Long vs Short Intervals: Which Builds VO2 Max Faster?
from Cam Nicholls Podcast Hosted by Road Cycling Academy
Are short VO2 max intervals better than long intervals for cyclists? In this episode of the RCA Podcast, Cam Nicholls sits down with coach and data science specialist Ben Treble to unpack one of the most debated topics in endurance training: long intervals versus short intervals for improving VO2 max and cycling performance. Recent research has suggested that short interval formats such as 30/15s and 40/20s may allow cyclists to accumulate more time above 90% VO2 max compared to traditional 4-minute efforts. But does that automatically make them better? The answer is more nuanced than most cyclists realise. Ben breaks down the science behind VO2 max training, glycolytic capacity, VLaMax, lactate production, and why the "best" interval workout often depends on your physiology and cycling goals rather than what the latest study says. In this episode you'll learn: ✅ Long vs short VO2 max intervals explained ✅ Why some cyclists thrive on 4-minute intervals while others prefer 30/15s ✅ The role of glycolytic capacity (VLaMax) in cycling performance ✅ Why climbers and sprinters often respond differently to the same workout ✅ How to choose intervals based on your physiology ✅ The importance of training variability and periodisation ✅ Why copying professional cyclists isn't always the best approach Whether you're training for road racing, gravel racing, criteriums, gran fondos, or simply trying to improve your cycling fitness, this episode will help you better understand how to structure your interval training for maximum results. RCA Coaching: https://roadcyclingacademy.com/one-to-one-coaching/ Timestamps 00:00 Introduction 02:00 Long vs Short Intervals Explained 05:00 Are We Talking About VO2 Max Training? 08:00 Why Short Intervals Became Popular 12:00 Understanding VLaMax and Glycolytic Capacity 17:30 Why Different Cyclists Respond Differently 21:00 Does Research Really Show Short Intervals Are Better? 25:00 Sprinter vs Climber: Which Intervals Should You Choose? 27:00 Training Variability and Periodisation 28:00 Key Takeaways Transcript: Cam Nicholls (00:01.804) Welcome to the RCA Podcast, designed for recreational and amateur road cyclists with a focus on performance. We dive into cycling training, nutrition, strength training for cyclists and even bike fitting tips, all designed to help you train smarter, ride faster and hopefully tear your mates' legs off. So without further ado, let's dive into today's episode. Welcome back to the RCA podcast, where today I am joined by European correspondent and data science geek Ben Treble. Are you okay to be called a European correspondent now? Ben saying that, well, you're currently in Australia, but in two weeks' time you're gonna be going over and living in Europe. Ben Treble (00:46.646) Yeah, I'll take it, maybe clarify. I am not European, but I will be moving to Europe permanently and I will be the boots on the ground for RCA when I arrive. Cam Nicholls (00:59.148) Yeah, you'll be based out of Switzerland. So hopefully that gives us a bit more presence in Europe for not only to support our existing European clients, but anyone considering getting coaching, you know, that who are in Europe and they're like, I don't want to deal with, you know, those Aussies over there. Well, now we've got an Aussi who's, I guess, part Swiss. You know, I know you're going over there with a lovely lady who's from Switzerland. So we'll call you part Swiss for the time being, part European. Ben Treble (01:25.154) My better half is definitely Swiss. so I'll take a little bit of that. Cam Nicholls (01:30.05) Nice. So today I wanted to talk about something that popped up in a recent RCA coaching group call. So we have a a catch up with all the coaches at the RCA about once a month. And one of the coaches presents a a topic and one of our coaches, Johan actually, presented a a paper and he did a little bit of practical exercises alongside the research, which he presented, which I thought was pretty cool, about long intervals. versus short intervals. And I thought the research paper was pretty interesting, Ben. So I gave you the project, being somebody that likes to dig into all the research, to find out is this a real thing? Are certain type of intervals better than the other if you were to focus on one or the other? So Ben, you went away and did some digging. What did you find? Ben Treble (02:25.998) I do love this topic, particularly 'cause I I love building different workouts and you know, I've been very fortunate to do my cycling certifications, you know, with the UCI. We've had some they had some very good scientists come and present certain topics. For example, Ronastad came over and talked about HIIT training, which has probably been his life's work endurance HIIT training for for some respects as a researcher. Yeah, I love this topic. It's really important. I think every few years, you know, there's new trends with cycling training and we had HIT training a long time ago, I think. We've had zone two in the last couple of years and it seems to be making a resurgent at the moment