Skip to content
Memory of Murder episode artwork

Oct 20, 2025 1 hr 14 min

Memory of Murder

from True Crime Brewery Hosted by Jill

On a warm September afternoon in 1969, 8-year-old Susan Nason vanished from her quiet suburban neighborhood. For two decades, her case remained cold, until a shocking bit of news broke the silence: a former playmate claimed she had witnessed Susan’s murder… and that it was committed by her own father. Join us for Memory of […] The post Memory of Murder appeared first on Tiegrabber.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Memory of Murder

0:00 1:14:49
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

head into the bar for today's true crime story just a warning that tcb might contain disturbing content so it's not for kids enjoy the episode welcome to true crime brewery i'm jill and i'm dick So on a warm September afternoon back in 1969, eight-year-old Susan Nason vanished from her quiet suburban neighborhood. For two decades, her case remained cold until a shocking bit of news broke the silence. A former playmate claimed she had witnessed Susan's murder and that it was committed by her own father. So join us for Memory of Murder. Susan Nason's story is not just a story about a shocking child murder. It's a story of dysfunctional family relationships and repressed memories. Memories can fade and some say they can return with devastating clarity.

Today, we're unraveling a complicated case that challenges the boundaries of psychology, criminal justice, and really the truth itself. Are repressed memories a defense mechanism to protect oneself from painful experiences? Or, like one prominent psychologist has said, are they the worst catastrophe to befall the mental health field since the lobotomy? Strong words there. Yeah, good question, huh? Yeah, I guess I know which side of the argument he's on. Yes, yeah. But I got to tell you, I'm more aligned with the lobotomy guy. You are? Yeah, just full disclosure. Okay, sure. So not really believing in this repressed memory stuff.

I have a very difficult time. Well, yeah, there are a lot of difficulties with it, which we will definitely talk about today. First, let's drink a beer. Good idea. Yeah. So I got one called Bravo from Firestone Walker Brewing Company in Paso Robles, California. It's an American brown ale and it's a bit supercharged. It's a 13% alcohol by volume. So it's kind of a whopper. Kind of, yes. It's a dark brown color, a little red mixed in. So maybe reddish brown, small tan head.

Nice aroma, caramel, vanilla, some fruit a little bit, and booze, of course. Taste follows the nose quite nicely. Caramel, vanilla, darker fruit, and bourbon. This is a big beer. You're going to take your time with it. It does sound large, but it sounds pretty good too, huh? It's really good. All right. Let's drink some. Open some up, will you?

Okay, so come on down here. This is quite a story. This is a case we've been talking about for a few months now and finally decided that we would just bite the bullet and cover it. So it certainly is very interesting. All of a sudden, just out of nowhere, Eileen Franklin Lipsker knew who had killed her childhood best friend, eight-year-old Susan Nason, back in 1969. She knew just how it had happened, who had done it, and even why. She'd been there. The killer was her father, she said. So detectives and prosecutors were stunned to hear it, but they very soon were accepting her story.

it was eileen's memory that led to the nineteen ninety murder trial of her father george franklin a fifty one year old retired firefighter and at stake was not just george franklin's freedom but also the validity of a recently recognized theory about the dynamics of the mind the repressed memory theory was said by advocates to be a defense against trauma So the mind basically represses a memory that's too traumatic to be dealt with when it happens. Then during therapy or hypnosis, this memory can resurface. That's the theory anyway. So when she took the stand as the government's star witness against her dad, Eileen claimed that for decades she had forgotten what had happened to Susan, her best friend, her neighbor, and her third grade classmate at Foster City Elementary School. It all came back to her, she said, as she was playing with her own daughter. So now she recalled being in her father's Volkswagen van when he picked up Susan in their suburban neighborhood and drove to an isolated area.

She recalled her father molesting Susan, then lifting a rock and crushing the girl's skull. She recalled a ring on her friend's hand that was smashed as she tried to defend herself from that blow. Police had found a ring at the crime scene, and San Mateo County prosecutors said that this corroborated Eileen's story. How, they asked, could she possibly know about it if she hadn't been there? So, good question. I gotta figure that she knew about it beforehand. Okay, well, that will be a subject of debate. Was that public information or not? That's something we'll have to get into. But the San Mateo Times and other newspapers had covered the case back in 69.

as had all of the local tv stations defense attorney doug horngrad had put together a package of news clippings and video proving that police had publicly discussed susan's ring and some other details years earlier But Judge Thomas Smith, a former prosecutor, refused to let the jury see that news coverage. He knew that if he let those articles in, it would imperil the prosecution, and he didn't want to do that, according to Horngrad. So George Franklin, the defendant, a stone-faced and pretty rough-looking guy, was difficult for anyone to sympathize with, and he didn't have an alibi. And testimony from Eileen and her sister would describe him as a violent, sexual deviant, and an abusive alcoholic. So Eileen also testified that her father had sexually abused her and her sister, Janice, during their childhood. Eileen's story also shifted and changed.

In one account, her sister Janice had been in the van, and in another, she wasn't. The murder was in the morning, and then it was in the late afternoon. But the contradictions did not cause jurors to disbelieve her. So that's kind of surprising. The jury took that as evidence of how damaged she was from having George Franklin as a father. And it actually made her more sympathetic to them. So that's pretty surprising. It is.

