Matthew Tuttle | Ross Hendricks | David Nicoski

1. Strategic Actions and Decisions* Maintain very small position sizing in speculative bottleneck trades (Space, Photonics, Memory): A space ETF doubled in two months since launch. The speakers advise position sizing of 1%, 0.5%, or 2% maximum so that if “everything goes to hell in a handbasket, it’s not a big deal.” [00:37:24]* Rotate capital into the “HALO” (Heavy Asset, Low Obsolescence) trade: Shift allocations toward railroads, energy, utilities, staples, and materials—companies that AI needs but that AI cannot put out of business. This represents “the new value.” [00:39:19]* Prepare for a “no bleed” tail risk hedge using option strategies: Traditional put buying bleeds dry. A new ETF strategy using ratio back spreads and put/call spreads on VIX and the S&P aims to profit only during major crashes like 2008 or COVID while staying flat during small drawdowns. [01:03:53]* Monitor leveraged ETF creation volumes as a concern indicator: A 2x MicroStrategy ETF had $525 million in assets and created $224 million in a single day million in a single day—half the fund. The speaker says, “I do worry” and “I’m a little concerned” when seeing this dynamic. [01:05:34]* Audit thematic ETF holdings for “dirty” composition before buying: Some space ETFs hold 75 stocks when there are not 75 pure play space names. A competitor’s “photonics ETF” does not show a photonics stock until holding number six. Verify the top holdings before deploying capital. [01:11:46]2. Executive SummaryThe market exhibits extreme divergence. While the S&P trades near highs, underlying breadth is weak: Mastercard and Visa are hitting multi-year relative strength lows, and Pfizer is at a 49-year relative strength low, down 90% in relative terms since 2002. Meanwhile, a narrow basket of AI and speculative momentum stocks is in a blow-off top reminiscent of 1999. The speakers unanimously agree that chasing “juice” (Space, Photonics, Memory) is risky, though they cannot predict the exact top. The actionable barbell strategy is: first, maintain very small position sizes (1-2%) in speculative themes, and second, rotate into “HALO” assets (railroads, energy, utilities) that AI cannot disrupt. A “no-bleed” tail risk ETF is also in development for crash protection without the typical decay cost.3. Key Takeaways and Practical Lessons1. Valuing Cyclical Commodity Stocks on P/E is “Analytical Malpractice”: The speaker compares semiconductor stocks to shipping stocks. Shipping stocks can trade at 2x earnings at their peak, but everyone knows you do not value them on P/E because earnings are volatile. The same logic applies to semiconductors.* Practical Lesson: When a cyclical stock is up over 100% and trading on a low P/E, value it on net asset value and replacement costs instead of trailing earnings.2. The “HALO” Trade is the New Defensive Value: Traditional value names like Visa, Mastercard, Pfizer, and McDonald’s are hitting multi-year or multi-decade relative strength lows. Real defensiveness is shifting to heavy asset companies AI cannot disrupt.* Practical Lesson: Review portfolios for “low P/E” traps in consumer staples and financials; consider replacing them with railroads, energy infrastructure, and utilities.3. Parabolic ETF Creation Volume is a Warning Sign: A 2x MicroStrategy ETF had 525 million in assets and created 224 million in a single day—nearly half the fund in one trading session. This magnitude of inflow into a single leveraged product signals excessive speculation.* Practical Lesson: Monitor daily creation volumes of leveraged ETFs tied to momentum stocks. When creation exceeds 30-40% of assets in a single day, treat it as a yellow flag and reduce position sizing accordingly.4. Most Thematic ETFs Are Not Pure Plays: A space ETF may hold 75 stocks when only about 15 pure play space names exist. A photonics ETF from a competitor does not list a photonics stock until the sixth holding.* Practical Lesson: Before buying any thematic ETF, download the holdings and verify that the top 5-10 positions are actually pure plays on the stated theme.5. Congressional Trade Tracking Was Blocked by Exchanges: The speaker tried to launch an ETF that would scrape Congressional trades (including Nancy Pelosi and defense subcommittee members). All three major exchanges refused to list it without providing grounds.* Practical Lesson: The fact that exchanges blocked this product suggests the informational edge is real. Follow third-party services that track Congressional trades manually.Follow Matthew On X here - @TuttleCapitalFollow Ross On X here - @Ross__HendricksFollow David On X here - @davevermilionWatch on Youtube Below - This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit georgenoble.substack.com/subscribe