A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to wear me when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.
That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.
This Friday, the ocean shows you to save us all. The stories are true. The story has just begun. From Disney.
I want to know a daughter of the chief. Let's save the world. Ready? It's Maui time.
I'm going to eat whatever that is. His name is Hayley. It's not. Disney's Moana.
In theaters Friday. Get tickets now. Hello and welcome. You're listening to For For State, the show where journalists talk journalism.
Coming to you from Tiresia in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the Euro nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to a device across the globe via podcast. My name is Anthony Dockrell. Tonight's show was recorded recently at the University of Technology as part of a series called Meet the Journalist and it features ABC's Lee Sails. The interview was conducted by UTS Post-grad student Wendy John.
So let's hear Lee Sails talk about her career at the ABC and her path to the 730 report. So Taitan, look three. Bit of a wild old success, yeah. It's been amazing, actually.
I'm so fun because my journalism career has been so heavily down the serious end of the pool and I think sort of the rise of social media and digital media has meant that the nature of I guess journalism has changed. So this idea that the anchor of a show is this sort of removed person who is just a sort of blank canvas, I guess, a very serious and authoritative. I think that these days we do expect that people have a bit more personality than that. So that's been sort of really fun for me that after 20 years of being considered as really serious person.
Hard nose journalist. I think I would be a bit lighter and sillier in the podcast. Does that confuse some of your fans or admirers? I think that people sometimes, well, people sometimes say to me, oh I'm surprised at how funny you are because they watch me on 730 where I do not see me remotely funny.
So that I think people sometimes are a bit sort of surprised by it. No, I think people are able to sort of hold the two things together that you can be serious in a serious job but not take yourself too seriously. A bit of a lesson for life though. Well, let's look at your life in one of your podcast episodes.
About a year ago you talk about a book called Boy Swallows Universe by Trent Dalton and it said in Brisbane in the 80s a boy growing up in that time, was that a nostalgic read for you? It was amazing and I said to Trent Dalton, I recommend that if anyone hasn't read it, it's a really wonderful novel. Okay. Any other British people here?
It's you and me. You know what's outside of Southside? Sorry. Right.
He has a bit of a set of the Northside, actually a bit of a leather Brisbane but is it a bit of a sub of called Bracken Ridge which was one sub of away from where I grew up. And it was just, you know, read books said in Brisbane, well, very many, there are handfuls but you just don't. And so it was really, it said in the 1980s when I grew up so yeah, there was so much in it that I felt like, oh my God, that feels like my childhood. Yeah.
What was your childhood like? What was your upbringing? Very, a lot of personal freedom like you just, if you went at school from when the sun came up, the expectation was that you'd be out of the house on your bike and that you wouldn't come back until the sun was going down and nobody really wanted to hear or see you to enter. So we just rode around the neighborhood and had tons of adventures and went fishing down the river and, you know, we'd be so played guitar-y downstairs and so my best friend lived around the corner so we had a very, when I look back at it now I think we've got a really amazing childhood.
A lot of whole freedom, say that my kids have living in, you know, close to the inner city Sydney and I just had sort of, neither of my parents have been to university. They had my father was in the army, my mother worked as an office worker, so just sort of middle-class parents and went to the local state schools, every night of your everyone, sort of went to the, and in that neighborhood you went to either the local Catholic school or the local state school and we went to the local state school and it was great, it was fantastic. And then you went to GUT, went to university school, which is sort of like, you know, the equivalent of UTS in Brisbane. But can I know that to get into the comms, course, undergrad, comms, course at QUT it was like a 960TE school which is, it was really good.
You needed 990 to do medicine so it was really competitive. It was the only communications program in the state and no one moved into state those days. So what got you there to a 960TE school? Were your parents like, do your homework, get in there and?
Yeah, I think because, like I think a lot of people if your parents have come from, because my parents have both come from quite poor and difficult childhoods and they were very hard workers themselves and so they wanted a better life for their kids and so the expectation was that we're making a lot of sacrifices and working really hard and so you guys don't waste that and so then I guess there was a fair expectation that you would work hard at school and do well at school and so forth. So, and you know both my parents are very organised and sort of disciplined people, they're very work first play later sort of people. So I think that sort of work ethic was pretty heavily instilled in us. Did that tell you word of party or at uni?
You were a student? When he was? I was not. I'm pretty square.
