Skip to content
Michael Huemer - Anarchy, Capitalism, and Progress episode artwork

May 28, 2021 1 hr 37 min

Michael Huemer - Anarchy, Capitalism, and Progress

from Dwarkesh Podcast Hosted by Dwarkesh Patel

Michael Huemer is a professor of philosophy at the University of Colorado. He is the author of more than sixty academic articles in epistemology, ethics, metaethics, metaphysics, and political philosophy, as well as eight amazing books. Watch on YouTube. Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or any other podcast platform. Podcast website here. Buy Knowledge, Reality, and Value and The Problem of Political Authority. Read Michael’s awesome blog and follow me on Twitter for new episodes. Timestamps: (0:00:00) - Intro (0:01:07) - The Problem of Political Authority (0:03:25) - Common sense ethics (0:09:39) - Stockholm syndrome and the charisma of power (0:18:14) - Moral progress (0:26:55) - Growth of libertarian ideas (0:33:37) - Does anarchy increase violence? (0:44:37) - Transitioning to anarchy (0:47:20) - Is Huemer attacking our society?! (0:51:40) - Huemer's writing process (0:53:18) - Is it okay to work for the government (0:56:39) - Burkean argument against anarchy (1:02:07) - The case for tyranny (1:11:58) - Underrated/overrated (1:25:55) - Huemer production function (1:30:41) - Favorite books (1:33:04) - Advice for young people This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.dwarkesh.com

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Michael Huemer - Anarchy, Capitalism, and Progress

0:00 1:37:04
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, folks, and welcome to the Lunar Society podcast. Today, it is my great privilege to talk with Professor Michael Hummer. He is, in my opinion, the best philosopher alive. He's a professor of philosophy at the University of Colorado, and he's written more than 70 academic articles on epistemology, ethics, metaethics, metaphysics, and political philosophy. He has also written eight books, the newest one of which is This Introduction to Philosophy, Knowledge, Reality, and Value. I highly, highly recommend it. It's incredibly clear and easy to read. It covers all of the arguments in philosophy that I've been curious about since I was a teenager. So I've included a link to his Amazon page in the description where you can go and buy it. Today, we had an incredibly wide-ranging conversation about a previous book of his, The Problem of Political Authority. Just a reminder, as always, to please, please share this podcast on social media or with your friends if you enjoy it. This is a small and growing podcast, so word of mouth really, really helps. Without further ado, here's Professor Michael Humer. Okay, Professor Humer, what is The Problem of Political Authority? Why did you write this book?

Yeah, so you have a copy of the book, and you can order it on Amazon. That's the important thing. Or anywhere. Yeah, so the problem referred to in the title is a philosophical problem about government. Basically, the problem is what's the basis for the government's authority.

And what I mean by the government's authority is, so first of all, it's usually thought that the government is entitled to give other people commands and force them to obey in situations where nobody else would be entitled to give commands and force people to obey, right? So like they could give commands that you don't already have to do, but you have to do them only because the government commanded it. And then the other part of this notion of authority is that it's generally thought that you have a moral obligation to obey. right to obey the law merely because it's a law and again you know the law could be things that you're not already obligated to do right so example if i decide that i'm going to collect money from other people to give to the poor right like i started a charity and i'm collecting money to help the poor and i decide i'm not getting enough contributions voluntarily so i decide to just like force people to pay right um if i do this this is called extortion and uh you know i'm gonna wind up in jail right but besides that i'm gonna wind up in jail most people will be disapproving of this and think that number one i shouldn't be doing that number two they don't have to pay me

okay but when the government does this this is called taxation and you know social welfare programs which is uh generally most people approve of right and they think that the government is entitled to do that and that we are obligated so and that's just an illustration of the idea that the government has a special moral status right that most people think they have a kind of status that puts them above other ordinary people and so the question is why right you know why do they why do they get to do all this stuff that nobody else can do and why should we obey them right So you're pointing out a contradiction between common sense morality and common sense political philosophy. Why should we resolve that contradiction in favor of common sense intuitions rather than, you know, the prevalent political abuse?

Yeah, common sense, ethical intuition. I mean, so, yeah, so there are the intuitions that you would apply to kind of ordinary people, and then there are the intuitions people have about the state. But I think if you raise this issue with most people, they will see that some sort of explanation is required, right? So, like, most people have the initial reaction that the government has authority, but they will not generally say, yeah, that's just self-evident and needs no explanation. Like, most people can see that it needs an explanation, right? And so then they will try to give an explanation, and it will just turn out that none of the explanations are any good, right?

So part of the reason why we don't just go with our initial intuition about politics is that we also, you might say, we have the intuition that it requires an explanation, right? Yeah, so that's part of it. Another thing is, you know, the ethical intuitions that I'm appealing to, so things like you shouldn't go up to people and just, like, steal their money, or, you know, like, threaten people with violence to get their money, or then lock them in cases, stuff like that. These are not controversial intuitions, right? Like, these are intuitive reactions that any normal person would have, regardless of whether they're Democrats or Republicans or Libertarians. The thing about the state having authority is not so uncontroversial, right? So there's a significant number of people who are called Libertarians who do not have any intuitive reactions that the state has authority, right?

Yeah. You know, I have like in the book in chapter six, I have a series of explanations for why people might have this bias in favor of the state, you know, based on different findings in psychology. Right. But I mean, one of the obvious things, like maybe the most obvious things that people have a bias towards the status quo. And there's just very clear independent evidence of that. Without talking about a problem of political authority, there's independent evidence that there's a bias for the status quo. So this explains why people in different societies with very different customs tend to think that their customs are superior to those in other societies. How could that be? It has to be that they're biased in favor of the way things are done in their own society. So I got an explanation of why people would have mistaken moral judgments about the state.

Yeah, so I want to talk about your second point there, which is that there's more controversy on the political views than there is on the basic ethical intuitions about that and so on. It's not self-evident to me that, so there are libertarians who believe that the state should be significantly smaller, but as far as people who believe that the state has no unique authority that non-state actors don't have, it's not self-evident to me that anarcho-capitalists outnumber the people who think that you should have to pay somebody, your neighbor has a right to make you pay when you have benefited from his services, even though you didn't ask for those services. I wouldn't say that anarcho-capitalism is less controversial than that. It might be, but that's not self-evident to me. Anarcho-capitalism is controversial. So anarcho-capitalism is the extreme version of libertarianism. So there are not very many of them, but there are a substantial number of libertarians. But most of them still hold a political view that the state has some unique authority, right? No, I don't think so. This is discussed in Chapter 7, where I argue that what differentiates libertarians from everyone else is skepticism about authority.

That is the basic libertarian view. By the way, many libertarians deny that this is what unifies libertarianism. But I think they deny that because they haven't read my book. And when they read my book, they will understand that. They may not even understand what I mean by authority and skepticism thereof.

Okay, this is what's common to libertarians. They think that you should apply the same moral standards to the state that you apply to ordinary people, and they do that. And then, right, so when the state does something like the state commits murder, the libertarians go, murder! And, you know, the partisans of conventional political views go, oh, well, I guess I shouldn't have done that, but, you know, we're not going to call them murderers or anything like that. Right. Yeah.

There's a quotation at the end that I put at the end of the book from the Chinese philosopher Masa, which was, you know, like whatever, some thousand years ago or something. But he says, you know, to kill one man is a capital crime and to kill 10 men is to multiply the crime by tenfold and to kill 100 men is to multiply by 100 fold. OK, and this is the rulers of the world all recognize. But when it comes to the greatest crime of all, making war on another state, they praise it. right because you know that's just like it's just murder but bigger right yeah um and so he says you know if a man on scene a little black says it is black but when seeing a lot of black says it is white then it's clear that this person cannot distinguish black from white and similarly the rulers of the world cannot distinguish right from wrong yeah yeah it's an interesting point like if we held a political leader to account the same way we hold individuals to account um it'd be an interesting way of looking at them so let me ask you about the uh biases you're talking about one of the ones you point out in the book is um stockholm syndrome where a victim of abuse will feel loyalty towards their abuser and feel that the abuser is actually protecting them and will feel gratitude towards small acts of mercy. I wonder, given the fact that people regularly criticize the president or regularly criticize government policies they disagree with, to what extent they're actually fearful of or in some way incorrectly loyal towards the government in this particular way because of fear of authority? Yeah.

