Skip to content
Mini Episode 11: Reese's Nutrageous vs. Outrageous episode artwork

Apr 28, 2019 29 min

Mini Episode 11: Reese's Nutrageous vs. Outrageous

from You Tried Dat?? Hosted by You Tried Dat?? Inc.

It's the Reese's showdown you've all been waiting for. The You Tried Dat?? crew finally settles the score: is it better to add Reese's Pieces to a candy bar or not? Reese's Nutrageous goes up against Reese's Outrageous with Pieces. The gang also discusses what to do when a collection of snacks shows up in your mailbox.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Mini Episode 11: Reese's Nutrageous vs. Outrageous

0:00 29:16
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

In this corner if you're feeling courageous It might be advantageous for you to maintain homeostasis so that you can devour the audacious Reese's outrageous And in this corner you may soon be feeling gracious or even flirtatious on the basis of how contagious and vivacious this famous treat is It's Reese's Nut Rages By vs. By Reese's Reese's You tried it. So Reese's showdown here on You Tried Dead, Nick Novak with our Pales, Jay and Handcag. Howdy.

Nick Eiger. Hello. And Jay, your dream has finally come true. We have a couple of Reese's products, chocolate and peanut butter.

How excited are you about this show? I mean, you guys know, I've been pulling for this episode for like, what, like nine months or something I've been talking, we should do this. Basically, ever since the outrageous came out, I was like, we need to do this so that we can finally get the definitive, you know, is something better with or without pieces in it. And I thought this was good because, you know, compared to like the Reese's Cups, where I think that it's pretty much a consensus that it's the Reese's Cups and stuff are not quite as good without the pieces mixed into them.

But sorry, I just like had a complete like verbal nerd gasm about these Reese's. Anyway, I'm very excited here. You also had a very literal orgasm about them. Yeah.

Yeah. Well, it took us, it took us so long because it was really hard to find the nut rages, right? Like it doesn't seem to be in a lot of stores anymore. I had a really hard time finding it.

And I eventually just went on to the Walgreens website and looked up the product. And then you can see which stores have it. And it was just page after page of sold out in Big Red. I finally found one that said like three left.

So I waited till after work and went straight there. And when I got there, there was just a Reese's, there was a Reese's Nut rages box that was filled with outrageous all over it. And I thought, no. So I dug through and there were like three or four from at the bottom of the box.

So how far away from your house was this Walgreens? Did you drive like 50 miles or something? It was moderately convenient. I was not saying I wouldn't have driven to get it, but I got lucky.

I'm just picturing you and your hands and knees snooped in front of the box like, showing candy bars over your shoulder, digging through the box, trying to find the one. The fuck is this? Check, I was doing. And then once we had to, not these products particularly, but I was dropping off some other products today to Geiger.

And I said, I'm going to drop some stuff off in your mailbox on my way past your house today, but you won't be home. He said, yeah. And so you have one of those mailboxes that's not out by the street. It's a walk up one little like right by your door.

And so it's in a shopping, a plastic shopping bag. There's a bunch of stuff in there. One of which is some cookies that we're going to do another episode that are in a plastic baggie. So no longer rats.

And so Geiger, you can pick up the third one. So actually, so I get a ping from somebody at work today that just says, you have a podcast? And I'm like, oh God, no, what happened? So I am very careful about...

Let's see, get this out. Look, I want to grow this podcast. And someday when we're rich and famous, this will all be funny. But for now, well, I have a real job and I don't necessarily want the team I manage, nor my boss listening.

We talk about polar bear calm and show their cheetah molesting people. I can't imagine why not. Yeah, I'm like, this is bad. So I went into his office and I'm like, so what's this about the podcast?

It's like, do you have a podcast? I'm like, perhaps. And so I'm like, how did you know? Is it called my wife has friends with your wife on Facebook?

We're good friends. This is one of the guys that goes on the fishing trip. And he's like, oh, your wife just posted something about, like, we're feeling the love. Nick and I are so lucky, like, somebody just dropped off a bag of goodies in our mailbox.

But they should all, oh, anyone knows that they're going to wind up on Nick's podcast. And I'm like, everyone who knows that? No, he knows that? I was like, what the fuck?

