Hey, Obsessors. This is Julia. You know I am all about getting obsessed with your big ideas and turning those dreams into actual businesses. I work with entrepreneurs every single day, and so many of my clients rave about Shopify. And I get why. Beautiful storefronts, easy setup, and even an AI assistant called Sidekick to help you along the way. And listen, Black Friday is coming. Why not get your business?
up and running before the holiday shopping rush. Are you ready to launch? Go to Shopify.com to start your free trial. That's Shopify.com. Go to Shopify.com today so you can start hearing. This is Believe. One network, every topic, everywhere.
From the Homestead Studios in Santa Clarita, California, this is a Headache Soul production. Welcome to Just the Tipsters, America's favorite true crime podcast. I'm your host, Melissa Morgan. With me today is my handsome and talented co-host, Joshua Noodles Bevin. Noodles? He thinks all jobs take two minutes. Okay. That's about... Like ramen. Like ramen noodles. Wow. I couldn't even pull it. I stumped you. You did. Well, I went everywhere with that. I was thinking like pasta. Maybe I don't really understand how to like catch catfish. Like, you know.
I went everywhere. Do you want me to get you another nickname? That was the least exciting thing I've ever heard. I thought it was so perfect. Wow. You were stunned. Of all the names I could give you, I thought Noodles was the perfect Joshua Noodles Bevan because he thinks all jobs take two minutes. But no. I saw your eyes glaze over and you're like...
it was the craziest thing i'd ever seen all the math equations yeah flinging by my head like algebra yeah on a chalkboard yeah wow okay i guess we're gonna file that one away as the first and only failure nickname all right well there's always next week i'll try harder okay i have a backup if you want for next week no i have a i have about 20 more sure yeah do you make another shock you back into reality no no i'm good i'm with you are you really though are you okay Because you still look like someone stuck a finger up your butthole and you were not expecting it. That's how you catch catfish. Okay. Do you mean like online or in a pond? No, no, actual catfish. It's called noodling. You hold dog food in your fist and they come and they eat it with your hand and then you kind of grab them and you have your hand inside their mouth. This is how you find girlfriends, isn't it? Yeah. But there's no noodles involved. Noodling.
Why is it called noodling? Maybe use yesterday's spaghetti. Like maybe it's not just dog food. You said dog food. Well, I've heard dog food works. Your theory is terrible. And why did you call it noodling? It should be called food. I've never actually done it. Because it isn't a real thing. Because it's not. You catch catfish by putting up a fake profile online. Sure. That too. Yeah. A profile of a, like an eight year old or something. Don't do that. Yeah. No, that's hilarious. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Should we just start over?
The worst. So many people are just starting. This is our first episode. I thought this was about murder. That boy's murdering a catfish or something. I don't know. And then that woman is trying to eat noodles. It's our recipe and murder podcast. Noodles and Catfish with Josh Amell. Oh my God. Okay, so let's just transition.
Again, if you are still following the Nancy Guthrie case, I just want to suggest you look on YouTube for Brian Enten, E-N-T-I-N. And if you know anything, please call 1-800-CALL-FBI. And there are little details that are coming out from the Sheriff's Department. They're looking at previous dates in the neighborhood, the 11th of January and the 24th of January, the Saturday before Nancy was taken. They're looking at neighbors' ring camera footage. They're asking about any odd activity, if people can remember. So yeah, please check out Brian Enten's work on Facebook. He is...
um the most reliable a wonderful guy he's gone back home to his uh home in florida but he was the one that hung out there the longest he was there for like 42 days and it's been 45 days and he's like my dog misses me i miss my dog you know so i i give him lots of props and he's still on the case even though you know it's it's become much more elongated than any of us could have imagined so so this case this week was sent to me a few weeks ago by tipster Mary. And she is obviously a really wonderful human. I don't know where she lives, but she does not live in Florida, where most of this case takes place, but some of the people have moved to different states avoiding the law. But Mary is such a sweet human being. She said, you know, I don't know if you've heard of this case of Sarah Gale Ebersole in Reddick, Florida, R-E-D-D-I-C-K. She's a missing mother that's been gone for three years now. Thank you to her sister, Michelle Crystal Tullis, T-U-L-L-I-S.
