Skip to content
Media and the Monarchy episode artwork

Sep 15, 2022 39 min

Media and the Monarchy

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week's major news headline- the death of Queen Elizabeth II. In this edition, we discuss how the media has and is still covering the death of the Queen and the discussions around Australia’s relationship with the monarchy. Tina Quinn spoke with Geraldine Doogue, host of ABC Radio National’s Saturday Extra and Peter Fray, Editor-in-chief of Crikey and Managing Editor of Private Media.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Media and the Monarchy

0:00 39:16
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to wear me when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for by the Government of Ontario.

Hello and welcome back to Full Estate, the show about journalism. We're coming to you from Tuecis, the R&C, on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia, on the Community Radio Network, and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Tina Quinn, and as always, it's a pleasure to have your company. Last Friday, we woke up to the news that Queen Elizabeth II had died.

The media had rehearsed for this historical moment years in advance. From the headlines down to the attire, the plan was set in motion, after all they are reporting on the end of an historic era. Days passed, and the media coverage continued and continued. From remarkable insights into Her Majesty's 70-year reign to a Queen-shaped cloud or a Kingsley-key pen, the news coverage found from respectable to sometimes downright bizarre.

In this episode, we discuss how the media has, and is still covering the passing of Queen Elizabeth II. And as always, we're two from here. To unpack this week's media coverage, I'm joined by two as name journalists. Geraldine Duke, who's an nearly 50-year career, much of which has been spent at the ABC, is a very familiar face and voiced of millions of Australians.

Since 2005, she's hosted ABC Radio Nationals Saturday Extra. Geraldine, a very warm welcome back to Forte State. Thank you, Tina. And Peter Frey also joins us.

He's the editor-in-chief of Crykey, a managing editor of Private Media. He was previously the editor of The Camera Times, and very notably editor-in-chief of The Sydney Morning Herald. Perhaps most notably was a former host of this very program, Forte State. I'm sorry, but yes, absolutely.

The pinnacle of my career was hosting Forte State. I'm desperate to try and get it back. I don't know why I was that. Well, I've got competition on my hands.

Well, Peter, welcome back. Thank you. So, the media was, of course, prepared for this moment. It's been rehearsed years in advance.

The action plan was basically just set in motion. Peter, do you think it played out successfully? Well, that's an interesting word to use successfully. I mean, yes, of course, the media was ready, and you're right.

I mean, it's been updated on a very regular basis across the world and across this country too. The ABC, I think, will get to the ABC at lens, but I think the ABC is certainly swung into action. And obviously unlocked your smashed glass cabinet with the Queenspace on it, and it popped this pre-ordained plan. So, yes, I think the media was definitely ready.

Has it been successful? I think the first two, three days of coverage were, in my view, very comprehensive. It's kind of the next few days, I think, is the interesting thing. Obviously, there's a big event happening on Monday, but my personal view is entirely already, but that's my personal view.

The media was definitely ready. There was some terrific evidence published and great work by all broadcasters, and across the web as well. So, yes, if that's the measure of success, then I guess it was successful. Geraldine?

I think it does depend from here on in, strangely enough. Look, you say the media was ready, I can tell you what. It didn't feel like that at the ABC on Friday. It felt we were scrambling.

Now, this is on radio, I'm talking about. I mean, everybody did scramble, and so you saw, if you don't enjoy these days in some form, you really ought to be in the media. I mean, they are the days for which you live in a sense. Huge news days, you just know that there's a service to do, you know, a provide.

Look, I felt that judging the public mood is really tricky. There was this incredible appetite, I think, for it. I still think that's there, but it's waning, although I'm not sure about that. So, that is a fascinating sort of moment to be in.

It's sort of judging on the run. I mean, particularly if you're in television, you've got to have your ducks in the road because you've got to have something to wear. And they did do that. But, you know, what has been striking to me is to see the numbers available for, for instance, the swearing-in-the-excession of King Charles.