So the original Stockholm syndrome, just for anyone who doesn't know, refers to, there was a bank robbery in Stockholm, Sweden, whatever, like decades ago, probably 1970s or something, where the robbers took some people hostage in the bank vault. And then it basically turned out that the hostages kind of emotionally bonded with the kidnappers. At one point, they thought that the kidnappers were protecting them from the police. At the end, the hostages didn't want to go out without the kidnappers because they were afraid that the police would shoot the kidnappers. right once they got them okay so anyway um and then i think one of them like um you know tried to aid in the legal defense like started up a legal defense fund for okay and this is a phenomenon that occurs periodically in hostage situations right it wasn't just that one case so like you know fbi negotiators are trying to be prepared for stockholm syndrome um now you know what happens with the government isn't literally exactly that they're not literally kidnapping us but my idea is um there's a you know there's a little bit broader phenomenon that people will um instinctively take the side of those who are who have power over them

And there's an evolutionary explanation for why this would be, right? So, and, you know, people have said about Sockham syndrome that it's a survival mechanism, which, by the way, there's evidence for thinking that it works because, like, the kidnappers in that case said, like, they were thinking of shooting the hostages, but they couldn't do it because of the emotional bond that they had formed with the hostages. So it might have worked. And, you know, my more general point is it's common in human societies for someone to have power over others. And if the people in the weaker position form an emotional bond with the powerful people, that may help them to survive and prosper.

So that might be why people try to take the side of the government. And then you asked about, well, people are often very critical of the president. And I guess I think it's because people are distinguishing the government from the current office holder. It doesn't feel like you're being disloyal to the government. What you're saying is you just want the other party. You wanted the other party to be in power, which they're also half of the government or something like that. Yeah.

But then there's people who, I mean, not from a libertarian perspective, there's people who question the legitimacy of the government in other ways. For example, they'll say it's systemically racist. And these are also the kind of people who want to increase the size of the government. But that also seems confusing. Like if it's, if fear of government to prevent people from, okay, so let's say it prevents them from criticizing the legitimacy of the government, but it allows them to criticize the president. Why are people comfortable criticizing the legitimacy of the government in this particular way?

I mean, I'm not sure they're questioning the legitimacy of the government, like the social justice warriors, rather than just criticizing some of its policies, right? So, I mean, in my view, questioning their legitimacy would be saying, like, they shouldn't have any entitlements that ordinary citizens don't have. Right. So, like, if ordinary citizens aren't entitled to tax each other, then the state shouldn't be able to tax us or, you know, something like that. Right. Yes, sir?

I don't think the left-wing people think that exactly. But I mean, they are like sort of... Actually, I mean, I, well, I'm not quite sure I understand the view, right? So, because I'm not quite sure I understand what the systemic racism is, right? So, like, I was going to say, like, they're accusing government of being racist, but I'm not even sure that that's what it means, right? Like, I'm not sure that systemic racism means that anyone is actually racist, right? That's right, yeah. I wonder to what extent, so, Verne Gerard noticed that after Stalin died, support for the Soviet Union amongst academia in the West declined. And so his hypothesis was that...

the academics didn't support uh stalin uh despite his violence but because of his violence there wasn't fear of authority but more so um that the charisma of authority that they find authority charismatic and violence charismatic uh what do you think of that hypothesis um yeah maybe so i mean i'm not sure if the academics knew about stalin's um murders right um they might have not known because they didn't want to know right but so i think there's a phenomenon that um horrible people are often charismatic or right or you know charismatic to ordinary average people so stalin was probably a charismatic character although like i haven't seen him But because, like, people, ordinary average people don't admire moral virtue. They admire power. Like, they admire somebody who appears strong and confident, right? But the people who are very strong and confident are often bad people. So, like, the reason why they're strong is because they crush all opposition, right? And the reason why they're confident is that they do not give a shit about other people, right? Like, if you don't give a shit what other people think and you don't care what effect you have on other people, then you don't worry.

like you're not worried when you're talking to them because you don't care what they think about you like and you know when you're when you're just taking actions like if you're the leader and you're like putting forward your new policies you do it with total confidence because you don't care if it's wrong right that's my read on dictators right they act like they're totally confident that this is the right policy because they don't actually care if it kills lots of people or not right right like a normal person would be worried what if i'm doing the wrong thing but then that worry would make them look unconfident and then people would not support them right yeah This does help explain something about the last four years. So I'm not claiming that Trump was Stalin or anything, but I never found him charismatic in the way that millions of people did. I was missing a module in my mind that was supposed to find him charismatic. I just couldn't figure it out, but that's a good explanation. Just the confidence itself. Yeah, I mean, I found him kind of anti-charismatic, but I think about half the country found him anti-charismatic, so to speak. But you still have to explain why half of them found him particularly charismatic, like better than the other 15 Republican candidates in the primaries. And yeah, it had a lot to do with being super confident, right?

which by my read is because he doesn't care and like he'll say stuff with total confidence and the the ordinary person thinks because he's talking with complete confidence that means that what he's saying must be true right but the alternative explanation is it's because he doesn't care about truth So then why do you think moral progress is likely if the average person cares about power or is more convinced by power itself than convincing arguments or by people who care about the truth? Yeah. How do we get moral progress? I mean, first, why do I think that there's moral progress? Because I looked at history. Because you look at what people were doing back in ancient Rome, gladiatorial combat. They were forcing slaves to fight to the death for fun because they thought it was amusing to see them cut to pieces. And then, you know, like just...

200 years ago in America, we were enslaving people just because they had darker skin and stuff like that. So, I mean, the evidence of there being moral progress is compelling, right? It's like enormous progress. But, you know, what's the explanation? How did it happen? I mean, I think that it's driven by a relatively small number of people, right? So there are a bunch of people who don't reflect very much and just go along with the customs of their society. And they're just sort of like sort of neutral. And there's a small number of people who kind of see the flaws in the status quo, and they try to push society.

towards the moral truth. And they push it slowly. There are always reformers who are trying to improve society. It's a constant small force. So over the course of many generations, it accumulates to a lot of progress, right? Right. So I read Dialogues on Ethical Vegetarianism, which you also wrote. And I want to question you on whether on net there has been more progress. At one point in the book, you say that the impact of factory farming rivals the suffering of all the humans that have ever existed. And how can a world where factory farming has been increasing be one where there's been tremendous moral progress? On net, there would seem to be a moral decline, right?

Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you could make the argument, people find this shocking, but you could make the argument that, like, you know, would have been better if there were no humans. Maybe the world would be better with no human beings, right? Because the amount of pain and suffering that we cause, just like a few years of human beings, the amount of pain and suffering that we cause to other species is probably greater than all of the suffering in all of human history, right? And, you know, probably outweighs all of the pleasure that human beings have ever experienced, you know, among all of the hundred billion or so humans who have existed. You know, that might seem shocking, but the number of animals that we're torturing and killing each year is something like 74 billion. Right.

there have only ever been 110 billion humans so like two years of factory farming we tortured and killed more creatures than the total number of us who have ever existed right yeah so anyway um yeah so like from a purely consequential standpoint um it's been like a huge regression okay however it does appear to me that it's turning around so um vegetarianism and veganism are becoming more popular when i was in college um you know there were there were not many vegetarians and i think i never met a vegan i think like nobody heard of that and there weren't like vegan restaurants you go to and stuff like that um what's ultimately What's ultimately going to change the situation is technology, right? Right. So now there are all of these products. There are these, you know, substitute products, substitutes for animal products, which are really convincing and it didn't used to be. Also, they're working on synthetic meat, basically. So they're going to make meat without the cruelty. And that's probably what's ultimately going to end it. Right. So like right now, it's really bad, but it's probably going to get better when we perfect this technology. Right. Also, I mean, you know, and this kind of, you know, this kind of fits with what I was saying earlier. This is being driven by a small number of people, right? There's like a small percentage of society who cares.

because there's like a small percentage of human beings who are basically morally decent small number of people give a crap about morality at all but okay but that's enough right so like that um the technological changes are being driven by um you know animal welfare advocates basically like that's that's why we have people who are interested in developing synthetic meat and stuff like that Yeah. Okay, so assuming that there's more progress that's happening, you say in the book that you expect the rate of progress to increase over time because of exponential growth. This seems to contradict a blog post I recently wrote talking about how progress will end, where you said that because of diminishing marginal returns, actually exponential growth has to stop. And you even hypothesized that it will actually decline at some point. So, I mean, you were talking about scientific and technological knowledge here, but why doesn't this also apply to moral progress? Why won't we see moral decline or just zero moral growth before we get to the point of anarcho-capitalism?

