At CPP Investments, we manage and invest the CPP Fund to help ensure it remains financially sustainable today and for years to come. Together, we're helping grow the CPP Fund for generations. The following is intended for mature audiences only. Listener discretion is advised. Jennifer vanished sometime in the overnight hours. Right now, there is no trace. Investigators say evidence leads them to believe that she's dead. Stick my nose back on the trail. That's all I can do. This is already gone.
On a Friday afternoon, June 23rd, 2023, Marty received a text that would eventually become the last breadcrumb in a trail that went cold. The text was from her daughter, Amber Marie Arnett. And the text wasn't just a check-in, it was a plea. Amber told her mother she needed to come home for a few days because, quote, it was not safe where she was staying. She didn't explain why she didn't feel safe. She then texted her brother and his wife, but the family was on a trip together and everyone was out of town. Marty told her daughter she'd be back late the following day, June 24th, and that her home would be the safe harbor that Amber needed.
By Sunday, June 25th, Marty was back in Lansing, Michigan, waiting for a knock on the door that never came. Her daughter, Amber, never showed up. This week's story is more than a missing person's case. This is about the intersection of trauma, addiction, and a systemic failure to protect the vulnerable. It's the story of Amber Arnett, a woman her family called a firecracker, who disappeared into the shadows of Lansing, Michigan, leaving behind a mother who has been forced to become her own detective in a world of scary people and unreliable witnesses.
To understand the tragedy of Amber's disappearance, you have to look back at the woman she was before the world grew dark. Born on January 5, 1984 in Lansing, Amber was the first grandchild in her family. And Amber wasn't just loved, she was adored. Because Marty was a young single mother working multiple jobs to make ends meet while going to school, Amber grew up in a household filled with grandparents, cousins, and her younger brother. To Amber, her cousins weren't just relatives. They were like a whole bunch of brothers and sisters, and they remained her closest friends into adulthood.
Even as a toddler, Amber's personality was oversized. Marty recalls with a laugh that when Amber was only two years old, her favorite song wasn't a nursery rhyme. It was Rebel Yell by Billy Idol. Quote, I should have known then I was going to have my hands full, Marty told investigators. Her Aunt Robin described her as a wild one, but in a good way, a high-energy child who was spirited, vocal, and always the center of attention. As she grew, Amber's firecracker energy turned into a deep sense of loyalty and compassion. She was colorful in every sense of the word, gravitating toward bright colors, music, and art. But her greatest passion was people.
She had a soft spot for those at either end of the age spectrum, young children and the elderly. She worked as a live-in aide and a caretaker, often spending her free time doing crafts or painting with the people she cared for. Marty said that Amber worked many jobs and probably waitressed at every restaurant in town. Amber loved to make her friends laugh. If you were having a bad day, she could make you smile. She had a quirky sense of humor that people remember clearly.
Everyone describes Amber as loving and loyal. Even when she was struggling, she still tried to be there for others. Amber was generous, sometimes to a fault. If someone needed something and she had it, she would give it, no questions asked. One friend said that Amber was always the go-to. You could rely on her for anything. She was deeply loyal to the people she loved. And that loyalty, it never wavered. Marty tells stories of Amber bringing people over just to give them food or a warm place to sleep. She was deeply caring.
But beneath that vibrant exterior, a darkness had taken root early on. When Amber was just six years old, her life was shattered. While her parents were going through a divorce, she was sexually abused by her father. One night, she found the courage to tell her mother what was going on, and Marty acted immediately, calling the police. This led to the father's arrest and conviction.
Instead of being supported, Amber paid a terrible price for speaking up. Marty says that Amber's paternal grandparents cut her off after she disclosed the abuse. There was a history of sexual abuse in that side of the family that had been hidden for years, and they were angry that Amber revealed their secrets. Amber's Aunt Robin told The Vanished podcast, quote, Unfortunately, she went through a bad episode with her father at a young age, and so it affected her for the rest of her life growing up. By the time amber reached her late teens the trauma she carried began to manifest in a destructive cycle of alcoholism It wasn't a daily habit marty explained that amber could go weeks without drinking But once she started drinking she couldn't stop she would drink for days on end until she passed out or until she was physically incapacitated I can't tell you exactly when it started marty said, but she was an alcoholic before she was even eligible to drink really For Amber, the alcohol was a shield, a way to block out the memories of what her father had done, but the shield was heavy. When she drank, she became someone else. She got into fights, had brushes with the law, and entered into a string of abusive relationships. Amber had many bad relationships. Her family says that because of her trauma, their related insecurities, and her substance abuse, she would date bad men who treated her poorly. She dated one man for years, a very abusive man. According to her family, he beat her so badly once that he almost killed her.
Also, Amber was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes as a young adult. She was insulin dependent, but managing her medication was impossible when she was drinking. Before she was 40, she had undergone multiple surgeries, gallbladder removal, an appendectomy, even had both of her hips replaced. Doctors were blunt with Amber. If you don't stop drinking, you will die. Then, about six years before she disappeared, something shifted. Amber stopped drinking cold turkey. Her family isn't sure what finally scared her into sobriety, but they were incredibly proud of Amber.
She got her life back on track found a stable job and began managing her health She even found a partner who helped her manage this new stability But tragedy seemed to follow amber toward the end of their relationship This man began using drugs and he died of an overdose shortly after they broke up Amber was devastated and she was overwhelmed by guilt that she couldn't save him The trauma that Amber went through as a young child and then later the guilt she felt about how his life turned out took a big toll on Amber. When he died, Amber began to withdraw from those who loved her. Quote, It definitely was a lifelong struggle for her. She just couldn't recover from it, her mother told The Vanished Podcast. After being released from prison, Amber's father was homeless, divorced, and an alcoholic. Amber's family said that he saw himself as a victim, and Amber was made to feel guilty. Despite everything, Amber had tried to maintain a relationship with him and help him in his later years. Then, in 2020, her father was murdered while living in a homeless encampment in Lansing.
His violent death was a breaking point. It was around this time that Amber began to withdraw from her family and drift back toward a rougher crowd. She had done well for so many years, and it was heartbreaking for her family to see her go down this path once again. In 2022, Amber's life took a dangerous turn when she began dating a man named Mike Rogers. Mike had an extensive criminal history, one that primarily involved drugs, specifically methamphetamine. At some point, Mike went to prison. Amber was sober while Mike was in prison, and this was the time that she turned her life around. It was clear to her family that Amber was very afraid of Mike Rogers.
At first, she visited him in prison and felt obligated to send him money because she was scared. Eventually, she was able to break away from him while he was locked up, and this was the period of stability in Amber's life. When Mike was released in the fall of 2022, he moved into the adult foster care home that Amber was managing. This was a job she loved, caring for two vulnerable residents who depended on her for everything. Amber's aunt said that when Mike came back into the picture, it was just kind of one big nightmare. Everything regressed.
In September of 2022, the Michigan State Police and U.S. Marshals surrounded the facility that Amber was running. They had been watching the house for weeks. They knew that Mike was dealing meth out of there. When the raid occurred, Mike was gone, but police found a large amount of marijuana and meth inside the home. When investigators asked Amber for help finding Mike, she refused. Her loyalty, as always, was her greatest weakness. Amber told police that Mike had once saved her life, and she couldn't turn on him.
due to the numerous violations it was recommended that amber be terminated from her position the afc facility was shut down in january of 2023 and amber lost the career that she loved by february she was evicted and homeless she was also charged and arrested for possession of a controlled substance amber was released from jail and still awaiting her court date when she went missing mike was also arrested but he remained behind bars presumably because he had been out on parole at the time of his arrest amber was due in court on july 13th 2023 Amber's family was shocked and saddened to hear the details of what happened at the AFC facility, though they weren't necessarily surprised. Amber truly was a compassionate caregiver, and she had been doing so well. But, as was unfortunately a pattern for Amber, she was loyal to bad boyfriends. At this point, Amber no longer had stable housing and was staying with different friends from place to place. Marty had to set firm boundaries with her daughter. While Amber could come over for a meal or a shower, she could no longer live at her mother's house, and she wasn't allowed to be there alone.
Amber spent the next few months couch surfing, bouncing from friend to friend. Yet, even at this rock bottom, Marty saw hope. In the months before she vanished, Amber told her mother, Mom, I'm just ready to do my time and get this over with. I want to start over. Amber was tired of the life she was living and seemed ready to climb back up. Now, Marty has done several interviews, and there is a consistent theme. Amber struggled in her life and did not always make the best choices. But it's important to remember that she experienced a lot of trauma and pain in her life too, and these challenges took a toll on her.
Amber's friends and family want people to remember that there was more to Amber than her challenges. She had a big heart. She was a loving and loyal daughter and friend, and Amber deserves to be found. The weekend of June 23, 2023 was supposed to be the beginning of that start over, when Amber messaged her family about not feeling safe. Amber's aunt says that Amber had burned so many bridges by this point that it was difficult for her to reach out to friends and family. It was not the first time that Amber had sent this type of text either, so her family was not necessarily alarmed.
Marty says that at this point in their relationship, things were not great between her and Amber, but Amber knew she could always come home for a reprieve. She knew that Marty's home was a safe place. Despite the challenges they faced, their relationship was strong, and Amber knew she was deeply loved, not just loved by her mom, but by the rest of her family as well. These days, I am so busy with the podcast and my upcoming book. Thrive lets me shop from the convenience of my phone and order healthy foods I know my family will love. My family enjoys pasta, particularly mac and cheese and spaghetti. With healthier, better-for-you options from Thrive Market, they're getting the foods they crave, and I know they're the healthier options. Plus, we aren't sacrificing flavor. Ready to make some healthy swaps and become a member? Visit thrivemarket.com slash alreadygone for 30% off your first order, plus a free $60 gift. That's thrivemarket.com slash alreadygone.
For 30% off your first order, plus a free $60 gift, check out Thrive Market. The last confirmed sighting of Amber Arnett was on Sunday, June 25, 2023. She was seen on surveillance footage at a dollar store on South MLK Boulevard in Lansing, Michigan. She was with a friend buying food items and paying with a card. That friend told police he dropped her off later that afternoon. From there, the trail leads to a house on the south side of Lansing, a place where a man named Paul lived. Amber had told friends she was afraid of this house and afraid of the people who lived there. She was so concerned that she had even shared her GPS location with a friend, and it pointed directly to that address.
Between 9 and 9.30 p.m. on June 25, 2023, Amber sent a message to a resident of that house. The message said, I'm at the front gate, let me in. That was the last communication ever received from Amber Arnett. When Amber didn't show up at Marty's home, Marty initially assumed that she'd found somewhere else to stay. After about a week, Marty began to wonder where Amber was. Amber was always very active on Facebook, sharing memes, memories, and photos. Family and friends knew they could always contact her via social media. Her last post and her last Facebook messenger contact was on June 25, 2023.
Amber was an adult, she was 39 years old, and it wasn't uncommon for her to go stretches of time without contacting her mom, but as time went on, the family began to worry. Amber's niece, with whom she was very close, tried to message her on Snapchat days later, but Amber never replied. The family said that was a big red flag, indicating that something was wrong. Then there was a family event, and more family members began to compare notes, and they realized that none of them had heard from Amber in a while. One struggle in her family's search was that Amber often changed phones and phone numbers. Her mother said Amber frequently lost her phone or accidentally broke them.
A few months before she went missing, Marty bought Amber a new phone so she would have a way to stay in contact. This was a pay-as-you-go phone. Her mom paid for May and then extended it another month in June. Her mom says that she tried calling Amber at the end of June but got a message that the phone was not in service. However, it appeared that Amber could still send messages as of June 25th. Marty said she sent Amber a few messages asking what was going on, whether she was coming over, and where she was. When there was no response, she assumed Amber's phone had been turned off again.
This as a missing persons advocate really frustrates me. Marty called the Lansing police to report her daughter missing. It took six phone calls and two and a half weeks before they even sent an officer out to take a report. Marty believes that the delay was due to Amber's age and her criminal history. Quote, I truly believe they thought she'd just show up. She's just another criminal off the street. It wouldn't be until November, months after Amber vanished, that police finally came to look through her items.
While Marty waited for the police to take an official report, she did not sit still. She immediately began posting on Facebook and messaging Amber's friends, asking if anyone had heard from her. In those early days, Marty truly believed that Amber would walk through the door and tell her to stop embarrassing her online. But that never happened. Eventually, Lansing police showed up and took a report, and Marty spoke with a detective. Not long after, that detective took time off for personal reasons. According to Marty, progress in the case stalled almost immediately.
Marty said it took weeks just to get a report filed and more weeks just to get police to begin investigating, then more weeks passed before they took the situation seriously. Marty believes that Amber's case was not prioritized because she was an adult with a criminal background. It wasn't until August 7, 2023, almost two months after Amber was last seen, that Lansing police posted a missing persons alert on Facebook. Around that time, a detective told the family they would speak with Amber's friends and visit homes where she had recently stayed. Marty says that, to her knowledge, did not actually happen.
According to Marty, it wouldn't be until November, several months later, that police returned to look through Amber's belongings and ask more questions. From the beginning, Marty, along with other family members, began conducting their own investigation. As they spoke to people in Amber's circle, they became increasingly alarmed. Many of the individuals around Amber had extensive criminal histories and violent pasts. Amber's aunt said they discovered messages Amber had sent saying that she was afraid, that she felt like she was going to die, and she was worried that people were going to kill her.
Understandably, her family feels frustrated by what they describe as limited communication and delayed action by law enforcement. While Marty says she is not anti-police, she believes her daughter's case was mishandled early on and that the lost time mattered. There were early theories, perhaps a diabetic emergency, perhaps an overdose. But if that were the case, where was she? Why hadn't Amber been found? Rumors started to circulate in Lansing, and not one of these rumors was what Marty hoped to hear.
One persistent rumor was that Amber had been labeled a snitch. She had been arrested in September of 2022 and later released on bond. Some assumed she must have been cooperating with the police. Her family says they have found no evidence that she was providing information. They also struggle to reconcile that rumor with Amber's fiercely loyal nature. But in circles where meth use and illegal activity are common, paranoia runs high.
Some of the snitch rumors appear to have intensified after Amber went missing. Remember, Amber told people she was afraid for her life, yet she continued spending time with individuals she said scared her. This raised speculation about whether she might have been trying to gather information. In the years since Amber disappeared, many painful and disturbing rumors have circulated about what may have happened to her. Some have suggested horrific scenarios, but none of those claims have ever been substantiated.
Marty even received a handwritten letter from a woman claiming psychic abilities, describing the place where Amber was buried. The letter went viral after Marty posted it publicly, but it ultimately led nowhere. Amber's family believes that after the dollar store visit on June 25th, she was dropped off at a nearby house where a man named Paul was staying. This is the same house Amber had previously expressed fear about. Amber had shared her phone location with a friend, and that phone location placed her at this residence. That evening between 9 and 9.30 p.m., she messaged someone at the house saying she was at the front gate, needing to be let in. After that, there was nothing.
Paul and a woman named Lena are names that repeatedly surface in conversations with the family. Amber had recently been staying at Lena's apartment, but reportedly left after an argument with her and she went to Paul's. Paul was living in the garage of a home owned by an elderly man. According to Marty, she later learned that drug trafficking activity was happening there. Paul's significant other told Marty that Amber had gone to Las Vegas on June 24th. That claim is contradicted by surveillance footage and messages from June 25th. So now we're asking why would they even say that?
By the time police began taking Amber's case more seriously in late 2023, this Paul person had already moved out. Marty says there are two poor quality recordings that exist in which Paul discusses Amber after her disappearance. In one recording, he allegedly refers to her as a rat. In another, he appears to be talking to another man, and he tells this man that he took care of Amber to help him because Amber was going to snitch. Apparently, the man responds by saying he doesn't believe Amber would have snitched, and he didn't need Paul to take care of anything. Unfortunately, these recordings have not led to charges.
The homeowner where Paul was staying in the garage has an adult son. This adult son has reportedly told others that Amber is buried in a nearby woods, though police consider him unreliable. The homeowner himself allegedly told a family friend that Amber was buried, but would not say where. Police, according to Marty, did not speak with Paul until a year and a half after Amber disappeared. Marty has also heard rumors that this Paul person has made other people disappear as well. It seems like a lot of people are afraid of Paul.
A family friend reported hearing that Amber may have overdosed, possibly unintentionally, and that others tried to step in to help her, but Paul refused to let them help Amber. Later, Paul had them help him bury trash bags. Again, these are allegations and rumors no one has been arrested or charged in Amber's case. Meanwhile, Marty continues to advocate tirelessly for her child. She has organized searches, visited homeless encampments, walked through wooded areas, printed thousands of flyers, and she follows up on every lead she receives. She has asked the police to at least advise her if she is searching in the wrong places so that limited time and resources are not wasted.
Marty said that losing faith in the system feels like another layer of grief. To this day, Marty believes that Amber went through the gates of that house on June 25th and then something happened. Foul play occurred. She believes that multiple people know what happened to Amber. Amber's on-again, off-again boyfriend, Mike, who we mentioned earlier, he was in prison when she disappeared and is not considered a person of interest in her case. However, his wife reportedly contacted Marty and said that Mike told her Amber was deceased and to stop bringing her up. Marty's goal is now clear, to find Amber and bring her home.
Marty has said that while justice and prosecution matter, finding her daughter and giving her a proper resting place would be progress. And Marty's not going to stop. She wants people to remember Amber's laugh and that she loved the kids and the older people, and that Amber was loyal to a fault. She wants people to know that Amber had a big heart. Yes, she made some mistakes, but Marty believes that she would have worked her way out of it. Marty's message to you is, tell your people that you love them. You never know when you're not going to be able to. When asked what progress she would like to see in Amber's case, Marty says finding her and bringing her home, helping her out one more time.
As of this writing, Amber would be 42 years old. She is described as 5'4", approximately 150 pounds. She was last seen wearing a black tank top with white writing, blue jeans, and black tennis shoes. Amber has a pierced upper lip and distinctive tattoos on both arms and thighs, including MER with a heart on her wrist, and beautiful disaster on her upper thigh. There is a reward for information in this case. If you have information on the disappearance of Amber Arnett, please contact Lansing Police at 517-483-4600, or you can get in touch with me via Facebook through Missing in Michigan.
I'm your host, Nina Instead, the producer and voice behind the Already Gone podcast. I appreciate you listening and please be safe.