I definitely wasn't somebody that was out, you know, rebelling and living a wildlife or whatever. I think as well because when we were at uni, it was, when Australia was in the recession we had to have and the biggest fear for everybody was that you would not get a job because the unemployment rate was so high and so everybody really was working hard and not, you didn't sort of do your degree and then just bugger up overseas for a year. Even if you got off the job like it had only two subjects to go, I mean I've multiple friends that had two subjects to go and then just never finished their degree because they got a job and you were just so desperate to get a job. So that was very, that was really pervasive over the whole sort of thing at that time.
And also as today, journalism jobs were very hard to get and was very competitive, like it was hard to get into the course and it was even harder to still get a job in journalism so it was pretty competitive. How did you bring in influence to the journalists that you are today? I think that it has made me, because I still, my family is still in Queensland and I still am friends with a lot of people that I grew up with. So I would like to think that I keep fairly well in touch with what people think about issues, who I'm not journalists, rich people, politicians, because I don't have plenty of people that would be, if you had to go to a specialist this week, that's going to be tricky for you to juggle financially.
So, and I remember going to, after the 2013 federal election, we, my oldest friend from school, the friend I referred to before, he had the corner of Mandy that we used to write our bikes around. It was her 40th and she was having a sort of weekend Fiji, it was her two sister, her friend, dad, me, my brother. And no big, everyone's job there was like, they only need either Brisbane or regional Queensland. Everyone's job was secretary, policeman, office worker, legal secretary, musician, jobs like that.
No, no, no, no, no PR people, no human resources managers, whatever. And it was really interesting, because if I had gone, it was the week, so directly after the election, if I had gone away with my Sydney friends, the conversation would have been nonstop about politics and how's Tony Abbott going to go and all of those sort of questions that people in media and politics get preoccupied with. All my busy friends, they talk about issues that are political but not in a political way. So they would talk about things like, oh jeez, the bloody road between glaz and Brisbane is so shit and da da da da da.
And so that's a political issue, but they're not viewing it through the prism of what's Tony Abbott going to do about it. Now multiple things where people would talk about, oh, you know, I had to take someone so first such an operation, I might like private health insurance, I only covered XYZ, what do I even have it. Like the sort of issues that I think we often cover in the news, but that you're not so plugged into how that actually affects people who are legitimately making decisions every week around their budget and what they can afford. And how does that translate into my job, what you do and how you view what you do?
I think it informs the kind of questions that I try to ask. So for example, Bill Shorten was on the show last week after his budget reply and he announced the cancer policy and how they're going to try to make it so you're less out of, you have fewer out of pocket expenses if you have cancer. Now anyone who's had cancer or any form of ongoing illness knows that you just are left giganticly out of pocket and that Medicare covers a fraction of everything and your private health covers unless you're sort of hospitalized, it covers hardly anything. And so when I was asking short about that I said, okay, so you're going to try to listen to the gap with Medicare, what about the fact that people pay constantly premiums for their private health and so they'll get to come up with private health.
So I think that I try to ask questions that are informed probably by what people I know in the real world experience and think about things. There's maybe a danger that we have at the moment in up and coming journalists through in this room that the number of internships that are required, right, to kind of get a job and you can't do a whole bunch of internships unless you're probably living at home or with someone who's paying for most of the bills. And there's a disadvantage between people who are poor and people who are wealthy as who's going to have more internships, who's going to get the job, so we're going to have perhaps a plethora of wealthy journalists who are making decisions and asking questions that may not reflect the road to the world. I'm massively concerned about that.
There's another book that I would recommend by Rick Morelsham, who's a journalist at the Australian called 100 Years of Dirt and he comes from all of a sudden Queensland from a very sort of working class family and he just talks about the structural barriers if you don't come from a family that's got money, for example, that means that when you're at UN you're not working two or three part-time jobs. So he was always having to work multiple jobs because he got no money whatsoever from his family. I think there's a focus at the moment in media and lots of industries which is fantastic on diversity and that needs to happen. The emphasis tends to be on cultural diversity but I think there needs to also be an emphasis on economic diversity because if everybody, regardless of your cultural background, you've all gone to city, grammar school and then you've got into whatever course you wanted at uni, you haven't had to work because you're living in a flat that mum and dad look after and pay for, that is giving you a certain set of life experiences.
