phenomena than darwin's it's fabulous and i've used it successfully with companies to help them with consulting and so forth it really it really is practical but that same theory is so deep with evolutionary game theory it's so precise that it also tells you that its very foundational concepts cannot be the truth so evolutionary game theory with jayton's theorem from it basically says the foundational concepts of evolution are not fundamental but we knew that from the beginning because every scientific theories starts with assumptions and no assumption can be the fundamental truth the um yeah and to underscore that that proposal this is if there's three chapters of the book the first uh chapter so to speak is outlining okay physicalists uh the world thinks the world is this way the universe is reality we should not say is in this structural uh form and that space and time are fundamental second chapter of the book being what you just said in that foundational work that's that's so mind-blowing that it's worth underscoring a third time of the mathematical uh proof that what we are seeing is zero percent not just like a what you're seeing is a low resolution version like oh you're seeing three percent there's so much more happening you know dark matter dark energy no it's not that it's it's way more extreme it's not a low resolution version and it's not oh you have a one percent or a you're perceiving right now as reality the second chapter of the book is taking away everything you're perceiving as uh as reality or fundamental reality completely that it's not a low resolution version and it's not a point one percent you at least this mathematical work is saying the chances that you are perceiving reality right now as you're listening to this in your ears and viewing uh this stage the chances you're seeing reality what's really going at zero percent so i can really summarize what both of these theories are saying about space time quantum theory and general relativity together are telling us that space time cannot be fundamental and they tell us precisely where it falls apart 10 to the minus 33 centimeters 10 to the minus 43 seconds it cannot be fundamental i'm saying evolutionary theory is telling us the same thing that on its own premises evolutionary theory is telling us the probability that the space and time that we see is any reflection of reality as it is is zero so our deepest most successful theories agree space time is a wonderful framework so it's a wonderful headset is the headset that we have but it's just a headset and our we've gotten to the point we thought we were describing reality when we discovered physics and so forth we thought we were describing reality as it is what science has been doing for the last four or five hundred years is exploring our headset and we've just now been discovering that oh this is just a headset we thought it was the reality it's just a headset and so now the european you know union has now got this big positive geometry effort and there's lots of efforts going on in physics to go outside of space time and there are hundreds of brilliant researchers now outside of space time looking for what's the next step and we're finding these positive geometries so it's over for space time it's not fundamental you had a good run you had a good run that's right the uh yeah and his third chapter being what what is there and discovering uh perceiving um certainly uh all of the attempts to measure what is there after this kind of this being taken away as fundamental um and that's the work that you'll do and a big uh maybe the biggest part of 2026 for y'all's work is the trace institute the institute that you're launching it uh maybe guess what i can talk about here for a few seconds as well um but it's you know this sounds so and you're we're in the bleeding edge of january 2026 this sounds and it is the bleeding edge of science it sounds like it is so novel so crazy so out there uh when you when it really hits you tomorrow or six months from now what's being said um but this is the this also matches the oldest ideas we have had in humanity of the oldest philosophical texts the vedas and the this concept of this is like an elevated version of a dream this is not reality they perhaps didn't have the science the math all of the tools that we have today but there were these certain individuals speaking from experience from the tops of every mountain they could get on saying this isn't it you have socrates perhaps the most famous philosophical concept in the west is the the allegory of the cave which we've all heard a thousand times by the time we're 30 we forget how fucking nuts what he's saying what the most famous philosophical concept in the west is proposing which maps so beautifully to the philosophy of the east and the uponishats a couple thousand years before that so beautifully to what you and your team are proposing but the allegory of the cave being these are shadows on the wall we are convinced this is reality and and every first friday we have philosophy friday in this very room and uh where we discuss um and one of the things we're discussing um and in uh in december was that one of the most interesting things about the the socratic allegory of the cave is and perhaps this idea uh through the mouthpiece of socrates but that everybody's convinced this is reality the shadows on the wall this is uh reality and the one person that is able to go up and ascend and see quote-unquote reality is so blinded by it then reorients and this is like the sages throughout history that have said this isn't it comes back down and tries to tell everyone and what i would i'd never it probably didn't hit me until i was like 35 because you hear that story when you're like eighth grade ninth grade and uh you're numb to it by the time you can really think about it but one of the most interesting parts of the allegory is that when that person comes down and tries to tell everybody that this is a reality they aren't like what it's not a glass of water in the desert they're like show us where it is they want to kill him it's so foreign that they actually want to kill the guy so let's update your uh security detail uh don because people will not take this uh lightly um okay with that we're gonna open it up for open for q a from folks and i think there might be a microphone right behind you you might be sitting it might be in the back of your chair that we can uh right here don maybe right behind you oh and um actually kick it off since i touched on the trace institute yes part uh who works with don you want to spend i'm interested just talking about um 2026 big announcement that if you follow don's work over the next few years you'll hear a lot about what they're establishing right now yeah um thank you uh james and thank you for having us because you're really the organizer and host all of us so thanks so much uh i guess yes a few a group of early supporters of don and people really passionate by this research don japan and chapan um are building an institute to support the research advance the research uh to make sure that the novel prize happens next year and in 20 years as you pointed out james we just want to make sure so you know we want to take sort of like if it happens after you guys die i'll find you in that other realm and deliver it to you right so yeah i mean the the idea is to get as many as much resources and talent to support research um and so we're working very closely with uh with and to organize uh these with the urgency almost like an intro entrepreneurial way, a way to accelerate and support the research as much as possible. We call it the Trace Institute. It's a reference to the trace logic, but also the idea that the reality that we perceive is only the trace of a much bigger, like maybe a two-dimensional mark of what is much greater and much more complex behind, right?

