Skip to content
Masterclass: Maximising Player Potential episode artwork

Aug 15, 2017 29 min

Masterclass: Maximising Player Potential

from Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching Hosted by Player Development Project

Don’t miss this fantastic Masterclass Discussion with New Zealand Football Technical Director, Rob Sherman. PDP Editor, Dave Wright, drives the discussion around maximising player potential. Rob has travelled around the world working in senior coach education and technical director roles with the Welsh FA, Football Federation Australia & NZ Football.We tap into Rob’s vast experience in the game, hearing about his journey from playing to coaching. We talk skill acquisition and how to design sessions that enable maximum opportunity for players to develop as well as some key advice around what makes an effective coach. Don’t miss this discussion with a true player development innovator. Exclusive offer for Podcast listeners: 30 Days Free Active Membership. Visit www.playerdevelopmentproject.com/podcast

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Don’t miss this fantastic Masterclass Discussion with New Zealand Football Technical Director, Rob Sherman. PDP Editor, Dave Wright, drives the discussion around maximising player potential. Rob has travelled around the world working in senior coach education and technical director roles with the Welsh FA, Football Federation Australia & NZ Football.We tap into Rob’s vast experience in the game, hearing about his journey from playing to coaching. We talk skill acquisition and how to desi...

Ready to play

Masterclass: Maximising Player Potential

0:00 29:45
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Thanks for tuning in to the Play Development Project Podcast. This conversation was recorded at the time that our guest, Rob Sherman, was technical director of New Zealand football. Unfortunately, due to circumstance, Rob had to step aside from the role in early 2017. However we hope you enjoy this fantastic discussion with the world leading coach developer and football administrator.

Rob has a wealth of experience that coaches can learn from. In this interview, Rob speaks candidly about play development in New Zealand, coach education, session design and many other topics. Enjoy the podcast. Welcome to the Play Development Project Podcast.

My name is Dave Light, co-founder and editor of Play Development Project. PDP is a website for coaches who are committed to their name and we provide a huge library of resources which consists of cutting edge insights from the world's most innovative play developers, coach educators and researchers. If you want to learn from the best and join a community of like minded coaches, then check out playdevelopmentproject.com. On this week's Play Development Project Podcast, we're joined by one of our expert contributors from the PDP Network.

Hi everyone, welcome to another Play Development Project Masterclass discussion. I'm absolutely delighted to have with us today Rob Sherman, who's the technical director of New Zealand football. Welcome Rob. Good morning, Dave.

Very well, very well. Nice to have you here and looking forward to the conversation today. So just want to throw it straight away and Rob, can you give us a little bit of background in terms of your playing and coaching career and how you ended up in New Zealand? Yeah, sure.

I mean, whilst you're rich, I was born in Avarice with and played for my local talent as a youth player and broke in the senior football when I was 14 years of age there. I ended up joining College City for a school boy and then signed as an apprentice in 1976. I was at the club for a couple of years as a pro after that. I joined Swans in 1980 for a short spell, I just felt at hell.

And then so I left the professional ranks. I've been playing Australia for a season, so I had an affinity to the Snack of the Woods and back to the UK, coaching non-league football as a player coach, which you could do in those days. And then started working for the Football Association of Wales as a regional coach and went through their ranks in terms of became national player development manager, eventually technical director. And the opportunity I had at Holiday New Zealand on the back of that was approached by the New Zealand FA to come over in 2007, the New Zealand.

And so I thought, yeah, that looks, as I looked up to be excited and maybe time to spread your wings and get a taste of another environment. So I took the opportunity and that's how I ended back in the Southern Hemisphere. Excellent. Well, look, as a cue myself, I'm obviously pretty biased and I can understand why you've chosen the lifestyle down there.

It's pretty good. So it's obviously great. Well, look, I understand you made a pretty big impact in your role and you've got some big challenges ahead. So we'll talk through a few of those this evening and a few other questions.

Look, you've worked in both Australia and New Zealand, as you mentioned, in seeing your positions in a similar role over in Australia. What impact does the culture or the football culture in particular have on those countries in terms of the way football's played and I guess the way football is governed in those countries? I think there's a couple of things. First thing is I think when you look at the map, when you look at the map, when you look at New Zealand particularly, you imagine that infrastructure allows you to travel freely and you don't realize the vastness of the country and or the difficulty of getting round.

So that's a major challenge and obviously Australia's the size of Western Europe. So I mean, again, you kind of underestimate the difficulty in actually moving people around. So the player on the football on a national basis in both countries is logistically tough and very expensive. So that does impact on the financial viability of you like playing football on a national level.

