Skip to content
Making Venture Capital Work for Entrepreneurs episode artwork

Dec 16, 2020 49 min

Making Venture Capital Work for Entrepreneurs

from Azeem Azhar's Exponential View Hosted by EPIIPLUS 1 Ltd / Azeem Azhar

Leila Rastegar Zegna, co-founder and general partner of Kindred Capital, joins Azeem Azhar for a deep dive into venture capital: how it really works, what’s broken, and how to fix it. They also explore a new model for venture capital, where founders become partners in the fund. This new approach aims to align incentives for both entrepreneurs and investors, in order to build a healthier innovation community. They also discuss: Why venture capital is a “people business,” not a finance business. Why obsessiveness is a more important than expertise for founders. Why not all startups should seek funding. Further resources: “How Venture Capitalists Are Deforming Capitalism” (The New Yorker, 2020) “What Is Equitable Venture?” (Kindred Capital, 2017) “Silicon Valley Needs a Shakedown with Chamath Palihapitiya” (Exponential View podcast, 2020) @lrastegar @azeem @ExponentialView About Exponential View: Welcome to Exponential View, where Azeem Azhar examines how exponential technologies such as AI are reshaping the future. Each week, Azeem shares his analysis or speaks with an expert guest to shed light on frontier shifts across technology, business and society. To keep up with the Exponential transition, subscribe to this channel or the newsletter: https://www.exponentialview.co/ To keep up with our AI economy research, subscribe to https://www.investmentbrief.ai/ Where to find me: Exponential View newsletter: https://www.exponentialview.co/ Website: https://www.azeemazhar.com/ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/azeem/ Twitter/X: https://x.com/azeem Production by EPIIPLUS1. Production and research: Baba Films, Marija Gavrilov.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Leila Rastegar Zegna, general partner and co-founder of Kindred Capital, joins Azeem Azhar to explore a new model for venture capital, where startup founders become partners in the fund. This new approach aims to align incentives for entrepreneurs and investors, in order to build a healthier innovation community.

Ready to play

Making Venture Capital Work for Entrepreneurs

0:00 49:26
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hi there, I'm Azim Azhar and you're listening to Exponential View. Now, every week I'm in deep conversation with a brilliant mind and we dissect our world and its intricate dance with technology and innovation. Now, if you like these conversations, please take a few seconds to give us a five-star rating, preferably on the Apple Podcast Store. It really helps us reach new audiences. Now, my guest today is my friend and one of the leading lights of venture capital in Europe, the founding general partner of Kindred Capital, Leila Zegna.

Now, before she founded Kindred, Leila developed a varied career across wildly different sectors, from consulting to genomics and online marketplaces, before becoming a lone angel investor to many, many startups. This led her to founding Kindred Capital, a VC firm with a difference, building itself as an equitable venture capitalist, where startup founders become members of the fund itself. Now, I have to declare an interest. I am an advisor to Kindred Capital, and I was a venture partner there for a couple of years, so I know Leila and Kindred fairly well. But hopefully this will let me dig into the issues that swirl around venture capital with even more depth than usual. Now, before we get started, some terms of art to help you navigate some of our conversation. We use the phrase AUM, that means assets under management. This is the total value of capital managed by an institutional investor, whether it's a mutual fund, a pension fund, or a VC firm. VC or venture capital is a type of investment that targets early stage companies. A GP is a general partner, the main investors who actually run a venture capital firm and make the investment decisions.

are limited partners. They are the underlying investors who fund VC firms. They tend to be institutional investors or family offices. Carry is the profit share that the general partners earn if they make money for their LPs. It's typically between 20, 25, maybe 30%.

of the profits. Then we have the stages of financing. Seed is one of the earliest stages of funding. It's typically when a founding team is really just getting started. It is the stage that has the most risk attached to it. Later stages of funding, as startups become more mature and less risky, are given names like Series A, the Series B, the Series C, or the Series D, or even beyond, sometimes known as the alphabet rounds. We also talk about the multiples of return, like 1X or 3X. Now, what does this mean? An investment of, say, $1 million that returns $3 million is a 3X investment. One which returns only $1 million is a 1X investment, and one which might return $10 million is a 10X investment. And that same 1X, 2X, 3X, 5X also...

for the overall returns of a VC fund. We mentioned power laws. Now, a power law is the statistical description of the returns of the companies in a VC's portfolio. Typically, a large proportion of companies in a VC's portfolio just end up returning their original capital or less, so 1x or below. A small proportion, perhaps 10%, might return 5, 10, 20, or 50 times their original investment and drive the overall returns of the fund. This distribution profile is called a power law. And with that, let's get to our discussion. Leila Zegna, welcome to Exponential View. Thank you so much. It's so exciting to be here. Now, you're one of my favourite people, so the challenge for me is...