So, yeah, I'm going to be, of course, around if you have any questions, and if you think there's any way you want to support this initiative, well, we'll be super happy to talk. Well, I will tell you, from the Magic Mind perspective, Magic Mind, we're going to give a five-figure donation to the way we exist for magical minds, like you all, and so we would be happy to, as I just came across the Institute recently as you were talking about it, happy to make sure Magic Mind support you all with a donation for that. So, thank you for that, Gaspar. Any other, and by the way, find Gaspar or the colleagues or Don right after this.

We also budgeted time for mingling if people want to come up, but yeah, if you'd like to get in touch, we'll send it out to some info on the Trace Institute. If you have ideas, you've got your own podcast that you'd like Don to come on to or you just want to chat with them, please feel free to reach out through the details we'll send after this event. Yeah, any questions? See, right there, right behind you, Gaspar.

Hello, thank you so much. That was wonderful. Question about birth. So, would you argue that when a baby is born, their headset doesn't come on until we project our own consciousness onto them and our own belief, and so they're essentially higher consciousness that's getting dumbed down into our reality because of our perceptions and are basically bringing them into this world that we're in right now?

Right. So, that's a great question. So, the idea would be that each one of us is an avatar that consciousness is using to look at itself. So, your body is just an avatar.

And so, the birth then would be, we're seeing the actual formation of a new avatar through which, or a new headset through which the one consciousness is coming into this world. And it comes in, it's very interesting, it's very humble in a way, right? We come here, we're completely helpless, we can't feed ourselves if our parents didn't do anything, we'd just die. And so, it's very, very interesting that consciousness comes in and you might ask why.

What's it all about? And I think that, first thing, I'll say it's very, very deep, I don't know the answer, so I'll just say that. But here's some thoughts. There's, as Rumi said, the language of God is silent, it's all else is poor translation, right?

Ultimately, anything you say is going to be woefully inadequate, but we're here to talk, so I'll talk. But I first wanted to sort of note that I think the reality transcends even science, almost, infinitely. But given that we're going to talk, then Galileo said the language, the book of nature is written in the language of mathematics, and so I think the more precise that we're going to talk, the more precise we can be, the better off we will be, the less dogmatic, and the more we'll be able to refute ourselves. So, the idea then would be that, I think that consciousness, what consciousness transcends any particular headset.

And yet, there's an infinite number of different headsets that it could use to look at itself. It's so infinite that there's an infinite number of perspectives that it can choose to look at itself, and that's what it's doing. Somehow, and now I'm way out of my pay grade, but it seems like consciousness somehow to know itself needs to know itself from an infinite number of different perspectives, as an aphid, as a nematode, as a human being, as a cat, as all these different infinite number of creatures we can see, almost large number of creatures we see on Earth, and who knows elsewhere. I think we can't think big enough.

There's an infinite number of potential different headsets in different ways that we can. So, that's my guess about birth, is that it's just an instance of consciousness choosing to look at itself from a particular perspective for 80, 90 years, and it's learned what it wants to learn about itself from that perspective. It was great, and it drops that avatar and moves on. One of the things that you also talk about in your work, and if we have three hours, then we'd be able to get to all these tough points, but that proposal from your side is that consciousness appears in an independent form in each of us, but it is really just a reflection of a collective consciousness, a single consciousness.