So it was November 17th, 1989, when Inspector Charles Etter of the San Mateo County District Attorney's Office received a call from Eileen's husband. He said that his wife had just told him she had witnessed a murder 20 years ago. She knew the murderer, the husband said, and the victim had been her best friend, but she'd been afraid to say anything because the murderer had told her he would kill her if she ever told anyone. So he wanted to know what would happen if she came forward, and her testimony was all that they had against him. So the man said his name was Barry and that the killing had taken place in San Mateo County. Barry was very clear about wanting the perpetrator of this horrible crime dead. Only a year away from retirement, Etter was a very solid investigator, but he wasn't really a star. The receptionist had sent the call to him because he was the only inspector in the office when the call came in. But Etter turned out to be the perfect person for this call. He was calm, he was reassuring, and he was non-threatening. So Barry had called Etter back a few hours later that first day. He wanted his wife to talk to Etter so that he could assure her that she would be treated with respect.

a soft-spoken woman got on the line and edder cautiously urged her to tell him her story the woman seemed reassured but she said she wanted to think it over over the weekend and then she would talk to him again so her husband barry called back on monday and he lectured edder about the failures of the criminal justice system edder tried to assure him that the case would not be mishandled barry began leaking details the killer whom he wouldn't name was a relative the killer had even raped his own children he was concerned that a cocaine charge as well as a charge of prostitution against his wife from back when she was about seventeen years old would affect her credibility. But finally, after stating that his wife would provide facts about the murder that had not been publicized, Barry began bargaining. His wife would tell everything about the crime if she had the final decision on whether to file charges. So Etter declined immediately. I can see where that would come from. Yeah, you can't guarantee something like that, can you? No, you can't. So Barry called back later with a new offer. His wife would tell Etter where the killing had happened, when it happened, and give the name of the victim. And then the police could examine the evidence. If they found any physical evidence to tie someone to the crime, then she would give them the name of the killer.

etter accepted this offer immediately so the wife got on the phone and told etter that it had happened in foster city and that the victim's name was susan nascent she really had nothing more to say etter heard voices in the background and then the woman came back on the phone and agreed that she would give a brief account of the killing her voice was confident as she recounted that she had been in the car with the person who committed the crime and that they had picked susan up across the street from her house they had driven to a wooded area on the road to half moon bay and there she had watched from the front seat as the man had raped her friend in the back of the van then the woman's voice dropped and softened and after that we were all out of the car and susan was sitting down and i was standing by the car so she said that they were maybe fifteen to twenty feet from the car and susan was sitting on a tiny little hill or maybe just a large rock she was sitting on something that was slightly elevated and he hit her she said now here her voice hesitated and caught in her throat she said he hit her on the head with the rock and she brought her hand up to her head and he hit her again and she saw blood go everywhere she said susan had had a ring on her hand and it crushed the ring on her hand then her voice wavered edder asked her what happened next and she said she had half a memory of him making her help him cover the body with a mattress then he left the body there she told edder that she remembered that she was screaming and that he pushed her on the ground and held her down and told her that he would kill her and that no one would ever believe her anyway and how old were you at the time asked edder i was eight eileen told him

Mary Jane Larkin, petite, with dark red hair and blue eyes, loved children and being a teacher. She always looked forward to fall and the beginning of the school year. She missed the kids over the summer and really looked forward to learning the new names and faces. This was her third year at Foster City Elementary, and she liked the school and the community. Everyone was new here, and the parents were enthusiastic and eager to volunteer for school activities. By the third week of school in 1969, her class of 17 girls and 12 boys, wow, 29 kids, 8 years old, must be a zoo in that room. Yep. Well, by the third week anyway, her classroom had settled into a routine.

math, reading, and social science in the morning, then science, art, and physical education in the afternoon. During recess, the kids played on the jungle gym or bounce balls off a high wooden wall playing handball. Girls had to wear dresses to school, so if they wanted to play on the bars, which most girls did, they had to wear shorts underneath the dresses. Girls also wore good shoes to school, often brown or black buckle shoes called Mary Janes. So on the days that the class had physical education, girls brought their tennis shoes to school with them. Usually the girls kept them under their assigned hook on the coat rack in the back of the classroom. Sure, now some of the children ran out of the classroom the minute the three o'clock bell rang.

others would take their time susan nason the girl with the freckles who seemed so little almost frail was one of the last ones to leave on this tuesday afternoon on her way out of the room she saw a paper bag with tennis shoes in it next to celia oakley's desk look susan said excitedly to mrs larkin celia forgot her shoes can i take them home to her well okay the teacher said but just be sure you go home first i will susan assured her i know where celia lives and it's not far from my house so the little girl picked up the sack tucked her books under her other arm and left the room margaret nason had come home from visiting a friend around noon that day and a few minutes later, a neighbor had dropped by to chat. When she left, Margaret began working on a dress that she was sewing for Susie's ninth birthday, which was that Saturday. The dress was almost half finished, and when Susie walked in the door shortly after three, Margaret was working on the dress. Susan was so excited about her birthday that she wanted to start decorating the house that day, even though the party was still four days away. So the plans were to take Susie and her friends roller skating, which was super exciting because Susie had never been to the rink before. So Susie was carrying books under one arm and a paper bag in the other when she greeted her mother.

She showed her a scrape on her arm, then opened the bag and explained that the tennis shoes belonged to a classmate named Celia Oakley. She wanted to take the shoes to Celia right away. So her daughter seemed to know where her friend lived, so Margaret said yes. She thought very little of it as Susie walked out the door with the paper bag. Shirley Nason was just arriving home as her sister was leaving. She asked Susie where she was going, and Susie told her. Shirley had not reported in with her mother yet, so she couldn't go along, but the two girls agreed that Susie would come right home and the two of them would play together. Shirley went inside and waited.

Susan walked up the block and stopped at a house on the corner of Belklutka and Matsonia streets, and she knocked on the door. So Suzanne Banks opened the door and greeted the little girl. She held up the paper bag and explained that it held her daughter Celia's tennis shoes, which she'd forgotten at school. But Mrs. Banks explained to her that she had the wrong house. That was the Oakleys, who lived a few houses away on Matsonia. So Mrs. Banks helpfully walked Susan down the street and pointed out the Oakley house to her, and then she watched as Susan walked up to the front door. When the door opened, Mrs. Banks turned away and called for her nine-year-old daughter, Linda, who was playing in the vacant lot across the street.

to come home celia oakley a tall girl with straight brown hair answered the doorbell when susan rang but she didn't invite her into play she thanked her and she took the shoes she watched as susan walked away then closed the door soon celia left to play with her friends so margaret was surprised when susan did not come right home after her errand her youngest daughter was always starving after school but she'd been in such a hurry earlier that she'd forgotten her snack but margaret wasn't worried she figured her daughter had probably stayed at celia's house to play she always asked permission before going to a friend's house to play but this time she would know that her mother would already know where she was So about 4 or 4.30, Margaret felt some worry beginning to seep into her thoughts, and she called the Oakley house. An older sister answered, and when Margaret asked if Susan Nason was there, the girl said she didn't know anyone named Susie. Celia wasn't home, so Margaret asked the girl to have Celia send Susan home when the two of them returned. Margaret called a little later, and another sister answered the phone and said that Celia wasn't due home until 6 or 6.30. So Margaret decided it was past time to begin looking for her youngest daughter. She called her husband Don at work and told him Susan hadn't come home, then went to the garage and got out her bike.