Do you know, I heard that 40% of the planet was watching that. That's extraordinary. You know, the numbers that are anticipated to watch the funeral will be truly remarkable. Now, that is a television event.

Radio is in a radio online or in different dilemmas. So, I think it's a work in progress watching this, I think. It's a work in progress, and, like Peter, are you tired of it? Look, yes, it's waning.

I look, I have to confess, I've just turned to the BBC, ad nauseam. I think they've been, of course they have been, the exemplars. I've been fascinated, for instance, with the whole business of the Scottish approach. And, watching the sheer skills of people talk for hours about nothing.

Well, they ended up talking about history, which I actually think is an incredible skill. And because I'm very interested in history and in sort of backdrop, that's as I've got older, I've become more and more interested than that rather than sort of simple, what I say, simple response. I've found that a very interesting thing to watch, and I'm still watching, and I'm sure that's what the BBC, and I know the ABC now, they're sending over a whole few big people to London to get a bit of depth and a bit of context, which, of course, the 24-hour mode, you know, I'm a modus operandi, I can't supply. And I think that's been quite vivid.

Globally, this is obviously a really big story. Were you surprised, Peter, by Australia's media coverage in comparison to, say, some other countries around the world, or other Commonwealth partners? Well, yeah, I think we could sort of say the ABC and everyone else, but the ABC seems to, as the official state broadcaster, I do feel like we have seen some sort of, everything short of running, you know, two days of processional music. You know, it was kind of off, I have to say.

And I'm not sure. I mean, I think Jerry makes a very good point that it's really tricky here to get the mood right. And the mood, of course, is different for everyone. I mean, I've been receiving emails from Krikey subscribers saying you're an idiot for running anything about the royals.

And I think, well, not really, because here is a moment. And again, to echo what Jerry just said, it's a great historical moment, and there's a moment of reflection of which you can use in multiple ways. I mean, there are some interesting news stories happening in the middle of this rather boring, oh, there goes the coffin kind of coverage, which, you know, and you're filling that massive gap of airtime. So I think, you know, there was a kind of one story in town problem.

I mean, and I think there is a kind of a historical, semi-historical legacy here because people in news media, anyone over about 40 or will remember Diana. And, you know, putting it really truly, Diana was an amazing business. You know, when I became the editor of the Herald, it was after Diana died, but he was sort of handed over to me in Hashitangina. You know, we've never solved more papers than when Diana died.

And this is kind of this sort of animal memory in the place. Oh my God, so therefore, when the pre-guys, we've got to do them bigger. Because obviously the Queen is more important than Diana. So there has been this sort of, and I'm not for any second sort of trying to negate the importance of the Queen per se, but there is tricky to get the balance right on this.

And I think that first day, two days, you know, yes, there's probably every justification for it to fill in every waking minute of news media. And then there are debates over the National Holiday here, you know, I mean, the fun for the weird shit, like the pen in Prince Charles, you know, there's kind of stuff to be done. But I think we're going to have, there's no other option. I think now we're going to have a lot of it.

And it's going to go on and obviously through to the weekend, it's Monday and Tuesday. And then hopefully on Thursday next week, we can all put our feet up and go to bed. Right. That's what I'm planning to do.

And turn off all media and not pay any attention to that their Queen or King Charles III. Well, I was going to ask, I mean, do you think the sheer amount of coverage, I mean, it is quite astounding. But in saying that, the interest is obviously there. I mean, Geraldine just referenced the ratings for King Charles's ascension to the throne.

God, that still sounds really funny saying King Charles. We've even seen Royal Documentary as documentaries trending across streaming platforms. And I think the crown has also had a big bump in viewership. Do you think, Peter, that the amount of stories is justified?

Yeah, I mean, I think the answer to that is probably no, but it could be yes. I mean, I'm sorry, I'm going to be better here. I mean, my opinion is that the number of stories is a little bit disproportionate. Right.

