Hello and welcome to management cafe and we are continuing with our season on management emotions. My name is Lilar Ortiz with me as always is Tim Burgess, wonderful co-host who drinks tea. Even though we're all about the coffee, well I'm all about the coffee in the management cafe. There's room for tea drinkers in the cafe.
There's room for everyone in the management cafe. Listen to us if you've been with us for a while, you might have picked up that we're running a series of episodes dedicated to management emotions. So a little bit more of a structured conversation that we've been having up till now but not much more structured. We will be here for about 20 minutes, 30 minutes, so we encourage you to hang around and we hope we'll be able to keep you company for a while.
Tim, we've got, this is a huge emotion that we're looking at today. So I suppose we can start with a caveat that we're going to keep it within the boundaries of what's manageable as managers and I suppose what's manageable for us as sportcasters as well. Yes, the emotion topics in general are a big deal, you know, there's a lot to cover and I think that there's also, particularly when we're talking about heavy emotions today, we're talking about hopelessness which is a heavy, heavy emotion, a difficult state that we need to have a delineation between what's happening at work, what we can deal with at work within ourselves and within the people we manage versus what's better for a professional to deal with, a mental health professional. Yeah, thank you.
So we'll bear that in mind and we'll start with a definition of hopelessness which after finding a very heavy one that took us into the clinical realm from one of the psychology associations, I went with generative AI, so I asked Claude and it came up with, hopelessness is a state of mind characterized by a lack of hope, optimism or belief that one situation can improve. It is often accompanied by feelings of despair, helplessness and a sense that the future holds no positive prospects. When experiencing hopelessness, an individual may feel overwhelmed by their circumstances, believing that their efforts to change or improve their situation are futile. This mindset can lead to a loss of motivation, decreased problem solving abilities and a general sense of negativity.
So are you okay? I was trying to put my own boots on so I didn't get cold feet. Putting your boots on? I was talking about for a focus I was too hot and I got to put them back on because I'm cooling down.
Sorry. But also, you know how some emotions when you just talk about them, you start to feel them in your body and for me hopelessness is an uncomfortable feeling, a very uncomfortable feeling. So as soon as we start to talk about it, I'll think about it. I start to tense up and in a real way, it's not a state that I enjoy and certainly.
What you're saying is really important as well that you are very self aware of what your body starts to do even when you start to think about feeling something that's quite strong. I think that recognizing using your body almost is a maramatami. I'm putting words in your mouth, this is my interpretation. But I think that's really strong.
Well, it's easy to do when we're talking about it at a distance. But I think hopelessness can be a pernicious thing. It's a sneaks up on you and then it becomes all consuming. I think as managers, it's just as work, it's so used to solving things by doing brute forcing when we get stuck and always more work to do, always more goals, there's always more to do, which is generally a positive or productive direction.
You can always sort of work your way through work to an extent. So the feeling of hopelessness is quite discombobulating in that environment. It's not something you're meant to feel at work, I think. Yes.
And I imagine to express it cannot be very easy, especially if you're in an environment where you're supposed to be in control of what you're doing, you're supposed to be on top of things because to feel hopeless, I mean, I don't know if this was in the definition, but it says that characterized by a lack of hope, optimism or belief that the situation can improve. And I think it also looks at the feeling of losing control because you can't do anything about it. And so that is not a very popular thing to be exhibiting in a workplace where you're just a manager, you don't want to do anything. Especially as a manager.
Oh, yeah, because the emotional contagion thing, this is a nasty one to spread. And if you're a manager and you're transmitting to your team, the people you manage that everyone's efforts are worse than that. There's no point. Then that's going to snowball from there.
But then there's a double inch sore there, isn't it? Because if it's an emotion, which is difficult to express in the workplace, as a manager, it's doubly so, which means if you do feel hopeless, it's not really safe to openly feel that way. What do you do? You have to hide it?
Do you have to pretend it isn't happening? Yeah. And I imagine following on from you what the description, the definition was given us, this experience of not being able to change and improve a situation is probably something quite common in organizations, especially middle management, when you can usually see what's going on. Sometimes you can even see, I mean, these are goals for individual contributors as well, actually.
