Diane, it's 745 p.m. Welcome to another episode of Twin Peaks Peaks. My name is Ashley Brann. My name is Matthew Olson.
And we have a special guest this episode. Introduce yourself our special guest. Hey, Matt, Ashley, thanks for having me on the show. My name is Scott Benson, and I reside in Indianapolis, Indiana.
And I'm a huge lifelong Twin Peaks fan. And I have pretty much listened to all the podcasts about Twin Peaks and thought you guys' take on it was kind of fun and refreshing and thought it be kind of fun to compare nuts. Awesome. Fun and refreshing.
Like ginger beer. Like ginger beer. Oh, wait. I just spoiled the surprise.
I don't even think Ashley's mom has called us fun and refreshing yet. We can get to my mom's comments later in the show. All right. Well, yeah.
Let's quickly set up our damn fine food segment for the week, actually. This week, there is a point at which Pete reads a note addressed to him from Josie, where he references the ginger beer. She has left for him in the fridge. So this week, Ashley and I are going to enjoy some hollows and fintoms, alcoholic ginger beer.
And I'll jealously watch. Yeah. And unfortunately, we weren't so coordinated as, like, hey, Scott, see if you can find this brand out on the east coast of this very, I mean, you can see it over this guy, very hip looking ginger beer. Very, yeah.
And I guess at the end, we'll tell you the listening audience what we think of it. But yeah, first guest. Yeah. That's not the only thing that's different this week.
We're recording not in my bedroom for once, but in my living room. Ashley and I both have our own mics. So we don't have to sit hip to hip on my bed. I'm sure you're as happy about that as I am, Ashley, right?
I am, yeah. This is, I think, going to be a good setup. Other things that might interfere, like my refrigerator cycles, you know, when it needs to keep things cool and fresh. The couch that we're sitting on is actually a futon, and it's very creaky.
But the thing I'm most concerned about happening while recording this podcast, and Scott, you can testify. This, you haven't heard this happen during the shows, just last night, I was just, you know, mind my own business watching some not Twin Peaks television. When what do I hear coming from the upstairs apartment, but the opening theme to Twin Peaks very loudly. And given how the audio in the show is mixed, I couldn't ever make out what episode it was or what the characters were saying, but whenever music would start playing, it would re-enter my personal space, and I was like, I can't escape this, not for life for me.
So that might happen. That might happen, and God knows what we're going to do. We purposely don't use music from the show on the podcast for a reason. So I don't think any amount of editing magic is going to remove that.
Yeah, well, let's just hope that Angelo Bonalemente doesn't sue us once he listens to this podcast as he does every week, I'm sure. Yeah, I'm sure he does. I'm sure David has put him onto it at this point. Yeah.
I guess, like, normally we start out with revival news, but if there's anything. There is revival news, and I was about the segue, because Angelo Bonalemente is officially signed on to do all of the music for season three. Cool, all right. Yeah, which is like, I would have never thought that he hadn't already signed on.
I thought that that was just definitely going to happen. If you actually get David Lynch's signature on a piece of paper, it means Angelo has agreed to do whatever it is as well. Yeah, more of us. But it was good to get that confirmation, because I also started thinking, like, what were they going to do if he didn't?
Just use the same music over and over again. I don't know. I mean, that's how they do the music. For what I understand is on the original run of the show that he hardly ever composed any music for any specific scene.
He basically created a whole library of music that was used and it went up to the music editors to go in and kind of work with the director and shape pre-existing music for each specific episode. And I know that as the second season one, obviously he had a whole bunch of new themes, but I would hate for them to just recycle everything. And I'm glad that's not the case. Yeah, I think it definitely stands out when there is something tweaked about the music.
For instance, this is last week's episode, the season one finale. But as our mystery gang, well, just the mystery twins of Donna and James are poking around Jacobi's office, there's a couple dramatic piano hits or tickling the ivories out of nowhere that don't fit with the music that's currently playing over it or aren't normally part of that composition. And yeah, my bagel place, people who know me in meat space know that I have a reputation for just being a regular physical place. They would occasionally put on the Twin Peaks soundtrack tape on the audio.
It was a real cassette. Yeah. And it's interesting how that library approached the music. Every song, outside of opening closing themes and so forth and the ones that are specific events like in the roadhouse, every song is you can associate with so many different scenes.
Oh yeah. And I think that helps make things more cohesive. So I would like to... Yeah, and I feel like that's a very like soapy choice aesthetically to kind of be recycling something like that.
So wherever this revival takes us, I hope that the music fits appropriately new and old. Yeah. Can I ask you guys thoughts about another aspect that I've thought about with the new series coming on? It's gone from the initially announced nine episodes to 18 episodes or over nine.
They're not really... They're being kind of coy about that. And don't you guys kind of worry about the logistics of one person being in task to direct every single episode of something and keep on schedule and produce something that's in the same vein as something that's already known and loved? I think it's going to be very interesting to see how it works but I'm also a little bit apprehensive about it as well.
Yeah, I think something that we've talked about is kind of David Lynch's kind of hands-off approach to a lot of the episodes, particularly later episodes and how it might be surprising for certain viewers to see 18 David Lynch directed episodes. This episode that we're about to talk about is directed by David Lynch. And I was alluding to this earlier but my mom watched the episode and texted me about it and she said, this is a direct quote here, I watched the Giants this week, not sure who wrote or directed it but I found it to be a different type of creativity. That's charitable.
Yeah. I know who wrote or directed it and I'm just going to text you without, sorry, Kathy. That's totally fine. Have we talked about how weird it is that both our moms are named Kathy?
No, we haven't. Scott, please don't tell us that your mom's name is also Kathy because that's too creepy. Alas, it's a Nancy, yes. Okay, also is at least.
Similarity and last syllable, right? Yes, yes. A little bit, yeah. And also a blackie sister.