But you know, she was a major global figure. She obviously came to this country many, many times. Lots of people with very fond memories of her, etc, etc. People fascinated by King Charles III, you know, because he's a guy who advocates talking to the plants.

You know, well, there's a, is he a wet job? Is he, you know, all those sorts of things are kind of interesting. But I do think they kind of, the processional part of it is really quite urgent. And I'm not sure where you would cut away from that.

But I was watching ABC News last night and there was someone at some part of London who threw to someone else 18 minutes down the road and they said exactly the same thing. I was like, you know, it's like, well, Geraldine, I'm sorry, sorry. No, no, sorry, I'm over. No, no.

What is that, the Royal coverage or this question? Geraldine, I look, I'm a faceless to Saturday extra on our own breakfast, which you've hosted and stood the ship off for the last 17 years. Now on Saturday, you devoted three stories. Now, I'm guessing you had a whole other programme organised before.

Yeah, we did. And then the Queen decided to get us all due. You, of course, had to make room for the coverage of the Queen's passing. And you devoted, I think it was three segments or three stories throughout the programme.

But you still also managed to cover a story on Ukraine and Russia, as well as a wonderful book about female foreign correspondence. So you've obviously gone out of your way to make sure that we're not dropping the ball elsewhere in the world. Yes, but we had quite a discussion. We were already, in fact, we're doing it this weekend.

And short of anything, dramatic happening. We're doing a vital discussion about a very cool head of discussion about constitutional dilemmas. Are there any around the voice now? We've been trying to do that story for three weeks.

That is a hard story. I know we're going, you know, it's tricky. And so we very reluctantly postponed that. And I just said to, you know, we all agreed in my team, we've got, it won't be doing the voice any good to be doing that now, you know?

So we made a decision that we wanted to give that full centre stage coverage, which will do this this weekend. So we then had to make a decision. Do we start the programme with the Royals? Where do we go?

Where do we go? Our biggest audience sort of builds from 7.30 on the state of fires. And we decided to sort of put other stories in, you know, to do with the world. And then we'd go 8.05 and we got Simon Hether, who's a very prominent sort of commentator for many years and he's written books about the Victorian area, quite a character.

And then we also, I want to do, what is the impact, what is an overview of an impact on Australia? We had Geoffrey Blaney, you know, the great historian. And then I'd also also knew, because of my other interests, just the role that the defender of the faith played in Queen Elizabeth's life. This faith aspect of it was incredibly important not to go under the theology, because she wasn't a great theologian.

But how it governed that whole duty emphasis was massively affected and influenced by her very deep absorption of Christian faith. And I felt that that wouldn't necessarily be done straight away. And we had Andrew West, who was quite a strong Anglican from the religion report on Radio National did a very good job. So I thought that was, but that did take up, I think, 35 minutes.

I think that's right. So that was quite, even more actually. So that was a big commitment. We, yeah, that was a huge commitment.

We wouldn't do that otherwise. So that did mean we all had to work our incites out, getting that all up. And people said yes, we had to chase people. Amazing the number of Brits we approached who didn't want to talk.

You know, we went to Matthew Parris, who's very much a standardist, superb commentator. He didn't answer Bill Emmer, the former editor of the Economist, didn't answer. Tom Holland, who does that fabulous talking of the rest of his history broadcast, he just, we couldn't make his timing work. You know, it really was all on for getting people.

Brits were on a demand, I think. Look, I had the text line was, there were quite a few texts in effect saying, oh, come on, what are you doing? You know, when are you going to discuss bloody colonialism sort of thing? And I thought that is for another day.

So they were all judgment calls. We're not doing anything this weekend, for instance. Right. Right.

So someone like the referendum conversation, we're being told is for another day. But I guess you do really have to, I think it's completely justified to memorialise this woman or this person that's obviously had a very significant impact on the Western world and the world in which we live in. The Guardian website on the weekend was almost comical in the amount of material it published on a single story. I'm guessing this was as much as much driven by the editorial team as it was by data of all the clicks.