The games usually popular in both countries, I think when I was there in the 80s, the football was the most popular junior sport in Australia and that's remained true and I think it's the most widely participated sport in New Zealand, which probably relies on this sort of external myth as well. And the culture's entrenched, obviously with the A-League in its tenth season or whatever the case is now then, that has put the profile of the professional game closer to home for both nations with our own finances involvement. And I think that's a big plus in both countries is that they've actually got a professional league right on their doorstep. It's all seven, not they're not reliant on the EPL or TV as their sole contact point.

So I think the culture's pretty vibrant and it's in a space where it can move forward with any show of it. And what are some of the big challenges around that culture, particularly on New Zealand because that's what we're focusing on at the moment, but what are some of the challenges you've got in terms of educating coaches or educating the wider football public? Well, I think the reality is that the gap between top football and the domestic game in New Zealand is immense and the investment is currently taking place around the world in top football is significant and that gap is accelerating and there's a smaller football nation with a predominantly amateur game keeping pace with that is extremely difficult. I think also, there's some fantastic things happening for all of New Zealand.

The grassroots game is growing which bucks are more trained in some respects. Junior figures are going to have you figures going up retention to better. And so people are obviously engaged in the game. It's probably providing the next tier of service if you like to those players who really want to try and excel at the game and chase the dream.

And that's probably where the role of the coaching becomes actually fundamental in raising those standards and providing those opportunities as something that I'm passionate about. Excellent. And what made you personally go down the coach education pathway and what do you enjoy most about working in this area of football? So you've forced a strong reputation there.

So what's the lead you to? I'm mistaken in some respects. I was when I was with the FAW we had the run junior leadership courses in our area and I saw a lot thrown in the deep end and actually really loved it. Whether that was just being at the front and having everyone look at you for two days or actually what I found was having to talk about football and explain the nuances of the technical and technical, physical, mental, organizational management.

I should make you think about it and improve your ability to analyze what you did, the processes you did, try to synthesize them into bite those chunks for others to understand. So I found that it improved me as a coach and therefore, and it was beneficial to others. And they thought it was hugely stimulating, both from my own coaching perspective and from the point of view of handing on some tools to other people. Excellent.

And in terms of your experience, you mentioned you were in New Zealand the first time in official capacity for 2007. At that stage, John Herdman was a big influencer and he's now obviously at the Canadian FA working with the women's there. And you were part of the team that went to London in 2012 and got a bronze medal, I believe. Can you tell us a little bit about working with John in that experience?

Yeah, well, I mean, obviously John and I had thought of a very strong relationship, my time in New Zealand football. And I knew John was on his way to Canada and I sort of flippantly said, I'd be assistant at that stage I was consulting. And he sort of jumped on that and said, I thought I was joking, I said, no, no, I'm serious, I'd like to be involved. And so it was a real opportunity with a very, very good practitioner.

John's very thorough, very detailed. Without stereotype, very modern culture. I think that's old tools, a term that's vastly overused because it's a fantastic practice that goes on when people have been in the game for a long, long time and still easily dismissed. But John's a very good practitioner.

So the chance to work with him and add something to that was a great opportunity. It suited me, I could fly in and out, I didn't have to move to Canada. I worked around their camps, did some analysis and preparation work away from the camp and then would go in, we'd go on the campaigns as they came up and come out. And so it was a great experience and I'd like to think that we both benefited a lot from John and I equally think that I probably added a bit.

So it was a great time and obviously I caught up with him in Rio, very briefly over coffee and he's a smashing guy and does every single bit of success he achieves. Fantastic. And based on that experience, have you had any sort of key findings from your own time of both the women's and the men's game that differentiate coaching either of them? My personal belief is that I would say that the players in the women's game are very keen to live and that was something that's jumped out straight away.

But I would say that that's also true of the men's game and maybe something that has become more prevalent, maybe with a younger player, maybe just a way of bringing more inquisitive I don't know. But I think that there's more closeness in the way they both think about the game than perhaps it's given credit to. And I think if you create the learning environment, if you create something that's player centered, develop the right culture, both male and female players are keen to be part of that. So maybe something different, new answers and how you deal with people without applies to both environments as well.

You have to shape how you educate and deal with people based on their personalities and their behaviour types of things. That's no different people. That's something that's come across from some of the best we've spoken to is knowing your individuals and being able to deal with different personalities and manage differences. It's a huge, huge attribute in any coach.

