Skip to content
Michelle Stone Have an Agenda? Her Ph.D. Program episode artwork

Nov 17, 2026 22 min

Michelle Stone Have an Agenda? Her Ph.D. Program

from Gospel Tangents Podcast Hosted by RickB

Does Michelle Stone have an Agenda? When I asked Michelle Stone whether her paper on Helen Mar Kimball was really an effort to poke holes in the traditional story, she pushed right back. I asked because I knew many listeners would be thinking it. Michelle has a reputation, as she puts it, whether she likes it or not, and her critics often say she has an agenda. “I didn’t have an agenda when I believed in polygamy,” she told me. “I didn’t have an agenda when I studied the scriptures and changed my mind about polygamy.” She says she has changed her mind more than once, and each time it was because of what she found in the sources. https://youtu.be/zV_yucnMoX8 Don’t miss our other conversations with Michelle: https://gospeltangents.com/people/michelle-stone/ Copyright © 2026 Gospel Tangents All Rights Reserved Award Winning Paper Her award-winning paper, “Constructing Helen: Absences, Ambiguities, & Adjustments,” is a historiography, and Michelle explains what that means. There is the past, what actually happened. There is history, historians doing their best to reconstruct the past from the sources we have. And there is historiography, the history of the history: what historians have said about a subject over time. Michelle traced every piece of Helen’s story she could find, in chronological order, from the earliest source forward. That’s why the paper is long. The assignment only required 35 pages. Polygamy, she says, “is such an octopus.” The tentacles go everywhere. Her conclusion is that Helen’s story “has been mediated by male ecclesiastical authorities,” and that we need to listen to Helen’s own voice. That doesn’t mean believing every woman, Michelle says, because the women’s accounts sometimes contradict each other. It means separating a woman’s authentic voice from affidavits she believes were written for women by men like Joseph F. Smith and then signed. Believing Emma Michelle says she expected to side with Emma Smith against Helen. Then she found Helen’s patriarchal blessing, which hadn’t been used in the traditional narrative, and decided she had to read everything Helen wrote and published in her lifetime. In the end, she says, one document dated 1881 and meant to come out 50 years later stands apart from thousands of other things Helen wrote in which she never says she was Joseph’s wife. Along the way, Michelle says she came to care deeply about Helen. She is careful about what she is and isn’t claiming. Michelle doesn’t plan to write a rebuttal to Brian Hales‘s work on Joseph Smith’s polygamy, and she cites him positively in her current paper. What she objects to is the idea that the origin of polygamy is settled. She points to what she sees as an 1839 revelation from Heber C. Kimball that polygamy needed to be restored, and says she spends most of her time in books like Todd Compton‘s In Sacred Loneliness reading the footnotes, checking which sources support each claim. She is frank that saying Joseph was not a polygamist has cost her, and that she has been treated badly for it, though she also admits she has had to learn historical methodology and could have engaged better early on. Her professors at UVU, she says, simply looked at her work. Michelle and I have had our disagreements over the years too, but we can argue and still be friends. Where is Michelle’s Ph.D Program? Then the news: Michelle has started a PhD in history at Arizona State University. It wasn’t the offer she expected to accept, but she says it was the right one, with a lot of Arizona history in what she studies. In Part 5, coming Friday, I ask the big question: was Helen Mar Kimball married to Joseph Smith? Members can get the whole interview right now at patreon.com/gospeltangents. Listen to the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts. Chapters 0:00 What Is a Historiography? 2:29 Journal Paper vs. Senior Thesis 5:18 “Polygamy Is Such an Octopus” 7:15 Listening to Helen’s Own Voice 8:39 Poking Holes in the Traditional Narrative? 9:16 “I Didn’t Have an Agenda” 10:28 The 1881 Jubilee Box Letter 13:18 Not a Verdict on the Marriage? 14:32 Rebuttal to Brian Hales? 15:35 Heber C. Kimball’s 1839 Revelation 16:15 Following the Sources 20:10 “Rick and I Have Had Words” 20:40 Breaking News: Arizona State University Don’t miss our other conversations with Michelle: https://gospeltangents.com/people/michelle-stone/ Copyright © 2026 Gospel Tangents All Rights Reserved

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Michelle Stone Have an Agenda? Her Ph.D. Program

0:00 22:25

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Gospel Tangents Podcast?

This episode is 22 minutes long.

When was this Gospel Tangents Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on November 17, 2026.

Can I download this Gospel Tangents Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.