That's true. Oh, yeah. But going back to the original question, I think the approach could either be like, David Lynch gets to do whatever he wants to do and it's like brilliant and incredible or like we're going to kind of see the ways in which structure can kind of inform such like a wildly creative and imaginative process in a positive way and that absence might certainly be felt. So, yeah.
Scott, have you seen Fire Walk with me? Yes, I have. Okay. Yes.
I assumed as much but I didn't want to make an ass out of you. Yeah, no, I was trying to be sarcastic but yes. And it's a film that I didn't warm up to initially and it's taken time but I absolutely love it now. I feel like that was the kind of general take I'd heard from fans of the show before I ended up watching the movie.
And it certainly wasn't something that after I was done watching that I was like, wow, that was really excellent. I can't believe it took me this long to come to the film. And we talked about how we think that this, you know, approach of writing the new series out in one chunk and then cutting into episodes and having all these sort of under David Lynch's directorial influence might make it more like that movie but I've, you know, in the week or two since we've had that discussion since I've kind of softened on that point. Like I think that this will itself be very different not just because of the 25 years of context and so forth but just that was a movie that was part of a plan like, you know, slate of sequels and that was plagued by, you know, cast members deciding that they didn't want to return and all these kinds of other problems that probably had as much to do with shaping as it, shaping it as it did with David want to do something different from the television.
So this will be, you know, certainly different no matter what I bet but I'm willing to, you know, let my cold exterior melt a little bit and be optimistic about the revival because it's gonna happen and the people involved that seem, who know were involved that seem to be excited. So that's a lot better than, here's this movie that's coming on the heels of a canceled TV show that half the cast doesn't want anything to do with like, that's a lot better. Yeah. And I think Mark for us being directly involved the way he's obviously gonna be, it's gonna kind of rein in everything and bring it back to excesses that could possibly happen.
Actually, you've mentioned that you want us to do a side episode or like a bonus episode of the show on Mahal and Drive, right? Yeah, I have. Also, you mentioned that pretty soon here in Portland, they're gonna be showing Blue Velvet at an actual theater. We should do that.
I think we should at least touch on that after we go see it. But my question is, are we gonna do a special or a couple of specials on the air, the show that Mark Ross and Dave Lynch made after Twin Peaks? We could certainly do that. We could also cover those videos that David Lynch released through his website where he talked about the weather in LA every day.
We should definitely watch all of those and talk about the themes. No, no. But just going back to the kind of episode filming format for season three really quick, I actually have started to feel a little more apprehensive primarily because this week I've been listening to the Rick and Morty director commentaries. And Dan Harmon is very conscientious of acts and act breaks and how that shapes a sitcom, which is obviously very different from an hour-long drama.
But I'm wondering if we're going to see those sort of contained arcs and it seems like there will have to be, and I'm not sure kind of how those will be manufactured in that shooting format. I feel like I might even use this episode as a reference point for episodes of Twin Peaks. And I mean, this one was directed by David that don't feel like they're so concerned that having clearly delineated acts and dramatic beats, or when they do seem to have those kind of touchstone moments, there's one in particular I really want to talk about this episode. So let's get there.
Sorry. Later. No, I love talking about the revival and potential. But do, I don't know.
I don't want to spend too much on this. I think no, we should really be excited while you're just like, now I'm apprehensive. Yeah. Because the two of us, you and I actually are, these guys will have to stay at an even level.
So I got more excited and you got less excited. Exactly. I didn't get less excited. Don't get me wrong.
I'm thrilled that this is happening. It's something that's in your mind, like, when you hear J.J. Abrams again to do the new Star Wars, you're like, is he going to screw it up or is he going to be awesome? So it's the same kind of thing.
But although I'm not worried that David Lynch won't deliver, but it'll be a new experience. I feel much better about knowing that David Lynch will be directing all of the new Twin Peaks than I do being like, OK, J.J. Abrams is going to start Star Wars off. And then it's going to pass to Ryan Johnson, who was responsible for some of the best episodes of Breaking Bad.
And then it's going to pass to the guy who directed Jurassic World. So we definitely know that the second new Star Wars movie is going to be great. It's the other two we have questions about it. Well, I think what it is is that they're definitely going to be, like, all right, episode seven is going to be like a new hope and that it's pretty good.
Like, J.J. Abrams can always be relied on to do one pretty good start to something. And then the second one's going to be really awesome, which we can know because of Ryan Johnson's Breaking Bad history. And then we'll have a second return to the Jedi.
Yeah, I was looking for the Ewoks in the next and the third one of the Neutral One of the Neutral One. I mean, it couldn't be so much different because David Lynch almost got to the Jedi. I know. I know.
There's an alternate timeline out there where that happened. And then no Star Wars movies were made again. Do you know who wanted to direct this season two premiere of Twin Peaks? No, do tell.
Things that I've read and heard in a couple other podcasts indicate Steven Spielberg sent a letter to ABC to one of the executives at ABC. And then he had dinner with Mark Frost and really, really wanted to direct it. But then when David Lynch got wind of it, I don't think he was opposed to Spielberg directing Twin Peaks per se, but he really wanted to shape the direction of the series coming back for the second season. And then by the time they got it going on, they got the season rolling.
Then I think Spielberg was working on a hook and we can see what a wonderful piece of masterwork that was. Yeah, I don't think that's good. Thank you for providing the context on what Eris Gilbert just was because he was Eris Gilbert. Probably shouldn't be anywhere near Twin Peaks.
Not at all. Not at all. I mean, it certainly would have been interesting but I can see why David wanted to direct this episode and I can kind of see the David Lynch cogs at work in this whole episode. Absolutely.
Let's start talking about the episode proper. And it's good that we talk about Star Wars because this episode's name is made a giant be with you. That's not the real name. Episode eight.
OK. Yes. All right. And the initial, well, this is the, I think only a second time this year, we've seen the extended credits.
