Skip to content
Looking for value… in growth. April 10, 2026 episode artwork

Apr 10, 2026 1 hr 12 min

Looking for value… in growth. April 10, 2026

from Motley Fool Money Hosted by LiSTNR

– Looking for value… in growth – Of stonks and meme stocks – Ceasefire in Iran… sort of

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Looking for value… in growth. April 10, 2026

0:00 1:12:26
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A listener production. This is Motley Fool Money. Welcome to Motley Fool Money, the podcast that is going to reform itself come the May budget. I'm Scott Phillips from The Motley Fool. He is Andrew Page. He needs no reform. He's been perfect from the start. Strawman has been the ideal business that no one can lay a finger on. And when it does end up being the everything up, no one will be surprised. Mr Page, g'day. G'day, g'day.

How about no need of reform? I don't know. In various aspects of my life, there's others calling for reform on multiple fronts. Let's be honest, they're probably right. Others calling for reform, I like it. My lens on it is absolutely perfect. There's nothing to worry about. Other people are wrong all the time, aren't they? I know, it's really frustrating. I feel like you're going to throw me your favourite Bitcoin meme about everyone else is wrong. What's that kind of cartoon? Oh, I don't know. You've stumped me with that one. I'm sorry, you're wrong? No, it's not everyone else is wrong.

I thought you'd know what's up your head. I can't remember. Normally I'm good with that one. Yeah, you're a meme fiend. It's like two panels left and right and it's like everyone else is... Oh, that's actually been adapted a few times. I think it stems back to a New Yorker cartoon. You see it with the share market, you see it with various other things. So it's sort of like there's two booths. One is right but complicated and the other one is wrong but easy in terms of an explanation. And the wrong but easy has got like a million people lined up behind the booth or in front of the booth and the other one's got like no one. That is a very good one. I like that one a lot. The Bitcoin one or the share market one or whatever one you want to fit into it is like you'll see things like...

Bitcoin at 120,000, there's a million people lined up. Bitcoin at 70,000 and there's no one lined up. Same thing, much cheaper, not interested. Fair enough, fair enough. Which works really well for stocks and all assets, right? Everything else in our life, we wait for sales, we want to get it cheaper. When it comes to assets, it's only when they go up in price that we become more interested, which is fascinating. I mean, there's something to that. I find...

Investing and our... It's no surprise. The market tells more about ourselves to other people. That's kind of the thing. Because I've written regularly about that. It's kind of like there's two groups of people. And it's that idea of where you sit on... So the price is falling. Someone's like, oh, it's a bargain. I'm not falling. I'm not buying. It's falling. And the price goes up. And the price goes up. People are like, oh, it's going up. Cool. I'll get on the train now. And they're like, I'm not buying. It's going up. I'm going to pay too much. I'll wait for the dip. And it's just really funny. And it's not that I... You both are wrong a lot of the time, right? It's not like that one is always... I have been really good, I would say, at...

It's seeing falling prices as a good thing. I've leaned into that. But I've been very bad at buying when prices are going up to my detriment. And it's been a very difficult process to train myself to be better at averaging up. In other words, you've bought a company, it looked good, you've got a decent thesis for it. It starts to play out. They start executing. Not only that, as they execute and as the sales momentum builds and product awareness grows and all of these kinds of things, it's a real genuine business momentum there. But it does require buying more at a higher price, which I've always found very, very difficult.

you see it all the time. It's like, that's actually the boss move, right? Is because yes, you might be paying a higher price, but you are now buying it at a much, there's much less risk involved because the business is sort of across various thresholds. Like, yeah, but it's lower risk now. And like, while it might've looked interesting at this point, they've got this potential. It's like, they're actually demonstrating that they've got the capacity to sort of prosecute that potential. And it's very hard to do. So yeah, I just sort of flesh that out, what you said there a bit more, because I think a lot of people go, oh yes, of course, you'd be greedy when others are fearful and fearful when others are greedy. It's like, well, sometimes it's good to be greedy when other people are greedy too, right? Right, yes, yes. It depends. Yes, and that's what I think.

I think that's exactly right. And it's probably, not too passive and further, but I think there's a difference between greedy and prices being higher. Yes, that's great. And not that you're 100% right, but the idea of kind of like when the sentiment of the market, and I think Buffett's right with the sentiment with the greed and fear, rather than, he didn't say, sell what prices are high and buy what prices are low. He said, greedy, others are fearful, and fearful, others are greedy. I think there's something to that which I think is important. Just to kind of break apart that difference. But you're right, and I think the point you made was, they're both wrong.

In any of those four scenarios, you know, price down, buy more, price down, buy less, price up, buy more, price up, buy less. They're all wrong because they start with what did the price do or what is the price doing? And usually you're leaning into buying when prices are cheaper. You're not really saying you're buying because the price is falling per se because as we've said a million times, it's stupidly expensive becomes still very, very, very expensive. You're not buying those. And so it's that idea of it actually doesn't matter what the price is. I mean, like you, I suspect, I don't know actually, I do like looking for companies that are down to see if the city bargains are being offered while pessimism is running. So that's useful in terms of looking for potential ideas, but it doesn't drive the purchase decision. That bit is, okay, the price is down.

I'll look at it. Okay, now I've looked at it. I don't care that the price is down. I'm only using it as a signal to say, is there a chance if I looked at this company, it might be an attractive price rather than because it's down. So let me ask you a question. It's just that, I just quickly just, it's an engineering problem, right? You know, I've always, always loved the various formulations of it, but a stock that is down 90% is a stock that dropped 80% and then halved. And then halved. Oh, it's down 80%. Oh, it's really cheap. We can't go, well, yeah, you can always go down 100% from, you can drop 99% and then drop 100% from that level, right? Yes, yes. Sorry, what was your question? Well, I don't, I mean, it's an unanswerable question. I don't expect you to have one. But it's easier for me to think about a company that

I don't and should more look at the ones that are up and go, hey, is there something there? Is there a there there? Yes. So my natural bias, I'm not naturally contrarian. I suppose a little bit. I try to be independent rather contrarian, but you know. So I am a bit naturally, I don't mind looking for over-excitement and going, that feels a bit much. Or DPS is like, well, that doesn't feel reasonable. So kind of, I'm okay at those extremes. But, and if a price falls like, oh, you might have a look. That's halved. I wonder if it's cheap. I should have a look now. The ones that go up, I don't particularly get drawn to. I think that's just a personality thing of, you know, I'm not like, who looks? What's up? What's up a lot recently? I can't see if there's anything there. And I should because we've just talked about the fact that can be indicative.

How do you think about making yourself aware of those companies, putting them on a watch list? Is there something you do use? Is there a fallback or a way you tend to look for those things? I mean, they probably come across the desk because, I don't know, someone's written about it on Stallman or something. And yeah, you look at the pricing, that natural reaction, I've missed it. I'll give you a really recent example without revealing too much. We spoke to the CEO of Echo IQ. They do AI on Echo.

I'm going to reveal my medical knowledge ignorance here. Echo cardiogram data. It's a whole thing. And they were kind of doing AI before all this hype. Anyway, it's up. We've spoken to the company a few times over the years. And I was just before I chatted to the CEO, it sort of made note of what was the price set last time we chatted. It's up 5x since then, right? Yeah. Now, the reason I mentioned this to answer your question, actually, again, first reaction.