How do I get straight to the point with you? I think the challenge for you is you need to get out more often if that's the case. Let's jump straight in. There was a great article in the New Yorker. The article was quite critical. It was critical in the role of VCs and the demise of WeWork. And it ended up the article with the quote, no matter what happens, the VCs still end up rich. So is venture capital broken? It's a great question to start with because it's sort of the start of my own venture capital journey as well. I think fundamentally, you know, we're looking at people in entrepreneurship who see great opportunity where they see challenges. So it's this amazing kind of mindset of abundance that you get to be in where.

entrepreneurs fundamentally look at the world, see lots of things that are broken, and then see them as actually opportunities to instigate change. I think that's really how we saw the venture capital landscape when we founded the firm, which is now about five years ago. But there's still so many more areas that we can continue to innovate to pioneers of new models, new strategies in order to try and make venture capital less broken. And I think one of the things, one of the words that we kept coming back to, which is still something that I think is a major struggle and was highlighted very prominently in that article, is this concept of alignment. So how do you think about aligning interests between an investor and an investee? How do you think about all the stakeholders that need to be managed? Technology is taking over, you know, software is eating the world. And then as one of my partners, Mark likes to say, software is now eating software. So we're sort of getting to the point where, you know, this is having this massive global impact. Venture capitalists and founders who sit at that epicenter. So thinking about alignment and structures and incentives, I think is more important now than ever. One of my previous guests, Chamath Palihapitiya, also talked about the incentive.

alignment problem that seems to exist between venture capitalists and the society at large, but also the founders who they work with. We will dig into some of these issues, but let's backtrack just a little bit and level up our listeners. How do you define venture capital? What is it and what's its purpose? So I see venture capital as actually quite a niche funding mechanism. I think this really isn't talked about.

enough in terms of there's lots of different ways to capitalize a business there's lots of different ways to get money almost now more so than ever that capital is pretty commoditized you know across stages across geographies capital is quite abundant so as you think about starting a company i think because you know media has proliferated as much as it has and we're all sort of reading tech crunch and looking at the cover of forbes magazine etc people think that venture capital might be the only way In a sense, I think it's probably like the funding of last resort in a way. It's if you are such a specific and unique type of person who is going after such a specific and unique and high risk kind of outlier outcome, then you have this option, which is called venture capital. But actually, there's lots of other funding mechanisms. You can think about corporate capital. You can think about your friends and family or angel money. You can think about crowdfunding. You can think about family office capital. You can think about customer capital. Profitability is the new product market fit, as they like to say. I think there's lots of different places where you can think about capitalizing your business.

Venture capital, I think, is quite a specific one. What our mandate is, as we raise money from so-called limited partners or investors into venture capital funds, is that there's a sort of tacit understanding that you are trying to return at least 3x net the money that goes in. So that's about a 25% annual return, which is well above long-term stock market returns, about 8% per annum. The other observation that you made was that venture capital is quite a niche form of capital. And I think it's worth quantifying that. Globally, there's about $150 trillion of assets under management.

of which venture capital represents about 1 trillion. So it's about 0.6% of it. There's another form of capital that VC is often bucketed with, which is private equity. There's about $4 trillion of assets under management in private equity. I often find it frustrating when I see market reports and they have this asset called PE slash VC, because I feel that they're quite different types of capital. How would you characterize what VC is like compared to what PE or private equity is like? I think your point also about seeing them blended together is a frustration of mine as well. I mean, if I think about...

portfolio theory. And as we were starting to talk about these famed 3x net returns and and actually peeling back that onion and understanding the drivers of those returns and these, you know, one or two or maybe three, if you're lucky, out of a whole portfolio of 20 or 30 companies in a portfolio being the only companies that matter, you know, the ones that are so outlier in terms of their success that they make up for all these losses along the way. And actually the most sophisticated limited partners will ask you when you're pitching your venture fund to them about your write-off ratio. And they'll ask you where you first think, oh gosh, wouldn't it be great if I could say nothing? You know, look at my track record, nothing has written off. But the reality is the most sophisticated limited partners are actually looking for a sizable write-off ratio. And they're looking for that because they recognize that you need to take enough risk.

in order to see the outlier reward on the upside. And so fundamentally, I see venture capital as being in the upside optimization business, not the downside mitigation business. And I think that is just a different mindset than how private equity firms operate, where if you lose money, if you get 0x or 0.2x on the dollar for a private equity investment, that's an enormous failure. I think the mindset is different, but I suppose I also want to make the point that I see them converging. more and more in terms of the types of companies that they go after, not necessarily in terms of the mindset or the human capital that's running those organizations, and not even necessarily in terms of the incentives or the return profiles. But I think value is being created at a pace that is unprecedented. And so everyone is getting into the preemption business, even private equity firms are. They're looking earlier, looking to capture some of that growth that otherwise would be gobbled up by venture and growth investors.

