Welcome to the Heavy Spoilers Show, I'm your host Paul, and after our last two videos about DC, I thought we'd drop in to look at the way things currently stand, and why I think the hierarchy of the DC Universe is about to change again, yay! Another change of leadership coming soon! The sky is falling! Okay, so though it seems a bit doom and gloom, I've been looking at things around Supergirl, the projects in the past, what the creatives have been saying, and the way things are with Warner Brothers and Paramount. As of yesterday, Supergirl's box office has had a terrible third weekend, and it grossed just 3.4 million on its third weekend overseas. Shoutout to Luis Fernando as well for putting together all these stats, but the guy absolutely kills it with his box office reporting, and is always there with the facts and figures, so we're just-
makes my job a lot lot easier now in comparison this makes it lower than madame web's box office on the third weekend which brought in five million dollars this also makes it the lowest third weekend release for a dc film in 20 years in total the film is currently eyeing a 125 to 130 million dollar global run making it one of the biggest flops of all time just checking what morbius grossed 167.5 million dollars which was bad but still better than this now i personally believe that it's going to be a big change in leadership soon um because of what's happened with this superman not really overperforming to the level that they needed it to peacemaker season two's number and yeah creature commandos wasn't really a big show. Paramount are also taking over the company too so I do think that things are going to change. Now whenever I brought the idea of a reboot I'm hit with a counterpoint that this is just one movie and we're only two films in. So one flop isn't bad but let me say it again one of the biggest bombs of all time. This isn't a case of just losing like a little bit of money like this is going to cost the studio hundreds of millions of dollars. Beyond that it might cost them even more than that now because the next couple of projects are probably going to lose money because of the effect that this will have on them but being bad. Shared universes are built upon momentum and connection and when things are going well it's like an unstoppable locomotive. That's how you go from Iron Man 1 getting 500 million dollars to getting 600 and then after Avengers
Iron Man 3 gets 1.2 billion dollars. There was a time in the MCU where like all of the films were getting over a billion dollars and it was because they built up this momentum that just made every film a hit. The projects all kind of bounced up each other and built towards the next thing being something you had to go and see. However, we've seen with the MCU how when people feel things are bad or the motion gets knocked and people don't consider things as stuff that they need to go and see. This has a knock on effect when it comes to the projects down the line. It actually costs more when these movies lose money because it affects your next couple of movies and you have to build that goodwill back up again. I would even go so far to say that it hurts the genre as a whole because superhero fatigue is of course a big talking pun at the moment and to have another mediocre project just makes it seem like there's nothing in the genre that's doing anything new and worth seeking out. Audiences are craving new concepts and something different and that's why we're in a situation where obsession and backrooms are completely shitting all over a Star Wars and DC movie. Which...
That is mental. So it has got me thinking about what's likely going to happen because I know movie studios and I know Warner Brothers and they've got rid of people for less without even warning a brother. We were all there when Henry Cavill announced he was back as Superman. He showed up in Black Adam and put out a big post and then a couple of days later was announcing he was out. Batgirl was all shot and ready to go post-production wise and then they canceled that entire movie and it had Michael Keaton as Batman in it. Brendan Fraser as Firefly. They shot the whole thing and still got rid of it. In the words of Rachel Zegler, it's Hollywood baby and we've seen time and time again that when the money or critical scores aren't there that Hollywood will pull the plug and tank absolutely everything in order to move in another direction. Now though one...