I mean, so any progress has to eventually slow down. And, you know, because I think there's a maximum point in everything, right? But that doesn't mean that will happen soon. So I can't predict where it will happen. Eventually, civilization will collapse and we'll all die. Eventually, the human species will go extinct. But I don't know when. It could be, you know, I don't know. It could be in the next hundred years or it could be in a million years. But what about moral progress? Oh, yeah. And part of why I said that in the blog post was there's been a decline in the rate of economic growth in the United States. And poorer countries have a faster rate of growth, right? They're poorer overall, but they're growing faster. So they'll eventually catch up.

And you can hypothesize the reason for this. If you're already doing pretty badly, it's easier to improve. And the United States is already pretty efficient, so it gets harder and harder to improve. And that could happen with moral progress, too. It will presumably slow down. As we get closer to the moral truth, the rate of progress will have to slow down. Will it decline? I don't know. I don't know why that would have to happen.

I mean, like, eventually we'll all die, but I don't know why we would have to become immoral before we die. It's something about the accumulation of knowledge that it tends to go, you know, it tends to just accumulate and not get destroyed. Yeah, so will we stop? Will the progress stop before we reach an arc of capitalism? I don't know. I mean, that might be true if there's some, if there's some truths that are super hard to apprehend, then it might be that, like, you know, human species never become advanced enough to understand them. Like, that could be true. But this doesn't seem to me like it's that hard.

Right. So, I mean, I think my basic moral point is the government isn't special. Like, they're people like you and me. There's no reason why they should get to do a whole bunch of stuff that you consider to be immoral if anyone else does them, right? So, like, the basic idea I don't think is that complicated. And, I mean, I think this is similar to other bits of progress that have occurred in history. Like, a lot of the stuff people were doing in the past was super stupid.

like not only bad but stupid okay so like the idea that um oh you have more rights than somebody else because of your skin color like that's super dumb besides being really harmful it's just dumb right anyway so like you know eventually people see that okay but i think this is similar so you know the idea that you don't have different rights because of your skin color i think that is kind of similar to you don't have different rights just because you're in power right yeah uh so i'm gonna try to critique that view actually um like it you could say that the change in attitudes over the last few centuries has been towards greater respect for the individual a stronger presumption against violence and coercion but uh That might be true globally, because the default state of mankind is authoritarian control. But in the United States, it seems that in the 19th century, obviously, to the exclusion of Blacks and women, attitudes were far more libertarian. There's a particular example of Grover Cleveland has sent a bill from Congress authorizing what would be $250,000 today for some natural disaster that occurred in Texas. And he vetoes it. And he says, first of all, I can't find any authority within the Constitution to do this. Second, this sets an expectation of paternalistic help from the government in the future. And we should just rely on the charity of fellow citizens. This is not the proper role of government. Both parties seem to have respect for the autonomy of the...

individual more so back then. So on the particular point of libertarian views, it seems that there's been regress. And I think maybe a better theory of changing attitudes has been an increase in safetyism. And in most cases, this is a good thing because countries that care about safety don't do genocides, torture, war, and so on. But it also means that they're more comfortable with regulations, with fines, with not so diligent in protecting property rights. So then this safetyism asymptotes to a regulatory state rather than anarcho-capitalism over time.

Yeah, I mean, that could be true. So definitely the United States has had growing regulation. Back when it was first started, the Code of Federal Regulations, so this lists all of the federal regulations. It started in, I guess, 1938 or something like this, 1930s. It was 22,000 pages, which sounds long enough, but it's now over 150,000 pages. And the size of these regulatory agencies is growing more employees.

I mean, it could be right that that's just what's going to keep happening, right? But it's not obviously right. So, I mean, there is a certain amount of pushback and there are people who are realizing the problems with regulation. So in many areas, just many areas of human intellectual inquiry, knowledge just accumulates. And we might just be in a primitive state of knowledge about social and political matters, right? But it looks to me like there's...

um to accumulating libertarian sentiment this could be wishful thinking or something i don't know but like you know when i was in college um you know like the institute for humane studies they had a summer seminar which i went to they had a summer seminar but like in the next few decades they expanded greatly right and you know these there are these different libertarian organizations now there was no students for liberty when i was in college right like that expanded also um there was um i recall there being basically like one well-known libertarian philosopher it was robert nozick yeah and uh and you know now there are multiple ones right um so i don't know you know possible Part of what I think was happening, so I don't know about Robert Cleveland in particular. I don't know if he was typical of people in that time. But I mean, so here's an interpretation. It used to be that people believed in the authority of the state, but they just didn't care about the poor. So that's why they didn't want to do all this welfare state stuff, right?

And then, you know, later it developed to where they still believe in the authority of the state, but they started caring about the poor as well. So they thought, okay, well, we'll use this power to help the poor, right? So that would actually be a form of progress, even though, like, even though the policy is getting further from what it should be, so like the attitudes are getting closer to what it should be. Yeah, so I wonder if instead of the attitudes getting closer to libertarian, what's happening is just that the tails have increased. So, I mean, there wasn't Students for Liberty maybe a few decades ago, but were the democratic socialists in America significant force back then either? Or were there socialists in Congress, right? I don't know if it's fair to say that the change has been towards libertarianism per se, rather than just towards the extremes. There could be. Yeah, I think like the internet culture might be making us more extreme, right? Yeah, so, you know, it used to be that...

information and uh just like you know the content that people consumed was produced by this small elite and now that everybody can have a voice on the internet uh yeah there's just more room for more extremists like like us um right but also like the socialists um yeah i mean i don't know where that's going right so like it could be that the internet is just like a bad influence on all of us right but it could be that you know this is kind of like relatively early days it could be that it's going to settle down and improve right so um it's just sort of like this um you know this optimistic philosophical view that the truth wins in the end this isn't guaranteed to happen but generally speaking like good ideas tend to be more persuasive than bad ideas like you know if you have the opportunity for all the information to come out And everybody gets to share their arguments and so on. If you hear all of the arguments, usually that favors the correct views. If you assume that the libertarian view is correct, then having more information and more discussion and so on should favor it. This is a general tendency. It's not guaranteed because there are biases in the human mind. There could be systematic biases. And also the possibility maybe we're wrong. So maybe our view will go down because it's wrong, actually. Yeah, maybe. So let's talk about the actual view then. I'm going to tripping devil's advocate now.

Hobbes had this idea that people engage in violence to steal each other's stuff or to launch preemptive strikes or just to get revenge and glory. And then he said, we need a strong government to stop this kind of violence. Now, you explained some game theoretical reasons why a strong government may, in fact, increase violence in those cases. But in Pinker's The Veterans of Our Nature, he lists out some empirical evidence showing that... First of all, when we go from primitive tribes to the first states, there's a decrease in violence. And then during the feudal period where thousands of independent political units merge into centralized monarchies, there's another decrease in violence. So how come it's the case that empirically speaking, whenever powers that tend to centralize, the rate of violence, death, war, homicide tends to decrease?

Yeah, that could be true. So I think it could be that the central power, the government, suppresses the small-scale violence. They do large-scale violence, i.e. war, but they suppress just ordinary one-on-one murder and so on. But I mean, if you're asking, well, why is it that people are prone to violence to begin with? So I think Pinkert in that book takes up the explanation, like the Hobbesian explanation, which is totally wrong and makes no sense.

But in a different book, Pinker gives a different explanation that I think is actually correct. But I'm not sure he realizes that it's a completely different explanation. So the Hobgian explanation is everybody's completely selfish, and everybody knows that anyone can kill anyone. And you're afraid that somebody else is going to attack you and kill you, so you attack them first because there's some advantage in combat to the person who attacks first. And this makes no sense because if there's...

more than one other person who is worried about being attacked, and you go around attacking people without provocation, then everyone else is going to know that you're the biggest threat. Like you're the one who's most likely to attack them without provocation. So all of these people who are thinking about doing preemptive attacks, like you become the biggest target for them, right? So like, you know, what you should do is, and you're assuming that you can't like immediately kill everyone else at once, right? What you should do is like, just try to mind your own business and stay away and not start any fights, right? Okay, however, this isn't what happens in primitive societies. This is not what human beings have actually done throughout history.

And so why is that? And I wondered about this for a long time until I read Stephen Pinker's book, How the Mind Works. There's a particular passage that explains this. And basically what happened in primitive tribes was the men from one tribe would attack another tribe in order to murder the men and kidnap the women. And this is extremely dangerous. There's a high chance that you die when you're doing this. So on the face of it, it seems like you wouldn't do that because it doesn't make sense. But here's the thing. Say there's a 45% chance that you die by starting this fight, but a 55% chance that you survive and you capture one extra wife.

Okay, then your reproductive success goes up. It doesn't seem like it's worth it if there's a 45% chance of dying, just from an intuitive self-interest standpoint, but from the standpoint of expected reproductive success, your expected reproductive success goes up if you presently have fewer than two wives. If you have zero wives, you have nothing to lose because you're going to have zero reproductive success if you don't. And by the way, it was probably common for men in primitive societies to have zero wives because most societies practice polygyny, which means the majority of men have zero wives. right because like you know there's some like dominant character who's taken multiple wives and so on anyway so if you have one wife still you have a chance of either doubling your reproductive success or cutting it down to zero and it's a good deal as long as it's slightly more probable that you succeed okay so like that's the evolutionary explanation why this would happen this is super bad right it's very bad that that's the case but that would explain why um okay you know human and so human beings like they're not thinking that when they go to war what's happening is they're driven by emotions but this is all to explain why we would have the genes that would give us the emotional reactions that would make it likely for us to attack

other tribes, right? Yeah, but so long as that instinct exists, why won't a state without a Leviathan or a society without a Leviathan fall back into that sort of, people just fall back into that emotion of conquest? Why won't that happen? You know, private security agencies, you'll hire private security agencies. So, I mean, the primitive tribes didn't have private security agencies. They didn't have like a, just like developed economy. And, you know, it might be that indeed anarchy doesn't work starting from primitive society, right? But it might still work if you transition from an advanced society.

But so, I mean, my theory is, you know, you transition from democracy to anarchy, to anarcho-capitalism. And it doesn't work if you just start, if you start a much earlier stage of society, right? Plausibly, it won't work. Yeah. Yeah, I guess it doesn't be a case for private security. Doesn't it assume somewhat of a parity in resources that you could afford a similar magnitude of help? Because if over time, rich people, just because either they're smarter or they have a lot of capital to begin with, can grow their capital stock much more than poor people. This is not a problem in a normal democracy. According to me, it's not a problem in a normal democracy because what are they going to do with it, right? But in- Buy some politicians. Yeah, fair enough. In anarcho-capitalism, they can buy an army, whereas you can buy like one security guard. So then there's not a sort of parity in power.

And they can really roll over people. I mean, I don't, I don't buy a security guard, right? Like I sign a contract with a security company, right? So it could be a large company. I'm just one of their customers, right? I'll be a billion dollars. Just, you know, let me get through this town. You tell us about private security agency that. Right. But what's his, what is his purpose? Okay. So like, you know, Bill Gates, um, hires like some really powerful security agency and to do what?

steal resources uh steal women okay but i mean he's got billions of dollars why doesn't he just buy them so right so i mean the thing is like this is why rich people usually don't do this because they could just buy the thing that they want that's why they don't have to steal it right and it's probably it's cheaper so like i mean rich people um rich people do well with women like bill gates would not have a hard time finding wife if he'd already have one um just because of that right and but the thing is like so if you want to pay somebody to help you steal money from poor people like okay the amount of money that the poor people are willing to pay to not be stolen from is about equal to the value of the stuff that would be stolen right so like what you could do is you could just buy it from them right yeah then you know not have to worry about the violence yeah fair enough although um in such a situation aren't the poor disadvantaged relative to the rich i guess they are in any society but if they if a larger portion of their income and assets has to go towards security than anybody else they're not going to see the kind of growth to their wealth that anybody else would

Yeah, but I mean, they're not, right? So, like, which people are going to pay more for security? Yeah. Like, they presently do, right? Yeah. Because they have more to protect, like, more stuff to protect, so it makes sense to do that. But also, like, and also for their personal safety, they place a higher monetary value on their personal safety, right? Like, okay, nobody wants to be beaten up, but, like, if you ask how much money we pay to not be beaten up, the answer is larger for the rich person, right? So, like, they will pay more dollars, right, for security.

Yeah. Okay. So one possible answer to your question, like, what are they going to steal if they can just buy the assets? I mean, you could ask a similar question about the U.S. government. Like, why do they expect tribute every year? Why don't they just trade with people? And the answer is they have nothing to trade with, right? The only thing they have to trade with is their coercion. And so Pinker floats the idea to the first states, but really just kind of mafiosos that took control of an area and expect a tribute every year. Why won't some of these private agencies kind of form the proto-states where they demand tribute every year from the people living there in exchange for living safely? I guess you could say that's what the state is today anyways.

Yeah, that is what they are. Although, you know, you might worry that maybe we would get a worse state than that. Exactly. Right. Well, I mean, it's just that if you already have one of these organizations, it's easy to keep it going. But if you don't already have one, it's hard to get it started. So, like, if we had the anarcho-capitalist situation just set up the way it's envisioned by the ANCAPs, from that position, it's difficult to establish your state-like entity, right? Like, everybody's got a security agency, and then, like, you try to start up a gang of people to attack people.

Right. And so, so you're not already rich and you don't already have all these resources. You're hoping to get the resources by attacking other people. Well, it's going to be hard to get there. Right. It's like, you know, without getting arrested by other people's security agencies and so on. But so, but you know, it matters how this whole thing comes about. Right. So if, if the energy comes about by, you know, one day the government just disappears, like the cops disappear, then it would be chaos. Right. So, you know, the first thing that would happen is there would be chaos in the street. And the second thing that would happen is people would immediately start setting about setting up another government. Right.

Okay, but that's why that's not the way I envisioned the transition going, right? The transition would have to go by the government progressively privatizing its functions. So the government would outsource policing to private security companies, right? Maybe they would do this gradually. And similarly, they would gradually outsource the courts to private arbitrators, right? So the idea is that the government is shrinking while at the same time the private organizations that would take over those functions are growing. If the government just collapsed immediately, it's no good. But if there's this simultaneous process, then you could get to a stable situation where now it's hard for an individual to overturn it.

Yeah. How soon can this happen? Like if everybody agreed, you know, humor's right. I bought this book. As soon as everyone buys my book, the paradise can begin. But if today everybody agreed, how long would it take to privatize things to the point where we're living in a system of anarcho-capitalism without doing it too fast so that bad things start happening? I don't know.

I mean, I don't have expertise on that. I have to, like, we probably have to observe things happening, right? But I mean, like, if people were convinced, like, we have a democracy right now. If people were convinced that we should privatize more functions in the state, we can start doing it right now. And, you know, it sort of, like, depends on how cautious you want to be. But, like, you know, a city right now could say, yeah, we're going to stop this police thing right now.

like the city of Denver tomorrow could say, we're going to like start hiring private security guards to patrol. So, and then they could pass laws to, you know, change the, change the asymmetry between government police and security guards. Right. Are you pro do you find the police? I mean, you could say that like in principle, right? I mean, I'm not sure what those people mean because it kind of sounds like they mean just cancel the police and then have no security. No, I don't want to do that. But I would, I would take that money and give it to private security companies. I wouldn't take it and just not give it to any security. Right. Yeah. So here's a question I'll ask you. You wrote a blog post.

a few months back where you were criticizing social justice warriors and the 1619 Project in particular. And here's what you wrote. You said, the title of the postage attacking your own society. You wrote, here's another plausible way of eroding norms. Directly, verbally, attacking the foundation of one's societies. Preaching that the society is founded on fundamentally evil values, that large parts of that society have no reason to be loyal to the whole, and that its institutions are fundamentally just a sham designed to take advantage of most of its members.