Yes. Both, you know, kind of pop and circumstance for, hey, it's season two, everybody. But also, a lot of people in this episode kind of get those names in there somehow. But it always warms my heart to see the additional establishing shots around North Bend, the giant sawed off chunk of trees sitting on a train car and all that stuff, diving back into the series.
And then the weirdest eight minute scene, I think arguably we're then the clearly dreamy otherworldly scene at the end of episode three. And the weirdest eight minute, like what's happening scene at the start? Yeah. Yeah.
It's interesting. And I know I've said this before. And this is totally just because it's set in the Great Northern to a certain extent. But like that whole scene really reminded me of the shining.
Mm-hmm. And the camera angles for sure. And the slow deliberate pace, that's one thing that Lynch and Cooper, Kat and Kommen was their very deliberate pacing of certain scenes. And they like to let scenes go on for a long to kind of give you sometimes a sense of ease, but a lot of times to give you a greater sense of unease.
Yeah. Yeah. It's really interesting. This is a slight tangent.
But earlier this year for a college theory course, we read Eisenstein's theory of montage. And this was conceived in the early 20th century when film was just starting. It was really at that point you were still filming a play being performed from one angle to a certain extent. And then people were starting to do these interesting cut shots.
And so what Eisenstein was saying is that this is the way in which directors can build up tension and the audience can be affected as on the spectator. But I think that montages have become so commonplace and quick cuts have become so commonplace that it's really the long languishing scenes that cause unease and discomfort in the viewing experience. And I think that's really valuable for this scene in particular. Yeah, absolutely.
I can agree. More. I really wanted to be like, I already can't keep up with this conversation. But I've seen battleship attempt to analyze through early montage and that kind of film theory.
So I can't even claim ignorance here of all this stuff. I really recommend Eisenstein's theory of montage. It's very readable and very interesting. And his breakdown of different types of montage and the effect on the viewer.
But it's just interesting how that's kind of just become separated in modern TV and cinema thinking about the tracking shot in true detective season one and the shooting style of Bird Man this year kind of proves the novelty of the long shot in the long scene. Yeah. Hello. We just lost about five minutes audio there after I said, yeah, and we were continuing to talk about the opening scene of the episode.
And I guess it could have worked. We could have lost more. So let's just get into the episode. Let's get into the giant view and talk about the initial scene for a second time and hope that the audio continues recording on our end.
Sorry about this, Scott. We're so unprofessional. Our first guest. Of course, the only time and the first time that's ever happened has to be the time when we have a guest.
Yeah. If you couldn't tell by our two hour long running times, you've never actually lost audio before. But the point that I think I was going to bring up just about the novelty of the long shots is the discomfort that it causes in the viewer, particularly in my experience because I knew from having seen this episode. Previously, that Cooper was wearing a bulletproof vest.
But as the scene went on, I really started to question my own recollection and say, is he wearing a bulletproof vest? Is he really not mortally wounded? Which I think was a pretty effective choice on Lynch's part. Yeah, you have to spend eight minutes with Cooper bleeding out on the floor no matter what, even if you know how the scene's going to play out.
So I think that testifies to the effectiveness of choice. In our brief amount of lost audio, we got to talking about the actor who plays the old waiter, Hank Warden, who's actually, as Scott gave the assist on a country western actor who was in a bunch of John Wayne movies. And here he is in one of his very much later career roles. And yeah, right where our audio cut out, we were asking you, Scott, about what it was like to see this segment as the season premiere to season two as it was airing instead of binge watching through the show, as Ashley and I have done in our experience.
Yeah, that's the one aspect of Twin Peaks that I'm sure gets lost on people that are able to consume it at their own pace now because it initially came out Easter Sunday of 1990. So it was on for those eight weeks. And then it was almost four months until the end of September when it came back. So that was really, really a long wait.
I watched the episodes over and over because I had them on VHS that I'd recorded dutifully and analyzed every tidbit. So the anticipation of that. And then in the media, it was just huge. I mean, it was on the girls were on Rolling Stone magazine.
David Lynch was on Time Magazine. It was in all features on TV and everything. It was just in talk shows. And the actors were showing up and appearing on different talk shows and stuff like that at the time.
So the buildup to this season premiere was massive. And the expectations I'm sure with lots of people watching it were, OK, well, they didn't say who the killer was the end of the last season. They're going to say it tonight because that's what the show is all about. We're going to get answers and that's that.
So for the show to start with Cooper on the floor like that and the old waiter for what seemed like 45 minutes, which was only about seven minutes, that defies expectations of the audience. But I think in a really good way, but not in a way that lots of mainstream viewers at the time were ready to accept. And I had friends and family that I sometimes watched it with or they watched it separately and talked about it and they were like, I'm watching it at that time. And that's unfortunate thing that happened.
But it did happen. And of course, when things heat up in the next few episodes and the audience did come back to find out what's going on. But that was definitely off for a lot of people. Not to me, though.
I went with it and I thought it was. I mean, I was stoked because this episode just gives you more of what you've been waiting for. I mean, I don't need to know who killed our Palmer. I just enjoy being in that world and seeing all the actors and characters and that sort of stuff.
Mainstream viewers are like, like, warm milk. I'm done. I'm going to know a lot of cheeses. Exactly.
Right. Yeah, so let's talk about the. I am curious though. Was there a lot of speculation in the gap between season one and season two?
Because I don't know about that four months. Yeah, like leading up to the final season of Breaking Bad, everyone was going on talk shows and talking about, is Walter going to live? Is Walter going to die? And it was such a cultural moment.
And people really had their theories about it. You've dropped your phone for the episode. Yeah, the actors showed up on like very soft shows in the Tonight Show. Lucy was on the Tonight Show in David Letterman and all this type of thing.