noting that both Shirley and Susan's bikes were in their usual spots. So she rode to the places that Susie usually played, and then to areas where she didn't play, even up north to Flying Cloud Isle in the middle of the lagoon. She stopped by the Oakley house and found one of Celia's sisters, who hopped on her bicycle and joined her in the search. The two of them rode around to all the places that Celia played, looking for the two girls, but no luck. When they returned to the Oakley house, Celia was there alone. Have you seen Susan? asked Margaret, now with a bad feeling beginning to creep over her. Susan who? Celia responded. Well, didn't Susan Nason bring you some shoes this afternoon? Yes, she said.

And she didn't stay and play with you? No. So Margaret's heart sank. Something was very wrong. susie would never stay out this late so she rode home quickly don was there but still no susie so she sent shirley to a neighbor's house and the two parents renewed their search don searched the streets in the car and margaret covered the neighborhood on her bike she stopped people on the street and asked if they had seen susie and she retraced her daughter's route knocking on doors eventually she found mrs banks on the corner who told her that she had given susie directions to the oakley house but by then it was getting dark and margaret now frantic decided to return home and call the police the foster city police and fire department were combined into a single department of public safety with sixteen officers most of the calls involved vandalism shoplifting or a home burglary in the fall of sixty nine there had been no serious crimes in foster city no murders and not even a robbery

lieutenant william hensel was the supervisor in charge of law enforcement when the dispatcher told him about the call about a missing child he drove to the nason home he knew donald nason pretty well don did have a serious drinking problem and had had run-ins with the law including one dui hensel first had to rule out the possibility that harm had come to the girl in her own home or that maybe she was hiding in or around the house so he and another officer searched inside and out including the attic and the yard and found nothing margaret's story made sense and she said that don had not been home when susy left the house to return the shoes They asked Don to come in the next day for a polygraph test, and he agreed. Hensel drove to the Oakley house and confirmed that Susan had dropped off the shoes and left around 3.15 p.m. He immediately notified police chief Gordon Penfold and put out an all-points bulletin for a missing girl. Four feet, three inches tall, with a slight build, blue eyes, and brown hair, freckles across the bridge of her nose, wearing a blueprint dress, brown shoes, and a turquoise ring with a silver band. Hensel called in off-duty officers, and they went door-to-door on the block, retracing Susan's steps. They lost track of her somewhere on Belclutha, not too far from her home.

So Lieutenant Hensel soon rejected the possibility that Susan had run away from home. margaret told him about the upcoming birthday party and said that susie was also due to begin ballet lessons the next day and that's something she'd wanted to do for a very long time she was happy clean through margaret assured him and over time hensel would develop a slightly different picture of the missing child away from home susan was kind of a loner with only one or two friends she was self-conscious about her freckles and other kids at school and in the neighborhood teased her sometimes pretty viciously she was an average student and she was well behaved she was not a problem child she did as she was told and her parents had told her many times not to talk to strangers so margaret was adamant that susie would never have gotten in a stranger's car after a few hours when he turned up nothing on the block hensel returned to the station and along with another officer began to organize a major search he called in the reserve officers and notified the san mateo county sheriff's office he focused primarily on susan's neighborhood and divided it into grids they began going door to door searching yards and garages and empty fields of particular importance were the many construction sites a half-finished house a partial foundation or a stack of lumber would be a really easy place to stash a small body

the edges of all of the lagoons would have to be walked also inch by inch so as the police went door to door they asked people to help in the search and soon more than one hundred people had volunteered many searchers worried that the girl might have drowned across the streets from the oakleys there was a lagoon and maybe she had stopped there to play neighbors walked the shore with flashlights others formed long lines and walked through the fields some deputy sheriffs rolled in a huge three hundred and sixty degree platform light and drove through the fields illuminating the night neighbors organized to comb the parks and the school grounds don continued drinking Margaret, revealing some real inner strength, held it together and helped in whatever way she could. Some of the volunteers were just convinced that Susan would be found quickly. A call would come that she had been found asleep in the bedroom of a friend's house. But then, by early the next morning, hopes were beginning to dim. I'm impressed by the turnout for the search. Yeah, me too. People were taking it seriously, which was the correct thing to do. I guess they were. So news of the disappearance spread really fast in the tight little community, and by morning, Foster City was really bustling with efforts to find little Susan.

More than 100 people gathered early at the public safety department to resume the search. The sheriff's office sent bloodhounds and their handlers, after holding pieces of Susan's clothing to the dogs' noses, set them loose in the vacant lots and the parks. A team of divers from Hamilton Air Force Base arrived and began diving the lagoons close to the nascent home. A Coast Guard helicopter skimmed the waters and hovered over vacant fields, looking for any recently disturbed dirt that might indicate digging. Also, there were small boats patrolling the waters of the lagoons, and by mid-morning more than 200 people had joined in.

neighbors converged on the nascent house with baskets of food and offers of help rumors swirled that susan had been found in central park lake and that she'd been seen riding on the back of a motorcycle with a tall blond man also workers at the nearby race track were suggested as possible kidnappers calls flooded the police department several of them from angry wives who were pointing fingers at their suspicious acting husbands the police found several people who they said had seen susan after she went out on her errand sharon fulls a blonde fourth grader who lived up the street from the nasons and a friend had been riding their bikes up belclutha to sharon's house when they saw susan walking in the same direction on the sidewalk carrying some sort of paper in her hand so the two girls used to tease susan probably because she was so tiny and shy and had so many freckles and as they rode their bikes by they yelled something at her like na na na na na na then they rode to sharon's home put away their bikes and then they roller skated on the sidewalk in front of her house Sharon's mother was standing in front of her house a short time later when she saw Susan walking on the other side of the street. She called over to the child and invited her in for a cold drink. Susan said no. She had to return some tennis shoes to Celia Oakley and then go right home. A few minutes after Sharon and her girlfriend began roller skating, Mrs. Foles was overcome by a really strange feeling that something very bad was happening close by. So she called the girls and told them to play in the backyard. Then she went into the kitchen where she could keep an eye on them from the window. So this was just a feeling? This was a feeling she had, yeah. And she might be saying that in retrospect. Who knows?