across social media that, you know, you've got the classic Norwegian, you know, four by fours, which I would consider long intervals. And now you've got a lot of research coming out from Ronastad and a few other researchers where these short high intensity intervals might be better. And when we're talking about those short high intensity interval sets we're talking about anything from your 30 fifteens. So that would be 30 seconds on, 15 seconds easy, and you repeat this between nine to twelve reps, then you have a rest period, and then you do a second and potentially third set of those short intervals. There is no universal answer to which one is is better, Cam. So everyone always hates me when I say it's a context that matters the most. So We can bring this back to why do we train? We need to create stimulus for the athletes. And every interval is going to create a stimulus, but the stimulus for the individual is where it differs and varies. So should you do long or short intervals is going to come back to what type of athlete are you physiologically and what are your goals? Cam Nicholls (04:16.183) Can I also just preface and you know this before you continue, because when we talk about intervals, you can do zone two intervals if you really wanted to. Most people don't. They kind of just ride zone two. But you can certainly do tempo intervals. You can certainly do sweet spot intervals. So these are all sort of below threshold. But when we're talking about long and short for this conversation and I guess the research on this topic, I'm assuming We're talking about intervals that are kind of above threshold, kind of in that VO2 max category. I guess probably pretty much in that VO2 max category because a all anaerobic intervals are probably gonna be short. I don't think anyone's doing a 10-minute anaerobic effort. And threshold training, correct me if I'm wrong, is would mostly be deemed as long interval training because it's gonna be at least three to four. four minutes bare minimum in length. So are we specifically talking about VO2 max training when we're talking about short versus long? Or is there a line in the sand? Ben Treble (05:25.932) Yeah, I think for the purpose of this conversation, it's gonna be in reference to trying to improve VO two max. So what's going on in the media is obviously there's an awful lot of discussion around VO two max being a very important metric. We're not gonna debate how important VO two max is in this podcast, but it is a very important metric. It's definitely not the entire picture, it's one one metric among many that would help you understand how your training is working. But yeah. So long versus short intervals, maybe I'll just run through them both to keep it clear, but long intervals sort of anywhere from four to eight minutes, typically on or slightly above threshold. this would be, you know, akin to the Norwegian four by fours, obviously being four minutes, so it's going to be typically a bit higher, potentially a hundred and ten, up to a hundred and twenty percent, depending on what papers you look at. And then you have four minutes easy, repeat. This typically allows you a VO2 max to climb. really high. So the VO2 kinetics are going to climb and hold. and then you typically get we'd call it full recovery between those intervals. The short intervals are going to be the on phase anywhere from it's it can be as short as 15 seconds, but more common is going to be 30 or 40 seconds with either 15 or 20 seconds rest. So very short rest. The 30-15 component is typically around 120% of threshold. Sometimes it's harder. Certain research papers have tested should the 30 be maximal. So a common example that's very hard to prescribe in practical sense is going to be Ronostad did some papers where the 3015s were if the set is 12 reps, the athlete had to try and keep the highest possible mean power within the whole set. So the 30s were essentially maximal. And then the 15s were still moderate. They were not easy. So that's there's nuances to this in the research. It's not all the same, which is probably important for everybody to understand that you often hear and people are citing research, but they'll talk about 30-15s, but if you really dig into it, it's not always the same protocol in there. But yeah, VO2 max tends to stay elevated with the short intervals. That's the idea that it doesn't drop. You get higher lactate accumulation, but Ben Treble (07:51.18) you get a bit more rest from a muscular point of view. So the cardiovascular system, the rest is short enough that your heart rate can drop, but not too much. You're trying to keep it up. But then you get more muscular recovery. So that's the idea. The other thing that where this came from, long versus short, is Ronastud talks about how do we do VO two max work but for less rate of perceived exertion. So can we achieve a similar outcome? Which is spending as much or accumulating as much time as possible above ninety percent VO2 max, but for less effort. Cam Nicholls (08:29.602) Yep. Makes sense. Like for me, the thought of doing like a five minute VO two max effort on an indoor trainer is like absolute death. Whereas doing thirty