Making movies is hard. Making movies is hard. Welcome, this is the podcast about the struggle of being an independent filmmaker. I'm Mark Bissell, the founding host of the podcast, and I'm a sci-fi horror filmmaker, and my feature Red Snow, which I produced, and my feature The Alternate, which I wrote and directed, are both out on all the digital platforms. Please watch those movies. On this Thursday bonus episode, we're going to play the interview from episode 214 from June 2019, featuring the animator, pre-visual artist, and filmmaker Michael Codwood. Michael has done pre-visual work for some of the biggest Hollywood films, and his last short film, Devils, Angels, and Dating, has over 60 million hits online. Michael broke down how pre-visual is done on big features, and gave us a breakdown of his work on a famous scene, which was really cool, and he talks about us through his life as an animated short film.
including his newest movie, Wrong Rock, which had just come out at the time. I thought Michael was a good match for our episode with Lucas Colshaw from Monday because they are both old school artists and I felt like Michael's work in animation and previous was in the same realm as Lucas' storyboard work. After that, we've made another round of You're the Expert, but first, don't forget to check out our Patreon page, www.patreon.com. This is the way the show can use to thrive, to grow, to be, to exist. So thanks to everyone who supports us on Patreon. We love you. And hopefully in the near future, maybe next year, we'll have some new Patreon features that we'll be rolling out. It still tells me not to promise these things, but we are planning on it, so hopefully we get to it. Also, we have a voicemail line. Call 818-732-8057. Leave us a message. We'd love to hear from you.
you. We've had wonderful messages lately. They're really fun. I love hearing them and then reacting to them live on the show and playing them for everybody. So yeah, if you have anything to say, question to ask, something to just throw at us, an idea, you want to talk about your movie or your idea for a movie, you want to talk about your new way of making movies that's different, whatever it is, just call us and we'll play on the show. But without any more Bibble Babble, here's our Throwback Interview with Michael Cotwood.
This week, we are very excited to welcome pre-vis artist, animator, and filmmaker Michael Cawwood to the show. Welcome, Michael. Oh, thank you. Thank you very much. Did I say your last name right? No, but never mind. Well, here. I was going to call you out on that. It's fine. It's pronounced K-Wood. K-Wood. Okay, there we go. That's easier. I added a Y to that, you know. I know. A lot of people pronounce it. Spell it with a Y. I think it should be like that. It's fine.
So Michael has done previews for a ton of big time Hollywood movies that you all would have heard of, such as Fast and Furious 7, Bumblebee, Venom and DC Shazam, which I can't wait to see. I'm so excited. But more importantly, Michael has also directed a number of animated short films, one of which has a ton of views online. And what was that? It's like Angels and Devils. I'm sorry, I should have angels and dating. Yeah, I was not very good at coming up with titles at the time. Yeah, it's funny because when I went to watch it, I had realized I'd already seen it like years ago. So I was like, oh.
I remember this short film. That's amazing. Yeah. It feels like it ages. It sort of dates me a little bit because there are people now commenting on that film saying, I remember watching this when I was a kid. Oh, that's funny. Yeah. Wow. 16.3 million views. Wow. Holy moly. That's crazy. And that's just the official upload. I'm sure it's been reposted a million times elsewhere. It has been, but I've done a pretty good job of taking it down wherever possible. So that's the main one. There is a director's cut that I put on video, but that's got like barely any views in comparison to YouTube.
Wow, wow. What's barely any views? Like 60,000 or something? I haven't even checked for a while, but it's just in the thousands. Yeah, single-digit thousands. Oh, single-digit thousands, okay. I don't know. When you have 16 million, I don't know what's small to you. Small could be, like, my biggest, like, hit ever, you know? Yeah, and I still share the Vimeo version when I want to show it to someone, because I want that to be the version people see. Oh, I see. But I also secretly kind of want them to know how many views it's got on YouTube. So the director's kind of different, you know? Yeah, it's a little different. The version I put on YouTube...
Because I never did the festival run, I never really had the time to sit back, take a breather from it, and watch it with a bit of time having passed. And I fairly quickly realized that it felt rushed in places. And there were people saying they were confused. So I actually went back in. um lengthened a few of the shots in places added a few extra shots that that it was like i felt dumb not having added these shots the first time around and so i basically made what i call a director's cut and then i stuck it on vimeo about six months later um but of course didn't get anywhere near as many views as the youtube version which you can never change so of course right yeah it's not frustrating you can't uh yeah you can replace a video on vimeo but not on youtube of course yeah yeah that's still the case they haven't done that yet they haven't given that update as far as i know that's crazy YouTube, come on. It's one of the only videos. Other than that, I like YouTube a lot. The features on YouTube are generally a lot better than Vimeo, I find. It's just you can't swap it out. Right, right. I wonder what the rationale is for both.
services like why? Well, I guess the thing is you could swap it out for a video with dick pics in it if you wanted to. Oh, they don't have any ability to like monitor it or something. Yeah. OK, so before we get into all the nitty gritty of everything, Michael, give us your quick one minute bio, like you have your background and everything. Yeah, well, I mean, I started in kind of trying to be a 2D animator. I got my degree in animation as a 2D animator and graduated in 1999. But that's right after Toy Story had come out. 2D was dying and I was over in the UK. And so I kind of I decided rather than taking a 2D job as my first job, I went.
and did CG and games, which turned out to be pretty smart because I haven't stopped working in Maya ever since as a 3D guy. And long story short, I've done games, films, commercials, TV and short films, all kinds of stuff ever since then. I bounced around the world. I started in the UK, spent some time in London, Glasgow, Sheffield, Midlands, but also went down to Sydney to work on Happy Feet. Then I came over to the U.S. in 2009, started in Austin, Texas, and then went over to New York for a bit. And I've now actually been in L.A. for about six years, where I've been doing a lot of sort of mostly movie stuff and sort of sprinkling of commercials on the side. What a journey. Yeah, all over the place. And where you grew up in the U.K., and what school did you study, as you said, animation? Yeah, so I was kind of self-taught for a bit there. I went to an arts course. I really knew I wanted to do animation when I was about 14, and I started...
I put myself on that path from 14 and then went to an art course where, to be honest, most of anything I did on that course officially had next to nothing to do with animation or anything I would ever use again. But on the side, I had a really good friend who was also into animation, and the two of us just did little animated things on the side, so stop motion and CG stuff and 2D stuff and all kinds of stuff. And by the end of that two-year art course, we actually had a portfolio of animated stuff, even before starting an animated course. And then I went off, and we both went to the Glamorgan Centre for Art and Design Technology in Wales. seven animation courses in all of the UK and that was one of the better ones.
And I was there for like three years. By the time I finished that three-year course, it was like 70 courses. Now there's probably 7,000 courses. It was exploding at the time. Yeah, you got in right. I mean, yeah, as all this movement was happening. Yeah. I mean, in terms of getting into CG, it was a really good time. I mean, although I knew a bit of CG because I was self-taught a little bit during those days, I was basically a 2D guy with the ability to use a computer to support it. But then when I got my first job working at Rare doing games for, at the time, Nintendo, it was a time when they were willing to let people learn on the job how to use CG.
which of course doesn't happen now. You've got to know everything before you get in. But at the time they handed me a manual and I probably spent the first... two or three weeks just going through the manual and doing little exercises. And funnily enough, at the end of about two or three weeks, I sort of said, hey, is there anything I can actually do on the project? And they let me start. And I thought that I'd spent quite a long time learning, two or three weeks in. But the funny thing was, the guy who started before me turned around and was absolutely embarrassed because he spent about six months learning it before they actually put him on something on the project. And so for me to do it in three weeks was just like, whoa! So what was that project that you worked on at Rare? What was that first project?
Yeah, I mean, pretty lucky first start, really. I got onto what was eventually released as Star Fox Adventures for the Game Keeper. Oh, wow. Nice. Now, it started out as something for the Nintendo 64, and it wasn't a Star Fox project, but it was still going to be Rare's big Zelda-like RPG. And so I still felt pretty privileged. And more than that, when I started in games, I fully expected to be told I was going to be doing cycles, just like characters running on the spot, that kind of stuff. Oh, yeah. And I was told on day one, like I was shown some cut scenes from the game on day one in this big screening room, and they...
And I was immediately told on the spot, oh, Michael, and you're going to be doing cut scenes. And I was like, woohoo. So I was like thrown straight in the deep end of just being a filmmaker from straight away. So I was super lucky. And were you animating? Were you basically an animator? How did it work in those days at that studio?
So we would have like two screens in front of us. One of them was the game and the other one was a silicon graphics machine. And they were kind of hooked up in this sort of slow link thing where you would do animations in Maya with the characters on your silicon graphics machine. And then you would do some coding and drop them into special lists and stuff. And they would show up in the game. And then you used a special tool in the game to compile them into a sequence. So you were able to basically create the cut scene, position the cameras. And one of the things I absolutely loved was that you used the game controller to maneuver the camera. So you could literally move them.
the camera through space with the game controller, and then press a button to set a key, then move the camera again, press a button to set a key, and so on. I got so good at that that I could literally almost real-time create a camera move just with a joypad. And I sort of missed that, actually. Yeah, it's interesting. I mean, it's nice to have that tactile feedback and to feel like you're performing something live, in a way. Well, as well as that, you could have the director come over. And I got so good at it at one point that he would say, we would have a bit of discussion about what it was he wanted to achieve. And I could almost real-time produce the camera work he was looking for, just straight in front of his eyes. And I could make adjustments.
was going a bit more left, and I just suddenly, it'd be like I was flying a helicopter or something, and I actually had that real-time control of it. So cool. So yeah, I mean, I've not had that much fast feedback now. I guess the equivalent now would be using some sort of VR, AR tools and things. But I was doing that 20 years ago. It's so interesting. Yeah, right. We've gone back in some ways. And so it sounds like, in addition to animation, obviously you had to be sort of a technical director.
person, someone who's familiar or comfortable writing code to some degree, and then kind of doing layout or camera stuff as well, previs-esque work, because you're touching camera and you're working on basically an edited sequence in designing a cut scene. Is that like all these skills? You're kind of a generalist. to make that work, right? I wouldn't have called myself a generous back then, but these days I do, actually, because I do cover so many different bases now that I sort of take that box. I guess that's what's sort of, yeah, behind the question is, like, you started as a 2D guy, and I'm just sort of curious how your specialty and how you found your niche in that long journey through, across all these studios and even industries, as you said, starting from games, going to animation, into effects, et cetera. Well, I think the thing that I did a little differently to most people was that
Typically, at that time, when I was working on that project, an animator, when they ran out of work, the most common thing that they would be teaching themselves would be, say, modeling and texturing, because they were looking to be that sort of generalist character. And in the animation industry, a generalist first usually means a modeler, and then all the other stuff. But my philosophy has always been to identify the things that were needed the most on the team, the things that were most lacking, and study those things. So when I was asked if I wanted to be a modeler or a texture artist, I actually said, well, no, there's like 20 people here who can do that already. What I'm seeing is that you need help with story and storyboarding and character design. Can I do those things? And when you're in downtime, they don't really care what you do. So they were like, yeah, OK, have a go.
It's your neck in a rope sort of thing. But it worked out. And because I'd already been focused on cut scenes, it was a logical extension for me to then just study those things. I'd always been sort of self-taught, reading about screenwriting and filmmaking and things like that. And I just expanded on that in my free time.
So I'm this funny sort of weird generalist in that I haven't focused on the things that most people focus on, but it's made me more into a filmmaker. And to the point that I basically felt like an animated filmmaker, that's what I call myself, really. I think it's a more accurate description than a generalist. Because a generalist, usually you don't turn to a generalist to make a film. Right, right. Although to make a film, you know, to make an animated film, in addition to being a filmmaker...
If you're working with no budget, it's good to be a generalist. And that's the other thing. I mean, again, you get to that point where, OK, the thing that no one can do or no one wants to do is the thing I have to learn. So over time, I learned all the other stuff, too. I taught myself how to be a character rigger. And I know just about enough about modeling and texturing in order to get by if I needed to. That's really smart, though, overall, just as a sort of strategy to identify the thing that is needed instead of, I mean, to some degree.
Obviously, you know, you've got to be passionate and interested. But there's a lot of modelers out there, as you say. And there's actually a lot of animators out there. I sort of feel like that's how I kind of got into layout, you know, or had a chance to get to work in animation is because, you know, comparatively, layout is, you know, sort of like the ugly stepchild that no one... Yeah, it's a bit of an unsung hero. Yeah, there's just far fewer, you know, layout artists out there or people training for that position.
Yeah, it's one of those things. There's a lot of people still looking down their nose from an animator's perspective at that position. And yet now that I've done it for a while, layout and previs, I feel like they're far more creative. And I've definitely enjoyed the breadth of the work that's associated with working in previs and layout. And it just happens that I can also be an animator if I need to, because that's where I started. Right. And so a lot of the work that you...
Like, for example, on Happy Feet, were you in Layout? No, but I wish I was. That was one of those ones where it was my first break working in an actual feature film. And really, they were just bringing on more bums in seats in order to do a lot of the stuff that nobody else wanted to do. I thought it was going to be an animator position, and I was hired as an animator, but they called it technical animator, which at the time I didn't understand basically meant all the stuff that none of the animators wanted to do. Is it fixes? Yes. I did a little bit of performance animation, but very little of it made it to the screen. If you were to ask me what was the one thing I could tell you I did on Happy Feet, it was the wobbling antenna at the end of the movie. But it was lots of little things like wing fixes, foot fixes, and paths of characters, and crowd shots, and all that kind of stuff. So you did some background.
character work to some you know a little bit but nothing really that you would point out and put in your reel I said we didn't walk away I mean I put some tests in my reel but really it was just to say I worked on the movie right So for us, for those of us who don't know what a fix is, can you just describe that? Because I know you guys are both in the animation world, but you know, for me and other people... Of course, yeah. So a typical fix on Happy Feet was, they had this epic pipeline where you could drop your mouse on a pixel on a render, and it would tell you exactly which penguin that was. You could then go into the software, bring in that penguin, and...
make an adjustment. So a fix might be that there's 100 penguins next to each other, but if you look really closely, two of them, their wings are passing through each other on one frame. And so you would have to go and grab one of them, move its wing in a plausible way that still works and so it doesn't pass through the other guy. But then there's a lot of other small stuff that it's not just little fixes so much as it's stuff that other animators with less time than you, and that cost a lot more, don't want to do. So I actually had there was a guy next to me who...
Poor soul. He's a friend of mine. I won't name him. But at one point, his job was to animate the characters that are off screen, casting shadows onto the ground in the frame so that that looks great. And then there was another time when it was his job to animate the characters in the handle frames just so that the motion blur would be correct or just in case the editor changed the shot and used it. So he knew his work wasn't going to be seen, but it kind of was needed. That's how far down the scale you go. And it's at that point that I realized after about...
Seven years into my career where I'd already been the lead animator in the games industry, it's like, whoa, relative to film, I'm a nobody. Well, you kind of have to start over, you know, so many times. I mean, it seems like having jumped from studio to studio, I mean, hopefully there's a certain amount of seniority or, you know, experience accumulated that makes a difference. But to some degree also, it's just like, yeah, hitting the reset button. Oh, and I've done that many times. Right. And I've gotten used to it. What I tend to do is I've started in one industry, and I've hit the ceiling on that one. And then I sidestep to another industry, but usually you have to take a demotion to start again in that industry. But then what I noticed was that I climb up in that industry faster because of what I already know. Right. And then I sidestep again and again and again until I get closer to what I really want to be doing. Yeah. So I mean, basically, I'm an animated filmer, and I love doing animated feature films or whatever variation thereof that could be in my future.
And that's the thing that you've been sidestepping towards this whole time, is basically directing, filmmaking, targeting, as you say, animated features. That's the goal. Yeah. And the funny thing is, I do love live action. And I watch more and more these days, and less and less actual animation. So sometimes I wonder, oh, I wonder if I could do live action and find some use for my skills overlapping in that. But it's daunting. The things you guys already know that I need to know in order to make a solid stab at.
live action is scary to me because I kind of already know what I've learned to do what I do in animation and so I feel like whoa that's a huge scary step right right I am very familiar with that the place that you are although I'll just say that I feel like that you know that there's so much overlap and there's so much that you have you know built up skills that are incredibly useful, regardless of the medium, whether it's live action or animation. Everything that you obviously know in the animation world gives you a leg up when it comes to visual effects, of course. And visual effects, filmmakers who are comfortable with those tools, I think, have a leg up over filmmakers who don't have that in their vocabulary. So you kind of just have this technical background that you could absolutely leverage in pursuing a career in live action. Kind of as you said, you'd sidestep, you'd have some learning to do, but you would pick it up fast and you have actually so much filmmaking.
expertise that you've accumulated in animation that would serve you really well, I think. Although one of the funny things is, if I were to do live action, my instinct is to include something animated to benefit from that experience. But what people don't really realize when you're, and you know this very well, Colin, that When you're doing live action and animation combined, you're kind of doing three jobs. You're doing the live action work, you're doing the animated work, and then you're doing this completely uncredited and unseen thing where you're trying to figure out how to make the animation fit in the live action and all the problems that there are associated with that. Matching and tracking the plates and all that kind of stuff. It's almost like three times the work, and yet most people are looking at it thinking it's only one job.
I've been doing a little bit of that here and there. I wouldn't say that I do a ton of it, but I've done some post-vis work, and I'm working in a company right now that's doing that. I was the post-vis supervisor on Bumblebee, so there was a bunch of that kind of stuff to do in there. And it's just kind of a thankless task, tracking and making everything fit in a shot, and sometimes something just doesn't work, and you have to figure out exactly why it doesn't sit there. That is a huge part of the process that I feel like, similar to layout, it's kind of under the radar.
the post-vis. So before we get into post-vis, I want to I want to hear more about like you going from animation or, you know, doing happy feet and this video game stuff into working on previs for for live action movies. So what is like what led you to that? And then, like, what are the difference between those two roles? To be honest, Previz is something I've essentially been doing for 20 years. That stuff I was doing in games was so similar to what I'm still doing when I do Previz today. The only real difference is that they call it Previz when it's intended for a live action feature film or something like that. And so it's funny. People look at my career and think, oh, I've only been doing Previz for about six years. But in reality, I've been doing it for about 20. But what really made me focus in on Previz at one point was
I was working on Skylanders Giants over in New York, and I was actually an animation supervisor, director kind of thing on that. But when we were recruiting for people to work on that project, I think we pulled in 60 to 100 people from various different sources. But what was really, really hard was finding people who knew what to do with the camera and how to lay out shots. And out of that 60 to 100 people, we only had three or four that could do camera work well. And they hired...
a previous house from LA to come out on and sort of subsidize what we were doing and and fill it out and at some point I realized I was one of these very few people who could do a really good job of it and so when I came over to LA it was just something I thought well let me try sidestepping again and see if I can get into previous when I came over to LA and it turned out to be a really smart choice and I was embraced by what is the previous industry over in LA and I've bounced around a few of the different previous houses but what was so good about it was that I came in at a high level All of a sudden, I'm a really good previs guy and they put me on lots of major movies. And suddenly my credits went from things, you know, games and more obscure projects to some of the biggest projects going on in the world. So suddenly my credits look amazing in just the last six years. But I'm really doing the same kind of work. It hasn't changed all that much. It's just, you know, that was what was needed. And I recognize that, you know, my skills were needed in that area. So I've mostly done that. So break down one of the movies you worked on and like talk to us about what.
what did you do as a previous artist and what scenes or scene or scenes you worked on? And I mean, I've seen almost all the movies that you've worked on, I think. But I don't know. I mean, maybe Venom or the Fast and Furious movie or Star Trek. One of those maybe. I don't know if there's a good story there. Yeah, I think it's not even my favorite movie, but I think the one I always come back to is Fast and Furious. Because I started, I think my first really big one was Dawn of the Plants of the Apes. And I had, there was an excellent pipeline there and I was handed what I needed to do on that. But when I started on Fast and the Furious, the reins were released a little better and I was given a lot more creative freedom. And, you know, I would talk.
it over with the supervisor who would bring out the little toy cars and say, this is what I need the cars to do, and you can figure out the rest. And I got a whole sequence. It wasn't just a shot. It was a whole sequence. And I would be given an undefined period of time that was just sort of, maybe it was going to be a few weeks or something, and you would just kind of start figuring it out. And I would animate the cars. I would be given...
a 3D set by the modelers and the cars and the characters. And I would essentially animate out a rough version of how those cars move through space and where the characters come in and roughly what timing. And then I would start putting down cameras, like the hero cameras, the ones that you think are going to really define the sequence. And you start timing it out and you shoot out little videos of that. And this was the first time I was really encouraged to do coverage. And we even had these rigs where literally you imported in this custom rig that had about 20 cameras on it and just constrained it to all the cars.
The idea being that each of those cameras covered a particular angle. So that's where all those little cameras attached to the wheel, the trunk, the steering wheel, all those kind that come in, they were just already there. And you could just move them around a little bit relative to that position, but they were constrained to the car. Then I would throw in all the cameras that I think I want to do for the external angles, the fake helicopter shots, the pedestrian on the street, someone looking through a window. And then I would make videos for as long a video as it was useful. So, for example, I would put down a camera and then I would say, I think I want that camera to go from frame 100 to 2000 and just make a video of that.
most of that's useless. You'd then fill a folder with those shots. then open up Premiere, start to bring them in and construct the sequence and basically be an editor for that sequence and make something that essentially works. Now, ironically, the editors still want to have those shots with all the extra frames so that they can make their own decisions about what they want. But I have to make at least one functioning, working version of the scene that I can give to them. And basically, I just evolved from there. And I think one of my favorite sequences was the one in Fast and Furious 7 where the two Dubai towers and the car jumps between the towers. So I constructed pretty much all of that and figured out how all of that was going to work.
the work um and and then what was amazing about that was when the super bowl came around um they were showing a trailer for the film and i'm sitting down with friends and i said oh that's my shot oh that's my shot too oh shit that's my shot too and it's like the whole trailer was like all my shots wow so that's amazing you know the that you know hero shot where the the car is is in slow motion kind of in between those towers yes that that's that was on your desk you yeah you previous that Yes. So did you also previs the stuff that's happening inside the tower that leads up to the car going out? So you do that whole part. Basically, I mean, from the car starting, you know, from the character getting the car, starting it up and then racing off all the way through crashing and the characters falling out of the car at the other end. Because what the thing is, that's amazing. We were previsiting what the characters would do, too, because they have to figure out what the stunts are going to be and where they need to set up those cameras to get those internal shots of, you know, character reactions while the thing's happening. In fact, on Fast and Furious, there's a lot of stock photo material.
where it should be stopped, but it never is. You have to keep creating it. But it's like the same foot on the accelerator, hand shifting a gear and steering wheel. And then there's other shots that are very common in Fast and Furious too, like the guy holding the bazooka three quarters to camera. After a while, once you've done a Fast and Furious movie, you feel like you've done the same shots a hundred times. So when they came to you with the sequence, what do they bring to you? Do they have storyboards of the whole thing of how they want it to look? Like how much information are you given before you create the previous sequence? Those buildings and how far apart they are, for example.
Was that kind of figured out as well, before I hit you, your desk? MARK MANDELSKI- Well, the set is pretty straightforward. It's the modeler's task to go ahead and make it accurate to the real world. Now, sometimes we might start something that doesn't have to be too accurate to the real world, and we'll just fake it and make it look good. But sometimes they do need it to be accurate to the real world. And someone goes ahead, and they're looking at Google Earth, and they've got various charts in front of them showing them all the measurements. So someone else would usually have figured that part out before I get my hands on it.
right um but what was the other question again you were saying about a script or other storyboards yeah well if i'm lucky um i'm given a screenplay when i first join a project and i get to read it and understand what it's about um it depends on the nature of the project fast and furious uh is so much about the action it almost doesn't matter if you read the script um but there are other movies where i would definitely read the script first i did on dawn the plant the apes and the mummy and things like that um and then in terms of the sequences and the storyboards Sometimes you get given storyboards and sometimes you don't. And what I just found is that in the early stages, yes, if you're the new guy, then more often they're not going to give you a sequence that's already been boarded. And you start out by reproducing the boards. Because generally the boards have been approved by the director, so you want to give him a version that he's approved before you then go off and do other creative stuff.
But as you go along and you become the senior guy, you get ahead of the curve a bit. And more often than not, I would find myself working without a storyboard. And so you're just told what happens and you have to make it. And you just start plugging gaps in the movie with very little information other than this is what is happening beforehand. This is what is happening afterwards. And you have to make something cool in between.
Which is exactly what happened when I was doing cut scenes for games. Literally there, they would just say, okay, we need to tell the player they're picking up this bauble and taking it to this character. You figure out what happens in between. Wow. So you'd be writing the story of the game in the cut sequence, basically? Well, actually, on the first one, I was handed scripts and dialogue. But as I went along, I was influencing the story more and more and more. And the thing was to try and make it a bit more interesting. So, yes, sometimes you would be...
You'd have a set and you knew you were entering through this door over here and exiting through that door over there or pointing in this direction anyway. And you would try and find the most interesting and condensed way to get from A to B. I would frequently just take the dialogue, lay it down in the tightest version that sounded natural, and then try and figure out what visuals went with that in order to make it work. But yeah. When it came to the movies, you are kind of trying to find something really cool to do with the pieces that you've given, basically. Wow. So for Fast and the Furious, did they give you storyboards, or was that one that you had to, like, just figure out on your own? Again, it was a mix. I can remember sequences where I had boards. Oh, okay. That sequence I just described was, like I said, was pretty creative, and I don't think I had any boards. Wow. Amazing. I'm sure somebody listening out there will tell me differently, but it will be like, you had boards, damn it. We worked on that for six months. That was definitely one where most of the creativity came purely out of working in 3D, but there were other sequences where there's a chase going down an extremely steep hill at about 45 degrees or something, and I know that that one was bored.
quite heavily and so you try to reproduce those boarded shots but the thing is and I've done enough storyboarding as well to know that you can kind of cheat like crazy for the storyboards and then when you've really got the set in front of you and you're really working with the timings you can't always stick to the boards exactly you've got to sort of take the spirit of them and capture it in a way that you hope the director feels like is the same thing this is where you get into this weird spiral though because sometimes they will just say oh actually I was in the office just the other day and this applies to animation and all kinds of different things too but what happens is An animator gets a brief and they see certain problems with the brief. They solve those problems and present back to the client the version they feel like captures the spirit of it, but basically solves those problems. Client then comes back and says, I'd like it to be more like the brief. Right. So you go and reproduce the problems that were in the original brief. Client then sees the problems and tells you in a micromanaging way, one step at a time, how to solve those problems until you get back to the first version that you gave the client in the first place. That's funny. That is a cycle we all play out.
on everything that we do all the time. And pre-vis is no exception. And so the funny thing is, the more information they give you, like a storyboard, the more you sort of realize, okay, I have to give them what they think they want for the first pass. And then... Maybe if you've got a free time, if you've managed to achieve what they want in a couple of days, but they haven't asked to see it until the end of the week, you then go off and create some other stuff, and you give them that too. But the supervisor usually prioritizes what the director asks for first from the boards in order to make sure that they saw that. And then you can show them the other fun stuff, and they go, oh, that looks cool, and I'll have that, and so on. But it is sometimes a bit of presumptuous, maybe, on our part, that we sort of go, well, that's not working, so I'm going to do this, and I won't even show them what they asked for. But that gets you into trouble. More often than not, they ask to see that first version if it was boarded.
one last question about the previous stuff so when you're doing like the sequence uh the divide tower jump in fast and furious how much are you working with the director is like justin lynn there like looking at all your cuts with you are you just sending them off and he's reviewing them like how does that work i wish that had been the case um on that particular movie no i never met the director um there were other movies where i did um and it's highly variable i think As a rule of thumb in previs, the supervisor would hope to actually meet with the director and get more immediate feedback. And the artist doesn't necessarily get to meet the director. But it does vary a bit. On the mummy, I was the supervisor. And so, yes, I was working directly with the director. But what we managed to do was get these.
feature animation like review sessions going where we poured all 20 previous artists into a small room we invited the director and the visual effects supervisor and producer in and we sat there and they would critique on a big screen in front of us everything that they saw with the animators sitting just behind them which was fantastic sometimes we all we'll on certain projects like on one i was doing a few months ago where we will record that what the director is saying so that the artist hears it kind of firsthand but the problem with that they can't ask a question So if the artist can be there with the director, that's ideal. But to be honest, there's so much going on with the director, it's pretty rare that he actually gets to speak to an artist one-on-one. So no, Fast and Furious, I didn't speak to the director. And what you would do is you would send off a version, give a load of material to an editor. Maybe you'd move on to another sequence for a while. And then they would start sending you back notes and new ideas and things like that. And maybe the story would have changed during the time you were doing it. So actually, one of the things I've found in previs is that you actually don't want to get into a scenario where you're animating it and noodling it and making it pretty. Because the more time that you have to make it pretty, the longer it is that the director...
is getting to see that thing. And the less like his original idea it is, and he may have come up with new ideas. So I always get a bit paranoid if I'm working in previs and I'm starting to make pretty animation because I kind of know that he's not seen it and that there's not a tight enough communication loop. So if you manage to stay rough, it's a good thing in previs. Yeah, that's kind of amazing. I mean, it sounds like you end up having a pretty big creative impact on the film or a sequence in the film in certain times. In certain times, maybe you don't have as much, but it's pretty amazing how much influence a previs artist has because I always just assumed you don't always get storyboards and you'd be just like...
you know, executing boards, basically, as a previous artist. I think that is the story most people tell you, you know, and it's just that there's so many changes going on so fast that you get to a point where you are typically quite creative. It is a funny thing, though. I've definitely played this game with the storyboard department of, like, how much creativity you have and who comes in and does their thing first. I think I learned the most when I was supervising on The Mummy because we were all in the same building and we had multiple different teams, each sort of...
kind of acting like different companies or different departments with different amounts of influence over the end project but a sequence idea might come down and you would hope that it hit the storyboard artists first they do a few ideas very quickly because storyboards for sure you can do faster than previous and at least especially for the character material. Maybe not for, say, cars and spaceships and stuff like that. But you would hope that it hit the storyboard team first. They got a few rough ideas out. The director saw them, approved them, passed them on to us, and then we would expand upon that. That's the hope. But actually, in a lot of cases, it would arrive, come down the pipeline, and hit our team at exactly the same time as the storyboard team. In fact, the storyboard team was a lot smaller than the previous team, so sometimes we had capacity at previs to start before storyboards did.
And at that time, I would sometimes run down the corridor and talk to the storyboard artists and say, hey, I found ourselves doing this particular sequence. Have you already started on it? Are you doing it at the same time? Is there something that we can do to collaborate in order to make this go a little bit smoother and not double up? Because the last thing I want to do is have two people who are not talking to each other, trying to do something completely creative. Right, right.
and wasting time when there's other things we could be doing. And unfortunately, it did happen many times. And I'm sure it does happen on lots of productions, and most people just don't see it, because the communication isn't tight enough. So a lot of this is just trying to figure out how to get that communication to work quickly. And more often than not, as a supervisor, you're just trying to bridge those gaps as quickly as you can, and making sure everybody knows what's going on. MARK MANDELAVANIUSSKI- By the way, don't we feel like it would be really nice as an evolution of this process in the medium, to some degree, to be able to more fluidly combine storyboards and previs, to be able to use previs or 3D as
as necessary, basically, as you were saying, like a car chase. You're not going to want to board that. You've got to get in there in 3D and figure out how this works. But then, when you have an exchange between characters and you want the expressivity and it's like medium close-ups, it's obvious what the shot is. And you want to just execute fast to be able to fluidly jump in and draw, either on top of 3D or, I don't know, but a sort of medium agnostic approach that's fluid and less rigid pipeline-wise. I've been personally searching for a better solution to that. I'm just curious. Me too. And it's something that I've been trying to envisage for ages. I have friends who are kind of doing it. There's one particularly famous one, Frederico Alessandro, who actually did work on The Mummy. I might just say that, by the way, when I came onto The Mummy, they showed me some of his work to begin with, and my jaw just dropped.
And I thought, why do you need me? But him and another friend of mine, Monty Granito, he's doing some incredible stuff too, where they mix storyboard drawn material. over the 3D material. But I will say it's not necessarily quick. It is amazing to look at. Afterwards you think, wow, why don't we do more of this kind of stuff? But it's like that other thing of mixing CG with live action. There's that middle step that just slows you down and they are still doing that to some degree. I did a project end of last year where I was the only previous artist on it.
It was an animated feature. And although I was hired to be the previous guy, it actually made sense for the characters to be 2D storyboards to match with all of the other storyboard artists. And I relish the opportunity to jump in and actually draw the characters rather than have a rig another character and do it the normal previous way. But the amount of time I spent just trying to get that 2D to sit well in the 3D environment, it was just really time consuming. And you kind of realize why it hasn't happened yet, this sort of blend. But if somebody were to come up with a tool that would allow me to just jump into a 3D environment and draw a lot more, I would do it. I know that there's things like grease pencil and things like that, and I've dabbled a little bit in it. I'm watching Frederico's reel right now. Oh, have you never seen it before? No. Oh, my God. Yeah, I just looked him up. He's like, did the storyboards for Captain Marvel. And he's just got a feature that he directed that just either came out or is about to come out. This guy's killing it. Yeah, you've not seen that stuff before?
It's incredible. I think I've seen some stuff on special features but didn't realize because there's a lot of stuff I'm familiar with or sequences from all sorts of movies that I think I've seen special features for. So he's worked on everything. Yeah. And I crossed paths very briefly and chatted with him and sort of bowed at the altar of Frederico when I met him for The Mummy. But I'd been seeing his work for some time and it's kind of incredible. But it is taxing. He's got to be doing things in 3D and as well as it's almost 2D animation because he's drawing way more material than a normal storyboard artist would need to do. Right.
Right. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And I want to have a go at doing that myself. And in the back of my mind, I've got this little project I want to do as my next thing. But having just had a child, my next project is going to keep me busy for the next 18 years. Right.
Amazing. So on that note, unless, Colin, do you have any other questions about Previz or anything? I think we should talk about the filmmaking because I was looking at your IMDb and I saw that you've got your first short film that you directed in 1999, then your next one in 2012, which we talked about already, and then your new one that's about to come out, 2018. So that's like what? Like 13 years in between the first two and then six between the other two. It's funny. It takes a long time. It's actually nothing because I haven't even included my first films in there at all. Oh, really? Wow. Yeah, IMDb I don't think was even around when I was making my first films. I was doing stuff in DOS.
25 years ago with a friend of mine with really crude software. And I've got this whole other website filled with things that most people would never watch today because they just look way too crude. And the resolution on them were like 320 by 240 or something like that. So they were pretty awful. But yeah, there was a gap there. I did all my student films. And then when I got my first proper job, I thought, oh, I'm never going to have to do these projects on the side anymore. My day job is going to do everything for me. And I was under that delusion for a while until I eventually came to the conclusion that, OK, your day job is never going to quite give you everything you want to do.
So it's smart to go back into making material on the side. And so, yes, I became another habitual filmmaker on the side. And Devil's Angels and Dating was my first big stab into doing that after quite a long break there. But then, yeah, my new film is The Wrong Rock. It's not out yet, but it will be this year most likely. It's in the festival circuit at the moment. It's in about seven festivals right now. But we're slowly but surely applying to all the Oscar qualifying festivals. And, you know, I assume it's...
it's kind of off to a good start. But it's one of the, I mean, that painful period right now where you, I want to show everyone this film, but I have to sit on it and wait. Right. Because, yeah, typically, I mean, you're going to wait the full year before putting it online. When did you start submitting out of curiosity? I think November-ish, somewhere around there. I mean, we were basically, we got to a point where the film was completely watchable. I think the last time you saw it, Colin, it was like probably 90% there or something like that. And you gave me a few ideas on how to improve a few things here and there. But then we got to a point where I'd solved those things. And it was, we had a first pass render for everything, but we might not have done all the effects yet. Or there were fixes we wanted to do. And so we started submitting, kind of knowing that the film, to the average Joe, looked finished. Right.
The first few festivals that got the film were definitely not the best version of the film. But we were like, let's make a start. And funnily enough, what we also learned at the time was that we were, in a way, wasting our time because we were applying to late deadlines with a long film that was slightly unfinished. And we've learned that if you've got a long film, you really have to hit the early deadlines. Basically, the festivals prefer to schedule those long films early on, and then they're just looking for shorter and shorter films to fill their slots. And so, yeah, what's the runtime on this? Is it 15 or so? It's 13 or 14 minutes. Basically, the final version will be 14 minutes. That's the one that we'll put online eventually. But for the festival circuit, I cut the credits in half in order to make it that one minute shorter and save yourself a bit of screen time. And what I did there was I sped up the credits and I dropped some of the lower priority categories and I chopped the song in half.
Oh, yeah. Yeah, I mean, because on the festival version, what's the length of the credits? Is it like a minute or 30 seconds? Yeah, it's a minute. And the final version will be like two minutes.
I feel like a minute is even long for a film festival, you know, because that was something I learned on my first film festival I ever got into. Like I had like two minute long credits and I was in an audience with people watching it and I just see everyone rolling their eyes. And then like the next movie after mine is like, you know, 30 seconds or less for the credits. And I'm like, oh my God, like that's what it needs to be to keep the show going, you know? And so I went back after that festival and then recut the movie to cut off the credits, you know? Just because for a short film in a festival, it's just like, that's what you need to do. But I know it's hard for like a movie like yours where you have so many artists working on it. Like you got to represent everybody, you know? And we didn't just run like white on black.
credit scrolling up the screen that we had a very pretty looking credit sequence with a great song over the top. So I couldn't bring myself to butcher it like that, but maybe, maybe I should have, but it will only have saved me 30 seconds on an already long film. So I know we were diving in maybe to the wrong, you know, to the wrong thing, but like, tell me about the song. Did you commission this or is this something that you licensed for? We licensed it. So yeah, when I was doing Devil's Angels in Dating, I actually wanted it to be a musical. So I spent a year working with somebody down in Texas who I built a good relationship with, who we were trying to put in, layer in songs. What I wanted it to be was the character's thoughts sung out loud. But what I found was that the music world is so different that there was a lot of learning for me to do. And even the music and the writing of the songs couldn't keep up with the animation, and the animation was slow. And we were doing all of this with zero budget.
So eventually I decided, even after doing some tests, I've got a little piece of Devil's Angels in Dating where the character sings. We went to a recording studio to do it. And even after doing all of that, I eventually had to call it and say, you know what, I've got enough momentum on the production side of things to get this film finished by a certain date. I'm just going to do it without the music and make it a traditional non-musical piece. And so the film went through, but I'd already made these relationships in the music world. And when we came around to doing, well, let me finish that story actually. We did end up doing a song with somebody else for Devil's Angels in Dating.
for the credits, which just was a bonus, worked out really nicely for that. And so many people loved the song in that film that I worked with the composer at the time to loop the themes of that song back into the score. And then what was interesting was that when the film was released and people watched the film, the film introduces you to those themes. And then by the time you hear it in the song at the end of the credits, everyone's like, oh, wow, I love this song. Where can I buy this song? And what they don't realize is that they've heard the theme two or three times already. They've just sort of been warmed up to it. And they give the credit to all the song.
but actually the score laid in those things first. And so that technique worked so well and gave people a feel-good factor for the film that I decided I definitely want to do that again for my new film. And I told the composer that that's what I planned to do, and he was up for it. So I went back to the very same people I'd tried to work with on Devils, and she'd actually formed a band called The Misses with some other people, and they were getting quite successful to the point that I was actually thinking, wow, they're going to be too big now. There's no way that they're going to work with me now, but let's have a go. Because at least I had that relationship with her.
So this was Larissa Ness, who's one of the band members on The Misses. And so I reached out to her and she spoke to the band, the person who owned the band. And it just turned out that they had a lot of interesting themes in the kind of work that they were doing. They were working with a charity and it connected to the kind of things we were doing in the film. And it was just a perfect fit. And they said they wanted to do it and that they would make it one of their next songs for their album. Fantastic. And so we gave them...
the tagline of what we wanted to be said and give them a sense of the kind of songs that we liked and we thought would be a good fit. And they went off and just produced that. What was incredible is, and I know the audience probably hasn't heard the song at this point, but it's really good. It's really great. Yeah, it's really good. And we were stunned. We were blown away because we sent off this thing. We didn't hear much from them for a while. I just assumed we were going to get a few tinkles back on the piano and a bit of us, an amateur sort of song version, emailed back to me as an MP3 at some point that I could give feedback on. But they sent back the whole thing completely finished. It had already gone through the studio. It had already been made really high professional quality version of it. And it was lucky that it was just amazing. But what I didn't, I mean, we always said it was just supposed
run over the credits. But I got that song and there's a certain way that that song ramps up for the first 30 seconds or so that I realized, oh wow, that could actually start during the final scene of the film. And so I layered it over and I was practically crying as it was just so perfect. So the song starts in the film during one of the most important parts of the character's journey and then just carries on through the credits and it feels great. Yeah. That's fascinating. I love to hear the backstory on that. That's really...
Yeah. I mean, it felt perfect at the end of the film, you know, and so it makes sense that you did it that way. Well, it doesn't, because how could it possibly, how could we have gotten that lucky? Because I didn't plan it to be like that necessarily. That's just the song fit like that. They may have had a whole different intro and it would have just been a credit song.
But the way that they chose to do it, it worked really well. So anyway, to carry on with that, we then, because we'd always said from day one, we wanted to take their themes and put it into the score. And we told them about the band about that, and they were OK with that. And so I then went back to my composer who I was working with. So that's Grant Kirkhope, who actually, funnily enough, used to work at Rare at the same time I was working there. And now he's living in LA. So that was an amazing coincidence that we managed to figure all of that out. But I handed him the song. He was blown away with it too. But then he started working elements of that back into his theme.
Yeah, the score is great as well. I know. He's amazing. I think one of the big things about him is not just the quality of the work he did, but the attitude he has to it all. I didn't pay him a dime. And he was just squeezing that in between other big projects. And he's got much bigger things to work on and huge credits and a huge following. The fact that he would spend his time working with us was just a huge honor. But he had a wonderful attitude as he was working on stuff. And he was completely open to taking somebody else's creative stuff and weaving it into his stuff.