I think so. But I do believe parents get that feeling. You can get that feeling for sure. Okay. I think so. Yeah, I think it was, to me, it was more of a comment that underscored the severity of the search, just to heighten the suspense. Well, who knows? You could be right. So tell me about the next school day. Well, when Susan was not at her desk in the morning, teacher Mary Jane Larkin decided to treat it as a simple absence and wrote an A by her name. The detectives came and talked to Mary Jane after school, and she explained to them about the shoes. It unsettled Mary Jane when they asked her for a sample of her handwriting.

Susan's disappearance seemed to frighten some parents more than their children. In many homes the next morning, moms and dads sat their kids down and lectured them about not getting into strangers' cars. From now on, the youngsters were never to walk anywhere without a buddy. There would be no more playing in the vacant fields, and they should always stay in view of a friendly neighbor's door. Other parents didn't want to alarm their kids by painting a picture of death for them at such a young age, at least until they knew what had happened to Susan. So they warned their children to be careful and assured them that she would probably be found okay. Well, what else are you going to do?

So residents did form prayer groups to ask for Susan Nason's safe return. The Safeway store kept platters of food on tables at the firehouse for the searchers. The FBI was called in for consultation. The Nason sent their other daughter, Shirley, to San Francisco to stay with her grandparents. So imagine how tough that would be for the sister. You're sent to stay with your grandparents not knowing what's going on with your little sister. Yeah, it's a tough situation. Really tough. So the police interviewed and re-interviewed the neighbors, but Lieutenant Hensel decided against questioning the children then. He was worried that policemen in uniforms might scare them.

so instead he asked the school to have the teachers talk to the children to see if they knew anything the case hit the media that afternoon and tv stations showed a color picture of susan on the evening news and the san mateo times carried the disappearance as their top story beneath it ran a picture of susan her hair neatly parted her bangs curling over her forehead and a slight gap between her two front teeth The founder of Foster City offered a reward of $1,000 for the safe return of Susan, and Donald Nason's employer pitched in with $10,000 for information leading to her safe return. Within a few days, employees were calling radio and television stations up and down the peninsula, trying to keep the story alive and Susan's picture on the evening news. Margaret and Don Nason began to cling to the theory that a childless couple had kidnapped their daughter and that she was safe in that couple's home, possibly in another state. One sighting had Susan in New Jersey. Police reported they had run down more than 200 leads, but had not come up with a damn thing.

margaret nason kept insisting that sizy would have obeyed her instructions not to go with strangers but she finally had to admit to one reporter that her daughter did love dolls and animals and someone with a kitty and a good story could probably entice her into a car so ann hobbs a classmate of susan's told the police a very startling story the previous friday she had been approached by a man in a blue station wagon in front of the school this middle-aged driver was wearing a suit and had a large nose that was pushed in on the side and turned up in the front he had ears that stuck out beyond his head and brown hair with white showing in the edges the man had gotten out of his car and said he knew her parents and he'd offered to give her a ride home ann could see mud on the floor and a pistol lying next to the pedals when he opened the rear door ann saw several dolls on the seat One or two were new, and a few had scratches on their faces, and one had a broken arm. Also on the rear seat lay a white sweater, and some cardboard boxes were piled up in the windows. So Ann Hobbs was frightened and ran home. On Wednesday, the San Mateo Times ran a story on this lead, and Don Nason's employer printed a flyer with the now familiar picture of Susan, her description, and a notation about that blue station wagon. Lieutenant Hensel began running blue station wagons throughout the Department of Motor Vehicles, and by the end of the week, the police abandoned the search and concentrated on the possibility of an abduction.

Hensel kept six men on the case and began checking the register of convicted sex offenders, calling them one by one and making them account for their whereabouts that previous Tuesday afternoon. then hopes were raised a bit the following week two girls in belmont a nearby community were accosted by a man in a blue station wagon and they had managed to get his license number he was aaron patterson an illustrator from san jose and he matched the description of the man given by ann hobbs ann identified him from a photograph and patterson was arrested and his house was searched in a line-up a day or so later the two belmont girls picked him out but ann didn't The cops tried fervently to tie him to the Susan Mason case, but he passed two polygraph tests, and they just couldn't place him in Foster City at all. That's interesting, though. Wouldn't you be suspicious about the same car being seen a week or two apart? Well, they were, sure. That's why they brought him in.

So five or six psychics called the police, and they offered their assistance in finding Susan. Each one came over to the Nason house and handled a piece of Susan's clothing or a toy. One lady held a blouse of Susan's to her forehead and closed her eyes, and then pointed on a map to a dump just north of Half Moon Bay Road in the mountains. Another used a darning needle and a piece of yarn to pinpoint the girl's location at a lake south of Foster City. Hensel and Morgan took them all seriously, and the police went charging off to whatever place the psychics indicated, but there were no results. For a moment, the horrible ordeal looked like it may never end.