She is the one actively advocating for Sarah. And her sister, Michelle, I just have to tell you, you know, I've said this potentially five times in over 300 episodes. This is the person you would want as your family member, your advocate. Michelle is, you know, working so hard to find her sister, Sarah. Her sister, Sarah, was like maybe 24. I'll get the age in a moment when we get into her actual case.
But Michelle keeps pushing. This is a case, and I hate to report this, but it sounds like the Marion County Sheriff's Office in Florida has not lived up to what their job is to serve and protect. I believe it was because Sarah's position was as an exotic dancer. Oh, so they're not valuing her life. Yes, her life. And her sister Michelle has done things like sell her plasma.
to get money to investigate her sister's disappearance. And she said, thank God I have that RHA blood. It's gold. I mean, it makes me want to cry. The things that, you know, she's started to go fund me. I mean, I don't, this case is so layered. I'm going to try to make it a little shorter because the details are so overwhelming. It could be like a multi-part episode and I don't want it to be confusing. There are a few, you know, people involved, but I just want you to keep.
This, you know, beautiful sentiment from Mary in mind. Sarah matters. Sarah's daughter's life matters. Michelle needs answers. This is, you know, again, Mary wrote the most lovely email and said she loved the way that we covered cases. So this case had actually even appeared on the Nancy Grace show. But it's so hard for me to explain to people.
TV may have a wider coverage in the immediacy. And then most people don't go looking for Nancy Grace episodes. People are constantly finding podcasts. It's in the cloud. It's constantly coming up. I have people contact me for cases we've done two, three, four years ago.
So that's one of the things that I love most. A podcast may have a smaller audience at first, but it's just out there and people find them. I mean, Nancy Grace's shows are out there too on YouTube or wherever you want to go. TV shows you can always find on YouTube if you know exactly what to look for. I just find, you know, you put it in a search engine. I find if I need to find something about a specific case or victim, I go to my Apple podcast and type in their name. Yeah, absolutely. It's just easier to find.
So in my mind, that's why I'm in the podcast world. You know, I mean that many, many other reasons, but we're doing this for Mary and for Michelle and for Sarah and for Sarah's daughter. So we're going to try to start at the beginning, but let me just tell you, this one is the, one of the most wild rides I've ever, the more I, I took a long time to get back to Mary cause I was looking into the case and I was like, this seems like a, a weird, like Quentin Tarantino movie. Oh wow. It's so, it's so layered. So Sarah Ebersole.
was born in 1966. So I guess she went missing at the age of 25. The youngest of seven siblings, she grew up in Sarasota, Florida, mostly with a maternal uncle and aunt. Sometimes in her teen years, she would stay with an older sister in Dunnellan. In 2014, she's 18 years old and she marries Thomas Allen Eversole. At the time, she's Sarah Van, B-A-N-N. They moved to Dunnellan and their marriage is very short-lived, like a year and a half. They get divorced on November 5th of 2015.
So at the time of her disappearance, Sarah is living with a roommate in Reddick, Florida, and she worked as an exotic dancer. And that was part of what Mary thought was holding law enforcement back. Was her operation. Yeah. And she's a beautiful girl. She looks very girl next door. Beautiful, long blonde hair, blue eyes, just a lovely, beautiful skin, beautiful smile. You know, so we're in 2023 now. She's last seen March 2nd of 2023.
And by that time, I guess she's 26 years old. January 23rd of 2023, she messages her sister Michelle and said, look, I have to change my phone number because my ex-boyfriend, because I don't think they were ever married. She's divorced from Thomas Eversol. She is with a boyfriend named Joe Mayton, M-A-Y-2-1. He had been illegally logging into her Gmail account, monitors everything she does, her location, her emails, her photos, her texts. So by January 29th of 2023, she has a new iPhone.
Now, March 2nd, a little over a month later, she gets dropped off at 7 p.m. when she gets out of work and wants her sister to come and get her. And Michelle's like, I can't do that. I'm busy right now. So at 7.50, and we're just kind of going through a timeline here, 7.50 p.m., she sends another message to her sister, Michelle, say hi to your kids for me.
So Sarah is waiting in the area of the Circle K gas station on Highway 441 in Reddick. And that seems like a place where, you know, like a convenience store where you hang out in a small town and everybody kind of, somebody's going to come in to get a pack of cigarettes or something. You know, you're going to find someone you know who might give you a lift home. Gotcha. Okay. So there is a man nicknamed Bubba. His real name is James Robinson.