So again, you've got that sort of sense of like a hint of the theme being dropped in during the score, which you then hear in its sort of ultimate version in the credits, which makes you feel good as you get to it. Right. Yeah, super effective. So we should probably zoom out a bit. Yeah, exactly. Sorry, we get into the macro so easily. All right, I'll let you take the lead, though.
Well, I mean, my main question that I have is, you know, like what what drives you to make these these short films? Because if they take so long to put together and so long to make and so many artists to do, it's like, you know, for for a live action filmmaker, it might be like two to three years or in some cases like five years is a really long time to be working on like a live action short. But like all your your projects have taken longer than that. So, yeah, like what's the genesis behind like the wrong rock and what's you know, what's what's your process like in getting this thing started? Probably insanity. I don't know. I don't know that. It's hard to explain. I think it's just in my blood to some degree that I have to do it. Like I said, there was a period where I stopped doing all these short films as a student and I got my first job and I stopped to do my day job.
I was hoping that the day job would be enough. And I became pretty unhappy for the first decade because I wasn't hitting all those creative cues I wanted to do. And so when I started doing Devil's Angels and dating, I think if nothing else, if nothing else came of it, what was most important to me was actually that I was becoming an animated filmmaker again. And I was doing things that I wanted to be doing that I may not be able to get in my day job. And so as I went along and I was doing other projects, I would frequently, my side project would be based almost as a compliment to whatever it was I was doing in my day job. So when I started doing The Wrong Rock, it was actually as a compliment to what I was doing at DreamWorks at the time. I was doing like almost a dream project at DreamWorks, quite honestly. The kind of characters and story and humor that we were doing there was so incredible. It was just like, well...
But I still felt a little bit like a cog in the machine and I needed a little pet project to do on the side. But what could I do that was going to complement that? And in some ways it freed me up because I was doing these cute, wonderful characters for my day job for the first time in a long time. And so I felt like, well, that means I now don't feel the need to have to do cute. cartoony biped characters for my pet project. And so I suppose logically I should have done something live action at that point. But I had this little idea for a character on a rock and I had a really good story that came out of my own experiences. And it was a message I really wanted to get out into the world. And so I just sort of went, you know what, I don't need it to be full on cartoony characters, but let's see what they could be. And I started that story. Basically, the core of that story is it's about a character who grows up in a rock and there's another rock across the sea.
where those characters are more like what he wants to be. And the rock he grew up on kind of rejects him, who he is. And he has to figure out how to get to the other rock. And that is a pretty, that's like a metaphor for a lot of things that everybody have in their lives. I mean, we looked at this as a metaphor for it could be racism, it could be sexism, ageism. Or in my case, it was just because I literally grew up in a country, one particular country, and wanted access to the opportunities that were happening in another country. You're on the wrong rock.
Exactly. That's funny. But I felt many of this, this is why when I watch a story about racism or something like that, it always triggers me a lot. Like I get really angry sometimes when I'm watching a very effective story about racism or sex or something like that. And I realize it's because it's tapping into similar themes that I've gone through myself.
And that's where it all started. And I was trying to figure out what's the easiest way for me to make a story about this. And it started with, well, maybe I can just have a pebble on a rock that wants to get to this other set of pebbles on another rock. But then I was like, well, it's very hard to make a pebble emote and show emotion. So I just slightly upgraded the pebble to a mushroom, which was just enough movement to keep things simple, but without going as far as turning it into a full character. Yes, audience, The Wrong Rock is a story about a bunch of mushrooms.
Yes, that's right. Basically. Yeah, which in some ways is a hard sell, but at the time it made sense because it was supposed to be just the smallest project I could make for myself on the side. Because you don't really want these projects to turn into huge epics. Right, even what they typically do somehow. Yeah, that's right. And just like you guys, I end up falling down the trap and turning it into an epic. But in some ways it was a good thing because we made twice as much footage as I did for Devil's Angels and Dating in only two years on the side of other projects and things. It really was a two-year project only. I don't know why I think that's such a short period of time.
But that's not long for a project to this scope. Right. Yeah. You know, independently and to be produced at this level. You know, visually, it's very polished. So when did you start on The Wrong Rock? Literally when I was finishing at DreamWorks. So end of 2016, I want to say. OK, so it's not like you were working on it when you finished Devil's Angels and Dating. It was, you know, there was a break. Yeah. And funnily enough, Devil's Angels and Dating took about five and a half years. And I made promises to other people at that time that.
I wouldn't do anything like this again for at least a decade. I slightly broke that promise. And, you know, I did other little things for myself, but there was that little niggling thing in the back of my mind feeling like I was kind of slightly incomplete, but if I'm not doing something like that. And so although I'd severely upgraded my opportunities in my day job and I was doing all these big movies in Hollywood and everything, I still kind of wanted that something small I could just have for myself and do on the side. And that's where The Wrong Rock started for. And it was I wrote the story.
The funny thing was I still it was meant to be really just one or two minutes. But in order to really sell the story in an impactful way, I still expanded and expanded to the point. It's like, oh, this is going to be longer than you really want it to be. And so at some point I thought, well, one of the things I did on Devils was I attracted volunteers from all around the world and we all collaborated online. And it was one of the earliest, most successful versions of that. So I thought, well, I can at least leverage that experience and do the same thing again on the wrong rock. And so again.
I jumped onto a platform that's called Artella. There's a few platforms out there now with similar themes where they bring together people online in order to create something animated. But that was the one that was the most publicly available at the time. And over time, we probably attracted about 100 people. I actually haven't counted properly, but my guess is the credits is probably about 100 in the full version. And just did a similar sort of thing. It's mainly sort of you put it out there and you just see who's interested in doing certain things on it. And then I can just focus my time on the things that I can't recruit for. Right. So same principle. So Ortella is sort of a crowd sourcing platform. I mean, like you actually can find people using that platform. And not only that, the platform itself is a way to organize that work.
It is, yes. I mean, it's in beta, so it wasn't 100% polished at the time that I started on it, but it was improving as we went along. I think one of the biggest things, though, that you get out of it was just that it had become, already at that stage, a place where people knew to go to get involved in animated projects. When I did Devils, there really was nothing. There were some forums where you could post, but even they were dying out. And the consensus back then was that don't bother starting these projects. They never work out. You waste your time. That's what people were telling me. And yet, funnily enough, I succeeded in doing it. So when I joined up on Artella, it had...
There was enough people out there that realized that it can be done that it was quite popular. I don't know how many projects were on. There was probably already 100 projects on there at the time, which means that there's quite a body of artists. And so I posted my project, said what I'd done before, and then posted what positions I was interested in. And for the most part, people just found me through Artella. So I didn't have to spend a lot of time running around all the forums saying, I'm looking for this, I'm looking for that, which is what I had to do first time around. And what kinds of artists were you looking for particularly? Was it shading or animators or riggers?
Kind of everything, but I knew that there were certain things I wanted to do more of myself, but you can't really do that, unfortunately. If you actually want to get something finished, you have to accept what people are willing to work on and then do the stuff that no one wants to do yourself. Right. So in the end, I didn't animate on the wrong rock. That's the insanity of it. I started as an animator and I'm making a film where I barely did any animation. I mean, sure, I cleaned up other people's scenes. Like if somebody was not quite up to standards, I would pick up some of those scenes and finish them off with a polish and all that stuff. But I literally have no shots from The Wrong Rock that I would put in my animation reel. Wow. So really quickly, like with Devils, Angels and Dating, you just put that movie out online and it got tons of hits, did really well, super successful, all that stuff. Why did you decide to do a festival run with The Wrong Rock? Was it something that you wish you had done with Devils that you decided to do this time? I did a bit of a festival run with Devils, but...
We all know that festivals prefer to have premieres. My view was that I wasn't going to get as much out of festivals as I would out of just putting it online immediately. So when I was doing Devils, not only was I doing it online with a bunch of volunteers, but I did it entirely in the public domain. Anyone could go and check out our work on the Devils. During the process. So over a six year period, we had a public website where people could see the feeds, the forums, the play blasts, the animation, everything. And I made a promise to my team members that they could use anything that they did on the project immediately in their portfolio. So that made it a lot easier to recruit. And it also meant that we just finished the film and put it online.
And then we did do a festival run, but obviously we were only accepted into festivals that were kind of lower tier, that didn't mind that we were already online. We still won a few awards and things, just nothing huge. We won some best film, best animation, but in smaller festivals that most people hadn't heard of sort of things. Enough to put a few laurels on the website. When it came to The Wrong Rock, though, I knew that we were making a film that was more of a festival pleaser. Devils was kind of designed to attract people to click on the thumbnail on YouTube.
