Skip to content
Lovers' Lane Slayings Part 2 episode artwork

Jul 12, 2021 23 min

Lovers' Lane Slayings Part 2

from Montana Murder Mysteries Hosted by NonStop Local

It's a case from the 1950's that would become so cold that more than half-a-century would pass before it could finally be solved: The Lovers' Lane Slayings. Last week on 'Montana Murder Mysteries,' after combing through old newspaper clippings and speaking to both the Cascade County Sheriff and the lead detective on this case, Podcast Hosts Angela Marshall and Blake Simonson revealed more about the tragic shooting deaths of 18-year-old Lloyd Duane Bogle and 16-year-old Patricia Kalitzke outside of Great Falls in 1956. Decades later, a fresh pair of eyes and a more thorough look at the evidence would point investigators to the discovery of a sexual assault-- a crime too taboo to talk about for the time. But it's this knowledge of the sexual assault that would lead investigators down a new path of tracking down a suspect. How new DNA technology was used to close the file on what may be the oldest cold case in the country: "The Lover's Lane Slayings.' Here is Part Two.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Lovers' Lane Slayings Part 2

0:00 23:17
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Montana Murder Mysteries is brought to you by The Advocates. Your accident wasn't your fault, so don't deal with it on your own. The Advocates will handle paperwork and deal with the insurance company so you can rest and get better. Been nervous to work with an attorney? Then work with an advocate instead. The Advocates are available 24-7 online at montanaadvocates.com. Last time on Montana Murder Mysteries... There were valuables in the car. There was money. There was a knife. There was an inexpensive camera at that time that was left all in the vehicle. So what they figured at that point was that no...

that robbery was not the motive. But what law enforcement couldn't figure out? Who would shoot to death a United States airman and his bride-to-be? It's a case from the 1950s that would become so cold more than half a century would pass before it could finally be solved. We can never say that he's guilty. We can never, you know, say that he's a murderer or a rapist. We really can't say those things. We can just say based upon the evidence, this is the most likely conclusion to the crime. How new DNA technology was used to close the file on what may be the oldest cold case in the country, the Lover's Lane Slains.

Welcome to part two of our Montana Murder Mysteries podcast, The Lovers Lane Slains. I'm Angela Marshall. And I'm Blake Simonson. In the first part of this story, we open the case files on the double murders of 16-year-old Patricia Patty Kalitsky and her 18-year-old boyfriend Lloyd Dwayne Bogle back in 1956. The two were shot execution style in a rural area outside of Great Falls, an area known by locals as Lovers Lane. No suspect was found, so no arrests were ever made. And the case went bitterly cold like the January night they died 65 years ago.

Now, if you haven't had the chance to listen to the Lovers Lane Slains Part 1, stop right now and go back and have a listen. We go into detail about these two homicides that were left unsolved for decades, confounding law enforcement and confusing the public. That is, until just last month when the Cascade County Sheriff's Office made a big announcement in this cold case. Here's Sheriff Jesse Slaughter at a press conference on June 8th. This case is going to be unique. I mean, he's the most likely suspect. That's right, a suspect finally named in the deaths of Patty and DeWade. And that suspect, as we found out, Kenneth Gold. However, we feel that...

The detectives that worked this case throughout the years have definitely found enough evidence to determine that this is the most likely solution to this case. And the only way to reach this solution? Modern forensic technology. I spoke with the lead investigator on the Lover's Lane Slain's cold case today. He also spoke at a press conference in June. Cascade County Detective Sergeant John Kadner told me during a Zoom conversation he was handed the boxes full of case files by his captain back in 2012.

Captain Van Dyken was my supervisor and he basically told me, I want you to review this case and we're going to solve it one day. So I began the process of looking through boxes of material that was, you know, 65 years old. And I realized pretty quick that that was a pretty daunting task and it would be much easier to take as much of that information and scan it, get it into a digital version. That way there would be, it'd be easier to organize and review. And that's the process that I started with. I also realized pretty quick that the only way we're going to solve this is with DNA.

Namely, Forensic Genetic Genealogy Testing, or FGGT. FGGT was originally created to help people find family members by matching their DNA profiles with others in a public database like 23andMe or Ancestry.com. Today, it's transforming criminal investigations by helping law enforcement agencies all across the country identify suspects in long-unsolved cold cases. Yeah, Ange, that's how California's Joseph James D'Angelo, the infamous Golden State Killer, was cut in 2018. And that's how we were able to break the news on our podcast that Missoula County Sheriff's detectives had identified the 1974 murderer of young Siobhan McGinnis just last fall. But the question is, how exactly was Sergeant Cadner able to find the suspect after all of these years, with very little evidence found at the crime scene, a scene that dated all the way back to 1956, no less? I wanted to know.

