yeah it's very useful it's a useful framework and i used it once so i was leading i was leading the theater company and it was near well it was two years before i left and it was approaching what i was hoping it would be which was an ensemble of people so we had about a group of them people who were they come in and out for projects they come in and out to teach we get together once a year to do a little experimental day and i really was thinking about how do i keep this going and how do i build and how do i make it a little bit more successful and then i came across the john adair model i don't even know if it has a name does it have a name do we know they call it the action centered leadership that's the one that's the one so listeners that is what we're going to be talking about today we're in the middle of it actually and um welcome to the management cafe my name is pilar ortia and tim burges is here with me and we're going to be here for about 20 minutes and it looks like the topic of today is the another model another theory action centered leadership which is a john adair model and it's interesting tim i mean i'll come back to my example in a second but i haven't heard much about john adair he's not like a very sexy uh management theorist but he's got this is great and he's got he's got a few books there and i read quite a lot of them during the 90s and uh yeah he's so interesting but this particular one which is action centered leadership says that the center so the action is in the intersection of team individual and task and so in order to run a team well you need to be paying attention to all three and it's that intersection it was really useful to me because i really started to see okay i have very strong relationships with individuals every now and then i mean the thing when you run a small theater company is that you spend a lot of the time planning for the work and very little doing the work just so that's how it works and so task it was very obvious what i was doing to to get the task done the tasks and then i thought ah i'm missing the i'm missing the team aspect what am i doing to create a hole around here so that it's a hole as in who you know the hole so i thought yeah the moment is just like lots of individuals and so that well in those days we didn't have any online stuff so i conveyed some meetings my younger self told me now and that is what i did i just got people together and i started to give a little bit more more ownership of um of the thing and yeah so that was that was my example of that was very useful for me yeah i think it becomes it's quite easy to sort of shift your focus and neglect one of those aspects isn't it like if the task is new or if it's a critical point then you can really focus on task task task if you're always you know if there's an individual who's excelling or an individual who's not doing so well then you might focus more on individuals like the team or or sometimes you can you know just focus on the team dynamic and you lose sight of the direction going in so i think it's really it's nice and simple but it does help you remember to those things you have to keep in balance imbalance or one of them needs to come in focus every now and then because as always there's a balance and then at some point it could be that one of them needs more focus for a while oh yeah because i think a lot of this these um these theories and frameworks and i have to thank my friend julie reese for this phrase that i'm gonna say what they help us do is to direct our attention to something and in this case to what's needed so for me this uh this framework really helped me to direct my attention to what i thought was needed but again we use them we could also use them as a balancing tool i mean i'm imagining that it's probably not that you're gonna have all three in perfect synchrony at the same time as you point out but if you've neglected one for too long then you have to sort of draw it back in and you know in doing that you're probably neglecting the other two and then you know it's constant cycle continues but something that i've often i think fallen foul of is i focus on the task and i focus on the individuals and i neglect that that team level of creating that team atmosphere and having it feel so cohesive and as a group working together and i think actually this theory would have this framework would have been helpful as a reminder to me that there are great benefits of people feeling like they're part of the team and that's actually there's a group activity i mean i think for me it goes beyond that the feeling of team i think it's all the practical implications of who can people call upon for example who can people be learning from that's not you and in fact and this is where it's so beautiful the the model is that intersection where the action is the action center is about the intersection between the three if you look at what the team needs it probably needs some shift in how you go about the task because if people are feeling disconnected there's something you can do around the work that helps them feel more connected or it could be about having to work more as well on the individual level and working on something that's going to help the individuals can help them to increase that sense of team or it can help us work better as a team so i think it's for me it's also interesting to see how focusing on one actually then can either lead to changes in the other two or focusing on one might actually mean that you need to do something different to the other two uh i don't know if i'm getting a bit but i i just love it because i love thinking about these things well and it's such a there's such a way of boiling it down because if like what the way that we typically structure our work is that it's a group of individuals who are brought together into a team in order to accomplish the task and then we have so much that gets you know laid on top of that or confuses or whatever that we can lose sight of of that basic fact that we're a group of people brought together to do something i think that's one of the things that that resonates so much with this is that it boils it back down