That would have been nice. And then you look at it now, and again, I don't own shares. I don't recommend it. Please don't go off and buy anything on this because statistically it could go very wrong from here, right? But the possibility is, yeah, but back then, I mean, they still don't have any revenue, right? They've got a really cool bit of tech, but they're only now going into the commercialization phase. What happened since we last spoke? All these milestones were passed. The tech just kept getting proven out. Anyone who's followed that kind of space will know that science in general, you find really promising early results.

And it's like, this is great. Works brilliantly in the test tube. Let's check it out on the mice. Brilliant. Works really well. You sort of go up the food chain. It's brilliant, brilliant, brilliant, brilliant. Market's getting super excited. Oh, we put it into humans and someone loses a leg. Something horrible, right? It's like, oh, and it's worth zero. 20 years, $400 million of investment, and it's nothing. And every single step of the way, it looked increasingly likely. Anyway, so in the case of Echo IQ, the potential here is, yeah, the price has gone up a lot, but this is a different risk proposition than it was a year ago, right?

big if, what they say is true and comes to pass. It's probably ridiculously cheap, right? Right now, after going up 5X. You know, think about Fortescue Metals back in the early days, you know, when it was pre-revenue and then it started making money. You could have bought it 5X from the bottom and it's done insanely well. REA group, car sales, you know, Prometicus, blah, blah, blah, blah. The list is on and on and on. So just there's a long-winded way of answering your question. I'm with you. I don't sort of see it and automatically think, oh, I need to explore that further. But I am trying to get better at going, well,

It is very common to see the price go up, but the value improve. Or let me reframe that. The risk-adjusted value proposition improves quite a bit. I tell you right now, the best investment on the ASX right now is a stock that's trading at less than two cents. With zero revenue, four employees, a rented WeWork somewhere in Perth.

Sorry, Perth. I mean, don't throw you under the bus there, but there's a pattern. Yeah, exactly. And some of the best companies in Australia are located in those places. So there are very much exceptions to the rule. But anyway, you get what I'm saying there, right? It's sort of like, and when you look back in five years, when that stock at his 0.3% is now trading at $4.87.

It's going to smash everything out of the water. There's nothing in the top 200 that's going to have those kinds of percentage returns. The trouble is, is that every single stock under two cents, like 99% of them are not going to do that. So there's a survivorship bias. There's a hindsight bias that's implicit in that. I think people often see these things and they draw the wrong conclusions is that that's the best investment to make. It's like, well, actually, I would argue that probably the best investment to make is that investment. But after it's gone from 0.2% to 20 cents.

Like it's gone up a hundredfold. Is that right? Yep. One, two. Yes. It's gone up a hundredfold, but then gone from 20 cents to $4.80 or whatever I said. And yes, that's not nearly the same kind of return, but it's still a very, very good return. And the odds, the risk at 20 cents is vastly lower. Sorry, the odds are vastly better at 20 cents. The risk is vastly lower at 20 cents than it was at 0.2 of a cent. So yeah. It's like the best bet is picking the right lower numbers.

Yeah, every time. By definition, right? Literally, you do. Right. Yeah, exactly. Easy. Best investment. Risk adjusted. Well, I think it's not a great idea. Try that again. Yeah. What about me? Can I make a confession, by the way? This is just to poke fun at myself and feel free to laugh at me. You did the $0.20 to work out what that was. So my son and I, Wednesday this week, took a day off work and went fishing and we bought a new slash old tinny. So we bought an old used tinny off the Facebook market. It's not Mark Zuckerberg's power yacht.

No, we're not talking about that. I'm going, Dad, we should get a bigger boat. I was like, no, this is fun. There's a Jules reference in that, right? Yeah, exactly. Let that one go fast. Exactly. I wish you get this, we should get that anyway. So it's a very, very, very basic tinny. And it was just because he's enjoying his fishing, which is lovely. So if he wants to be out fishing rather than in front of a screen, I will take him. Two holidays took him out. And speaking of a bloke who's supposed to know maths, right? If you're a multiple member, my apologies in advance, and trust me, I check my calculations more than once. It's a two-stroke engine.

which has 50 to 1 petrol to oil. So for those who don't know, you don't have separate lubrication, two-stroke engines, the oil in the petrol does the work, blah, blah, blah. That's the extent of my mechanical knowledge, by the way, so don't ask me any questions. I'm bad at healing. We fill up the fuel tank on the way home, and I've got the oil in the boat, so just fill up the fuel tank, put the oil in, put it at 51. Good, no worries. I wake up at 4 o'clock this morning and go,

I didn't put in 51, I put in 500 to 1. I put in way less oil than I should have. We put in five litres of juice and I put 10 litres of oil in. I went, oh, that's 51. Good work. Literally, right? I woke up this morning going, should have 100 litres, not 50 litres. What am I doing? So I luckily haven't driven the boat since, so I will go and rectify my error after we finish this podcast because I've literally put in my diary. I was like, may she add some more oil to the fuel films? So we'll see how it goes. But yes, I have to rectify that problem sooner or later. I have made similar mistakes. We do not need elaboration, but yes. I'll put myself in the hole. In terms of, I mean, you asked how I do it.

The answer is badly or not enough, honestly. Not that the – I mean, look, the way you describe it is the only way to do it, right? You're assessing what you know, what you don't know, and the price you're paying versus the potential upside. And our only job as investors – and it's why Bristol and people kind of say investing in gambling are 100% different things. I mean, they are for lots of different reasons. Predominantly, gambling has a negative expected outcome. Investing has a positive expected outcome. Statistically, they're very different. They're also – gambling – well, it depends on what you're doing, but things like roulette or whatever abounded. Like, you know the full shape of the probability set. Yeah, yeah, good point. And that's partly what leads into the positive expected outcome.

on average. But, so it's very, very different. I don't want to, it's a difficult conversation. People who miss the point that there's a lot in common, right? It's all about expected outcomes and understanding probabilities and risks and uncertainties and just luck, frankly, and a whole lot of other stuff. And so when you say, oh, they're nothing like each other, not you. People say, it's like, you're saying that because you're trying to want to make investing sound dignified and smart and somehow reputable. And investing is that degenerate thing that people do over there and they do it with the TAB, you know, the BSA and carpet. And that's gambling, but what do I do? No, I invest. It's like, well, yeah. I mean, yes, 100%. They're very, very different. But also,

They're not that different, you know, the way you think about it. So the way you describe how we should think about stocks going up is 100% correct. How do I do it? Badly, in the sense that I am not instinctively drawn to it, so I do less of it than I should. And because I'm always happy about being the optimist in the room of pessimists, rather than someone who thinks that the optimist of others is not optimistic enough, I'm naturally not that person. I'm not a curmudgeon. I'm not particularly dour. Well, listen to me, disagreeing. They're welcome to that view. You may disagree. I'll thank you to not say it. But, you know, that kind of, I just, whenever I'm getting excited, the guy's like,

That feels a bit much. You know, actually, I sound like I'm not dour. I will throw myself under the bus yet again. I can reverse back over me. You know what I hate in football is the post-try celebrations where they're carrying like pork chops or the wicker taking the cricket where they'd run around with their arms in the air. It's like the old days that the centre would put the ball down, the fastball would take the wicket, nodded and turned around and go back to his mark. And then he's got this over-the-top celebration carry on. I'm just like, for the love of God, just get back to your job. Celebrate the win when it's over. You don't have to be a show pony, so yes, maybe I'm not a commotion. But I think it's that... I like the theatre of it all. It's great. The guy who's in the ring, you know, give us a show.

But I think that personality trait does probably lead me to being too wary of some businesses that actually are worthy of investing in. And so I have a few high-peggy companies in my portfolio. Amazon, I've mentioned a million times, is the poster child for buying it expensive all the way through. And I haven't bought it enough. That's my latest. But you don't regret averaging up there. Right, exactly. So I do it not well enough. How should I do it? If I was going to try and coach myself...