so on september thirtieth the nasons received a letter demanding thirty thousand dollars for the safe return of their daughter in words cut from a newspaper the sender threatened to cut off susan's fingers one by one and mail them to the parents if the ransom wasn't paid kidnapping for money had always been considered an unlikely possibility since the nasons were not wealthy but margaret and don believed they were going to get their daughter back safely don nason was instructed to put the cash which his employer had provided in a sack and drop it off in the doorway of a tavern in san francisco so on the appointed day don drove to the spot with an agent hiding under a blanket in the rear seat the police had staked out the tavern with police dressed as garbage men and bums don put the money in the doorway and left the sack lay there untouched for hours then finally a police officer instructed don to return and pick up the money but somebody forgot to tell the officers in disguise what was going on so in a scene which has been described as something like from the keystone cops don picked up the sack returned to the car and a garbage man in wing-tipped shoes rushed him and slabbed a gun up against the side of his head the agent under the blanket thinking that either the kidnapper had shown up or don was being robbed popped up jacked a shell into the chamber of his shotgun and stuck it in the face of the agent slash garbage man then numerous other cops sprang from their hiding places with their guns drawn and only at the last instant did someone realize that all of them were the good guys poor donald nason was severely shaken the alleged kidnapper sent a second note saying he had spotted the disguised cops and gave instructions for a new drop

this time don wearing a wire went alone as he was walking away from the drop he saw a man approach and pick up the sap he spoke into the mike and the cops converged and arrested the man so although he was the note sender the police soon determined that all he knew about susan's case was what he had read in the newspaper In the weeks after Susan's disappearance, people in the community tried to get on with life. People still talked about the missing girl, but with less frequency. Susan wasn't discussed in the classroom. The kids seemed to go about their lives, and Mary Jane Markin continued to write an A by Susan's name every morning. Parents' patrols were still watching children walking to and from school. Officer Bill came to the school and talked about cars and candy and strangers, so often that some kids began calling all policemen Officer Bill. One day, Donald Mason decided to look for his daughter himself. He and a friend followed Half Moon Bay Road through the foothills and up to the lakes and the watershed.

thinking that uncivilized country might be a likely spot. The two men parked not far from a pull-off overlooking the lakes and hiked around in the hills for several hours, looking for signs of Susan. Margaret ran into Kate Franklin, a neighbor's daughter, who lived around the corner on Harvester Drive, and mentioned to her that no one had come over to play with Shirley since Susan had been missing, and she was lonely. Kate gathered her sisters, Janice and Eileen, and went over and played with Shirley. Right, so these are the daughters of George Franklin. Right. So in Pacifica, a small town north of Foster City, a small boy who had a habit of wandering away from home disappeared again.

and the papers started covering the cases in the same article no clues to missing youngsters as the weeks and then months went by lieutenant hensel stayed on the case full time still expecting to find susan alive the peninsula widens gradually as it descends from san francisco to san jose and the temperature warms just as gradually san jose can bake in dry heat while san francisco shivers in the chilly fog in the middle of the thumb around san mateo and foster city the weather is bone dry in the summer with occasional rain from october through may so during the summer months the cool air rolls in from the pacific and collides with the warm air from the valley to create a dark fog that blankets the coast line and sometimes slides over the mountain range and down to the edges of the bay cities the high ridge of mountains running down the peninsula forms the western edge of the san andreas valley which was condemned in the early nineteen hundreds for use as a catchment basin for the peninsula so dams and reservoirs were constructed and the valley was flooded creating a fifteen mile long twenty three thousand acre watershed the watershed was turned into a game refuge and placed off limits to the general public the lakes which sit on top of the san andreas fault shine like elongated sapphires in the rolling green hills few people knew the watershed like effie ray

at six feet five inches tall and two hundred eight pounds the soft-spoken bottimore had thick arms and large hands and he walked with a lumbering gait bottimore grew up in a house on the north end of the preserve and he went to work there himself shortly after world war two and raised his family in a house on the edge of the south lake bottimore's job along with the other nine keepers was to patrol the watershed and make sure everything was okay he checked the level of the reservoir every morning then got in his pickup and drove the back roads checking fences and spillways and running off hunters and fishermen he loved to park his truck and roam the wilderness for hours some of the other keepers called him the snoop because he was so curious bottimore had read about the disappearance of the nascent girl and watched it on tv and the cops had been out looking around the watershed several times in the past two months once or twice tromping along behind psychics who claimed they knew where the body was but they had not found anything bottimore wasn't exactly looking for the little girl but he did have his suspicions and he was keeping an eye out for her maybe he was suspicious because he had found seven or eight corpses in the watershed over the years so once after he spotted a car unattended by a gate for several days

he started snooping around and eventually noticed a purse hanging on a snag by the water's edge he called the sheriff and the divers came out and pulled the body of a little girl from the shallow water her mother later floated to the surface in the north lake he learned that the woman and her husband had been fighting over the custody of the little girl and the cops figured the mother and her daughter had driven to the lakes and parked and walked down the hill right into the water the morning of december second nineteen sixty nine was very clear and bright and bottimore was up early policing his preserve as usual so around ten o'clock he was heading down from the ridge on half moon bay road toward the lakes when he decided to turn into a pull-off on the south side of the road this pull-off about a mile and a quarter up the hill from the lakes was large enough for two or three vehicles so standing on the edge he looked down the hillside and over the south lake which had dark green cypress groves a narrow trail led down from the lip of the pull-off through the shrub and the poison oak that was always littered with beer cans milk cartons and paper bags over the years people had pushed a variety of appliances and furniture over the edge two cars had even made the journey the trail ended in a small clearing which was obscured from the road by the brush

and just to see it done on countless other occasions, Bottimore decided to walk down the trail and have a look around. The leaves of the poison oak bushes had fallen off, making it easier to see the ground. He stopped and glanced over at a box spring not too far from an old stove. He'd seen the spring before. It was a simple wooden frame enclosing rusty coils. So Bottimore had never paid the box springs much mind before, but this day he walked over to take a closer look. He leaned over the frame and through the coils and the brush, and he saw a small brown skull with a hole in the side. A chill shot through him then. He could tell the skull was human, and he guessed it was a child's.