What are some of the challenges that you have as an organisation in front of you right now from a coach education perspective and some of the things that you're working on? Well, we obviously, there was a culture education foundation already happening in the U.S. and they built their pillars around junior youth and senior. So it's not hierarchical structure.

So you can actually choose to be excellent as a junior coach or excellent as you've coached and seeing it, which is something that I don't believe is the way to go that you could rather hire someone start off in the other race because they want to be in the first team. There's a danger you get the wrong people, the wrong slots with someone starts in their under 12s because they want to coach under 12s and become good at it. There's the opportunity to grow. So those pillars are in place.

What we've added, what we've done is we've looked at a two pillar approach, an advanced coaching, a structure for those who really want to pursue excellence in coaching and a community coaching pillar. We basically want to coach your grassroots, just want some basic tools to enable them to facilitate a healthy environment for young players or the players. And in advance, when they were trying on perhaps pursue not to career, they just want to be the best they can be as a coach. And under that structure, we've aligned ourselves a little bit more to the European model through OFC where we have a level two, which is the equivalent of C-licence in terms of algorithm content.

We have an OFC ended up B-licence, which we introduced in the first year, we ran an A-licence and we had a lot of training staff come out from you on behalf of you, to look at that course. And he was glowing, if you like, on terms of his comparability to the European standard. So that's good to know that we're actually operating in terms of world's best. And the numbers of the people engaging on the course has been phenomenal.

There must be almost 100% upturning numbers, and it's been absolutely phenomenal. So our level two is a 20 plus a level three is a 20 plus, and the 8-licence is 24 candidates plus some from Oceania. So in terms of the response from the coaching fraternity, it's been enormous. And then on top of that, we have a re-accreditation scheme very much like in Europe.

So every three years you need to re-accrate it through a point system. It doesn't mean you lose your award, but it just means that in terms of being accredited and having recognized the culture at certain levels in the game is fundamental. And again, the numbers that we've had through our regional conferences and our national conference has been significant. So there's definitely a strong coaching community here, probably very thirsty for a level of education and aspiring to do the best of the can.

So that's been really encouraging in the last 18 months in that space. Sounds like some great strides being made. I know we've spoken at different times around the value of self-reflection, and you've worked with Sean Douglas, who's been a contributor to our Play Development Project. What sort of elements of self-reflection you bring into the way you organize your coach education, because I know you've spoken a little bit about this?

Yeah, well, everything we do is application-based. It's replicated learning. So we actually start the course with a video of a game, kind of just coming in watch a video of a game, and we check them in at the deep end, and they have to give a half-time talk. It's on that game.

They have to do a more problem and design a football session. So it's what they face in real life, rather than as giving topics and saying, you know, three, five, two, coach the role of the sweep or something, well, they determine what the football problem is, based on their own analytical power. It's to me, obviously, guide them. And so when they go away, they go through the same process based on how they play the game, based on their philosophy.

And then we work through a number of tools in terms of the country methodology, and the underpinned detail behind that. And then when I developed the tool in Australia, which I bought over, which is in their self-assessment session, they film themselves regularly, review what they're doing based on a number of questions, which check the methodology going from the designing of the session, or to defining the football problem to the designing of the session, working right away through to how they conduct the session. And on the back of that, if they feel they're ready or moving forward, they submit that for assessment. And they get feedback on the video line timeline, which is much more powerful than verbal on the side of the pitch.

As I said, I might have said, oh, you said this to the better, no, I didn't. I said that. You know, I'm going to split in hairs over something. And you've got no visual support back, or even support learning.

So that reflective process, I think, has been really well received. It's a little bit of work on behalf of the coach. But people are serious about their development. It's how they need to get into it.

Excellent. It sounds very progressive. And I know we've advocated for filming yourself at the sessions. And we were talking about players reflecting and trying to work on their individual targets and so on.

But it's important as coaches that we do that. In terms of just some practical advice, I guess, what in your opinion are the key characteristics of an effective coach and why? Well, I think you need, first of all, you need a foundation. We've got the professional coach model, which, if you like, is an illustration of our beliefs.

So I think you need a decent football knowledge of management and other associated skill sets. But football knowledge is one. And that takes years to accumulate. It changes.

So I think that's an ongoing journey that never stops. But a knowledge base helps. And they're all how you watch football, how you end up at the people, reflection, all those tools, build your knowledge base. And if you like, I firmly believe that you need a very clear vision and philosophy about how you play the game and how you manage how you develop your culture.