And of course, they want to know about the experience but then they always are jabbing them. Are we going to find out who killed our Palmer? And they were all very coy about it. And they know that's what brought people to the program.
I mean, nobody had any illusions for any other reason than that. But at the same time, I think they just kind of were relishing the attention and what it did for the show, the notoriety for the show. And they just wanted to keep David Lynch and I read things he would have never wanted to answer the score was. I mean, he really wanted the world of Twin Peaks to just continue and to just evolve into ongoing mysteries that were all intertwined with Laura Palmer.
So that wasn't for everyone at the time. But now it's just funny that in retrospect, how everything's changed with what people expect from their dramatic series like this. And Twin Peaks fits right in with basically all those types of shows now. Yeah, it's interesting.
I think we definitely have to do an episode where we talk about the influence of Twin Peaks. I was talking to my work friend earlier this week who hasn't seen Twin Peaks, but said that she was under the impression that Gilmore Girls was very influenced by Twin Peaks. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.
All the crazy dream sequences in Gilmore Girls? Yeah. Yeah. That time when Melissa McCarthy just spends a 15-minute long scene talking to a log, it's really great.
I have no idea if you're being sarcastic or not, because I've not seen Gilmore Girls. Well, there's a really great podcast. You could watch along with it. Anyway, some more girls.
Really? Yeah, really? I don't know. I'm watching Pretty Little Liars right now, and I totally see some of the influence.
I think Twin Peaks was the dead girl genre, where there's a central mystery around missing and or dead young attractive white women. Desperate housewives, and desperate housewives even owed some to Twin Peaks. And of course, Kai was on that. And one of its standout actors.
So let's before we move on to the rest of this double long, we should mention episode, not even an episode. The giant when he appears to Cooper before yoyking Cooper's ring tells him three little snippets of information that the giant says Cooper will know and couldn't be true. And then he will return the ring. And those three snippets of information are I have them written down.
I also have them. Great. Awesome. Also prepared.
I'm going to do it backwards though. Without chemicals, he points. The owls are not what they seem. And then I have this paraphrase, but just man in a smiling bag.
And there's a bonus clue. There is. There's a bonus clue. Oh, god.
What's the bonus clue? I think it is. Leo locked inside a hungry horse. There is a clue at Leo's house.
Yes. That sounds pretty. There is a clue. Because that is like a little.
That's as explicit as the giant kind of ever gets. Well, plus he requires medical attention. Yes. Yes.
I think we don't give the giant points for that one. Anyone can see that he requires medical attention. OK. Except for the waiter evidently.
Yeah. I think about how that, at least in terms of the very beginning of season two, that's the hook or these snippets of information compared to as much as you like to bring up true detective and breaking bed actually, I should slightly lower and bring up losses. But I think about how this raises questions, but it keeps it kind of limited. Like this is clearly some kind of coded message or riddle.
And there is the potential for these things to be explained versus how a season, think of a season two premiere of Lost, where they look inside the hatch. Or season three when they reveal the others' village in the middle of the island. It's just like raising a nine limitless amount of questions all at once for the sake of this big shock scene versus this very deliberately paced cooper is lying on the ground. It's lying on the floor is great, more than bleeding out scene that has a very particular payload in terms of the information it's going to sprinkle in.
I think it's a very restrained approach. And I like it for that reason. Because Twin Peaks had a reputation, where they could have opened season two in any number of like gosh-a-ways. And this one just is not perfect for the show, I think.
Yeah. They could have opened in a way that as much as I like Mark Frost's directing on the season finale, that was so much more of a conventional television formula show. And of course, it was a season finale. So all season finale is usually up to stakes and have cliff fingers.
But that seemed like it was running at a pace of like 15 on a scale of one to 10. Whereas this is like David Lynch just going, OK, we have that excitement. Now I'm sorry, I'm co-opting your David Lynch. And I can't do it as well as you, Matt.
I'm going to try. Wait, what are you talking about? We have David on the front. I'm sorry, sorry.
But when Lynch comes back, everything just comes to a dead halt. And then slowly goes on. And I just love that. I think that's awesome.
Yeah. I think it was such a deliberate choice on Lynch's part to kind of set up these little tendrils that take on their own life as the series goes on. But it kind of narrows the scope in a certain sense to this parameter that he's setting in the season 2 premiere. Now, Ashley, let's get into the conversation.
We cut short last week. Because before we even see what's going to happen to Cooper, we cut away with one eye jacks and start to resolve or start to move on from one of our other cliffhangers involving Audrey and her dad, Ben. I guess this is now the time for a fuller discussion of that whole scenario. I'm really curious as to what your thoughts on our.
Because I have opinions on how this is resolved and where the storyline goes from here. But I want to know what your particular take on the scene is. I mean, it's a pretty disturbing scene, in my opinion. Audrey is obviously not consenting to what's going on.
And for Ben, that's just sort of tiddling. He says that she really knows how to catch a man's interest. Because she's kind of in his mind playing hard to get. And obviously, I think that's very predatory.
And I. It's really gross. It's really gross. I agree 100%.
There's a weird. It's not just that Ben is being like, oh, you're being caging and being a tease. Then he brings it to openly invokes the age difference there by doing the three little pigs. I'm going to puff and blow your house down.
It's just like it's not leaving anything on the table in terms of mis-dop. There's no mis-oppertures in terms of making this not very gut wrenching. But cringe-worthy scene is you're just like, oh, please. Oh, please God.
Find a way out of this. And as much praise as I like to keep on Jerry at all times, I won't. I will thank Jerry for removing Ben from the situation. But I'm not saying this is not a heroic act.
And there's really nothing that Audrey could have done. And this is the most we've seen Audrey in that sort of situation where, compared to when Blackie was going to kick her out of one eye jacks and then Audrey makes a way out of it, by doing the cherry stem thing. This is a situation where clearly she's in overhead now and got lucky. Well, she's able to dangle her sexuality as a tool and use that as a power play.
But obviously, in a situation where, if you were to take that route, it would lead to horrible consequences because it's her own father. So that has a whole other layer. It's just only goes far enough to stall and then luckily, Jerry being the hyperactive shit that he is, needs his brother to zip it up and get out there. And did you think Jerry was particularly a new side of him when he was interacting with Blackie and he was dangling the drugs in front of her?
It was a much more hardcore sleazy side than we've seen of him before. Yeah. That's why I don't want to keep so much praise on him. Because I do remember the scene, but for the way it ends, which is, seen for network television at that time, you can testify as to whether or not this was kind of pushing it.
But just for it to end on Blackie pulling out the surgical tubing and being about to shoot a scene a little bit much for ABC. Yeah, it actually was. Yeah. But yeah, Jerry, I think both Ben and Jerry, and even aside from the scene with Ben and Audrey, take a turn a little bit darker this episode.
And maybe that's David's interpretation of these characters coming through more. And when we see kind of a sillier excess and just sort of, in a way playful bad guy representation of these two, that's some of the influence of the other creatives involved. But they're bad people this episode through and through. Later on talking about basically rubbing out Catherine and being responsible for the mill fire.
I'm not like, oh man, these are the fun evil people at all. And we had a discussion about this quite recently as we went to see a movie. Oh yeah, we did. About the extent to which people want to identify with the villains in their film and television.
And we got very deep into that. I don't know if we want to get into that on the podcast. But I definitely feel that for Ben and Jerry, in season one, there's partially because the joy of it is you get to learn more about what the goings on are in the town, like who's double crossing whom. But there's definitely a kind of playfulness in their behavior that's weird and makes some interesting bad guys that here is just kind of more exchanged with, they're just not on the level they're bad people.
And that we were playfulness instead comes through with Leland, who we know as of season one has just murdered a man and is going to go around singing all episodes. Yeah, the murder of the Jock-Reneau definitely seems like it's kind of lifted a certain burden off of Leland shoulders, although his hair does turn white overnight. Snow white. Yeah, for the life of me, I tried.
I was like humming it to myself earlier today. But I have to say, Ray Wise does a very good job at enunciating throughout the entire Diddy he's saying. That's almost like an alliteration exercise. Yeah, I have it written out here.
Oh, Mary's, you know it's in Dozy. You know it's in Little Lamb's. A kid like Dozy too. And with the word sound queer, it's coming to you here.
A little bit, double then, drivey. Say Mary's, E. Oh, it's come on Ashley, we're doing it. And Doze, E.
Oh, she's like, I don't know any others. Little Lamb's. Little Lamb's E. Hi, V.
I'm really looking forward to the message from your mom about your beautiful singing voice this week, Ashley. That was all the boy I was trying to get you to go with that. But Ray Wise is giving the performance of a lifetime in this episode. Absolutely.
It's just so delightfully unhinged. I think you're right. Is that playfulness that kind of expanded during fun that we're kind of seeing kind of being channeled into Leland? Yeah.
Yeah. I don't, for a second, play this game where I'm just like, oh yeah, I want to sing the song. But I don't want to be Leland who just suffocated a man in his hospital bed. We were talking about it in the context of Breaking Bad and Walter White Heisenberg and people who wear Heisenberg t-shirts and that whole sort of thing.
And then linking back to, as we mentioned on the podcast before, your thesis on Lolita, where I think part of why I find Ben and Jerry to be fun bad guys, at least in the way of their depiction in season one, is because when they're not talking about evil things, they are patently ridiculous. They're enjoying their Bree and Bagette sandwiches in a totally absurd way. And they're 100% representative of excess. Ben looks like you're typical, at least in my mind, 80s film villain businessman, whereas Jerry's just constantly wearing this weird-ass designer clothing.
And they're fun to watch because they're fun to hate, not because you actually want to. The show, I don't think, is actually trying to build empathy for these two. And I got to respect that move. Right.
And a lot of my thesis was about and a lot of what we had been talking about. Oh, no, it is OK. It's still going. It's still going.
I was like, that looks like it stopped. But I guess it just stops scrolling. Anyway, but a lot of what my thesis was kind of running up against was this theory of aesthetic disinterestedness. It's pretty prevalent in literary theory and art history from the 20th century moving forward, which was just this idea that in order to fully aesthetically appreciate a work of art or have an aesthetic experience, you had to be personally disengaged from a work.
And then that led into this idea that one has to give oneself over to the narrative and its characterization and its characters. And that would lend itself to saying that, well, it's a power fantasy. And that's how the show was meant to be watched in the moment. And I think you could make a similar argument about why people enjoy watching Ben and Jerry.
But that's certainly not my experience. I don't think it's the only way to experience the show or experience any work that incorporates this, or ethically amoral characters and storylines. And I think Twin Peaks is going to play without giving anything away about major characters, where you perceive them as one way. And then they change from the protagonist to the antagonist.
And that's an interesting shift on how that affects the story and the characters, what all. Yeah. And I think it's a show that despite its soak trappings, or maybe because it wants to play within that space, it has characters that do bad things that I don't think are just patently bad people. Like I feel comfortable in saying Ben and Jerry Horn are bad people.
They just burnt down this mill with the intent of killing Catherine, which itself is a double cross, which somehow seems it's definitely as bad. It's not more bad where you're just like, we're going to be in business and then go to hank of all people and aim. There's a scene I want to talk about there in this very episode, where someone who is not one of the golden upstanding members of the Twin Peaks community. If there are anybody really, we talked about how affairs are the number one pastime here in town.
But one of the not upstanding members of the community has a really like tender moment where you can see them maybe considering their decisions. But we'll get there in time. Can we talk about finally what happens to Cooper? Does he survive?
What I actually really liked was the folding up of the best things he's wearing the Bulletproof vest that he is exposed. And I think that that was a nice balance between like, he's fine. Don't worry about it. That was just like a seasoned finale gag and introducing some real semi-debilitating stakes into that storyline.
Yeah. The image of him on the floor with the two shots and the one that's clearly bleeding through, it's striking enough. And there's the little bit of imagery, symbolism at play where it's yes, by having the folded up vest, it's like Cooper is not, we talk about the mystical, magical version of Cooper that throws rocks at bottles and stuff but he does have vulnerabilities that kind of come from within his own choice to try and eat his scratches at each other. But I also love how quickly it's resolved.
There are stakes. And then the shot of, I guess, I think it's all three of them. Yeah. Perry, Hock, and Andy.
Or Lucy. But Perry, Lucy as well. Lucy gives a recap of who's injured and everything. Oh, yeah.
Yeah. And they're in their hospital. Oh, my god. Oh, sorry.
But when they're at his door, and it looks like a little like Charlie saying, yeah. I was going to say it's a little bit like, here's a book house where, well, not Andy, but here's the book. It's an honestly, and also I got to give it to Andy at the top of the show for his dedication to continuing to talk into the phone and being like, is he going to pick up? Is he going to pick up?
It's like, what? Did they have a flat tire? Like, would they not just drive over the great or do they meet me? But yeah, Lucy's recap.
I'm glad that it's immediately going from is Cooper going to survive to, we see him on the table. He's the main character. So the signal is like, he's fine to then even ramping that up to the point where the audience might be uncomfortable with it because not only does Lucy then give this breakdown of the cliffhankers, essentially sees one kind of heightening mistakes. But then Cooper's just like, I'm going to get up.
Give me a couple hours to get dressed. Just to put that scene ends on, and I love it. The show doesn't want to waste time now on this thing. It doesn't want to waste time on, let's have an episode where Cooper's bedridden.
It wants to at least start addressing some of what was set up at the end of the season one finale. And it's also then played through the rest of the episode. I love Kyle McLachlan's kind of wheezy limp throughout the rest of the episode because it provides a sense of here's the main character show affected by the events of this climactic finale, but not in a way where it's just like, and now we have to have confined to this one space or something. I think it's interesting to see at least.
It's as realistic as I can be. Mm-hm. But I do think that Lucy's recap reveals different than priorities between Mark Frost and David Lynch. As we know, Mark Frost wrote and directed the season one finale.
And now this episode is story by David Lynch and Mark Frost, teleplay by Mark Frost, directed by David Lynch. And in a sense, we're seeing kind of both threads from the first season finale, which could have definitely informed all of season two and just been the storylines for season two. Those are getting wrapped up very quickly and effectively. As these new spookier, more supernatural tracks are being laid down simultaneously.
Yeah. I had it in my head, and it just vanished. My next thing I wanted to address. Because there's more to talk about with the hospital, but I don't want to get there quite yet.
But also, let's not feel like we're confined to chronological structuring. Is there anything that you want to transition to, Scott? Well, I was just going to go back to the scene where we saw Leela and Tara's hair turned white with Mares He-Dotes. What about this scene with Madeline with that?
Oh my gosh, yeah. That's kind of a biggie. Yeah, Madeline and Sarah. Sarah, Sarah Palmer.
We haven't seen her in a minute, and I'm glad that she's back. Yeah, she has some great scenes in this episode. I always just want to call her Grace of Risky, because every time I want to talk about her, I want to just talk about her amazing ability to scream. But no screaming here, instead, Maddie screaming, because of the dream and then sort of waking vision she has of blood on the carpet of the Palmer residence.
Now I feel like we have enough mass between Sarah Palmer and Maddie to start talking about. And this is, we have a giant in this episode. Do we think, and this is less analytical and more theorizing, when you watch this, do you think that there's something going on with a particular attenuation of, be it a family in the town or the people of Twin Peaks to this sort of supernatural going on? Because it seems like a fairly regular occurrence for some.
Yeah, I would say that they've already established that Laura had dreams and visions, to a certain extent, when Donna was telling James and then said that Sarah had those visions as well. And so I think that that kind of falls in line with it would be natural to assume that Maddie might have a propensity for that type of ability to, whether she realizes that this may have very well been the first instance that she's been picking up or seeing anything that was so overtly out of the norm for her. So being in Twin Peaks and with everything that's going on, I think it's probably amplifying that, maybe being around Sarah, because like when Cooper said he didn't want to be there for the police sketch, Bob, he said I didn't want to be there to be a strong sender. So there could be some of that metaphysical stuff going on as well.
And correct me if I'm wrong, but Maddie indicated she knew when something bad happened to Laura, she had like a feeling come up. Yes, also this is awesome. Very twinning, very twinning-like. Yeah, and now we can talk about the thing I made it to you earlier, the kind of troublemaker character who gets a sympathetic turn in this episode, I want to talk about major breaks and bodies seen together in the double arm.
Because I think we might have actually all of us hit on all the points wherein something maybe sort of extra sensory or along those lines is invoked and alluded to either in scenes or verbally by characters. But major breaks just calls the sun over to the table and starts to talk about this not a dream, but a vision he had about him and Bob. And that's a bit different tone already because we're not talking about something that is not a waking vision. He's very careful to say that this is significant.
It's not just cataloging of memories and that kind of thing, reorganization. So whether or not we watching this or hearing this want to believe it is, we are given that this character who other shows, when you have the major, the major is like the sort of stern rational way. But major breaks is nothing but kind and open-minded and almost kind of new age, especially in this scene, with his beliefs and how he wears them on his sleeve. So by saying this was a vision, he's putting on the line that this is important to him that he believes this is core to his being.
And then tells Bobby about this amazing thing he saw that gives him real hope for Bobby and for their relationship. And Bobby starts openly weeping. And this is the guy who not like 24 hours ago planted three ounces of cocaine in James's bike. He's not a good guy.