probably susan nason there wasn't much left of her but he looked closer and he noticed bones and pieces of multicolored material that looked like a dress and then he figured it had to be susan nason for sure but without touching a thing not even the brush bottimore walked back up the trail and radioed his office and he told them to call the sheriff's department a sheriff's deputy was on patrol in the area when he received the call to go to the pull-off when he arrived bottimore led him down the hill and pointed to the box spring beneath the brush the deputy could see the badly decomposed skeleton of a young girl she was lying on her left side with her left leg drawn up under her and her right foot outstretched a white bobby sock was on her left foot and a brown shoe lay near by beneath the multicolored material covering her torso was a pair of denim cut-offs her head was devoid of flesh and hair exposing a black hole on the right side of her skull and behind her right ear so what little flesh remained on the bones was discolored and mummified a small dental retainer was lying in the dirt and not far from the skull sat a large rock

soon other officers arrived and their cars crowded on to the pull-off criminalists began surveying the crime scene and collecting evidence a photographer took pictures then the body was uncovered and put in a canvas bag and carried up the hill bottimore watched the bag being loaded into the ambulance for transportation to the morgue the chill that had taken hold of him earlier had dissipated and now he just felt very sad well at least the nasons would finally know what had happened to their little girl which he hoped would be some small relief Dr. Peter Benson had graduated from Yale Medical School in 1958 and completed his residency in pathology at the University of California in San Francisco in 1962. He went to work immediately for the San Mateo County Coroner's Office and was still employed there as a forensic pathologist on the afternoon of December 2, 1969, when he was called to the hospital to perform an autopsy on the remains of a white female child.

so benson performed his task carefully describing in detail her items of clothing the multicolored dress which had stains consistent with blood or body fluids the denim cut-offs the white underpants the white sock and the brown buckle shoe while removing the a-line dress he found hidden in the folds of the material a small rock with blood and hair on it and a finger-nail attached to a clump of hair the body was skeletonized but a small amount of dried and hard tissue remained on the arms and legs and the right hip area which showed signs of bruising he estimated the time of death as some three to six months earlier he noted the injury to the skull a dumbbell shaped defect above and beyond the right ear measuring approximately two by five inches with fracture lines radiating away from the edges in his opinion either the small rock or the large rock found close by could have produced the injury the body's right hand was severely distorted the convex contour of the hand had been flattened leaving it almost concave The back of the hand also showed tissue damage, and several of the long metacarpal bones, as well as one wrist bone, were missing. The tips of all four fingers were gone, and some of the bones of the index, middle, and ring fingers were missing. Benson had two possible explanations for this damage. Either insects and animals had been attracted to the hand because of the damage, and the animals had carried off the bones, or the animals had simply done the initial damage themselves, and then taken the bones. The fact that the left hand was intact and showed no signs of damage suggested the former.

so the condition of the white metal ring on the middle finger of the right hand supported the conclusion that the hand had suffered injury the pedal-like oval setting in the center was empty and distorted and the under side of the band was flattened as if it had been resting against something hard when the setting was smashed a small undamaged ring with four blue stones was on the left hand the location of the injury on the right rear of the skull and the damage to the right hand and the ring suggested the possibility that the hand had been injured while being used in a defensive or a protective manner the location of the skull injury also suggested that the girl's head was bent downward when the blow was struck so a detective from the sheriff's office was present for the autopsy as was a photographer who took color pictures of the remains the detective noted that the stitching on the dress appeared to be home-made then susan's dentist arrived around five thirty p m with x-rays and a plaster mould he had made of susan's mouth for the retainer he examined the skull on the table and found marked similarities between the teeth and the x-rays and the mould a second dentist was called in and after examination and consultation these two dentists made a positive identification of the corpse as the body of susan

gordon penfold the foster city chief of police had been called out to the autopsy he drove to the nason home on balclotha in foster city margaret nason immediately recognized the material and her stitching on the hemline she'd bought the fabric in lake tahoe and she'd made the dress herself and the panties looked like susan's too the crushed silver ring with the missing stone had been a gift from susan's grandmother shirley had received an identical ring which she was still wearing there was no question in any one's mind how the body found up in the hills overlooking the lakes was that of susan nason On the front page of the San Mateo Times, they ran the familiar gap-toothed photo of Susan and a picture of a deputy at the pull-off on Half Moon Bay Road. The paper also had pictures of Susan's family. Donald told the media that he had always hoped that his daughter had been kidnapped by someone who wanted a little girl. Then he broke into tears. It seems like you warned them so many times, he said, but it's just not enough. It seems to go in one ear and out the other. They probably think parents should warn them about important things, not trivial ones. So Margaret also accepted responsibility for her daughter's death.

I guess all mothers warn their daughters because they were once little girls, and just about every girl is approached by some kook at some time, she told the reporters. I guess I just didn't warn Susan enough. So both parents really blaming themselves, which is really heartbreaking to hear. It's a difficult time for these poor people. It's unimaginable, yeah. It really is. So at a press conference on Wednesday morning, December 3rd, the day after Susan's body was found, the police revealed that Susan had been found lying at the bottom of a 35-foot embankment under a partially overturned mattress and that she had died from a skull fracture.

possibly from a three-pound rock that had been found nearby. The papers noted that a ring and a brown buckle shoe and white sock had been found close to the body, so the sheriff appended that the body must have been carried or thrown to the spot where it was found. Susan's father, Donald Nason, a once-contractor, offered a $20,000 award with the help of his employer for any information leading to the arrest and conviction of her killer. A few tips came up, but investigators hit a wall, and the case went cold until November 1989. Well, we can say that casually, but that's like 20 years. 20 years. Yeah, long time.

Now, November of 89 is when Susan's childhood friend, neighbor, and classmate, Eileen Franklin Lipsker, came forward to say that she had just remembered that she had witnessed her father abduct, rape, and kill the eight-year-old Susan near the reservoir in 1969. 20 years go by. Right. This woman, actually her husband called first, but this woman has this kind of revelation. She knows what happened to her friend. Yeah, yeah. It's pretty amazing. Very amazing. Hard to believe, sure. Well, Eileen said that the memory came back to her while she was watching her own daughter playing.

And she added that it could be because her daughter was nearing the same age as Susan was when Susan had been killed. Then she told her husband about the situation first, and he helped her share the details with the police. According to Eileen, her father and retired firefighter, George Franklin, had picked Susan up on that day, drove them to the woods, and then she had seen him rape her friend in the back of the vehicle before he used a rock to hit her over the head twice. And she even did mention that ring. Right. So when do they think that Franklin abducted her? Because we have people that saw her.

That afternoon? That same afternoon, yeah, when she was walking through the neighborhood. It was her friend, so to think that her father might pick up her friend is not hard to believe. Certainly Susan would have gone with him because she knew him. Yes, that's true. Yeah. So George Franklin was divorced from his wife Leah Franklin before he was arrested in 1989. While the exact date of the divorce isn't publicly documented, it is known that Leah filed for divorce after confronting George about his possible involvement in Susan Nason's murder. And in the divorce filings, she accused him of physical and verbal abuse.