But sometimes you can see how a situation could change, but you can't because you have the authority, because you don't have the influence, because blah, blah, and you see a lot of time, obviously, how the managers stuck between the people who can see what they can see, that's something could change. And the people who can't see how things could change. And it's the squeeze in the middle that I think very easily lead to hopelessness and very demotivating. Absolutely.
And I guess that they, so there are different sort of intensities or manifestations of it in that you can feel hopeless about one aspect, you know, like you might feel hopeless about a particular interaction or relationship with somebody. They're fairly easily compartmentalised. You know, you can hold those within the greater container of work and say, well, this is a bad thing, but it's not everything. I think when it becomes that, when it escapes the container or when it becomes more pervasive, one example that comes to mind for me is I had a friend who worked at one of the UK banks around the Millennium Bike Times, around the 2002, 2001.
He had a group of people, like a big group, I want to say like 40 people, it must have been something around that. We're all working on this big project, been going on for a long time. And then it was revealed to them that actually the bank had commissioned two projects to deliver the same outcome. And they were only going to pick one.
So they'd run them both at the same time just to see which one was going to be better. His was not the one that was going to be better. So there was that feeling of like, this is a total disaster, you know, the work has been a total waste. And he left, right, he had to leave because he just felt that there was no point to what he's doing and all to his relationship with his work.
And it might not be a classic example of hopelessness, but I think that that loss of motivation is very difficult to recover from. And also because if you can see that if you get this feeling at the times when you want to change something or improve something especially, and you can see that there's just no way that it's going to happen, it starts to also cloud everything. Because then even the good things that you can do feel like, well, yes, I'll do this, and I can do this, but actually in the grand scheme of things, it's going to make a difference. So I think it can really cloud over.
Oh, for sure. And it's very much about perspective, I think, because we've spoken about this a little bit before, like you might feel like you can't influence things, but you might be able to look at it from a different angle and find ways you can influence. You can also change the importance that you view on. You view on something like, OK, there's a particular outcome that I want for a work task.
I feel hopeless about getting that outcome. What if I just abandon that task? Or de-prioritise that task in terms of what it means to me? Can I still find meaning elsewhere?
It doesn't always work. But within the work context, one of the advantages is there are like lots of things going on. There's lots of relationships that you have, there's lots of projects going on, there's always stuff, almost always stuff. So I've felt for myself, a lot of it, like when I've experienced hopelessness, it hasn't become that pervasive because there are other sort of directions I can go in or ways I can sort of rationalise it to myself.
I think what we're saying is it's going to happen at some point in different degrees, and depending on where you are, I think also this is where we had a chat about this sometime ago about building your network outside of your team. I think this is where the importance of having a network that you can go to or people that you can go to when something like this starts to creep up is really important. Even if you haven't felt it or you can't see yourself getting to that stage, just to almost plan for it in that way of having relationships because as you said, this is not the time when we come to our team. For me, hopelessness at work is a, it needs to be kept in control, which means it's a emotion that I can, if I'm going to experience it, I need to experience it within an acceptable context.
It might be time limited around who I can experience it within my context, but it's not, like you say, it's not something you can just walk into the, it's not a weakly meaning we think I feel like it's all hopeless. It's too damaging. And I wonder as well whether there's like different levels that you can be feeling. So sometimes we might feel hopeless about what we're doing with the team and the part of the team.
And sometimes as a manager, we might be feeling hopeless about a situation that only affects us because we are a manager, so something very specific either, I don't know, a relationship with one of our team members or our own career progression as well. And I think that's interesting that the manager always has that individual piece and then the piece that is connected to the team. Particularly because you have to look forward and to any extent you have to plan for good outcomes and bad outcomes. It is something that's going to come up.
What if we fail? What if we don't mean our goal? What if this person's performance doesn't improve and I have to file them? What if the funding that we're trying to get doesn't come through and the whole company shuts down?