to that simplicity yeah and if we go back to what you remember when we talked about the leadership styles uh 11 leadership styles that we had i think it also brings it back to you need to you need to pull in different sets of skills for each three of these things and i think it can also be a quite a good reflection tool and even a development tool as in for example you were saying your tendency was to focus on the individual to focus on the task okay when you focus on the team what style do you need or what's going to be most useful or or is there something that you need to do differently or is there something that makes you uncomfortable or you need to be a little bit more uncomfortable when you're doing one or the other and i haven't seen it used that way like as a reflection tool and we can pull for the theory junkies you can pull the leadership styles theories and merge them with this and say well i can be a little bit less affair when i'm doing this actually maybe i need to be a bit more participative when i'm doing this yeah you can have a whole coffee on your own analysis with these theories but that's actually a great point in that a lot of the stuff that we're told and that we you know that we listen to or that's promoted is is trying to bring simplicity but it's in a quite a direct way you know that this is the way that you should manage this is what people need in order to in order to succeed or this is the framework that you should apply whereas i mean maybe i've only just come into contact with this because you're talking about maybe it gets a lot more granular as you go through it but at this level it doesn't seem that prescriptive about how you go about it but rather that you have to you know that you've got those three aspects and you need to try and bring them together in order to get the best results and often i think we have a basic human nature where we dislike complexity and we like things to be simple and also it's appealing to be told that things are simple there's some simple formula to follow and so if you say to somebody well leadership you're gonna pick a little bit from this and a little bit from that and sometimes you're gonna dial it up and you're gonna do this that you don't really want to do and you'll do it badly but it'll still be for the best because that's what they need like that's a complicated messy message which people might have difficulty you know most people will be like i don't know that doesn't sound that doesn't sound easy well no it's not easy we've said that before it's not easy no one goes into management leadership because it's easy but i think that at the same time it depends where you are in your in your career and in your experience i think actually at one point it is nice to be told well you could look at it like this you could pick a bit like this you could i don't know it's uh i'm not sure what the point you were making was but i just thought that sometimes to be told it's messy is actually maybe what some people need i like it well i think it's the truth it's the truth yeah and i agree i but i don't think it's a common message and i wonder in fact in our management cafe if let's say there were different management cafes i'm imagining that there are some management cafes where the menu is a set menu yes you know the prices are fixed and it's a you know it's a degustation you know whatever you just get these courses they come in a certain order blah blah blah off you go you're done uh i'm imagining our management cafe the menu is a little more flexible you know what you're gonna get you might be in the mood for a flat white and you get a casino and you don't and no one tells you or maybe you walk up to the counter and i say well what do you feel like explain how your day is going let's see what uh what we have that might help you do i went to so so um i once went to it it was a training course it was a contact of mine was trying something out and he got lots of his contacts together he was a coach and there were about i think 15 of us we came together for i don't know if it was a two or three day leadership training i don't remember i think it was free it must have been free because it was an experiment and basically the first day became very clear that they didn't have a learning objective this is what you're going to learn and basically they flipped it onto us and they said okay what do you need to learn i loved it i absolutely adored it because i had so i when i go to training courses i never go with one thing that needs to be solved i just go to sit and see what they tell me and at some point it might be useful and it's basically for me going to training courses like reading a book i don't really even might not even have an issue that i want to deal with i just think it'd be interesting to hear about it but of course many people aren't many people won't have very specific things on their mind and stuff and i only had like one small thing that needed sorting out and everything else for me was like whatever and so in this context i was able to sit with someone and sort this one thing out and that was it wow but so much anxiety in the room so much anxiety when they said oh we don't have learning objectives we don't know what's going to come up one person can come back you know fair enough if that's not well if that's not going to be the best use of their time if what they want is something that again that you say that it's much more like this is how you should do it and without being very telling but very structured and obvious and i just loved how to go at them because i think at one point they bottled up and they became a little bit more like a normal workshop and i said oh you didn't go far enough but i love that and so i take your point that everyone's different we all are different stages we all need different things so anyway that came to mind i love that story and it's often the issue is that we get some training or we learn something or you know we find some new theory whatever and it's all great in our head everything seems like you know 10 steps to success is all going to be wonderful and then we leave the training we go back to our jobs or