So when he was arrested on November 29th, 1989, he was living in Sacramento, California. Police searched his apartment at the time of his arrest, and reportedly they found pornographic magazines and pictures, including some with children and some that were pretty much promoting incest. So one of his books, Forbidden Sexual Fantasies, contains chapters on incest, bestiality, and rape. One drawing shows a fish swimming toward a woman with her legs open. They found a large collection of pornography and paraphernalia, also books entitled The G-Spot, Lusty Dusty, and The Altar of Venus.

They also found more than 23 dildos. Many of them were later described by the prosecution as child-sized, which is just horrifying to think that that would even exist. Yes, I'm shutting that out of my mind. Yeah, good idea. But one of the biggest finds for detectives was the names and phone numbers of George's girlfriends, because in talking to them, they unmasked the personality of a man who was obsessed with sex with young girls and animals. In the mid-1980s, George Franklin had answered a Lonely Hearts advertisement that described a Christian woman with an eight-year-old daughter. According to the woman, Franklin insisted that when they were making love, she should call him Daddy, and he would refer to her as his naughty little girl. When she revealed to him that she had been molested by her father, Franklin had asked her all about the details of what her father had done to her.

And then he had insisted that she talk about the specifics while they were having sex. So this was the kind of thing that turned him on. So whether you believe his daughter witnessing him murdering Susan Nason or not, definitely a sick man. Yeah, there's no question that he had some issues. Right. Well, according to this woman, he questioned her about her daughter's breasts and pubic hair and even asked her to take photos of her daughter asleep with her legs spread. He explained that he belonged to the Rene Goyan Society, which advocated children having sex at a young age and had, as its motto, sex before eight or else it's too late. So.

Should we take a break here for vomiting purposes? Yeah, that's really disgusting. It's revolting. And whatever you think of Eileen, or if she actually knew anything about Susan's death, she did go through something as his daughter, I'm certain. Yes, that has to be the case. Yes. So George had told this woman that a young girl's first sexual experience should be loving and caring, and that she was depriving her daughter of a beneficial experience if she didn't let him have sex with her before her eighth birthday. He even explained that girls between the age of seven and 10 often came on to him by sitting on his lap and rubbing against his groin.

So she was able to tell the detectives that he had asked her to procure little girls for him for sex. So really clear that George Franklin was a sick man and a pedophile, but Eileen was the only eyewitness to this murder of Susan Nason, and no physical evidence was ever found tying George to that crime. So this was especially controversial because the prosecution's case relied almost entirely on Eileen's recovered memory in 1989. The idea of recovering repressed memories has been largely discredited since then. She described details of the crime scene, including the smashed ring on Susan's hands, which did match police findings, but also we know that that was publicized at least in some places years ago.

That's correct. In fact, I think everything that Eileen remembered had been published, where the info was available to the public. Yeah, it kind of turns out that way when they look more into it. But in the meantime, George Franklin went on trial in October of 1990, and he would be convicted. He was convicted in January of 91. He was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life imprisonment. The trial was the first in U.S. history to rely solely on recovered memory as a basis for a murder conviction. And of course, experts on this were very divided.

The prosecution argued that traumatic memories can be repressed and later accurately recalled. The defense claimed such memories are unreliable and susceptible to contamination by external information. So surprisingly, the judge barred the defense from presenting newspaper articles that contained crime scene details Eileen may have read, which could have influenced her memory. It certainly could have. In 1995, a federal judge overturned George Franklin's conviction due to improper use of his silence as an implied confession. The trial court's refusal to allow the defense to present media coverage could have influenced Eileen's memory.

and concerns over the reliability of repressed memories, especially those recovered through hypnosis, which Eileen later admitted had occurred. She stated that there was no hypnosis in her original statements. Yeah, and she likely knew that it would not be acceptable because things that come about by hypnosis are not presentable in court as evidence. So we think that she was covering that up. So Eileen later claimed to remember two additional murders committed by her father, and that kind of backfired on her as well because DNA evidence ruled him out as the perpetrator in those cases.

So after his release, George Franklin sued his daughter, law enforcement officials, and expert witnesses for conspiracy and presenting false testimony. His lawsuit was ultimately dismissed by the courts, though. The case does remain a landmark in legal and psychological circles, really sparking some ongoing debate about the validity of repressed and recovered memories in criminal trials. So it is frequently cited in discussions about false memory syndrome, hypnosis in legal settings, and constitutional rights in court proceedings. The case was based on Franklin's daughter Eileen suddenly remembering 20 years later that she saw him commit a murder.

This kind of memory is called a repressed memory, where someone forgets a traumatic event and then later recalls it. But the big issue is whether such memories can be trusted. Experts disagree. Some say they can be accurate, but others say they are easily influenced and often false. Yeah, let's take it as an example. You can put a patient under hypnosis and suggest all sorts of things. Right, but we never did find out who killed Susan, and he did not have an alibi for that, so it's not 100% that he didn't do it. No. The credibility of Eileen's testimony about her repressed memory of the events of September 22, 1969 was, of course, the primary issue at trial. The focus of the defense was to challenge the credibility of that testimony, and that included the possibility that Eileen intentionally or maybe unintentionally fabricated her story, or maybe her memory was a byproduct of hypnosis.

or otherwise an example of memory contamination. So what does that mean, memory contamination? Well, again, this is where you can suggest things to the patient. And on awakening, we'll put that into the whole fabric of what they were testifying to. Right. Well, based on the expert testimony, Eileen's account of the murder might be a conscious or an unconscious fantasy because she knew Susan Nason had been murdered. And of course, she knew her father was violent and abusive.