He pulls in at 1010 and he has another friend with him and they're, you know, hanging out at the Circle K, getting gas, getting cigarettes. And at 1011, Sarah sends a text to her sister, Michelle, and says. I am getting into a random truck with some cowboys and I hope they take me on a ride. Now she knew Bubba, but it was still, you know, this is what she sends to her sister. And she'd taken a picture of her and Bubba and sent it. And I have to say Bubba looked insane. Bubba's kind of a little pudgy dude and his eyes are like this. I think he was just like so excited to be in the company of a pretty girl. His eyes are like, look at me. Some of us are less photogenic. He's actually a cute little round, you know, he looks like the Pillsbury Dome boy. Big blue eyes. Yeah. James Robinson, AKA Bubba. So.
They go back to Bubba's home, which is a duplex. So he lives on one side. They call it a subdivided residence, but in California, they're called a duplex. So a subdivision is like a group of homes, but a subdivided residence, I guess, instead of saying like a townhouse or a condo, it's a duplex. So Bubba lives on one side and a couple, James and Teresa, no, James and Tisha.
live on the other side. And they all kind of get together at, you know, 10, 15 and have a little party. Who knows what they're doing? You know, drinking, having smoking pot. I have no idea what they're doing. They could just be, you know, smoking clove cigarettes. Sure. And the other, the other guy that was in the truck is gone now or is he's there? He leaves a little later. Okay. Like at one in the morning. Got it. So, um, it's now one 22 and you know, Sarah's iCloud shows there's some, you know, she's taking pictures of the group having gone goofing off. I mean, she's 25. That's what you're going to do. So.
James Bubba Robinson begins texting a man named Tyrone Mormon. Now, it turns out that's probably his drug dealer. Okay. And he, you know, there, he's like, oh, Sarah's at my house. We're all hanging out. Why don't you come over and bring a bag of whatever, you know, whatever, whatever. And Tyrone Mormon says, hey, would Sarah be interested in hanging out with me? And Bubba, Bubba Robinson says, James Bubba Robinson says, yeah, sure. Come on over. So Tyrone Morgan comes over at one, no, two, is it two 40, two 40. And yeah, so like an hour and a half later and he shows up in a blue 2017 Hyundai Sonata.
And at 4 a.m., he leaves with Sarah. Now, we cannot talk to James Bubba Robinson anymore because he died of a drug overdose. But before he died, he spoke to the Marion County Sheriff's Office and said, Tyrone Mormon took Sarah in his car and I helped him carry her to the car. Oh, she was out. Right. And either inebriated or unable to walk. Right. So 4 a.m., Tyrone Mormon leaves with Sarah.
So there are witnesses who said, I saw a Hispanic male in his mid 30s with long hair and a thin build taking Sarah in his car. We thought maybe it was an Uber because she was like incapacitated. The police determined Sarah had not called for an Uber and they thought, well, maybe she got an off the books Uber driver or a third party. And I was like, well, OK, you can throw out all the things you want, but it's Tyrone Mormon. Right. You know, we find out later it's Tyrone Mormon's girlfriend's car. Right. Registered her.
So Sarah has a roommate. Now, her roommate was on a retreat. Her roommate is a female veteran and she was on a retreat. When she comes home, she finds that Sarah's cigarettes and lighter are on the porch. Her shoes that she was wearing when she left on March 3rd are gone. There's no struggle at the house and there's no dirty clothes anywhere as if she had come home to change. But her cigarettes and lighter are on the porch and she had over a thousand dollars cash on her that night when she went missing.