more often I am seeing my private equity friends have asking me about companies that maybe have just raised a series B or a series C that historically, you know, they would have waited many rounds and almost waited until that quote unquote exit time until they thought about getting involved. So this is, I think this is an important observation, which is that typically private equity firms are investing in in companies where there is a certain amount of certainty and where deals are structured in such a way that their downside is managed, there's a low chance they'll lose money, but perhaps the upside is not structured in such a way that they can get the types of outsized returns that we hear firms like Sequoia or Kleiner Perkins, the sort of fabled West Coast Silicon Valley firms get. And then the consequence for venture capital to work as an asset class, you worry less about whether you have a write-off, but much more about whether you have a path to making 20, 50, or even 100 times your money on a deal that you have invested in.

There's a really fascinating chart that I think it was Andreessen Horowitz published several years ago now, but it showed the makeup of portfolios in venture capital funds, and they'd segmented them by funds that return less than 1x, so pretty crappy firms, firms that return anywhere from 1 to 3x, firms that return 3 to 5x, and then firms that return 5x plus the money. And so those are some of those firms that you mentioned, you know, Benchmark, Sequoia, etc. And what it showed actually, which is really fascinating, is that... the percent of write-offs was pretty consistent across a fund that returned 1x and a fund that returned 5x plus the fund. And that hovered around somewhere between 30 and 40%. So, you know, if you think about the way that we celebrate every time Sequoia or Benchmark makes an investment in a company, you know, as a seed investor, you think, gosh, that's winning. You know, we've sort of made it in a sense versus, you know, one out of three of those companies and maybe one out of two or two and a half of those companies.

is actually not going to make it. It's going to return less than 1x. And so I think that is really critical. The best in class, the best in breed still have to take massive risk in order to see the successes. The main difference is the percent of that portfolio that ends up being a 10x plus investment, but actually the magnitude of those winners. So that really is where venture capital is this sort of brand slam business, not even a home run business in terms of really swinging for the fences and having these outlier returns. Is there something particular about the way that this kind of venture capital financing that needs to...

achieve grand slams. You're not rewarded for getting an A, you're rewarded for getting a special letter from the examiner saying you've done the very, very best that's ever been done. How does that influence the way technologies come to market and the kinds of ideas that find success? I think it's really interesting, actually, that you mentioned getting an A. I think our education system is really not built, not constructed to kind of raise and value people who go off map, quote unquote, who don't really know what the playbooks are, what the guardrails of success look like and who also aren't following a rule book. Josh Koppelman actually has this really beautiful phrase. He's the founder of a firm called First Round Capital in the US. He talks about how we raise and value navigators and map readers. But actually in venture capital, we're looking for cartographers who are comfortable to create their own map.

And so I think we are really looking for those contrarian thinkers. That's where you are actually going to get the alpha. That's where you're going to be able to be in that sort of non-consensus but right category where astronomical returns are made, but also where you run a real risk. There's something that's very unique and very special about that type of person who can persevere in the face of so much challenge. One of the things that's sprung to mind, of course, is that many of the VCs that I know do have that conforming academia of Harvard or Yale or Stanford or Oxbridge or the Ecole Supérieure, if you're in France, and then the MBA and the great consulting background. So is there some...

psychology that comes to play about having been a navigator and in some sense secretly pining that you had been the cartographer? I think the first question that you asked, what's broken in the industry or what can change? I think that's one of the things actually that can change. I think we need more diversity in the ultimate sense of the word, more heterogeneity on the venture capital side to actually reflect some of the mindset and ethos of the entrepreneurs that you are investing in. I mean, at the end of the day, I think venture capital really is a service industry. It's a service business. You have to think about where the scarcity lies. And today, there's this abundance.

of capital. The scarcity lies on the side of these extraordinary, unique entrepreneurs who are giving their lifeblood, their earning potential, their time, their money, everything they have, they're putting into this one thing that they hope will be this big outlier success. I think everyone has to orient around that scarcity. And you're basically in the business of selling your money to the best founders who will take it from you. And so I think if you take that orientation, then the question for me is, how do you build a depth of relationship with that person who's on the other side of the table? And if you've been to all these storied institutions and you have quite a formed mindset in terms of following rule books and playbooks, and I think it becomes very difficult to truly relate to the person that's on that other side of the table. And so that's where I think there's a big opportunity to actually find more operators who have had that depth of experience, who've been on those rollercoaster rides themselves.