Do you think the media's job Peter is to give the people what they want? Oh, there's an eternal question. No, obviously the answer to that is yes and no, I keep saying this today. It must be a day for us.

But obviously you've got, especially in digital environments, we are far closer to the audience now than we've ever been. And that is a good thing. I can only be a good thing and we should never think to once ramble that egg. In digital environments, you know, you do know what works and what doesn't.

Does it stop you from doing other things? No, of course not. I mean, that's the point. I mean, I don't think we don't get a lot of clicks, for instance, on stories about Ukraine.

But we send a journalist to Ukraine and it was a good thing to do and a really important thing to do. So there is always that balance between if you like, give the people what they want and also what you think is in the public interest. So that balance is always there. I mean, trade by the Queen thing on many levels.

And one of them is a lot of young people, it's really some stuff today. A lot of young people in this country don't really know that she's the head of state. I think there was a poll referenced in the film review this morning. It said something like 78% of 18 to 34 year olds didn't actually know the Queen was the head of state of Australia.

That's a massive, I mean, there's a big fail piece in the education there perhaps. But it shows, I think that there isn't that granular sort of need. So I think you're right to, yes, memorialize an important historical figure. Get a bit intrigued about King Charles and the various things.

Sit back and marvel at the palms doing ceremony so well, and I speak as a palm of course. And then sort of get on with the other stuff. I mean, I'm really happy to hear that Geraldine isn't doing the Queen. I'd be very interested to see how that goes for you, Geraldine.

Yes, well, I'm quite happy to. I said, we got some texts saying, what do you think you're doing? Some funny stuff too. But there were some lovely things too.

I mean, that's the typical story. So I actually expected more pushback from radio national listeners than we got. So I think the appetite is still pretty strong. What is really intrigued me is people sort of talking, I think I've read, because I have now, I have read cobbiously to try to pick and choose, is in a funny way, what has surprised me is the audience for symbolism.

Now, I think we will see a massive audience for that ongoing, the procession of the coffin and everything. Strangely enough, I think we will see a big audience for the funeral. Because it's almost as if people are learning about it. People are learning, you know, someone said, rather than diluting the magic quotes, if anything, it all messes it.

Now, that is not what I expected. I may be wrong. I honestly may be wrong. That might be.

But to hear that 40% of the planet, you know, is estimated to have watched that accession of King Charles, what? You know, watching a whole bunch of people standing around something called a pretty council, ready to watch him, stand, stand, stand, stand, stand, stand, he finally comes in and says, this is this man who's allegedly, you know, so sort of nobody really cares. That was a revelation to me. I thought this is a surprise.

So this is about people sort of watching, you know, watching coffins move, watching cars drive down the M4, for God's sake, you know, to get to back in path. Look, I think we we've got to be, we could get it wrong by underestimating it as well. I'm humbling the face of watching how my fellow citizens behave. And I don't think we quite know yet.

Right. Thomas Canelli Wright in the Guardian this week, a very good piece on this subject. And we was on Iron Breakfast this morning with Patricia Carvellason was quite critical and said, you know, there was floods happening in Pakistan. There's still a war raging in Ukraine, but you wouldn't know it if you had turned on the ABC on Friday morning.

Would you would you say that's a ferris or any day of the week? And would you say that's a ferris estimate, Peter, or criticism? Yeah, yes and no again. Oh my God.

The paper is a massive story. Ukraine is a massive story. Yes, I really hope Ukrainians don't win on Monday because there is always a question about and the problem we got with the screen story of course is that there's some it's really, a lot of this really dull to my do, you know, like popping down down road, but this movement is an event on every sort of hour really and it's really yesterday was seen to be an event on every 10 minutes. Again, a lot is really boring, but it's sort of like it's compelling.

You can sort of suddenly go, well, I won't cover that bit, you know, because that bit leads to that bit, which you will cover. So I think you were kind of either in it or out of it. I think the ABC, yeah, I mean, my view is the ABC has got to get over the top. I mean, as I said, it did felt like they had gone into two days of official processional music almost with a bit of commentary over it.