So I don't know if they brought her home first because there are some things missing. Toothbrush, hairbrush, makeup brushes. And... A binder that her sister Michelle had put together for her with all of the legal documentation she would need to get her daughter back from her ex-boyfriend, Joseph Maiden. His criminal history, data from all of his cases from 2019, 2000, a teddy bear with Dahlia on it from the day that her daughter was born. Her daughter's original name was Dahlia Marie Van. And then her, I guess her boyfriend potentially adopted her or maybe not legally adopted her, but they changed her name.
legally to Cora Dahlia Mayton. Okay. So all of the legal paperwork that was in a manila envelope that showed that Dahlia's name went from Dahlia Marie to Cora Dahlia, that's all missing. Okay. Okay. So sometimes in the early morning hours of March 3rd, Tyrone Moorman is shown with Sarah at a 24-hour convenience store. I don't know if that maybe she had sobered up or I don't know how they see her. Maybe she's just in the car. Okay. So two days later, it's actually, I guess, one day later because it was overnight. That was overnight. Okay. March 5th of 2023, Marion County Sheriff's Office receives a missing person report.
about Sarah Eversol. Her roommate said, I haven't seen her since March 2nd when I left for my retreat. Her sister, Michelle Tullis, has been unable to identify her. So a deputy responds to the residence. Now, why does it take 10 days? I don't have the answer. March 15th, detectives are assigned to the case as part of their responsibility as major crimes detective.
It took 10 days to assign a detective? A missing persons report is taken March 5th. March 15th, a detective is assigned and Tyrone Mormon is identified as a person of interest because he's the last person to see her. And they say assigned to the disappearance and presumed death of Sarah Eversol. Oh, she's already presumed dead. In their eyes. After 10 days, sure. 13 days. Now, if I...
Wow. Is that common? No. Okay. That's what I'm saying. I don't, it feels like a failure and I do not want to call out Marion County Sheriff's office, but it feels like, and again, and we got more to go and you're going to see some moves they made that are, you know, Michelle politely refers to them as unprofessional. It's, it's, it's more than that. She's, she's being, I think she's trying to toe the line in case there's legal. Right. Yeah. You don't, you don't want to start blaspheming or point fingers, slander, slandering people. All right. So I'm going to show Joshua.
From 2005 to 2024, I'd like to show you the legal charges against Joseph Maiden. Oh, my God. Well, OK. Yeah, he's. Oh, my God. One and a half, eight and a half by 11 pages of report charges, full on charges. Yeah. Wow. For contempt of court eviction. Let's see.
Two men in a truck, a moving company versus Joseph Maiden because he stopped payment. Okay. Car accident, arrest, his custody attorney, I guess Michelle had filed after Sarah went missing, had filed for conservatorship of Cora. He has a custody attorney and that man, his attorney, Susan, for non-payment. Oh, geez. Yeah. So we can't go over all of this because this would be a really long, right? Okay. So, and this is, I don't want to get out of order, but.
He does some very shady shit, like applies for medical benefits for Cora in Florida when he's in Kentucky. And that was in February of 2024. She's been missing for a year. Oh, boy. Right. But it's in her name. OK, so.
October of 2023, Michelle realizes she is going to have a fight on her hands because Joseph Mayton fled with Cora. Okay. So she starts a GoFundMe. She says, you know, I'm trying to get custodianship of my niece. My sister has been missing actively for seven months. We suspect foul play. I applied for custodianship of my five-year-old niece after my sister went missing. The court, here's the part that breaks my heart. The court has dismissed my case because, you know, I don't, I guess Joseph Mayton has proved that he adopted her. Okay.
Now the other party and who is considered one of the suspects and my sister's missing persons case has been awarded also attorney fees. Wow. I have 60 days to come up with the first part of the attorney fees or they will file contempt of court and charge me with more attorney fees. Oh my God. My sister loved her daughter more than anything. It's my duty to save my niece from this monster. Okay.
He it's not disputed that he's the father. Is he? Well, I don't know if that's why they changed the name. I don't know. She divorces Thomas Ebersole. And then Dahlia's name was Van, even though they were married. So maybe Joe is legally the father. Oh, OK. Van came from her maiden name. And then she changed Dahlia's Dahlia Marie Van to Cora Dahlia Mayton. Gotcha. OK.
I don't know the history. Okay. November 7th of 2023, Marion County Sheriff's Office makes a Facebook post that is ridiculous. We know that this investigation has been the subject of much speculation on social media, including by those who are trying to conduct their own investigation into Sarah's disappearance. Yeah, her sister, because you're not doing fucking shit. Right, exactly. The Marion County Sheriff's Office post goes on to say, worse yet, they may falsely accuse somebody of having taken part in a crime, which not only subjects an innocent person to harassment and ridicule.