By the way, the P of Amazon is 25. I just looked it up. It seems timid next to some of our stocks. And that's kind of when you look at some of these companies. This is why I guess I... And because I'm not a value guy with a capital V, but I do like to find some value. I don't want to jump on everything that's growing just because it's growing. If you look at Google or Amazon I own, and you look at the P's, I mean, they're both cheaper than Woolies.

At some point, it's kind of like, so hang on. And so I find myself saying, well, there seems to be enough inexpensive, not super cheap, but inexpensive quality out there, but I probably don't need to go so far to try and chase other stuff that maybe has an uncertain future. So I'm not a, you know, David Gardner, who's talked about a million times, famously, he strike rates like three or four out of 10. And he's buying these high flyers, most of which don't work out, right? And that's not my natural instinct. My natural instinct is not to aim for less than 50% strike rate, almost as a point of, David's trying to do that. I mean, he wouldn't say he was trying to, he'd say, I'm trying to be right every time. But he's embracing investing strategies that he knows.

despite the way he picks every single stock, hoping it's the next big winner. He knows most won't be. You obviously want Amazon to make your entire investing career, right? Right. Well, I didn't watch enough for that, but I bought it, thankfully, early enough that I've done very well. And so it's, yeah. So I don't know the answer, mate. I wish I had a better solution for you. I probably need to take the grandpa slippers off maybe sometimes and...

actively look for winning companies that are expensive and maybe can keep winning. Maybe I should do that as a matter of course. Maybe there's an episode for us to do on that at some point when we've got some time we're playing ahead or something. It's like, look at which high-flying stocks are worth buying and not worth it. We don't want to make recommendations, but just that sort of process of what does this look like? What does it have to look like? We mentioned Prometheus a gazillion times. I can't buy that thing. I just can't, right? And maybe it's worth it, maybe it's not. But the current price line, no. So much has to go right. We did a deep dive on it recently. Right, exactly. The VLDR on it was just zero debate on the quality. It's not even worth having that debate because I think that's what the ball's got. Oh, but it's such a great company. Agree.

Unbelievable. Best company on the ASA. Phenomenal. 50% net margins. Growing without any share issuance or debt. Paying a dividend. It's insane. And it's lost two-thirds of its value. It's a broad church, so different people have different views. But I think the consensus is probably around reasonable price.

Like, it's not cheap, though. I don't think there's anyone in our group that, oh, it's a screaming bargain. Which, if you looked at the price alone, would suggest it is a screaming bargain. It might be, by the way. Don't take what we say as gospel. Before all the enthusiasts write in. So, what should I do? I should make a point of actively, from time to time, pulling up a list of companies that are quote-unquote expensive and comparing them to their current growth rates. And then, when that makes some sense, working out what from there might deliver market-building returns. Which is exactly the concept of how I'm promoting. So, it's that process. I probably just need to be more...

deliberate about it because I know I'm not going to be you know investing is a funny thing right I talk about successful investing being the ability to overcome our revolutionary biases and I'm highly convinced that's the case and so it's just another version of that which is I need to recognise my natural inclinations and proactively and deliberately and with some sort of framework acts to make sure I open that door more widely so things I naturally do anyway it's a chore the chore for me is a chore is something you don't really want to do but you know you should do right that's kind of what defines the idea yeah yeah And so I probably just need to do the chores. I probably have a chore list, which is once every so often go, right, okay, this is not what I normally do. Let's actually put the other hat on, put aside my biases and expectations and whatever, and go, right, where can I find value? And not just at the bottom end of the market with a single-digit PE, but, hey, this is a PE of 40, but it's a screaming buy, and here's why. And then I'm not naturally drawn to those kind of examples, and I should do a better job. I work with a team of people, by the way, some of whom do this, so I'm very fortunate that we have team-based services where we get groups of people who are not opposite in thinking necessarily, but just ranges of thoughts and outcomes. My biggest challenge, mate, as you've said this on the pod before, is trying to pick the companies that are

Because I'm probably under a lot of things, but I'm a skeptic when it comes to investing. And so when I sit down and go, so the P is 40, that means it's got to grow 15% a year for the next 10 years. I mean, I don't know. Maybe it will, but maybe it won't, so I won't do it. And I'm sure I pulled too many punches doing that because it's just the uncertainty of, who knows? Next year, I might have a reasonable view of. It's year two. I can't say that might work. The further out you have to go, the harder it is. But that's where the value is. That's the Amazon story. Amazon didn't justify its valuation two, three, four, five years after I bought the shares. It justifies its value 10, 15 years after I bought the shares. So yeah, that's probably the thing I need to get my head around better.

The way I try to do it, I don't because it's so hard to avoid the share price. Even like on CompSec, you type it in, it's just like right there, right, you know, on the side of the page. So it's hard not to, but I always like to try and not even consider it without looking at the company because there's no context. it's impossible to form a view on anything without putting it in the context of the underlying business. Price could have gone up 10 fold, but the business's quality and potential could have gone up a hundred fold or it could have fallen in half. And it's actually, it's on its way to dropping another 90%. So it's more about sort of saying, is this like the first, at least the North star, put it that way. I think I would like to frame as.

In the same way that I would look at if I was a private investor just looking to buy a business outright. I don't go up to the owners and say, how much is it? No, I go, well, what's this business? Do I want to own it? That's the first question. Is this something that I want to get into bed with? It's like, okay. If it's not, I mean, I would sort of say, it's wrong to say there's no price because there's almost always a price, but there's no realistic price where I'm going to want that. So it's like, it's a midpoint. I don't need to look any further. If it's sort of like, actually, it's a really cool business. I really like it. I mean, they've got...

Great products, great culture, great opportunity, great market positioning, great balance sheet, all the usual stuff. It's like, all right. And then actually before you look at the product, it's like, well, what would I like to pay for it, right? Do a bit of maths and then go like, okay, now what's the market offering me? Often you get to that point. I do anyway, at least sort of like, oh, I like it. I like it. And I think this would be a really great price to pay for it. Obviously the best price is 0.1%, but realistically I think this price would allow for some good returns and a bit of a buffer and the rest of it. And you look at the market and it's 30, 40% above that.

it's not a wasted effort, right? There are watch lists. I'm checking on the watch list, right? At some point, Trump will tweet out something stupid and it's like, there you go. There you go, right? It's like the thing that I said I wanted and that's hard to do as well because then it's like, well, maybe something else bad will happen and you start doubting yourself. But I think for me, easier said than done, but price is always the last thing to look at. How can you even make any judgment of the price if you don't know anything about the business? And if you've not worked out what a sensible price would look like given your view of the business. Yeah, I'm thinking about...

Yeah, you're right. It's impossible not to know. It makes it really, really difficult. And the other thing is a natural tendency to reduce future growth expectations because to not do so seems outlandish. I don't know what Amazon's confidential growth rate is at this point. It's slowing down sales and profit-wise, share price-wise. But I suspect if I went back to 19... Not 19, sorry. Oh, yeah, maybe. 2005, pick a year, right? And someone said...

If I went to 2005 now, and I compiled a known value DCF of this is what actually happened next. And you pick that up, and there's a company, and here's the DCF I put together, what do you reckon? And you're going to go, what? What growth rate? What year? I mean, how long? Right? Yeah, you could, but... And that's the hard thing. It's not that it didn't happen. I mean, firstly, we need to be a little bit skeptical of companies that promise to, because there's only one Amazon, realistically. I mean, they'll be mothers, but you know what I mean. And, yeah, that natural tendency to go, well, I can't put 20% every year. So maybe 15%, maybe 10%, maybe 5% by year, by year 10%. And you could never have bought Amazon on that basis.