and then who come onto the venture side and think about sort of taking that set of experience and knowledge and network and capital and actually investing in the next generation of entrepreneur. You founded a couple of companies, one in a consumer marketplace, and then you've built a company in the biotech space as well, which is a very different sector. What are the key learnings that come across from those that help you do your job better? I think one thing was I had this extraordinary benefit of building a company that was a very capital consumptive company in the heart of Silicon Valley in kind of 2010 to 15, which was like a really dynamic. moment in time and in the Valley in general with new funds that we're launching with new models and new theses and new partnerships and new structures. And coming to Europe in 2014-15, looking at a market that was a bit less mature than that that we'd seen in the US, you know, it was a couple of decades behind, but the trajectory was really positive in terms of looking at where it could go and thinking about how I baked some of those learnings as being a recipient for a venture capital into what I thought was an underserved customer at the time in Europe. And I think that does enable you to build a relationship that's quite unique. You know, the definition of relationship that we keep coming back to is the ability to share problems. And if you can't really share a problem with someone, you don't really have a relationship with them.

And why would you share a problem with someone that you think either will use that against you in some way as negotiating leverage, will sort of judge you for that, may lose conviction in you and your leadership capabilities or your company. But if you've ever been on that journey, you know that there's so many jagged edges of up and down on that stock chart, which hopefully goes up into the right overall, that you kind of can bring those own experiences into the discussion and talk about how it was for you and permission, if not mandate, that ability for a founder to be open and honest around where they have challenges as well. I think one of the things that definitely comes across in the time that I've spent in this industry is this notion that it is increasingly a people service business. The thing that stands out time and again is the importance of being able to find the founder, relate to the founder and help the founder succeed. A few weeks ago, there was quite an interesting blog post by Jessica Livingston, who's at Y Combinator, which is one of the incubators in the US. And she wrote a post about what to look for in founders. And one of the things she identified was the domain expertise. And another very well-known venture capitalist, Vinod Kostler, he's absolutely sort of storied, been in the business.

30 years, said, well, actually, if you look at these really outlying companies, like a Tesla, for example, the founder didn't know anything about the domain. How important do you think domain expertise is to deliver the kind of extreme returns that the industry looks for in its founders? I'd say domain expertise does matter in some sectors, but perhaps not as much as people think. And from a founder perspective, I really don't think it matters nearly as much as obsession. You know, we spend a lot of time at Kindred with our founders asking the question why. And you ask a why question three or four or five times, you really get to what's at the root of the motivation of a particular founder. Why do they have such a motivation to solve this problem? And why are they going to stop at nothing to get there? And, you know, you have this wave of sort of tourists or entrepreneurs.

for lack of a better term, when you have these quote unquote hot industries, which I'd say entrepreneurship and venture capital are quite hot at the moment. So, you know, there's quite a funny Harvard Business School set of charts that you can look at, which shows where Harvard Business School graduates go to post-graduation. And you look at that over the decades and it's like a near perfect picture of what was. extrinsically valued as the most impressive thing that one could do or the most lucrative profession at the time. So banking in the 80s and private equity in the 90s and hedge funds in the 2000s. And then, oh, look, entrepreneurship and venture capital in the last decade. I remember speaking at Harvard Business School in 96, just as the dot-com boom was about to accelerate. And everyone was going into the dot-com back then. But you're right. It's a lagging indicator, not a leading indicator. Absolutely. And so I think that's why this depth of motivation, this question of why, is such a critical one to get to. And I think what you look for is someone who's so obsessed to solve that particular problem.

And they think the best way or maybe the only way to solve that problem is by starting a company. But it's sort of the means to an end, not an end in itself. And where I say domain expertise matters in some sectors and not so much in others, I think you can bring in domain expertise instead of necessarily needing it in a single founder and a single set of initial founders. And one example that comes to mind for me is, you know, my good friend, Kevin Nazemi. He was a co-founder of Oscar Health, which is this pioneering insurance company in the US. And when he spoke about his superpower, it was getting suits and hoodies to work together.

He did need the suits, right? He needed the 50-year-old actuarians who were steeped in a few decades in the insurance world, but he also needed the hoodies. He needed those people who would think very differently about an age-old industry. And so I think it's really the kind of combination of those things. And I think oftentimes, if you're so steeped in domain expertise, it's really hard to think very innovatively about the future. And you see that a lot in diligence. So if you're looking to speak to experts in the field, by definition, they represent the incumbency, right? And they'll oftentimes be quite negative about a new innovation and point out all the reasons it won't work. I think you need a fair amount of naivete to embark on any of these journeys and somehow...

The knowledge of all the things that can go wrong can inhibit people from diving in and actually taking the plunge. That's one of the things that I struggle with when I hear early stage investors speaking to experts about diligence, because the experts, as you say, they reflect the incumbency. If they had had the insights that the founder has, they might well have already gone off and set up a company. So how do you then go through that diligence process where you have a founder who's taking a completely different approach to the market? I think you have to ask the question, what business are you in? Are we in the business judgment business? I would say no. I think we are in the people judgment business.