But then, you know, the ABC, you know, it's the national broadcaster. It has certain obligations that other networks don't have. And it's clearly, it would be in a pretty tricky space actually. So I think, for instance, it's taken a lead, but from the way our political classes has received this, you know, I mean, you wouldn't know that Anthony Nobody's was a Republican right now.

There's no difference between him and Peter Donut and this one. If you like the politics of it, it's been put to one side. I thought, you know, there was very little debate about suspending parliament, whereas I was thinking, really, we really just spent parliament for two weeks. I mean, we have taken this very seriously, and I think, you know, more seems to be more in this point, you know, in the media itself, is sort of taking those leads and reflecting them back.

In the recent couple days, we, you know, there is other debates being had that are related to the raw things. So this, you know, the treatment of the indigenous NRL player, I think, is a complete overkill at my team, that she would lose 25% of her salary. That's extraordinary. The guy got sort of arrested for just pointing out that, you know, Prince Andrew has been about a check of career show, you know, I mean, that's sort of overkill.

And I think those sorts of debates are bubbling to the surface now, and I encourage that. Jodine? Yes, look, I think the ABC is going to really watch itself now. I personally feel it's the quality of what's often that is terribly important.

And I think, look, I believe always that I just can't bear absolute seat of the pants stuff going on forever and ever. Now, I don't like that about Ukraine. I don't like it about GFCs, you know, I like, I believe in angle getting, and that's what I was brought up with, where somebody in charge comes in and says, right, we've had enough of that. That's been done to death.

Where do we go now? Now, and how do we support that? Where we go now? You know, which to me is the essence of surprise.

You must, I still think, you know, the essence of good media is you surprise your audience. And that takes effort. That's what's hard about it. That's what's interesting and worthwhile.

That's why it's a craft, in my opinion. But you've got to have judgment, you've got to intervene, you've got to have the character convictions to then possibly be criticized, which you've over went up. There's a little bit of sort of, oh, just let it run, which I think is a mistake. But for instance, the ABC had commissioned that documentary on the 14 visits.

I think that was the documentary on the ABC. That was good on Sunday night. That was fresh, and I hadn't seen that before. That was pertinent to Australian life.

And I'd be interspersing it, so someone's got to get in there and govern it. That's hard. I mean, I don't know what the decision making is around Monday. I hope this decision making, because I think for exactly the reasons that I hope they're listening to this, it is a judgment call.

And it needs to feel curated. My own view is that something that just feels you've almost let it go, just let it run, you know, on a loop. That is where people say, what? Accurated.

Something is a pleasure. Well, you know, it's something you think, oh, gosh, maybe I've had enough. But gee, that's interesting. So that's, you know, what I think.

I reckon, Geraldine, London, to a break, they'll just let it run on Monday. I think you might be right. I'm from, yeah, I'm from the M.B.C. It's huge.

They're having seven kilometer long lines to say that they're talking about in London. I mean, why are you flying up for those 70 hours beats me? But I've got friends who are English over here who sort of flying over, so they could see the lying and say, you know, I'm just not there. Like, no, nothing in the world, just wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, so the B will have, God knows what's going through their heads.

Wow. Management of that. How and when do you think that the media, or when should the media present opposing views to the Queen, including mixed emotions and perspectives of the Queen and the colonial power that she represents? A little bit of that.

I mean, there has been some talk about, you know, what's going on in Barbados and what happened in Jamaica and I don't think it's been completely submerged. I mentioned it's side of that in great notes. Well, maybe, you know, I think that's what I think we'll see is that there'll be a separation of the Queen in the morning and everything and then there will be debates we had, you know, I know some people have been pretty cool at the Australian Republican movement, for instance, but you know, it's not a hiding to know where it started making a big noise now. I mean, it's a very smart thing to do, I think, to shut up and say we're not doing anything and recognize the passion of the Queen.