And so it's a really, really difficult one. I'm going to say two, mate. I bought Amazon shares. This is not about me, not about me being good or probably just lucky, frankly. But I bought Amazon shares without a DCF on the company.

And this is where I've tried to lead a little bit into the David Gardner kind of thinking, or just the growth kind of thinking. And it wasn't, I mean, a lot of people do this total addressable market thing, and everything's investable if you do that, right? Once in a China type thing, it's like, imagine if this was this big. But I did with Amazon to some degree, I kind of did that. I kind of did the whole, this is a visionary company, incredibly well-led, with massive price advantages, with huge scale economics, with massive global potential. And I just kind of went, there's a range of potential outcomes here, but without having to put a percentage each year and compound that, which sounds reckless. It's like, could it be 10 times the size in some future period? It's like, actually, yeah.

I mean, it might not, but yeah, I can see, I can extrapolate it's the wrong word because it makes it sound mechanical, but I can absolutely look at the future and imagine a scenario where, given its advantages, given its scale, and this is the 20 cent versus 0.2 of a cent you mentioned before, mate. I didn't buy a 0.2 of a cent in metaphorical. I bought it metaphorical 20 cents. And yes, I missed out a huge, huge upside. But I did it because I kind of went, well, it's got to this point and here are all the things I see about it. And here's the range of potential futures. And in some of those, the thing crashes and burns for a million different reasons. But in the vast bulk of those, I reckon there's a much, much, much bigger, more valuable business in, I don't know, when I bought them, but decades worth of time. I think this is a huge business. And I think that's...

That's kind of how I did that. And it feels, on one hand, even to myself, sometimes a bit reckless of, what do you mean you didn't do a DCF? You didn't ask what needed to happen. But it kind of didn't need to be. And maybe sometimes the focus on the per-year growth can maybe make us risk missing the bigger picture. And again, I'm not saying throw your DCF. Especially new-term, year-on-year growth, yeah. Right? I guess I'm left wondering what those businesses are today. And again, trying to make myself think about, not the next Amazon, because it's like one Amazon every now and again, but...

Where else that sort of thinking of how big could this be? How dominant could the company be? How big is it already? You know, how does it go from here to there? I mean, I've mentioned a million times Coke, I haven't told the shares that I own, sorry, and that I got the analysis right, but I missed the growth runway or lack thereof because it was everywhere already. But it's the Coke story. I mean, imagine Coke's, I think 96, the bloke.

put some cocaine in a bit of syrup and pushes some bubbles through it. Wow, that's amazing. That's the 0.02 cent answer. At some point in the $0.900, it becomes the $0.20 answer. At some point after that, it becomes the $2 answer. Would you have known on day one, you ever want to drink Coke at some point? No. But at some point during that process, you think, well, this could be a thing. I mean, this feels like everyone who drinks it loves it, wants more of it. And gee, if that could scale it any size, those are the kind of opportunities I think maybe we, I'll say, I need to do a much better job looking for proactively and maybe just harnessing the long-term potential without getting too caught up in...

the occasionally depressing, as in not mentally depressing, but the depressing impact of trying to put a yearly growth number to DCF and talking yourself out of it because it feels like it's reckless. Yeah. I mean, it's particularly hard for the relatively smaller companies. You know, when it comes to like a Woolies or a CBA or whatever, people will have different views, but no one's coming out there and saying, I think Woolies can grow. It's top line at 30% for 10 years. A mega bull might say 7%, you know, per year for 10 years. I'm like, really, that's quite bold. You know, that's about Drone Shield, right? Because that's in the news for all the wrong reasons at the moment.

Came across our desk 2021. I'm just looking at the figures now. They did $10 million in revenue. It was really great. And a lot of the bulls were, oh, it's going to go fantastic here and rah, rah, rah. And you think, okay, well, what does strong growth look like? You think, wow, maybe they'll double or triple their earnings in the coming years. Well, between 2021 and 2025, they grew their revenue 20x.

20x, not 10x, 20x. Two years after 2021, it was 5x. And it's like, can you imagine? And this is where you give credit to the people who sort of saw that potential and actually stuck it. There's a much larger cohort of people who just bought it because it was cool tech and the share price was going up. But I'm talking about the people who actually sort of thought of what they were doing. Just, you know. And again, I'm just really hastening the way out here. I'm not trying to make a quality judgment or trying to infer any sort of investment advice from it. But it's sort of like you...

you almost need to sort of make these insanely reckless forecasts. And it's sort of like, you can imagine if I was chatting to you in 2021, I reckon like in 10X, two years time, three years time, I'll like 10X it. That is bold. It's like, oh no, 20X, like double what you said, right? And why, how is that possible? Well, it's called the basing effect, right? Like you are starting off such a low base.

that you can do that, whereas actually that's entirely reasonable. I think with those kinds of companies, you have to look at the addressable amount. How big is it? How much of a market share could you have? How long will it take you to get there? What do your net margins look like at that point in time? And it's hard because you feel as though...

It is reckless to make those forecasts. But therein lies the opportunity. I haven't even talked about operating leverage where the sales do that and the fixed costs don't grow that much and then the bottom line just explodes. And it's particularly when you're near that break-even inflection point. Loss, loss, loss, loss, loss, loss. Oh, a couple million in profit. Oh, 30 million in profit. Oh, 480 million in profit. In the space of a few years, right? And it's just sort of like anyone sort of junior analyst presenting that to their bosses. Tone it down. I am not putting that in a report for our clients to read because you sound like you're taking crazy pills. What are you smoking? But actually...

Actually, that happens a lot, you know, more than you would imagine. And so for me, part of it is, I think I've said on the pod many times, it's not trying to, I think too many people do this. They feel as though they have to come up with some valuation. That's it. That's my line in the sand. And I get it because you kind of do need at the end of the day, there is a point, do I buy or do I not buy? Do I hold or do I sell? But, you know, you can play around, you can explore the probability set. And I think it's just a really valuable thing. It's like, well, let's...

I don't have to plant my flag on this hill, but all right. I don't know. What does it look like? Let's assume it grows 10 times in revenue. Let's assume this is what it looks like. It's actually less so than made me money, but more so in saved me from losing money. When you see, I mean, ProMedica story again, I was pretty embarrassed about that for a long time. Now I'm starting to feel a little bit justified, right? Where it's sort of, well, Afterpay was back in the day. We had these arguments. I'd be on Auspies and people was like, oh yeah, but it's a great company. It's like, well, let's, okay.

How much? Oh, they could grow their revenue. Okay, well, let's go. You know what? Let's add 50% of that. Okay, let's do that. And once you do that, it's not to say this will happen, but to say what if this happens. And you find particularly these really sexy, hyped up, sort of stonky meme stocks, that it's just sort of like, even if what you say is true, I'm still going to be taken to the cleaners here because the market is forecasting in what you've said and then another 5X on top of that, which is not even the most biggest megaball is calling for that. So even if you are right.

you'll get an average return, which is a terrible proposition. I'd rather let's have a very, very low risk ETF and get the average return. Why am I rolling the dice on this one in a hundred shot that I might get an average return? That is not success, right? Success is when I get double the market return, right? That's what I'm kind of looking for here. So I don't know. I think it's worth, where are we going with all of this? I guess it's a question of trying to sort of contextualize things, explore various things, understand what is possible, what is likely, and then adding, what's the three most important words in investing?