So why should she not then ask herself, did dad do this too? Did dad take away my friend? I mean, it's not unreasonable to make that jump, especially someone who grew up in such a dysfunctional household with an abusive man like that. In other words, it's not that far-fetched that he could have done it. Right, but they don't have enough evidence. No, no, I understand that. But this also raised the possibility that Eileen's husband may have affected her memory, right? Barry. Barry was a controlling person and had an intense dislike for George Franklin. There was a history of animosity between Barry and George.

and Barry was the one who initially encouraged Eileen to come forward with her accusations against her father. In fact, he was the first person who contacted the police about her memory, and this was without her knowledge initially. Barry kept a file of articles about the nascent murder in the couple's home, so this was interesting. He'd actually made a videotape of a pre-trial Today Show episode in which Eileen was interviewed about the case, and he had articles that had the information that she was claiming she couldn't have known unless she was there. You got it. So Eileen testified she never looked at any of the articles that Barry kept in their home, but...

I mean, how can you really believe that for sure? She even admitted that Barry tried to read her articles about the case as many as 50 times. So was Barry encouraging this? Because maybe he did think George was responsible. Well, yeah, but you've already said that they had a strained relationship, Barry and George. Well, how could you not? When it's your father-in-law who's, you know, it's pretty clear that he did abuse his daughters. George did. So why would Eileen's husband not have a hatred for George based on that alone? Yeah, and he sees this as a way of getting back at him. And then the materials they found in George's apartment and the things his girlfriend said, some really horrific stuff.

But of course, the defense saw it as Eileen's fault. They suggested that Eileen may have been motivated to accuse her father for financial benefits because she did have a book and a movie deal concerning the case. And she did sign that in late June or early July of 1990. So could she have been doing it for the money? That's also possible. The defense further raised the possibility that Eileen's testimony was based on a false memory that was triggered under hypnosis. George Franklin Jr., his son, testified that Eileen had told him in August of 1989 that she had remembered their father committing a murder and that the memory had surfaced under hypnotherapy.

So in November of 1989, Eileen retracted her statement about the hypnotherapy. She admitted that she had made statements about being hypnotized to her brother and her mother, but she said she'd lied to her brother and mother when she made these statements. So it's really hard to say. The defense also pointed to inconsistencies between Eileen's testimony at trial and her first report of the crime to the police in November of 89. Because at trial, she testified that she thought she remembered that her sister Janice was in a nearby field when she and her father picked up Susan Nason. Prior to the trial, she had told the police and others that her sister Janice was in the van with them.

and that her father had told Janice to get out of the vehicle when they picked up Susan Nason. Janice did testify at trial, too, and she said she remembered the day that Susan Nason disappeared, but didn't recall seeing her sister Eileen, Susan Nason, or her father at all that day. Eileen originally told the police in November of 1989 that her father drove his van into the woods before stopping to rape and murder Susan. At the trial, she described the assault as occurring at a turnout off Highway 92. Eileen testified that the changes in her testimony were due to an improvement in her memory over time.

While the defense claimed that she may have consulted media reports. Which honestly does seem likely. She denied that she consulted any media reports on the murder, with the exception of a couple of seconds of the Today Show broadcast. So the defense claimed that absolutely everything to which Eileen testified was contained in publicly available newspaper articles. Defense counsel maintained that the newspaper articles were the heart of the defense. Yeah, I think that's true. George Franklin Sr. has always proclaimed his innocence, but he was convicted in 91 in San Mateo Superior Court.

and a district court judge later reviewed the case and overturned it in ninety-five and that was based on several errors in the trial among the biggest came when janice franklin revealed that her sister's repressed memory had been recalled through hypnosis because the state supreme court had ruled that testimony based on memories recovered by hypnosis were unreliable eileen could have been barred from taking the stand eventually prosecutors decided not to retry the case and george franklin was released eileen also claimed her father killed eighteen-year-old veronica cascio and seventeen-year-old paula baxter both of these women were found stabbed to death in nineteen seventy six seven years after susan natherson's death in a case that was called the gypsy hill killings but in twenty eighteen the dna evidence linked someone else rodney lynn halbauer to these murders and he was convicted of both murders and sentenced to life in prison So just a really checkered past for Eileen, but also makes me feel sad for her because she obviously did have a dysfunctional upbringing with some abuse. And that seems obvious from what we've read, doesn't it? Yeah, no, I don't think there's any question that she had a tough time growing up. She did, but then it seems like the public really turned on her when she was found to not be 100% honest. She did co-author a book titled Sins of the Father, which detail her experiences and the trial. She appeared on talk shows and became an advocate for survivors of abuse and repressed memory. However, by the mid-1990s, she stepped away from public life.

and stopped making media appearances. So Eileen moved to a different state and has a new name. She does have children, so I hope she was able to get the help she needed and give them a more stable life. But it's interesting, she's been widowed twice and wishes to remain anonymous, so she's totally out of the public eye now. Yes, she is. So what did you think initially? We saw this documentary about this whole murder and the whole case. It's on Showtime. It's titled Buried. And when it starts out, I found her so believable. Well, yeah, and I'm sure she believes what she says. You think so? I don't think she's trying to pull a scam on anybody.

Oh, okay. I kind of thought she might have been. I mean, initially, it's some of the editing with the documentary, I'm sure. But initially, she seems like this very stable, middle-class mom who just wants the truth to come out. But then you find out she's had some rough roads. She's had drug addiction. She's been a sex worker. She's had a lot of problems with her sister and her mother as well. Yeah, they're all not speaking with each other. Yeah, yeah. There's a lot of troubles in that family. But I think when she first talked about her recovered memory, I think she believed that it was a true, correct memory. Okay, I can see that. And then as things started going the way they went.

To me she kind of doubled down on it. She's not going to say, well, I just made that up. Well, now and then she brought up those two victims of the Gypsy Hill killings, which were proved not to have been crimes of her father. So that certainly did some damage to her credibility, rightly so. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Well, it really is a fascinating story. I'm glad we finally did decide to talk about it. Okay. Well, we're not going to do feedback today because we have a lot going on this week and this has just been a heavy, heavy case. It's weighed heavily on me. So we'll do it next time. I think we'll wrap things up for today and we'll see you next time. You bet. At the quiet end. Plenty of room. Come on down. All right. Bye-bye. Thanks everybody.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of True Crime Brewery?

This episode is 1 hour and 14 minutes long.

When was this True Crime Brewery episode published?

This episode was published on October 20, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this True Crime Brewery episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.