Well, DNA began being used to crack cases back in the 90s. Right. It's something that we spoke about in a previous podcast series during Season 3, the Riverside Healthcare Murders. But authorities could only land a suspect if they had a sample of their DNA to analyze and compare it to DNA left on a victim or at the crime scene. Yes, so Kattner combed through pages upon pages of police reports, thoroughly looked through what limited photos of the crime scene were taken, and re-read witness statements. He also spoke with previous investigators and re-examined the autopsy findings from 1956. And here's what he found out.

The coroner, who conducted the original autopsy on Patty, reported finding no signs of rape or sexual assault. He did, however, take a vaginal swab and put it on a slide all to be preserved as evidence. And then I did have Dr. Kurtzman review this information. He's Montana's chief medical examiner. What he noted was that after reviewing all available photographs and autopsy findings, although the description and photographs are limited, the injuries are consistent with injuries sustained in a struggle or sexual assault. You heard him right. Patty was sexually assaulted on the night she was murdered. The DNA from the vaginal swab was semen. This was important evidence that surfaced that could now move investigators closer to the killer. But why did it take so long for this information to come to light?

What I found is there was very little disgust about the potential of sexual trauma. I don't know if it was that era, that timeframe where they just didn't want that out to the public. The autopsy did not indicate any findings of trauma to her body that were consistent with a rape or sexual assault. What we do know now is that less than 5% actually show trauma to that area of the body in those types of circumstances. So it's not unheard of to have those findings or lack of findings.

Here's another question we're all asking. Who did the seaman belong to? Was it her lover's, Dwayne's? Or was it someone else's? Sergeant Cadner told me a now-retired sheriff's detective, Phil Madison, also found that crucial clue when he was working in the evidence room at the Cascade County Sheriff's Office back in 1988. But he had to wait for technology to play catch up. The double homicide was even a focus of a hard copy episode in 1989. Then, well over a decade later in 2001, Madison was able to get the sample tested at the crime lab for DNA evidence. Two years after that, in 2003, a DNA profile of the person whom the seaman belonged to was made.

they were able to develop a sperm cell fraction that was tested against Dwayne's DNA and there was no match. So that indicated that it was not her boyfriend at that time. So there was a likely scenario that she was sexually assaulted that night. So we know that the semen sample did not belong to Dwayne. And we know that the semen didn't belong to anyone in the FBI's national DNA database. At the time, only the DNA profiles of people who had run-ins with law were uploaded to the system. But again, who?

This is when Kadner told me he knew they were onto something or someone. But he also told me, based on new cases that he was assigned to, this cold case had to sit yet again. And here's where an interesting theory came about, Ange. A retired detective with the Great Falls Police Department was researching the murders of serial killer Edward Wayne Edwards. Just months before he died in 2011, he confessed to killing five people from 1977 to 1996. But former GFPD detective James Cameron publicly said that Edwards could be connected to even more murders, including the deaths of Patty and Wayne. He came about that theory when he was able to place Edwards in Great Falls in 1956. I read in the Great Falls Tribune, Blake, that Cascade County Sheriff's Office was intrigued by this theory and the evidence that Cameron put forth. So investigators tested their DNA sample against Edwards to see if they could tie him to the crime.

It was no match. The Tribune reported, quote, 35 suspects came and went. Law enforcement compared the sample to other men, ruling them out one by one. And these suspects included Floyd Robertson, a former airman at Malmstrom Air Force Base, who confessed to the 1958 kidnapping, rape, and murder of Marjorie Schneider. But Robertson was in Colorado at the time of the Lovers Lane murders. And then there's Kenneth Swist, a former Great Falls resident and serial rapist and murderer. His DNA did not match the sample on file. Organized crime boss James Whitey Boulder was also a suspect. His DNA, also not a match.

And then, Arnold Rochester Blackwell. He was stationed at Malmstrom in 1956 as well. According to the Cascade County Sheriff's Office, in 1962, he forced a friend at gunpoint to rape his wife. Because he is deceased, authorities in 2018 were seriously contemplating exhuming his body for DNA testing. That is, until...

evidence back to them. And here's where forensic genetic genealogy testing, again, FGGT, helped Kadner break the case. And the good thing is what we learned in 2001, when they tested that evidence, they only swabbed half of that slide. So what that did for us, we were able to use the other half for further testing, you know, years later. So they swabbed that other half, they were able to identify the same DNA, but use different testing so it could be used for familial type testing.