And then there's nothing left. Not only does it do A, there is no B. For what it's worth, detectives have confirmed Sarah did not order, for what it's worth, you don't need, did not order any Uber services on the night of her disappearance, but have not ruled out the possibility that she could have left with a third party. Detectives are actively working to investigate whether that occurred, including determining whether a Gainesville-based Uber driver who owned a dark-colored sedan would give Sarah an off-the-books ride on March 3rd. Besides investigating these possibilities, detectives are investigating additional tips that point to the involvement of other persons in Sarah's disappearance. Okay. The other person being Tyrone. Okay, so on December 5th of 2023, you know, what, nine, ten months after her sister's been missing, Michelle starts a petition to demand that the Marion County Sheriff's Office subpoena cell phone records for the people involved.
Sure. I mean, wouldn't they have done that first off? I would have. That would have been as a detective 10 days later when I was first assigned. I think. I think I would have started the process of that. I think that they, you know, let a lot of stuff drop because they thought, oh, she's, you know, an exotic dancer. She went off with somebody and that's her life. Yeah.
Yeah. OK. I mean, yeah. After nine months of persistence, December 2023, Michelle said she secured permission to search the area north of U.S. Highway 441 to search for her. Marion County Search and Rescue, along with volunteers and search dogs, conducted a thorough search and the area has been taped off. December 7th, forensic investigators examined the area, but nothing suspicious was found. Marion County sheriffs remained on the scene with a guard posted overnight after three search dogs alerted to something on the property.
Something. Yep. Not specific. Okay. 12 days later, December 19th, 2023, detectives obtain a search warrant for Tyrone Mormon's Apple iPhone. Now this is almost a year after. Jeez. To examine and search data and seize data, including application information, call logs, text messages, logs of content, photos, videos, GPS location. So now this has been phenomenal. December 20th.
Tyrone Mormon, there's been no contact with Sarah Ebersole and her friends or family, including her young daughter. She would never have left her five-year-old daughter. There's been no activity on her social media accounts or financial transactions. Her normal life pattern ceased as of March 3rd, and her remains have not been found. Tyrone Mormon was the last person to be seen with her. At 9.30 a.m. on December 20th, detectives respond to Tyrone Mormon's place of employment.
During normal working hours, they make contact with a business owner who said, oh, he's not working at this time and I don't know when he's coming back. So they're covering for him. So they go to his residence. Yeah. And there's a blue Hyundai Sonata matching the description of the vehicle used.
You know, and it's owned by him. Well, actually, it's owned by his girlfriend, Shayla Richardson. At 1043, after 45 minutes of knocking on the door, Tyrone Mormon exits the front door and walks into the yard. Detectives ask Tyrone Mormon why he had not returned calls and missed his scheduled appointment to allow the Marion County Sheriff's Office to extract contents of his cell phone. And he said, you know, everything he said, he's already said.
Everything I said, I already said. I told you that in our first interview. People are blaming me for being involved in something and law enforcement is causing issues at his workplace, which is interesting because they had only been there an hour and 15 minutes earlier. He wasn't there that day. So did somebody let him know? Yeah. Oh, boy. Tyrone Norman says, oh, that phone was trashed.
When detectives say, where's it located? He goes, oh, it's broken. And I threw it in a trash can one and a half weeks ago. The phone was completely non-functional and I disposed of it at work. I'm planning on getting a new phone soon. Yeah, because you can go without a phone for a week and a half. That's a thing these days. Yeah, when you're a drug dealer. Oh boy. Okay. Because his pager was offline.
I did write the correct years. Yeah, it's 2023. And his abacus was not working. And his sundial, it hasn't been sunny in Florida. Usually I get a drug dealer request by Carrier Pigeon. Because Carrier Pigeon had a hurt leg. So, yeah. Okay. So, ironically, detectives had appeared at his girlfriend, Shayla Richardson's place of employment, to talk about the investigation. So, Shayla Richardson says, well, he didn't break his iPhone. I don't know what you're talking about. He hasn't gotten a new one.
He dropped me off at work around 10 o'clock. I don't know how that's unless they didn't get there till right after 10 at his house. But when he dropped me off at work this morning, he still had his iPhone with him. So Tyrone Mormon is is, you know, based on the information from Sheila Richardson are, hey, you lied to us. So we are going to arrest you. So they arrest him at 337 in the afternoon as a person who is knowingly and willfully provided false information with the intent to mislead or impede an investigation.