Brothers are seen as the biggest culprits of this. There's actually another studio out there that are even worse. That is none other than Sony who I have to say make great TVs and headphones as well. Who want to send me that? I'm more than down. However, when it comes to Spider-Man, it's the perfect example of how stuff will be rebooted and changed with no real warning or
even reason for doing it. If you're as old as me, then you might remember that after Spider-Man 3, Sony announced they were moving forward with Spider-Man 4. Tobey Maguire was involved, Sam Raimi was back, The Vulture was going to be there, and yeah, it was all going ahead. The Sam Raimi films were some of the most beloved comic book movies of all time, and they were critically acclaimed and made lots and lots of money, but Sony still shit the bed after a middling entry. That also wasn't critically panned and one of the worst bombs of all time, I say it again. They then went ahead with the amazing Spider-Man universe and put out two movies in quick succession. Both made money, but weren't these beloved things, and then yeah, we know they rebooted once more to time with the MCU. So in the space of nine years, we had three different Spider-Men and two movies that were-
were announced that never went anywhere. They also started their villain universe and even though Venom's films crushed it at the box office, like even during a pandemic, they still canceled the whole universe after things turned sour. And Morbius again made more money than Supergirl. So it can happen. Now, let's look at Warner Brothers and what's on the horizon. James Gunn said during an interview with Boba Talks that he doesn't know if he'll still be in charge after Man of Tomorrow. Now, I do feel for the guy because he has a lot more on his plate than Feige seems to. So far, DC Studios have released Creature Commandos, which he wrote and directed, Peacemaker Season 2, which he wrote and directed, Superman, which he wrote and directed, and Supergirl, which he didn't write and direct, but he did end up being heavily involved with and writing some of it and by the sounds of it,
certain creative choices. Plus he has to oversee everything, greenlight the scripts and then blah blah blah. It's a big big job. Doing all that while working on Man of Tomorrow is a lot and it's going to be very difficult for him to keep up with the workload I think. As it would be for anyone to be completely honest there's a reason that there hasn't been this kind of job in Hollywood before and it's because it's very very very difficult like this is very difficult. Now kind of jumping back to the idea of momentum before I think the projects that he's picked are actually sort of the antithesis to how you build things and
get real motion going. Gunn has always liked to obscure characters and that's pretty much all the projects seem to have a level of niche to them. But of course Superman. But even stuff like Clayface coming as your third movie just makes no sense because this isn't something that's gonna build up momentum. You go from Superman to Supergirl which kind of makes sense but then Clayface's number three is...
a weird choice out of the three films so far you have one big character and then two are spin-off ones with one being a batman film for a batman that we haven't even met yet the rule with spin-offs as well normally is that you have to actually build the thing up that you're spinning off from and get that in place first and then then when that's successful then you can spin off otherwise you're just making something about a side character that doesn't have a main character to anchor it now this even got me thinking about what happens if clayface is successful mike flanagan has now handed off the project and he's gone on to work on his own things but like if it comes out and It does really well. Does he suddenly come back? Like, do we get a Clayface 2? I was thinking that. They might even put a Clayface sequel in the works before we've even seen a Batman film. However, if you do that, then you also run the risk of another Joker folly a deux situation. And we're back to another one of the biggest bombs of all time. So do you then bring him back as a villain for the brave and the bold? And do we launch the DCU Batman with Clayface? I don't know. And I would have thought they'd go with someone else because I don't know if Clayface is who you'd kick things off with. But look at what they're making a movie on the guy. So who knows at this point? But yeah, personally, I don't think that'll happen. And this will be kind of a one-off that again...
speaks to the idea of momentum. It doesn't really feel like there's a through line on this universe and you've just got projects with characters that are all kind of off in the world but not connected in any meaningful way which is sort of what happened with the DCEU in the end in that we had like Shazam, Aquaman, Birds of Prey, Blue Beetle, all these projects that sure they're in the same universe but don't necessarily feel like they coexist. I've said it once and I've said it again but due to how much of a mess the DC universe was the first thing they should have done was make sensible choices. Supergirl was always going to be a major risk as a second film in the universe because you hadn't even established your big names yet. Obviously anyone coming into this looking at how to guarantee success and build towards things would have done Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman. I don't think that's a hot take but there is a reason that these three are known as the Pillars of DC. Personally I actually think they don't really have a plan and this was shown by the fact the plan they announced hasn't really came to fruition.
If we jump back to that original James Gunn video, it didn't really seem like he was rebooting things anyway. Shazam has always been off kind of in his own part of the DCU, so he connects very well. That moves directly into The Flash, a fantastic movie that I really love that resets the entire DC Universe. Then to move into Blue Beetle, a fantastic film about a kid who's a marvelous part of the DCU, and then into Aquaman 2, which leads directly into our next few projects, which I'm going to tell you about now. So all of them were still part of the DCU as he stated. Peacemaker's still around and he carries over from the Suicide Squad which had Harley Quinn in which connected to the first Suicide Squad which is connected to the Flash and Batfleck. So I don't even know if general audiences are aware that this is all a new thing because it's not really. In the video he also says Shazam's off in the corner, Blue Beetle's still in the DCU, Flash then kind of resets things but keeps around Aquaman for Aquaman 2 but now Jason Momoa is also playing Lobo. Plus the stuff they announced in the video doesn't really seem to be in production. Creature Commandos was announced but then that was supposed to be followed by Waller and Gunn then said the DCU truly begins with Superman. But what do you mean truly begins? Like...