You do have some work responsibility to consider these possibilities, which means that you can be exposed to greater feelings of hopelessness. I think certainly experience that quite a lot like running a company, some challenges you just look at and you just think it's too much. And times when your energy is low and you don't, you're at the front of the mountain of a new mountain, a new challenge and your energy is low and you look at it and think, I just don't think we can ever get there. That's a difficult feeling.
But I've always, what I feel like to your point, there are some people who you can talk to about it. You know, peers potentially or people who are, you know, it's something you can talk about. I think in a trust relationship going up, you shouldn't talk about it and trust relationship going down, people outside of work. But also I find that it's a, it's helpful to remember that all things will pass.
For me, I haven't found it to be a long state. Typically it's a temporary reaction to adversity that diminishes over time. Because I wanted to ask you about when you said that as a founder and leader of the company that you found yourself sometimes in situations where the hopelessness was creeping up, how you manage that was this part of it to think, okay, well, this is something that it will pass basically. It's just time, I just need to basically waddle through this or.
Yeah, there's a good and bad aspect to that. Like, because you know, show must go on, right? Which is bad in some respects because it means the torture continues. But it's also good in some respects because, you know, sun's going to rise again tomorrow and you're going to have to go back to work and the problems are still going to be there.
But you have to keep going, you don't really have a choice. And I remember one thing in particular, we were trying to build a technology platform. We thought we needed it to compete and we had a bit of success at a small level. And then we tried to do it more on a bigger scale and we hired people in to do it and felt like it just started getting harder and harder and further and further away.
And I remember, like, at some point in that, just feeling like feeling hopeless, like it was, this was a project that ultimately rolled up to me. I was in charge of that area that had managed reporting to me and like, I couldn't solve it. I didn't have the skills to solve it. I didn't have faith that we were going to be able to solve it the way that we wanted to.
But if you're able to step out of that perspective for a little bit, you know, there was still lots of good stuff happening and we're still making progress, just not what we wanted to do. Didn't mean the whole thing was a failure. Even though one big key aspect was a failure. I can think of a couple of things.
I mean, similarly to when we were talking about anger, this feeling of hopelessness sometimes does signify that you are in a situation that you can't improve. I think that when it's harder, this one, it's a complete realization. You can have it one as a marker of something that you need to move on from and then make the most out of that situation. On the other hand, I imagine that there might be times when, depending on our personalities, we might want to move away from that feeling and in order to move away from that feeling, we might, I'm going to say, make the wrong decision as in move away just to avoid the feeling rather than because we know that rather than because we're going down the rampathlon, because we can't change things.
Absolutely. Sorry. I remember a very specific episode where we had this project. It wasn't going well.
We were given like some bad news, you know, like, oh, it was going to take like twice as long as we expected. And one of the first reactions was should we just grab the whole thing? Like, instead of continuing with this, why don't we just like, scrap the whole thing and then like ourselves to someone else or something like, um, because to your point, like you try and avoid it. That's definitely one of the, one of the reactions.
And the heart, that's something I find really, really hard is when you, in the moment, you can't communicate that that's your honest reaction. You know, you can't say that person, look, when you tell me that this project is going to be delayed, like by an extra nine months that I feel totally hugless and it makes me despair that we're never going to achieve anything because that person's like that person's ruined at that point. But on the side, by the same circuit, you can't be like, well, that's fantastic news, you know, yes. And, and, you know, I think one of the things you said in your definition, like, hopelessness, it leads to a lot of motivation to increase problem solving abilities.
And I think that's, that's part of it. What makes it so hard is you don't have the capacity to look at the problem with it, like a positive, open problem solving, you know, a creative that whole side of yourself is not available during the hopelessness side of mind. So we've touched on how it kind of affects us when we're in charge of others as well. What about if we see it or actually, how do we recognize that somebody's feeling like this, apart from if someone says to us, oh, this is hopeless, or, you know, oh, I'm feeling hopelessness.
What, what, what we see? I mean, the negativity, I think, is being one bit, when people aren't able to see a positive future outcome, I think it's a bit of a giveaway. You know, and there's probably, you know, lots of ways that that might happen that aren't full blown hopelessness, but you know, more sort of like adversity on YouTube. But I think that that when you see someone's trying to deal with something and they can't see a good outcome for it, that's, that's a bit of a giveaway.