Kadner worked with Bodie Laboratories so they could perform additional testing on the DNA sample. There, technicians uploaded the DNA profile of this unknown source, their suspect, to voluntary genealogical databases, and a familial connection was made. So obviously, after all that time, you're thinking 65 years, when they actually came back with a name and they sent a, basically a visual of the family tree they built and narrowed it down to this, to Gould. It was pretty shocking, to say the least. It was hard to believe, but at the same point, it was really exciting because now for the first time in 65 years, we had a solid lead and we were able to start running with that information and basically building on his life to see if we could put him in the area of where Patty was living and ultimately killed. Same with Dwayne. So one of our first goals was to get him identified, see if he was still living. Unfortunately, we found out that he had passed away in 2007. The next...

goal would be to find out where is he buried are we able to exhume him to have his dna tested to our suspect dna sample we found out that he had donated his body to science and he had been cremated so the next step was to see if he had any children which we did learn that he had four children that were still living so that began the process of trying to meet up with these folks and asking them if they'd be willing to submit a DNA sample. We met in person. And on the way to the address, I took a detective with me, Detective Kambik. And that was one of our conversations. What is the best way to give them this news and then turn around and ask them for their DNA? So we kind of went through a few scenarios.

There was no great plan. We just basically gave him the information, said, here's the investigation. Here's how we've identified your dad as a potential suspect. We would like to either show that he was involved or disprove that he was involved. And they gave the sample. Obviously, we had to take that sample. We sent it off to Bowie and they did their testing. And yes, when we got that, that news that really solidified that this was our guy. And their guy, Kenneth Gold.

He was born on August 23, 1927 in Great Falls, and that's where he was raised. He was an avid horseman and made his living training horses and working as a ranch hand. In 1952, at the age of 25, he married. His bride at the time, 16 years old. The same age Patty was when she died, if you remember. He and his wife would have a total of five children, three daughters and two sons. He died at the age of 79 on May 27, 2007 in Oregon County, Missouri, well before investigators could connect him to Patty and Dwayne's murders.

Here's what Kadner also found out when taking a deeper look into Gould's past and working to connect him to the killings. When Patty and Duane were killed, Gould would have been 29 years old, and his wife lived a little over a mile from Patty Kalitsky's home. He also boarded horses on a property that was located just 600 yards from the Kalitsky's. By the way, during the morning hours, she had a paper route. So every morning she'd go deliver papers, so she would have been around that neighborhood quite often. On 1210 of 1955, the Goulds welcomed their second child. 24 days later, Duane and Patty are murdered, and his semen is found inside her body. But Gould was never questioned in the murders.

39 days after the murders, Kenneth sold his property in Tracy, Montana, and he's shown living in Geraldine, Montana, with the rest of his family. And then in 1958, they're living in Hamilton, Montana, where they stayed until 1967. In 1967, they moved to Alton, Missouri, and they would never return to Montana. Never return to Montana, never be connected to the deadly crimes. We didn't find any known criminal history. We were never able to find any connection that he had to Dwayne or Patty.

that was identified in any of the reports and his name never came up he was never questioned he was never a suspect so he just frankly was not on anyone's radar that's really all we could come up with you know after after so long and after so long cascade county sheriff jesse slaughter told me during a zoom conversation recently it's a privilege for him to know the lovers lane slain's just maybe the oldest cold case solved using fggt Solved, I think, is the appropriate term because we have brought the case to using all the evidence and tools that are our ability. We brought it to its most likely conclusion. But there'll never be a trial. The witnesses will never be heard in a court. And that is really our justice system. So I can't say that, you know, the suspect in this matter is guilty. We can't say that. We can say he's the most likely person who committed the crime. And today, the advances in technology, namely FGGT, are allowing investigators like Kadner to catch up with the suspect and finally identify them. You know, if there's only one guy involved and he can keep a secret.

And what I found is in researching a lot of the cases that have been solved with forensic genetic genealogy is that there was only one suspect involved. And all they had to do was keep quiet. I love the technology. I love the use of how genetic genealogy has became such a great tool for law enforcement to help these families get closure. Kadner told me while many of Patty and DeWayne's family members are now deceased, those who are living are relieved to finally receive closure. And Sheriff Slaughter echoed that sentiment. I think it shows desire for our people to find justice.