I don't judge those life experiences. It's just a certain set of life experiences that are not the same of if you've been the primary care of your mum since you were 18 and she has a disability. We need people that bring all of those experiences and the same that you want people to come from the migrant background, you want LGBT people, you want people that bring a whole array of experiences because when you look out into the world at the sorts of things that you think could be a story, if you don't, for example, have any experience carrying somebody with special needs or disability, that's sort of invisible to you. It's like sometimes when you have experiences with these things, like, wow, this whole world, I didn't realise actually existed and all these people out there that are trying to deal with this particular issue.
And that's the example of Rick Morton. He does really great reporting in the Australian about the National Disability Insurance Scheme. And I think it's because his background means he has a really good understanding of, you know, $20 a week less for some people is really a major issue. It's a difference between, you know, paying your electricity bill and not paying your electricity bill.
He knows that because it happened in his family. So you want, I think, that kind of economic and class diversity represented as well as cultural diversity. So if our background does inform who we are as journalists, I want to bring up the notion of impartiality. So in your book, Lee Sales on Doubt.
It really extolled the virtue of impartiality and that's something that is very important to you as a person, as a journalist. Why is this such a big deal? I mean, we've got the world of opinion pieces. We've got everyone's got a voice.
Why is impartiality still important? Well, I think that this view is changing in some sectors of the media. But I still hold it probably because I'm, you know, just a product of my background and my experience of the media and my age and all the rest of it. I think that there is a huge value in the public being presented with facts by somebody who doesn't have a vested interest so that it allows them to make up their own mind to what they think about issues.
Like I know myself, I don't want to be constantly forced by views by, say, Andrew Bolt or by David Marr. I want someone to just present me as best they can with here are the facts that exist in the real world. Now impartiality doesn't mean that you don't have an opinion about something. I think for journalists what it means is being aware that your opinion about an issue is a product of your own life experiences and it doesn't necessarily represent the truth.
And it's amazing how many people have a view about something and they think, well, my views is absolutely right. How could anybody think any differently to this because this is the truth? But it's often not the case. And so the ability to understand, okay, well, what I actually think about this, like say, for example, my own background, I've come from a family where there's a heavy emphasis on personal responsibility and taking personal responsibility.
So that means on certain issues, I bring a mindset that's like, well, don't be a victim about it. Like take control of yourself. And now that is not a right way of thinking. That's just my way of thinking because of my background.
So what I'm going to be aware of if I'm doing an interview about something where, you know, these had a problem because they've taken out a housing loan and they've got their head, my natural way of thinking is to think, well, you should have thought about that yourself and done your due diligence and it's your fault and you should have taken personal responsibility. So what I try to do is note that that's what I've thought about it and then ensure that that opinion doesn't bleed through into the kind of questions or the kind of reporting that I do. I might ask a question like that, but then I might also ensure that I ask questions that come from a different perspective. So you need to be really mindful, conscious about it.
Totally mindful of how you think about issues all the time and being conscious of your own biases that you're bringing. I think another way that being mindful plays into being a journalist is noticing what catches your attention because that's often a story. So if you see something and you think, oh, that's unusual, sometimes that can actually turn into a story. So what was I thinking about this afternoon and then I thought, oh, yeah, on electric, electric arms, because it's cars.
Electric, for what, you're going to crack into a song with some cars. Like I was thinking, you know, everyone's talking about their electricity bill being really high. Like what would your electricity bill go up? Why if you were charging your electric car at home and you're just plugging into the power point?
And I was thinking, I'm going to do it like idly because I passed a Tesla charging station at Broadway and I was thinking, I wonder if you've charged me at home or cost. And then I just sort of clocked that and thought, I've got to go shorten that actually. Is he pushing? I actually love that.
I had a question. I'll ask the Prime Minister. I don't know anything. He hasn't told me anything.
You did a bit of a gap once with Skomo and you said that his deputy was Chris Bowe. Yeah, I called him Fluffing up Chris Bowe. And you called yourself a nincompoop. He said that the opposition, the shadow, the shadow treasurer was going to speak with the then treasurer.
Chris Bowe, after the election, because he's so used to calling somebody the shadow or whatever. He's just a flip. So yeah, he's messing up. So back to impartiality.
And thanks for your insights around seeing something that makes you curious and that can possibly be a story. How do you know when something is going to be your own bias? What is it a trigger? Or when did you start to see?
Because we have unconscious biases. What is it that makes you aware of what your biases have been? Just the constant paying attention to it. And particularly if you feel really strongly about something, I think that that's often a question.