We're now in 2024, early 2024. An unknown individual renewed Cora's medical and dental benefits in Florida under Sarah's name, Sarah, who's been missing for 11 months now, despite Joseph Mayton residing in Kentucky at the time. Okay. So, all right. So that's just renewing them. That's not. Yeah, but you have to have a live person. Oh, it has to. You actually have to show up. Like I couldn't renew my benefits under Mark's name. Mark's been dead for. Right. She's been missing for 11 months. But there's no death certificate. Good point.
It's not. Yeah. Good point. So here's some more. Sorry, Bench Warren. Oh, boy. I know. It was another page. Sorry. All right. May 18th of 2024, Bubba Robinson dies. He's found by his roommate from a drug overdose. And he was the last kind of like living witness who said, look, Tyrone Mormon took him in his 2017 blue Hyundai Sonata. Right. So listen to this shit. I don't even I feel so terrible about this whole.
Mary is right. Sarah's life matters. Cora's life matters. Michelle, her sister, is doing the job of an entire detective department. And this is just awful. Yeah. Okay. August of 2024, a year and a half after Sarah's been missing, her ex-husband, Thomas Allen Ebersole, is arrested and indicted for transporting a minor with the intent to gauge in sexual activity. Oh.
Just some other random charge. This is not related to the case, but just let you know. That's the kind of thing he's up to. He drove from his residence in Florida to Ohio to where the minor lived. They met up on World of Warcraft. Online games. He picked her up and drove her back to Florida where they engaged in sexual activity. The minor stayed in his home until January 3rd. So about five days from December 28th to January 3rd.
Law enforcement was able to identify her location through the internet protocol address she used to play video games online. She's been sexually assaulted. Now she's at his house playing video games. After law enforcement removed the minor from Ebersole's home, DNA results confirmed that she had engaged, that Ebersole had engaged with activity. Yeah. Yeah. So things are slowing down because it's been...
you know, um, a year or so after she, you know, a year and a half now. And Michelle is still trying to post things on, um, on Facebook, like, you know, please keep my sister's case, you know, in your, you know, in your top of mind. So she says, um, DCF is looking to speak with Joseph Mayton and it's pretty sure this is the, you know, adopted a real father of Cora, not the, not the ex-husband. They're looking for him in Naples, Florida. My niece, Cora Maiden, age six, has been traveling with him in a 2021 Hyundai Santa Fe that's silver. He's now 44 years old. Please keep a lookout for them. Now, let's just say he has been on the run for a long, long time. So now I want to tell you what Joseph Maiden has done.
A rap sheet as long as Tyrone. Oh, they're both rap sheets. Okay. April 10th of 2023, Joseph is dismissed from his managerial duties at Ocala Suites after it's discovered he's using a separate room as storage. Oh, boy. Yeah. They find him because he filed a police report against Sarah's daughter, Michelle, after she tried to get custodial, you know, benefit, custodial, you know. Okay. So, wait, what day is this? Hold on. April 24th.
This is still going on at the end of 2023 before we jump back into 2024. He breaks into the office of Ocala Suites using a spare key he made. He shuts down the security system and the power. He rekeys the lock for room 119. He takes possession of rooms 119 and 121. They now begin trying to evict him. They find him because he filed this police report. July 25, two months after.
July 25th of 2023, Ocala Suites begins the eviction process. Oh, boy. So he snuck in, changed the locks, squatting now. Yes. And now they're having to try to run the eviction process on a squatter. Previous manager. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, boy. Right. So 2025, July 25th, they wrap up the eviction process. What does he do? He hires Sky Moving, based in Ocala, Florida, to remove all the property from 121, including but not limited to beds, mattresses, furniture, and TV.
Okay. No action is taken by Ocala Sweets as a matter would fall under small claims court. They're probably like, at least he's gone. Yeah. We can get new shitty beds. Right. Wow. Right. So he goes on quite a journey after that. But let's just say Michelle tries desperately to get Marion County to do forensics on room 119 to see if, you know, Cora had been there. Where is she? You know, there are handprints all over, but they don't do anything. You know.