Marginal safety. Marginal safety. Thank you. And yeah, right. And, and, and, and that's like, and by the way, that, that is a, that is a setup or a scenario where you can do that. And then nothing comes your way for like two years. And then in the space of three months, you get 12 opportunities. So it's not like, if I just do this, I'll always be something else. Like often you can do everything. Right. And you're sitting there twiddling. It's been Buffett's problem for the last however many years. Yeah. I've got a mountain of cash, but.

And it's not like I don't want to deploy it. I want to deploy the capital. It's just like, there's nothing for me to buy that I'm excited about. And that's the other hard part of it as well. Because when it doesn't sort of line up within your framework, it's like, you know what the right thing to do? Not a damn thing. And that is hard when there's money burning a hole in your pocket. And it's especially hard when the market and every person you know is making a fortune. You're like, yeah, but it's too expensive. I will say the difference for Buffett, of course, is he's trying to deploy what was. The CEO was trying to deploy hundreds of billions of dollars. And so the opportunity with those individual investors is, this is the cool thing. Our opportunity is multiples, orders of magnitude more.

than Buffett's which sounds weird right because Buffett said no the money he's got to deploy and the amount of time he can do and he's not he can look at the same company as us but what's he going to do with him he put 15 grand there or 100 grand there he's got to start paying divs I suspect dividends follow Buffett's death by less than three years I mean, it's just a sensible, it's just a sensible, either buy back a bunch of shares if the stock price stanks, or pay a dividend. Yep. Or at least, what are you getting, 3%, 4% at the moment? Things I'll never do, obviously, but even just buy an index ETF. Yeah. Because cash drag itself, even just keep up with the market in the meantime. That's what you're going to do, right? But just the cash drag goes, we'll be honest with you, anyway. Can I wave? Tell him how to do his job. Yeah. Warren. You've got my number. What's up? I'll show you how to do it. I'll show you how it's done. We'll be cool if you listen to the podcast. That'd be kind of fun.

That's it. I'm pulling up some job. I'm going to die happy. Well, it depends. Is he streaming at the pod machine or is he nodding? That's right. He is. He's not listening to one before money. That's totally not how I think. What would you know? If I was not listening, then I'd take it all back. He's really not. I found the meme I was thinking of.

So two things. Firstly, if you're not following Andrew on Twitter, at Sage underscore Simeon, you can go for tweets, replies, posts, replies, or media. Your media game is interesting. I have to look at that. Before you do that, I'm going to get to that point. But most of our listeners will know this because they've been listening for a while and they're smart people. You mentioned stonks or meme stocks, just as a phrase in passing. And I'm always reminded, no, I'm not always reminded, as I do it more often, I'm occasionally reminded, I should be reminded more often, that we use, even us, we try and keep jargon pretty light on this podcast because it's just garbage and nonsense.

Generally, you used to exclude rather than include people. It's not something I have to try to do. I just think it's a wank more often than not. The amount of people in our game who hide their ignorance and very low intelligence by using big fancy words is... My current least favourite is names. I've looked at some of those names when they just meet some of those companies, but names sound somehow cooler. Motley Fool Money. For more, subscribe to the free newsletter at fool.com.au forward slash listener.

What do you mean by stonks and meme stocks? If someone's listening to you going, I don't even know what that means. When you say stonks and meme stocks, what are we talking about? So I think stonks is a bit like HODL. So HODL comes from a very old Bitcoin forum post where a guy was a little bit drunk and he misspelled. He's basically saying it was one of those bear markets where it had dropped 90% to like 100 bucks or something. That blows the mind to think about. And it just became a thing. I think stonks is like that. I think it might derive... I'd have to look it up. But it's kind of... It's a derogatory term. It's kind of like...

The meme stocks comes from essentially GameStop. I believe that's where the phrase was sort of coined. It's sort of like, it's not really a real business or it's a business that is mainly dominated by what you would unfavorably call retail investors. Dumb money is the movie, right? It's dumb money. It's like, everyone's buying it, but they don't know what they're doing. They're buying it because it's going up. They're buying it because of some misreprehension as to what the business is doing, you know. Are story stocks the same thing in your mind? Is that we're in the same ballpark or are we somewhere different with meme stocks?

It's adjacent. So a story stock is something where it's kind of like there's just no fundamentals is what I read it to be. And when I say no fundamentals, it's like there's always fundamentals, but there's no good fundamentals. There's very little sales, no earnings. This thing has got a really amazing thing. It's going to go in this many markets, so this many customers want to get there. This is going to be so cool. And by the way, you see the technology and the website and they're doing some stuff with blockchain. And imagine when this thing hits the highs, that everyone goes, oh yeah, yeah, let's do that. They kind of jump into these story stocks and share price rockets. And then eventually people get bored and the share price plummets because they'll go, what are we doing here again? And the price isn't going up anymore, so I'm selling. And then of course, the other side of the mountain is a horrible fall as you come down, crashing roughly normally back to somewhere where it started before everything got

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Pretty much. I mean, and the thing is like, it's so easy to sort of be derivative of these things, but you know, there's, I mean, Amazon was a story stop at one stage. I mean, there are exceptions to the rule. You don't want to be so jaded as an investor. And I see this a lot of the professional quote unquote investing class. They would just put their nose. Actually, Jones, you'll mention that's a great example, right? The amount of, whenever I sort of speak to a fund manager or someone in the space, it is, it's sort of laughter. And I'm like, look, there are things to laugh at. I feel like I'm really sort of promoting Jones. I don't own it. All of that kind of stuff. But it's sort of like, I'm too sophisticated to even look at that.

Because just by virtue of the fact that it seems like at least on Twitter and online, most of the people looking at it are the unsophisticated, great unwashed who are just there for the vibes, right? So you... You want to be an independent thinker, I guess is what I'm saying here. And there's also a career risk, I think, with that as well, because they don't want to be the person who goes to their boss and says, hey, listen, I think we should buy this. You're going, what? Is that the one that's sort of trending on Twitter at the moment? His share price has gone up 10x and he's not making any money and it's all about these. It's all of those kinds of things, but I don't know. To my mind, what I like about meme stocks or story stocks is actually the word stocks rather than companies. Right. And that's to me where I separate the two. Story stock refers to the way the stock is being treated by.

the investors slash traders slash spruikers rather than, it doesn't really describe the company at all, right? Drone should be a terrible or wonderful company. GameStop could have been a terrible or wonderful company. When the story takes hold about the stock as opposed to, you know, a fundamental unseen of the business. I think for me, that disconnection is what defines the difference between a story stock or a mean stock or a stonk rather than a business that we've independently and cautiously and, you know, reasonably valued or understood and tried to learn about and bought at a price that we thought was reasonable. Story stock is everything other than that. It's just the exciting, new, flashy, cool thing. Everyone's making money and it just becomes, the purchasing becomes about the stock and about the company and about the price and, you know, the excitement.

rather than in five years' time, I think the profitability of this thing will be this much higher. To my mind, that's how I would probably separate the two. Yeah. I mean, I love a bit of ill-informed distortion in the market in both directions. Not because I like to see people suffer, but that's how... I mean, it's the thing we always want. I want a great company that's super cheap. It's like, well, guess what? That only happens when people are being irrational. Or I want to sell a moderately good company at a really, really stupid high price. Yes. Yep. Great. So you need all of these kinds of things that are in there. And again, it is that idea of trying to...