Just ask yourself, why do I feel so strongly about this? Or if you feel strongly about something and other people feel very strongly in a different direction about it, then maybe that's a sign that's an issue that does have multiple viewpoints. But then I think the useful thing, when you talk about impartiality, it leads into fairness and balance and questions like that. You have to also be careful that you don't set up a thing where you have false balance.
Because say for example, an issue of climate change, it's not, the existence of climate change should not be in any journalistic story balanced equally with people who argue that climate change doesn't exist because the actual reality doesn't reflect that. So if you go and look at, you know, what is this diverse as the Chinese government, NASA, BHP, Westpac Bank, the German government, the Royal Academy in London, all of these very diverse range of organisations absolutely say that human-induced climate change exists. The people, if you look at the sort of scientific body, maybe 0.05% of scientists would have any queries about it. So therefore, why would you elevate the anti-climber change view to 50%?
That does not reflect actual reality. So there's not, I think, you know, you need to, when you're looking at fairness and partiality and bias and all these things, also look at proven fact. And one of the things that really bothers me and that I write about it in on doubt is that I think in the past sort of 20 years, we've seen not just a contest in the area of opinion, but facts become uncontested and that people have their own facts. And that I find incredibly disturbing because if we can't sort of say, all right, here are the facts, we can therefore, and now we will have our argument about what is the best policy to address this factual set of circumstances.
Once we start contesting the facts, then I think that that becomes a really difficult area. What do we do with that? What do you do with that? I wish I knew the answer to that because it's just so profoundly disturbing.
And when I first read on doubt in 2007, we were at the start, I think of this, what do they call it, distinction between what was called by someone at the Bush White House, the reality-based universe that someone might try to inhabit and a universe in which we're making up our alternate reality and sort of spinning it and pitching it. And I have been absolutely shocked to see how much further we have progressed down that road and that now, say, with the Trump White House, you have somebody who, demonstrably, as President of the United States, tells lies. And I don't say that lightly because in my job I'm normally accused of a political leader of being a liar, but I think it is a demonstrable fact that he lies. I think that disturbs me about that is previously, if you told as many lies, you would not be able to survive as a leader if you were busted in that many lies.
But now it doesn't seem to matter so much. And I just find that absolutely profoundly disturbing. And I don't know where it's going and what the answers to it. I just try to keep my little niche of the media being, you know, hopefully grounded in reality.
The rise of opinion. And, you know, opinion pieces I think you wrote about or spoke about. Opinion writers often are paid more for less work and that there's advantages in everyone having a platform for their opinion and the value of that and the diversity of voices, but also the increasing polarization of conversation around it's, this is what I believe, no, this is what I believe, as opposed to what you're talking about, let's try and deal with the facts now. But many of us don't necessarily want to work in the news because it's just so damn depressing.
Yeah. I mean, you wrote yourself that news is becoming increasingly depressing and is increasingly upsetting or upsetting than ever. Oh, I think, and part of the reason I find that increasingly upsetting is because of the peddling of just untruths, you know, unchallenged and backing into that by certain sectors of the media. I think the news has always been depressing.
But I think there's a moment, there's a degree of global instability that makes it feel sort of, for me at least, I feel a bit sort of rattled by how much instability there is. And also I think the pace of technological change is based so massive over the past decade that that is, it just feels like man, the world is just changing so fast right in front of us. I think as well for me, when I was a field reporter, you know, sometimes you're doing a story about the political debate, because you might be doing that some Australians made the US open final and then you might be doing Hurricane Katrina or then you might be doing somebody who's husband being killed in Iraq. But you're not immersed all the time in the saddest and most horrible stories.
Bizarrely as the anchor of the show, really every night my show is pretty much a parade of the random catastrophe that can befall people, whether it's that you made a bad decision on the loan and when you're age 65 you just lost all your life savings that you can't make up, or whether it's that you were just having an all day at work and you felt a bit funny and then you've got the Ninja Koko and you've lost all your limbs, or you've been a terrorist, you've been a victim of a terrorist attack, you've got your remaining friend for coffee, my show is a constant parade of that and so that means I'm immersed in that far more than I used to be as a general reporter. Right. I'm going to get a reprieve from that. Sounds terrible online.