And, again, this is so not only contrary to what we kind of perceive in our daily lives, but also just as wildly in tune with Christ's prayer of the Last Supper. 26 verses, and five of those verses are, I pray for, his own apostles to recognize their oneness. It comes up again and again, and yet the math that you hope you're doing is starting to scratch at these things. Yeah, and I'll just say that we haven't gotten into the technical stuff about the trace logic, but I'll just say the trace logic is the logic of that.

It's the logic of the unity and diversity all in one. It's taking the idea that there is one, and yet there's an infinite number of perspectives, and it's putting that into a mathematical framework. And it's when we only discovered that framework about 18 months ago. We've been working on it.

Shaken and I published a book in 1989. We've been working on this for a long time. So it was only 18 months ago that we made this breakthrough, and it is the breakthrough that sort of gives us the math that gets at what you're talking about. How could there be, in some sense, one, and yet all these infinite number of variations of it?

And so when we look at that mathematics that we realized that we were immediately seeing as we went to different traces at different scales, we were getting different time scales and different distances. And that's when we realized we might be able to get Einstein's special theory of relativity out of this thing. And that's our first goal to actually show that when you just take the idea that you're talking about, that we're all one, and yet there's all these different traces of the one, that actually gives you Einstein's relativity that different observers can have different times and different lengths as what we see as different velocities. And that falls, I claim, straight out of the trace logic.

And that's going to be one of the first terms we want to prove, just to show if we get Einstein's theory from this oneness, a mathematical model of the oneness, and showing that we're all projections, traces of this one. You hit ayahuasca, and you can kind of, you might corroborate, you might make a larger donation than that one. Oh, yeah, right over here on this side of the room. Yeah, right there.

First of all, whoa. Amazing. And James is unbelievable facilitating here. Thank you, James.

Easy to be fascinated by this stuff. So much. I've been the beneficiary of some psychedelic experiences, therapeutic experiences, and I, myself, am learning to facilitate. You describe headset as one way to view our existence now.

And in these psychedelic experiences, I've seen and had my own experiences where I felt like I put on my own headset. Have you used and are you able to come up with the mathematics behind psychedelic experience? I'm writing a paper with James Gellimore on this very topic. I'm sorry, Andrew.

Andrew Gellimore. Andrew Gellimore. Andrew Gellimore and I are writing a paper on this right now. He just gave me a draft.

So we're exploring how we might be able to actually, at top level, model DMT kinds of experiences using this kind of thing. So if you might spell out for people that might be unfamiliar why there seems to be even that TIA that was kind of quite cosmic, because I was joking, and then this question comes. Why there is even that, those universities colliding around psychedelic experiences in this work. Right, so what Andrew and the people he's been working with have discovered is that they go into new realms that seem even more real than this.

They're higher resolution, sharper, and more dimensions. And they've had mathematicians who are trained mathematicians go into these DMT trips, and they will be able to describe seeing geometries you cannot see in 3D space. So one hypothesis is that, so DMT, and by the way, this is all initial work, so this is a lot of work to do, but these are the ideas. DMT is endogenous.

Your body has it right now. So what you're doing is just increasing an endogenous chemical disorder, sort of like serotonin. In the work that we're doing right now, we already have a first draft of a proof for how to build Minkowski space. We're not ready to publish, but we're still working on it, but already we have a draft of a proof for how to build Minkowski space from the trace logic.

And one of the parameters in there is the D, which is the dimension of the space time. So for our space time, D is 3. But you can easily imagine just moving D up 4, 5, and the same mathematics goes through. So when we prove, when we publish this theorem, it will be not just our space time, it will be an infinite set of space times, and ours is just at the bottom of the room.

We're number 3, but there's 10, there's 5 billion, there's 50 billion. So we're going to be very interested to, so Andrew had been looking for a mathematical framework for years to explain the DMP stuff, and so we connected, and he realized this is the framework that he's been looking for. So that's why we're now collaborating with some neuroscientists as well to try to put this through. So the idea will be that we can now start to explore other headsets and get constraints on how headsets are constructed.

So if D is a parameter, does DMT itself switch D up and down, three dimensions, five dimensions, five? So you can see our goal as hard-nosed scientists is to use this to give us the clues to reverse engineer. I said we have to reverse engineer the brain. Neuroscience is, you know, the brain is the headset representation of how the headset is engineered.