When they're talking about things in mostly negative terms and sort of dig into it, they're going to experience it's also hard to see other people struggling with it, because they're in pain. I think that's a very good, because a lot of the time, well, not a lot of the time, and maybe not recently, but I do remember a time when people would say something like they're struggling with something or whatever it is, and then, oh, don't be so negative. I think you're right, like, negativity is usually is coming from, well, I've either done this before and tried to change it or nothing happened. And I think sometimes these, these are opportunities to find out a little bit more about what is getting in the way, because I think also a lot of the time, we might feel hopeless because we don't have a bigger picture or because we're very much stuck in seeing something in one way.
And that asking and finding out what is exactly where's the negativity coming from can help actually, someone just see that there might be other ways. I mean, sometimes they are in a hopeless situation and that's it. And then maybe, depending on the degree of hopelessness, you might be dying for them to talk to someone else. But I think understanding that why someone is feeling like that and coaching them, I suppose, in a way to help them see a way forward is.
Yeah, it's a tough one, because it's like people are digging a hole. And so if you see that they're in the hole, if you climb down in the hole, like, are you helping? You know, then it's two people stuck in a hole. Like, right?
But if you stay up the top and go, oh, look at you, you're in a hole, that doesn't look great. Maybe you're not helping there either. Well, you got to go to a rope. Yeah.
You don't have to go down with that. Yeah, no, exactly. Exactly. I think that that's part of the thing you have to navigate as a manager with this is you can try and identify it in people, you can help them understand what it is they're going through.
I think giving them space to feel and to express it is good to an extent. You know, you talked about that. So the tough love approach, which is something which I feel familiar with the other people's have listened to. Tough love is never too far away from my response.
You know, like, I've always got a tough love response ready to go. If I say someone feeling helpless and hopelessness and so I have to try and fight that. But I do think that at some point, you do have to sit prebound around and say, look, you know, if you want to wallow in this feeling of hopelessness, you can, but I'm not going to wallow with you indefinitely, particularly in a work context, I think at some point, we have to say, okay, but what we're here to do stuff. If we don't feel like we can make progress on that, like, what else can we do?
We still have things that we can do that are going to make a difference. What do you mean when you say wallow with someone? Because what I'm understanding is that you go into the hole with them, but we don't want to do it at all. So what you're talking about, like, oh, we don't want to hear that negativity.
Oh, it's something different. Yeah, someone can say that. And I'm not sure that's the best approach. Exactly.
I think if you deny people's experience, it's more isolating to them. Yeah. But if you acknowledge their feelings and naming it, I think it's a good thing to do. So, you know, you are feeling hopelessness.
You know, you feel like there's nothing you can do here. Because saying that that's how you feel doesn't mean that it's a fact, that's how you feel, you know, and feelings that are valid, they can also be invalid. They can, you know, they can be a strong feeling, but also might be a temporary feeling. You can be with somebody and have that feeling.
But I think if, you know, if all you're doing is saying, oh, well, you really didn't see any good outcome here, and let's talk about that for two hours or the next two weeks or whatever. That's better. I think you're right. You can acknowledge and then you work with them to see if you can find out.
But I don't think we need to follow at all. Like, we don't need to go there. That's what I mean. Yeah, no, I agree.
But I've had people who I felt like just wanted to complain. They just they got into a situation where they were happy or not happy because they weren't happy, but they were unhappy and they wanted to express that. And there didn't seem to be any end to the expression. And in my mind, I'm thinking, okay, if you want to express your unhappiness or your feelings of futility here, I'll listen to it.
But I'm not going to listen to it indefinitely. Like, that's not my role here. And if all you want to do is complain about this, I don't think that that's helping you or me or the situation. At some point, we just have to say, right, this is a reality.
And as a friend of mine, her and her husband, they do this to each other. And they were both raised in somewhat difficult situation. And the parents had to sacrifice a lot to get them to where they are. And so they brought up in a situation where hard work and being tough with the valued.