But I think that Bobby is a character who's treated by the show as someone who is conflicted, who probably, if he could really stop himself, would just try to live a normal life with Shelley and have that. But the way he even got to the things that he might be bringing him happiness, like Shelley, is kind of by being the bad boy and cannot escape that. And so I think it's like, I really like that scene. It kind of, it surprised me again this viewing of the show.
It's not one that really stuck out to me before. But in this watch of the episode, I was struck by just how raw the moment that is. And then it immediately followed up by Bobby realizing, oh shit, did Hank realize I saw him shot Leo? Or saw him shoot Leo?
Like he gets this moment of like kind of peace or introspection and maybe being able to hope for something better for himself and then is immediately confronted by this person who is capable of killing and probably would if you knew that Bobby saw him. He can't get out. That scene also is like one of the scenes for a character when they have some sort of epiphany or big, broad emotional moment that makes you worry. Like when I first saw that, I was like, is something that happened in Major Briggs?
Is he going to like walk away or die or be hit by a bus or get shot right then and there? It seemed very much like a character send off before. And I had a note here that just said, best scene ever, like acting wise, I think that Don Davis who played Major Briggs was just fantastic in that scene. And Dana.
Yeah, he was a lot of the occasion for sure. Yeah, that single tier was like was not cheesy to me at all, despite single tiers usually being. No, actually it was the cut to that setting where the guy just says, damn, that's a good pie. Is that cheesy?
Because that almost felt like it was a meta moment in and of itself or just like Dave Lynch being like, yep, we're the pie show. Did you here's your pie I mentioned? But then again, there's a much gentler pie call out between Shelley and Norma. Yeah, well, and also Major Briggs is eating that huckleberry pie at the top of that.
But that the kind of jarring difference between those two moments in that one scene reminded me of the kind of balance of tragedy and humor that we saw in the funeral episode. Obviously on a much smaller scale, but I think that the show can mix those two elements very well and I'm glad to see that in this episode. Yeah. Shelley scenes this episode.
We see her alone in the hospital watching the news report of the Millburn and Downwich. As someone who doesn't normally get caught up and like, how did they do that? Like, what was the production behind that? I really want to know where they shot the footage of the Burnt Down Mill because it looks like there's a Burnt Down Mill behind that news reporter.
I do know that the actual Mill that they filmed in the first season, that did burn between the first and second seasons. And I don't know if they actually had footage of that after the fact or not. Now I have a theory that marked for us to get the show to play the way you want it to. And that's also that's marked for us playing the news reporter in that scene as well.
Oh, really? I didn't know that. I have a fun fact to talk about with regards to side actors at the end of this episode too. Oh, and our loss bit, we didn't even mention that.
Yeah, we lost it, that the giant is lurch from the Adam's family. Which is a cool connection. But yeah, so Shelley. Well, there's another thing that happens in the diner kind of concurrently.
This is definitely the episode of important conversations. Are you talking about sunglasses? I don't want to talk about sunglasses. Sometimes it's actually the one part of us hoping we would skip over this episode.
OK, well, I just have a note which is that I think Donna is single white femaleing Laura. Yeah, let's talk. We need to talk about Donna and this episode. Let's talk about Donna's OK.
Donna's definitely coming back with a different look. Like, most of the other actors look the same, but there's something very visibly different about Donna, not just in the writing. And she's still in Laura's boyfriend. I know she's still in Laura's sunglasses.
And it seems like she's stealing Laura's kind of bad girl, shtick. Yeah, absolutely. And I do know from reading some, there's a really good book by this guy named Brad Dukes. It's called Reflections on Oral History of Twin Peaks.
And he's interviewed over 100 people that were both writers, producers, directors, actors, and everything from the series in the film. Not David Lynch, he didn't participate, but pretty much everyone else. And apparently Laura Flumboil, in addition to not wanting Cooper and Audrey to date, also wanted her character to not be the good girl next door. And she definitely wanted, she thought the attention that Cheryl and Finn was getting as Audrey with her sexy image and everything that she wanted a little bit about herself.
So that's why the overnight change happened. Well, be careful what you wish for, because if there was anything about this episode that I desperately wanted to just skip past, it was, because it feels like, and I almost want to say that Laura Flumboil is purposely acting to this end. But if this is actually something that she wanted for a character, it doesn't come off great, because it comes off as Donna trying really, really hard to be cool. Tragically so.
Yeah, and oh god, the scene of James in the jail, it's just, in the two things. I mean, the way the lines were written feel like very tongue-in-cheek with regards to the idea of like Donna like being. How'd you get so tense? When I started smoking.
Oh my god. And to think that we haven't even gotten to what I think is universally recognized as the worst scene involving James and Donna. I love that scene, I'm sorry to say. It's OK.
It's OK. But I understand. I want to talk about my girl, Shelley, who has survived the mill fire, tally on the mill fire, Shelley is alive, Pete is alive, we don't know what happened to Catherine. I mean, Josie is considered missing earlier.
Yeah, but not really. Not really. Not presumed that the mill. Yeah.
So Shelley crying, seeing Mark cross on the news, versus Bobby's visit. I guess Shelley has kind of three scenes, because normal visits and it's very sweet. And I actually love these small moments that we get between Shelley and Norma. I'm resonating more with those now on this watch than I have in previous watches, because it's just like, maybe it's partially influenced by me focusing more on Nadine.
But just to think about the lower, the quote unquote, lower stakes, domestic drama that Shelley and Norma have both been through, but that they can actually relate to each other on, is refreshing given the backdrop of the murder mystery, I think. It makes me, it definitely always has been, but it helps fill in the edges about the town of Twin Peaks. It makes it feel believable in its own way. So offering to bring pie and Shelley's bringing the whole pie and it's like, that's my girl, Shelley.