The Ocala Police Department says, look, all this evidence is contaminated due to you being in there first. Right. Yeah. Yeah. So Joseph Mayton leaves Florida. He goes to Indianapolis, Indiana. He goes to New Albany, Indiana. He goes to Louisville, Kentucky, and he's staying at another hotel. He gets a job where I'm from in Florence, Kentucky at a Hyundai dealership.
Okay. November 23rd, he's now working at a Hyundai dealership in Florence, Kentucky. December of 2023, there are allegations by the daycare that Cora is in of sexual abuse. Oh, boy. A custody attorney initiates legal action against Joseph Mayton due to nonpayment.
Oh boy. March 29th of 2023. Now we're going back. This is a weird timeline, but this is just part of his rap sheet. He is involved in a vehicle accident and he assaults a 75 year old man during the incident. I don't know what city this is in. I don't know if this is in Indiana. I don't know if this is, I don't know where this is. Maybe this is back in Florida, but he asks an officer, can you delete items from my phone?
And the officer said, I'm not sure I can. But, you know, I if it's possible, I can. I'll try it if it's possible. I don't know why a cop would side with a guy who's beat up a 75 year old man on the scene. Yeah. Can you please delete things from I don't know what the things are. Maybe it's pictures of him beating up the man or maybe it's, you know, child porn. Yeah. Yeah. So he's dismissed from his job at the Ocala Suites, breaks in, blah, blah. You know, he's now sued by Sky Moving and he's been sued by two guys in a truck moving. Wow. Because he doesn't pay. So he must be quite the. He didn't pay them to help him steal the.
Yeah, stuff from the Ocala suites. Wow. Yeah, isn't that? That's some kind of special. He's got some, yeah, he's got some. Hold on, we're close to done. I swear we're close to done. Okay. So he moves again because there are allegations from the daycare that Cora is in that she has been sexually abused. July 2nd of 2024, he files bankruptcy in Indiana, but he has a P.O. box in Louisville.
Three weeks later, July 24th of 2024, he's hired as the general manager at the Wood Springs Naples Suites property. Okay. I mean, you keep doing a similar job, I guess. They hire him with a start date of July 29th, and he gets 60 days rent free. Okay. August, September, October. A scant two months later, his employment is terminated. And you're going to be shocked. Hold on. He refuses to vacate the premises.
So Woodspring Hotel sends an eviction notice of pay with stipulations, pay rent or vacate by August 9th. And you're going to be shocked they didn't receive any money. Oh, boy. So they initiate eviction process and he is living in a campground in December of 2024 in Quincy, Florida. And he is removed by the sheriff from a campground. What do you think you do in a campground to get? I don't know, because I've done I've done some stuff in the campground.
that's pretty far over the line that i didn't get removed i am i i'm thinking to myself like how you've been you know evicted from two um hotels where you worked and you're like what the f have you done i mean and that's probably not even he's done things so much so much worse right so we're going back to her ex-husband who you know um this girl disappeared from lima ohio and that is where he picked up the girl and he sent her text he's so dumb sent her text going 856 miles to go 12 more hours i'm almost out of florida oh boy driving to florida to pick up a 16 year old girl oh man yeah he was 31 at the time yeah okay what uh you know i don't want to say that sarah's picker's broken well yeah i mean you're these there's three uh three dudes here yeah that she's chosen
Two she chose. I think one chose her. Sure. With these piles of rap sheets you've got going here. I do have to say I printed 27 pages of notes on this. So if you listen to this podcast, you know I don't write a script. It's obviously not smooth enough to be scripted. I don't like telling someone's story in a script. It deserves better. It deserves me being able to say Michelle is selling her plasma for her sisters, you know, to fund her sisters.
investigation on her own because she feels, you know, that the law enforcement in the area has failed her. And I agree with her. I am, I'm sort of shocked at how, at how they've handled things, how they've answered things, how they've responded. And, you know, I'm not a law enforcement shit on person, but I know because you and I fight about it all the time as you're pulling your pants down to shit on them. And I'm there with the scoop. So can you believe that?
Her ex-husband was charged with sheltering an unmarried minor and is held on $6,000 bail. Wait, is this a whole different incident? No. This is a girl from Lima, Ohio. I don't know if things are different in different states, but to me, when you drive thousands of miles from Florida to Ohio to have sex with an underage girl, you take her back to your home. They find her within five days because she's on online video games. $6,000? That's the... Yeah, wow. Is Florida just not somewhere you want to live because shit like this happens?