fifteens and getting myself a cumulative time of thir you know, five minutes at that same power, but in thirty second increments, so much easier. Ben Treble (08:51.106) Yeah, but it's gonna depend. Like if you talk to a highly aerobic athlete, they're probably gonna prefer longer intervals. Like it'll feel potentially feel easier. And for certain athletes, they find the short, harder intervals easier. The bit that's often missing, I think, here is consideration for the glycolytic capacity. So, you know, if we just quickly touch on what the research is is showing We're trying to drive more time above 90% VO2 max. You know, this is there's plenty of papers on this. We can link them in the podcast. But Ronastadt is a big one on this. Alpenhans, and I'll pronounce this wrong, but Scovering also did studies on this. most of the studies on well-trained cyclists also have been repeated on runners and triathletes, so I think it's fairly reproducible. But the VO2 max of these athletes are a bit higher. So we have to really keep in mind. These studies are typically done on well-trained athletes. And what you do see in well-trained athletes is they tend to have a lower glycolytic capacity. They have more slow twitch muscle fibers, they're more aerobic, they're less sprinter. When we look at our recreational cyclists, let's take the RCA for example. Generally speaking, people who are new to cycling, people who don't do a lot of endurance training or have a a low history of high volume endurance training tend to have a higher glycolytic capacity and tend to have more type two fibers. So how relevant is this for the all these people who are reading this research? This is the bit that's kind of missing for me. And this was what sparked this podcast when we had this team discussion. I was thinking it was a little bit missing from this conversation as well. So interest. I mean, have you ever considered it? Cam Nicholls (10:33.762) Sing look, I I more so think about training now when you know, I'm training myself for event is variability. So not looking at one or the other, you know, is longer better or is shorter better, which one should I be doing? But appreciating the fact that if I'm going to be constantly, you know, just the old general adaptation syndrome constantly shocking the working muscle so they can adapt and don't get stagnant. I've got to change up what I'm doing. So if I'm spending, you know, six weeks on VO2 Max, I'm not doing all long intervals. I'll do a blend of short intervals and unfortunately long, even though I don't like the long ones. I prefer the shorter ones because I I realize and I know actually it's interesting when I'd start doing the three to five minute VO2 max intervals, for me personally, that's probably the biggest stimulus that I get from my training. I notice once I've done that for like two or three weeks. I'm like, well, okay, now I've I feel like I've got another gear. Whereas the short intervals, even though I find them easier and in the science it says, yeah, if you you're spending more time above ninety percent. So technically they're more effective. I don't find for me personally they're more effective. It's the longer ones interesting, but I do both. Ben Treble (11:54.614) Okay. That's good. I think we'll we can loop back to that because I think there's a lot more to be said for that than I think it's underrated, essentially. for the it's cohort of people listening to this anyway. Let's I'm just gonna jump into glycolytic capacity because I think that's let's kinda just I'll discuss it. Maybe one of the ways that you can consider measuring it or how it's typically measured in the literature. I would say it's a little controversial and it's Probably new metric for you, Cam, but it has been around for some time. It's called VLA max. This is the maximal lactate production rate. So you've heard of VO2 max. You can understand what VLA max is. So the V stands for flux rate. Obviously, O2 is oxygen and max is maximal. So what is the flux, the production rate of your oxygen and its maximal? So VO2 max, your maximal consumption rate of oxygen. Likewise, VLA max is V flux LA is lactate max, so maximal lactate production rate. Why is that a good marker for glycolytic capacity? So if we really think George Brooks is probably one of the most well known researchers on lactate, I think most people now know that lactate is not a negative thing. We have two energetic systems in a simple model, shall we say? You have the aerobic and the anaerobic system, probably better termed glycolytic, but they work together, right? Glycolytic system, it's producing lactate. And if we think of it like the exhaust, the aerobic system needs that lactate to go through the oxidation process. It's an input to allow it to produce ATP. So their systems are constantly working, and you have this thing called the lactate shuttle, right? So we're each side producing, consuming, moving the lactate through both sides. This is where, you know, I would say the original threshold is coming from, which would be. maximal lactate steady state. To me that is the gold standard for your threshold when people talk about threshold these