Walk that fine line between being an independent thinker, not so independent that you dismiss any outside perspective, right? Like everyone else is wrong and not worth listening to, so I have to do it all myself. And that's probably just as reckless. But so is just like, well, someone said this, and so I'm going to go with that as well. Everyone thinks this, so I'll join the crowd. Yeah. And as we often say on the pod, I think more often than not, well, at least for me, and I think for you as well, the answer isn't they're right or they're wrong. It's just like, actually, I don't know. And that is a very big, I would actually put that in the top five superpowers for great investors. They have that ability to say, I don't know.

It's three simple words, right? Put your ego aside for five seconds, right? It's okay not to know. This is complex stuff. And it's like, I don't want to bet on something that I don't know or I don't have a firm conviction in. It's not like there's plenty of stocks I see that I think are really cool. They've got a lot of potential.

But when I start having, as you said at the start, it's a gamble at some point because I've got to have some kind of prediction here as to what will happen in the future. If I can't have a high conviction view on that, it's like, well, the answer is don't do a damn thing. As frustrating as that can be, if you look back years ago, I remember looking at that. And it's like, yeah, but, you know, hope is not an investment strategy, as I'm fond of saying, right? And it's all of those kinds of things together, which makes this an endlessly fascinating endeavor and also a diabolically difficult and yet satisfying sort of endeavor at the same time.

Who'd be an investor? Well, we would because it's fun and it's interesting and it's worth doing. Speaking of things that are memes, I found the one I was thinking of before. Yes, yes, yes. I couldn't have put it in any sort of context and I was horribly wrong. I thought it was left and right, it was top and bottom. It's the Principal Skinner meme.

where he's saying at the top frame is, what's wrong about Bitcoin? And he's holding his hand to his chin and thinking deeply. And he looks up and says, no, the world is wrong. That's actually a great meme for a whole bunch of different reasons. In the episode, it was like, could I be wrong? It's like, no, the children are all wrong. That's very, very good. We managed to get most of the way through the podcast by even touching on some of the big macro stuff, which is lovely and a nice change. I think we both enjoyed it a bit more. A couple of things are worth...

kind of trying to touch on in a relatively short space of time, which is actually nice for us and probably nice for our listeners. I hesitate to talk about this because it's Thursday morning in the now world, but it's now yesterday morning in the then world. And if you listen to this even later than that, we might have seen more wrong and stupid because- You're 2048 and you're in a bunker somewhere listening to some archived footage. If you're in a bunker, that's probably all you've got left. You're like, you've got the podcast, all you've got left is monthly for money. All right, put it on. I say that because this stuff is moving so quickly. Wednesday.

one of the best days on the ASX in 12 months, on the back of an announcement from Iran and the US that there will be a ceasefire for at least a fortnight, while in theory things try to get sorted out. There's supposed to be a reopening of the Strait of Hormuz. Things are supposed to get back to normal. The oil price fell 14 to 15%. The ASX was up 2.74%. That was the All Lords. And everyone got really excited. And we've just finished talking about the fact that I'm never happy being an optimist or an optimist. I'd rather be an optimist or a pessimist for all the reasons you just mentioned about it. That's where the opportunities are. And so the market jumps almost 3% on the back of an announcement by all people, Trump and Iran. Oh, thank goodness. Oh, good. This is done now.

And I kind of, I mean, I like being richer. Like, I like my portfolio going up. Don't get me wrong. It was a nice day yesterday. Look at the numbers and go, oh, that's nice. But I'm kind of looking at this going, hang on. You people know who you're dealing with. You know that a fortnight is 14 days at best, assuming the ceasefire isn't broken in the meantime. You know. It's already broken, isn't it? Right. That's what I was going to get to. You know, the oil hasn't started flowing yet. And you go, oh, announcement. Good. Okay. And I'm kind of like, now I say all the time, it's possible the market was too low to start with. And so this is a relief back to some sort of abnormality. It's possible the market was too expensive and the jump up makes it even more expensive. So I'm not commenting on the absolute value, but the relative change in perspective.

between 4pm on Tuesday and 10am on Wednesday. I mean, it's a big deal. Don't get me wrong, I'm glad there's a ceasefire announced because it's better than no ceasefire announced for all the reasons, right? So I'm not that bad that I want to poo-poo every possible bit of good news or hope things are going to get better. But when your job is to be a rational pricer of assets and you see an announcement for a 14-day ceasefire between a regime that is just awful and, I'm not sure whether it's Iran or the US next, it might depend on your perspective, I suppose. But, you know, Trump has gone some combination of lying, chickening out, delaying, threatening. Iran is just, you know, miserable bastards at the best of times. And you kind of go, really?

that is worth 3% more. The full value of these companies from here to Eternity is now 3% higher because of the possibility of maybe a sustained 14-day ceasefire that may or may not lead to either resumption hostilities or something else. And yes, everything's going to be priced with a probability. And yes, there is a higher probability of oil flowing with a ceasefire than without one. So yeah, okay, okay. I just, I don't know, I don't know what your thought was, but I kind of looked at that and went, I like being richer, but I feel like we're just putting ourselves up for disappointment.

Yeah. I mean, it shows you... Yeah, what does it show you? I mean, it shows you the short-term myopic vision of the market. But again, that's not news. I mean, that always happens. I don't really get... I share your frustration, but I don't get... I've seen it... I mean, we've seen it for so many decades at this point. It's just like, I don't know how it could be any other way that the market does something dumb in both directions all the time. And as I say, it's like, this is a good thing. But selfishly, it's a good thing. It does... I do wonder that...

there feels like there's a bit of a coiled spring. Like if this thing resolves in a non-disastrous way, and that's probably the best we can sort of hope for, you know, there's a lot of stuff that's been beaten down. There's a lot of money on the sidelines. You know, I can see assets rallying very strongly if this is sort of, if it just, if the market can get a sense of just, you know. Trump moving his finger away from the proverbial button, right? It's sort of like, yeah, I can see a very, very strong rally in stocks. Again, let me hasten to add, this is not Andrew saying you should be bullish now. Because the other alternative is like, you know, there were talks of bloody nukes at once. I mean, for God's sake, anything. I wouldn't even say that with a straight face 10 years ago, right? But it's like these days, it's like, I don't know if I'd be that surprised, right? And then markets could go down 90% from here and life as we know it could be ended. So it's really wild. All I do, though, is the practical so what is...

You'll never predict that stuff because by the time this goes to where another social post is out there. And like, how are you going to predict that? You talk about gambling. You can't do it. Predicting the future is always hard, but there's just some things that are easier. As I've said before, it's like, is it a guarantee? Let's go with the Amazon example. Is it a guarantee that Amazon will be around in 10 years? Like, no, it could be found to be a fraud tomorrow. Right. And go to zero. But.

It's a reasonably high probability, I would imagine, at this stage, given their assets, given their balance sheet, given the sticky customer relationships, given the services they offer, given their competitive advantage. It's not a reckless bet, but they say that. Is a company working on AQA for cancer in the microcap end of the ASX likely to be successful? Well, they could. They absolutely could. Someone's going to do it at some stage and it'll probably come out of a little no-nothing company, right? But the odds aren't good. So what is going to happen on the geopolitical front in the next, frankly, three, four years? I have no idea. Is this business that I'm looking at likely? It's always my starting point. Are you around in 10 years?

And are you earning more money at that point? If the answer to those questions are no, it's like it's dead in the water. There's no point proceeding from that point. And again, I'll never know for sure. I'll never know for sure. But it's like some bets are just easier than others. You know, it's like you can go to the casino, right? And pick a number and put your chips on that number on the roulette table. And if you win, what is it? 36 times? I don't know. It's pretty good. Pretty nice, right? It's a pretty good return, right? Or I could just go red or black. Now, I'm not going to win as much, but I'm going to win roughly half the time. Don't at me, math nerds. I know this is zero. You know what I mean?