It is sort of... It is a chat 10, look three, kind of an anecdote to that. Oh god, yeah, that's... I mean misery that comes across your...
but how much control do you have over the agenda over what, 730 does cover? You mentioned the news doesn't help you assess the greatest risks to your safety, but it distracts you by redirecting the things that don't place you much danger at all, like the flesh-lighting-like a terrorist incident, like many of the cobbly things that are statistically very, very, very unlikely to cross our path, but that's what we'll start worrying about because that's what we're being presented in the news. Do you have an influence in 730, what's covered? Yeah, but I think that that's just the nature of the news.
I wouldn't go into 730 and go, oh, we need to not cover that terrorist attack, it's just really depressing and most people in Australia went about life today and they didn't work in a terrorist attack, so let's focus on that. I wouldn't do that because I think the nature of the news is to focus on the aberration. But in terms of like, to give you an idea of, say, an average day at 730, so the executive producer of 730 who is absolutely amazing, Justin Stiefen says his name is. He and I, from when we wake up, will often be texting back and forth or sometimes we have a phone call about what's in the news, what's in the papers, what's happened overnight because obviously things can happen in Europe and the US overnight.
So sometimes we need to get moving really fast, like if we need an interview out of America, we'll be sort of on to what's straight away. We have a conference call then at 9 o'clock with the rest of the team and we talk about, in very legal, have some stories that are pre-prepared and that have been in the can, ready to go, and then we'll talk about what's happening today that we need to get on top of. So that can be, some people will say, oh, I think we need to do this and Justin will say, oh, I don't think so. I'll say, yeah, I think that'll be good and then we'll say, what about interview wise, should we go for short today and we'll go, no, I think the story today is really with Morrison, so we sort of chew over all the ideas.
At that meeting you've got your sort of wish list of who you'd absolutely like. So say, take the first day, for example, you know, Israel for allow, we would have liked. So if you're not getting Israel for allow, then you're getting Michael Chekker, the coach, and then, you know, as the day progresses news happens, so then it, I think it was about 732 when the Julian Assange news came and then we have to move into getting that. So over the course of the day, what time do you start?
Well, 6am when I wait. Well, you're not in the office, but you've got to be looking at everything, listening to everything and be across it straight away. So then, yeah, so we did a conference call at 9 o'clock. Then normally I have a couple of hours where I can just do, go to June or do whatever.
I try to go in around 11 and then it's a case of either my job will either be trying to talk people into coming on the show, so ringing people, try to find that information, try to persuade them, why don't you come on. Or let's say, depends on the person. It's a highly sales from the ABC. Depends on the person and what's in it for them.
You're never thinking like what's in it for me is I want to hold on my show feels. Why do they care about that? So it's always going to be what's in it for them. And that depends on the person on the story.
Give us an example. What do you say? Michael Chekker, so is Ruffler, couldn't be righteous? So then you move to you, OK, who else would we like?
Michael Chekker? So Justin, I don't know anything about sport. So Justin says to me, Michael Chekker's a really smart guy, I bet he's a fan of some dirty I bet he watches it. You should text him personally.
You should do it. You should do it because he might want to talk to you. So I've texted him and said, hi. Sorry to send an uninvited text.
It's like sales. We liked recovering this story tonight. You'd be our number one person who likes to talk to. And so even though he wasn't.
Yeah, everyone's always got one person. Sorry to write that down now. By the way, you were our number one person. Bill Shorten wasn't available.
So then you're sort of waiting and then you're thinking, all right, what are our real chances of getting Michael Chekker? OK, probably what would be in it for him? It's going to be tricky because they're working out what they're doing. Are they going to sack for now or not?
Why would the coach want to speak publicly? We better get a plan, you know, be in place. So then the producer will be calling, say commentators or people. So then in this instance, Michael Chekker did bring me back.
And he said, oh, I love your show. I don't really ring journalist, but I don't like you. So then I think, oh, great. So then you have an actual conversation about this is what we're thinking.
This is what we'd be interested in talking to you about. And then the person will often say, well, this is what I'm thinking and this is what I don't really want to do at the moment. And then you'll go, well, I'll take a look at what about blah blah blah. So it's just a straight.
Frankly, it's almost like sales, really. And I'm not very good at it, to be honest. Have you ever been listening to Lee's sales? Talking about her career.
She was talking Wendy John, as part of the UTS's Meet the Journalist series. You can find the full talk at the UTS website. And thank you for listening to The Portfistate. This edition is recorded at the Studio to ThoughtCr and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network.
Make sure you subscribe to Portfistate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a few things in between. We'll be back in more next week. I did in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter and our handle is globalstate.au My name is Anthony Dottball, thanks for listening.