days. And that's the point at which your production of lactate meets the combustion. So bring it back to VLA Max. If you can produce more lactate, you're gonna be more glycolytic because you need lactate for glycolysis to work really well. Where do we produce the most lactate? It's in your type two fibers. They're more glycolytic. So Ben Treble (14:22.432) If you're more sprinter, you're going to be more glycolytic, more type two, type two X fibers, you're going to be able to produce more lactate. But it often comes at a cost to a weaker aerobic system because you have less type one fibers, which is where the oxidation of the lactate occurs. How do we measure VLA max? This is the probably most tricky part, and which is why we won't get too stuck into it. But there's various tests. Typically, there was a 15 second test done on an SRM ergometer. I think the new literature brought brings it out to a 20-second sprint test to account for the a-lactic time period. And then they actually did this with measuring lactate, which we know is not feasible for most people still. They're not measuring lactate at home. And then you can use this as a measure, right? It's typically you get these ranges of VLA max of anywhere from a very low, let's say 0.2, which you would expect in a highly aerobic trained climber type athlete with high volumes. Maybe a triathlete even, all the way up to, you know, your weld to a sprinters at say 0.7, 0.8 even, maybe in a track sprinter. Very high glycolytic capacity. So there's a bit of a range. And if you know this range, this is what helps you understand why long, short intervals have different effects on different people. Cam Nicholls (15:41.014) Hmm, interesting. Ben Treble (15:43.426) I know this is going a little bit deep, probably over some people's heads, so I can already see your eyes glazing, Kem. Cam Nicholls (15:50.104) No, it's actually I'll you were going pretty deep there, but I now you've come back to essentially tying into what I was saying earlier about what I found in my own training, how actually, you know, despite what's maybe some of the papers say that one's better, it's dependable. This podcast is brought to you by the Road Cycling Academy. And as you now know, we've got some massive news for our listeners, especially across Europe. Now at the Road Cycling Academy, we are proud to serve an international audience from our base here in Australia, mate. Connecting our US, Canadian, Asian, and of course Australian clients across the days work beautifully. But Europe has always had that unique time zone puzzle. Usually, just as our European members are waking up, starting their days, we're wrapping up our days and preparing our dinners. Well, that puzzle is now officially solved. Based right out of Switzerland, Ben is servicing our European clients in absolute real time. So if you're in Europe and ready to smash your FTP, nail your nutrition, or unlock your true cycling potential, Ben is right there in your time zone running our 12 week custom plans and our one to one coaching offering. If you want proof that Ben can do a good job for you, just go check out our Google reviews. Our members consistently rave about his deep scientific approach, his game changing whole food fueling strategies. And his ability to consistently get riders to improve by a minimum of ten to twenty percent on their FTP or we use critical power at the RCA in as little as three months. Spots are of course limited, so head over to the roadcyclingacademy.com and lock in your spot with Ben today. Let's get back to the episode. Ben Treble (17:37.74) Yeah. And so we're gonna I will loop this back to try and make this feasible for people to picture at home where they sit on the scale. So I'm gonna talk about two edge cases because it just stretches out the extremes to make it clear are the differences. But if you had two athletes, one is very sprinter, very glycolytic, you've got one that's more of a climber, high volume, very aerobic type guy. Let's take the long intervals. Let's say they both had a similar VO2 max. Similar threshold, but one is just more glycolytic than the other. What happens when they do the four by four minutes? Right? The aerobic, so the low VLA max guy, the climber, is getting more of a glycolytic stimulus. It sounds counterintuitive, but the sprinter guy needs less of a glycolytic stimulus when he does those long intervals. So By the numbers, I won't go too deep on this. This is something from Sebastian Weber, who kind of continued Alois Mater's research in sort of glycolytic work and VLA Max, but it's the you think of fractional utilization of VO2 max, we have fractional utilization of VLA Max. Same notion, but on the glycolytic or anaerobic side. You need to stress that system to either cause it to adapt, maintain, or if you don't stress it enough, it's going to reduce. Now, if we think about if you have a high glycolytic capacity. It needs a lot more stimulus just to stay where it is, or it's going to start to drop. So if we're doing a four by four, the aerobic guy who has a very low like glycolytic capacity doesn't need to do a lot of effort in the high intensities to stimulate glycolysis. So