This is the first step of the reverse engineering. What is DMT doing in the brain? The brain only exists when you perceive it. The brain has no causal power, but it's the only clue we have to the realm beyond.

So we have to look at DMT in the circuits of the brain and then ask, what does that project from outside? What outside structure of consciousness in the trace logic would project to that? So that's the kind of work that we're doing. So the answer, long answer, yes, we're working on that, and there's a lot to do there.

If I could just follow up on that. I'm sorry. Please. So from this one, I don't know what I did anymore, he's one of the most prominent researchers in psychedelics, and especially in DMT, but that was confidential.

In the case of your identity, we're going to try to keep that, you know. That's why you come listen to Don and not Gaspar, because Don will give you the goods. It's very prominent and very famous. So what happens also, you know, that's part of the work of the institutes, is that there are, you know, areas in which we find incredible, like, convergence.

These, you know, scientific reports in many ways, are showing incredible convergence with Don's work. And as far as I can go back to the time, there are some papers that we find where the descriptions are incredibly similar to Don's research and research of its findings. So that's one of the directions of the research of the institutes. That also includes the content of the spatial tradition as well.

The convergence is completely striking, yeah. So to your point, it's definitely one of the areas of development. The convergences and also the applications. This work, the overlap with how AI models can be built is also so fascinating.

In its own realm, it's probably half of the fascination with what the Trace Institute has a chance to do and what this work allows for. And like we were saying before, in an oversimplified version, going outside of the current system and going into a different system, using the math to then, you don't even need to live in that other system, but use the math that works in that kind of source code that then changes the application that we're all a part of in this kind of a plane. And it's the AI application of it. It's fascinating.

If we have more time, I'm sure we can say. I can give one minute. Yeah, please. So if you think about one important aspect of intelligence is this.

If every time I try to do something, I'm surprised. I try to pick up a glass, but it breaks. I try to button my shirt and I rip it. Then I'm not very smart, right?

I'm not very bright. So in some sense, being surprised and being, or not being surprised and being intelligent are correlated. So the less you're surprised, the more you're intelligent. It's not the only thing that's about intelligence, but it's important.

It turns out that the Trace logic is provably. The zero surprise logic. It is the logic of, not only that this is something I talked with, I was talking about minimal surprise, and it's actually zero surprise. So it's the logic of zero surprise.

So it is going to be, I think, a foundation. Versus space time being a lot of surprise, maximal surprise? Well, so there's two separate concepts here. So the logic itself is about minimal surprise, but then the Trace logic, the logic of all these different parts gives us space time, with its time contractions and length contractions and so forth behind this time.

So they're two separate parts of this one formalism. Carl Fristin and others are using something called active inference, which they're trying to minimize surprise. They're trying to search to minimize surprise as a way of building artificial intelligences. And so they minimize something called free energy.

The Trace logic is the logic that they're trying to approximate. That's what they're trying to approximate. So we actually do see this as a next generation of AI as well. Back to this side of the room.

I saw some hands before. Yeah, sure, right there. We'll give you the mic just for the recording. We'll have to edit the Andrew stuff out.

Don't worry, guys. Thank you for sharing that. It truly is mind-blowing in a lot of ways. If there's a mathematical model to measure consciousness, then you can measure it?

Or where do you go from there? And then the kind of deeper question is, can someone control it? So the mathematical model will allow us to understand how consciousness is creating everything that we see inside of space and time. And if this is a headset that consciousness has created as one way of looking at itself, and we reverse engineer it, then the technology that will come out of that is indistinguishable from magic, literally indistinguishable.

Everything that we have will be trivial so far compared to what would happen. Again, the example of the person who's an expert at some VR game with a wizard, but the person who wrote the code and actually knows the code can just do magic that the wizard would never even understand. So that's what this could open up. So we actually have to be careful because it's a Pandora's box.

All right, we've got time for one or two more questions. Right there in the structure. Yeah, you're right there. You can pass the mic back.

Thank you. Hi, thank you very much for an amazing lecture. And my question would be, a lot of the times when we talk about conscious, we also say, oh, subconsciously I thought that, subconsciously I did this. So if our consciousness is a headset, what is the subconsciousness?