And I think, in my experience, that's probably not dug into enough. It's something that people have a clear vision and philosophy. You might have some opinions and beliefs on football, but whether you can really articulate clearly in how you attack, how you defend, how you transition, what you believe your culture is, et cetera. Well, I think I'm not sure many actually get to the level they should do as a coach.

So thinking about what you truly believe and how that interprets in football is very important. And then the competencies, if you like, you need to be good during the match at the end of the day. That's when it matters. And again, I think most of our learning of your play is based upon what you've experienced, which is often shouting from the side, can't get ranked at half time.

No, obviously, I think that's not always the case. But those things, if we're not good, we just mirror behavior, that maybe wasn't as effective as it could have been. But there's a whole range of things that relate to the match. So we've determined that from the minute the last training to the pride of the game, to the training app, again, that'll be the match period.

So you need to know what you're doing in there as a coach and be prepared for that. So whether you're dealing with the end of the race, you've got a little routine, you know what you're going to say to them. It's not too complicated, etc. And then training.

So you need to be confident in training, and that needs to be related to what you've learned from the game. And then obviously the management pillar where you need to know yourself and develop yourself and you need to know others and help them develop. And there's obviously component of leadership. But, you know, so that's how my interpretation of what an excellent coach is, that you're confident in those areas clearly, very deep knowledge and a clear vision of philosophy.

And therefore, you've got to start something. That's when you're going to arrive with that package, when you start something like that, you keep building them, you know, the credit in those accounts. The idea of culture, I just wanted to sort of go back to that point. And I think we've had previous video discussions around this idea with your colleague Tony Redington, with another expert of ours, John Order, who's sort of studied this and worked with New Zealand, like you lead around this.

Do you think there's too many coaches generally who try and sell a coach? And when we spoke to John, for example, he said, for me, too many people try and use the word buy in it. And that then means that you're trying to sell me something. Do you think a culture is much more dynamic and something that is much more fluid, that coaches can't necessarily control or influence that.

They have to, I guess, become part of it and roll with it a little bit more, because from a control point of view, without using that old school term or that old fashioned term, control is something that a lot of people might perceive coaching has to have. Do you think that culture is something that we can't necessarily control and something we have to be a little bit more dynamic with or understand more about that perhaps coach education traditionally is neglected? I probably do. I mean, without being an expert in culture, you know, pass a, I certainly feel that, you know, really, if you're going to have a culture, your part of a culture, not necessarily the sole architect of a culture, but you're part of it.

And therefore you need to try and maybe shape or influence that and get others to try and shape and influence it. And I think if people have an opportunity to be part of the formation of that culture and the players particularly, then it's not so much about it, and they actually have ownership of it, so it's something that they've contributed towards and will live. The danger is if I'm trying to oppose something, people don't live it. If you've contributed to it, you actually want to invest it into it, bring that to life.

You know, I think that some of the fundamentals that I believe in is that you need a clear purpose, that everyone buys into something that you get going every morning for. And you can almost say, are we living X? Are the answers? No, let's not do it.

Yeah, fair enough. And then, you know, around people is how you, you know, your behaviors and values, if you like, that underpin, you know, how you interact with each other, the type of things that people do every day. And then for me, those processes don't underpin that, which is, you know, how we actually, the protocols we follow so that you can check if there's gaps, if things fail, you know, the first default is someone didn't do their job or were they clear on how it was done when it fitted in, etc. Sure.

And it could be the fault lies in the management, not actually with the person. Excellent. Excellent. Well, in terms of, I guess, some more advice for our audience and developing coaches.

What do you, I guess, advise for coaches who perhaps in the early stage of their development or maybe they've hit a little bit of a ceiling and they're looking for ideas, what would you advocate as some basic fundamentals around session design that will enable hopefully a group of players to have a positive experience? Well, first of all, try and keep it as close to the game as possible. I think, you know, the game actually is a very good teacher. It's the chaos there, challenges, people, there's an orientation, the pitches rectangle, before you session in effect, and also helps with direction.

So keep it as close to the game as possible. It's the danger is if you do a nice way to practice, you know, just passing the ball back and forth. There's no problem with that. But, and it's easy for you, but it might not be that similar to the player.

So, starting by, imagine you were the player and if you would enjoy the activity you put it on. And if you think I'd enjoy this, you'll soon know by the reaction of the players. But if you think a little bit like you were the player, that's not a bad starting point, especially when you're starting off. The other thing is don't try and teach too much.