Yeah, right. But you are always in the probabilistic domain. Some things are more probable than others, right? So lean into the more probable things. And I think anyone who is investing, this is why just any single cent I put into the market, even if it's a relatively inconsequential amount relative to the overall portfolio, I'm only putting money in that I do not expect to need for at least three years.

Now, it might be that tomorrow it goes up 10x and I sell it. Great, I'll take the money and run. But that's not my expectation. If I'm going to put money here, I have to at least allow for various things to come and go and wash over and for the business to prove itself. These things just sort of take time. So when I'm looking at the current geopolitical situation, no clue. No clue how it's going to resolve. But history would probably suggest it will resolve one way or the other. And in three years' time, it might not.

it'd be a relatively distant memory. I remember the GFC is a distant memory already, right? And how big a deal was that? COVID's already starting to fade from consciousness, right? And it's hard to imagine bigger things as they were unfolding. And I'm not saying that the world's gone great since then. I would, you know me, mate, I would probably argue that actually we're dealing with consequences where the seeds were sort of set back in those times. But the ability to look past the immediate, even the medium term there, and just sort of say that there is something on the other side of that. And there's probably a world where, you know, I guess short of complete Armageddon, where...

you know, people are making things, other people are buying things and someone's delivering value and receiving reward in return. And you can share in that, right? And it's just sort of, I think all of the best investments I've made, I've made this point many times, it's just sort of been, you buy something and then you just have a year or two of complete and utter frustration and looking like an idiot. And then all of a sudden things just go incredibly well. And it's not because you could have picked the timing on all this stuff, but you just, you forced yourself not to have an investment thesis that was predicated on what will happen in the immediate time. And that's what wronged for so many people. It's like, I come across a lot of investors who buy very well in the sense that,

It's a great company. It's a good price. I don't need the money for a while. It's a long-term investment. I'm going to buy it. It's like, great. I have no notes. That is excellent. And then three months later, like, how's it going? I sold out. Like, why? Oh, because Trump did this. Like, whoa, whoa, whoa. That was never part of your thesis. Yeah, but now in reality, you'll rationalize it and you'll use a lot of big words, but you got scared. You doubted yourself and you freaked out and you sold. And, you know, again, we all do that at times, but it's sort of like you've got to try and make these bets where you're not.

You are not beholden to these near-term events and just continually remind yourself of that when they happen because it's going to happen. And once this resolves, there'll be something else, right? Who knows who's after Trump, right? Maybe we've got four more terms of Trump who changes the rules and anything can happen. Maybe Barron's running the US at a point in time and things get far, far, far worse. I think most of the time, most people are doing sensible things. Most of the time, humanity will struggle forward, right? We're an innovative species, you know?

There's a lot of creative, hardworking people out there and, you know, you can participate in their success no matter how messy and confusing and scary the world is. It's just not going to be a straight line. Make your peace with that and you just move forward in a better way. And I'm rambling at this point. No, I think you're right. I think the, yeah, it's why you kind of had the point earlier that the, you know, the announcement was made, the market went up and then overnight before we traded again, I was like, oh, actually another straight's going to close again because something else has happened. Yeah. And ironically, and again, we're doing this at a point in time, it doesn't really matter. And you're right, I know I don't care about it in the sense that I don't.

I care about it because I'm half our listeners and readers and members and viewers and stuff because you and I are like, here we go again, you know, whatever. Is there an opportunity to just ignore it? You're absolutely right. For most people, they are asking me to explain why it happened, whether they should be worried or excited or happy or sad or whatever. It's that kind of, that idea of the market giving you a signal that somehow you have to respond to. And we will say it a gazillion times, welcome to this podcast, ignore the market. Don't let the market tell you what to think or how to think or what to believe or what something's worth. Do it yourself. But there are...

Countless people, mate, and I'm sure you have the same. Well, Mark's up. Is that good? Mark's up. Is that bad? Had a relative of mine asking whether it was a big deal and that oil was being bought in Euro and, you know, should I worry about that? It's like, no, it's a thing. No, don't worry about it. It's all the stuff that kind of people worry about because they see prices moving and they assume incorrectly most of the time, maybe not most of the time, but they assume incorrectly that the market has something to tell them. And I say most of the time because most of it does. Most of it's roughly right, and that's okay.

But the shorter the timeframe and the more specific the movement, the less it has to tell you, generally speaking. Again, there are differences, but that's kind of where things are. So that's kind of my interest in it is just that idea of, it's another example to remind people, ironically, as you said, not to pay attention. You know, here's a big deal. Okay, good, so what's the lesson? Don't ignore it. That doesn't seem right. I know, but ignore it because it's not telling you anything other than what the market's thinking or feeling right now, which is not useful to you unless you're trying to take the other side of that trade and God forbid, you try and out-trade or out-think or out-sentiment the market because that's just a mad...

effort just don't do it so that's kind of my take is just that but then as you said the ceasefire has already been effectively broken I don't know that around Lebanon was involved in the original one but now they're doing stuff and yeah it's just the whole thing is mad and so It's why I think the market would have reacted on the upside. And so it is why I would caution people when those things happen, don't get too excited. Just so it's on the downside. That's why this is important. Because you make the point a lot, mate, that volatility is the fancy way we used to mean losses. You use volatility when it's up with volatility. Right, exactly. But that's why it's important that when the market is up, we still say the same thing. It's exactly why we need to, which is, it is just volatility. If the market was down 2.75 yesterday or up 2.75 yesterday, this is Wednesday I'm talking about, it doesn't tell you how people are feeling right now. And so it's really important for me, if we're going to say, when losses happen, yeah, guys, this happens sometimes, just chill out, don't worry about it. As long as you own quality companies, as long as you pay good prices, as long as the businesses have a future.

Don't sweat the price movements. We've got to be consistent for our own sake and for credibility. And because it's just true, that the same is true on the upside when you have these big movements. And that goes up over time. So you're more likely to have more ups than downs, hopefully. And ups are likely to be bigger than downs over time, hopefully. But the volatility on the upside, it's every bit as common. And we shouldn't just do the whole, you know, wins are my good management, losses are my bad luck. In the short term, ups and downs are just the market having a different view, getting on a different side of the bed and going, how do I feel now? Or trying to guess somehow they can outtrade geopolitics. I just think it's nonsense. So it's why I wanted to raise the point. I think it is important when there are wins.

to do the same as you do in their losses, which is the slave behind the Roman general saying, you are mortal, you didn't deserve this, you didn't earn this, you didn't deserve the downs, you don't deserve to earn the ups in daily chunks, monthly chunks. Over time, if you're right about the businesses you own, that value will out. If you own an index ETF and you bought at a reasonable price, your dollar cost averaging and markets create value, that value will out. Just don't get too caught up in trying to diagnose, understand, respond to these big movements in either direction. One of the – I've got to find where I read this originally. There's some research which is going to sound so right when you hear it. I'm sure you've read it before. When you're talking about daily movements, so what happened on the market on one particular day, the biggest daily gains are observed in bear markets. And the biggest daily falls are in bull markets. In other words, let's say the market is on its way top to bottom to a 30% or 40% correction, a really bad bear market.