you know or we you know close the book and go to work that day and all of a sudden it's all messed up you know like you're like saying the other person no hold on hold on that's not what's meant to happen next we're gonna you're at step seven we're still at step three here although that's not written in the book what are we meant to do and that's the difficulty because people are so unpredictable and fluid you know they don't stay put uh yeah yeah which does make it difficult if you're going to be too prescriptive about your management practice yes yeah and also you this coming from the other side of you know someone's been in a management training because they come back and they suddenly say strange stuff that's that's happened to me as well that's happened to me going on like a negotiation course or something and then coming back to the team and going well i'm good after your opinion um i might then you know incorporate it or not stuff like that and someone turning i say hey what do you mean by that what you're saying okay right drop it or my husband's coming back and say i think someone's been on a management training because they were doing this and this and that and it's um yeah yeah i mean that that's a whole other subject isn't it about yeah about training but anyway but this is one of the interesting things i think with these frameworks is a lot of stuff i think is like peeling peeling the onion you know you're just developing your understanding developing practice and some stuff is just not applicable to you or not helpful some of it just isn't for you right now you know and then you'll come back to it at some point in the future when when it is helpful and then there are other things that stick and you don't know in advance what they're going to be but the things that stick are super valuable because they're the touch points that guide you practice and that help you remember where it is you want to go and when you get stuck you know the things that you come back to that help help bring you back and show you the way forward so i love the theories i'm not as well versed in them obviously as you are but this specific one i think is one that could really stick with me because it's so simple you know and because it gives a lot of space as we were saying to apply it in your own way and it's almost like the what we said the other day that uh let's say fair start of this yes you're saying you know you got individual team and task keep them going in your way however you choose to do that i like that i like that approach great well i'm glad you like it and everyone else around the table i hope it's obvious to you we'd love to hear about whether you've come across it before whether you use it if you want to go into what you think about training and frameworks that'd be great to add any any other relevant or non-relevant examples as a team said you never know what you're going to get in the management cafe so we don't mind what we get from from you around the table so managementcafepodcast at gmail.com and you can also find a contact form over at managementcafepodcast.com uh tim anything else uh before your tea gets cold well if anyone has a different management style or a framework that they'd love to share with us we're enjoying learning about them so i'd love to hear more let's do that so listeners coffee's over for us now it's over to you thank you for joining us at the management cafe remember you can subscribe to the show on whatever podcast app you use to make sure you get your weekly dose of reflection our website is management.caf and on twitter we are at managementcaf that's all for this episode from myself library and our fellow co-host team purchase thank you for listening you
MC59 Action-centred leadership: a truly useful model
from Management Café
Continuing with our discussions on leadership frameworks, Pilar and Tim discuss John Adair's Action-Centred Leadership which was first introduced in 1973. Adair uses three overlapping circles to illustrate that effective leadership happens at the intersection of the task, the team and the individual. And it is this deceptive simplicity which is a big part of the appeal. The model doesn't rely on a particular leadership style or organisational culture. Instead it reminds us that if we "zoom out" of our current situation we can identify which of the three areas needs our attention. 00:00 mins (yes, we went straight into it this time!) Pilar shares a story of when she applied Action-Centered Leadership at her theatre company. The model suggests we focus on leading on three different levels: the team level, the individual, and the task. 3:50 Pilar quotes Judy Rees: frameworks are helpful because "they direct our attention to something". As managers we rarely have all 3 focus areas in balance all the time. We can use the Action-Centred Leadership framework to guide us to the area needing the most attention. 5:00 Tim has tended to focus on individual and task while neglecting the team dynamic. 6:00 These 3 elements are interconnected and interdependent. If you try to shift one element it will inevitably also change the dynamic in the others. 10:00 Tim goes down a long rabbit hole talking about how management thought-leadership tends to show things as simple. But management is actually really hard and complicated. We speculate how this real world complexity would influence the menu and service in our Management Café. 11:30 Pilar recalls going to a training session which didn't have a set objective. Instead the facilitators asked the attendees what problems they needed to solve. She loved it, but noted that this approach didn't work for all attendees. 13:45 Prescriptive theory and processes are great in a book or training session. But when you get back to your actual job, things rarely play out the same way. People are unpredictable! What about you, dear listener? What do you think of Action-Centred Leadership? Are there other leadership frameworks we should discuss? We'd love to hear about your experiences! Get in touch through our Contact Form https://managementcafepodcast.com/contact/
Embed this episode
Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors