Skip to content
Metadata, Time To Ditch Facebook And Diversity episode artwork

Jul 11, 2019 43 min

Metadata, Time To Ditch Facebook And Diversity

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we look at the latest revelation about AFP accessing journalists metadata, Facebook and defamation and we also talk about is a lack of diversity in the media hurting the media's ability to speak to all Australians. To discuss all of this we are joined by Antoinette Lattouf from Ch10, Emily Watkins from Crikey and Ricky Sutton CEO of Oovvuu

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Metadata, Time To Ditch Facebook And Diversity

0:00 43:19
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.

Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from 2CR in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the Orr Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey and I am the Co-Director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology Sydney and my producer today is Anthony Dockron.

Australian Federal Police is like a dog with a bone. This week we found out they have been chewing through the ABC Junos' private travel records and that the AFP last year accessed two journalists' metadata almost 60 times. Good job, there's now a parliamentary inquiry into journalism and security rules. So what really needs to happen to protect press freedom?

Meantime, barely a week goes by that Facebook doesn't make the news within the news media industry. The latest hot button issue flows from a legal ruling that publishers can now be sued for content the publishers didn't make and for comments they can't easily turn off. So what to do about that? And while we're at it, what to do about the market's power of Facebook and Google?

Ahead of the expected release of the nation's Consumer Competition Watch Dogs report into digital platforms, we ask what steps need to be taken to even off the playing field in favour of news media? And finally, but not least but not least, it's important. Finally, does the media have a problem with diversity? You look at the average newsroom and you probably say yes, yes, and yes.

So again, what needs to change? Is it time for quotas or there are other mechanisms that need to be put in place to ensure that the media looks like the nation is talking about? To answer these questions and many others, we are joined by a diverse, esteemed and dare I say a wonderful panel. We have Anternetlutov, who is an award-winning multi-platform journalist and the director and co-founder of Media Diversity Australia.

Hello, Anternet. Hello, thanks for having me. Great pleasure. We have Emily Watkins, who is the newly minted sort of media reporter and basically a reporter for the Krikey Offshoot Inc and a long-standing friend of the show from Krikey.

And previously, ABC's Media Watch and the NT News Hello Emily. Hi, Peter. And our third guest is probably best described as a journalist who became a media entrepreneur. But he's definitely on a mission to save journalism or as he puts it, and I quote, to repatriate $20 billion in advertising from Facebook and Google to back to the journalist who report the world around us.

Welcome to the panel, the CEO and co-founder of the video platform, Ooh, Voo. Ricky Sutton, hello. Good to see you. It was great to have you, Ricky.

And just for background you in this journalism thing, you've been a reporter for, or you were a reporter for many, many years, working for NSN, for Fairfax and New School up in the UK and here. Yeah, I was working for the National News Papers in the UK. I began my career as a war correspondent and then kind of went my way through the National Papers in the UK and then to New School up here, been here since 2004. Wonderful.

And also, you've been jailed a couple of times for doing your job. Let's get to that later. Let's do that. It's great to have you all here.

And we'll have a bit more time, I hope, later in the show to talk more about your various projects and ventures. But let's get cracking with the news about the news. So, media rates. We had the media rates now, what, three, four weeks ago, and the flow on just keeps giving.

We found out this week that the AFP has access to Australian journalists' metadata 58 times over the course of one year. So that's the data that's on your phone records which can reveal where you were, who you were, who you were calling, how long you spent talking about various other things. So the identity of the journalist, who's access is unknown at this point, and that means the journalists and questions have no idea that they know that the AFP now has their metadata. I wonder how many ABC journalists are fighting and wondering if it's there?

Well, you're not, you're obviously fine. I think that, yes, you think it was something to do with the raids on the ABC and the news corp journalists and the news that the media has been accessed with journalists even known as sign that there is even more at stake. Emily, what's going on here? Well, look, I mean, like Antonette said, and like you said, it may or may not have been those two journals that, whose metadata was accessed.

And I think it's just an indication of some of the chilling effects that these laws have had on journalists because it's not even just the journalists who would be worried about their information being accessed. I'm sure there's a lot of people who have leaked or spoken outside their contract or terms to the ABC or to other journalists who might be rethinking their decision and others who might have considered leaking on matters of public interest who may not do that or may have decided against it because they don't know if they could be found out. Yeah, exactly. Andrew, General Tan, has you been talking about this?

Yeah, I think one of the things we talk about around the water cooler is that while my industry mates, my media diversity Australia mates, the chatter on Twitter that while a lot of journalists are concerned, politicians are making noise, but we don't think the general public are as concerned. One of my colleagues, quite finally and aptly perhaps said, our stocks are low as journalists. We're not necessarily seeing outrage and uproar from Mr. and Mrs.

Kamachawa. I'm just not sure that the general public feels as sympathetic or outraged as to what this impact is going to have on the industry and the flow and effects is what this impact is going to have on the kind of stories that we're able to break. What do you think needs to happen for the general public to get upset about these things? Is that asking too much?

What do you think I'm too upset about that? Yeah, I'm not sure. I think it's interesting because it comes at a time where I think many feel that outlets or journalists who overstep the mark, there isn't a lot of accountability within their news outlets or within so-called regulatory bodies, we get the press council or Akama. I think it's hard to have a sympathy for journalists when there is this sense and I hate to think that Trump is having an effect here, but you have to read some Facebook comments and people go, fake news, it's just right-wing crap, it's just left-wing rubbish.

People are really quite hotly divided in their politics and are really quick to dismiss anything they don't agree with. But then there are some examples of pretty sloppy divisive journalism that seems to be fed in and people just do it and what the impact is on an individual or a community, there doesn't seem to be a huge amount of consideration or much in the way of backlash. So it's hard to have people rallying for our craft with some of our colleagues. I would argue, particularly wonderful job.

Ricky, not to pick on you here, but you'd have got a journalistic experience to draw on and you did work for the news of the world. I did, which broke a lot of stories, but wouldn't be one of the world's greatest loves newspapers. Did you go into journalism expecting to be loved? You can get back to the previous question for the answer.

Oh, give me thought. You can think about whether you want to be loved. Yeah, sure. I think that I just want to raise the point on the previous point about the meta-data being captured is that sure the story is now breaking because of the news is now breaking because the stories have already broken and it's in focus.

The question is, how many stories are being stifled before they're ever known by this kind of interception? Of course. So the thing that concerns me most is that the more likely and more damaging and more important publicly, the story is going to be the stronger the concern to find out the information to stop it ever being revealed. And our job is to keep the powerful accountable.

And if the powerful have the ability to stop that accountability at its inception, we don't get to see the stories that we need to think. So our job is not done? No, absolutely not. And the problem is that the rules and the regulations for us as journalists to actually get our stories into the public arena are getting harder and harder.

The costs of defamation and the risks of not having a name source are harried into us every single day as they should be. But the problem is that getting a name source to say something is hard enough given the threats that they face as a whistleblower. But if they can then be intimidated before you get to publication by this kind of interception, then you have a whole new game. And that's a game that's played outside the public's attention.

So how are they supposed to know if it's the story they need to know? Exactly. And I'll take your notice that you probably didn't go to journalism to be loved. Just in passing.

No, in fairness, I asked that question. I went into journalism because I was a kid from a kind of not very exciting council estate in Bristol in the UK and I wanted to see the whole world and I thought it was super exciting. And the best way for me to find a passport to go and do all those things was to go into journalism is the only way to do it. And to be honest, I live in Australia and in a different country every couple of months, it's the best career ever.

And here you are in the two S.S. studios. Which is which is my goal when I was 16. Let's go back to this issue.

Emily, we don't have the one for the name Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security investigating various aspects of the S.S. Internationals. Somewhat oddly, I guess, we have the same committee that basically when they passed said that these laws were perfectly good and they're investigating whether they're good. So do we have any hope in this inquiry to think?

Probably not. I mean, successive governments over the years have always moved in favour of national security over public interest or open government. You know, when we have some of the broadest anti-terrorism laws in the Western world that have kind of been introduced in bits and bobs since 2001. But I think it's more of a PR exercise than anything to kind of say.

Yeah, look, we're looking into it. Can't say anything until the inquiry is done. I think it's a really hard sell to the general public who might not be media literate. And to Rick's point earlier, may not understand just how much stories may be stifled before they even reach the public based on this kind of pressure and monitoring.

But at a time in the age of terror, I guess, I hate using these American buzz words, which I continue to refer to. It's really, people seem more willing to cash in their civil liberties and their press freedoms when they think it's kind of terrorism. It's why we haven't seen a larger attack like Europe has. This is going to mean I'm safer and our capital is safer than I guess that's very dinkum.

I guess what you're getting at is one of the kind of central issues in this is the, and you've all kind of mentioned it, which is the lack of transparency. You know, we don't really know. We don't really know stories being suppressed. We don't really know whose journalist, metadata has been accessed.

We don't know who are the subjects of journalism information warrants. If we don't know, how can we make informed decisions about this? In terms of selling it to the public at a time, for them to carry it also comes when the political spoonies. We have these tough stance on terrorism.

We've intercepted boats. That's a different issue with Rick with refugees. And we haven't had an attack and the AFP had a series of raids last week. They had planned terror attacks on churches and police stations.

We've intercepted that. We are keeping us safe and part of doing so. Might be curtailing press read. Just a little bit.

Hey guys and girls, look at the benefits. We're safe for country for it. I think just on that point, are you saying that the news media industry, and this is for everyone, but starting with you, Internet, do you think the news media industry doesn't sell itself, sell its use to the public that well? I think that what we've found is attempting to at the moment, what price would you pay for independent journalism?

But I think that the fact that people don't want to pay necessarily subscriptions to get past paywalls, I'm not sure how much they value the product and value in the craft. Rick, just on the tech side of this, because it was a great mode of journalistic idea and a very smart piece of tech. Can tech help us in this? Can tech help protect journalists in any way?

It's funny. I had the pleasure of opening a conference to 35,000 engineers in Las Vegas at an IBM event last year, and my opening line was that I know you're all here as engineers, I understand, but let me tell you, technology can be learned. Trust has to be earned. Okay?

Understand the difference. Technology has to be learned because I'm presenting to all 35,000 of you and I can't write a single line of code. But the reason I'm here is because the world's in a crisis of trust. And if we're going to use technology, let's use technology to assist trust, that ultimately helps people, let's not use technology to drive machines, that drive more money to technologies.

And I think we've lost that. So if you merge that with the conversation that you were saying a moment ago, about are we failing as journalists to tell our story, I think that we've had 10 years of falling behind on the technology curve, but we've now caught up. And it's now our job to then tell the rest of the world that trust doesn't matter. And now we can start to sell our story with the weapons that those technology companies have used against us.

So I think this is our time, actually. I'm an optimist for the future. But the trust has to be re-earned. And I think that's when I mentioned earlier that some of our stocks are low.

I think trust in media outlets, because of some really divisive, polarizing reporting, or increasingly seeing click online and via social media is opinion pieces, but they're not sold or marked as opinion pieces. They're under the guise of a news piece. But when you read it, there's not a single source. There's very little what I would call independent journalism.

And it's just, you know, it rants from your desk, a cheap off. And it rewards emotion rather than fact. That's right. And I see some of my journal mates calling it out, or scoring grabbing it.

And this is a blatant editorial. We saw a lot of it around Israel for a while recently. Masters as a supposed news story. So I agree that trust needs to be earned.

We need to be doing a better job to earn that trust and to have that integrity attached to our craft. Okay. Talking about trust and technology. Another week goes by and Facebook makes a job that much easier.

The latest was Facebook. It revolves around a defamation case involving Dylan Vollar. For those who have not been following the case, Dylan was one of the boys at the Four Corners Show years ago, covered in their expose-aimist treatment and detention centers in the Northern Territory. He was attacked recently with several people making allegedly defamatory comments about him on a number of Facebook pages in news media.

The short version of this, and there is a longer version, but the short version of this is that the story is that the now, the media is now, it seems, responsible for post-by-the-parities on their Facebook pages. This seems to be a very chilling development, Emily. Yeah, look, I mean, a lot of media companies are incredibly concerned about this, because they're, you know, in a time of great pressure on their bottom lines. They've used, like we've already talked about, they've used social media to push some of those more divisive and controversial news stories or opinion pieces because they generate comments, which pushes them up the algorithm and all those sorts of things, and they've really relied on that to drive traffic to their websites and to drive revenue, which, yeah, I mean, they're really good in there.

Yeah, they're kicking the challenge. Well, it's a ten-day, for example. It's a digital outfit launched by Ten, which I'm a part of, so we're going to run for about a year. And the audience, which is actually growing grutantly, you know, many people say, shrinking media marketplace, but 70% of, about 70% of the usage comes and clicks and eyes come via social media.

And the audience is tapping into, is kind of the project type audience. Digitalist savvy, younger professionals, always on the go, accessing their user current affairs, primarily and largely online. So for a site like Ten Daily, which heavily relies on social media traffic, we've now had to have, you know, workshops with our legal team and training that we can't do. But also a lot of time we spent having to go through and create comments or delete iGOLs at the end of the shift and somebody can no longer monitor them.

So it's adding extra work to newsrooms, which we know are already stretched by media or sometimes trimedia in the fact of the ABC and SBS. So it's certainly putting extra pressure. And that just means less time for journalists to do traditional, traditionally journalists, to do their jobs as journals instead of monitoring really horrible comments. Well, the kick in the tail of this ruling by Justice Rothman, it seems that it seems to ignore, it seems to ignore that media companies can't readily turn off the comments on their Facebook.

So is this an example of what the judiciary not fully understanding the kind of social media world we live in? Or is there something else going on again? And is there a tech solution to this? Yeah, I have a contrarian view, I'm afraid.

Well, my contrarian view is that this is the wake up call that the media needs to recognise it and have to rely on tech companies to succeed. We worked perfectly adequately before. Social media came and mixed our world up. I say this many of my friends are at Facebook, you know, we had Facebook and Google on our advisory board for a while.

But the truth, you can't control, if you give up, think about if in a print context, right? So if you print newspapers and you don't own the presses and you don't own the news agent, and both of them are directly competing with you, how much control do you actually have? And we've kind of given that control back to social media. Now, I understand that we were convinced that the metrics that we had to work towards were paid to use and audience size, I understand.

That only makes sense if we're actually telling the news and we don't want to make money, or it's making us money. If it's not making us money, then why? My question is that, you know, if we bring, if our audiences in our media companies were to have, would our revenues have, and do we really make enough money from social media to be worth giving up our future or autonomy? I'm going to get to that in a second with the HPC discussion.

But can I just also play out? There was a bit of myself here, which is that having the media companies themselves invited, it's kind of what Ricky's saying in a way, having the media companies themselves invited their audiences to interact with their stories on Facebook. So perhaps it's a little bit rich, now complaining that, you know, oh dear, we've got to look at what's being said on their comments pages. I just want to clarify one thing.

I'm not giving Facebook a get-out gel free card here one bit. No, I need a reminder, but I'm asking a few questions, isn't it? Yeah, the point I'm trying to make is that if you publish the content, there's Facebook, you hide behind section 213, so you're not responsible for the content. If you then put the content on the page to drive traffic and consumption of your platform, which you then sell as Facebook, and you drive the commentary in the conversation because that's the reason you exist, and then you're not liable for that.

What are you liable for? Exactly. And so my point is, I don't think in any way whatsoever, I actually listened to K2B2 from NewSock.com.au on this very show talking about this morning, and I was raging about it in my car, because the whole point is, is that if you either play the game and play the same game as social media, or you don't play the game, right? Either you can't fight a completely vacant argument and say, we're not responsible for anything that happens on here, and by the way, if something bad does happen, we're not responsible for that either.

So I enter that, and then, is it, is it hard not to play the game? I mean, I'm not, I don't have as much, you know, I, my career has been largely broadcast. I'm a relative newbie to the digital space when I joined Ten Daily. So I'm interested to hear some of Ricky's solutions, but not playing the game or how media outlets can be sustainable without relying on social media eyes.

From what I've seen, it's really hard to get people off those, particularly the demographic that Ten Daily and the project reach to get them off those social media platforms. So I wouldn't say I experienced enough to say it's time to not play the game, because I don't know what the best alternative is. So that brings in the ACCPCC, the ACCPCC being the Australian Consumer Competition Commission. So I'll have this digital platforms inquiry.

As I understand it, the report has gone to the government. It's going to release any day soon, and we're all going to be very interested as to what's in it. Yeah, people tell us one thing. Well, the metadata was just here.

But Emmy, so what do you think? So, okay, let's, let's say, the, not playing the game is not the best option, perhaps one of the options is to reduce the market power of Google and Facebook. How would you do that? What's the, what's the answers here?

Well, the answers to, I mean, one of the answers for instance, but for what is that there should be a kind of content text on Google and Facebook for using news media content, and that money should be sent fed back into the news media industry. What do you think of that idea? I mean, look, I'm always a bit suspicious of taxes or government money going into the news business other than via public broadcasting, but I mean, what we've got now is obviously struggling and have, at least feels like it has to rely on, on Facebook and social media to drive traffic, to get clicks, to get advertising revenue or new subscribers. I wish I had a clear solution, but I am aware of it.

Okay, Ricky, we've got to deal with the devil. How do we unwind it? Yeah, so I don't think anybody went into this pact expecting it to end up where it did, including the technical news. I think they're also confused.

But, you know, that's because they talk tech and we talk truth, and they're very hard to understand what they are if you come from two completely different worlds. What I would say, though, is that we can't have a situation where, as I mentioned before, the tech companies have Section 230, a complete get out of jail, free card in the US, they can do anything that they want and not worry about what it said, and that our laws have not kept place with the changing technology. I would also go so far as to say to you that Google will tell you, or they've certainly told me, that what they've built and the AI that they've built, they have no idea where it's going, and they don't know where it's going to go next. They had to create a law for something that you can't put in a business plan, or tell anybody's going to be along in three or four years.

So we're in completely uncharted territory. What I would say, though, is what we can control is where we choose our content to go. So in the early 2000s, when I was in the UK with News Corp, there was a very serious discussion about removing all news content from Google Search to just control its distribution, and the control of that was, okay, our traffic goes down by 98% or whatever it might be. But maybe we just focus on growing our traffic as the media companies as we used to be when we used to sell newspapers or have the best stories or create an economy of scale that was based on what we actually contribute to our audience, rather than just going and finding the audience while doing something else.

No, they did not happen. No, they did not happen. And we made the pact with the devil and we've been paying for ever since. So Oovem says it's going to repatriate $20 billion with the ad revenue back to the news media industry.

How are you going to do that? Yeah. So what we do is that we're a partnership between broadcasters and publishers all over the world. So we believe that the future of news selling will be video led.

So what we do is we partner with broadcasters like the BBC and Bloomberg and Reuters and the Associated Press and others all over the world. And we take all of their video output, which is hundreds of thousands of videos. We put them in the cloud. We then have a separate technology that reads articles and identifies what they're about, and then says this video is relevant to this article and enables the journalist to put the video on the page.

We resisted the temptation as a tech company to insert that video in the page without human interaction. We could have done it. It would have made us a much bigger and much more valuable company, but we didn't do that. What we do is we take those video recommendations and recommend them to a journalist, only when a journalist embeds them in the page that they ever appear.

And when the journalist embeds it in the page, it teaches the machine. So we're actually using journalists to teach machines to distribute trusted content. Now, how does that repatriate money from Facebook and Google? It's because Facebook and Google doesn't understand that.

And so if we want to get... When you're saying they don't understand, what is it they don't understand? They don't understand that. A video in an article of a campaign sick in a bucket that drives a hundred views is more relevant for that article than the actual video about what the article is about.

They just recognize the metric, the echo. Lots of people have watched it. Therefore, it is viral. So that's another bugbear of mine.

I see people working in newsroom saying, what do you do? I work on virality. Virality is just what we used to do with the best stories. They're the ones that people want to read.

It's not something that's just invented. So how relevant are these articles? How relevant is the video to the article content, to the journalism? Or are they just kind of fun videos to watch?

What, from our perspective from Oovu? Yes. Oh no, it's 100% directly contextually relevant. So the story will be that, you know, just pick something from the last couple of days.

So Donald Trump on his 4th of July with the Jets flying over will have a selection of videos from perhaps 20 different broadcasters all talking about their perspective on that. So you'll have a Fox News perspective might be very positive, but then the Guardian's coverage may be very different and AP's coverage may be very middle ground. And the Genomex decision was right. But the Genome is teaching the AI.

Absolutely. So what ends the teaching that though, if the Genome keeps deciding? Every time the Genome over rules or validates the machine's recommendation, it up wakes that much validation. So that by the time Australia wakes up, every journalist in the US and New Zealand has taught the machine companies are companies.

And just $20 billion. How are we going to get that back? And can I have some? Well, because $20 billion is how much the two tech companies, Facebook and Google have taken out of video from media companies and broadcasters over the last five years.

That money isn't there as it's ours. They've taken it and put it on rubbish on YouTube. What we need to do is to bring audiences back at scale into publishers. So here's an interesting stat for you.

Is anybody here read Hitchhaka's Guide to the Galaxy? Of course. Right. What was Douglas Adams' answer to the Life of the Universe and everything?

Yeah. The number 42. It wasn't. It was 26.

And the reason it's 26 is because the 26 largest newspapers in the world have an audience larger than Facebook. So you only need to get 26 publishers and broadcasters from the world to achieve it. Okay. There you go.

We will. I think we should have a whole show devoted to having Ricky in the room with someone from Facebook and someone from Google. Would you be up there? I think so.

I'd like to hear that. I'd like to take some notes as well. We'll do that one. We'll do that one.

That 20 billion. Yes, that's right. Now, let's move on. Recently on the fourth estate, we've been digging over the digital news report from the Reuters Institute for the Sully of Journalism at Oxford University.

This is an annual report, surveys about 38 countries, the Australian part of it is done by the University of Canberra. And it asks a series of basically questions about news usage. And this report had some very troubling results in the Australian context, which was essentially a large number of people. 65% in fact, either occasionally sometimes or often avoid the news, which does seem like a very large number.

So I mean, I guess one way of looking at that is that we're not providing the news that people, these people, these 65%, actually want to read, listen or watch. And maybe part of that is that we're not talking to those people because the news media industry is dominated by white blokes like me. What do you think about that? Is it all my fault?

What do I think about white blokes like you, Kyd Frei? I do think this is something Media Diversity Australia is doing some research into at the moment. We're doing a diversity audit of all free-to-air news and current affairs programs across the country. Looking at who tells our news, how that pairs up with, which we're not going to, but just how probably that reflects the Australian population.

But further to that, we're going to look at UK, US, Canada and New Zealand, and New Zealand and see how their newsrooms are fairing in representation and perhaps learn from some of their policies as to how we can have more diverse bodies in newsrooms and what the flow on effect. Then that is to more diverse perspectives and stories. I know from my experience from the people we've spoken to around the country and the workshops we've held from our committee here in the National Committee, the Queensland Committee, and we're just about to launch in Victoria. Some of the things we're hearing and feeling is that not only do journalism, not necessarily have longevity in this industry, they're often in junior roles.

When they are in newsrooms and contribute to a story of national significance, be it about their cultural group, they often don't have the editorial clout or they're not in senior leadership positions to really have a huge amount of impact. So if I might have a little bit of one story or one story idea, it's not necessarily reflected in what the rundown is or what makes from page. What's the answer to? What's the answer to?

You think you've got any early thoughts about that? Is it a kind of credit system? I don't know about quotas. We're looking to see what the BBC has done and again academics doing this as we speak.

I don't believe necessarily quotas are the answer. I don't know yet. We're interrogating how it's played out elsewhere. What we've seen in Australia is quite a lot of resistance to the diversity discussion.

I don't think we have very grown up discussions about race and multiculturalism in the first instance. If newsrooms feel that they're being forced to hire people because they're a certain ethnic background, particularly in a climate where as we know a lot of media outlets and most media outlets are struggling to maintain audiences, a lot of journalists are being made redundant. I'm just not sure. Where do we see this research?

The results will be out early 2020. Okay, great. I'll definitely come on the show and talk about them. They're well underway and I'll have more.

I don't want to jump the gun and say we've got to do X, Y or Z. But my understanding at the moment, based on the experience of other people of Douglas backgrounds in newsrooms, is that even when there is diversity spoken about by management and cadets brought in or in turns, often they don't last. They leave within two years. There's a real retention problem because there isn't a clear career path for success.

There's often middle management blocks, unconscious bias. So I'm just not sure that you have to employ 10 NSB cold people or indigenous people in an environment. People struggling for deal after maintaining their jobs is going to be good for long term change. So what are the results of this?

I mean, look, in my experience, most of the newsrooms I've worked in have been overwhelmingly white and the people making the decisions like Internet said about what goes on the front page are white men. And that's overwhelmingly still the case across the country, even though... Even at SBS, even at SBS, even at SBS, even at the people who decide on the rundowns and making the calls are still middle class, middle age white men who leave in affluent areas and will probably privately educate it. So even at our multicultural broadcaster, they're the decision makers largely.

Yeah, and I think also, like Internet said, at a time when lots of journalists are losing their jobs and scared for their jobs, any sort of quota system feels essentially threatening. Yeah, look, I mean, in general, I think quite a very good idea. I'm not sure that in our industry necessarily... So how do you make the case that you need a more diverse industry?

I mean, I guess you could argue, I would argue that it's a solid business idea to have a more diverse... Absolutely. And I think, like we've been speaking about this whole show, trust in media has been steadily declining. And I think probably part of that is that the mainstream media doesn't really represent most of its potential audience.

So I think that's probably as good a case as any to encourage greater diversity. I think there have been some instances where organizations simply recording the diversity of female versus male talent or staff has helped increase a bit of balance between experts used and those sorts of things. So maybe something like that would work, just like a public accountability and having it written down and published what the diversity is like in particular organizations. I'm not sure whether your case is like, but we're...

you might have more understanding there. But in the US, or employment forms, you feel out just like we do without taxile number and our date of birth. You feel out there are certain categories that capture your ethnicity. So whether you go to work for Microsoft or Mac is, they have that kind of data on the ethnic makeup of their workforce.

We don't have that. So for the first time in Australia, history or Australia media history, we're going to hold a mirror. And it's pretty uncomfortable we're up to the industry to say, this is who is telling our stories. And this is at a time where we know you're unengaging audiences as well as you should.

That this is perhaps the politically correct thing to do. It is the commercially viable. It is a smart thing to do because this is your audience. You're already in 49% born overseas, I have a parent born overseas.

One in five, live with a disability. Our argument is that this difference in diverse is the mainstream. If you need to capture the mainstream, which we know so many media outlets just really do for their sustainability, well then hey mate, how about you start reflecting and you'll have a... you'll have your finger better on the pulse.

What Australia is a feeling and thinking and wanting and veering and whatnot. I'm going to have that as a review for a near final word. Anything to say on this matter? Really?

Look, as a white male former media executive and a Brit, I'm probably not best qualified to do that. I'm probably not best qualified to be honest to have an opinion on this other than to support both of you and what you said. I agree that they need to be diversely. I do want to go back to one other thing though that came up in that survey results that you were mentioning.

Yes, the news avoidance. Yes, which is the fact that people are avoiding news. That seems very odd because all the data suggest complete opposite. So, you know, if you go and chat to all of the major news brands and we've got, you know, Tena here and you know, you can talk to news.com.au from the York Podcast the other day.

Everybody's tracking is growing so actual news consumption is rising. I think the question mark about trust is that I would ask you to come and play this game at the next dinner party you're at. Okay. I'm going to show you on their mobile phone the latest article that they read and have a look at the brand that it sits under.

Okay. And it will be under one of the no news brands that we know. If you then go and ask five other people what story they read last on Facebook and ask them where they came from, they'll have no idea. I think people's lots of trust has everything to do with the fact that they're getting a whole name sources from Facebook.

When an actual news source, when they do trust it, it comes from a brand that they know all the more reason for us to take back control of the distribution of our content. Okay. On that note, that's the penultimate note because I did want to double check in with Emily who has moved from a kraiki media role to this new ventricle ink, which is part of the kraiki family. And how's that going?

Just quickly. Right. So we launched, I think, two weeks or maybe two and a half weeks ago. Now it's just a really exciting time to be at kraiki.

We had an investment from two of our shareholders, which has funded, I think, 10 new journalists. New jobs. It's very exciting to be working at a media company that is investing in journalism and in serious journalism that really allows us time to look into things in depth. And when Ricky gives you back that $20 billion that he's going to...

Well, I appreciate that this is a conversation we can always have. But look, to be fair, I actually do. I'm completely bullish on the future of media. I think consumption's going up.

I think creation's going up. I think quality is back in the discussion and trust has been discussed for the first time in a decade. I think all of those things are terrific. Well, you've got your investors investing in your new business.

We've just invested half a million dollars of our investors' money in co-production video deals with the AFP and with press association in London and a whole host of others. I think that we are recreating what we launched because we've just realized the cost of losing the thing we valued. Out of that, you concur? Oh, yeah.

I was saying, I agree with that. I mean, you know, we're seeing CBS's bought 10 and pumped more money into digital. They've really grown an audience that, you know, we're no longer watching the show. They're no longer watching the shows that perhaps their parents and grandparents are watching.

They're not habitual television viewers for the evening news, but they're younger. They're tapping into a younger demographic that cares about the Bachelor and survivor and all of that reality television and what Kim Kardashian is doing and wearing. Similarly, they're still engaging in news and current affairs and politics. And so, you know, that's actually an exciting new audience.

All right. Well, on that, very positive note from all three of you. I'd like to thank you, Antoinette for Latour, for your wonderful insights into the show and all the best of the media, obviously. Thank you.

Emily Watkins, media reporter for Inc. Krikey. You name it. The University of Generalist, all these things.

Thanks, Emily. Thanks, Peter. And Ricky Sutton, you're going to save it at the industry. It's great.

Thanks for having you on the show. No big deal. Thanks very much. Appreciate it.

Thank you for listening to The Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SCR and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast so you can hear us talk, media, politics, and a few things in between at your leisure. And we'll be back next week with more and the meantime.

You can stay in touch with us on Twitter where our handle is Fourth Estate AU. Many thanks to my producer, Anthony Tocquell, and my name is Peter Frey, and thank you so much for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 43 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on July 11, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.