So I literally text Betsy and Mike, Novak dropped those off for the express reason of being on the podcast. He goes, oh, why would someone just, she goes, I thought it was kind of a random bag to drop off. Yeah, no shit. That's kind of like M&M's and crackers and all kinds of like, who would just randomly stuff this in our mailbox other than one of us?

Plus there's cookies in there, cookies in there that weren't in the package, which you really should not eat or be happy about. Is someone sticking pre-ramps? This is clearly either like from Novak or one of our fans is a psychotic stalker who has like found out where you live and just shoving random snacks. And those cookies are for sure filled with cum.

And knows my address. Yep. Found out where you live because they knew you had a mailbox that's not out on the street. And they went through all of Street View in the entire United States until they found out that matches that description.

I think I found out why it's tough to expand our listenership and that when one person finds out we have a podcast, we panic and we do everything we can to make sure nobody else finds out. I'm just going to have to go to and re-edit all the podcasts and take out all the dirty jokes and replace them with clean ones. So Chester, she was like, this is the side effect of like us having respectable jobs or is it? Are you a jizmapper at a porn store?

Oh, you're right. I am. But I don't want them to know that I also verbally mop of jiz. Does that make sense?

What? I spend once a week, I spend an hour mapping up your two, both your guys' verbal jiz that use view all of them. All right. Well, let's build some.

Which is worse. Verbal jiz or verbal diarrhea? Which one is worse? It's worse.

Well, I don't know why I'm even giving this thought. Novak, Novak, hold on. What's worse? It's way more thought than that.

Yeah, let's worse. Diarrhea of the mouth or jiz of the mouth. And this is why I know that I can know about our podcast. All right.

Here's a totally unrelated story. Tell me what you guys think about this. So going through the drive-through of a doughnut chaffinear and I ordered the doughnuts. I get home, which is only about five minutes away.

And I have the wrong doughnuts. Not because they gave me somebody else's doughnuts, but because they just fucked up my order. I asked for a vanilla long-gen that gave me a chocolate long-gen. It's not what I want.

So if you're... Wait, so hold on. What was your order and what did you get? This is important.

Well, a couple of them, like, I don't remember how many donuts we had exactly, but I had my kids with me. So we had their doughnuts. Definitely two of the doughnuts were mixed up, one of which was a vanilla long-gen was made into it, a chocolate long-gen. And another one was just flat out wrong, like a double chocolate doughnut was a bear claw or something like that.

So I'm now five minutes from the place. Tell me in the same scenario, what are the chances that you drive back to get the correct doughnuts? So that's what I was asking because it really depends on the doughnuts. So in a vanilla chocolate long-gen situation, I would not go back because I prefer one to the other, but I do like them both.

But if I were to double chocolate doughnut and I got a fucking bear claw, not only would I drive back, I would burn that doughnut store to the ground. That's a serious fuck up. How do you mess that? They're not that alike.

They're probably not even next to each other on the shelf. So in that case, I would totally go back. But I'm also a guy who one time went back to... I got a Philly cheese steak from this place and I came back to my house and started to eat it and there was not quite enough cheese on it.

So I went back to get more cheese. So I don't know, I might need the wrong person to ask. You say not quite enough? That sounds like a pretty small amount.

It was probably like 70% the amount of cheese I normally get. 70% of it. Yeah, I scraped it all off onto an atomic scale and measured like, oh, there's this many... I don't know what the fucking atomic scale is.

What would you do, guy? I probably wouldn't go back if it was just the wrong doughnut. I guess it would depend on how wrong it was or if there was an algae or an implication and also how far away the doughnut place was. I don't put it in lazy and I'll eat almost anything.

I probably wouldn't go back. I've just started now sending steaks back if they overcook them because I hate eating an overcooked steak and I feel like I'm spending enough money on the steak where I don't feel bad sending it back usually. But generally if someone screws up a minor detail about an order of mine, I'll just probably eat it. It's not a real big deal.

All right. Well, that's not too much because I'm definitely looking forward to... Wait, what did you do? You need to go back for the doughnut?

Of course not. No way. And I think part of that has to do with having kids. If it was just me jumping in the car and running back is different.

Sure. To load the kids up in the car again, it's too much of a pain in the ass. So just eat whatever doughnut I got. Yeah.

And also a doughnut's like a dollar. Right. So in the end it's not that big deal. But it is disappointing, especially because I get older.

I try not to just eat whatever doughnuts I want without thinking of living past 65. So now when I do rarely have a doughnut, I really want the right doughnut. Let's get into these candy bars. And we usually use a five point scale, but in our mini-ups, our head to heads, we generally use a scale that's made up by Chad.

Chad, you have a scale. Sure. So we're going to do the nut rages comparison bars here. So we've got a three point system here to compare these two bars.

So starting at the top, we've got, I want to put this in my gut rages. Then in the middle, we've got, oh shit, hold on, you have to cut this out. Well, let me see. No way.

What the hell was it? A little known fact, we don't actually edit the podcast. We just do them perfectly straight off the top. What's the last one?

Maybe the, the, the, the, the, the, oh, um, in a rut. In a rut. In a rut. The middle one was, it's got me stuck in a rut rages.

That's exactly what it was. And then the bottom one is, I wouldn't even feed this to King Tutrages. There we go. That was what I can see why you couldn't remember that.

That was all worth it for rut rages and tutrages. All right. What's the explanation on the last one? There's just no other words rhyme with nut.

I mean, what bot does, but I was like, God, we talk about asses so much on this fucking podcast and I was just trying to be clever. Plus I figured we're going to love these things and we're not going to use any of the two bottom ratings anyway. So it gives a shit. So there we go.

All right. Now I'm going to come out and say that I've never had either one of these. Whoa. Okay.

Have you guys had them? You both had them? Yeah. Both.

I've had no, I've had no rages. And I'm a big fan of them. I'm not a rages. Spoiler alert.

Yeah. I think it's outstanding. And for a while, I was actually obsessed with the outrageous with pieces. I don't know why they call it outrageous with pieces.

But whatever, I don't work for their marketing department. And so I, for me, I've gone back and forth. Like I don't actually know which one I'm going to like better here. So should we start with the nut rages?

Yeah. Let's go with the nut rages since it's the classic. Now one thing that I thought was a little weird at first, if you look at both of them, the nut rages is 240 calories. But the outrageous with pieces is only 200 calories.

So by adding the pieces, you lose 40 calories. What are they subtracting with the peanuts? But it is also a smaller bar. It's like a, it's a six grams smaller.

If you're not familiar with the nut rages, the description, milk chocolate, peanuts, peanut butter and caramel. One thing that you taste a lot of here, which you don't get with a lot of Reese's products, is just a real like pure peanut, like you can, not in a peanut butter form, but just like a crunchy peanut, just whole peanuts in there. That is a damn good fucking bar, man. I've always really liked the peanut butter from the nut rages bar.

Like it's kind of creamy and it has like a really good peanut taste to me. And also the other, I mean, the peanuts probably come up with that. But for some reason, I always just like really liked the peanut butter here. Now I wish that it had, it is very good.

I wish that it had a little more peanut butter. Agree. The peanut butter ratio was a little higher and the just regular actual peanut quantity was lower. Now I remember when this came out, I used to get a confused a lot with the Reese's fast break.

You guys had Reese's fast break because they were both candy bars and the Reese's. I don't particularly like fast break at all. So I was very hesitant to try this for a while because I was like, oh fast break is bad. This is probably going to be bad too.

And then I finally bought it. And I was like, my God, I've been missing out on this this whole time. The fast break has new good, I think, doesn't it? Yeah, I don't think it's a very good new get.

I don't know. The combination just doesn't work for me. I remember the candy bar. I remember it being there.

I don't remember what it is or how it tasted. One thing I think that sticks out with this is that the bites aren't that consistent. Like with a normal, obviously if you have a Reese's peanut butter cup or something, each bite, you know what you're going to get. Even with the Snickers, I feel like it's pretty well dispersed.

I think I think three or four bites and some have a much higher peanut butter content than others. So some bites are just better bites than others, which is not what something I'm used to so much with the candy bar. Fair point. All right, guy, go ahead.

Sorry to talk. Wait, should we dig into the outrageous first? Yeah, I have an eating another one. I know I'm a child.

I've got the two candy bars. So the outrageous same thing says milk chocolate, peanut butter, and caramel. And it just has presumably the same thing, but with instead of peanuts, Reese's pieces inside of it. Are the pieces regular size or are they the mini?

They're the mini. No, I'm wondering if this is going to suffer the same fate a little bit that the Hershey bar did that had the mini, I mean, I'm in it, because it's just peanut butter in the middle and then a Reese's pieces in the middle, they're just full of peanut butter. So all you're really adding is texture through the shell. That's true.

But there is something about the Reese's pieces shell and, you know, probably it is almost the exact same ingredients as the M&M shell, but I'm willing to go to the grave saying that the Reese's pieces shell tastes better than the M&M shell. Are you dying? On what basis? I don't know.

I'd like it better. On the basis that it tastes better. The M&M shell is harder. I do think than the Reese's pieces shell.

If you just were to bite into an M&M and bite into a Reese's pieces, I feel like it's easier to get through. It's a softer bite into the Reese's piece. Man, this is hard. This is hard.

And you're hard too. I can see. Since we're on Reese's. Yeah.

This is hard. I have a third nut rages bar in my pants. But Geiger here are usually lead off man. So you're going to have to make the call here.

And if we give both a high rating, then we're going to have to also tell a choice between the two. Right. So I have already forgotten the scale. What is the scale?

I mean, I would even feed it to King Tut, which is I don't know. I mean, it doesn't make sense. I don't even feel like King Tut or what? You wouldn't like him.

So we're not giving him. You wouldn't feed a two King Tut rages. Not King Tut. Oh, does this mean we don't like King Tut?

Yeah, but does it mean because the candy bar sucks, like I'm not going to give it to a King of his caliber. Yeah, that one sounds better. Look at no bad reverse justification for your shitty scale. Look, all I'm saying is that when I went to the Valley of the Kings in Egypt, which for real, I did go there and I saw where his tomb was, I looked at the hieroglyphics engraving on the wall and one of them said, get these fucking nut rages bars out my face.

That's what it said. So you shouldn't give him the bar. There you go. Okay.

Okay. Anyways, the other two were the middle was I'm stuck in a rut rages and the top one was I want to shove it in my gut rages. Right. Shove it into my gut, which is not how you eat food, but that's fine.

Maybe it's not how you eat food. You could do it to King Tucker because he's right. I can't. I can't actually put food in my mouth because I'm too busy verbally jizzing to actually fit food.

I've defined alternate feeding methods. All right. I like both of these. I mean, we already knew I love nut rages.

I am going to say I like nut rages better. I'm just going to put that out there up front on front street. I fucking around fellas. All right.

I don't. I think it maybe is because the peanuts as much as I said, I wish there was more peanut butter. I agree with no back. I wish there was more peanut butter less peanuts in it.

Maybe the peanuts were what was giving it the peanut flavor all along that just sounds stupid, but you know what I mean? Yeah, he's being out. I wonder how it tastes like peanut. Maybe the sugar is what made it sweet.

No, but I meant like I thought it was the peanut butter taste that I liked. Maybe it's really the peanut taste. I just found the second one to be a little. It was still very good, but for some reason it didn't taste as peanut buttery and I don't know why, even though theoretically there's more peanut butter in there.

Maybe because the Reese's peanut butter is a little saltier. I think then like a standard and then the nut rages peanut butter that's in there already. I would go both give them a what was it? I'd rather go to pizza hut rages.

What is it? Yeah, that was it. So I'd both give them a put it in my gut rages, but I would take the nut rages over the outrageous Jesus. The lot of ages is.

So that's where I'm standing. All right. All right, Chad. What do you think?

I have a feeling I'm going to be on my own here. Both of these are outstanding bars. I'm going to give them both stuff into my gut rages, but for me actually I like that little bit of extra sweetness and the texture that the outrageous provides with those pieces. I think it just sort of makes it like a more interesting mouth feel.

It makes it like a little bit more addictive and plus since I'm trying to watch my girlish figure, I appreciate that it's 40 fewer calories. So for me, I'm going to give the slight edge to the outrageous with pieces, which leaves it up to Novak to pick a winner here. It was not easy. And I had to think what would King Tut do?