I think it would be really easy to take a case like this where obviously the victims are deceased, the suspect is deceased, most of the witnesses are deceased, and just say, well, let's put that case on a shelf. Everyone's gone. And not to take advantage of current trends and current technology to be able to give families some closure. I just received an email today from a family member of one of the victims just thanking us for closing it out. She was describing looking through a closet in her house and finding newspaper clippings from back in the 50s about it. And just thanking...

us for doing it. And that stuff is amazing. And that's why we work for the people. We work for them to close these matters out and give them. Sometimes you can't give them anything other than closure. To add to that, not only were the families affected, what I learned through researching this case is numerous detectives poured their heart and soul into it. I mean, they wanted to solve it badly. They wanted it to come to a close. And you can just read that when you're going through these reports. So it's for the family, but it's for past investigators as well.

When it came to this specific cold case, what does it mean to you as a sheriff to know that you essentially closed the lid on a 65-year-old cold case? You know, for me personally, obviously it's satisfying. It's an honor to be the person sitting in the chair at We're Talking. Oh, gosh, almost 10 sheriffs ago, this murder actually occurred. It's a huge honor, but I didn't do this. This roadwork was done by our people, and it was done by actually multiple generations of investigators throughout the years. I just get to be the honorable one who gets to present it. I'm just, I guess, lucky, you know, as far as that goes. What was really amazing to me and what really captured me was that...

Back in 1956, the deputies investigators did a really good job of preserving this evidence and obtaining the correct evidence and doing the right things. And so much so that it was able to preserve for all this time. It's historic. It's part of this legacy. Still to come on this season of Montana Murder Mysteries. How would that affect your workflow moving forward, knowing that you have to obtain this warrant? So I just, for example, after so many years, it may be hard to develop probable cause to get that search warrant when these are open source or open voluntary databases. It just does not make sense to me why you would need a search warrant for that information.

The use of FGGT, a modern tool that has recently been helping law enforcement agencies across America crack cold cases, soon to be restricted in the Treasure State. Montana, now one of only two states in the country, that passed a law recently limiting the use of forensic genetic genealogy testing to protect the privacy of suspects and their families. We'll examine the state law that is set to go into effect on October 1st and hear from those who are either criticizing or praising the legislation and why. That's coming up later on this season of Montana Murder Mysteries. See you next week.

Murder in Miami iHeartPodcasts In the 1980s crime journalist Phil Stanford dove into the decadent and dangerous world of Miami just as the city was becoming the cocaine- and murder- capital of the United States. His path would place him in the crosshairs of a federal investigation focusing on a mysterious and controversial drug smuggling pilot who claimed to be an operative of the American government- all while flaunting his extensive illicit activity. Murder in Miami traces the connection between the murder of a missing Miami private investigator to the sprawling roots of an international money laundering scheme as Stanford tries to make sense of his role in a surreal story of spies, smugglers, killers and corruption. All reaching to the highest levels on both sides of the law. Explicit Suspect Convictions Kast Media Barton McNeil discovers his 3-year-old daughter's lifeless body in her bed the morning after breaking up with his girlfriend. McNeil insists that she was murdered by his former girlfriend after pointing to a cut screen in the bedroom window. Police agree a murder has been committed, but arrest him. Explicit Atlanta Monster iHeartPodcasts and Tenderfoot TV From the producers of Up and Vanished, Tenderfoot TV and iHeartPodcasts present, 'Atlanta Monster.' This true crime podcast tells the story of one of the city’s darkest secrets, The Atlanta Child Murders. Nearly 40 years after these horrific crimes, many questions still remain. Host Payne Lindsey aims to find truth and provide closure, reexamining the disappearance and murder of over 25 African American children and young adults. Explicit Something's Not Right Something's Not Right Dive into the world of true crime and the paranormal with Olivia and Thashana on Something’s Not Right. From heartbreaking crimes to bizarre mysteries, their single-host true crime episodes offer a serious and thoughtful exploration of cases, while their duo-host paranormal and oddities episodes bring humor into the unexplained. Prepare for a captivating listening experience that will leave you craving more. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/something-s-not-right--3204743/support. Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Montana Murder Mysteries?

This episode is 23 minutes long.

When was this Montana Murder Mysteries episode published?

This episode was published on July 12, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Montana Murder Mysteries episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.