Along the way, you will have some of the best performing days you will ever see where the market is up 4%, 5%. In terms of like indices, that's huge moves, insanely big moves. And it's like, it doesn't feel right. It doesn't feel, because it sort of had these death by a thousand cuts with these interspersed with these big, big short term, literally like one day kind of rallies and then down we go again. And it's the head mess, not swear, where things are going up in a long term structural bull market. And yet you have all these.

3% down days along the way. And it's just like, it's confusing the weather for the climate is probably the best way to sort of understand all of that stuff. And I'll tell you a little story. I said to you a few weekends ago, I caught up some old schoolmates. We get together every now and again. I haven't seen them for a while. And obviously when we get together, I talk stocks and other things. And anyway, so the last time I was going on about Catapult, which I've been fond of and a disclosure, I own a bunch of shares. And one of my mates was like, oh man, you picked it. It was like a dollar, right? I was like, what is it now? It's like three something, like 350. It's like, yeah, but it's like, oh, nicely done. That was a great return. My other mate goes, what are you talking about? It was like $6.

Like six months ago. And it's so, it was so funny. They're both right. They're both right. And one person's looking at you and going, yeah, that was a really good investment. I wish I'd listened to you. The other person going, oh, I'm so glad I didn't because if I did, I would have seen it go from six to 350. It's like, it's that volatility again that's sort of screwing with you there. It's like, yeah, but it was really, really cheap. And like, even despite the fall, it's still like a triple and then change, right? Like, and that is, it is that, I don't want to dox my mate here, but he's that guy, right? Who is just sort of like,

If it's not perfect, it's a fail, you know, when it comes to investing. You buy low, if by him it's like, it's the bottom tick, top tick, that's a successful trade. What about the lowest price? You've paid too much, still anything below the top level, you've sold it too early. Yeah. Which my comment is like, have you ever done that? He did it once and you just keep dining out on that. It's just done like, you never do it. Do you want to make really good risk-adjusted returns on average over time? Or do you want to sound really clever and just have your...

just faceplant time after time after time and then occasionally get lucky it's a classic gambler fallacy almost you know it's like that person who just sits at the slot machine just loses loses loses hey one yeah see i know what i'm doing loses loses loses and it's like it's no way to live your life a and it's certainly it's certainly no way to invest and i think it's the easiest thing in the world to sort of say yeah don't worry about all this stuff because you sound you sound like a simpleton and you sound you sound like a reckless simpleton uh but but you know it's kind of true and it's not that nothing matters it's just like you've got to focus on what actually matters and and a lot of these things let me let me also hasten they matter a great deal for a great number of people but just in the investment realm um these these things uh are not what do you think that you think that you're just gonna wait for war and conflict to stop and then you're gonna invest and and politicians are gonna stop doing stupid things and corruption is gonna go and all our major problems around the world are gonna be solved and then you're gonna invest like it's just there's always something there's always something pick any random point in history in fact the only Whenever you get a scenario where things look really good and there's no storm clouds, it's probably the time. I mean, statistically, that's usually the most reckless time. That's when reality just comes out and just slaps you across the face and go, oh, feeling confident about the future, are we? How about a little pandemic? Whack, you know? How about a geopolitical conflict between superpowers? Whack, you know? How about this, this, this, this, and this? And, you know, it's just- I know a time despite that. All things have happened and will happen again. And different things have happened and different things will happen next time. And it'll be similar enough and different enough. And that's kind of the point. That's where you end up with if you do this.

properly is you've got to invest through that stuff. You mentioned your mate and the kind of idea of top and bottom and it's, ex-college you guys used to, Joe Maggie used to like the line, everyone said it, but it's just a line, especially with him as well, which is just, do you want to be right or do you want to make money? Yeah. And it's kind of like, so hang on, if I buy a reasonably good price but not the bottom and sell at a reasonably good price but not the top and do that over and over again, I'm going to make a lot of money. Yeah. So I'm going to obsess over, oh, I left a dollar on the table here or 15 cents on the table there. I can. And I can obsess about being perfect. I'm going to be perfect, the enemy, the good. And I'm not right on this. Oh, I'll try and do that, try and do that. It's like your, it's Buffett's, and you've made this

A seven-foot bar is, I'm going to make an investing career, or just a career professional, I mean, with your portfolio, right? I'm going to be a lifetime investor. I'm going to spend my entire time trying to work out a way to clear seven-foot bars. Meanwhile, the bloke behind, besides you, is stepping over one foot bars going, eh, reasonable value, eh, not great value, buy, sell. Some more decent value, I can't buy there. A bit expensive, I can't sell now, I'll move on. Or I won't sell at all. I'll just step over the one foot bar and keep walking. That is the, it's a beautiful analogy because it's just so true. You've got really to work out what you're trying to achieve here. Because if your aim is, as it should be, I want to amass sufficient wealth so I can have a comfortable life. I mean, everyone has their own wine, knock yourself out, but you know, for most people, I hope that resonates. Okay, so how do I get to that point? How do I most easily, most reliably get to that point? How do I get to that point without risking blowing the whole thing up?

and having too many sleepless nights and too much stress and too much self-loathing, how do I get there in a very simple and repeatable way? And the answer is just kind of be roughly right as often as you can. You know, the precision of I must do the top, I must do the bottom or I made a mistake and I sold two elements was a mistake. Objectively, if you want to look at it that way, you didn't sell the very, very highest price. So were you perfect? Does the Russian judge hold up a 10? No. You don't need a 10 from the Russian judge. You need a six on average from the judges more often than not. That's success if you, you know, ego is so caught up. I need to be smart. I need to be better. I need to, I need to, I need to. So you can do that.

We can just do the thing that actually helps you amass enough wealth to have a comfortable life. I get it, Raymond. I really, really get it for some people. I get personality types, and I get misunderstandings of the market, and I get the drive for perfection and better, and I get the emotional feeling of, oh, you've said before, some of your companies sold too early for the price to rise. Like, oh, I'm an idiot. I can't believe that. But you've got that. You're trying to make your piece of that stuff. That is investing, right?

That's what this is. There is no version of the future where you always buy at the cheapest price and always sell at the best price. You're seeing yourself a failure. It's total luck, you know. It's that once in a lifetime. Right, exactly, exactly. Unlike my Bitcoin purchase, which was at a peak and has never been there since. I get the reverse really, really well. I'm good at that. I'm not so good at that. Me too, me too. Mate, I think we've probably come to the end of our conversation, which has been thoroughly enjoyable. I'm going to be different in recent times, which was lovely because we talked about stocks almost the entire time and investing, and we love doing that. So if you enjoyed this, then thanks for listening. I would like to believe that.

We won't talk about Macro next week, but the world's a funny old place and seven days is a long time. A week's a long time in politics, right? It's an eternity in geopolitics. So we will see what happens. In the meantime, though, I reckon we take a bit of time out and some questions on Sunday. Would it be so good as to come back? I always enjoy the Mailbag episode because we're actually talking about stuff that people want to hear about rather than our hobby horses. So yes, looking forward to it. Which usually for us is regular magnanimous because we'd rather talk about us, let's be honest. It's far more interesting. And important. Enough about me. What do you think about me, Andrew? Until Sunday, hopefully, with not too much self-referencing. Full on. Cheers.

The Motley Fool and people appearing in this program may have positions in the companies mentioned. General advice only. Please speak to your financial professional to understand how it may pertain to your situation. Subscribe to the free newsletter at fool.com.au forward slash listener. The Motley Fool operates under financial services license 400691.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Motley Fool Money?

This episode is 1 hour and 12 minutes long.

When was this Motley Fool Money episode published?

This episode was published on April 10, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Motley Fool Money episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.