I don't want to live there, but it's not because I have a habit of sheltering minors. Right, right. Although I do shelter three minors. You do, but you gave birth to them. Right. So this piece of shit, this 31-year-old piece of shit with a 16-year-old girl, I am in a romantic relationship with her, and I'm going to hide her in my home until she's old enough, and then she's going to be his wife. Wow. Well, okay. I mean, it feels like a trend. Right. This guy's picking teenage girls that...
Yeah. Other states who don't feel that healthy. Yeah. Obviously. Or I need to get out of my house. I need somewhere to go. Will you be my new daddy? You know? And I mean, I don't even know what to say about Joseph Mayton, who has custody of Cora. Well, yeah, that's that's the. Yeah. And he's on the run again. And he must be some slick talker that he can talk himself into managing, you know, Ocala suites and Wood Springs suites and inns. After after having these police reports of.
squatting and evictions. I mean, doesn't that stuff come up when you do a background check on somebody? That's such a great point because I'm going to say something and I don't want to get in trouble. I have not always stayed at, you know, the Four Seasons. Sure. And a few times, you know, a few times going back home to Kentucky, like Hampton Inn and stuff. And it's not, those are not bad. Right. They all are kind of the same unless you level up to something, you know. Yeah. Some of them better than others, Lequinta Inns, whatever. But they're motels, right? Right. So, you know, you might call it a hotel because your doors are on the inside. But a motel has a door on the outside. Oh, that's the balcony. That's the difference. Okay. They're all motels. Okay. Yeah. Okay. So some of them have better, you know, I'm going to tell you that I have.
Never run into anyone, please God forgive me, working behind the desk at a hotel that is a Phi Beta Kappa. They're not all rude. Sure. But a percentage are. Some are kind. Some are friendly. Some want to be in the hospitality industry. Yes. And again, I have not run into a lot of brilliant ones. But I run into sweet, kind ones. And we didn't talk about astrophysics. So I don't know their intelligence level. And it's not mine to judge. I think that certain organizations need.
to fill spots and they hire people and they don't vet them okay and then they end up in situations like this but to not even file charges When he took a bed, a TV, a nightstand, you know, the air conditioning unit out of the wall, you know, because that would just still be under small claims. I feel like this is not their first rodeo. You know, they may have had a couple of other shitty employees who that one took the sprinkler system. You know, I don't know. Yeah. So I'm more focused on, you know, Tyrone Mormon, who was the last person to see her, but Joseph Mayton, who has her daughter. And I know that's what Michelle is focused on. You know, Thomas Ebersole can hopefully be strung up, you know, for what he does.
by the law. Right. You know, he is her ex-husband. He is not a good human being, but I, you know, he's a little bit on the back burner for me. Right. So I'm just going to tell you, thank you, Mary, for giving us this case to look at because I had not heard of it and I don't particularly watch Nancy Grace because I don't, I can't stand the way she talks. And yeah, but I have watched her recently because of Nancy Guthrie, but there are so many other.
outlets that are really good about that uh michelle tullis is the girl you want on your side that is a sister who will not give up and i hope tyrone mormon knows this and i hope somewhere wherever he is he's sweating hopefully in church i'm in church in jail with another bench warrant probably not church in jail with another bench warrant and while i do not like giving out these numbers because i feel they have failed sarah cora and michelle if you know anything about Tyrone Mormon, where Sarah Ebersole is or where Cora is with Joe Maton, please call Detective Ryan Stith at 352-368-3542 or the Marion County Sheriff's Office non-emergency number at 352-732-9111. And if you want to remain anonymous, you can always call Crime Stoppers of Marion County at 352-368-STOP. That's 352-368-7867. And please reference case 2371.
and your tip. And please know you can always call us here at the tipster hotline 832 tipster. That's 832-847-7837. You can always email us at JT tipsters at gmail.com. You can find us on the social media platforms, just the tipsters Facebook page at JT tipsters on Instagram at JT tipsters on X and more cowbell. If you would like to support this podcast and get early access and other cool murderous swag to go to patreon.com slash just the tipsters.
If you like the show, please take a moment to rate, review and subscribe. It really does help the show to grow. Thank you for listening.