four by fours, you're probably going to find the aerobic guy is maintaining his glycolytic capacity and the sprinter type guy. will actually end up with a reduction in his glycolytic capacity. So if your goal is to become more aerobic and you're already more of a sprinter, you probably want to lean towards the longer intervals. Cause your goal is to reduce a glycolytic capacity and lift your aerobic. Are we good? Have I got you? You're following me? Cam Nicholls (19:51.106) Yeah, interesting. Ben Treble (19:52.578) Let's jump to the short intervals. So you take 4020s, 3015s. What happens between these two examples? You're gonna have the aerobic guy gets a significant glycolytic stimulus, potentially say 20, 25% utilization of VLA max. So you would expect him to lift his glycolytic capacity. So if you're typically a very slow twitch, lean guy genetically, and you actually want to do more crits and sprinting or lift your sprint. But you also want to work on VO2 max, you're going to lean towards doing these short hit intervals, the 4020s. If you're a sprinter, it also goes up the glycolytic utilization in the short intervals, but it only goes up to about 10%. So you would expect them to just maintain their sprint capacity. So if you have a sprinter that wants to do VO2 work and they're trying to maintain their glycolytic strength, they want to maintain their sprint. Then you would also do the short intervals. But if you get a sprinter who's trying to reduce their glycolytic capacity, so really lift the the aerobic and fat oxidation type aspects of training, you're gonna want to lean on the longer intervals. Cam Nicholls (21:05.644) Interesting. So it's not a one size fits all after all that. But did didn't this paper that Johan presented indicate that shorter were better? Ben Treble (21:17.57) Yeah. So think about this though, right? Most of those papers work on highly trained athletes who are gonna have this as a hypothesis because it's not typically measured, they're gonna have lower glycolytic capacity. So they're gonna spend more time in VO two max in the short intervals. But they we're talking about if you really look at the short versus the long intervals in these VO two max papers of for time above. The differences are still small, right? They're scientifically measurable, but we're talking about small differences that are measurable. I think most athletes probably have bigger goals than just lifting VO2 max. So I'm probably what I'm doing is trying to get people to look beyond those papers a little bit and ask deeper questions around do you want to think not just about VO2 Max, but equally think about maybe the best VO2 Max workout for you should be brought back to Are you more glycolytic or more aerobic? And what are your goals? Do you want to become more of a climber, maintain your climbing capacity, or are you trying to improve or maintain your sort of sprint glycolytic capacity? I think that needle, that decision point is a bigger decision point than the difference you would see in doing long versus short VO2 work. Cam Nicholls (22:36.12) Okay. So going back to my example now, I'm you know, I'm a simple man, Ben. I need I need you to spell it out for me. So I would consider myself more of a aerobic guy, more of a grinder. You know, I'm more of a climber, even though I don't look like a climber and I'm probably not a climber. That's just my skill set. And sprinting is definitely not a strength of mine. You know, being able to You know, neuromuscular repeatability, like the thought of going and doing a hot dog crit, like I'll be out the back straight away. You know, jump even this morning I was doing a local group ride and I jumped on a guy's wheel because we have like a little sprint to the signpost at the end. And you know, he's not a big sprinter, but there was no way I was getting around him. I was just sitting on his wheel, sprinting out of the saddle. So my you know, my sprint capacity, like I'm assuming that's the glycolytic system is is not that great, whereas the aerobic I think's reasonable. So why do you hypothesize that I'm responding well to like the longer VO two intervals when I do them? Ben Treble (23:41.452) Well, yeah, if I was to guess, you probably sit more in the middle. You wouldn't ha you're not an edge case for glycolytic. You're probably more in the middle, which is gonna be let's say your VLA max is between, I don't know, point four and point five, maybe. P 0.35 to point five, somewhere in here. And this is gonna come back to maybe for you, if only sit in the middle, it's coming back a little bit to what sort of work do you typically do? And you probably respond better to long intervals because you don't do them. True. And this comes back to, you know, some let's bring this really back out of the science to the core principles of training, which is you need stimulus and you need to stress the body to get adaptation, that often needs variability. So again, back to your original idea, which I think is really valuable for non-elite athletes, which is in the early days in training, it matters less which intervals you pick. But rather that you're consistent with your training, which