Now, Professor, are you attacking our own society, right? You're claiming that coercion is legitimate. Our society is in large part founded on the idea that the state is legitimate, that coercion is legitimate. If coercion is evil, then isn't our society legitimate? And then aren't you eroding then the norms, which have brought us peace and prosperity then? Yeah, let me do that. Good thing nobody listens to me.

I mean, I was thinking about what they called the democratic norms, which is partly democracy, but a bunch of things that are associated with it that are not exactly democracy, right? But, you know, like when you lose the election, you concede. But, you know, also like with the social justice war, it's just saying like everybody's racist, America's racist and so on, right? And sort of like... you know, in America, there's sort of a norm of respectful discourse. Like, that's one of the things that I'm worried about. There used to be, maybe. And I say this because, so this is somewhat of a digression. It's not exactly answering your question, but anyway. You know, one of the things that made me think about this was, so many years ago, I read that some, like, leaders from Iraq came to visit the United States so that they could kind of learn about how the political system works here. And, you know, they visited, like, a city hall meeting in Boulder or something like this. And, like, the main impression they had was they were struck by how respectful our discourse was.

And up until that point, I didn't realize that our discourse is respectful, right? But it was true compared to other countries, right? So like there'd be people who are an opposite size and they'd be like disagreeing with each other, but they'd be doing it in a basically respectful way, right? And apparently that doesn't happen in other countries. So one of the things I was worried about is that that's eroding. So anyway, okay.

And then in that blog post, I want to leave room for criticizing society. I want to leave room for saying there's some stuff that's very messed up that we need to change. So how do we do that and not be accused of wrongly violating the norm? So I didn't have that much of an answer to that. But basically, I'm thinking, well, you know have an alternative that you're saying we should do like don't just attack but say here's something we should be doing instead of what we're doing right and now we can compare these man can explain why this thing is better than the status quo right okay so that's like constructive criticism um what what i sort of sense from um left-wing ideology today is that it is a lot of attacking right just just like for the sake of um undermining confidence in america like there's a lot of just wanting to say that america is bad not not clearly for the sake of promoting something good instead right I want to say, I've been known to have a fair amount of criticisms of the government, but I also want to appreciate that it's a lot better than most governments. It's much better than the vast majority of governments that people have. Let's just keep that in mind. Let's not tear down the good stuff while we're trying to get rid of the bad stuff.

Yeah, yeah, that makes sense. But by the way, how long does it take you to write a blog post? Because they're all so good, and you write so many of them. Are you just writing in one state of flow? How much editing does it take? Yeah, I write it in an afternoon, but then I reread it multiple times. So I reread it a few times that day, but then reread it the next day, maybe just before it goes up. So I make small edits, which the small edits don't make that much difference probably. But yeah, the total amount of writing that I've done on that blog is

kind of a lot right it's like one a week so it's been going for a couple years so there's like whatever it is over 100 posts yeah and it's amazing how uh digestible uh not just your blogs are but uh just generally blog posts are just they're bingeable in a way that books often aren't like for example i've probably uh read most of scott alexander's writing and you know that's got to be at least a few books right but it does not feel that way at all you know it just feels like yeah it just goes by very fast and same with yours i've read i don't know if i've read a majority of yours but i've certainly read a large part of it right that's like you know that's high quality stuff right that's better than it's better than a normal book yeah yeah much better than academic books did you read as non-libertarian fq by the way i don't think so no yeah it's an interesting counter-argument uh that's worth checking out um so i want to ask you is it unethical of you to believe that coercion coercion is evil but your your job is subsidized by the fruits of that coercion is that unethical of you to have that kind of job

I don't know. Probably not. I don't think so. You know, I talked to Walter Block once, you know, a couple years ago. And, you know, in case anyone doesn't know, he's like a big time libertarian economist over at Tulane. Wait, no. Another university in New Orleans.

And his attitude was, you know, take as much money from the state as you can. Because, right? Like, you know, they're going to do something bad with it if you don't. And, you know, like, if you don't take it, they're not going to give it back. They're not giving it back to the taxpayers. They're just going to, you know, they're going to waste it on something else. But anyway, and, you know, I think his attitude was that you're sort of like helping to undermine the state. Good to take money from the state to undermine the state. But, you know, but I should tell you, like, the difference between University of Colorado and a private university is minimal.

So I think that the state provides something like 5% of our budget and something like that. Now, the state university, of course, universities are subsidized in general. So we get a subsidy in the same way that every other university gets a subsidy. Namely, all these students who are paying are super high prices. Most of them would not be paying if it weren't for financial aid provided by the government. So the government helps these people get all these loans, which they probably wouldn't take. So definitely, we, the university, are overcharging. But I mean, everybody's overcharging. And we're overcharging less than most of the universities. So not so bad.

Yeah, in the libertarian society, there would be less universities, right? Because there's a market distortion created by all the financial aid. So there'd be less of it. And would I still have a job? I don't know. Like some professors would still have jobs. It wouldn't go down to zero, but it would be cut down significantly. Yeah, I hope you have a job in that society. How would you... Sorry, go ahead. Yeah, I mean, like, you know, the government has its hands in almost everything, right? They have its hands in all kinds of industries. So, you know, like if you say, oh, well, I don't know, I can't work in an industry that is, like, benefiting from government distortions of the economy. There's a lot of things that you can't do, right?

Because what matters isn't whether nominally it's said to be a state institution or whatever, right? What matters is something like, I don't know how much benefit they're getting from the state or something, but there are lots and lots of industries that then you can work in. I know it can be a doctor, but there are going to be benefits from government regulations and so on. Right, yeah. I wonder how much stuff you could do, actually. You'd have to move into the woods to actually find some sort of trade. Let me just float a few other arguments against anarchic capitalism for you and see how you respond. So the first is a sort of Berkian argument, like we shouldn't try things that haven't worked before.

Yeah, yeah. I mean, yeah, you know, you can imagine somebody saying this back when the U.S. was founded, right? They could have said, this democracy thing, it never worked, right? They tried it in Athens, and it didn't work that well. And, you know, notice how all the countries in the world are dictatorships. This just shows that that's the natural state, right? Society involves a dictatorship, which is, you know, a lot like what people say about anarcho-capitalism, right? Like, we have states everywhere. It must be that that's the only stable society, right? Okay, now, you know, you might say correctly, well, it's kind of like...

kind of anecdotal like okay that's just one case right and so i'm not saying that that means that every radical change is worth 20 okay but okay but so you know that's just to prepare you for the fact that there could be big fundamental progress that we don't we don't want to rule out right at being overly conservative okay but we do want to be careful about the way we pursue progress right because like if you make radical changes you should expect there to be unexpected consequences right okay but so what you should do to mitigate this is to move kind of gradually right so um you know there's a lecture by brian kaplan that you can find online somewhere where um there was a title there's something like less than a minimum where his idea was you could have a subminimal state. And so the minimal state has police courts, a military legislature, something like that. You could have a subminimal state, which they privatized the police force, and then they could privatize the court system.

And so that doesn't completely eliminate them. It doesn't completely eliminate the state, but it makes it much smaller. And so you can imagine this process where the government could be progressively outsourcing police duties, which, by the way, they have done in some places. There are some places where the government will hire private security instead of using their own police. They could progressively outsource court duties. And there are some cases where that happens as well. There's some cases where the government court will refer you to a private arbitration. But they could start doing that more and more. And so the person who's worried that anarcho-capitalism would be a disaster, now they should answer at what point in the process they think the disaster would happen.

there's like you make this transition gradually like I don't see where a disaster would happen so you could get pretty close to anarchy but you know you still have like somebody that is um saying the rules like you don't have a police force anymore you don't have courts anymore but they are giving rules to the police and the courts so okay um and you know like if you're if you're already sympathetic to libertarianism we could eliminate all these you know business regulations and all this the government could be much smaller um and you think okay so do we need that last bit right which is like I guess the legislature and then I guess there's the military you might need that actually you know Well, what about the argument from the black swan that at every stage like this, you might have a 1% chance of destroying everything we might care about. And you make a similar argument actually in dialogues against, dialogues about ethical vegetarianism where you say, even if you alone stopping eating meat doesn't cause people to produce less meat, in expected value terms, if like every hundredth person stopping eating meat causes a decrease in animal suffering, it's still worth it for you to do that. In a similar way here, if, I don't know, if at every 10th increment of decreasing the state is possible that something bad happens, it's still good to not try it.