But as much as I want to give Bobby his little moment in the spotlight this episode, his gross playing doctor thing, when your girlfriend just had like her lungs are hurting right now. If pizza be believed, it's like happy lips tape to the tailpipe of a bus. This is not the time for fooling around the hospital, okay? I mean, she was also put in the mill by her abusive husband and like, leoparded.
And it's not like she's not happy to see Bobby, but Bobby's showing his true teenage boy colors there for a while. My girlfriend's provided a millfire. I'm really turned on like, nah, just like, give it a rest, man. We can't expect after the emotional breakthrough with his father that he's gonna carry that over to everything in his life, he still has to be a dumbass.
Yeah, but touching on the Shelley, normal friendship, I find their friendship so refreshing because it's like very positive and supportive and also like extremely honest and they're very open with each other, which you really don't see with relationships in Twin Peaks. Yeah, they don't keep secrets. They go and get their hair done and like actually share openly the ones themselves about what they're going through. And I dig that so much.
Like it's, it sucks to say you don't even see that on TV a lot. Even today, I feel like in some cases, we're just like, we don't want to do this kind of... Yeah, that's how they heighten the stakes because it's like, who knows what and how are they finding out? Yeah, it's just like, oh yeah, it feels sort of like, you know, a misogynistic tendency to be like in writing to be like, oh, they have to like, you know, it's even at some level, have to be competing or keeping secrets from another.
Like not feel like, no, like Norman Shelley, like our best buds basically. And I think that's really refreshing. Oh, very, very maternal kind of thing, yeah. Yeah, exactly.
I think Norma really is like a mentor for Shelley and really tries to look out for her. I saw someone hoping that Shelley is the owner of the double R in the revival. I would love that. I don't like talking too much about like, where we hope our favorite characters would be in the revival show because someone that might be considered spoilery, that spoilery, I'm gonna say this though, I've been holding onto it for eight episodes already.
I really hope that in the revival, Andy is the mayor of Finti's. I want that so bad. That would be within a realm of possibility. That's so perfect.
That's like when Jerry becomes the mayor of a Pawnee and Parks and Recreation. Yeah, yeah, it was totally ideal. I want the underdog. Oh man, Andy this episode.
Poor Andy. Andy and Albert Roseerfeld. Roseerfeld? Roseerfeld?
Roseerfeld? Roseerflowers. Roseerflowers, that's what it is. Roseerflowers.
God, I like that this reinforces Andy's kind of above average tolerance for pain, getting smack on the face of that board. Like he got smack on the head with the rock and so forth. Not a high point after having shot the Rock last episode, to be smacking the face of the board, but still advancing the police work, so good on Andy. And then this is the great scene where Cooper leaves Andy and Lucy with the box of Back Issues of Fleshworld given their their relationship strife.
I like that that's like that's not being left at the wayside in service of, you know, exploring what happened with the other cliffhangers like the relationship's tension between Andy and Lucy is still being foregrounded at least a little bit. Yeah, yeah. And to great effect, Lucy is reaction to the fleshworld. Yes.
Andy's greatest triumph that was definitely up to it's Albert in this episode. Yeah, I want to talk about Albert a lot. I forgot like how great of a character he was. Like I remember that like you really liked him but like when he reappeared I was like, oh yeah, you're funny.
Because Miguel Ferra whenever I see him pop up and anything now I'm just like, that's who I'm watching. I don't like that's who I'm watching this thing now because that's how great of a character I think Albert is and how great of a dog he does with him. And this gets into the other thing I want to talk about and Scott, you mentioned the hospital food. Yes.
And you have to bear with me here because I'm I feel like I'm kind of getting out in the weeds with this one. But so we see I think three times in this episode shots of this disgusting tray of hospital food. Yeah. When they're talking to Kobe, it's looked at and Hayward's like, that's what's making them feel weird.
Shelly turns it down and Pete like literally gags at the at the scent of it. So this is food in a show that's actually been very concerned with food that is not glorified. It is not kind of given praise in any sort of way. I think this is the first example we've seen in the show so far of repulsive food.
Am I wrong? Does anything else come to mind? Well, Jerry Jerry also described something disgusting earlier this is pretty disgusting. I understand how that would be disgusting, especially to you because it's made out of a head of some animal.
But that's a delicacy of some people. So yeah, even I as a meat eater would be. Yeah, I was going to ask like is that is that tempting to you or is that just me for all meat eaters, actually? I can say.
I wouldn't eat that. Yeah. But the absolute opposite of the glorification and beauty of food and especially since the food of the hospital has its own sound effect, you know, that's kind of. The little birdling.
Yes. So where I'm going with this and how it relates to Albert is that food is like definitely given kind of this restorative rejuvenating place or reverence in, oh, God, please don't. Okay, good. I just saw my screen, wind, the screensaver and I got so worried.
So food, everyone, Twin Peaks is into the coffee. Everyone Twin Peaks is into pie. Everybody hates disgusting looking hospital food. It's the first food that we've seen that is not good and it's supposed to be good for you.
It's possible food. It's what they give you when you're ailing and yet it is not up to it. Well, you would think, right? Like you can just make like the almost time fell as like hospital food.
It's terrible observation. Yeah. But I think that they're like, but it stands out because like, why are we seeing this three times? Like, why is this a theme of this episode of this gross place of played a food?
Like, it seems like an obvious joke. Yeah. And I think there might be more to it. And this is where I'm getting kind of out there is that Coopers like, like sort of thing about, you know, give yourself a little gift every day and so forth and how fondly everyone speaks of pie and then like, you know, your green bag at your, whatever food occupies a special place.
This food clearly does not and everyone's rejecting it and Cooper goes so far as to just leave the hospital. Like people are rejecting this food in one string, but Cooper is just like you, the recuperative power of the body when the willows and boars are like amazing. Right. Amazing.