You know, if you go to school, it takes a long time to actually study mathematics. You don't get it all in day one. And I think as coaches, we definitely try to get a learning outcome that's far too instant. And so, you know, the right type of feedback or the right type of stimulus or the right time and the modification of the session at the right time is more as much as possible as you talking for a lot.

Yeah. So, talking a lot less, talking at the right time would be something to try and train yourself to do. OK, excellent. Excellent.

And you mentioned the idea of isolated practice that leads nicely to my next question. Do you have a view on, I guess, the value of isolated or unopposed practice and its place in player development? Is it something that, you know, should, should sort of traditionally happen more at senior football or does it have its place with foundation phase? Because this is a debate that often rages particularly in social media, from those who advocate, you know, ballmaster approach, unopposed or ballmaster approach and chaos.

There's loads of different ways to look at it. What are your personal views? I think, you know, I think that if I look back historically in my own background, I was never a big bit like that without a different start. But I spent an unknown amount of time on my own because I was keen to make.

So, you end up undertaking isolated practice in the ball against the wall, et cetera. And if you read books on, you know, from Bobby Chardonnaw stuff like that, I think all players have done that. But when there was someone else around, we'd better get, so the minute you went on your own, we invented a game that actually maybe we would either opposed and it always, as soon as it became too, we became opposed, you know, it was simple as. So, I think that if you, there's definitely a role and a time for isolated practice.

But if it's at the expense of, and this is the challenge, you have, so if you have two contacts a week or three contacts a week with your players and they're each and hour long and you spend one hour of that, so to steal in a line and file, then you're potentially robbing them of an opportunity to understand the chaos of the game and develop their perception, their decision-making and their ability to execute, you know, vis-a-vis their ability to develop skill. They could do the isolated practice in the other 100 hours remains in that week. And therefore, for me, it's the time of play. So, you're certainly going to get better at something if you practice that technique.

Whether you're going to apply it at the right time and right place will only come if you get a chance to test it in the game. Excellent. Well, look, again, that leads us into the final question I've got for you. The debate around skill acquisition and deliberate practice and what that means and what context is, I think, a lot of people have shot to bits the 10,000-hour role, which was obviously popularized.

When we talk about deliberate practice and skill acquisition, you mentioned perception, decision, execution. This is something one of our other contributors, Todd Bean, is huge on. Can you give a few ideas around perception, decision, execution, and I guess how we can then go and coach that? Well, I suppose, let's put in simple terms, perception is what you see in here.

So, you know, if you take the UNI passing all back and forth, I see you in front of me and I'm passing one a straight line and you can vary that. But I don't experience anything in my peripheral, I don't have something beyond you, something to the side of me left me behind me, which is a fundamentally-naked game, it's a 360-degree game. So, that's something that, if you can, you know, if those elements can be in left, right, middle, far, for instance, in my perception, then at least I get used to recognizing those triggers, whether they're opponent or a teammate. Those are the decisions that make them.

My decisions are always influenced by other people in the game, or by space, or the flight of the ball, or my teammates, the opponent, et cetera. So, if they're missing, how can I make a, if they're missing from my practice environment, by the liberty of practice environment, how can I then, you know, learn to proceed with the side and make the right choice and then the execution comes down and do well, can actually, you know, use the right technique at the right time. And that, for me, in the skill acquisition phase, the more we can expose players to game-like resistances, where the game components in a ball, a opponent, teammate, space, a orientation of the goal at present, and the more likely is that they were able to come with that chaos, because it is chaos, when you're actually playing the game. The worthy way from that, then the less likely the skill acquisition success.

And then when we say skill acquisition, I mean, there's a misnomer between technique and skill. So, for me, skill is, you know, you actually have the technique and then you can apply it at the right time, based on the right of the circumstances. So, you're able to perceive the side next to you, consistently, is the mark of a skillful player. Not something to do with that was the E, 1000 key, yeah.

I think the semantics are absolutely key there, and I think that's a fantastic way to conclude our call and I guess, you know, really it goes back to making that training session as realistic as possible. So, Rob, I want to thank you very much for your time today and your expertise and wisdom, you know, obviously vast experience. It's been great to have you on the call and we hope we can continue to work with you. Pleasure.

Pleasure. Thank you very much. We'll see you again soon for another Play Developer Project Masterclass video discussion.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode published?

This episode was published on August 15, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Player Development Project Podcast - Learning Tools for Soccer Coaching episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.