Yeah, but I mean, we don't have any evidence for that premise. We don't have any evidence that something bad happens at every 10th stage or whatever. I mean, the thing is like, Sure, anything that you try could have some unknown bad effect, right? And by definition, it's unknown, so I can't give an argument that it won't happen, right, because we haven't specified what it is, okay? I do want to say, though, that, like, bad stuff could happen from maintaining the status quo, too, right? And so, like, you know, in the book that I mentioned that, actually, there's a pretty good chance that the government is going to kill all of us, right? Like, I don't think that's an outlandish possibility, right? Like, they've actually, I think they've come kind of close to that a few times. Yeah, there were a few times when we were pretty close to a nuclear war.

right so like they could have killed everyone luckily they didn't but that doesn't mean that we can just like keep going right just keep going forever and it's always going to be fine right yeah we probably have people right now who are working on you know, bigger, more destructive weapons, right? More destructive, but cheaper, right? So we probably have people who are working on biological weapons or, you know, other things, nanotech weapons or things like that. Yeah, this actually leads to my next argument against anarchic capitalism, which is sort of the Nick Bostrom vulnerable worlds hypothesis, if you've heard of that. Basically, the idea is with every new technology you discover, there's some small chance that it allows us to destroy everything. Like it's a technology that allows one guy with 50 grand to destroy an entire city. And in such a world, you need strong government regulation in the sectors where this kind of technology is possible. And without a government that regulates this kind of development.

it's almost guaranteed that something bad's going to happen. Yeah. I mean, in fact, I think I had a blog post that was kind of about this, right? And which I guess I view as the strongest argument for a strong state. And yeah.

I think it was titled something about the case for tyranny or something like that. And then a bunch of people started arguing about whether I should have used the word journey there. It's not necessarily tyrannical, but it was just an argument that there needs to be somebody monitoring individuals in a pretty close way. So not having much privacy and able to stop them. So that might be the case if you're in a society in which one person has the ability to release a world-destroying weapon.

Right now, right now, that's not the case. But yeah, as technology advances, that could definitely happen, right? Because as technology advances, like just what it means is that you can produce larger effects with smaller efforts, right? But then isn't the worry that by the time you get to that point, you've already destroyed the state capacity to regulate that kind of stuff? And so you might as well preserve the state. And also for most of human history, if there's going to be a human history, that's going to be the state. I mean, if these weapons come around in 100 years, and there's like a million years of humanity left, then for most of it, we're going to need a state anyways. So what's the big benefit of doing anarcho-capitalism now? Yeah, I mean, that might be.

Right, right. I mean, like, I think this is the strongest argument for keeping the state. But, you know, I think there is a, like, there's an argument on the other side, which is, well, actually, the government is likely to be the ones who develop the deadly technology, right? So, so far, there's one technology that... would plausibly be capable of killing everyone. That's nuclear weapons. And it was created by the government and has only ever been used by the government. But in fact, I think every weapon of mass destruction has been created by governments. Most weapons have been created by governments, right? But isn't that a bit like saying in like the year 1800, well, everything could, if you're an atheist and arguing for atheism, somebody could think, well, all the bridges and all the really cool things, all the knowledge has been made by religious people. But you could respond, well, that's because there's been nobody else around, right? Like if there's not an anarcho-capitalist society where you're permitted to build nuclear weapons on your own, then obviously the state is... If everyone is...

religious then yeah all the good things are going to be created by religious people but not everyone is a government employee right you can't just build a nuclear bomb while states are dominant they won't let you but if you can then you might uh yeah so before the nuclear bomb was invented could could a private individual have invented it I don't know. I mean, after it was invented by the U.S. government, then the U.S. government would stop anyone else from building them. But before they, you know, before it had been discovered, I don't know why a private person couldn't have done it. Fair enough. Except that it's super expensive and, you know, like, there wasn't a person who had a good incentive to do it, I guess. But anyway, yeah, so you might think, yeah, but if we didn't have a government, then maybe there would be more, I don't know, would there be more people who are trying to build weapons against destruction? I wouldn't think that. I mean,

I understand why governments are doing this, right? Well, there's this thing called war that happens between states. And so they build all these standing armies. And so they're constantly looking for bigger and more powerful weapons, right? And so that's just like this constant pro-destructive technology lobby, right? So, I mean, it just looks like that's the way to accelerate the time that we get the world-destroying technology. Okay, but I'm not sure because...

you might say, yeah, even though the government is going to create this technology, like they're going to create the world destroying technology sooner, you might say, but they're still safer, right? Because like, you know, maybe private parties will develop that technology much later, but when they do, then someone's going to release it, right? Unless there's a government to stop them, okay? But by the way, like, I'm not sure that the government is going to stop it even if they continue to exist, right? So like, you know, one of the things I'd be worried about now is genetic engineering of biological weapons. So maybe somebody could engineer a virus that would be extremely dangerous and would cause the extinction of the species.

So that might happen just naturally, but it's a lot more likely if somebody's trying to make it happen, and that might just become cheaper and cheaper. So you might think, oh, we need the government to stop that from happening, although I'm not sure the government will actually stop it if we have them. And I think there's a fair chance the government will cause it because they might actually hire people deliberately to create biological weapons. So it's a little hard to say. The alternative you might want is you might want sort of distributed monitoring, like people monitoring each other, just regular people monitoring each other all the time, rather than like a single central authority monitoring everyone else. Yeah, blockchain, but for nuclear weapons. I mean, I think, is this Neil Stevenson's idea? I think I got this from some science fiction author, right? Everybody should be watching everyone else, not one organization watching everyone else. Is this from a book?

I just heard about this on the internet. Okay. Yeah, that's an interesting idea. Oh, final argument. A state in order to prevent people from torturing animals and eating them. Yeah. Yeah, so like if a state would actually do that, that would outweigh all of the other bad stuff they're doing, right? Like most other libertarians would not accept this, but this is obviously true. But when we have the government, what they actually do is they're actually supporting the meat industry.

Yeah. And so they're actually making it worse. So you might think, oh, but, you know, we can just change that. But no, it's not so easy. Most of the things the government does, it's not an accident that they're doing them, right? Like, well, I mean, they're obviously not going to ban meat when most people want it, right? Right. Like, you know, I think it was like, so I think Cory Booker was the first vegan presidential candidate I saw, but like, I think that was clearly a liability for him.

And in fact, there was a time when an interviewer asked him, hey, so are you going to try to make everybody vegetarian? And he was like, no, no, I'm not doing that. Because if he said yes, he's definitely out of the running. Right. Although he did propose some bills calling for regulation of animal cruelty. Although he didn't win. So I guess I would make your point for you. I mean, yeah. So that is a plausible. I think that society has to make more progress. So I think if the majority of people cared about animal welfare, then the government could pass regulations that would promote animal welfare. It would get a lot better.

right so but this will only happen after most of the problem is solved and then the government will come in and sort of like sweep up the remainder of it from like you know the backward people who are still promoting cruelty yeah yeah uh okay so uh now let's let's do a game of underrated overrated the rules of course is this thing underrated overrated and you can pass if you want and you can also offer a brief explanation for why you think so so you wrote a few pieces recently a few blog posts about what students should be learning in school and in college uh one thing you didn't mention either for or against was like a coding class and this has been proposed by a bunch of people recently that because of the dominance of computers in our society everybody needs to learn how to code what do you think of this idea Let's see, is it overrated or underrated? Maybe about correctly rated, I suppose. I mean, I think it's useful, but I don't agree that everyone needs to learn to code, right? So, like, I think some people, basically, I think people who would be reasonably good at it should learn it. And some people would just be terrible at it, so there's no point, right? Like, they could learn to do some basic stuff that would never be useful, so.