often just requires variability. So I actually see that for some people, when you're early in your training journey, you're probably better off using a mixture of these interval style workouts. Cause you just want to create different stimulus, you want to test the body and you wanna see what works well. Often the intervals you find the hardest are the ones that will create the most stimulus because it's what your body's not good at. Cam Nicholls (25:04.61) Makes sense. Yeah. So I guess, you know, if people are out there listening, one of the key takeaways, I think first and foremost, if they were to favor one side or the other, they need to consider what type of rider they are. How do you do that without going and getting, you know, a blood test or whatever's required to identify this? Is it as simple as like, yeah, I'm really good at sprinting and good at repeating my sprinting and I'm terrible at climbing, or vice versa, or does it go deeper than that? Ben Treble (25:33.742) I think if you ask most people to self assess probably eight out of ten times, they'd be pretty close to saying, no no, I know that I'm I feel more comfortable doing long sub threshold efforts and I enjoy climbing versus the people who say, no, I consider myself more of a sprinter. I like doing high intensity interval work. I find that easier than doing tempo for two hours. I think that's a pretty good indicator. If you said, which one do you find easier and prefer and lean towards naturally? And that would tell you if you prefer more high intensity work, like you just you enjoy doing Hessions and you don't find them as taxing, you're probably more glycolytic. Cam Nicholls (26:17.996) Okay. Ben Treble (26:19.542) On the flip side, if you say, No, I love long climbs, I prefer long efforts and TTs, you're gonna be less glycolytic, more aerobic. Cam Nicholls (26:26.988) Okay. So then on top of that, like you still want variability irrespective. So yeah, you might tend to favor one or the other, but ultimately, yeah, you want that continuous shocking of the working muscles, the the different stressor, so you can progress. And as you said, you know, I probably respond best to the longer VO twos because I don't I don't do them. I only do them when I really want to peek for something. So it might be like once a year or once every eighteen months, do I actually go, All right, that five minute climb that I hate, I'm willing to go do, you know, repeated five minute VO two max efforts on it. Ben Treble (27:08.76) Yeah, I agree. I think there's a there's a big timing component. So the periodization in your say annual training plan. This conversation's probably most relevant if you really want to pick one and stick with it and work on a specific capacity. It's gonna be in your building phases in terms of the periodization, potentially even in the base periods. But once you get into the racing season or the specific components of your training blocks, I think the interval style you pick should really just be matched to the demands of your goal. So if your goal is to do crit races, I would still end up pushing people towards the shorter interval styles closer to their crit races because it's going to be more, you know, replicable within the race. It's going to replicate the race demands a lot better. Equally, if someone's going to do more hilly road races where they've got two to four minute climbs or even longer climbs, we're going to lean more towards longer intervals. Cam Nicholls (28:07.822) Well that's interesting, Ben. Thanks for your time. Was there anything else that you wanted to to mention or do you feel like we've we've wrapped up there? Ben Treble (28:16.512) No, I think it's the key takeaway for people is ask yourself a question. Would I consider myself more of a sprinter, more of a climber? What type of intervals do I find easier? And what is your goal? Like are you training to go over to Europe and do some big of the famous climbs in the Alps? Or are you training in the US because you want to do the crit season? Like two very different goals and depending on what type of rider you were when you asked the first question. probably gonna help indicate what type of intervals you should think about doing more than another. Cam Nicholls (28:51.17) Yep. Good. Well, if you're out there listening and you're like, well, I've just learned a fair bit there, but I'm still a little bit unsure about, you know, what's the best way to bring this into my training? How do I, you know, slowly progressively increase, you know, the intensity and difficulty sessions. When do I bring in short? When should I bring in long? Don't forget we're a coaching business here at the RCA, so you can head to our website, www dot roadcyclingacademy dot com. Check out one to one coaching. that's where you'll find Ben and a number of other coaches. And of course, if you're in Europe, don't forget, by the time this podcast goes live, Ben will be maybe settled in Europe or settling in Europe and ready to take on some European clients for the summer season. Thanks for your time, Ben. We'll catch everyone in the next podcast.
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.