The first project is where it truly begins. But it just shows they still have these hangover projects and they're all in the way before they can kick things off and the old DC is very much still influencing this. And it's not a full on reboot. He then goes on to say that the authorities in the works as well, which has been cancelled, a Booster Gold TV show, Paradise Lost and James Mangold's Swamp Thing movie. All of which are still yet to materialize. Instead, they're announcing stuff that wasn't part of that and they're kind of getting buried.
So the Jimmy Olsen and Mr Terrific stuff is now taking center stage, but it's like, I don't know, it feels like what you get with Star Wars when they announce loads of things and they don't go anywhere. The video is actually kind of like the equivalent of Marvel announcing their slate on stage at Comic-Con and then them not making any of the projects. Now to Marvel's credit, I think Barblade, Armor Wars, and a couple of others like Captain America Serpent Society, all their announcements have eventually been made. Gunnar also explicitly stated that they weren't going to greenlight things if the script wasn't good. And though he denied this video as being greenlighting of the projects, it's like...
You're telling the world this stuff is getting made. So I do think behind the scenes, confidence is being lost in the plan because the plan ain't planning. I'm circling back around to Comic Con, DC have said they aren't doing it this year. This has been said to be because of the expense, which is definitely a factor. but I feel that they might be saving face. I actually think that everything is currently tied up with Man of Tomorrow and that if that doesn't do well, then they'll have a change of leadership. But I do think that behind the scenes, they've said, do not announce anything yet or put anything into production until we're fully sure about where we're going with things. So skipping Comic-Con is just one of those things they have to do because they can't go there and announce things because those things might not be made and people will lose further confidence. Personally, I think that's a bad idea to do this because after a bomb, you need to come out, set the world on fire with something and show that you guys mean business and people need to have faith in you. Instead, this is giving me feelings in the opposite direction where I feel like it's a big red flag to miss this event.
Beyond that, Gunn has also said something that really stuck out to me. In an interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Gunn talked about how Paramount were embracing the direction they were going, and how Ellis and himself had visited the set of Man of Tomorrow. However, when asked about what was coming down the line, he said there were some projects where the train had already left the station, meaning that Paramount couldn't stop them. Go back and read the article, he talked about what's coming, it's like the trains left the station. Now, does that sound like the kind of thing you'd say if you were confident they were going to let you go ahead beyond that? Or is that like, well, it's too late to stop those ones, mate, so even if you get cancelled, those ones are still definitely coming out. So yeah, that's just a phrase that really, really stuck out to me, and with Paramount getting involved...
I don't think anything is safe. You're talking about people who are buying Warner Bros and DC to utilize their properties to make the most amount of money possible. This is putting Paramount in a hell of a lot of debt. I think it's like over a hundred billion dollars and they're going to be wanting to make money because the interest on that alone, absolutely insane. They're not going to be happy with the constant greenlighting of these niche characters. And the only reason that they're even buying this universe is because they want things to go ahead. Now, I don't feel like they're going to announce that Man of Tomorrow is where things are going to change after because they're not stupid enough to do that. And they have seen with the original DC announcement video, how doing that kind of tank those four films.