Yeah. You mentioned in one of your blog posts that if you didn't get into grad school for philosophy, you were considering becoming a computer programmer. So did you learn how to code in college? I mean, I took one course on Pascal, which was a programming language that I guess nobody uses anymore. But it was not enough for me to do anything useful with it. But many years later, I discovered that there's a language called Game Maker Language, and it's really good for writing games. So I tried writing a game using that. Kind of fun. The class of people called public intellectuals.

Oh, yeah, I mean, they're greatly overrated by some and underrated by others, I guess. Like, I like public intellectuals. So, I mean, I think the academic intellectuals underrate the public intellectuals because they're like, oh, yeah, these public intellectuals are not being rigorous enough or they're not, like, citing all the academic literature. The thing is, yeah, the reason they're not doing that is no one will listen to them if they start blabbing on about boring stuff, like, you know, boring little details that are in the academic literature, okay? Yeah, I guess underrated. Right. How about intellectuals outside academia, or maybe not even intellectuals, but thinkers outside academia who have a blog but aren't associated with an academic institution? So, for example, people like Scott Alexander. Yeah, I mean, like, well, Scott Alexander is probably correctly rated because, like, I think that he has an extremely high reputation among people who know who he is, right? Right. Although, I guess not enough people know who he is. But, you know, about non-academic intellectuals more generally, I don't know. So, I mean, most non-academic intellectuals, I think, are not good.

and like so like not not worth reading or they wouldn't be worth it to me to read i don't think worth it to other people to read but um but that's you know i'm like i'm not trying to be a snob or whatever um but i think it's i think because you learn stuff when like when you go to graduate school and you get the phd they actually teach you some stuff right and one of the things one of the problems is like if um if you don't go through that kind of training like people are naturally lazy and like in order to do stuff that's really good and useful um it requires work and effort and stuff like this that is not it requires some stuff that's not so fun right and then and um you're like oh reading a bunch of literature and you're finding out what people really think right and um you're just not gonna do that unless you have like well few people will do it unless they have somebody else who's telling them you have to do this and that's what happens when you're in graduate school right yeah yeah it's a milgram experiment but for academic discipline yeah it's like so you know like um I run into people on the internet and whatever, and sometimes I get email from random people. And there are people who have written their treatise on something or whatever, and they just don't realize that they don't know what's going on.

They just haven't read the stuff that's written on the topic that they're writing about. So they don't know that they're A, reinventing the wheel, but B, doing a simplistic version of it. They're defending a view that has already been defended, but they're defending the simplest, least adequate version of it because they haven't looked at all the objections that caused you to be modified, and they don't know the reasons why it's wrong, and they don't know what the alternative views are, so they can't adequately respond to them. They'll respond to alternatives that are stupid and don't need to be discussed. So that's a thing that happens.

If you were outside of, if you for some reason didn't get into grad school, but let's see on the side, you were still publishing a blog. How much worse do you think you would be without the benefit of grad school? I don't know. I mean, you know, there's a possibility that it's actually a selection effect rather than the training effect, right? Like the people who have patients, people who have enough patients to do good work can make it through graduate school. Right. If you don't have patients, you'll be excluded by that, right? Yeah. So it's possible that it would still be good. But I mean, I think that, let's see. Actually, I mean, a lot of the stuff that goes on on the blog is kind of social commentary, which I think doesn't require that much of, you know, reading literature or stuff like that. So like most of that would be the same.

But, like, if I were writing about issues that are debated in academic philosophy and I didn't know the literature, like, it just wouldn't be good, right? And, like, you know, like, my undergraduate papers just weren't good, right? They were good for undergraduate papers, okay? But they weren't good for, you know, academic papers. Right. A peer review. Oh, peer review, underrated, or overrated? I don't know. Yeah, probably, it's probably overrated, I guess. So the thing is, like, people think that, I guess, right, I guess the average opinion is that it's a pretty good quality control mechanism. And I think that...

probably most people don't realize how lame it is. So you don't get paid for doing these reviews, right? Which means that not that many people want to do it. So you have this editor who's trying to find peer reviewers, and they have to keep going down the list. I've never been an editor, so I'm assuming this is what happens. You try to get top people in the area of the paper to review it, and they say, no, I'm too busy, and it's not in my interest to do this. They don't say that last part, but that's what you're thinking. I have no self-interest in doing this review for you for free, so can't do it. And so they just go down the list, okay? And you have things where graduate students are reviewing papers.

And then you have situations where the person who's being criticized by the paper is reviewing the paper. And I know that that happens because they've sent to me papers that are criticizing me. And I think that I'm a fine reviewer. I'm perfectly objective anyway, but I don't trust everyone to be objective. And just my experience reading referee reports, I often think, oh, this guy did not read this carefully at all. He's raising some objection that I answered and he doesn't seem to be aware that I answered it. Or he's totally misunderstood and I clearly explained what I meant and he's misunderstanding it. And it would make sense that they wouldn't read it carefully because they have no stake in it.

um the the editor would have more of a stake in it right because like it reflects on the quality of the journal so it's an anonymous review so it doesn't reflect on that person no one will ever know if you did a bad job of reviewing so yeah um okay how about online education oh um i mean it's probably like it's a good way of learning if that's what you want right but i think it's a less good way of getting prestige right so which is what people actually want so um i mean i guess i think um most people So most people don't actually want the education. They want the prestige. But also, most people don't realize that that's what most people want. So online education, I don't think that it's going to take over. It would if people just wanted knowledge. So people don't realize why it's not taking over. But that's the reason, right?

Actually, by the way, if you just want the knowledge, you don't have to pay somebody a bunch of money. Not even for online courses, right? If you just want knowledge, almost all of this is on the internet. You can get great education for free, just reading sites on the internet. Or even better yet, if you think that there's something ineffable about being there in person, you can still go in person. Nobody's going to stop you. In fact, professors will often even grade your stuff, even if you're not in the class. Yeah. Sorry, go ahead. Yeah, I would be happy to have extra people show up who actually want to learn in my class. But to be clear, I'm not grading your paper. I'm not grading.

Yeah. It's funny. At my university, you need your ID to get into the gym, but you don't need any ID whatsoever to go into any class you want, which goes to show you what they think people are actually likely to steal or try to use voluntarily. Stealing the knowledge, right? Yeah. I think the in-person education is better. It's a better experience. But the thing is, it's just not better enough that it would justify paying whatever $10,000 or whatever people are paying. Right. I agree. Pronatalism. I asked you about this. The average person's probably going to eat meat.

oh i see um yeah i mean so i assume that that's going to end at some point right right and so um it will be better to have more people i am to some degree worried about the population dwindling right because as um as people become wealthier and their living standard goes up you know their fertility goes down and like it's at the point now where in the wealthy countries like the fertility of well-off people is below replacement rate right so i am somewhat worried about the human species dwindling, right? Just as we become good, just as the moral progress reaches the point where it's better for us to be around and not the population will be dwindling and maybe we'll go extinct from just, you know, not deciding to have kids, right? And it'll be around to enjoy the moral progress. What do you think the idea that children have comparable or even equivalent rights against coercion as adults? I mean, I think they have comparable rights against malicious coercion. I can have that, right? But, you know, about paternalistic coercion, like that seems justified to me.

I mean, I don't have like a particularly involved argument for that. Like I don't have an interesting or surprising argument for that, right? I guess I just have a conventional view, which is that, you know, like these children just don't know what they're doing. They don't have enough knowledge and they just need somebody to take care of them, right? Right. But at what point do you think that now there's an expectation that you can't just tell this person what to do? So like 12, 16, 18? I mean, you know, it increases gradually, right? Yeah. And it also could vary depending on the maturity of the individual.

Yeah. I mean, I don't think I can say a hard and fast rule. Now, you know, you might think like there's some people who are not mature at 18, right? Like they still need someone to take care of them then. But, you know, what can we do? Like we need to have a general rule for society in general, right? So I guess it's kind of reasonable to pick 18 as the time you become an adult. I don't know. Right.