What would he do? He can tell a bunch of people to build a pyramid for him. Yeah, he was known to spew a lot of vergals, trying to tell people to do what he wanted him to do. And he definitely kept around his share of slight rages to keep him company.

But here's the thing. I actually had them both on the same level and put them down. And the deciding factor was the one I picked up to eat again. And that was the nut rages.

You were right, Chad. You're going to be a little alone. The thing about the outrageous is that the sweetness is what took you back. I think it's too sweet.

I think it's too sweet for me. The other thing is I wouldn't eat either of these over a number of other Reese's products. They're still far down. The Reese's chain for me.

But I am going to give the slight nod to the nut rages. I will probably still give them both a nut rages rating. Shove them in my gut rages. So they both made the cut rages.

But if this was a five point scale, I wouldn't be giving them the tap. The tap spat on this. Yeah. No, I agree that as far as the Reese's scale, Reese's sticks batter, Reese's cups batter.

Sometimes I just sort of have a craving for this. And it really has that itch. It scratches that itch or whatever. But I could see you guys both picking the nut rages over the outrageous.

That's fair. The outrageous is just not a champion. And like Tiger Woods, it can't hit the putt rages to finish it off. That's really, really poor timing of Tiger Woods.

Just one of the masters. Right. I meant to say, unlike I said, you literally just had a ton of putt rages. And no back I can tell from when you remember in the previous episode, there was a part where you accidentally shared your screen.

And we could see that you had a bunch of tabs open and you were looking at some smart rages. Yeah, I saw that. We got to borrow that now. Yeah, no, you were you were as disgusting as job of the hot rages.

That's your second use of hot, but definitely it's not really done. My apologies. But high standards we have for rages puns here. No one's used butt at all either, which I guess is too easy for.

Well, just call this out for like using butt too much and it made us all feel dumb if we went back to it. Well, I'll tell you what, these with the volume of these snacks, it's just we have a glut rages amount of snacks. No, I was running out. Clear sign, we're running out.

Well, the winner here today, the nut rages by the slightest of margins. But you can't go wrong, I don't think with either one of these, which I think we all sort of anticipated at the beginning of the episode. But, Geiger, we'd like to hear from the listeners and hear what they think about these candy bars. Where should they contact us?

Yeah. One thing you should know that you want to keep these away from your dogs because dogs can't have chocolate and it would be pretty much rages if one of them ate one. But sorry, I had to sneak with more in there. Swish.

Boom. Yeah. So if you want to let us know what you think of nut rages, outrageous, if you want to literally just write it and tell us it's not making rage response ever again. If you wanted more butt pin, disagree with chat.

Hey, let us know. Give them all of us at, you try to add a Gmail.com. We have a hashtag, you try that on Twitter, we are on Facebook, we are on YouTube, we are on Stitcher and SoundCloud, Instagram. We all over the place.

I think we're also on Bumble. That's a dating side, right? I think so. Yeah.

We're there. Our name is hashtag, it's 1093 slut rages and it's just us doing really slightly things with candy bars. We haven't gotten the hits yet. So a lot like my regular dating life before I got married.

What's 1093? I just made up numbers. I don't know. I was like, I wish I could put my actual zip code but enough people know my fucking address if they're leaving me random care packages.

So I don't want to do that. Yeah. So that's the deal with that. It's cool.

All right. Well, I think it's time we shut rages the door on the surface. Nice. Let's keep it over 30 more seconds while we all scramble around and think of one more fun.

We've had many, we've had some bad episodes. I'd say overall this is just somewhat rages and terms of data. If it was a, I would say, if you had a four stars to give us and you gave us one quarter portion, it would be an uncard plate. That's a fucking double.

Deep cut. Deep cut. That's deep cut rages right there. Fuck it.

Here we go. That's how you switched. All right. Call it there and we'll catch up with you next time and we'll be trying out three brandies.

Two strangers. Yep. Three. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of You Tried Dat???

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this You Tried Dat?? episode published?

This episode was published on April 28, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this You Tried Dat?? episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.