And so the two of them to each other, whenever one of them gets down about something, after a while, I think it's not out, it's after a while, the other will turn around. Okay, so what are you going to keep whining about? Or you're going to do something about it? Yeah, yeah.
Yeah. And that's the dynamic. It works well for them. But like, I think it's hopeful at times to have someone say, look, okay, so this is reality.
What do we can do? Yeah, I think the guiding what we're going to do is the most important part because they're hopeless. So that's why they're complaining. I think we've got to remember that as well, they cannot see a way out when we get to hopelessness, we're beyond unhappiness and complaining.
And that is really difficult because they are already at that stage. And so it's a real skill. It's a real coaching skill, actually, to come in and help the person as much as they can to come out of that hole with our well, just by choosing to climb up the rope rather than from them tugging them out of that hole. Because I think that's the way I'm talking when I'm thinking is a real danger is to try and be the savior and get them out of the hope, you know, and talk them out of the hopelessness rather than helping them find a way out.
And that is really difficult. Yeah, and you know, there's stuff you can do, you can change people's tasks, you can you can change the priorities, you can give them space. There are ways you can accommodate them. But I think to your point, like they have to pull themselves out of the hole, like, this is not something you can solve for someone else or you can do is provide them with the opportunity to make it easier for them to find their way back.
And even that, you know, if we go back to this sense of hopelessness where you feel that you're in a bad situation and to summarize the definition, you've lost, you don't have any control over making it better, really trying to get them to find one way in which they can start to climb out can actually be all they need, because then you realize that you are a lot more in control than you were. I think one, it's really interesting because this comes all back to how much control you think you have. And I just remember, so nothing to do with hopelessness, but with control, when we were running the theater company and all our projects were always like the really badly paid ones, you know, because it's a small company. And a lot of the time, of course, if we were running over a four week rehearsal, then someone might have an audition and it would be immediately like, Oh, I need to go to an audition at this time.
And he was like, well, can't you see if they have a slaughter at another time? Oh, no, no, I have to say yes. And you knew when I know that sometimes I've just gone back and said, is there any way that the client can accommodate me over another? Yeah, they usually go, yeah, that's why we just read your things around.
But you're already in that situation of there's nothing I can do. And then suddenly someone just opens up and you see that actually you can change that one thing that you thought you couldn't change. And that just changes something in the back of your mind. Yeah, digging into why they feel hopeless, like what started it in a work context can be helpful as well.
Yeah, yeah. Because sometimes what starts at all, what's driving is a solvable problem or a temporary one. Yeah, you have a temporary setback as opposed to a long term in solvable one. But Yeah, and if you can acknowledge the feeling and then solve it through the work, I think that's very useful as well, because then it brings us back to managers, managers, managers, therapists, I think it's you use if you can use the work to solve this problem, then well, to help them feel better than that's great.
And at some point, just going back to your point at the beginning, at some point, if this person is really in a sense of hopelessness where we think, well, nothing we do is going to work out. Then that's the moment to ask them or ask someone else to have a look at what's going on, because it might be something that does need looking at, but that's not our job. That's a great point, because it might be a general sense of hopelessness that from outside work, that is coming into work. And that, as a manager, like someone at work, there's not much you can do about that, because you can only control the variables within your realm.
Yeah, right. Well, I don't feel hopeless at all about our conversations. So I think this is a nice moment to wrap up, unless there's something else that you wanted to say to him. I think we've gone a little bit more time.
Yeah, well, my tea's gone. My coffee's disappeared. This is a little bit of froth left right at the bottom, which I might spoon out with a spoon. But meanwhile, listen, we would love to hear if you have any thoughts around anything we said or about any times that whether this emotion is something that you're familiar with, and especially I'd like to hear about what you've done when you've seen it in others.
I think I'm especially curious about that. So you can get in touch by our email address, which is which is Management Cafe podcast. A team over com. Or you can go over to our contact form over at management.ca.podcast.com.
Listen as coffee is over for us. Now it's over to you.