I think we're in the human capital industry, not the financial capital industry. And so we oftentimes get the question from prospective limited partners, are we a thematically oriented fund? Do we think about certain themes and then do we go out and hunt in those themes? And the answer for us is that we don't. We actually are led much more by the founders. So I think seed stage venture investing, in our view, is a primary research business. If we are reading about things in...

Wired or TechCrunch or I'm listening to the Exponential View, I'm probably at the point where I'm too late as a seed investor. I need to get there two years before Sequoia or XL or whoever else is going to come in and do the Series A. And so we learn by keeping our ear to the ground and just meeting with the smartest people we can find and thinking about what they're working on. We talk about it as suspending our disbelief when you go into a meeting with a founder and just looking at their lens on the world, thinking about what the world would look like if all of the things go right in this person's pitch. And so I think if you tend to be quite thesis driven, what you could fall victim to is kind of when you meet with an entrepreneur who's painting a picture of something that you have thought very deeply about and that you have this great belief that the world is going to look like that, you can't help but sort of project your view and your excitement about the outcome onto that individual. And in our view, it sort of clouds the judgment of ultimately we're investing in people. Everything else will change. The product will change. The market will change. The environment will change. The competition will change.

But hopefully the constant is that person or set of people. And that's where we really try and spend the bulk of our time. In my observations of the time that we've been working together, one of the things that has always struck me as an internal discipline has been the willingness not to project what you think a future outcome might be. Is that a muscle that you recognize? And how do you train that up? It's actually a challenge in particular as we think about operators that come onto the investment side, which the year we set up in Europe, only 5% of the capital represented people that had.

founding experience in those partnerships. 95% of the capital was people who only had financial investing experience. And now that number has grown, but it's still sub 10%. So it's still absolutely the exception to the rule. And when someone comes in and pitches their concept to their idea, not getting so carried away about your own ideas and projecting those onto the founder, but really taking the ratio that you have of ears to mouth, like listening, you've got two ears and you have one mouth. How do you actually act in a meeting with that same ratio and actually just do more listening? And equally, once you've invested in that company, how do you recognize just time and time again and force yourself that...

to realize that this is that founder's journey to run. This is not your company to run. These are not your decisions to take. Your role is to ask the right questions, but not to be prescriptive and sort of step in and run companies yourself. We talked about the incentive alignment problem right at the beginning of this conversation. You are on the founder's journey and you have to establish a set of trust. And one of the ways of ensuring that trust has teeth is if the incentives should be aligned. Now, venture capital has often tried to align incentives. It's why...

Typically, the structure is a management fee that's often quite generous, and then 20% of the profits across the fund. And that's quite different to, for example, mutual funds, where you simply get paid a management fee based on the amount of capital you manage. You spearheaded an innovation in the way you've structured your venture capital fund with this idea of equitable venture. So what is that? And why do you think it helps align interest with founders?

So equitable venture is a structure where we essentially ask for a piece of all of these businesses when we make an investment, right? We pay for a chunk and ownership in those businesses. Equitable venture is where we in turn give those founders a piece of ours. So it really is this sense that by virtue of coming into a community and a portfolio of co-owners, every founder that we invest in will own a piece of the fund and therefore own a piece of one another's upside. You're coming into this sort of army, this community of like-minded individuals, of kindred spirits that have a vested interest in your success.

You know, we meet with 800 or a thousand companies and founders individually face to face or Zoom to Zoom today, you know, every single year. And out of those 800 or a thousand meetings, we'll maybe make eight to 10 investments. And those are individuals who we've hand selected because we think they're the most ambitious people building breakout technology companies in Europe. And so who better to tap into than those people when it comes to the best and brightest minds that are tackling these challenges and opportunities of company building today? I think the half-life of that empathy is actually very long, but the half-life of the tactics.

of company building, of what tools you use, what network you tap into, how you think about strategy of company building. All of that, the half-life is incredibly short and every year it's getting shorter because technology changes so dynamically, so quickly, at this unprecedented pace that your knowledge becomes outdated, certainly in a 10-year close-end fund, let alone if you have multiple funds under management. So our view was, how do we build a model whereby... We think we're aligning incentives. We're aligning kind of a venture capital investor with an investee by saying, we'll take a piece of your business, but we'll give you a piece of ours. We'll sit on the same side of the table. But also how do we let them tap into this community of like-minded individuals who are best positioned to help them grow and scale their own businesses? Were there any precedents that inspired you in this particular design? The precedent is being a founder who has set up their own business. I mean, it would be unthinkable today if a founder came to us and said, I'm starting a company. I've got 100% of the cap table and I will always have 100% of the cap table. I mean, it would be this crazy concept. And yet somehow on the investment side.

the general partners typically, and sometimes if you're lucky, some additional team members, you know, will get access to the carry, to the performance, to the kind of equity, as it were, in a fund. And our view was, let's just treat this like it's the next company that we're founding and that we're operating. It happens to be a VC firm, but we're obsessed with solving this problem. And so if we're structuring it that way, you know, let's think about us taking 80% and having 20%, just like we would if we were in an operating company, be our option pool. And let's think about the concept of a smaller piece of a bigger pie. You know, this isn't zero sum. And I think most funds aren't really set up to capitalize or capture a lot of the value that's created by nature of that. So let's step through how it actually works in practice. So what does it mean if I'm a founder who receives an investment from Kindred Capital and how do I participate? So you're treated just like the general partners in a firm in that when we get performance fee, you get performance fee. So the way it works is if we meet Azeem, he's this fantastic, brilliant young founder who's building this business and we make an investment in your business. And then we meet Fred and he's building this other really exciting business and we invest in his business.

Both of you de facto, by virtue of having taken capital from Kindred, own a piece of each other's upside. And so when Azeem sells his business to Google, we all get a check in the mail, Fred included. And when Fred IPOs his company, Azeem gets a check in the mail, just like we all do. And so everyone is sort of in it together in the sense that one individual or one company's success is everyone's collective success. And it's a much more sort of camaraderie, community oriented view of how to build companies. Not one that's won by individual successes at the expense of others, but a much more collaborative way of thinking about company building and value creation over time.

It sounds great, but I guess it could be open to the challenge that it's an expensive marketing gimmick, that you're willing to give up 20% of your profits in order to signal to founders that this happens. And you've made a point that founders are relentless in the pursuit of trying to solve this problem, so much so that they put their professional career, their earnings potential, their mortgage, their lives subsidiary to solving this problem, sometimes for a decade or more. So how does the rhetoric actually meet the road? You've been doing it for five years. And can you persuade listeners that this is more than a tactic to drive interest? Here's what I'll say.

When we were first raising Fund One, we had with a prospective LP who will go nameless, but who was saying, you know, this is a really innovative model. This is new. Nobody's doing anything like it. Why are you guys giving 20% of your upside for that? You know, you could give 5% of your upside and you'd still be able to use it as a marketing message and you'd be doing far more than anyone else. And I think it really begged the question for us internally as a partnership of why we were doing it. And we aren't doing it because of the marketing benefit. I think we're doing it because we think it's the version of the world that we want to live in. I think when you have this amazing privilege, which is building a company, you know, you have.

the greatest privilege, which is to construct the world around you, to construct the world that you want to live in. And that's at the micro and the macro level. So that's the type of people that you work with, the value system that you deploy, who you invest in, what office environment you work from. Everything is literally a construction out of your own imagination. And so we first and foremost wanted to say, well, what world do we want to live in? What experience do we want to have as venture capital providers, as partners to these founders? And so that was step one. Step two is...

I think, you know, it's at worst net neutral and at best it adds value, right? We had to believe that this is a good business decision when we first set up, but now we actually have data and evidence, you know, thinking about is equitable venture working? Is it changing behavior? And I think we can definitively say now five years along, but yes, it is. And I'll give you one example of how that's manifested. So as a seed stage fund, you know, one of the most important things that we have to do is sourcing because, you know, we aren't at the stage where there's demonstrable traction. So we're just looking for these extraordinary people who are in some windowless basement somewhere thinking about extraordinary ideas.

And so actually just getting in front of them is the first step. And as we think about how we source, you know, we have now not four partners in the carry pool out there looking for the best quality founders we can find in Europe. We're now over 80 people in that carry pool. The vast majority of those people being the founders that we've hand selected because we think they're the most ambitious people building companies in Europe. They have the most extraordinary network of other founders because great talent just naturally gravitates to other great talent. And so quantitatively, those individuals, our founders, make up about 40% of our top of the funnel deal flow.

almost 70% of our invested deals are sourced from that group of people. We call it our fifth partner, right? We share 20% of our upside with that community of founders instead of that 20% going to a fifth equal partner that we hire. And if I judge them that way and I say, has that fifth partner performed? Well, one single partner, quote unquote, is responsible for seven out of every 10 deals that we do. Yeah, it's a pretty prolific partner. It makes some of us look pretty poor in comparison. So it definitely is working to drive business value, but I think really it is the version of the world that we want to live in. A few years ago, Eric Paley, who is the founder of a...

a seed stage fund in the US called Founder Collective, wrote an essay that was called Veggie Capital is One Hell of a Drug. And he had a line to the founders that said, VCs need billion dollar exits, you don't. And I want to return to this question because it's clear that a very large portion of the companies that have changed our world have been VC funded. Firms that represent 40% of the market capitalization of the NASDAQ in the US can trace some part of their founding capital to Sequoia Capital, which is a well-known VC firm in the US. What's the room for...

models which don't have to return this. three X that a fund like yours needs to return to its investing partner? Is there any zone of agreement where you could build a fund that says, we're not going to push for these global outsized returns. We're going to build businesses that have a slightly different returns profile. I definitely think there is room for that. As I said, I think there should be in this proliferation of capital, a proliferation of models and return expectations and types of journeys that founders want to be on. And oftentimes that is what we're talking about with founders is what journey do you want to be on? What do you want the day-to-day to feel like? How do you think about some of the trade-offs? And I think...

There is space for it. I think the caveat would be and sometimes, you know, I struggle with smaller funds who say, you know, we're a 30 million, 40 million dollar fund. And therefore, we don't need a billion dollar companies to return our fund because actually, you know, a 200 million or 300 million dollar outcome can return our fund just fine. I think the challenge is that there aren't that many 200 or 300 million dollar outcomes. They are still sort of unicorns in their own right. And you aren't the first and last and only source of capital for those businesses typically. So you rely on this continuum of capital that comes after you as a really early stage fund and as a small fund who, by definition, is probably doing.

pre-seed and seed stage investing, you know, at some point that company needs to be interesting enough to the next round investor and then the next round investor. And yes, there are some businesses that can get profitable or break even reasonably quickly, and then they can grow more linearly and over a long enough time period can actually get to some really interesting, sizable outcomes. But if you are reliant on outside funding in one way, shape or form, then you do have to think about not just what the return expectations of your fund are, but what are the return expectations of the universe of funds that are out there? And how do I make sure that there's this continuity of capital out there for companies? And that's where I think you can get into this no man's land of either make sure that you can be hugely capital efficient.

And you can get to profitability and that you want to be on the journey of growing the company in a more linear fashion without so-called blitz scaling or actually say, I am in this Grand Slam business with you. I'm aligning my risk appetite and my incentive with that. And I'm looking for the right capital to back me on that vision and on that journey. That is the sort of typical. outlier venture capital success that most people are gunning for. And that's what we're looking for as well. If you look at the kinds of businesses that we build today, their value all accretes to intangible capital, right? It's software, it's network effects, it's brand, it's things that other types of finance aren't very happy to work with, right? The reason why founders can't go off and get loans. I mean, if you're Larry Page and Sergey Brin founding Google 25 or so years ago, you couldn't go off and say, well, I've got this white paper I did as part of my PhD and loan me $100,000 to it. There are no assets against which you can kind of collateralize. Typical.

loan financing. So you do, in a sense, get left with needing to take equity-style capital. And so I've thought about this problem for a lot of time, I mean, about 15 or 20 years. And even though I see the excesses of driving towards extreme outcomes, and we see a lot of bad behavior coming out of VC-backed companies, whether it's WeWork or Uber or others, I find it hard to think of a model that allows you to have a returns profile across your portfolio that is made up of two, three, four times return companies, a more mediated return profile. Given that these companies simply don't have any assets, they've got nothing more than an idea, conviction, stamina, and the blood of the founders at the beginning. I know people are trying for this model, but I keep coming back to the fact that I think the way the industry is configured at the moment is probably roughly the right configuration. Well, I think there should be different forms of capital for different founders that want to be on different journeys. I think the challenge and where you and I are getting stuck a little bit here is a founder that doesn't really have the appetite to be on that crazy rollercoaster ride journey that is required to build a multi-billion dollar outlier success.

So I think it's this crisis of perception in some ways or not being actually very real and authentic about the type of journey that you want to be on. That's where you get the mismatch. I think if someone says, listen, I think I'm dedicating my life to solving this problem. I have the next 20, 30, 40 years to do this. I am going to be patient. I'm going to do it in the right way. But I want to own the bulk of my business. I want to do this funded predominantly through friends and family, through crowdfunding, through some very patient family office money. I want to subsidize this with customer capital over time. I'm going to look for grants. I think there are people who, if they're honest about what...

what journeys they want to be on. They should be on those journeys, but they shouldn't look and sort of covet and project, you know, the way they are on the inside, because the reality of those journeys is never quite as, you know, beautiful and perfect and easy as it looks from the outside. So Kindred is based in London and Europe always feels, has always got this story that around startups, which is it doesn't have the outcomes that we see coming out of Silicon Valley, but it's nearly there. Things are getting better. It's nearly there. Are they? I think the answer is yes. And I think the answer is also, you know, looking with a fine tooth comb at where we think some of those big opportunities will come from. Like if I look at the UK,

alone. There are six of the top 30 universities on the face of the globe are in and around the UK. There's only one in the whole rest of Europe combined, which is ETH, which is in Switzerland. And to give you a corollary example, there's three in California. So like there's six in the UK. Let's now think about what some of the most cutting edge disciplines that, you know, massive businesses will be built at the intersection of technologies in areas like synthetic biology and applying this combination of engineering and biology, which historically sort of weren't overlapping disciplines into a single new discipline or areas like machine learning and artificial intelligence. You know, these cutting edge disciplines.

are very well represented in these academic campuses where you have master's and PhD students who are studying and at the leading edge of these disciplines who historically, probably because of environmental contexts or appetite for risk or sort of cultural norms, would have joined McKinsey or Goldman or maybe stayed in academia and now think about entrepreneurship as not a euphemism for unemployment, but something that's actually a really exciting perspective option for them. And so if I think about where I think some of the biggest outcomes in Europe will come from, it is from quite deeply technical founders who come out of some of these extraordinary institutions and who partner themselves with now the cohort of executor of operator who has seen the growth journey before, which was one of the things that we were really missing 10 years ago in Europe is that we didn't have the AdYens and the Spotify's and the TransferWise's and the Deliveroo's. And we didn't have all those experiences on the management teams of people who had been on that journey before and could bring that to bear in their next adventure. So I absolutely think if you plot the trajectory, it is a hugely exciting one. We're putting our money where our mouth is. We've just raised our second fund with the same strategy to deploy in Europe. But absolutely, we see huge opportunity there. Of course, in some sense, any venture capitalist in Europe is going to give me that answer. And they would have given me the answer for the last two decades.

But of course, what you still need as a founder to have this great outcome is you need a really big market. And you also need a capital market where you can go off and exit. And the capital market of choice has been NASDAQ and then more recently, the New York Stock Exchange. So how important are those two other attributes, addressable market and market size, and then later stage capital and a venue to exit? I think the benefit of today versus 10 years ago or certainly 20 years ago is just the global nature of the societies that we operate in. And I think any business that we get really excited about.

would have a global outlook, would be looking for global impact and can actually achieve that pretty much from day one. And I think this is something that we've really seen explode in the last five years, certainly, and even in this COVID era in the last nine months, is that the capital base is also incredibly global. And we just live in such a data-rich world that those early signals and signs are discernible on a global basis. So the minute a company starts to get escape velocity, that is discernible from a Silicon Valley-based investor, from a Chinese-based investor. just the same way that it's discernible to a local European player. I think it is more of a local business at pre-seed and seed, but the alphabet rounds are turning completely global and certainly the customer bases are global as well. So we see them addressing big global opportunities and therefore looking at global outcomes.

I know that you are a people-oriented rather than a thematic investor, but if there are particular themes that interest you, if there are things that are the intersection of technology and other domains, which are the ones that you're most interested in right now? I think one in particular for me is this intersection of technology, computation, robotics, automation, and biology. Yeah, this idea of synthetic biology is pretty interesting. And there's obviously been... a bunch of investment in this sector already. I spoke with Josh Hoffman, who's the CEO of a company called Zymogen a couple of weeks back, and Vijay Pandey, who runs the bio fund at Andreessen Horowitz, and Deep Nishar, who does something similar at SoftBank. So if we look at that particular area for a general listener, and we step out in seven or eight years, that's the kind of horizon that you have, what are the types of things that founders will have built using this set of technologies? I think one of the things that is so fascinating is applying these engineering disciplines to the world of biology and thinking about building.

new things. So fundamentally in engineering, you're using zeros and ones and bits. And how do we think about applying those same principles of engineering, but maybe to the ATCGs, you know, that's letters of the DNA. And how do we think about constructing new things, engineering life? You know, one company that we looked at recently, for example, was looking at new ways of engineering plant life so that it took on new characteristics that would be really useful. If you can take structures of proteins testing.

through robotics and automation in a lab, you can create drugs for traditionally undruggable conditions. I think we're going to see a lot of that. And I have a child who has a very rare disease, and I think about it a lot as a parent. Now, they would have been completely overlooked before. There's no way that you can apply brute force or human capital to solving those problems. But if you could deploy technology and algorithms and you could automate a lot of that, then actually, I think there will be discoveries in these edge cases where historically we just didn't have the economic structures to address them. So I'm hugely hopeful from both a personal and professional standpoint.

That is an amazing picture that you have painted. It's quite an optimistic picture. The idea that we can bring brilliant brains together with the right kind of capital, the right kind of support to tackle some of these novel domains. And you've also shared with us some of the DNA behind Equitable Venture. So Leila Zenya, thank you so much for taking the time today. Thank you. It was so much fun.

Thanks to Exponential View Premium members who attend. This recording, Kate Antrobus, Gustav Stromfeld, Paolo Bonomo, Christina Nisheva and Chris Chrysanthou. And finally, Exponential View is a production of e to the pi i plus one limited.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Azeem Azhar's Exponential View?

This episode is 49 minutes long.

When was this Azeem Azhar's Exponential View episode published?

This episode was published on December 16, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Azeem Azhar's Exponential View episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.