Megan Lally | CEO, Highdive | What Your Agency Wants to Tell You But Won't

A CMO Confidential Interview with Megan Lally, the CEO and Co-Owner of Highdive, an agency which has created more than 10 Super Bowl ads. Megan explains why you shouldn't separate brand building from AI, the risk of optimization overwhelming strategy, and the importance of having partners tell you what you need to hear. Key discussion topics include: deciding whether your brand should or shouldn't be in the Super Bowl; why it's often challenging to have a good relationship with your agency; why brands should consider skipping the pitch process; and the reason you should ask your agency "Are you doing your best work for us?" Tune in to hear why you shouldn't care about "what everyone else is wearing to the party" when judging creative and case studies on Jeep, Lays and MSC Cruises.What does your agency really want to tell you — but won't? Megan Lally, CEO and Co-owner of **High Dive**, pulls back the curtain on the client-agency relationship: why great creative gets killed before it starts, when the pitch process does more harm than good, and the two questions every CMO should be asking their agency right now.Megan shares how AI is *saving* ideas rather than replacing them (the Jeep talking-animals campaign), why State Farm became the #1 consumer brand in 2025 by outperforming competitors who outspend them, what makes the Super Bowl worth it (and when it isn't), and why blending in with your competitors is the costliest marketing decision you can make.This episode is hosted by Mike Linton — former CMO of Best Buy, eBay, Farmers Insurance, and Ancestry.com.---🎙️ **This episode is sponsored by Scrunch** — the agent experience platform that helps your brand show up when consumers start with AI. Get a free website audit at **scrunch.com/cmo**--- Chapter Markers```0:00 - Intro & Sponsor: Scrunch1:24 - Meet Megan Lally, CEO of High Dive2:16 - AI vs. Brand Building: Why It's a False Choice5:04 - How AI Saved the Jeep Talking Animals Campaign8:00 - Why Marketing Is Still Treated as a Cost, Not an Investment9:17 - State Farm, Batman, and Measuring Breakthrough Creative11:33 - Super Bowl Strategy: Who Should (and Shouldn't) Be There13:32 - B2B Brands and the Super Bowl15:00 - What Makes Great Agency-Client Relationships16:22 - Why Radical Candor Is So Hard in Practice18:27 - How to Deliver Hard Truths Without Blowing Up the Room19:47 - Testing Chemistry During the Pitch Process22:28 - Why Clients Should Skip the Traditional Pitch24:33 - How Agency Search Consultants Can Help (or Hurt)25:49 - One Thing to Do This Year to Improve Your Agency Relationship26:37 - The "One Thing" Rule: The Lay's Super Bowl Example28:17 - Final Advice: Two Questions to Ask Your Agency Now30:27 - Funny Story: The Cheese That Won Jeep32:03 - Closing & Show Recommendations```--- TagsCMO Confidential, Megan Lally, High Dive Agency, Mike Linton, Chief Marketing Officer, agency client relationship, creative agency, brand building, AI and marketing, Super Bowl advertising, Jeep campaign, State Farm marketing, Lays Super Bowl ad, independent creative agency, breakthrough creative, marketing strategy, CMO podcast, how to work with an agency, agency pitch process, radical candor marketing, B2B marketing, marketing ROI, brand investment, marketing leadership, performance marketing vs brand, Scrunch, agent experience platform`See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.