But let's not shy away from. I mean, I think one of the things that will be, which will sort of, if you like frame this debate, debates to come will be King Charles and III and either he can, you know, he's already filled it if you like the ceremonial vacuum that by the Queen. I mean, that was very interesting the way he just, he becomes key. No argument, that's not to bother.

I mean, you know, the second she dies, but there is a birch bigger debate to be had and it will be set in part by his performance, I think. And I think he's, you know, obviously very well briefed at the moment, apart from the pending and so, but the type of person he emerges in the way people transfer their love from the Queen to him will, I think, create opportunities because I have so much sense of it is that he will assist Republicans one way or another. I've heard similar, similar opinions that he may very much help the Republican movement in Australia. The ABC, Geraldine was doing some quite nuanced coverage this week on those exact issues of colonial power and how the Queen and really monarchy on a broader level contributed to that and at times on a very direct level too late or about right to think.

I think it's been about right that. Look, I just think you've got to have the funeral, the funeral's got to be allowed to go by before you start really canvassing indignation. It's interesting, I didn't know that I was walking this morning, I didn't know that breakfast had Tom Canili. That is interesting.

Look, I actually suspect he's going to double down. I don't think that the republics further away, that's my view. I think it was interesting to say, I mean, it's such a silly little thing that that incident with the pen last night or whatever, I finally saw it and I thought, oh yeah, he won't need to have too many of those, even though of course why shouldn't, you know, for goodness sake. I mean, obviously, you know, see, I'm realised I'm going here, I'm going to describe to the president of myself, he and he and Anne, you know, they've been there at the death of their mother.

It's a huge, huge thing. Obviously very affected, you know, and then they've got to behave differently so straight away. Look, I think it will be very interesting. I mean, I think it's quite tricky with the indigenous people because there's tremendous interest in the royals from a lot of indigenous people.

The notion, the assumption that the indigenous, you know, all feel it was the white English coming and who made the problem, that's not true, that's not true at all. And it's not true in history, by the way, colonial office tried extremely hard to protect indigenous people. The pastoralists here who were locked into a battle for land, that's where it all went incredibly pear shaped. But so I think it's more complicated myself than is generally received.

And I, yeah, I'm again, I'm standing back and watching. Peter? Well, with, yeah, look, I think it's a debate that we will have, and it's a debate that we should have, and the media has a very responsible role. And I absolutely agree with, you know, we've got to get over the funeral, we've got to have our day off, one thing, another parliament needs to come back.

You know, I, where do we, you know, I was very interesting that you're going to do that we need to start talking about the voice in a really deep way. I mean, it's very important that we do that. Those debates, you know, should have, will go on. Jolene, I know you also agree, you're in greater variance that we need to start talking about the voice and putting a focus on this.

Well, I think we do, but I mean, I think that's a long term. I mean, I'm honestly, I'm not looking forward to the debate around that, Australia. I'm not looking forward to it. I think it's going to be harder than people imagine.

And we had to pace ourselves heavily. Yep, it's going to take good journalism to do this properly and to be useful contributors to the discussion, because it could go exceptionally pear shaped. I'm very, very, very respectful of that. I don't know whether people feel like that, but I certainly do.

No, absolutely. I mean, I, I, I, I am approaching, I'm approaching this with some trepidation, but at the same time, you know, we may well surprise ourselves and get this right. Yes, we might. Yes, we might.

Couldn't agree more. I think Australia is in a very interesting, you know, an interesting phase in its life. And I think we should, we certainly ought to be up for it. But it will require that very thing I was saying, it will require much more than sort of somebody saying, you know, in a 24-hour interview.

And what do you think about that? What do you heard last? You know, how would you respond to that? Like, I hope and pray, frankly, that we don't just fall into that.

But it, we've taken quite a while to work on our coverage in the first one. So I hope everybody, yeah, I hope people put their best efforts forward. Finally, we've obviously been talking about Australia becoming a republic and our relationship with the monarchy. Do you think it's the right time to talk about it?