Fantastic. That brings up another aspect of the trace logic, and that is that there's all these different traces are effectively different conscious agents. We're consciousnesses. And so what we're showing is what you call your consciousness could have all sorts of subconsciousnesses.

In fact, the whole trace logic is the logic of all the subconsciousnesses. Trace logic is meaning what we're perceiving as a tiny trace of what's really happening. So that's why we keep using the words trace logic. It's also a very technical term in the theory of Markov chain.

So when you have a big Markov chain, you can take traces and make subchains on it. And it turns out that that's what we're using, that kind of technology from the theory of Markov chain. So it's very precise and mathematical. So the notion of trace actually, there is an equation to write down that describes what a trace is.

But informally, what it means in the case that you're talking about is that the trace logic is showing the relationship of all these different projections of consciousness. So it could effectively be, yeah, here's what I'm calling my consciousness, and here's a subconscious thing, or a non-conscious. In some sense, your consciousness is only indirectly known to me. I have to talk with you to understand what's going on in your conscience.

But inside you, you have two hemispheres, like the left and right hemisphere, that are joined by the corpus callosum, about 200 million fibers. And if you have the corpus callosum, you can actually show that the right hemisphere has a different consciousness and different consciousness experiences from the left, and the right hemisphere has a different personality, different religious beliefs, and different likes and dislikes than the left. So already you have two separate consciousnesses combined by the corpus callosum, and then much more. And the trace logic is really a mathematical logic that's showing how all these things could possibly connect.

That's really wild stuff. Yeah, we'll go right there. thank you um and honestly this is some mind-blowing stuff so this was an excellent discussion thank you for um hosting um i have two questions in there the first question is is if i understand correctly which i probably don't is space time an emergent property of consciousness is that an accurate way of saying it and the second part of that question is i'm not quite sure i under the way that you're using the word consciousness i'm not quite sure i understand that how are you defining that okay right so there is a sense which you can say that space time is emergent it's a particular format that consciousness uses to represent itself so in that sense it's you can think of it as emergent the for those who are interested in a technical definition of what we're doing here we have a paper online called fusions of consciousness so if you google my name and fusions of consciousness you can actually see a paper online that's a published paper it doesn't have the trace logic we're writing the paper right now in the trace logic so it has the fundamental definition of conscious agents that you can see um so so it's download upload it to chatgbt and go to town if it's if it's too technical but if you want to see the trace logic mathematics itself just email me at ddhoff at ddhoff at uci.edu and i can send you a write-up about the trace logic of mathematics but it's markov chains and traces of markov chains are the fundamental idea thank you all right one more back right there yeah we can pass the microphone back hi i hope on topic but um listening to your theory at first it kind of seems kind of lonely that once you're not like even looking at you that somehow i'm moving through this binary system of information and i'm making you up to make sense of reality right but when you said our brains could be a projection of a bigger technology of consciousness it kind of makes me think of how you explain the moon and light earlier that we're all just like reflections of this but then we're only humankind so there are other creatures that we know move through echolocation or that have different color conical spheres in their eyes is there a way to try to access their version or flavor of consciousness or is this a particularly homo sapien take that's that's a great question the idea is as you said that there's all these different ways that consciousness can experience yourself as homo sapiens or as a bat and you know there's a famous paper by thomas nagel called what's it like to be a bat um and so there's that kind of question that we can ask and for us right now as homo sapiens it's hard to imagine what it's like to be a bat um but i think that with technologies like dmg and so forth some people start to be able to expand their horizons about the kinds of experiences they can have maybe not into the bat area but but beyond normal human experiences and i think that as we begin to understand how the human experience is a particular headset and how the bat experience is a different kind of headset we begin to get the mathematics of how they're related we may then be able to develop technology so we can actually better have a chance of understanding what it's like to be about um so i think it'd be quite interesting so i think there's lots to do there but probably won't happen this year and you can go up a level and perhaps perhaps go up a level and see consciousness from a higher level than our current one to where maybe it's the least lonely thing in the world to see right clearly that uh just to see clearly that everything you've ever perceived multiple versions of you um okay don well thank you so much for the time tonight feel free to come up and say hey to donnie we got to get to a dinner here in about 10 minutes but come feel free to come say hello to him gaspard his colleagues and uh and stay tuned for all the lighthouse events that happen here on a monthly basis thank you again don thanks so much you

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Vedantic?

This episode is 1 hour and 25 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Vedantic episode published?

This episode was published on April 17, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Vedantic episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.