So the claim is that, at least after a certain age, saying that this person is not entitled, does not have certain rights, is equivalent or comparable to saying that a particular race of people shouldn't have rights. In that, like, maybe you can come up with some explanation for why they can't handle those rights, but at the end of the day, just human dignity means that you have to respect those rights. Yeah. I mean, yeah, so, like, the way that children are treated is somewhat like slaves, right? Like, no rights, parents just tell them what to do all the time, right? Yeah.

And, you know, is it better than slavery? Well, you know, fortunately, most parents love their children in a way that most masters do not love their slaves. So things work out better. Right. But also, you know, it was factually true that the children couldn't make decisions for themselves. It was not true that the slaves couldn't make decisions for themselves. We just weren't letting them. Yeah. You might think that like, well, there actually are some adults who are like not really suited to run their own lives, like mentally retarded people or something. Yeah. It doesn't mean that you can treat them as slaves, but they probably do need like a guardian.

um to tell them what to do right um is it okay like what if they don't want to listen to the guardian is okay to force them i don't know you know probably depends on the situation right like if they want to go play in traffic i guess yes right yeah okay final two questions or actually final three questions i didn't notice the third one there um first of all uh at least in my opinion among the philosophers i know of that are living um you seem to address the big questions uh more prolifically creatively and excessively uh what's the humor production function how are you able to be this uh this productive oh um i don't know It's partly because I'm smart. It's partly because I love philosophy. If you don't love it and you're just doing it as a job, then you won't do that much of it. In the academic world, there's not really incentives for producing blog posts or stuff like that. There's not incentives for producing public philosophy. So you don't get prestige from it. The other academics are not so much impressed or whatever. And literally, in my department, we literally have a point system for publications.

Like, you get a performance review every year, and, like, we assign points for each publication. There's no points for blog posts. Although that might change in the future. But anyway, so, yeah, so you'd only do this if, like, you're just, like, well, I mean, I'm on a mission, right? I'm on a mission to promote rationality in society. Yeah. And, like, you know, like, I'm in philosophy not just as a job, but to get a paycheck or whatever, or to get prestige or any of that. Like, I'm trying to improve the world intellectually, right? Yeah. What do you think about the impact of intellectuals versus entrepreneurs slash engineers in shaping how the world turns out?

yeah good question um you know so like i mean this makes me think of an example so think of the example of um there's peter singer and then there's um the people who are like um beyond the beyond meat people who don't create that company and you know these other companies like the impossible burger and the people who are doing the um synthetic meat okay so um i think peter singer is kind of the reason why people are doing that I think those people, like the entrepreneurs, I think are animal welfare advocates or something like this. And it's largely because of Peter Singer and other philosophers like Tom Reed. But also like...

you know, after writing that book, apart from convincing the entrepreneurs, like he tries to convince a bunch of ordinary people. Like I go to, like I try to convince students, I write this book. And I think that that part is having a lot less influence, right? Like it's super hard to convince people to change their life in a way that's not in their personal self-interest, you know, for ethical reasons. You can get like a few percent. You can change a few percent of people's lifestyle for ethical reasons because that's how many people care about more Latin. Anyway, but...

A few percent of those people are entrepreneurs who are going to make a big difference. If you want to assess who's making a bigger difference, it's hard to say. The entrepreneur probably wouldn't be doing it if it weren't for the philosophy. But apart from the entrepreneur, the philosopher is having a much smaller influence on society. Is your goal then with your books not to convince, not just to convince people like, oh, you're right, but then to get some of them to build the so-called machinery of freedom? Are you trying to inspire entrepreneurs more so than just convince people?

I guess. I mean, I don't have a very specific plan, right? I just have the idea that it would be good if there were more people who had true beliefs, you know, about important philosophical matters. And I don't know how it's going to happen, but in some way that is going to improve society. I kind of think that it goes from the top down, so to speak. That is, if you convince the elites, then the rest of society will go along. I know Brian Kaplan thinks that you got to get the elites while they're young, because that's when they'll change their minds. Are you trying to convince future elites, people in college, or are you trying to convince elites as the existing elites?

Yeah, I mean, I guess I try to work on all of them, but, you know, like, Kaplan's probably correct. Like, it's a lot harder to get people who have already formed their beliefs and, you know, have been there for a few decades, right? Yeah. Yeah. Oh, so next question. What are your three favorite books? Oh, let's see. It would be three of my books, so. That you did not write yourself. Oh, okay. I don't know.

Like, I would probably have to spend a lot longer to actually accurately answer that. Yeah, that's all right. I liked The Fountainhead a lot, that novel. And I guess, like, you know, I had an influence on me in, actually, Ayn Grant had an influence on me in doing philosophy, right? Although she was not a professional philosopher and ultimately was not very good at philosophy, she still influenced me to do philosophy. What else?

yeah i mean i'm you know like i might so like when you ask me this and i haven't thought for a long time i'm biased towards books that i read recently okay so i like the book time and chance by david albert because it's just like fascinating right just fascinating stuff about um you know what physics teaches us about the nature of the universe and so on um and also i like the cosmic landscape by um um i've got his name now anyway um you know which uh was about the multiverse theory which i just find amazing it's just just an amazing fascinating idea maybe the quantum multiverse um Well, there's sort of like different versions of the multiverse, but I guess like he thinks that it comes out of string theory, right? I don't know. And, you know, there are different ways there could be multiverse. There could be like just really far away, other universes, that the space in between our universe and the other universe is expanding so fast that there's no way to ever reach the other universe. So they're effectively isolated, right? I'm sorry, I can't remember this guy's name now. Anyway, but, you know, there are lots of good books. I like the myth of the rational voter, right? That was very good. And, you know, just thinking about why politics works the way that it does.

Yeah. And then the final question, what advice would you have for a philosophically inclined 20-year-old who doesn't want to go into philosophy as an academic discipline but is still interested in philosophy? I don't know. Like, you know, my first advice is buy all my books. But I mean, like advice for like what? Like what are they trying to accomplish? Let's say they're technically inclined as well. So engineering is entrepreneurship. Oh, I see. I don't know. Would you advise working in specific fields? Is there some thing you'd advise in terms of excellence and getting good at what you're doing? Or just where the important problems are? Yeah, I mean, like I have a...

like i would give advice from the standpoint of self-interest to people like um so like okay i mean that this is probably not what you're asking about right like you know how you can you can be happy or something right but anyway okay this is what i figured out it's very simple but the secret to happiness is first of all having um solid meaningful relationships so like hang out with people that you're along well with and develop close relationships with them right and uh and like people that are not beneficial just cut them out don't don't hang around with people who are not beneficial to you right and like this is obvious super obvious but a lot of people don't do this like we just keep having this boyfriend just like i don't know try to change the person or whatever you're not gonna change people okay then the other thing is um meaningful work right so like going to a career that feels like you're doing something meaningful But it's got to make enough money to pay the bills, right? But it needs to feel like you're doing something meaningful because otherwise, when you get later in your life, you're going to be like, I have a lot of money, but boy, sure, I wasted my life. And then smaller scale advice. At some point, I'm probably going to like, maybe I'll put this in blog posts. I'll put my advice for people about buy a house. If you're ready to be somewhere for a few years, buy a house or a condominium or something like that because it's a super good investment. And then when you have money,

invest in index funds, you know, like, don't try to beat the market because you're probably not going to. Right. There's stuff like that, right? Anyway, okay, but that's probably not what you might as know about. You might as well know, like, oh, well, how can we improve the world? I don't know, that's really hard, right? Like on a small scale, my idea is to model rationality, right? Like interact with people in a way that is reasonable and rational.

And part of the reasonableness is you listen to them and try to actually understand what their point is before saying your thing. Don't just only be thinking about your point. And my idea is if we get enough people doing that, maybe the culture will improve. Yeah, let's hope so. OK, so those are all my questions. Professor Heimer, thank you so much for your time. I really appreciate talking to you. This was a lot of fun. Thanks for having me.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Dwarkesh Podcast?

This episode is 1 hour and 37 minutes long.

When was this Dwarkesh Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on May 28, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Dwarkesh Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.