Or it might be even a little bit more provocative here from the media's coverage since last Friday. It is pretty clear that Australia perhaps is not going to be one anytime soon. Do you think though this is, there's a lot of people that are sort of shouting about why not now? Why not now?

These issues are being brought to our attention. You both reference the fact that a lot of Australians, a lot of young Australians didn't even know that the Queen was the head of state. Well, the monarch in England is Australians head of state. And this event seems to have actually informed a lot of Australians, where are constitutional ties lie and is putting that question to them?

Should they? Should they, indeed? Should we still have this sort of constitutional tie to the United Kingdom? Jodin, to you first?

Well, look, I mean, I saw Malcolm Turnbull. I mean, I was set with him on the Republican Movement Committee. So I'm well-versed in all of this. And I saw him in a slightly war to see him so emotional on Friday morning.

Well, I still haven't seen that. Everybody's told me about that. No, this was actually a more measured Malcolm on Sunday, talking to 60 minutes, saying, you know, a slightly weary man saying, look, I think we've, yes, I think it's unfortunate, I think his words were, all I would say is, he said, it's unfortunate, I think that we have somebody from out of Australia as our head of state. That's all we would say.

She tried to get more out of it. He wouldn't give any more. I thought it was fascinating. And I thought, look, I think Malcolm believes, and I do too, I honestly think the voice conversation is going to take a lot out of us.

And I think we must have that before we start going to that other Republic discussion. Now, some people might say that inextricably leaked, I don't think so. So I intend to put most of my efforts into covering, covering Australia, like there's a whole lot of other things like August and how we're in the earth, we're positioned regarding the US and China, which I actually have to think it's terribly important. I think when he's made King, that will be another stage of discussion.

But I don't think the Republic's going to be a big discussion for the next couple of years, I'm afraid I don't. Peter? Yeah, I know I agree. I think we will be assuming that Labour gets another term.

It's probably a second term, Labour's, Blair discussion. The great totally, the voice is more important. And I also think though, right now, it really almost impossible to talk about this. I mean, one thing that's happened, and it's been pointed out by several people, you know, this kind of assumption that Queen Dye's King Charles is the moment we go, will be a republic now, thanks.

I mean, clearly that isn't going to happen. There will be, I think there's a reason to have, you know, we shouldn't let this issue fade. There is an opportunity. I think I'm back to what I said a minute ago.

A lot of it will depend on how Charles, you know, is seen and how he says, you know, he may be the child, and a lot of it depends also on what happens elsewhere, not necessarily here, but you know, thinking the Caribbean is really interesting to a lot of what's going on there. And that, if you want to talk about, you know, the impact of colonialism, you can sort of see and touch it there and they're really bloody angry. The level of anger here isn't, you know, we don't have that level of anger in the general rule. But you know, so I think the voice is more important.

I suspect the republic debate will simmer along, and I'd be interested to see what the Australian Republic movement does. But you know, again, you know, Elginese has been very, you know, solid on all this, you know, not I don't want to talk about whether the Queen's head should be on a five dollar note, that sort of stuff or not, you know, and those sorts of things. So clearly that's been kicked into touch for this week, but I think it's been changing in six months, but I think really, I mean, I think Geraldine tried to, but the voice is going to be, I think the voice is more important, and it may well take a lot out of us here could do. On that note, I'd like to thank our guests on Fourth Estate this week.

Frankie's Peter Frey. Thank you so much for attending to the panel. Very pleasure, thank you. And Geraldine Dogue from ABC Radio Nationals Saturday Extra.

I've really enjoyed the discussion. Thank you very much, David. And thank you for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios at 2SDR and heard across the country on the community radio network.

Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, a big thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app, so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back with one next week, of course, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. My handle is Fourth Estate AU.

I think thanks as always to my producer, my lead even and executive producer, Anthony Dopro. I'm Tina Quinn. Please do stay well, stay safe and catch us next time on Fourth Estate.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 39 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on September 15, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.