But there's nothing in the DCU that really shows there's a massive and major interest in this universe. And I think when they look at the profit and losses, how much these things are costing, what projects they're greenlighting, they're probably going to question things. They've only had one hit movie with Superman. And even the success with that is slightly arguable. The box office was very similar to Man of Seals from 13 years ago. It didn't have the aftermarket that that did with rentals, getting sold to TV networks, Blu-ray sales, DVD sales. And when it gets released on 4K, that gets more money in. So I do feel like though the numbers haven't been put out in the public, using common sense.
man of steel will have made more money peacemaker season two also didn't chart supergirl has bombed and clayface in my opinion even if it's really good won't really move the needle in terms of building momentum towards a big shared universe so i think that the writing is kind of on the wall and people are going to come in and say look we're going to have to really rein you in for the projects that you need to choose or you're going to have to go work somewhere else and we're going to bring someone on board who is more aligned with our vision which is making money whenever i talk about this stuff um i'm always like look you guys are very attached to dc i understand your passion for it but you have to view this as these being people who aren't necessarily interested in this universe. I doubt any of them have a big comic book collection. They probably heard of Batman. And personally, I think you have to view it as like a franchise that you don't care about. For example, I don't care about the Twilight universe. I'm sorry, Breaker, you guys, put them away, put them away. But if I bought Twilight and they were like, well, what are we doing now? And I was like, oh, we're doing an Edward movie? And they'd be like, yeah, yeah, we're doing that. And go, Bella movie? Okay, yeah, yes, okay. And then they start bringing out all the niche characters that I'd never heard of. I'd just be like, can we do just the main ones? Can we actually just remake and just redo everything?
these people are going to want the popular choices because that's what makes the most money. I even think that if Man of Tomorrow underperforms or only breaks even, they'll probably abandon the shared universe thing and have a reset or maybe just do standalone films for a while, but I can't see them keeping the things the way they are. I think Safran's track record is really getting to the point as well where the hit to flop ratio is going to be in the latter direction and I just can't see him being brought on for another term since the majority of his films under DC have underperformed as well. You'll see there's a ton during corporate shakeups where a company comes in and completely changes everything. Hell, even David Zaslav coming on board had massive repercussions. Like at the time, you might remember, they were even talking to Todd Phillips about taking over the DC universe. The Rock also could potentially be a direction, and in the end, they settled on James Gunn. They also have lots of people that are really wanting to do this job and get involved, and I think with Paramount and George, when they see the numbers, they're probably going to take a good hard look at stuff. So yeah, personally, I don't know if we can do another full-on reboot. I would...
probably put things on ice for a while maybe do some standalone films like what they're doing with the batman and wait till the dust is settled and then do a hard reset where it's like right first three films are going to be part of a trilogy that's going to be superman batman wonder woman and then after that we're bringing them together for the justice league the batman universe actually seems far more promising than anything else they have on the slate at the moment and i just think the stuff i've laid out here the fact we have a corporate merger the comments by gun and everything else means that we probably are going to be seeing a massive change of leadership after man of tomorrow gun may even be put back on directing projects as well because that's where he excels at I'm not really sure him choosing what things to go ahead is the best idea because he doesn't really want to do something that general audiences want, which is ultimately who you have to make things for if you want to make money. I have seen people saying that this means we're going to be getting Batman movies forever, but I don't really think that's the case if they're smart about how they do things, but they can't really rush in with spinoffs first and they have to come out straight away with their big hitters to draw people in with names they're familiar with rather than characters that they haven't really heard of.
they're not necessarily going to be rushing to go see. Especially when it's like, mate, you wait a month and it's out on streaming. So yeah, just my two pennies on it. And I'd love to hear your thoughts below. And also, you know, if you like these industry videos, I do make sure you comment below. I feel like I'm going really hard on DC at the moment, but that's just kind of the talking point right now. But I just kind of wanted to touch upon this on the third week. Some of the stuff that's been said and the news that DC aren't going to be at Comic-Con because I did say in some of the other videos, they needed to be there because yeah, this is like...
I don't know, this is like the biggest event of the year for a lot of companies. So yeah, please drop a like on the video, or drop a dislike if you disagree, and follow us on Instagram at HeavySpoilers if you want to keep up to date with what we're doing. Did you know as well that members of the channel also get early access to videos like this every single week, and if you click that join button, you get at least one big breakdown a week, a week before anyone else, and it costs just 99 cents a month. Huge thank you if you do that, huge thank you for sitting with me until the end of the video as well, I hope you enjoy the rest of your week. Sam Neal's dead, so I feel like there's a bummer over the whole thing, like, how can I get happy now? But yeah, thank you for watching this, and take care of yourself. Peace.