The Wrong Rock was designed to do well at festivals. So we figured we have to kind of give it its due, give it its chance to see what it can do at festivals before we put it out online. So we're still figuring out if it's going to be successful or not in that front. Nice. And then how did, like, I mean, do you know why or how, you know, Devils got so many hits online? Or was that just like you put it out and it did well? Or did you do a bunch of like campaigning for it and trying to get articles written about it and that stuff? Or like, do you know how that happened? Well, it's not a traditional thing.
I have, Colin and I both have a mutual friend, Lucas, who put out his film and he got like millions of views very quickly and it attracted attention. Whereas this one didn't quite spike that fast. What happened was I put the film out and it kind of had a slower, more organic growth. I think by the end of the first year, it had done a million views. And then I was contacted by Frederator, which is like a network on YouTube. And they said, we'd love to have you as part of our network and we'll put advertising on it so you can make some money. I didn't really care about the money part. I didn't expect to make much money out of it. What I said to them is that...
But can you get it seen by more people? And they said, yeah, we can do that. And so they took my whole channel, basically, and we put adverts on most things. But really, Devils was the main thing. Funnily enough, at first, it didn't seem to do much. And then I prodded them and said, hey, have you done that marketing yet? And they went, oh, yeah, we'll do it now. And when they did that, it spiked big time. Oh, wow.
That's crazy. And it was the original link? Yeah. They didn't repost it? Oh, wow. Crazy. So my channel became part of their network, and they put advertising on it, so they basically take a third of the advertising. And we still have that arrangement to this day. Oh, wow. Amazing. And so it's not like it did 16 million views overnight. What it did was it increased the amount of views I was getting, and it just kept increasing and increasing and increasing until it got to a point where even when it didn't seem to be doing anything crazy, it was still doing
15,000 views a day. Oh, wow. And when you're doing that many views every single day, it climbs and just keeps climbing. Yeah, crazy. It's slowed down now, for sure. I think it's doing more like 3,000 or 4,000 views a day. But it's basically become a regular...
video that just keeps showing up in people's feeds on YouTube. Wow. To the point that people are coming back to it and going, oh, I remember this old film. You know, I watched this when I was a kid. That's funny. Wow, amazing. Yeah, it's sort of a testament partially to the importance of marketing, as you kind of indicated, because they were pushing it to some degree. Yes. And then also, you know, like some sort of threshold that happens, you know, in YouTube's mysterious algorithm, you know, where suddenly, okay, like it's gotten this amount of, you know, like it fulfills, like people watch it, they watch it all the way through, people like it, you know, when it's suggested, people click on it, like somehow it reached.
this critical mass where it was just showing up in people's feeds. But one thing I will say, and I don't know how influential this is, but I feel like this is part of it, is that I put it on my own channel. Whereas a lot of people these days are giving their films to somebody else's channel who's already got subscribers. And the snag with that is that it's thrown out there. And if they don't put much behind it, you have no control of it after the fact. Whereas when I put it on my own channel, I was able to change the thumbnails. I could keep changing the keywords. And so I could react to things as they were happening. So over the years, I've been adjusting the keywords, responding to what's going on in the world at any given time, changing the keywords and adjusting that thumbnail.
I mean, for a long time, I had the same thumbnail for a very long time because it was very popular. When I removed the thumbnail, the views would drop, like thousands of views left, less per day. And so it was like, oh, shit, I'm going to put that thumbnail back again. There was a time when I would put the laurels over it, and YouTube doesn't care about that stuff. So it's about an image that's going to look good in that, like...
inch-sized box off onto the right-hand side. We're going to want to click on it. Exactly. So I just made sure to have a vibrant, interesting image for the main thumbnail. And then I keep adjusting maybe every few months. I go in and update the keywords. And what I frequently do, and this is a little secret, I hope nobody's going to copy this. I go to Rotten Tomatoes and I see what's currently coming out in Popular. And I pinch the titles or keywords for things that are currently coming out that I think are related, so like animated films and things like that. And I drop them in about...
a quarter of the keywords um so that there's always something so if someone's looking for the latest trailer for a particular new movie that there's a chance my film might show up in the suggestions bar on the right hand side that's incredible wait a second so this is uh it's not in the description it's not like hashtags it's uh keywords keywords okay which i'm not i guess not familiar enough with how youtube works but you know that's the thing because your films your films are on other people's channels right most of the time well Yeah, I guess so. I know some of them are on your channel. The only ones that have gone anywhere are not on my channel. Exactly. My point is that you don't have control over those keywords to go back in there and make a change 10 years later. Brilliant. Okay. So, yeah, I think we should wrap things up, but I have one last question. Do you have a last question, Colin? I can come up with one. Okay. I'll ask first. So, what is your ultimate goal? I know that you just, you know, your son, son, daughter? Yes, my son, Ethan. Your son was just born. Congratulations. Thank you.
Are you thinking about your next project now? What is the ultimate goal with all this? Are you hoping to get the chance to direct your own feature animation film later down the line? Or are you just hoping to do another short film? What's the plan? That would be the dream. My impression is that you don't just jump into things that quickly and easily. So I'm doing the kind of work right now that I think is very comfortable and very suitable and I will enjoy for quite a while while I'm getting adjusted to being a father. Somewhere along the line, I'm always pursuing other little things on the side. And when I get a little bit more headspace to figure things out, I will...
continue developing my side projects. I think maybe the next smart thing might be just to collaborate with somebody else who's got more free time. But we'll see. And then just build from there and hopefully further down the line, before my career is done, I will have directed an animated feature. That would be nice. Totally. Awesome. Sweet. My last question, just curious, looking back at the two-year process of making The Wrong Rock, what is the biggest lesson you took away that you'll apply next time around? I don't know.
There's so many big things that hit you. I think for maybe the most immediate thing for a next project, I'm probably just going to try focusing on the writing and the storyboarding and less on the CG. Because I already spend my day sitting in front of Maya. I mean, I've spent 20 years looking at the same piece of software. And I kind of don't want to do that in my pet projects now. And it's funny how I still got sucked into doing that for the wrong route.
I had no idea it was going to look as pretty or have as many effects as that one did. And so I feel like my big lesson is trying to figure out how to focus on that pure creativity of the writing and the drawing for my next thing. So it might just be that I make a little storyboard next. Right. Cool. Nice. Awesome. Yeah, it seems like part of it is, it kind of goes back to the thing that you said, which is, I mean, because this is essentially a passion project and people are volunteering and you kind of have to do the things that other people don't want to do, you sometimes don't have control over what it is that you will.
find yourself doing. Yeah, exactly. Until you have resources, until you have lots of money to throw at people. Do you feel like that is the key? That's definitely a lesson I took from the first to the second. So devils, I was paranoid that if I paid anybody, I would lose team members because I couldn't afford to pay everybody. Or if one person found out someone else was getting paid, they'd be offended and they'd leave. So I just didn't do it at all. And I only paid for a few things out of pocket that I had to, some piece of software or some service I needed. So that one cost very little on paper. But The Wrong Rock,
By that time, I'd come to the conclusion it was actually smart to spend the money on the things that you can't get done. So those things that were very, very challenging to get done and that getting character models took, at least pushed the project back a year, at least. And that's a long time to get something that important done. So on The Wrong Rock, I just sort of said, okay, I talked to my wife and we put aside a budget and we said, this is how much we're going to spend. We're going to break it up amongst the categories of things that are hard to get done. And so, yes, we spent money on team members. And the way that we...
found that was the most effective for that was we called the work kind of volunteer plus, in that it's basically volunteer work, but that we will occasionally pick a milestone, say that we want to get some things done by this milestone. We're going to spend this much money. We're going to offer chunks of that money to team members and say, if you can get this particular assignment done by this date, we will send you this money. And more often than not, it helped a bit. They would get that thing done by that date or close enough, and we would send the money over. Occasionally, though, you would find it made no difference at all, because they were just doing it on the side. They were more into the work than they were, and they had some other day job that paid way more than we could ever afford to pay. So it would make no dent at all. And so that could be frustrating, because you're trying to find ways to control the process. Yeah, to motivate people. And you realize, shit, I don't really have any control at all. I'm just lucky if I get anything, at which point you just have to be very grateful.
Okay, so, Michael, where can we find your work? Give us all the stuff. Your website, links you want people to look at, Twitter, Facebook, all that stuff. Right. Well, my portfolio can be found at michaelkwood.com. So that's M-I-C-H-A-E-L-C-A-W-O-O-D.com. You can find out about The Wrong Rock at therongrock.com. You can find out about Devil's Angels and Dating at devilsangelsanddating.com. All the logical stuff. I'm pretty good at getting the domain names for stuff. Awesome. Yeah. So those are the main links, I would say. Have a look at those.
And I've sort of, with my wife, we've partnered up and formed a company that we call Heromation. To be honest, mostly that is just to do our pet projects. We've published a few books through that brand and we've put the wrong ruck out there with that brand. Other than that, it's mostly kind of scraps of stuff because I still have a day job. Right. Yeah. And then are you on social media? Do you do Twitter, Instagram, any of that stuff? Yeah, just look me up. Michael Kaywood. It's usually my name in most of the places. So I'm on Twitter and I have an Instagram account and a few other things like that. Nice. Yeah. Awesome.
So normally I would just be talking to you about you're the expert, but based on a suggestion from listener Jerry, Liz's, one of Liz's buddies, we're going to do a new thing where we check in and see what the bonus episode guests have been up to since we last had them on the show. So this was 2019. So that's like eight years ago. No, not quite. Seven years ago. Over seven years ago. Yeah. What has Michael been doing?
since then. So he was a layout artist for a movie called Under the Boardwalk, which is an anime movie starring Kiki Palmer, Michael Cera, and Bobby Cannavale. So that's very, very cool. He also made his own video game called The Phoenix Gene, which is a VR game that's available now on Steam. So you should check that out for anybody who is doing the VR thing. I played VR once or twice. It's very, very fun. I don't know if I'd ever get my own VR headset, but very cool stuff. But I'm sure there's a lot of you out there who love that stuff. So yeah, check out The Phoenix Gene. Also, The Wrong Rock, Michael's film, which we talked about a lot on the show, also now has 5.6 million views on YouTube, which I don't think it had at the time. I think it had a lot less, which isn't as many as 16 million for his first short film. But hey.
5.6 million is pretty damn amazing if you ask me, so congrats to Michael on that. And yeah, let us know if you like hearing a little bit about the guests and where they are now. I don't know, this is very brief, but I think it's kind of fun. Yeah, thanks, Jerry, for the suggestion. All right, well, now it's time for the You Are the Expert question of the week. What's You Are the Expert? You may ask. Well, it's a segment where our producer Eric Thompson comes up with a question where he knows Liz and I will be the ultimate experts to answer the question. I've been doing this alone lately just because we've been short on time during our meetings. My prep has been very bad.
for these sessions. This is this week's You're the Expert Question, which I'll answer solo this time. We'll get Liz to back on these soon. That's part of the plan. It's just been a lot lately. Anyways, here's a question from Eric. And I don't know if I said this part of it, but yeah, basically he collects these from all walks of life in this filmmaking world. Some of these are emailed to the show, some of these questions he has, some of the questions from filmmakers he meets, but basically all the things, all the questions have the same thing in common that we should be the experts to answer it. All right. Hey, y'all. I've been a micro-budget filmmaker for a while now and I've made two feature films and a handful of shorts. They've done well and I've recouped my budgets from the feature. Dear God, you are my hero. I'd like to start applying to studio features, but I feel like I can't without an agent or a manager. I don't live
So how can I get connected with the folks like that? Well, Jesus, if you recouped a budget on your feature, that's really amazing. Yeah, that's the million dollar question, man. It's really hard to get an agent or manager. And it's really hard to get studio connections. And it all comes from who you know. And yeah, I mean, I don't know. It's all agents and managers. I think that's part of it. But I think it's also other connections you make that get you in those kind of positions. It's also like who sees your movie and who decides that your movie is so great that they want to have you direct some bigger movie. So yeah, it's not like you apply to direct a studio feature. It's like, OK, let me send my resume in to direct the studio features. It doesn't work that way. You basically have to get in the right circles. You got to work your way up. You know, if you made a movie that recouped it.
budget just make another movie with a little bit of a bigger budget make another movie with a little bigger budget bigger stars just keep on going up going up and up and up and eventually you know it's either gonna work out or it's not but like there's no like way to just jump into studio features unless you have like some awesome connections and you just know the right people to like talk to to get you in that room and usually that comes from You know, for people who don't have those kind of connections, I think a lot of it comes from agents and managers. But like for people who are more connected, like it could be other ways, too. But yeah, I basically feel like, you know, for someone in your situation, I would just keep making movies, you know, just go bigger and bigger. Previous guest of the show, the Nell's Brothers. And I think, yeah, no, this is a Nell's Brothers one. Basically, they said like the first movie, like no stars, you know, we just did it with who we had access to. Second feature, we got like a little bit of a bigger name in it. Like I think Dickie Dale was in there, second feature. And like that kind of helped them get in some other names, too. It wasn't just Dickie, but it was a couple other names. And like having like established like actors, even though they're not famous, like the A-listers.
a lot of filmmakers know who Dickie Dale is because she's just amazing. But like, that's just an amazing character actor. But I feel like those kinds of people are really, really helpful to like bring prestige in a way. It's not prestige, like on a critical, critical level. It's like prestige, like in the world of filmmaking is like, oh my God, like this person got these actors who are really great, who've worked on the biggest things in their movies. Oh, they must be worthwhile. So it's like, you just like want to work your way up, you know, like, and then their third movie, they had Danny Lover star in it. And then like, then they're working with Mel Gibson and then they're working with Orlando Bloom, you know, it's like, it's just, you start small and you work your way up. And I feel like that was advice they gave me after I made the alternate. They're like, okay, now you made the alternate. That's great. So next movie gets them.
you know, a little bigger talent in your, in your movie. Now your next week, a little bit more bigger talent than that in your next movie and just do it that way. And then like, you're going to, you're going to work your way up. And like, I don't know if you can really say that they're directing studio features. Like, I mean, they're directing movies for studios, like Saban and stuff, but like, I don't know where you got the distinction. I mean, those are like $14 million movies. That's like a huge deal, but like, it's not like for Sony or it's not like a hundred, you know, million dollar movie or $50 million movie. But I mean, if that's what you mean by like the Sabans of the world or whatever, then I mean, that's a clear path. It's like, you just make movies and they just get bigger and bigger and bigger until you're getting the opportunities to, you know, be hired, you know, or, or pitch the big
like be a part of the conversation to direct something much larger. So yeah, I hope that helps. Yeah, I feel like from all the hundreds and hundreds of guests that we've had on the show over the years, I think that the one clear line is that the more that you practice the art of filmmaking, the better the chance you're going to get to make more movies. So you don't get more chances by waiting or by trying to like, you know, get this one movie made for like a certain budget or like grinding out a project forever and ever. I mean, I think that's like sometimes that's what projects need. Like they take a long time. Like my movie took me fucking seven years. But like you don't want to be so precious. Like you just want to make stuff. Like take the opportunity to make movies when you get the opportunity to make a movie. So if you've recouped the budget.
on your first movie, I'm sure you have an opportunity to make another one in the same manner. So just do that and keep on doing that until you get to where you want to go. All right. I answered that very, very long windedly. Hope that's helpful. But what do you all think? You can send us questions, comments or suggestions or reactions to what I just said to podcast and making movies is hard dot com over read them on the show. If you like the show, you can leave us a review or rating on a podcast and all the other places you can leave those ratings. That'd be fantastic. Also, we have a voicemail on you can call 818-732-8057 and leave us a message. You can respond with your voice to the words I just said. If you agree, disagree or whatever. And we will literally play on the show like we have. We have never denied a voicemail on the show yet. I mean, we might if it's an.
pleasant or rude or mean or evil, but if, you know, reasonable voicemail, like, you know, talking about filmmaking, I think we're going to play all those on the show. So send us your thoughts. We'd love to hear them. If you have questions, whatever you got. put it in the form of words into a phone by dialing that number and we'll hear it and we'll play it and we'll talk about it. Also, you can check us out on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter at MMIH Podcast and YouTube at Making Movies Hard Podcast. YouTube is getting beefed up right now. We're getting lots, all the episodes basically we've ever done are being added to YouTube. So if you want to see us talking in real time, basically I think episode 400 onward will have video and then like some of the earlier ones like 200 and some, like 254 through like
300 and something have video, but then there's a bunch that don't. And then all the ones before 252 won't have video. They'll just have audio. But yeah, it's still a good place to check out the show. A lot of people love YouTube. I watch podcasts and listen to podcasts on YouTube. So yeah, give us some love there. Give us a comment on one of your favorite episodes if you want or, you know, whatever you got. A subscription. Subscription, you know what I'm saying? Give us a subscription. Hit subscribe to that. That'd be awesome. You know, whatever you're willing to do, that'd be great. But thanks to our editor, Jeff Fangman, for doing the editing on the show. Thanks to Robert Jones for doing all, for doing our social media. Thanks to our co-producer, Kerry Carlock, for doing the video socials, which has been fantastic. Big thanks to our producer, Eric Thompson, for simply being awesome. And thanks to you all for listening and we'll talk to you
Don't forget to hit subscribe, leave a 5-star rating, and write a review. You can find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts. Thanks again, and we'll talk to you all next week.